You are currently viewing a new version of our website. To view the old version click .

All Articles (7,476)

  • Systematic Review
  • Open Access

Delphi Consensus in Otolaryngology: A Systematic Review of Reliability and Reporting Completeness

  • Anastasia Urbanelli,
  • Giorgia Pugliese and
  • Elisa Bolis
  • + 8 authors

Background: The Delphi method is increasingly used in otolaryngology to develop consensus in subjects lacking robust evidence. In these contexts, consensus documents play a dual role: they provide structured expert guidance while determining shared principles adaptable to the individual patient. Nevertheless, the methodological rigor and reporting consistency of Delphi studies remain variable, raising concerns about transparency, reproducibility, and potential bias. Methods: A systematic review was conducted according to PRISMA guidelines. MEDLINE, Embase, and Web of Science were searched for Delphi-based consensus studies in otolaryngology. Fully published studies in English, Italian, German, French, or Spanish were included. Each article was assessed using established methodological frameworks for consensus development, bias domains described in the methodological literature, and the DELPHISTAR reporting checklist. Reliability and completeness scores were calculated to enable comparisons. Results: Out of 3168 unique records, 86 studies were included. Most defined their purpose and consensus criteria, but transparency regarding panel selection, anonymity, feedback, and criteria for stopping the consensus process was often missing. Based on methodological bias domains, only 9 studies (10.5%) reached a “good” reliability score, while the majority were rated as “fair.” According to DELPHISTAR, just 3 studies (3.5%) showed good levels of completeness. Reporting completeness and risk of bias proved heterogeneous across subspecialties. Conclusions: Delphi-based studies are increasingly shaping clinical practice in otolaryngology, but persistent methodological and reporting limitations undermine their reliability. Wider adoption of standardized frameworks is essential to improve transparency, reproducibility, and clinical impact, ensuring that consensus statements support both evidence-informed practice and personalized patient care.

24 November 2025

Delphi-style flowchart depicting the article selection process.

Personalized treatment specifically tailored to the patient’s needs is nowadays a successful and necessary therapeutic approach [...]

24 November 2025

Background/Objectives: Spinal decompression surgery shows variable outcomes, with reoperation rates up to 37.5%. Surgeons lack objective intraoperative tools to assess decompression adequacy. Mechanomyography (MMG) measures nerve excitability through mechanical muscle responses to electrical stimulation. While compressed nerves require higher stimulation thresholds, optimal quantification approaches remain undefined. We explored associations between intraoperative MMG threshold changes and six-week pain outcomes, comparing metrics anchored to a 2.0 mA reference threshold versus percentage-based measures. Methods: Prospective exploratory pilot study of 42 patients (112 nerves) undergoing lumbar or cervical decompression. MMG thresholds were recorded pre- and post-decompression. Numeric Pain Scale scores were obtained preoperatively and at six weeks. Three metrics were compared: percentage change, Threshold Reduction Ratio (TRR; measuring proportion of threshold elevation above 2.0 mA eliminated by decompression), and Threshold Excess (TE; residual threshold remaining above 2.0 mA), with TRR and TE anchored to 2.0 mA based on published normal ranges. Results: Among 40 patients with baseline pain, threshold-anchored metrics showed substantially stronger correlations with pain improvement than percentage-based measures (TRR: r = 0.656, p < 0.001 vs. percentage: r = 0.397, p = 0.011). Threshold Excess was associated with a linear dose–response: each 1 mA above 2.0 mA corresponded to 6.3% less pain improvement (p = 0.001). Patients achieving ≤2.0 mA had 6.1-fold increased odds of complete pain relief versus those above 2.0 mA (76.5% vs. 34.8%, p = 0.013). Internal leave-one-out cross-validation suggested internal stability (TRR shrinkage ≈ 9.3%; TE’s dose–response slope remained stable). Conclusions: In this exploratory pilot study, threshold-anchored MMG metrics (TRR and TE) showed stronger correlations with early pain outcomes than percentage-based measures. These exploratory findings require external validation in independent cohorts before clinical implementation. If validated prospectively, these metrics could provide objective, real-time feedback for clinical interpretation to inform surgical decision-making during spinal decompression, enabling surgeons to tailor decompression to individual physiology rather than relying on standardized anatomical criteria. Future work should explore patient-specific threshold targets that account for age, chronicity, and comorbidities.

21 November 2025

Background: Osteoporosis is a prevalent metabolic disorder frequently managed with bisphosphonates, which reduce fracture risk but, with prolonged use, may predispose to atypical femoral fractures (AFFs). These rare but serious complications highlight the need for individualized treatment strategies within the framework of precision medicine. Methods: We retrospectively analyzed six female patients (mean age around 70 years) with AFFs surgically treated at the University of Catania between September 2022 and March 2023. All patients had received bisphosphonate therapy for more than seven years. Demographic, clinical, and radiographic data were collected according to ASBMR criteria. Outcomes included fracture healing, hip and knee range of motion, quality of life (SF-36), and residual pain (VAS) at 12 months. Results: Fractures were subtrochanteric in two cases and mid-diaphyseal in four. All patients underwent intramedullary nailing. Mean radiographic union occurred at 5 ± 1.5 months, and functional recovery occurred at 4.5 ± 1.2 months. Quality of life declined from a pre-fracture SF-36 score of 77 to 57 at one year. Residual pain was minimal (VAS 2). Conclusions: Prolonged bisphosphonate therapy was strongly associated with AFFs, longer healing times, and reduced quality of life. These findings emphasize the importance of personalized management of osteoporosis, including risk-based treatment duration, tailored monitoring protocols, and early therapeutic adjustments to balance efficacy and safety in long-term care.

21 November 2025

News & Conferences

Issues

Open for Submission

Editor's Choice

Reprints of Collections

Novel Challenges and Therapeutic Options for Digestive and Liver Diseases
Reprint

Novel Challenges and Therapeutic Options for Digestive and Liver Diseases

Editors: Daniel Paramythiotis, Eleni Karlafti
New Challenges and Perspectives in Neurology and Autonomic Disorders
Reprint

New Challenges and Perspectives in Neurology and Autonomic Disorders

Editors: Svetlana Blitshteyn, Ilene Ruhoy, Jennifer Robblee

Get Alerted

Add your email address to receive forthcoming issues of this journal.

XFacebookLinkedIn
J. Pers. Med. - ISSN 2075-4426