Skip to Content
Education SciencesEducation Sciences
  • Article
  • Open Access

10 October 2026

20 Pages

Belonging, Visibility, and Voice: Perceptions and Practices Promoting Social–Emotional Support in Online Learning in Teacher Education

1
Faculty of Education, Oranim Academic College of Education, Tivon 3600600, Israel
2
Department of Counseling and Human Development, Faculty of Education, University of Haifa, Haifa 3498838, Israel

Abstract

The consolidation of online learning in higher education raises a question teacher education can no longer defer: How is social–emotional support created when teaching and learning are mediated by screens? This study explored how preservice teachers experienced social-emotional learning (SEL) in an online course, focusing on three dimensions: belonging, visibility, and voice. Using reflexive thematic analysis within a constructivist orientation, the study analyzed the summative written reflections, composed as letters to the lecturer, of preservice teachers (N = 27) in a year-long synchronous online course at a teacher education institution. The cohort, aged 19 to 35, was heterogeneous in life circumstances, professional experience, and learning profiles. The analysis constructed four themes: belonging built through structured relational rituals; visibility as pedagogical noticing across the screen; voice as graduated, chosen participation; and the intended translation of experienced online SEL (O-SEL) into a professional toolbox for inclusive teaching. The findings indicate that the online space is double-edged: it heightens the risks of invisibility and disconnection, yet its affordances, written channels, structured formats, and learner control over self-presentation, can deepen inclusion when deliberately designed. Because the letters were addressed to the lecturer–researcher, the findings are read as situated accounts of perceived support and intended practice rather than as evidence of effectiveness or of classroom implementation. The discussion links the findings to systemic and transformative SEL and online disinhibition theory, and proposes a practice architecture for preparing teachers for inclusive classrooms.

1. Introduction

Online learning has moved from the margins of higher education to its infrastructure. What began for many institutions as emergency remote teaching (Hodges et al., 2020) has settled into a durable feature of academic programs, including teacher-preparation programs. Yet the debate that accompanied this transition concentrated largely on technologies, platforms, and learning outcomes, while an underlying question remained underexplored: What happens to the social and emotional fabric of learning when the classroom becomes a grid of windows on a screen? For teacher education, this question is doubly consequential because preservice teachers not only learn course content but also absorb, through the way they themselves are taught, a working model of what teaching is (Darling-Hammond et al., 2020).
Social–emotional learning (SEL) offers a systematic framework for that fabric. SEL refers to the processes through which learners and educators acquire and apply the knowledge, skills, and attitudes needed to understand and manage emotions, establish supportive relationships, and make caring, responsible decisions (Weissberg et al., 2015). Contemporary scholarship has widened the frame from discrete student competencies to systemic SEL, in which classroom practices, adult competencies, organizational climate, and family and community partnerships operate as one aligned system (Domitrovich et al., 2025; Mahoney et al., 2021), and to transformative SEL, which places identity, agency, belonging, and cultural context at the center rather than the periphery of the model (Jagers et al., 2019; Polleck, 2025). At the same time, the field continues to struggle with inconsistent terminology and with the absence of agreed training frameworks for developing the social–emotional competencies of teachers and teacher educators (Kasperski et al., 2025).
The migration of SEL into online spaces, referred to here as online social–emotional learning (O-SEL; Lapidot-Lefler, 2022), inherits these difficulties and adds its own. Educators report lower self-efficacy for addressing learners’ social–emotional needs online than for delivering content online (Yang, 2021). The cues on which relational teaching ordinarily relies, such as eye contact, physical co-presence, and the informal talk in corridors and during breaks, are attenuated or absent. Research on computer-mediated communication has long shown that these very conditions, and above all invisibility and the loss of eye contact, reshape how people express themselves online, sometimes toward aggression and sometimes toward openness and self-disclosure (Lapidot-Lefler & Barak, 2012, 2015; Suler, 2004). The online space is therefore not merely a thinner version of the classroom; it is a psychologically different environment with social–emotional dynamics that must be studied and designed in their own right.
This study explored O-SEL in teacher education through three interrelated experiential dimensions: belonging, the learner’s sense of being an accepted and valued member of the learning group; visibility, the sense of being seen and recognized as a particular person rather than a name on a screen; and voice, the sense of being able to express oneself and that this expression matters. These dimensions were chosen because each names a point at which online learning is widely assumed to fail and because each is foundational to SEL itself: Belonging, visibility, and voice provide the relational ground on which social–emotional competencies can be exercised (Baumeister & Leary, 1995; Noddings, 2005; Peacock et al., 2020).
The study asked two questions. First, how do preservice teachers experience and perceive SEL in the online space, in terms of belonging, visibility, and voice? Second, which practices do they identify as promoting social–emotional support in online learning in teacher education? Answers were sought in the summative reflective letters of preservice teachers who completed a year-long synchronous online course that deliberately integrated SEL theory and practice, with a curriculum that was itself devoted to the pedagogy of learner diversity and inclusion. The study thereby responds to recent calls for research on comprehensive programs and professional development initiatives that develop the social–emotional competencies, resilience, and professional values of students, teachers, and teacher educators within inclusive and special education contexts (Domitrovich et al., 2025; Kasperski et al., 2025). It traces how a highly diverse cohort of working teachers, parents, and students with a wide range of life and learning experiences described deliberately designed O-SEL practices as supporting their participation in a shared learning space, and how they intended to build such spaces for their own diverse pupils.

2. Theoretical Background

2.1. From SEL to Systemic and Transformative SEL

The first generation of SEL scholarship defined a set of five interrelated competencies (self-awareness, self-management, social awareness, relationship skills, and responsible decision-making) (Weissberg et al., 2015). Later work reframed SEL as a property of systems rather than of individuals: Systemic SEL asks how policies, adult learning, classroom pedagogy, and community partnership align to support the social–emotional development of the entire school community, including educators (Domitrovich et al., 2025; Mahoney et al., 2021). Transformative SEL extended this: Jagers et al. (2019) inserted expressions of identity, agency, belonging, and engagement into the competency model in the service of educational equity, and subsequent inclusive reconceptualizations have reorganized the model itself, making identity and culture a constitutive component of the competency rather than an external lens applied to a neutral skill (Polleck, 2025). The theoretical implication is sharp: There is no culture-free skill to teach first and adapt later, because the very definition of the competency is interwoven with the learner’s identity and context.
Teacher education occupies a strategic position in this systemic picture. Teachers’ own social–emotional competencies condition both their well-being and their capacity to support learners (Hemi & Kasperski, 2023; Yang, 2021). However, structured opportunities to develop these competencies during preparation remain scarce and unevenly conceptualized (Kasperski et al., 2025), and teacher educators themselves report uncertainty about how to build them (Hooper & Johnson, 2025). Studies of SEL-oriented teacher preparation indicate that experiential formats, such as clinical simulations and relationship-centered course design, can develop these competencies in preservice teachers (Kasperski & Hemi, 2024; Lapidot-Lefler, 2022; Lapidot-Lefler & Israeli, 2024) and that crises that force programs online make such preparation more, not less, urgent (Hadar et al., 2020). The present study joins this line of work at the point where it is least researched: the deliberate enactment of SEL within an online academic course.
Recent SEL scholarship has drawn on the science of learning and development, which holds that cognition, emotion, and relationship develop together and that learning is relationally mediated (Darling-Hammond et al., 2020). This position has a theoretical lineage in sociocultural theory, and the present study reads SEL through it. Following Vygotsky (1978), social–emotional competencies are understood as higher psychological functions that develop first between people, in mediated joint activity, and only later within the individual. In these terms, a check-in ritual, a message after an absence, or a scaffolded invitation to speak is a form of mediation through which regulation, awareness, and relationship are first experienced socially and then appropriated. The same reading gives transformative SEL its developmental mechanism: If competencies are appropriated within culturally organized activity, identity and context cannot be external to them (Jagers et al., 2019; Polleck, 2025). Two consequences follow for the present study. The unit of analysis is the designed activity and the relationship rather than the individual skill, and teacher education is a doubly mediated setting: Preservice teachers meet SEL both as content and as the mediated form of their own learning, and what they later carry into classrooms is what they have appropriated through that experience.

