Abstract
This paper investigates how Scottish rural schools engage with their broader educational landscape, particularly through collaborative practices and capacity-building efforts. It examines how these schools cultivate a culture of partnership, both among institutions and within their communities, to strengthen leadership and enhance teaching and learning. Guided by Place-Based Education (PBE) as its conceptual framework, the study emphasises equity challenges rooted in local contexts and situates rural education within Scotland’s historical, societal, and policy landscape. Drawing on qualitative case studies of five schools, data were collected through semi-structured interviews with principals and supported by documentary evidence and student attainment data from national assessments. The findings showcase school leaders’ efforts to enhance social and educational outcomes and build sustainable, equity-driven systems. The paper concludes with implications for policy and practice, addressing equitable access, workforce recruitment and retention, and the potential for schools to collaborate with local and regional stakeholders to strengthen rural education.
1. Introduction
The persistent poverty-related attainment gap in Scottish schools represents a multifaceted challenge that demands targeted system-level responses grounded in innovation and sustained improvement. Central to this is the National Improvement Framework (NIF), which places continuous improvement at its core through iterative, data-informed cycles of self-evaluation, planning, action, and review (Scottish Government, 2023b). The Scottish Attainment Challenge policy’s mission is to support this with local stretch aims and multiple indicators to track progress and surface unintended consequences. Schools and local authorities diagnose strengths and weaknesses against nationally agreed quality indicators which are externally evaluated by Education Scotland (Government’s executive agency for education), to support a shared ownership of improvement (see Scottish Government, 2023a).
While national policy frameworks are designed to be inclusive, they often mask the distinct realities faced by Scotland’s rural schools, which make up more than a third of all schools in the country (Scottish Government, 2025). These schools operate within unique socio-economic, geographic, and professional contexts that remain under-researched. Although more than a third of Scotland’s schools are classified as “rural schools” (as defined by the Scottish Government), less is known about the educational environment in which they operate and very little is known about the conditions in which rural school educators and leaders do their work. The difficulties faced by schools in rural and often isolated locations that serve the most deprived communities have been amplified by the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, teacher and leadership shortages, and financial and environmental instability.
The first dimension shaping this discussion is sustainability. Many rural communities particularly in the Scottish Highlands and Islands are remote, economically fragile, and often classified as “disadvantaged”. They typically experience lower socio-economic standards, reduced quality of life, and poorly resourced schools. Employment opportunities are often limited to tourism, agriculture, and craft industries, prompting an outmigration of young adults to urban centres in search of work (Lasselle & Johnson, 2021; Royal Society of Edinburgh, 2023; Scottish Government, 2013). These demographic and economic pressures raise critical questions about the long-term viability of both the communities and their schools, making the sustainability of rural education a pressing concern.
The second dimension concerns educational equity and the achievement gap. Poverty continues to marginalise rural and isolated communities, limiting educational infrastructure and opportunities for collaboration between schools. A growing body of evidence in Scotland shows that pupils in rural and remote schools often achieve less than their urban peers (McKinney et al., 2020; Borbely et al., 2023; Chapman & Ainscow, 2021; Muir, 2022; Robertson & McHardy, 2021). This pattern reflects broader national and international trends, where socio-economic disadvantage, whether in rural or low-income urban areas, is largely associated with lower educational attainment (Ovenden-Hope & Passy, 2019; Price Azano et al., 2021; Shucksmith et al., 2023; Sullivan et al., 2018). Despite targeted government interventions, the attainment gap remains stubbornly wide, highlighting the need for approaches that address the specific barriers faced by rural learners.
