Skip to Content

443 Results Found

  • Review
  • Open Access
2 Citations
2,431 Views
25 Pages

8 December 2025

Argumentative reasoning (AR) refers to the kind of reasoning used when individuals engage in argument about a disputed claim or proposed action. In its mature, most proficient form, AR involves several reasoning skills such as providing effective jus...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Academic Performance: Understanding Complex Student Outcomes Through an Integrative Lens)
  • Article
  • Open Access
304 Views
26 Pages

17 August 2026

Higher education institutions are increasingly expected to contribute to achieving the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) by equipping students with the competencies needed to address complex sustainability challenges. Among these co...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue A New Paradigm in Teacher Education: Sustainability in Teacher Training)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
7,247 Views
18 Pages

Argumentation and Defeasible Reasoning in the Law

  • Marco Billi,
  • Roberta Calegari,
  • Giuseppe Contissa,
  • Francesca Lagioia and ,
  • Giuseppe Pisano,
  • Galileo Sartor and
  • Giovanni Sartor
  • + 2 authors+ 0 author

18 December 2021

Different formalisms for defeasible reasoning have been used to represent knowledge and reason in the legal field. In this work, we provide an overview of the following logic-based approaches to defeasible reasoning: defeasible logic, Answer Set Prog...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Law)
  • Article
  • Open Access
470 Views
38 Pages

14 September 2026

Frameworks of core practice in science teaching name practices either generally enough to span the disciplinary practices of the field or specifically toward explanation and modeling, leaving open what teaching requires when the practice at hand is a...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Re-Examining Argumentation in Science Education: Implications for the Future of Learning, Pedagogy and Research)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
7,295 Views
30 Pages

16 March 2023

James P. Sterba has provided a compelling argument to the effect that given the extent of significant, and indeed even horrendous, evil that an all-good and all-powerful being could have prevented, there is no God. There is a hidden assumption in Ste...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
5,038 Views
13 Pages

Argumentation Schemes for Blockchain Deanonymisation

  • Dominic Deuber,
  • Jan Gruber,
  • Merlin Humml,
  • Viktoria Ronge and
  • Nicole Scheler

27 March 2024

Cryptocurrency forensics have become standard tools for law enforcement. Their basic idea is to deanonymise cryptocurrency transactions to identify the people behind them. Cryptocurrency deanonymisation techniques are often based on premises that lar...

  • Article
  • Open Access
13 Citations
3,968 Views
25 Pages

12 September 2024

Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) is a research area that clarifies AI decision-making processes to build user trust and promote responsible AI. Hence, a key scientific challenge in XAI is the development of methods that generate transparent...

(This article belongs to the Section Data)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
2,460 Views
22 Pages

29 May 2024

To diagnose someone’s reasoning today as “sophistry” is to say that this reasoning is at once persuasive (at least to a significant degree) and logically invalid. We begin by explaining that, despite some recent scholarly arguments...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Ancient Greek Sophistry and Its Legacy)
  • Article
  • Open Access
12 Citations
4,152 Views
24 Pages

The pervasive use of AI today caused an urgent need for human-compliant AI approaches and solutions that can explain their behavior and decisions in human-understandable terms, especially in critical domains, so as to enforce trustworthiness and supp...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Feature Papers in Computer Science & Engineering)
  • Article
  • Open Access
29 Citations
10,002 Views
19 Pages

Reasoning on Controversial Science Issues in Science Education and Science Communication

  • Anna Beniermann,
  • Laurens Mecklenburg and
  • Annette Upmeier zu Belzen

8 September 2021

The ability to make evidence-based decisions, and hence to reason on questions concerning scientific and societal aspects, is a crucial goal in science education and science communication. However, science denial poses a constant challenge for societ...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Scientific Reasoning in Science Education: From Global Measures to Fine-Grained Descriptions of Students’ Competencies)
  • Article
  • Open Access
12 Citations
6,291 Views
23 Pages

Multi-Model Dialectical Evaluation of LLM Reasoning Chains: A Structured Framework with Dual Scoring Agents

  • Catalin Anghel,
  • Andreea Alexandra Anghel,
  • Emilia Pecheanu,
  • Ioan Susnea and ,
  • Adina Cocu and
  • Adrian Istrate
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

(1) Background and objectives: Large language models (LLMs) such as GPT, Mistral, and LLaMA exhibit strong capabilities in text generation, yet assessing the quality of their reasoning—particularly in open-ended and argumentative contexts&mdash...