2.2. O-SEL: Social–Emotional Learning in Online Spaces

The literature on online learning has developed its own vocabulary for the relational dimension of screen-mediated study. The Community of Inquiry framework identified social presence, the ability of participants to project themselves socially and emotionally as real people, as one of three pillars of meaningful online learning (Garrison et al., 2000). Within that framework, emotion was first treated as a category of social presence and was later proposed as a distinct emotional presence, the expression of emotion, affect, and feeling in the course of online inquiry (Cleveland-Innes & Campbell, 2012). A study of preservice teachers in an online SEL course during the pandemic found that participants located their learning in being asked how they were, being seen, and being heard, and proposed that social presence be reconceived as social–emotional presence (Lapidot-Lefler, 2022). The two constructs should not be conflated. Emotional presence, in the Community of Inquiry tradition, describes what participants express; social–emotional presence, as used in the O-SEL framework, describes what a course is designed to make possible: the deliberate provision of relational and emotional support, through specific practices, so that learners experience being asked, seen, and heard. In online literature courses in teacher education, lecturers and preservice teachers likewise identified relationship building, collaboration, and emotional involvement as essential practices of online teaching, alongside techno-pedagogical skills that the original competency model does not include (Levin & Segev, 2023). Beyond the single course, perceived social support from peers and mentors during online and hybrid phases of teacher education has been linked to preservice teachers’ perceived learning success and competence (Neuber & Göbel, 2022), which suggests that the relational dimension matters for professional development and not only for well-being. Scholarship on humanizing and caring online pedagogy has argued that care must be intentionally designed into online courses because the medium does not produce it incidentally (Mehta & Aguilera, 2020; Noddings, 2005; Pacansky-Brock et al., 2020), and that teacher presence online is likewise an achievement of deliberate design of activity and interaction rather than a by-product of the platform (Rapanta et al., 2020). Recent reviews of technology-enabled SEL in higher education concluded that the field remains fragmented, with practices reported anecdotally and rarely theorized (Mukhemar et al., 2025).
The term O-SEL, introduced in that earlier study, is used here to name a specific claim: that SEL in the online space is not the transfer of classroom SEL activities to a video platform, but a re-design of social–emotional support around the affordances and constraints of the medium. Some constraints are obvious, such as the attenuation of nonverbal cues and the ease of disappearing behind a closed camera. The affordances are less obvious and less studied: written and asynchronous channels that allow composed self-expression, structured formats that lower the social cost of participation, fine-grained learner control over self-presentation, and the possibility of private, immediate contact between learner and teacher alongside the public space of the lesson. A central purpose of this study was to document how these affordances were experienced by preservice teachers when a course was deliberately built around them.

2.3. Belonging, Visibility, and Voice

The need to belong is a fundamental human motivation, and its satisfaction or frustration shapes cognition, emotion, and behavior in any learning environment (Baumeister & Leary, 1995). In online higher education, sense of belonging has been identified as central to learner engagement, persistence, and well-being, and as an achievement of design rather than an automatic by-product of enrollment (Peacock et al., 2020). Belonging in a learning group is closely tied to participation in shared practice: Learners come to see themselves as members of a community through legitimate, mutually recognized activity within it (Wenger, 1998).
Visibility refers to the experience of being seen and recognized as a particular person. The ethics of care positions this experience at the heart of education: Caring begins in attention, in the engrossment of the one-caring in the reality of the cared-for, and is completed only when the cared-for recognizes that they have been seen (Noddings, 2005). In physical classrooms, visibility is carried by a dense stream of micro-signals. Online, those signals thin out, making visibility something a teacher must build deliberately: by noticing absence, by following up individually, by remembering and referencing learners’ words and circumstances.
Voice denotes the learner’s experienced capacity to express thoughts, feelings, and positions, and the sense that this expression is received and matters. Voice is developmental and relational: It is built through mediation, through safe scaffolded opportunities to speak, and through the gradual internalization of participation that was first supported by others (Vygotsky, 1978). In online settings, voice acquires additional degrees of freedom: it can be spoken or written, synchronous or delayed, publicly shared or privately addressed to the teacher, and each channel carries a different threshold of exposure. Taken together, the three dimensions are treated here as designable features of a learning environment rather than as by-products of it (Pacansky-Brock et al., 2020; Peacock et al., 2020).

2.4. An Online Disinhibition Lens on Presence and Participation

Online disinhibition theory offers a distinctive analytic lens for these three dimensions. Suler (2004) described the online disinhibition effect, the loosening of social restraints in computer-mediated communication, and distinguished its toxic expression (hostility, aggression) from its benign expression (openness, self-disclosure, unusual generosity). Experimental work identified the conditions that drive the effect, showing that invisibility and, above all, lack of eye contact are the strongest contributors to toxic online disinhibition (Lapidot-Lefler & Barak, 2012), while under other situational configurations the same distance can induce self-disclosure and prosocial behavior, a benign disinhibition with pedagogical potential (Lapidot-Lefler & Barak, 2015).
Read through this lens, the online classroom is a field of disinhibition conditions that can tilt either way. Left undesigned, invisibility breeds disengagement: Cameras close, faces disappear, learners become unseen and unheard, and the group dissolves into an audience. Deliberately designed, the same medium can be turned toward the benign pole: Written channels can make self-disclosure easier than speech; structured formats can contain exposure; and the teacher’s engineered acts of noticing can restore the eye contact that the platform withholds. The three dimensions studied here, belonging, visibility, and voice, map directly onto the psychological terrain that disinhibition research has charted, and the practices documented in the findings can be read as an attempt to manage disinhibition conditions in favor of connection.

2.5. SEL and the Preparation of Teachers for Inclusive and Special Education

SEL and inclusive education converge on a single premise: that learning environments must be organized around the full human variety of those who inhabit them. In inclusive and special education settings, the social–emotional dimensions studied here are not enrichment but access itself. Belonging, visibility, and voice are the conditions under which participation in learning becomes possible at all for pupils with disabilities, learning differences, or histories of exclusion (Jagers et al., 2019; Polleck, 2025). In screen-mediated settings this access is not supplied by the technology: Teachers of learners with special educational needs report being unprepared for e-learning and needing support in designing accessible instruction and interaction (Yazçayır, 2023), which makes the intentional design of digital interaction, rather than platform adoption, the relevant unit of inclusive practice. Teacher responsiveness, the capacity to notice and adjust to learners’ shifting circumstances and needs, has accordingly been identified as a linchpin of inclusive pedagogical practice and of teacher well-being (Lapidot-Lefler, 2025). Teacher preparation for inclusion therefore carries a double task: to teach about learner diversity and to enable preservice teachers to experience, in their own learning, what an inclusive environment feels like. The course studied here was built around this double task: Its curriculum addressed the pedagogy of learner diversity, including attention deficit disorders, specific learning disabilities, the autism spectrum, trauma, and emotional-behavioral needs, while its online pedagogy was designed to ensure that a diverse adult cohort, a third of whom themselves lived with these differences, would experience belonging, visibility, and voice in practice.

