Skip to Content

387 Results Found

  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
3,902 Views
17 Pages

26 December 2022

In this essay, I revisit the univocity thesis, Sterba’s analogy between God and a leader of a politically liberal society, and, most fundamentally, whether the existence of horrendous evils is logically compatible with the existence of a good G...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
4,380 Views
14 Pages

7 January 2022

The evil god challenge is for theists to explain why a good god’s existence should be considerably more reasonable than an evil god’s existence. Challengers note that there is a symmetry between a good god and an evil god. Moreover, the c...

(This article belongs to the Section Religions and Theologies)
  • Article
  • Open Access
4 Citations
4,223 Views
12 Pages

15 June 2021

In this article, I offer a response to James P. Sterba’s moral argument for the non-existence of God. Sterba applies to God the so-called Pauline Principle that it is not permissible to do evil in order that good may come. He suggests that this is th...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is the God of Traditional Theism Logically Compatible with All the Evil in the World?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
5,010 Views
11 Pages

11 January 2018

Prominent approaches to the problems of evil assume that even if the Anselmian God exists, some worlds are better than others, all else being equal. But the assumptions that the Anselmian God exists and that some worlds are better than others cannot...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Theodicy)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
3,804 Views
10 Pages

28 January 2023

Jim Sterba’s Is a Good God Logically Possible? looks to resurrect J. L. Mackie’s logical argument from evil. Sterba accepts the general framework that theists seeking to give a theodicy have favored since Leibniz invented the term: the se...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
3,712 Views
12 Pages

22 August 2022

In this paper, I provide a defence of theism against James Sterba’s version of the logical problem of evil, at least where the focus is on moral evil (I do not have much to say about natural evil in this paper). After giving my own account of t...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
7 Citations
3,429 Views
13 Pages

13 May 2021

In this essay, I affirm the univocity thesis while discussing some alternative positions that avoid the problem of evil by rejecting the univocity thesis. I reject Sterba’s assumption that God’s governance of creation is adequately understood as an a...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is the God of Traditional Theism Logically Compatible with All the Evil in the World?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
3,183 Views
10 Pages

24 September 2024

In this paper, I propose a defence against the problem of evil. This defence does not involve either free will or soul-making, but, rather, is intended as a replacement for the traditional theodicies. The defence will have two components: firstly, a...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Theodicy and Challenges of Science: Understanding God, Evil and Evolution (Volume II))
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
4,134 Views
13 Pages

11 July 2021

I argue that deeply ingrained dispositions to do evil do not render moral perfection impossible. I discuss various accounts of moral perfection and the evidence from cognitive (neuro)science that points towards a strong disposition for evil. Afterwar...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Theodicy and Challenges of Science: Understanding God, Evil and Evolution)
  • Article
  • Open Access
7 Citations
5,534 Views
11 Pages

27 February 2021

Most contemporary discussions of the problem of evil assume that “logical” formulations of the problem are untenable, and that we should operate with “evidential” formulations instead. I argue that this consensus is founded on a mistake and that ther...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is the God of Traditional Theism Logically Compatible with All the Evil in the World?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3,287 Views
9 Pages

22 October 2022

The article argues that the logical argument from evil is dead, and the new version presented by James Sterba cannot resurrect it. In the first part, I say that the logical argument from evil is dead either because, in the version given by Mackie, it...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
4,976 Views
15 Pages

2 February 2023

Logical and evidential arguments from evil are generally thought to have been rebutted by various refutations, defenses, and theodicies. While disparate, these responses employ similar strategies to show that God has morally sufficient reasons to per...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Essay
  • Open Access
5,973 Views
10 Pages

24 April 2018

This essay explores the concept of theodicy in Flannery O’Connor’s works of fiction. O’Connor’s fiction complicates the subjects of good and evil, moving the reader through what seem to be competitions not only between good an...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Theodicy)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
2,818 Views
18 Pages

1 December 2022

Sterba has recently produced a searching and significant version of the argument from evil. Here, I set out aspects of the view of God, suffering, and the afterlife articulated by Isaac Qatraya (also known as Isaac of Nineveh and Isaac the Syrian), a...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
6,788 Views
9 Pages

31 January 2018

I consider the two venerated arguments about the existence of God: the Ontological Argument and the Argument from Evil. The Ontological Argument purports to show that God’s nature guarantees that God exists. The Argument from Evil purports to show th...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Theodicy)
  • Article
  • Open Access
4 Citations
4,024 Views
15 Pages

27 June 2023

In this article, I sketch, both in broad outlines and in selected details, the new, richer picture of von Hildebrand’s account of moral evil as it emerges from my discovery of extensive materials in von Hildebrand´s Nachlass at the Bavari...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Continental Philosophy and Christian Beliefs)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
2,211 Views
9 Pages