The third dimension is the knowledge gap surrounding rural education in Scotland. Recent systemic reforms have sought to address the attainment gap and strengthen professional practice, yet there is limited understanding of how rural educators navigate these reforms, restructure their schools, and foster professional learning in contexts where deep, sustained change is inherently complex. The lived realities of rural educators, often working in small schools with multi-stage composite classes, limited specialist provision, and geographically dispersed professional networks are significantly different from those in urban settings. This gap in understanding is particularly significant because rural schools can be understood as complex adaptive systems (Constantinides, 2025a, 2025b; Jacobson et al., 2019). Change in such environments is rarely linear; it is shaped by the interplay of multiple, interdependent factors, including community demographics, local economic conditions, staffing stability, infrastructure constraints, and cultural expectations. Educators in these settings must navigate competing priorities: delivering the national curriculum, meeting accountability demands, sustaining community engagement, and innovating within the constraints of limited resources and professional isolation. The complexity is compounded by the fact that rural schools often serve as central hubs for their communities, meaning that educational change is deeply intertwined with local identity, social cohesion, and community sustainability. Addressing this knowledge gap is therefore not simply a matter of transferring urban-focused policy solutions into rural settings. It requires a nuanced understanding of how (rural) educators make sense of reform agendas, adapt them to local realities, and generate context-specific knowledge that can be shared and scaled (Constantinides, 2023a). Without such insight, there is a risk that well-intentioned reforms will fail to achieve their intended impact in Scotland’s most geographically and socio-economically marginalised areas.
By situating the poverty-related attainment gap within the broader structure of the Scottish education system and exploring the lived realities of rural schooling, this paper highlights the pivotal role that rural school leaders play in advancing both social and educational outcomes. It examines how these leaders, often working within complex and resource-constrained environments, actively adapt national into locally relevant strategies tailored to their communities’ needs. Scotland provides a critical case for examining rural schooling not only because of its distinctive geography, demographic patterns, and policy emphasis on equity, but also because its education system diverges in important ways from those of the other UK nations. As a devolved system, Scotland operates its own curriculum, governance arrangements, and accountability structures, with the Curriculum for Excellence and a sustained focus on equity setting it apart from the market-driven reforms in England, the curriculum overhaul in Wales, and the selective post-primary system in Northern Ireland. These differences highlight the value of examining rural Scottish schools as a distinct and under-researched context within the wider UK landscape. By addressing this gap, the paper contributes to the scholarship on rural education by highlighting how collaborative practices and community partnerships can advance equity and sustainability in geographically isolated schools. To address this aim, the following research question guided the study: What structural and cultural conditions enable or inhibit sustainable improvement within and across rural Scottish schools?
2. Conceptual Framework
Placing rural schools within the Place-Based Education (PBE) framework offers a powerful conceptual lens for understanding their role in advancing equity, sustainability, and community engagement. PBE, as articulated by Gruenewald (2003), Smith (2002), and later synthesised by Yemini et al. (2023), is an umbrella term for educational approaches that are locally driven, community-based, and ecologically focused. Importantly, this paper frames rural schools not as “deficient” compared to urban ones, but as sites with unique assets and challenges, encouraging locally responsive approaches.
From a geographical view, rural schools in Scotland are situated within distinctive landscapes ranging from the Highland glens to island communities and coastal settlements where the natural environment can both be a learning resource and a determinant of community life. Outdoor learning, environmental stewardship, and local ecological knowledge can be integrated into the curriculum, aligning with Scotland’s Curriculum for Excellence emphasis on interdisciplinary, experiential learning (Education Scotland, 2023).
From a socio-cultural perspective, rural schools often act as community anchors, sustaining local traditions, language, and cultural practices. They are key sites for intergenerational knowledge transfer, echoing Bowers’ (2008) notion of the “cultural commons”. In small, close-knit communities, the school’s role may extend beyond education to fostering social cohesion and civic participation. This embeddedness positions rural schools not only as centres of learning but as cultural stewards and catalysts for community resilience (Constantinides, forthcoming).
Many rural Scottish communities face economic precarity, limited employment opportunities, and outmigration of young people (Borbely et al., 2023). PBE’s political-economic lens encourages schools to engage with these realities, for example, by linking learning to local industries (e.g., sustainable tourism, agriculture, renewable energy) and by fostering entrepreneurial skills that can contribute to community resilience. Notably, place attachment and identity formation are deeply influenced by rural settings (Ovenden-Hope & Passy, 2019; Yemini et al., 2023). For pupils, a strong sense of belonging can enhance engagement and wellbeing, but feelings of isolation or limited opportunity can also shape aspirations. PBE encourages educators to address both the strengths and constraints of place in supporting learners’ personal development (Gruenewald, 2003).