2.6. The Present Study

Against this background, the study explored the experiences and perceptions of preservice teachers who completed a year-long online course in which SEL was both subject matter and lived practice. Two research questions guided the inquiry: (1) How do preservice teachers experience and perceive SEL in the online space, in terms of belonging, visibility, and voice? (2) Which practices do preservice teachers identify as promoting social–emotional support in online learning in teacher education?

3. Materials and Methods

3.1. Research Design

The study employed a qualitative design and used reflexive thematic analysis as its analytic method (Braun & Clarke, 2006, 2019, 2021). Within the range of orientations that reflexive thematic analysis accommodates, the study took a constructivist orientation: The phenomenon of interest was the lived experience of social–emotional support in online learning, the analytic aim was interpretative rather than merely descriptive, and the meanings participants attached to belonging, visibility, and voice were treated as situated constructions rather than as reports of an underlying reality. Reflexive thematic analysis, rather than an idiographic approach such as interpretative phenomenological analysis, was chosen because a corpus of 27 letters called for patterned meaning across the cohort rather than case-by-case analysis, and because its account of the researcher as an active constructor of meaning fits a study in which the analyst was also the course lecturer; themes were accordingly understood as constructed by the researcher through engagement with the data rather than as discovered in it (Braun & Clarke, 2019, 2021). The overall logic of qualitative inquiry followed established guidance (Creswell & Poth, 2018).

3.2. Research Setting: The Course as a Case

The study was conducted in a year-long course on leading the classroom space, taught in a secondary teacher preparation program at a teacher education institution. The course was delivered synchronously online via the Zoom videoconferencing platform (Zoom Workplace, version 7.0.6; Zoom Video Communications, San Jose, CA, USA), with occasional hybrid meetings, and integrated SEL at two levels simultaneously: as curriculum (theoretical and practical study of social–emotional processes, learner diversity and special educational needs, and teacher–parent partnership) and as pedagogy (the deliberate enactment of SEL practices in the conduct of the course itself). Recurring practices included an emotional check-in at the beginning of each session and a check-out at the end; collaborative digital boards on which students wrote reflectively about the material; small-group work in breakout rooms; peer-led sessions in which pairs of students taught the group about a dimension of learner diversity, such as attention deficit disorders, specific learning disabilities, the autism spectrum, or the experience of pupils coping with trauma, frequently anchored in their own lived experience; a simulation session with a trained actor; expressive writing in structured formats; and personal channels between lecturer and students, including messages after missed sessions and individual online meetings.
These practices were woven through the year in three strands rather than delivered as a module. In the first strand, learning about SEL, participants studied the conceptual foundations of SEL and of learner diversity through readings, lectures, and discussion. In the second strand, experiencing SEL, they took part, as learners, in the recurring rituals and structured activities described above, so that the course itself became a place where social–emotional support was practiced on them. In the third strand, doing SEL, they designed social–emotional activities for their own disciplines and pupils, enacted them with their peers in the online space, and explained the rationale behind them; the peer-led sessions on dimensions of learner diversity and the simulation with a trained actor belonged to this strand. Alongside the group work ran a personal channel: brief messages after absences, greetings on life events, and individual online meetings that any participant could request and that the lecturer also initiated when a participant seemed to be struggling. The three strands and the personal channel were intended to reinforce one another, so that what participants learned about SEL they also experienced as learners and rehearsed as teachers.
The course was chosen as a case because its O-SEL design was deliberate rather than incidental. It built on an earlier study of SEL in an online teacher education course during the pandemic, which traced the emotional, conceptual, and behavioral impact of O-SEL practices on preservice teachers and proposed the concept of social–emotional presence (Lapidot-Lefler, 2022). The present course extended those practices into a post-pandemic setting in which online delivery was a choice of program design rather than an emergency measure, and in which the curriculum itself addressed inclusion and special educational needs. It therefore offered an information-rich case for the questions posed here.

3.3. Participants

Twenty-seven preservice teachers participated in the course during the 2025–2026 academic year. They were undergraduate students, aged 19 to 35, preparing to teach secondary school subjects including history, languages, mathematics, and the arts, and enrolled together in this education course. Six participants were men and 21 were women. The cohort was notably heterogeneous: most (22 of 27) worked with excluded youth during the year, in school practicum and as guides of community-based special projects that form part of their program, while five completed their practicum in mainstream secondary schools; six were already employed as teachers, three in secondary schools, one in a primary school, and two in residential settings for vulnerable youth; seven were parents, three of them parents of children with diagnosed learning disabilities or attention deficits; and nine reported living with such differences themselves. All 27 consented to the use of their letters, so that the analyzed corpus comprised the summative reflective letters of all 27 participants; the letters ranged from one to six pages in length, and most were about three pages. Table 1 presents an aggregate profile of the cohort. Because several participants’ circumstances are distinctive enough to be identifying within a single cohort, the profile is reported in aggregate rather than as a per-participant list, and counts of life circumstances rest on what participants disclosed in the course or in their letters. All names appearing in the findings are pseudonyms, and identifying details have been either removed or generalized. Personal circumstances are reported only where participants themselves connected them to the course experience in their letters.
Table 1. Aggregate profile of the cohort.

3.4. Data Collection

Data were collected through a structured summative reflection written at the end of the academic year, after final course grades had been issued. The reflection took the form of a letter to the lecturer, and the term letter is used below to refer to these reflections. Participants were invited to write a letter, beginning with the words “I wanted to tell you that…”, summarizing the process they had undergone in the course in their own style and voice. Guiding questions invited them to recall one meaningful online SEL activity; to describe moments of belonging or, alternatively, of disconnection and loneliness in the online space; to describe experiences of being seen or of feeling invisible; to reflect on moments in which their voice was heard or withheld; to compare SEL in the online space with SEL in the physical classroom; to look across the year for change in their sense of belonging, visibility, and voice; and to identify online SEL practices they would carry into their own teaching. Participants were explicitly free to address any or all of these prompts, and the letters accordingly vary in length, structure, and emphasis. Letters were written in Hebrew, the language of instruction. Excerpts quoted below were translated into English by the author, a native Hebrew speaker with academic fluency in English, following a meaning-based rather than word-for-word approach so that idiom and tone would survive; each translated excerpt was then compared with the original by a bilingual colleague, and wording was adjusted where a nuance had shifted. Back-translation was not used, since the aim was fidelity of tone rather than lexical equivalence.
The choice of an epistolary format is a design decision with interpretive consequences, and it is treated throughout this article as a constraint on what the data can show rather than as a limitation to be listed at the end. A letter addressed to the lecturer, opening with “I wanted to tell you that…”, invites warmth, gratitude, and appreciative summary; it positions the reader as the person who created the experience being described; and it was written by students to a teacher they had known for a year, even though grades were already final. Three consequences follow for the analysis. First, positive evaluation of the course cannot be read as evidence of effectiveness; what the letters can show is how participants described, ordered, and made sense of their experience when invited to do so in this genre. Second, the practices participants attribute to the lecturer are reported as their attributions, and the analytic commentary avoids causal language. Third, the frequency of gratitude in the corpus is treated as partly a property of the genre, so that analytic weight is placed on the specific, concrete practices participants named, on the moments they described as difficult or unresolved, and on the negative cases, rather than on appreciation as such. The dataset is also single-source: All data are of one text type, written at one point in time, with no observational, interview, or longitudinal corroboration.