10 November 2022

In this paper, I reformulate Sterba’s argument from evil and consider the various ways theists might respond to it. There are two basic families of responses. On the one hand, theists can deny that God, as a perfect being, needs to act in accor...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Essay
  • Open Access
2,563 Views
13 Pages

1 December 2022

The central argument of James Sterba’s “Is a Good God Logically Possible?” relies crucially on the notion that a good God would have to abide by various evil prevention requirements. Because it appears that God has not done so, Ster...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
3,920 Views
16 Pages

8 June 2021

In this paper, I suggest that James Sterba’s recent restatement of the logical problem of evil overlooks a plausible theistic interpretation of the divine–human relation, which allows for a theodicy impervious to his atheological argument, which boil...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is the God of Traditional Theism Logically Compatible with All the Evil in the World?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
9,549 Views
18 Pages

21 March 2021

This article attempts to reframe the traditional account of the problem of evil for God’s existence. The philosophical debates about the problem of evil for the existence of God within the traditional framework do not exhaust the available options fo...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is the God of Traditional Theism Logically Compatible with All the Evil in the World?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
12,439 Views
13 Pages

16 January 2023

In this special issue on justice, ethics, and philosophy of religion, let us consider a historical case study. The trade of slaves across the Atlantic lasted 400 years and led to the forcible removal of about 12.5 million people from Africa, south of...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Justice, Ethics, and Philosophy of Religion)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2,071 Views
19 Pages

12 November 2025

The contemporary debate over the problem of evil in analytic philosophy of religion is prone to focusing solely on the problem as an abstract dialectical issue that only concerns philosophers. However, this focus on abstract solutions to the problem...

  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
5,895 Views
16 Pages

18 March 2020

Mid-twentieth century witnessed a renewal of the interest in the problem of evil, presented by Mackie et al. in the form of the logical argument from evil. However, this argument was proven ineffective in securing victory over theism. A more successf...

  • Article
  • Open Access
7 Citations
4,104 Views
13 Pages

11 March 2021

Sterba’s Is a Good God Logically Possible? (2019) draws attention to the importance of ethical assumptions in ‘logical’ arguments from evil (LAfEs) to the effect that the existence of (certain types) of evil is incompatible with the existence of a Go...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is the God of Traditional Theism Logically Compatible with All the Evil in the World?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
14 Citations
22,604 Views
17 Pages

13 April 2021

In his book ‘Is a Good God Logically Possible?’, James Sterba argues that the existence of much of the evil to be found in the world is logically incompatible with the existence of God. I defend the Thomistic view that when one properly understands t...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is the God of Traditional Theism Logically Compatible with All the Evil in the World?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
23 Citations
46,796 Views
13 Pages

3 February 2018

This paper sheds light on the treatment of the ‘problem of evil’ and human suffering from an Islamic perspective. I begin by providing an overview of the term ‘evil’ in the Qur’an to highlight its multidimensional meaning and to demonstrate the overa...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Theodicy)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
7,606 Views
13 Pages

16 April 2018

This paper argues that, although Margaret Cavendish’s main philosophical contributions are not in philosophy of religion, she makes a case for a defense of God, in spite of the worst sorts of harms being present in the world. Her arguments abou...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Theodicy)
  • Article
  • Open Access
10,000 Views
17 Pages

29 May 2023

The problem of evil seems to have been the patent of theism for a long time. However, some philosophers notice that this is not necessarily the case and raise arguments from evil against atheism. In this paper, I follow this insight and raise the evi...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Classical Theism, Evil and Its Varieties: Abrahamic Science-Engaged Theology)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1,544 Views
16 Pages

25 September 2025

In Religion, Kant posits an innate and natural propensity to evil, which he implicitly designates as “radical evil”. However, this notion has been criticized for its apparent incompatibility with freedom and its problematic atemporality,...

  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
7,303 Views
30 Pages

16 March 2023

James P. Sterba has provided a compelling argument to the effect that given the extent of significant, and indeed even horrendous, evil that an all-good and all-powerful being could have prevented, there is no God. There is a hidden assumption in Ste...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
4 Citations
4,463 Views
15 Pages

8 February 2023

James Sterba has presented a powerful and existentially sincere form of the problem of evil, arguing that it is logically impossible for God to exist, given that there are powerful moral requirements to prevent evil, where one can, and that these req...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
10 Citations
9,408 Views
14 Pages

WPFD: Active User-Side Detection of Evil Twins

  • Fu-Hau Hsu,
  • Min-Hao Wu,
  • Yan-Ling Hwang,
  • Chia-Hao Lee and ,
  • Chuan-Sheng Wang and
  • Ting-Cheng Chang
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

12 August 2022

The bothersome evil twin problem has an active user-side remedy in the form of the Wireless Packet Forwarding Detector (WPFD). The evil twin issue can lead to further security problems, including man-in-the-middle (MITM) attacks. Open public Wi-Fi co...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Human-Computer Interactions 2.0)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
3,934 Views
12 Pages