At the core of these defining characteristics lies a deliberate effort to (re-) establish strong, reciprocal relationships between schools and their surrounding communities. For example, Children’s Neighbourhoods Scotland adopted a place-based strategy to improve outcomes for children, young people, and their families by integrating educational, social, and community development initiatives (Chapman et al., 2019). This model emphasised long-term, collaborative engagement with local stakeholders, recognising that sustainable change requires aligning educational improvement with broader social and economic regeneration. Similarly, work in Dundee as discussed in Ainscow and Chapman (2025) demonstrated how place-based thinking can inform systemic reform. Here, the focus was on tackling entrenched inequities by aligning school improvement strategies with local socio-economic realities, while also identifying the structural and policy barriers that can impede such efforts. Comparable principles have been evident in England, albeit in different contexts (Ainscow et al., 2020). The London Challenge, a large-scale initiative aimed at promoting equity across urban areas, showed how targeted, place-sensitive interventions, combining leadership development, collaborative networks, and tailored support, could raise attainment and narrow gaps in some of the most disadvantaged areas. As Ainscow et al. (2020) note, understanding and addressing the barriers to equity in such initiatives requires a nuanced appreciation of the interplay between local context, system-level policy, and the agency of school leaders. Taken together, these examples illustrate that whether in rural Scotland, post-industrial Dundee, or metropolitan London, place-based approaches share a common thread: they seek to integrate educational improvement with the social, cultural, and economic fabric of the communities they serve. They also highlight that the success of such initiatives depends on recognising the complexity of place, fostering authentic partnerships, and enabling educators and learners to act as co-creators of change.
3. Materials and Methods
The data used in this paper were generated from a broader project to explore how rural educators, attend to and manage their environments and relationships to create and sustain support for pupils’ learning and achievement outcomes in their local communities. A case study approach was employed to generate rich, detailed narratives and accessible illustrations of the challenges and successes encountered by rural schools in implementing local and collaborative initiatives. These examples highlight efforts to foster and maintain mutual learning and sustained support over time. Collectively, they form a repository of locally responsive practices and pinpoint areas where further improvement and targeted support for (rural) school development are required. The researcher’s background includes work on school improvement initiatives and partnerships with local authorities, which shapes their interest in equity and sustainability in geographically isolated schools. These experiences provide practical insight into policy processes and collaborative practices.
Taking into account their geographical locations, phase, size, classification (e.g., accessible, remote, very remote) and socio-economic contexts, a purposive sample of five schools (three primary, two secondary) was selected as case study sites. In designing the study, input from key stakeholders, including rural school leaders, was sought from Scottish local authorities with the highest concentration of schools in rural settings. The selection allowed for maximum understanding of the individual cases seeking variation in school location, performance, and student composition.
Data were generated during site visits and through other communication mediums such as zoom videoconferencing/telephone interview. More specifically, semi-structured interviews were conducted with all principals and several senior and middle school leaders. Interviews lasted between 60 and 90 min which were recorded and transcribed. Documentary evidence comprised school improvement plans and student attainment data from national assessments. Additionally, field notes were gathered during site visits to capture real-time observations of relationships, roles, responsibilities, and unfolding events within the school context.
The analysis followed an iterative cycle, incorporating both deductive and inductive coding (Miles & Huberman, 1994). This analysis integrated the identification and interpretation of similarities and differences, while also generating new insights into the contextual dynamics, leadership practices, and challenges shaping rural school improvement efforts. Practically, this meant that codes and analytic memos were not only applied to actions and practices (e.g., leadership strategies, partnership activities) but were also explicitly linked to place-specific features such as geographic isolation, patterns of population change, and community histories. During coding, a set of place-oriented nodes was created (i.e., access and distance, community identity and belonging, financial and human resources, institutional partnerships) and were used to trace how leadership decisions and improvement initiatives were enabled or constrained by place. Although the findings are based on self-reported accounts from senior leaders, this limitation is acknowledged and claims are carefully bounded. Triangulation across interviews, documents, and field notes was used to validate interpretations about community identity and socio-economic context, and participant feedback was sought to check whether place-centred readings resonated with local needs. These procedures helped ensure that the PBE framework did not merely provide a descriptive lens but actively shaped interpretation, revealing how location and local socio-economic structures mediate both the possibilities and limits of rural school improvement.
