Tang Dynasty Daoist Diversity: Immortal Daoism as an Offshoot in Li Bai’s Era
Abstract
1. Introduction
2. Li Bai’s Daoist Practices Related to Immortal Daoism
- Secularization of the transcendents: They gradually shifted from immortal realm to the human world, with their appearances transforming from non-human forms into ordinary human features.
- Transformation of transcendent methods: Originally, the transcendents were born as such, while mortal people rely on immortality elixirs granted by those inherently mysterious beings to achieving immortality. Later, Immortal Daoism offered various practical techniques, known as Fangshu, that enabled mortals to pursue immortality.
2.1. Famous Mountains: Li Bai’s Preference for Daoist Sacred Sites
1 The land of Shu abounds in sacred peaks, 蜀國多仙山, 2 Yet Emei stands unrivaled. 峨眉邈難匹。 (Climbing Mount Emei, Bai Li 2015, p. 17)
2.2. Reclusion: Li Bai’s Politically Detached Religious Activities
1 Ask me why I reside on Green Mountain? 問余何意棲碧山? 2 I smiled and offered no response; I have attained inner peace. 笑而不答心自閑。 3 Peach blossoms drift away with the flowing stream, 桃花流水窅然去, 4 This is a realm beyond that of mortal men. 别有天地非人間。 (A Dialogue in the Mountains 山中問答,12 Bai Li 2015, p. 83)
1 I shut myself in the southern tower to read Daoist books; 我閉南樓看道書, 2 The quiet curtains and tranquil atmosphere resemble a transcendent realm. 幽簾清寂若仙居。 (Reply to Dou Gongheng from the Southern Tower in Shanfu, Early Autumn 早秋單父南樓酬竇公衡, Bai Li 2015, p. 379)
1 The District Defender is a five-hued transcendent figure. 五色神仙尉, 2 He burns incense and chants Daoist scriptures. 焚香讀道經。 (To the Magistrate of Jiangyou 贈江油尉, Bai Li 2015, p. 8)
1 If my political fate were unfavorable, 時命若不會, 2 I shall return to the art of compounding the elixir. 歸應鍊丹砂。 (Early Autumn, Presented to Pei Zhongkan, the Seventeenth of His Siblings 早秋贈裴十七仲堪, Bai Li 2015, p. 353)
1 I shall dedicate myself to the practice of compounding the elixir; 吾將營丹砂, 2 And permanently sever ties with the mortal world. 永與世人别。 (Ancient Style Poems, No. 5, Bai Li 2015, p. 619)
1 A paragon among courtiers, Lord Li. 李侯金閨彦, 2 Cast off his official robes to seek secluded transcendence. 脱身事幽討。 3 We undertook travels in Liang and Song, 亦有梁宋遊, 4 Expecting to gather the yao plant. 方期拾瑶草。 (To Li Bai 贈李白, Du 1979, p. 33)
1 My family lives on Purple Cloud Mountain, 家本紫雲山, 2 Where the Daoist tradition remains uncorrupted. 道風未淪落。 (Writing on the Walls of the Mountain Retreat of Yuan Danqiu, the Recluse of Song Mountain 題嵩山逸人元丹丘山居, Bai Li 2015, p. 892)
1 I erase my traces to escape worldly chaos, 滅跡遺紛囂, 2 Ultimately returning to mountain valleys. 終言本峰壑。 3 I take pride in forest streams, 自矜林湍好, 4 And envy not the pleasures of the court and city. 不羨市朝樂。 (Writing on the Walls of the Mountain Retreat of Yuan Danqiu, the Recluse of Song Mountain, Bai Li 2015, p. 893)
2.3. Transcendent: The “Self” in Li Bai’s Spiritual World
In the past, I met Sima Ziwei from Tiantai in Jiangling, who said I had the immortal’s bones and could travel with him to the farthest reaches of the ultimate realm.15
余昔於江陵,見天台司馬子微,謂余有仙風道骨,可與神遊八極之表。(Ode to the Roc 大鵬賦, Bai Li 2015, p. 1736)
At the Supreme Purple Palace in Chang’an, Mr. He, the Adviser to the Heir Apparent, saw me once and called me an “ostracized transcendent,” then took off his golden turtle to exchange for wine to celebrate.