3.5. Data Analysis

Analysis proceeded in six phases (Braun & Clarke, 2006). First, all letters were read repeatedly for familiarization, with initial observations recorded. Second, the corpus was coded systematically, with codes staying close to participants’ language (for example, “choosing how much to be seen”; “message after a missed session,” “easier to write than to speak”). Third, codes were clustered into candidate themes organized around belonging, visibility, and voice as deductive sensitizing concepts, introduced through the reflection prompt and carried into the analysis as an initial organizing frame, while remaining open to material that exceeded them. Because the reflection prompt itself named these three dimensions, their presence in the letters was not treated as a finding; what the analysis sought was how participants filled each dimension with content, which practices they attached to it, and where their accounts diverged from or exceeded the frame. In reporting the findings, material that exceeded the frame was deliberately foregrounded: the renewability of belonging for intermittent attenders, the location of visibility in the para-instructional layer rather than in the video image, the multiplicity of channels through which voice was exercised, and the negative cases in which the designed practices did not work for a participant; material that merely restated the prompt was demoted or omitted. The analysis was therefore deductively oriented at the level of the three dimensions and inductive within them, a combination that reflexive thematic analysis explicitly accommodates (Braun & Clarke, 2019). The fourth theme reported below, the intended translation of experienced practices into a professional toolbox, was constructed inductively in this phase. Fourth, themes were reviewed against the full corpus, with deliberate attention to disconfirming cases, several of which are reported in the findings. Fifth, themes were named and defined. Sixth, the report was produced, pairing each theme with illustrative excerpts and interpretative commentary. Consistent with the interpretative orientation, the analysis treats the letters as acts of meaning-making addressed to a particular reader, and this rhetorical situation is considered explicitly in Section 3.4 and Section 3.6 and in the discussion of limitations.
To make the analytic process transparent, Table 2 traces selected excerpts through initial codes to the themes constructed from the corpus, including the negative cases that bounded the first and third themes.
Table 2. From excerpts to themes: examples of the analytic process.

3.6. Ethical Considerations and Trustworthiness

The study forms part of a research program on O-SEL in teacher education that was approved by the institutional research ethics committee on 5 August 2021; the first study under that approval was conducted during the pandemic (Lapidot-Lefler, 2022). For the present cohort, taught during the 2025–2026 academic year, the committee approved an extension on 2 June 2026, before the letters and consent forms were collected at the end of that academic year, so that the current data collection was covered by a valid approval throughout. Participation was voluntary and confidential rather than anonymous: The letters were addressed to the lecturer and were fully identifiable to her, and anonymity applies to publication only, through pseudonyms and the removal or generalization of identifying details. Written informed consent was obtained on a form approved by the committee. To remove any dependence between participation and evaluation, both the letters and the consent forms were collected only after final course grades had been issued, so that participants decided whether to take part, and wrote their letters, knowing that their grades were already final. The dual role of lecturer and researcher was addressed through several safeguards: collection after grading, systematic search for negative cases, maintenance of an audit trail linking every interpretative claim to dated source material, reflexive memo-writing throughout the analysis, and a reading of each letter for what it withheld, hedged, or described as difficult alongside what it praised. The dual role is nonetheless likely to have shaped the narratives in identifiable ways: Participants wrote to a reader they knew, described practices that reader had designed, and could reasonably assume that she would recognize herself in their accounts. Rather than treating this as noise, the analysis treated it as part of the phenomenon: The letters are accounts of a relationship given to one of its parties, and their warmth is read as data about how that relationship was experienced, not as evidence about the course’s effects. Trustworthiness was further supported by thick description of context and practices, verbatim quotation, and transparent reporting of the analytic procedure (Creswell & Poth, 2018). As the lecturer of the course and its sole researcher, I approached the letters with a commitment to SEL in teacher education and with a research background in online disinhibition. Both shaped what I was disposed to notice, and both were treated in the memos and the audit trail as a resource to be interrogated rather than as a bias that could be removed.

4. Findings

Four themes were constructed from the corpus: (1) belonging built through structured relational rituals; (2) visibility as pedagogical noticing across the screen; (3) voice as graduated, chosen participation; and (4) the transition from experienced O-SEL to an intended professional toolbox for inclusive teaching. Together they describe an online space that participants entered with skepticism and frequently with apprehension and that many came to describe, by the end of the year, in terms of connection, safety, and being seen rather than of distance. The themes are reported within the constraint described in Section 3.4: They trace how participants described and attributed their experience in letters written to the lecturer, and analytic weight rests on what exceeded the prompt’s frame, on the specific practices participants named, and on the negative cases.

4.1. Belonging Built Through Structured Relational Rituals

Participants rarely attributed their sense of belonging to spontaneous chemistry. Again and again, they linked it to specific, recurring, deliberately structured practices: the emotional check-in that opened each session, the check-out that closed it, small-group work in breakout rooms, and shared activities in which the group itself became a source of support. Michelle described one such activity:
The activity we ran on Zoom dealt with the advice we give one another for coping with difficulties and challenges. Through the conversation and the advice that was offered, a space was created in which each person could bring themselves, share their struggles, and feel that they were not coping alone.
(Michelle, preservice teacher working in community-based youth education)
The decisive phrase is a space was created: Belonging is described not as a feeling that happened to arise but as an environment that was constructed, through a designed activity, inside a video call. The activity gave mutual support a legitimate, bounded format, and it was the format, rather than exhortation, to which she attributed the experience of being accompanied. For practitioners, the implication is that, in online settings, the group does not become a group by being co-present on a screen but by doing structured relational work.
The opening and closing rituals carried particular weight. Talia, whose attendance was disrupted by an extended period of emergency duty, connected the check-in to the very possibility of a safe space:
I especially connected to opening the lesson with an emotional check-in. I loved that the lecturer made room to stop for a moment, to ask how you are, and to take a genuine interest in the feeling each of us brought to the session. In my view, this is a simple but meaningful way to create a safer space and to build the relationship between lecturer and students, and later between a teacher and her pupils.
(Talia, preservice teacher)
Talia named the mechanism precisely: The check-in is simple but meaningful, a low-cost ritual whose value lies in its regularity. As a design element, it synchronizes the group at a shared starting point, lets the teacher scan for learners who need particular attention, and signals, week after week, that people precede content. Notably, even participants who could attend only intermittently, because of emergency duty, childbirth, or work, described these rituals as what allowed them to return without feeling that they had lost their place in the group; in their accounts, belonging was renewable rather than continuous. This renewability was not asked about in the prompt and is one of the findings that exceeded its frame.
A minority voice marks the boundary of the theme. Ruth wrote that because everything was on Zoom, it was hard for me to feel connected or close to the group, and located her belonging, instead, in one peer who invited her into a shared presentation with such openness and acceptance (Ruth, preservice teacher and mother of young children). Her account is a reminder that structured whole-group rituals do not produce belonging for everyone; for some learners, belonging develops through a single relationship rather than through the collective, and course design must leave room for both routes.