  • Article
  • Open Access
837 Views
32 Pages

Proof-Carrying Neuro-Symbolic Reasoning for Non-Monotonic Legal Decision Support with LLMs

  • Maxim Ulizko,
  • Tatiana Polevaya,
  • Ivan Tomilov,
  • Natalia Gusarova and
  • Aleksandra Vatian

Large language models (LLMs) and retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) are increasingly used in legal decision support, but retrieved evidence and fluent explanations do not guarantee valid normative inference. This paper proposes a proof-carrying neu...

  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
6,424 Views
15 Pages

31 July 2017

In this article, I show that Pascal’s prudential agenda, centered on the Wager, more successfully overcomes the restrictions of Pyrrhonic skepticism expressed by Montaigne than Descartes’ probative philosophy, which was based on his “ontological argu...

  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
2,778 Views
17 Pages

13 March 2025

Sterba has argued that ethics does not require God and that an atheistic objectivist ethics is compatible with an evolutionary account of our development. This paper argues that though ethics does not require God specifically, it does require a god o...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is an Ethics without God Possible?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
3,920 Views
29 Pages

16 March 2025

This research investigates the potential of computational argumentation, specifically the application of the Abstract Argumentation Framework (AAF), to enhance the evaluation of deliberative quality in public discourse. It focuses on integrating AAF...

  • Feature Paper
  • Article
  • Open Access
180 Views
30 Pages

26 October 2026

Argumentation is the inferential strategy aimed at coping with inconsistent knowledge within a logic theory. Abstract argumentation is based on a graph model where nodes are uninterpreted claims and arcs denote relationships between pairs of claims....

(This article belongs to the Section E1: Mathematics and Computer Science)
  • Article
  • Open Access
14 Citations
5,017 Views
19 Pages

Ideology as Filter: Motivated Information Processing and Decision-Making in the Energy Domain

  • Ulf J. J. Hahnel,
  • Christian Mumenthaler,
  • Tobia Spampatti and
  • Tobias Brosch

13 October 2020

The transition towards more renewable energy will substantially increase voters’ involvement in the political decision-making process in the energy domain. Decisions such as whether to approve or reject large-scale energy programs can be comple...

(This article belongs to the Section Sustainability in Geographic Science)
  • Article
  • Open Access
7 Citations
3,749 Views
18 Pages

Embodied Argumentation in Young Children in Kindergarten

  • Josephine Convertini and
  • Francesco Arcidiacono

7 September 2021

In kindergarten, children are usually engaged with both verbal activities and non-verbal activities, often requiring the manipulation of physical objects. During technical tasks (e.g., problem solving), children can use argumentation as one of the la...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Languages and Literacies in Science Education)
  • Article
  • Open Access
14 Citations
4,053 Views
15 Pages

Deep Uncertainty, Public Reason, the Conservation of Biodiversity and the Regulation of Markets for Lion Skeletons

  • Peter Coals,
  • Dawn Burnham,
  • Paul J. Johnson,
  • Andrew Loveridge and ,
  • David W. Macdonald,
  • Vivienne L. Williams and
  • John A. Vucetich
  • + 2 authors+ 0 author

17 September 2019

Public reason is a formal concept in political theory. There is a need to better understand how public reason might be elicited in making public decisions that involve deep uncertainty, which arises from pernicious and gross ignorance about how a sys...

  • Article
  • Open Access
1,049 Views
25 Pages

It has been argued that one or other asymmetry in temporal ontology grounds there being reasons to have certain temporal attitudes which we not only have, but also judge to be reasonable, and that this gives us reason to posit that asymmetry. Call th...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Debating Temporal Ontology: The Existence of Yesterday and Tomorrow)
  • Article
  • Open Access
13 Citations
5,659 Views
21 Pages

15 November 2021

Geography education can facilitate learners’ critical thinking and argumentation skills to make well-reasoned decisions on social and environmental issues. This study reports on a geography course consisting of 18 lessons, each of them 75 min, design...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Geography Education Promoting Sustainability—Series 2)
  • Article
  • Open Access
11 Citations
7,903 Views
21 Pages

1 March 2022

Proof, a key topic in advanced mathematics, also forms an essential part of the formal learning experience at all levels of education. The reason is that the argumentation involved calls for pondering ideas in depth, organizing knowledge, and compari...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Research on Powerful Ideas for Enriching School Mathematical Learning)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1,091 Views
15 Pages

16 August 2025

This essay develops a distinct moral argument for the reasonableness of believing in God (conceived as a perfectly good creator) inspired by the pragmatic argument for “the religious hypothesis” advanced by William James in “The Wil...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is an Ethics without God Possible?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
11 Citations
8,287 Views
11 Pages

We should not have children because (i) we have no child-regarding reasons to do so, (ii) we have child-regarding reasons not to do so, and (iii) although we have other-regarding reasons to do so, these reasons are not decisive. Objections to (i) inc...

