- Article
Classical micromechanical models are widely used to estimate composite stiffness, but their transferability to electrospun-fiber-reinforced polymers is uncertain because the reinforcement forms a continuous, often random, network whose effective properties depend on fiber diameter, orientation, architecture, and processing. This study uses six diagnostic case studies from three published composite studies with polyamide 6 (PA6) fibers in poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL), poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), and poly(lactic acid) (PLA) matrices to test whether the rule of mixtures, Halpin–Tsai, and Tsai–Pagano relations remain predictive when the fiber modulus must be taken from an independent single-fiber study, as is often unavoidable when utilizing data from the literature. With a PA6 single-fiber modulus of 901.65 MPa, all relations fall below the measured moduli. The Reuss–Voigt spread is at most 64 MPa, whereas prediction–experiment differences reach about 4.2 GPa. Uncertainty propagation and sensitivity to density, Halpin–Tsai shape parameter, orientation efficiency, and fiber-modulus choice classify one PLA/PA6 composite as a robust bound violation (required apparent fiber modulus ≥ 166 GPa), a second as a nominal violation, the PCL/PA6 series as input-ambiguous, and the PMMA/PA6 case as inconclusive. The choice of the model is therefore a smaller source of error than the definition of the input phases. A minimum reporting framework is proposed for future micromechanical and data-driven prediction.
13 November 2026


![Reported Young’s modulus of individual electrospun PCL and PA6 fibers as a function of fiber diameter. Panel (a) retains the Alharbi et al. PCL power-law fits and representative points [13], Baker et al. mean ± SD tensile modulus [11], Croisier et al. mean ± SD three-point-bending modulus [12], and Alexeev et al. reported diameter/modulus domains represented as range markers [14]. The shaded band denotes the bulk/extruded PCL range summarized in the cited literature. Panel (b) adds PA6 single-fiber evidence: the ~85 nm/~30 GPa AFM suspended-fiber value reported by Li et al. and summarized by Bazbouz and Stylios [15,34], the 113.0 ± 16.3 nm/1.32 ± 1.52 GPa in situ tensile result of Hang et al. (only the +SD bar is drawn because mean − SD is below zero) [33], the ~130 ± 30 nm/4–5 GPa air-stream-assisted tensile result (plotted at 4.5 GPa) [27], and the ~800 nm/901.65 MPa direct tensile result of Bazbouz and Stylios [15]. Logarithmic axes are used to display the full range; values obtained by different mechanical protocols are not pooled into a common fit.](https://mdpi-res.com/micro/micro-06-00097/article_deploy/html/images/micro-06-00097-g001-550.jpg)