4.2. Visibility: Pedagogical Noticing Across the Screen

The most emotionally charged passages in the corpus concern moments of being seen, and their opposite, the fear of being invisible. What is striking is where participants located visibility: not in the video image, but in acts of noticing that crossed the boundary of the lesson. Hala, whose attendance was constrained by work, wrote:
Personally, I felt that I mattered to you, that there was room for my voice, and that you saw me even if I was not present in every lesson. For me, this is a living example of an educational space that is inclusive, safe, and enabling, and I hope to be an educator who can give that same feeling to the pupils I meet.
(Hala, preservice teacher working with adolescents)
The phrase you saw me even if I was not present captures the paradox at the heart of online visibility: The participant felt most seen precisely where the medium made her least visible. The seeing she describes was attributed, across the corpus, to deliberate practices: a message after a missed session asking how she was, the mention of an absent student’s name in class, flexibility that was personal rather than procedural. Munir, whose participation was interrupted during the year by difficult personal circumstances, closed his letter with the same idea:
Thank you for seeing me even when I was not physically there. Your flexibility and understanding allowed me to feel that I belonged despite everything.
(Munir, preservice teacher)
In disinhibition terms, these practices can be read as reversing the default valence of online invisibility. Where invisibility ordinarily loosens the bonds of mutual regard (Lapidot-Lefler & Barak, 2012), participants here described the teacher’s engineered noticing as restoring the experience of eye contact by other means. Rebecca’s account details the machinery of this noticing:
The messages after a Zoom session I had missed, asking how I was; the congratulatory messages after the birth; a personal online meeting in which you truly took an interest, asked me questions, and also told me about yourself. You turned the course I had dreaded into an interesting, learning place that is also a safe and containing space.
(Rebecca, preservice teacher and new mother)
The analytic point is that none of the acts Rebecca lists occurred during instruction. Visibility online was located, in participants’ accounts, largely in the para-instructional layer, in messages, follow-ups, and individual meetings that occurred around the lessons. This location of visibility outside the lesson was not suggested by the prompt, which asked about being seen without specifying where, and it exceeded the prompt’s frame. Participants then generalized the experience into a professional principle: In Rania’s words, after describing how she would arrive at sessions after difficult days at school and leave calmer, with more strength, the feeling of being truly seen is exactly what every pupil needs to feel with their teacher (Rania, preservice teacher working with vulnerable youth). The experience of being seen thus functioned at once as support for the participants and as curriculum, a lived lesson in what they were learning to offer their own pupils.
Visibility also had an inclusive dimension within the group. Ethan, who had shared personal subjects with the group, wrote that these disclosures had sometimes made him feel exposed, yet the space created in the course gave me a strong feeling of belonging and full visibility… the responses made me feel that my personal experience was an asset and not a burden (Ethan, preservice teacher). For participants who brought their own learning differences into the group, visibility meant that difference could be shown without cost, the condition that inclusive education seeks to create for pupils, and one that the preservice teachers here described experiencing as learners themselves.

4.3. Voice: Graduated, Chosen Participation

Accounts of voice describe a developmental arc rather than a state. Rebecca, who began the year with declared resistance, traced the arc explicitly:
With time and the Zoom sessions, I began to feel more comfortable reading something aloud in the course, unmuting myself, expressing my opinion, or responding to what was said. It was an eye-opening process, and it gave me confidence.
(Rebecca)
Unmuting in the online space is the literal threshold of voice, and participants were acutely aware of crossing it. What enabled the crossing, in their accounts, was a combination of invitation without coercion and learner control over exposure. Sarah formulated the principle:
Within the lesson, you really tried to include the class as much as possible, but without pressuring anyone, and that matters. It allowed genuine, honest expression from whoever wanted it, which is by no means self-evident in a Zoom course. I also felt I could choose, each time, how much I wanted to be seen and heard, and so I felt more at ease throughout the whole course.
(Sarah, preservice teacher)
The decisive formulation is choose, each time, how much: Voice, online, was experienced as safe because it was granular and revocable. Where the physical classroom often forces a binary of participation or silence, the online course offered a graduated ladder: listening, writing on the shared whiteboard, speaking in a small breakout room, speaking to the plenary, teaching a session. Maya positioned herself deliberately on its lower rungs and still reported belonging: I usually preferred just to listen and did not share, but the virtual space still felt safe and pleasant. Listening to the conversations and what other students shared gave me a sense of belonging and connected everything we learned to our real lives (Maya, preservice mathematics teacher). Her testimony resists the equation of voice with audible speech: receptive participation, freely chosen, itself constituted membership.
Written channels formed a critical middle rung. Several participants described the collaborative whiteboard as the place where their voice first appeared, because writing allowed composed, unhurried self-expression, an instance of benign disinhibition in which the medium’s distance eased rather than blocked disclosure (Lapidot-Lefler & Barak, 2015). Yet the same channel excluded others. Adam wrote:
I found the shared writing on the collaborative whiteboard difficult. I feel greater freedom in writing when the sharing is personal, with the lecturer, and does not invite possible comparison with others.
(Adam, preservice teacher working with vulnerable youth)
Adam’s discomfort is not a failure of the design but its completion. It shows that no single channel of voice is universally safe and that voice was protected, in this course, by the availability of multiple channels: public and private, spoken and written, synchronous and delayed. This multiplicity, and the fact that different participants located their voice in different channels, was itself outside the prompt’s frame, which asked only whether voice was heard or withheld. Peer-led teaching supplied the highest rung. Participants who taught the group about a dimension of diversity anchored in their own lives, such as eating disorders, the autism spectrum, or growing up with divorced parents, described these sessions as peak experiences of voice. One participant, who, with her partner, composed monologues giving voice to a pupil on the autism spectrum, to his teacher, and to his classmates, wrote that for once we did not speak about difference; we let difference speak.

4.4. From Experienced O-SEL to an Intended Professional Toolbox for Inclusive Teaching

The fourth theme concerns intended transfer. Because the letters were written at the end of the course, what they document is transfer as participants imagined, planned, or reported having begun, not transfer as observed in their classrooms; the theme is therefore named and read as intended transfer. Most letters contained a version of the same movement: a practice experienced as a learner in the online course, re-described as a tool the participant had begun to use or intended to use in teaching diverse pupils. The check-in and check-out were the practices most often named for transfer. Dana, a preservice mathematics teacher, reasoned through the adaptation:
How important it is to start the lesson with a moment of quiet, to ask how everyone is, to give each pupil a moment to gather themselves, and also a chance to notice whether someone needs particular attention. And the check-out is a good way to close the lesson: in mathematics, it may be less emotional, but it can still be a small exercise that sends the pupil home with a feeling of capability, with the sentence “today I learned that…”.
(Dana, preservice mathematics teacher)
Dana did not copy the ritual, but translated it, in her letter, into the grammar of her discipline, which is precisely what teacher education hopes reflective transfer will look like, even if the letter can document the plan and not its enactment. Her letter also records the moment the translation became possible: She had struggled with the digital whiteboard, was invited to stay on after the online session for a short private tutorial, and, weeks later, reported using the same tool to stay in daily contact with her own daughter across continents, before planning it for her future classroom. The scaffold she received privately became a scaffold she could give.
The transfer described by participants was directed, again and again, at the pupils at the center of inclusive education. Participants working in residential settings and with vulnerable youth connected the experience of being seen to pupils whose challenging behavior conceals need; participants teaching mathematics connected the graduated ladder of voice to pupils who freeze at the demand to perform publicly; participants who had taught the group about specific learning disabilities and the autism spectrum wrote that they now watch for the invisible pupils in their own classrooms. Participants wrote explicitly that the decisive pedagogy was modeling. One wrote that the lecturer’s way of conducting the course was itself the curriculum: the greeting at the door of the virtual room, the tone, the response to every request. Another summarized as follows: The course did not only teach pedagogy; it let us experience it in practice in the academic space. This isomorphism, in which the manner of teacher education enacts what its content preaches, appears in the letters as the source of credibility for the practices: Participants had experienced them firsthand before being asked to believe that they could benefit their pupils. This pattern parallels the accounts of secondary teachers who experienced online learning firsthand during the pandemic and drew on that experience, including its isolation and its relational repair, to shape their own online teaching (Carjuzaa & Williams, 2021); in both cases, being a learner in the medium preceded and informed the intention to teach in it. Several also marked its limits from field experience, noting that the surrounding school system rarely extends such social–emotional attention to teachers themselves, expressing a gap between experienced ideal and institutional reality, to which the discussion returns.