4. Findings
The following findings are informed by the PBE framework’s multidimensional lens, highlighting how rural education is shaped by the interconnected dynamics of location, community identity, and economic structures. They cluster into three themes: cultivating agency and sustainability through community-anchored capacity, bridging place and policy via adaptive strategies, and advancing professional learning and pedagogical innovation rooted in local knowledge.
4.1. Cultivating Agency and Sustainability
School leaders in the study appeared to foster a sense of empowerment, identity, and responsibility through meaningful engagement with their local environment and community. They encouraged staff and pupils to see themselves not just as passive recipients of knowledge, but as active contributors to the well-being and future of their place.
Community is everything. If we look at our young people who are struggling in society… they are looking for community. These young people are human beings, are hardwired to feel like they belong, and as smaller, bigger group as they want. But they are there. We are seeking out closeness and connectivity.(Primary Principal)
…I think the idea that I first had about inclusion and about a sense of place and culture really was a driver about me wanting to come back to small and rural schools because certainly there was a lot of reflection on how similar that was to my own experience as a pupil in one multi composite classroom.(Primary Principal)
In the west coast, both secondary principals embedded the Gaelic language through e-Sgoil (national e-learning service), oral histories, and traditional crafts into the curriculum. This helped reinforce pupils’ cultural identities and strengthened intergenerational ties.
We worked with outdoor practitioners from the Scottish Gaelic Language community who do a lot on Gaelic and a lot of map and place names. We worked with Kilmartin Museum as well.(Secondary Principal)
Strong community ties, smaller class sizes, and sustained teacher commitment appeared to underpin place-based agency, but these strengths proved fragile, contingent on staffing stability, leadership, and volunteer capacity, making them difficult to scale or sustain without broader systemic support.
It’s the relationships between the school as the centre of the community and yourself as a member of staff also for the school, but also for the community as a whole.(Primary Principal)
We’ve got whole community buy-in to what we do and what we believe as well, which we do generally speaking. That’s parents, children, staff etc. Moving forward, we’ve got to promote, and it is easy for me after 20 years in the role, opportunities and the importance and time and support networks to see how important it is to understand the things that have worked well in the school.(Secondary Principal)
The primary principal of an island community school highlighted the strong community cohesion combined with the smaller learning environment and committed local staff.
…I feel really passionate about the community that I live in. And the children here the school has gone through a period of instability for quite a long time. They don’t get equity of experience because it’s harder to get stuff here because we’re an island. Even though I can see the mainland, it’s not far away. It’s much harder for those children to get stuff here. And in order to kind of give your best, you really need to live here. Because whenever the weather’s bad, the ferry goes off. I’m invested in this community, and I want what’s best for these people.
4.2. Bridging Place and Policy
All principals negotiated local strengths and systemic constraints, showing that sustainable improvement in rural settings is shaped by context rather than determined by geography.
We are much more a family unit in a small school, working together to improve. That is what underpins this school is that we work together no matter who you are, we will help you, your background doesn’t matter. No, we are here to support everyone.(Primary Principal)
One of the secondary schools displayed a marked contrast within its Local Authority as one of the few schools consistently achieving high outcomes while others were performing poorly, showing that rurality does not deterministically predict success. This suggests that size or location alone does not guarantee positive results.
One of my favourite words is compromise. Communities can only live and thrive on compromise. If we do not compromise in school, the impact on our young people, their academic achievements, their personal development skills, is very limited. The community is a small, very spread-out community. Different villages that are all seeing the schools here.(Secondary Principal)
Participating leaders highlighted priorities such as investing in digital infrastructure, negotiating specialist teaching time across school networks, while also acknowledging persistent structural barriers, including limited resources and funding models, which complicate equitable provision.
Digital learning is not just about providing the tech, it’s about teaching them to use the tech and teaching them to learn with the tech. It’s one of their tools and how to use that tool effectively, how to map it to their brain almost and how they work it so. And that’s where rural schools and it comes into the rural school leadership aspect because if we are not going to get more staff and if pupils in the rural communities are going to achieve, then it needs to be equitable. They need to have the skills to learn using resources they are given, so if they (Local Authority) are not going to give us human resources, they can’t just fling technology at us.(Secondary Principal)
In addition, standard measures of deprivation (e.g., Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD)) appeared to obscure the unique dimensions of rural poverty, leading to skewed resource allocation and inadequate policy responses.
