Abstract
The integration of social media into the media landscape brings about important editorial and ethical considerations that impact daily work routines and traditional journalism principles. One inevitable thing is that digital media have allowed the rapid growth of citizen journalism. Consequently, this has resulted in tampering with privacy, causing panic and fear among members of civil society. The rapid growth of digital media has blurred the distinction between citizen journalism and professional journalism in South Africa, creating complex ethical challenges regarding accuracy, accountability, public interest, and freedom of expression. Citizen journalists often provide immediate coverage of events and amplify marginalised voices, yet they may lack the professional training, editorial oversight, and ethical standards that guide traditional journalism. Professional journalists, while adhering to established codes of conduct, may face criticism for gatekeeping information or failing to represent diverse community perspectives. This paper applies Aristotle’s Golden Mean ethical framework to examine how these competing approaches can be balanced in a democratic society. The Golden Mean advocates moderation between extremes, suggesting that ethical journalism should avoid both unregulated dissemination of information and excessive institutional control. Through this lens, a virtuous approach to journalism in South Africa would encourage citizen participation while maintaining commitments to truthfulness, verification, fairness, and responsibility. The study argues that the Golden Mean offers a practical ethical model for navigating tensions between speed and accuracy, freedom and accountability, and public participation and professional standards. Ultimately, the framework promotes a balanced media environment that supports democratic engagement while minimising the risks of misinformation, bias, and harm to individuals and communities. This study recommends a high level of ethical conduct and a code of practice among those collecting and sharing information, and the implications of citizen journalism on a person’s privacy. Furthermore, the study also recommends awareness of the danger of distributing inaccurate or unverified information by citizen journalists and the incorporation of social media services into everyday routines in the newsroom to enhance journalistic practice.