- Article
Digital Payment Use Across Macroeconomic States: Factor-Augmented Models and Temporal Generalization
Digital payment use reflects household characteristics, transaction context, technological diffusion, and aggregate conditions, but the incremental value of macroeconomic information and algorithmic flexibility is uncertain. We harmonize 182,409 U.S. payment records from 2015–2025; the primary comparison uses 146,507 dated transactions from eight definitionally comparable waves (2018–2025) linked to 122 FRED-MD indicators. Five architectures range from a microeconomic regularized logit with a diffusion trend (M0) to a factor-logit/gradient-boosting stack (M4). Under leakage-controlled leave-one-wave-out validation, M0 attains AUC 0.8121 and log loss 0.3423. M4 raises AUC to 0.8214 (difference 0.0093; 95% wave-bootstrap interval 0.0067–0.0120) and reduces log loss to 0.3389. In practical ranking terms, the AUC gain corresponds to approximately nine additional correctly ordered mobile/non-mobile pairs per 1000 randomly drawn pairs; it is, therefore, repeatable but modest. M4 improves AUC in all eight waves, yet its prospective rolling-origin advantage is smaller and its mean log loss is worse than M0. Under the strict mobile-instrument-code outcome, M4 does not improve AUC, although it improves precision–recall performance. Econometric associations with a composite macroeconomic state are sensitive to the diffusion-trend specification and are based on only eight aggregate states. The evidence, therefore, supports limited incremental predictive value—not macroeconomic irrelevance or causal resilience. For U.S. digital financial services, simple models are preferable when calibrated probabilities, transparency, or rapid updating dominate; the hybrid is defensible when small, stable ranking gains have decision value.
22 November 2026





