- Article
This study examines whether sustainable human resource management (SHRM) is associated with triple bottom line (TBL) performance through circular economy orientation (CEO) and green supply chain integration (GSCI) in manufacturing firms in emerging economies. Drawing on the natural-resource-based view, stakeholder theory, and institutional theory, CEO and GSCI are conceptualized as sequential sustainability capabilities, and strategic environmental orientation (SEO) as a moderator. Survey data were collected from the HR manager and the production/supply-chain line manager of 175 firms in Kenya, Nigeria, Ghana, South Africa, Indonesia, Vietnam, and Bangladesh (350 respondents; effective response rate 45.8%) and analyzed with partial least squares structural equation modeling. In the primary cross-rater model, in which the HR manager reported SHRM and SEO and the line manager reported the other constructs, SHRM was not associated with CEO (β = −0.024) or GSCI (β = 0.049); the indirect, serial indirect, and moderation hypotheses were therefore not supported. CEO was strongly associated with GSCI (β = 0.578), and both CEO (β = 0.270) and GSCI (β = 0.513) were positively associated with perceived TBL performance. When one respondent rated all constructs, associations involving SHRM became substantial, showing that rater source strongly shapes findings in this literature. Because the design is cross-sectional and perceptual, the results are associational, not causal.
18 November 2026



![Study area and spatial distribution of the main variables: (a) location of the 24 districts of Chernihiv, Sumy, Kharkiv and Dnipropetrovsk oblasts (district numbers as in Table S1); (b) value of agricultural output per hectare of sown area, USD/ha; (c) maize share of the grain area, %. Source: authors’ elaboration based on OCHA COD-AB administrative boundaries (version 05, 2025) [19] and district tables of the regional statistics offices [15,16,17,18].](https://mdpi-res.com/sustainability/sustainability-18-11753/article_deploy/html/images/sustainability-18-11753-g001-550.jpg)