Rural poverty is very much underreported issue. The amount of money that we’re able to spend in a rural school and the costs involved of getting anybody to come here or the cost of buying anything that has to be delivered here, you know there’s different layers of costs. They’re all cost pressures that prevent schools in rural areas being able to access with any degree of equity in comparison to a Glasgow or an Edinburgh school, for example. Then there’s the staff and resource costs. So, there is poverty of opportunity.(Secondary Principal)
…To me, the needs of this community are really obvious, that food poverty is an issue here. So, the things I’ve done and I’m trying to tackle are the needs of the island for the benefit of the families. I’ve set up a food bank and I’ve got a breakfast club up and going. I’ve done stuff that the island needs. So when the job came up, I was a bit like, I don’t want someone else coming in with these ideas of, oh, let’s do this. I want someone who wants to come in and actually support this community. And I knew I could do that.(Primary Principal)
4.3. Professional Learning and Pedagogical Innovation
Locally anchored professional learning and teacher inquiry reduced professional isolation and produced contextually relevant pedagogical innovations that translated into improved classroom practice. Findings suggest that principals were constantly working to provide protected time and strategic incentives for teachers to engage in inquiry projects focused on locally relevant problems of practice (e.g., multigrade pedagogy, digital communities of practice). These projects appeared to deepen pedagogical understanding while generating tangible resources and artefacts that benefited the wider school community.
…One of my staff said to me she’s just actually finished one qualification to train as a childcare and education worker, and she said, I’m really interested in learning sign language because we’ve got a non-verbal child coming into nursery. And I said that’s fantastic if you’re willing to lead that and we can find those resources to support you doing that. And I think in supporting people to take forward things that that benefits the school, there’s this absolute that’s a win–win, but it’s about making sure that she has the time to do that and is able to have that time out of class.(Primary Principal)
On the other hand, distances between schools and increasing travel costs constrained teachers’ as well as leaders’ access to continued professional development opportunities. Small school staffing patterns, especially in the case of two of the primary schools in the study, required teachers and their principal to adopt multiple roles, increasing workload and limiting time for sustained inquiry.
One of the challenges of small schools is that you have to be everybody. When I worked in big schools, you might have three clerical assistants. And there is also a deputy principal and four principal teachers. And I am all of those people.(Primary Principal)
A lot of our professional development is done on the run. I’m due to my professional review coming up shortly and that’s one of the things I’ve already written down that I’m going to be saying. This is finding time. I said I’ve got colleagues in big schools that might be doing their principal qualification, but they’re in a team of four or five deputy principals.(Secondary Principal)
We can’t really do that because of, you know, the workload for our mental management team as well. They’re, they’re all faculty heads too, so.
They’re not just their own subjects, they’re managing multiple staff and managing multiple resource.(Secondary Principal)
This was exacerbated by the wider recruitment and retention issues that exist in the system, making it difficult to sustain place-based initiatives, secure specialist staff, and protect the time needed for ongoing teacher inquiry and professional development. Despite targeted government incentives, including financial support and accommodation packages, school leaders reported persistent difficulties in attracting and training new teachers. This issue was especially noticeable in the two secondary schools, where retaining and recruiting subject specialists proved exceptionally difficult.
With the human resource and my worry is that our part time staff are going to walk and find jobs where they will be full time and yes, their workload will be high, but it won’t be as high as they’re doing here because all our staff here manage single teachers, departments within faculties, they manage S1 to S6, all the courses, every course, some of them from S1 all the way up to advanced high.(Secondary Principal)
We have a real struggle with our staffing and here I’ve got 3 examples. One is an art teacher. We can only afford her 2 1/2 days a week. Our music teacher, we can only afford her just over 0.8 in a week. And an English teacher. So she’s actually got 4 GTCS registrations, Gaelic learners, Gaelic Medium, English and history. So our key subject area, along with maths.(Secondary Principal)
5. Discussion
This paper offers empirical insights to rural education in Scotland and demonstrates the complexities and challenges of geographic remoteness with wider aspects of school improvement and professional learning opportunities for rural educators. By aligning sustainability, equity, and the knowledge gap with the socio-cultural and political-economic dimensions of PBE, this study contributes to rural leadership research by reframing rural schools as critical sites of innovation rather than peripheral components of the national system. This approach also positions rural school leaders as central agents in building a sustainable, equity-oriented, and contextually responsive education system. Through this lens, the study deepens our understanding of how leadership at the local level can drive systemic change and foster inclusive educational improvement across diverse rural contexts.