5. Discussion

This study asked how preservice teachers experienced SEL in the online space, in terms of belonging, visibility, and voice, and which practices they identified as promoting social–emotional support in online learning. Read within the constraint of letters written to the lecturer (Section 3.4), the findings support three interlocking interpretive claims: that in online settings, belonging, visibility, and voice are described as products of deliberate design rather than by-products of co-presence; that the psychological conditions of the online space can be tilted from disconnection toward disclosure; and that the experience of O-SEL functions, in teacher education, as a second curriculum that participants intend to carry into their professional toolboxes.
The first claim extends the literature on belonging in online higher education. Participants located belonging in structured relational rituals, in check-ins and check-outs, designed peer-support activities, and small-group work, rather than in spontaneous group formation. This is consistent with the argument that sense of belonging online must be intentionally produced (Peacock et al., 2020) and with the Community of Inquiry contention that social presence is a designed achievement (Garrison et al., 2000). The findings add a temporal nuance: In participants’ accounts, rituals made belonging renewable. In a cohort whose attendance was repeatedly broken by emergency duty, childbirth, and work, the fixed, low-threshold format of the rituals was described as allowing members to re-enter the group without accumulated debt. For adult learners with complex lives, this renewability may matter more than continuous cohesion; it resonates with evidence that perceived social support during online phases of teacher education is tied to preservice teachers’ sense of learning success (Neuber & Göbel, 2022); and it speaks directly to inclusion: The practices that intermittent attenders credited with keeping them inside the group are the same practices that inclusive and special education settings need for learners whose participation is irregular for reasons of disability, health, or circumstance, and they align with evidence that teacher responsiveness to learners’ shifting circumstances is a linchpin of inclusive practice (Lapidot-Lefler, 2025). The findings also give content to the earlier proposal that social presence in online learning be reconceived as social–emotional presence (Lapidot-Lefler, 2022): belonging, visibility, and voice can be read as three designable components of such presence.
The second claim engages online disinhibition theory directly. The conditions that research has identified as drivers of toxic disinhibition, above all invisibility and the absence of eye contact (Lapidot-Lefler & Barak, 2012; Suler, 2004), are the default conditions of the synchronous online classroom. The practices documented here can be read as a systematic management of those conditions. Engineered noticing, in messages after missed sessions, naming of absent members, and individual meetings, was described by participants as restoring the functional equivalent of eye contact and reversing the valence of invisibility, so that they could feel seen precisely when unseen. Simultaneously, the course drew on the benign face of the same conditions: Written channels and structured formats were described as lowering the threshold of self-disclosure, in line with evidence that situational configurations of online communication can induce openness and prosocial behavior (Lapidot-Lefler & Barak, 2015). The theoretical proposal that follows is that O-SEL is usefully conceived as disinhibition design: the deliberate configuration of visibility, audience, and channel so that the loosening of restraint in the online space serves connection rather than harm.
Two distinctions sharpen this proposal. The first is between general humanizing practices and medium-specific affordances. Remembering and using a learner’s name, asking how people are, following up after an absence, and holding an individual conversation are not online practices; they belong to relational pedagogy in any setting (Noddings, 2005; Pacansky-Brock et al., 2020), and what the online space changes is their necessity and their cost, because the medium withdraws the incidental noticing that a corridor or a classroom doorway supplies. Other practices in the findings have no direct classroom equivalent and are affordances of the medium itself: the private chat that lets a learner address the teacher during a plenary without being overheard; the breakout room that creates a small, temporarily closed space inside a large one; the collaborative whiteboard on which a contribution can be composed, revised, and posted without speaking; and the mute and camera controls that turn exposure into a graduated choice rather than a binary. Disinhibition design draws on both, but only the second set is new, and it is the second set that lets voice become granular in the way described in the third theme. The second distinction concerns the tools themselves. No digital tool is inherently inclusive, and accessible screen-mediated instruction depends on deliberate design rather than on the platform (Yazçayır, 2023): The same whiteboard that gave several participants their first voice was, for Adam, a site of comparison and exposure, and the same breakout room that created intimacy for some can isolate a learner with the wrong partner. Inclusivity in the online space is therefore not a property of any channel but of the availability of several, so that a learner excluded by one can be reached through another.
Third, the findings on voice refine the construct itself. Voice appeared in the letters as graduated and chosen rather than binary: a ladder of participation modes whose safety derived from learner control over exposure, and whose lowest rung, freely chosen listening, still conferred membership. This granularity is an affordance of the medium, and it aligns with transformative SEL’s insistence that agency and identity are constitutive of competence (Jagers et al., 2019; Polleck, 2025). Participants did not simply acquire the skill of self-expression, but exercised agency over its form, and those who brought their identities into the online space, as parents of children with disabilities, as members of minority communities, or as people living with learning differences, described the space as returning those identities as assets. The negative cases are equally instructive. The participant for whom the collaborative whiteboard felt exposing, and the participant for whom whole-group rituals did not generate connection, show that every channel includes and excludes simultaneously. The availability of multiple channels, not any single practice, is what, in these accounts, made the course inclusive. In this respect, the graduated ladder of voice operates as a social–emotional counterpart of universal design: Participation is planned from the outset for the full range of learners, rather than adapted after the fact for those whom a single format excludes.
Finally, the toolbox theme bears on systemic SEL and on the concerns of inclusive and special education. The systemic model requires social-emotionally competent adults, yet offers few accounts of where adults can develop these competencies (Kasperski et al., 2025; Mahoney et al., 2021). The present findings point to one possible formation mechanism: isomorphic teacher education, in which preservice teachers undergo, as learners, the practices they are expected to enact as teachers. Participants repeatedly stated that they believed in the practices because they had experienced them firsthand; experience preceded and, in their accounts, warranted the intention to adopt. Whether that intention becomes classroom practice is a question the present data cannot answer; the letters document intended transfer, and verified behavioral transfer would require observation of graduates in their own classrooms. This mechanism is consistent with evidence on experiential SEL preparation (Hadar et al., 2020; Kasperski & Hemi, 2024; Lapidot-Lefler & Israeli, 2024) and gives empirical content to the claim that teacher educators are, willingly or not, a living curriculum (Darling-Hammond et al., 2020). It is particularly consequential for inclusive and special education, where the competencies at stake, noticing the unseen pupil, granting voice to those who cannot claim it, keeping irregular attenders inside the group, are precisely those the participants experienced themselves. At the same time, participants’ observation that schools rarely extend such attention to teachers marks the systemic boundary of what any single course can achieve and points to the alignment work that the systemic SEL agenda assigns to institutions rather than individuals (Domitrovich et al., 2025). A comparable gap between preservice teachers’ commitment to SEL as a means of amplifying student voice and the structural pressures that confine it to discrete activities has been reported in secondary teacher preparation (Manchanda et al., 2025).
A further boundary concerns the feasibility of the para-instructional layer. With a cohort of 27, a message after each missed session, a greeting on each life event, and individual meetings on request were sustainable for one lecturer; with enrollments of 80 or 200 they are not, and the practices do not scale linearly. Care in online teaching is emotional labor that remains largely invisible to institutions and insufficiently recognized or resourced (Kennedy et al., 2022), and a course design that depends on the lecturer’s unbounded availability transfers a systemic responsibility onto an individual. Three adaptations preserve the function of the layer at scale without pretending to preserve its form. Noticing can be distributed, through teaching assistants or peer pairs asked to notice absence and reach out, so that the lecturer’s personal contact is reserved for cases the distributed system flags. It can be targeted rather than universal, with brief personal contact after a second absence rather than the first, and standing invitations rather than lecturer-initiated meetings. And it can be bounded openly, with learners told what kind of contact they can expect and when, so that the promise is one the teacher can keep. The systemic SEL agenda applies here to the institution: If the para-instructional layer is the primary carrier of care online, then the time it takes is teaching time and needs to be counted as such.