14 August 2023

The problem of evil permeates contemporary theodicy, raising the question of how an omnipotent and benevolent God can allow its existence. Exploring this inquiry is inherently tied to investigating divine action, specifically the interplay between ti...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Classical Theism, Evil and Its Varieties: Abrahamic Science-Engaged Theology)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1,833 Views
10 Pages

19 September 2023

Sterba argues that God would be ethically bound to implement a set of exceptionless evil prevention requirements. However, he argues that the world as we know it is not as it would be if God were applying them. Sterba concludes that God does not exis...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
2,437 Views
7 Pages

9 October 2022

In this brief article, I consider James Sterba’s logical argument from evil, finding it to be ultimately unsuccessful. Not for the various issues Sterba raises, which do seem to be problematic if God exists, but for the logical approach itself....

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
487 Views
15 Pages

26 July 2026

In this article, I argue that the probabilistic argument from evil rests on an assumption that weakens its conclusion. The argument presupposes epistemic conditions that we are not in a position to meet. I use combinatorial axiology to show that the...

(This article belongs to the Section Religions and Humanities/Philosophies)
  • Article
  • Open Access
8 Citations
4,669 Views
13 Pages

28 April 2021

James Sterba’s book, Is a Good God Logically Possible?, argues that given the amount of significant and horrendous evil in the world, it is not possible for a (morally) good God to exist. This article draws on the work of Brian Davies’ interpretation...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is the God of Traditional Theism Logically Compatible with All the Evil in the World?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
5,368 Views
10 Pages

9 November 2022

Against the background of the current debates about God and evil, the article elaborates in three stages of argumentation the thesis that statements about God must not be understood as factual or representational statements, but as descriptive elemen...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
2,988 Views
8 Pages

28 October 2022

This article is a rejoinder to James Sterba’s response to my previous article on the topic of his book, Is a Good God Logically Possible? Sterba argues that a good God is not logically possible given the amount of horrendous evil in the world....

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3,972 Views
20 Pages

30 November 2024

This study examines how Ibn Arabi’s metaphysics can address key challenges in the contemporary philosophical debate on the problem of evil. John Mackie famously argues that the existence of an omnibenevolent and omnipotent God is logically inco...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Problems in Contemporary Islamic Philosophy of Religion)
  • Essay
  • Open Access
10 Citations
3,028 Views
7 Pages

29 December 2020

This article addresses the main argument in James Sterba’s book, an argument which claims that the existence of a good God is logically incompatible with the evil in the world. I claim to show that his main premise, MEPRI, is implausible and is...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Is the God of Traditional Theism Logically Compatible with All the Evil in the World?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1,987 Views
12 Pages

1 November 2022

We pose two challenges to Sterba’s position. First, we show that Sterba fails to consider alternative historical positions such as Leibniz’s (who argues that God knows that the actual world is the best of all possible worlds) or Kant&rsqu...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Do We Now Have a Logical Argument from Evil?)
  • Article
  • Open Access
6,454 Views
21 Pages

7 August 2023

This article explores the relationship between the alcahueta or bawd, the evil eye, and midwifery in the early modern Spanish cultural imaginary. The evil eye, though an ancient belief, received renewed attention in theological and medical texts, inc...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue The Eye in Spanish Golden Age Medicine, Anatomy, and Literature)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2,881 Views
9 Pages

5 October 2023

The paper explores the concept of epistemic theodicy and strengthens an argument that reconciles human fallibility with the existence of an all-powerful and benevolent God. This argument is grounded in epistemic responsibility, emphasizing our episte...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Theodicy and Challenges of Science: Understanding God, Evil and Evolution (Volume II))
  • Concept Paper
  • Open Access
1 Citations
3,147 Views
13 Pages

4 September 2024

A conceptualisation of the COVID-19 pandemic through the analytic lens of a ‘necropolitics as evil’ brings to the fore Hannah Arendt’s theorisation that evil is both an expression of, and a threat to, humanity and its plurality as a...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Interdisciplinary Social Research in Economics, Environment, Education, and Philosophy)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2,133 Views
10 Pages

23 April 2024

This is a response to Zain Ali’s critique in this journal of our presentation of a ‘right relationship’ normatively relativised ‘logical’ Argument from Evil. Our argument aims to show that the existence of horrendous evi...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Problems in Contemporary Islamic Philosophy of Religion)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
5,868 Views
10 Pages

13 April 2024

Most Pentecostals, at least in the global South, believe that Satan and his demonic forces are responsible for much of the carnage and suffering that characterise life on earth. The broader context of the discourse is the challenge theodicy poses to...

(This article belongs to the Section Religions and Theologies)

of 8