Drawing on the findings presented in this paper, it becomes evident that rural school leaders play a pivotal and proactive role in shaping both social and educational outcomes within their communities. Operating in complex, often resource-constrained environments, these leaders demonstrate a nuanced capacity to interpret national policy frameworks and adapt them to the specific needs and aspirations of their local contexts. The evidence shows that their efforts extend beyond mere implementation of national directives; instead, they engage in strategic decision-making, foster collaborative relationships, and mobilise community resources to enhance equity and sustainability in schooling. Their leadership is instrumental in cultivating inclusive practices, strengthening professional development, and driving locally grounded innovation, thereby contributing meaningfully to the development of a more responsive and equity-oriented education system across rural Scotland. This is in line with the wider literature on rural educational leadership, highlighting the unique challenges and adaptive strategies leaders employ to foster equity and innovation in geographically dispersed communities (Fargas-Malet & Bagley, 2021; Grimm et al., 2025).
Against this backdrop of locally driven innovation, findings suggest that the processes of restructuring schools and fostering professional learning in rural areas are also influenced by unique organisational dynamics deeply embedded in the structural conditions of rural education. Workforce challenges and professional development opportunities, often shaped by travel distances, time constraints, and the scarcity of substitute staff, are well-documented in rural education research (Rhinesmith et al., 2023). Findings also indicate that collaboration, both within and between schools, is a critical yet complex component of rural educational improvement. While creative strategies such as digital networking and cross-authority partnerships offer promising avenues for professional learning and shared practice, their effectiveness depends on reliable infrastructure and sustained investment (Constantinides, 2025a; Dick & Burns, 2023; Zuckerman, 2023).
Reinforcing the importance of place, findings also demonstrate that local strengths, and community-based educational practices create learning that is both contextually relevant and socially embedded. Within this framing, place-based education embodies a form of active citizenship or civic modality, in which pupils and staff are not only encouraged to recognise and critically examine issues affecting their localities, but are also empowered to take informed, constructive action in response (Smith & Sobel, 2010; Yemini et al., 2023). Building on this form of place-based meaning-making, some scholars call for place-conscious leadership, an approach in which leaders draw on the cultural heritage, environmental context, and community relationships to inform strategic decisions and drive school improvement (Gruenewald, 2003; Sutherland et al., 2023). Although the need for a profound understanding of the place and community is vital, this connectedness also calls for an ecological approach to leadership (Toh et al., 2014; Constantinides, 2023b, 2025b). Such an approach situates the entire school as a complex adaptive system, where dynamic, interdependent relationships among personal motivations, interpersonal connections, organisational routines, community networks, and broader societal forces collectively shape leadership practice (Kershner & McQuillan, 2016). By attending to these multiple layers of interaction, ecological, place-conscious leaders can craft holistic strategies that mobilise local resources, strengthen professional learning, and drive sustainable, equity-oriented innovation in rural schooling.
6. Concluding Remarks
Empirical evidence from this paper serves policymakers, rural educators, and community members interested in acknowledging the effective features of rural education and leadership that could potentially play a key role in regenerating rural communities. Rural schools should be recognised as dynamic and multifaceted systems, shaped by a set of interdependent factors including geographic location, resource availability, socio-economic context, and access to professional networks. As demonstrated through the findings of the study, their complexity emerges not only from the logistical challenges of delivering education across dispersed and often remote communities, but also in the intricate interplay between local culture, staffing capacity, infrastructure, and policy expectations. To foster meaningful and sustained improvement, these schools require strategic restructuring that goes beyond surface-level interventions. This involves cultivating environments that actively support professional learning, facilitate the generation and exchange of contextually relevant knowledge, and promote collaborative practice across schools and regions. In such settings, innovation is often hindered by isolation and resource scarcity, making it essential to design support systems that are adaptive, inclusive, and responsive to the unique conditions of rural education.