  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
2,810 Views
13 Pages

2 November 2022

Two recent atheistic arguments from evil have made much of natural evil and the suffering of animals in their case contra theism. The first argument is that of James Sterba. Sterba’s argument is an incompatibility argument premised on the claim...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
12,565 Views
12 Pages

11 November 2022

Atheists feel there is no reason for religious beliefs and that they should only believe things that can be proven logically or by experiments, while theists believe they have enough reason to believe. At some point, the arguments and counterargument...

  • Feature Paper
  • Article
  • Open Access
10 Citations
6,868 Views
18 Pages

In the era of generative AI and specifically large language models (LLMs), exemplified by ChatGPT, the intersection of artificial intelligence and human reasoning has become a focal point of global attention. Unlike conventional search engines, LLMs...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue The Ethics of Modern and Emerging Technology)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
2,812 Views
18 Pages

15 October 2025

In the ontological argument for the existence of God, Descartes famously argues that the idea of God is the idea of a perfect being. As such, the idea of God must combine all of the perfections. Now, as (necessary) existence is a perfection, God must...

  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
2,978 Views
14 Pages

22 April 2024

In this paper I discuss Moses Mendelssohn’s argumentation on religious tolerance in his “Vorrede” (“preface”) that he added to his translation of Rabbi Manasseh Ben Israel’s letter “Vindiciae judaeorum”...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Skepticism and Tolerance: Moses Mendelssohn, Salomon Maimon, and Jewish Enlightenment Thought)
  • Article
  • Open Access
9 Citations
3,640 Views
20 Pages

One goal of environmental civic education is preparing students, both as citizens and as professionals, to use effective arguments in public debates. Such debates include dominantly economic claims, which are multifaceted and rarely taught in schools...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Sustainability and Citizenship: Integration of Socio-Scientific Issues in Science Education)
  • Article
  • Open Access
4,524 Views
16 Pages

Sexual activism (for, e.g., participants in the LGBT+ or BDSM communities) is prima facie commendable, at least for the liberal. However, it is unclear whether the end goal of such activism is toleration or recognition. The argument of this paper is...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue The Philosophical Richness and Variety of Sex and Love)
  • Article
  • Open Access
9 Citations
4,319 Views
24 Pages

1 September 2021

The purpose of this study is to assess the learning effect of a multilingual web-based argumentative writing instruction model called the Ensayo Científico Multilingüe (ECM, Multilingual Scientific Essay) adapting the didactic model called Genre-base...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Inclusive Mathematics Education and Basic Academic Skills: Language and Numeracy)
  • Entry
  • Open Access
630 Views
15 Pages

Practical Argumentation in Teaching Reflection on Practice

  • Carlos Ledezma,
  • Vicenç Font,
  • Alicia Sánchez and
  • Alexandre Cortés

Practical argumentation refers to a form of argumentation oriented towards action. Unlike theoretical argumentation, which primarily concerns the truth or acceptability of propositions, or mathematical argumentation, which is mainly concerned with th...

(This article belongs to the Collection Encyclopedia of Social Sciences)
  • Article
  • Open Access
902 Views
27 Pages

In an era of information explosion and overload, individuals face a constant influx of mixed-quality, contradictory data. Navigating this complex landscape requires critical thinking, which enables individuals to dynamically adjust their reasoning an...

(This article belongs to the Section Contributions to the Measurement of Intelligence)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3,182 Views
14 Pages

3 October 2025

In this article, we explain how Kant upends the terms of the debate concerning the relationship between God’s existence and an objective morality by looking at his moral-teleological argument for God’s existence in the third Critique. We...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is an Ethics without God Possible?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
3,744 Views
14 Pages

9 December 2024

This paper explores the argumentative strategies employed by Daoism and Buddhism in their debates during the Tang dynasty (618–907). Despite being significant in Chinese intellectual history, these debates, particularly the strategies behind th...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue The Interaction of Daoist, Buddhist and Confucian Thinkers in the Sui and Early Tang Dynasty)
  • Article
  • Open Access
13 Citations
3,432 Views
17 Pages

Analysis of the Informal Reasoning Modes of Preservice Primary Teachers When Arguing about a Socio-Scientific Issue on Nuclear Power during a Role Play

  • Isabel María Cruz-Lorite,
  • Daniel Cebrián-Robles,
  • María del Carmen Acebal-Expósito and
  • Maria Evagorou

28 February 2023

The use of nuclear power is a socio-scientific issue that is controversial in many areas. Concerns of nuclear power touch on health effects, environmental impacts, employment concerns and energy supply; arguments both for and against it are easily ge...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Sustainability and Citizenship: Integration of Socio-Scientific Issues in Science Education)
  • Article
  • Open Access
4 Citations
6,254 Views
18 Pages