6. Implications for Practice

The findings support a practice architecture for O-SEL in teacher education, organized by the three dimensions studied. To build belonging, courses need to embed fixed relational rituals at the boundaries of every session, an emotional check-in and check-out whose value lies in regularity rather than depth, and should schedule designed peer-support activities in which the group practices helping itself; small stable groupings in breakout rooms give belonging a protected scale. To support visibility, teachers should budget deliberate time for the para-instructional layer: brief personal messages after absences, explicit naming and welcoming of returning members, and short individual online meetings; in online settings this layer is not administrative overhead but the primary carrier of care, and, as argued above, its form must be adapted to enrollment size. To develop voice, courses should maintain a ladder of participation channels, spoken and written, public and private, synchronous and delayed, and should protect learners’ control over the degree of exposure at every rung, treating chosen listening as legitimate participation; peer-led teaching anchored in participants’ own lives offers the highest rung, on which voice becomes contribution.
Two design principles cut across the dimensions. First, model and name: teacher educators should enact these practices and periodically make the enactment explicit, so that experience is converted into transferable pedagogy. Second, differentiate channels rather than persons: because every channel includes and excludes, inclusiveness is achieved by multiplicity, not by perfecting a single format. Programs preparing teachers for inclusive classrooms may find this architecture doubly relevant, both as preparation for teaching diverse pupils online and as a lived illustration, on the preservice teachers themselves, of what accessible participation feels like. These implications are offered as design propositions grounded in participants’ accounts, not as verified effects; they are starting points for programs to try and to study, rather than conclusions about what works.

7. Limitations and Future Research

Several limitations bound the findings, and the first of them is the constraint that has shaped the reading of the data throughout. The study addressed a single course, taught by a single lecturer who was also the sole researcher, and the data consist of letters addressed to her. Collection after grading removed the dependence of participation on evaluation, and the analysis deliberately sought and reported negative cases, but neither safeguard changes the genre: A summative letter opening with “I wanted to tell you that…”, written to the person who designed the course, invites warmth, gratitude, and an appreciative arc, and it may have led participants to frame their experience more positively, and more coherently, than they would have in an anonymous questionnaire or in an interview with a stranger. Some of what reads in the findings as connection is therefore likely to be, in part, a property of the letter as a form and of the relationship it addresses. For this reason the findings are reported as participants’ situated accounts and attributions, causal and efficacy language has been avoided, and the discussion offers interpretive proposals rather than claims of effect. The dataset is also single-source: one text type, produced at one point in time, with no triangulation through observation, interviews, course artifacts, or follow-up, and a corpus of 27 letters from a single cohort limits the transferability of the findings. Because the prompt named belonging, visibility, and voice, the analysis was deductively oriented at the level of these dimensions rather than purely inductive; the contribution lies in the content participants gave them and in what exceeded them, not in their presence. The cohort, most of whom worked with excluded youth during the year, whether in practicum, community projects, or employment, and many of whom brought substantial life experience, may be particularly disposed to relational pedagogy, and the fourth theme documents intended transfer, that is, stated intention and at most first use as participants themselves described it, rather than observed practice. Excerpts were translated from Hebrew for publication and checked by a second bilingual reader, with the attendant risk of shifted nuance. Future research should collect data through channels that do not address the teacher, such as anonymous reflections or interviews conducted by a third party, and at more than one point in the year; follow graduates into their classrooms to establish whether intended transfer becomes enacted practice; pursue the disinhibition-design proposition comparatively, across instructors, institutions, and cultural contexts; explore the experience of pupils, including pupils with special educational needs, when the documented practices are enacted by graduates in their own online and physical classrooms; and develop ways of documenting belonging, visibility, and voice as distinct, designable dimensions of online learning environments.

8. Conclusions

Online learning is often described as a space in which relationships thin, presence attenuates, and learners disappear. The preservice teachers in this study describe something different: an online course that they entered with apprehension and left having felt, in their own words, seen even when absent, heard even when silent, and part of a group they met only through screens. In their accounts, the difference was made not by the platform but by design: structured relational rituals, engineered noticing, and a graduated architecture of voice that returned control over exposure to the learners. For teacher education, the stakes of such design are doubled, because every practice a program enacts on its students is also a lesson in what teaching is, and for programs preparing teachers for inclusive classrooms the stakes are higher still, because the practices in question are the very substance of inclusion. Where SEL is lived and not only taught, preservice teachers leave, by their own account, with more than a toolbox; they leave with the embodied knowledge that belonging, visibility, and voice can be built anywhere, including on a screen, and that building them is the teacher’s work.

Funding

This research was supported by an institutional research grant from Oranim Academic College of Education (grant no. 5100290).

Institutional Review Board Statement

The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and with institutional ethical guidelines, and was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of the author’s institution (protocol code: 123; date of approval: 2 June 2026).

Data Availability Statement

The data presented in this study are available on request from the corresponding author due to privacy and ethical restrictions.

Acknowledgments

The author thanks the preservice teachers who shared their reflections and their voices. During the preparation of this manuscript, the author used Claude (Claude Opus 5; Anthropic, San Francisco, CA, USA) for minor language editing; the author reviewed and edited all output and takes full responsibility for the content of this publication.

Conflicts of Interest

The author declares no conflicts of interest.