Consistent with the findings, recognising that rural education draws its strength from deep community ties and locally relevant curricula provides a solid foundation for future innovation. By intentionally aligning professional development, policy frameworks, and resource strategies with these place-based features, educators and leaders can turn systemic barriers such as urban-centred policy and CPD models into opportunities for context-driven innovation and long-term community resilience. These insights reframe demographic fragility as a call for creative recruitment, retention, and leadership practices that celebrate, rather than sideline, rural distinctiveness, directly responding to the policy tensions highlighted in the discussion.
Equally, redesigning evaluation systems beyond aggregate indicators such as the Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) quintiles and pass-rate rankings into nuanced, context-sensitive measures will empower more precise policy and investment decisions. When metrics reflect variations in cohort composition and resource distribution, stakeholders can target support where it matters most; advancing place-based reforms that grow with purpose and endure over time. These shifts position rural schools as dynamic hubs of locally rooted but globally aware practice, capable of driving equitable outcomes and long-term community growth.
Funding
This research received no external funding.
Institutional Review Board Statement
The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki, and approved by the University of Glasgow College of Social Sciences Ethics Committee in June 2023 (protocol code 400220250).
Informed Consent Statement
Informed consent was obtained from all participants involved in the study.
Data Availability Statement
Data is unavailable due to ethical restrictions.
Conflicts of Interest
The author declares no conflicts of interest.
References
- Ainscow, M., & Chapman, C. (2025). Developing equitable education systems: Propositions and barriers. Journal of Educational Change, 26(3), 373–396. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ainscow, M., Chapman, C., & Hadfield, M. (2020). Changing education systems: A research-based approach. Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Borbely, D., Gehrsitz, M., McIntyre, S., Rossi, G., & Roy, G. (2023). Rurality, socio-economic disadvantage and educational mobility: A Scottish case study. British Educational Research Journal, 50(1), 162–182. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Bowers, C. (2008). Why a critical pedagogy of place is an oxymoron. Environmental Education Research, 14(3), 325–335. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Chapman, C., & Ainscow, M. (Eds.). (2021). Educational equity: Pathways to success (1st ed.). Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Chapman, C., Drever, A., McBride, M., Orr, C., & Weakley, S. (2019). Leading place-based interventions to improve outcomes in low socio-economic settings. In T. Townsend (Ed.), Instructional leadership and leadership for learning in schools. Palgrave Macmillan. [Google Scholar]
- Constantinides, M. (2023a). Making sense of complex relationships in the workplace: Principals in action. Cambridge Journal of Education, 53(5), 587–603. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Constantinides, M. (2023b). Systemically oriented leadership: Leading multi-school organisations in England. Journal of Educational Change, 24(3), 525–547. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Constantinides, M. (2025a). Leadership at the boundaries of schools: Navigating the complexities of collaboration. Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 1–16. [Google Scholar]
- Constantinides, M. (2025b). Successful school leadership in Scotland: A journey to sustainable improvement. Journal of Educational Administration. Advance online publication. [Google Scholar]
- Constantinides, M. (forthcoming). School leadership forged in crisis: Lessons from Scotland. In A. Kafa, P. Virella, & M. Striepe (Eds.), Bloomsbury handbook of crisis leadership and management. Bloomsbury Publishing. [Google Scholar]
- Dick, S., & Burns, H. (2023). Professional learning and an emergent community of practice on the Scottish islands as viewed through Biesta’s educational domains. PRACTICE, 6(1), 3–16. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Education Scotland. (2023). Interdisciplinary learning: Ambitious learning for an increasingly complex world. Education Scotland. [Google Scholar]
- Fargas-Malet, M., & Bagley, C. (2021). Is small beautiful? A scoping review of 21st-century research on small rural schools in Europe. European Educational Research Journal, 21(5), 822–844. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Grimm, F., Ärlestig, H., & Johansson, O. (2025). Working together towards school success in a rural school context: “It works well but we are not satisfied”. Journal of Educational Administration. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Gruenewald, D. A. (2003). Foundations of place: A multidisciplinary framework for place-conscious education. American Educational Research Journal, 40(3), 619–654. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Jacobson, M. J., Levin, J. A., & Kapur, M. (2019). Education as a complex system: Conceptual and methodological implications. Educational Researcher, 48(2), 112–119. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Kershner, B., & McQuillan, P. (2016). Complex adaptive schools: Educational leadership and school change. Journal of Educational Administration, 54(4), 373–393. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Lasselle, L., & Johnson, M. (2021). Levelling the playing field between rural schools and urban schools in a HE context: A Scottish case study. British Educational Research Journal, 47(2), 450–468. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- McKinney, S. J., Hall, S., & Lowden, K. (2020). Poverty and education in Scotland: Reality and response. In I. Thompson, & G. Ivinson (Eds.), Poverty in education across the UK: A comparative analysis of policy and place (pp. 65–88). Policy Press. [Google Scholar]
- Miles, M. B., & Huberman, A. M. (1994). Qualitative data analysis: An expanded sourcebook (2nd ed.). Sage Publications. [Google Scholar]
- Muir, K. (2022). Putting learners at the centre: Towards a future vision for Scottish education. Scottish Government. Available online: https://www.gov.scot/publications/putting-learners-centre-towards-future-vision-scottish-education/ (accessed on 22 September 2025).