Conventional Implicatures in Argumentation

  • Annette Hautli-Janisz,
  • Katarzyna Budzynska and
  • Chris Reed

30 December 2022

Despite the ubiquity of conventional implicatures in language and the critical role they play in argumentation, they have heretofore been almost entirely absent from theories of argument and the linguistic expression of reasoning. In this paper, we d...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Pragmatics and Argumentation)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2,857 Views
45 Pages

25 July 2023

This article aims to provide an a priori argument—termed the Flourishment Argument, for the veracity of the Christian conception of the Abrahamic religion that centres on God’s action of sending a divine and atoning prophet into the world...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Philosophy and Incarnation)
  • Article
  • Open Access
4,929 Views
12 Pages

12 January 2023

Erik Wielenberg has offered a fascinating argument from moral psychology against a sophisticated theistic account of moral obligations: Divine Command Theory (DCT). This argument focuses on the pathology known as psychopathy—a perennial interes...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue God and Ethics)
  • Article
  • Open Access
7,282 Views
17 Pages

6 September 2011

Freiling [1] and Brown [2] have put forward a probabilistic reductio argument intended to refute the Continuum Hypothesis. The argument relies heavily upon intuitions about symmetry in a particular scenario. This paper argues that the argument fails,...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Symmetry in Probability and Inference)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2,548 Views
11 Pages

22 July 2024

It has been argued for a long time that God has been involved in the biological evolutionary processes observed on Earth. However, no convincing theistic argument has yet been formulated for biological evolution. In this article, I use the concept of...

(This article belongs to the Section Religions and Theologies)
  • Reply
  • Open Access
6 Citations
4,291 Views
7 Pages

13 September 2018

A response is given to a comment of Zanotto and Mauro on our paper published in Entropy 20, 103 (2018). Our arguments presented in this paper are widely ignored by them, and no new considerations are outlined in the comment, which would require a rev...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Residual Entropy and Nonequilibrium States)
  • Article
  • Open Access
12 Citations
3,565 Views
12 Pages

20 January 2022

AIMS: The aim of the study was to investigate the relation between declared intention to get/not get vaccinated against COVID-19, prior to the start of the global vaccination program, and actual vaccine uptake. Moreover, reasons for getting vaccinate...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Psychological Aspects of COVID-19 Vaccine Uptake: Principles and Empirical Strategies)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3,415 Views
13 Pages

Pareto on Cunning and Deceit

  • Christopher Adair-Toteff

In Plato’s Republic, Socrates praises reason and vilifies force. This preference for reason continued its role in philosophy and only a few political thinkers considered the use of force. Plato also dismissed persuasion as the Sophists’ a...

(This article belongs to the Section History of Knowledge)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1,312 Views
26 Pages

Toward Sustainable Education: Generative AI-Powered Argument Mining in Student Writing

  • Yupei Ren,
  • Ning Zhang,
  • Xiaoyu Li,
  • Yadong Zhang and ,
  • Yuqing Chen and
  • Man Lan
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

30 March 2026

As critical elements in argumentative writing, argument components and strategies significantly influence argument quality. However, the existing research lacks an in-depth exploration of how students construct and utilize these elements in argumenta...

  • Article
  • Open Access
18 Citations
5,757 Views
19 Pages

21 November 2021

Argumentative writing is the most commonly used genre in writing classroom practices and assessments. To draft an argumentative essay in authentic settings, writers are usually required to evaluate and use content knowledge from outside sources. Alth...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Applied Linguistics and Language Education for Sustainable Development)
  • Article
  • Open Access
21 Citations
5,324 Views
10 Pages

Strengthening Critical Health Literacy for Health Information Appraisal: An Approach from Argumentation Theory

  • Sara Rubinelli,
  • Alexander Ort,
  • Claudia Zanini,
  • Maddalena Fiordelli and
  • Nicola Diviani

The overload of health information has been a major challenge during the COVID-19 pandemic. Public health authorities play a primary role in managing this information. However, individuals have to apply critical health literacy to evaluate it. The ob...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Empowering Patients and Supporting Health Care Providers—New Avenues for High Quality Care and Safety)
  • Article
  • Open Access
11 Citations
6,171 Views
35 Pages

8 October 2021

For high school students to develop scientific understanding and reasoning, it is essential that they engage in epistemic cognition and scientific argumentation. In the current study, we used the AIR model (i.e., Aims and values, epistemic Ideals, an...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Scientific Reasoning in Science Education: From Global Measures to Fine-Grained Descriptions of Students’ Competencies)

of 9