References

  1. Baumeister, R. F., & Leary, M. R. (1995). The need to belong: Desire for interpersonal attachments as a fundamental human motivation. Psychological Bulletin, 117(3), 497–529. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  2. Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  3. Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2019). Reflecting on reflexive thematic analysis. Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health, 11(4), 589–597. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  4. Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2021). One size fits all? What counts as quality practice in (reflexive) thematic analysis? Qualitative Research in Psychology, 18(3), 328–352. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  5. Carjuzaa, J., & Williams, K. (2021). Navigating through turbulent times: U.S. secondary teachers share their experiences as online learners during the COVID-19 pandemic and the implications for their teaching practice. International Journal of Modern Education Studies, 5(2), 245–279. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  6. Cleveland-Innes, M., & Campbell, P. (2012). Emotional presence, learning, and the online learning environment. The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 13(4), 269–292. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  7. Creswell, J. W., & Poth, C. N. (2018). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches (4th ed.). SAGE. [Google Scholar]
  8. Darling-Hammond, L., Flook, L., Cook-Harvey, C., Barron, B., & Osher, D. (2020). Implications for educational practice of the science of learning and development. Applied Developmental Science, 24(2), 97–140. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  9. Domitrovich, C. E., Li, Y., Kendziora, K., & Greenberg, M. T. (2025). Impact of schoolwide support for social and emotional learning: The effect of the CASEL school guide on organizational capacity for SEL and systemic SEL. Social and Emotional Learning: Research, Practice, and Policy, 6, 100156. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  10. Garrison, D. R., Anderson, T., & Archer, W. (2000). Critical inquiry in a text-based environment: Computer conferencing in higher education. The Internet and Higher Education, 2(2–3), 87–105. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  11. Hadar, L. L., Ergas, O., Alpert, B., & Ariav, T. (2020). Rethinking teacher education in a VUCA world: Student teachers’ social-emotional competencies during the COVID-19 crisis. European Journal of Teacher Education, 43(4), 573–586. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  12. Hemi, M. E., & Kasperski, R. (2023). Development and validation of ‘EduSEL’: Educators’ Socio-Emotional Learning questionnaire. Personality and Individual Differences, 201, 111926. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  13. Hodges, C. B., Moore, S., Lockee, B. B., Trust, T., & Bond, M. A. (2020, March 27). The difference between emergency remote teaching and online learning. EDUCAUSE Review. Available online: https://er.educause.edu/articles/2020/3/the-difference-between-emergency-remote-teaching-and-online-learning (accessed on 27 September 2026).
  14. Hooper, A., & Johnson, K. (2025). Teacher educators’ reflections on supporting pre-service and early career educators’ social-emotional learning. Social and Emotional Learning: Research, Practice, and Policy, 5, 100100. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  15. Jagers, R. J., Rivas-Drake, D., & Williams, B. (2019). Transformative social and emotional learning (SEL): Toward SEL in service of educational equity and excellence. Educational Psychologist, 54(3), 162–184. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  16. Kasperski, R., & Hemi, M. E. (2024). Promoting socio-emotional learning competencies in teacher education through online clinical simulations. European Journal of Teacher Education, 47(4), 805–820. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  17. Kasperski, R., Levin, O., & Hemi, M. E. (2025). Systematic literature review of simulation-based learning for developing teacher SEL. Education Sciences, 15(2), 129. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  18. Kennedy, E., Oliver, M., & Littlejohn, A. (2022). “You make yourself entirely available”: Emotional labour in a caring approach to online teaching. Italian Journal of Educational Technology, 30(1), 30–48. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  19. Lapidot-Lefler, N. (2022). Promoting the use of social-emotional learning in online teacher education. International Journal of Emotional Education, 14(2), 19–35. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  20. Lapidot-Lefler, N. (2025). Teacher responsiveness in inclusive education: A participatory study of pedagogical practice, well-being, and sustainability. Sustainability, 17(7), 2919. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  21. Lapidot-Lefler, N., & Barak, A. (2012). Effects of anonymity, invisibility, and lack of eye-contact on toxic online disinhibition. Computers in Human Behavior, 28(2), 434–443. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  22. Lapidot-Lefler, N., & Barak, A. (2015). The benign online disinhibition effect: Could situational factors induce self-disclosure and prosocial behaviors? Cyberpsychology: Journal of Psychosocial Research on Cyberspace, 9(2), 3. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  23. Lapidot-Lefler, N., & Israeli, R. (2024). Quality education through teacher-student relationships: Implementing social-emotional learning in teacher development. Quality Assurance in Education, 32(3), 401–415. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  24. Levin, O., & Segev, Y. (2023). The missing piece in the CASEL model: The impact of social–emotional learning on online literature teaching and learning. Education Sciences, 13(11), 1123. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  25. Mahoney, J. L., Weissberg, R. P., Greenberg, M. T., Dusenbury, L., Jagers, R. J., Niemi, K., Schlinger, M., Schlund, J., Shriver, T. P., VanAusdal, K., & Yoder, N. (2021). Systemic social and emotional learning: Promoting educational success for all preschool to high school students. American Psychologist, 76(7), 1128–1142. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  26. Manchanda, S., Ballard, A., Golshirazi, M., Morales, S., & Ramos, N. (2025). Advancing equity through transformative SEL: Insights from preservice secondary STEM teachers. Education Sciences, 15(12), 1583. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  27. Mehta, R., & Aguilera, E. (2020). A critical approach to humanizing pedagogies in online teaching and learning. The International Journal of Information and Learning Technology, 37(3), 109–120. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  28. Mukhemar, R., Affouneh, S., & Burgos, D. (2025). Technology-enabled social-emotional learning for university educators: A systematic review. Frontiers in Education, 10, 1655634. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  29. Neuber, K., & Göbel, K. (2022). The same, but different? Learning activities, perceived learning success, and social support during the practical term of teacher education in times of COVID-19. International Journal of Modern Education Studies, 6(1), 108–132. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  30. Noddings, N. (2005). The challenge to care in schools: An alternative approach to education (2nd ed.). Teachers College Press. [Google Scholar]
  31. Pacansky-Brock, M., Smedshammer, M., & Vincent-Layton, K. (2020). Humanizing online teaching to equitize higher education. Current Issues in Education, 21(2). Available online: https://cie.asu.edu/ojs/index.php/cieatasu/article/view/1905 (accessed on 27 September 2026).
  32. Peacock, S., Cowan, J., Irvine, L., & Williams, J. (2020). An exploration into the importance of a sense of belonging for online learners. The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 21(2), 18–35. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  33. Polleck, J. (2025). Neurodiverse youth book clubs for transformative and inclusive social emotional learning. Social and Emotional Learning: Research, Practice, and Policy, 6, 100163. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  34. Rapanta, C., Botturi, L., Goodyear, P., Guàrdia, L., & Koole, M. (2020). Online university teaching during and after the COVID-19 crisis: Refocusing teacher presence and learning activity. Postdigital Science and Education, 2(3), 923–945. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  35. Suler, J. (2004). The online disinhibition effect. CyberPsychology & Behavior, 7(3), 321–326. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  36. Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes (M. Cole, V. John-Steiner, S. Scribner, & E. Souberman, Eds.). Harvard University Press. [Google Scholar]
  37. Weissberg, R. P., Durlak, J. A., Domitrovich, C. E., & Gullotta, T. P. (2015). Social and emotional learning: Past, present, and future. In J. A. Durlak, C. E. Domitrovich, R. P. Weissberg, & T. P. Gullotta (Eds.), Handbook of social and emotional learning: Research and practice (pp. 3–19). Guilford Press. [Google Scholar]
  38. Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  39. Yang, C. (2021). Online teaching self-efficacy, social-emotional learning (SEL) competencies, and compassion fatigue among educators during the COVID-19 pandemic. School Psychology Review, 50(4), 505–518. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  40. Yazçayır, G. (2023). Teachers’ instructional design for e-learning of deaf and hard of hearing students. International Journal of Modern Education Studies, 7(2), 475–498. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.