- Ovenden-Hope, T., & Passy, R. (2019). Educational isolation: A challenge for schools in England. Plymouth Marjon University and University of Plymouth. [Google Scholar]
- Price Azano, A., Eppley, K., & Biddle, C. (Eds.). (2021). The Bloomsbury handbook of rural education in the United States. Bloomsbury Academic. [Google Scholar]
- Rhinesmith, E., Anglum, J. C., Park, A., & Burrola, A. (2023). Recruiting and retaining teachers in rural schools: A systematic review of the literature. Peabody Journal of Education, 98(4), 347–363. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Robertson, L., & McHardy, F. (2021). The poverty-related attainment gap: A review of the evidence. The Poverty Alliance. [Google Scholar]
- Royal Society of Edinburgh. (2023). The cost of living: Impact on rural communities in Scotland (Advice Paper AP23-01). Available online: https://rse.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/RSE-AP-The-cost-of-living-impact-on-rural-communities-in-Scotland-2023.pdf (accessed on 1 October 2025).
- Scottish Government. (2013). Commission on the delivery of rural education: Report. Chapter 7: Resources for rural education. Scottish Government. Available online: https://www.gov.scot/publications/commission-delivery-rural-education-report/pages/10/ (accessed on 1 October 2025).
- Scottish Government. (2023a). Education: National improvement framework and improvement plan 2024. Scottish Government. Available online: https://www.gov.scot/publications/education-national-improvement-framework-improvement-plan-2024/pages/8/ (accessed on 2 October 2025).
- Scottish Government. (2023b). National improvement framework (NIF) and improvement plan 2023: Summary. Scottish Government. Available online: https://www.gov.scot/publications/2023-national-improvement-framework-nif-improvement-plan-summary-document (accessed on 2 October 2025).
- Scottish Government. (2025). Rural schools in Scotland: Definition. Scottish Government. Available online: https://www.gov.scot/publications/rural-schools-in-scotland-definition/ (accessed on 1 October 2025).
- Shucksmith, M., Glass, J., Chapman, P., & Atterton, J. (2023). Rural poverty today: Experiences of social exclusion in rural Britain. Policy Press. [Google Scholar]
- Smith, G. A. (2002). Place-based education: Learning to be where we are. Phi Delta Kappan, 83(8), 584–594. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Smith, G. A., & Sobel, D. (2010). Place- and community-based education in schools (1st ed.). Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Sullivan, K., McConney, A., & Perry, L. B. (2018). A comparison of rural educational disadvantage in Australia, Canada, and New Zealand using OECD’s PISA. SAGE Open, 8(4), 1–12. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Sutherland, D. H., McHenry-Sorber, E., & Willingham, J. N. (2023). Leading rural districts: Research synthesis of rural educational leaders. Peabody Journal of Education, 98(4), 414–429. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Toh, Y., Jamaludin, A., Hung, D., Chua, P. M. H., & Goh, K. C. (2014). Ecological leadership: Going beyond system leadership for diffusing school-based innovations in the crucible of change for 21st century learning. The Asia-Pacific Education Researcher, 23(4), 835–850. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Yemini, M., Engel, L., & Ben Simon, A. (2023). Place-based education—A systematic review of literature. Educational Review, 77(2), 640–660. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Zuckerman, S. J. (2023). The ecology of rural cross-sector school-community partnerships: A literature review. Peabody Journal of Education, 98(4), 430–447. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the author. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.