太子賓客賀公於長安紫極宫一見余,呼余爲謫仙人,因解金龜换酒爲樂。(Preface to “Two Poems Recalling Mr. He While Drinking” 對酒憶賀監二首序, Bai Li 2015, p. 775)
1 The world knows not of Dongfang Shuo, 世人不識東方朔, 2 A great recluse behind Jinma Gates, he was a transcendent exiled from heaven. 大隱金門是謫仙。 (Jade Pot Chant 玉壺吟, Bai Li 2015, p. 526)
1 The Green Lotus Recluse, an ostracized transcendent; 青蓮居士謫仙人, 2 Thirty years I hid my name in wine shops. 酒肆藏名三十春。 (Reply to Assistant Jiaye of Huzhou Asking What Man I Am 答湖州迦葉司馬問白是何人, Bai Li 2015, p. 769)
1 Where the sea is rigid with frequent gales, 海寒多天風, 2 White waves, rolling like mountains, topple the Penglai and Fanghu isle. 白波連山倒蓬壺。 (Ancient Ballad of ‘What One Longs For’ 古有所思, Bai Li 2015, p. 1594)
1 I began to explore the affairs of Penglai, 始探蓬壺事, 2 Then suddenly felt the world lighten. 旋覺天地輕。 (Autumn Evening Thoughts 秋夕書懷, Bai Li 2015, p. 1454)
A very large part of our writing is a story of its roots in a place: a landscape, region, village, city, nation or continent.(Bradbury 2001, p. 8)
It looks at many of the revealed and hidden maps of literature, past and present, real and imagined.(Bradbury 2001, p. 8)
1 Thus, I set out from Tianchi to sail to Penglai and Yingzhou, 因出天池泛蓬瀛, 2 The ships’ hulls crowd together, startling the waves. 樓船蹙沓波浪驚。 (Song of Spring 春日行, Bai Li 2015, p. 438)
1 I lift my body to rest in Penglai, 舉身憩蓬壺, 2 Wash my feet in the vast sea. 濯足弄滄海。 (Reply to Director Cui, the Fifth of His Siblings 酬崔五郎中, Bai Li 2015, p. 233)
Everyone says she entered the East China Sea and climbed Penglai, but no one can guess where she went.
世或傳其入東海,登蓬萊,竟莫能測其往也。(the Preface to “To Master Jiao of Song Mountain” 贈嵩山焦鍊師序, Bai Li 2015, p. 187)
1 Among them is a guest from Penglai Sea, 中有蓬海客, 2 Who seems to be the goddess Ma Gu. 宛疑麻姑仙。 (To Master Jiao of Song Mountain 贈嵩山焦鍊師, Bai Li 2015, p. 187)
1 I muse that the transcendent beings dwell in the eastern corner of the blue sea, 我思仙人乃在碧海之東隅, … …… 2 I wish to dispatch a letter to inquire after Ma Gu. 願寄一書謝麻姑。 (Ancient Ballad of ‘What One Longs For’, Bai Li 2015, p. 1594)
1 Await the call that bids me leave the mortal veil, 待號辭人間, 2 Hand in hand with thee, to seek the transcendent Chisongzi. 携手訪松子。 (To Hermit Wu of Moon-Playing Stream 寄弄月溪吴山人, Bai Li 2015, p. 90)
1 I will follow Chisongzi, 將隨赤松去, 2 Sitting in Penglai and Yingzhou to play chess. 對博坐蓬瀛。 (Ancient Style Poems, No. 7, Variant 古風·其七, 别本, Bai Li 2015, p. 398)
1 You possess the essence of the immortal in your very bones, 自是君身有仙骨, 2 How can ordinary mortals comprehend its true nature. 世人那得知其故。 (On Seeing Kong Chaofu Off to the Jiangdong After Resigning Office, with a Note to Li Bai 送孔巢父謝病歸游江東兼呈李白, Du 1979, p. 55)
1 I hear you pursue the Dao upon the vast ocean, 又聞訪道滄海上, 2 And often converse with Ding Lingwei and Prince Qiao. 丁令王喬時往還。 (Ren Hua, “Miscellaneous Verse to Li Bai” 雜言寄李白, Bai Li 1977, p. 1492)
3. “Chengxian” and “Dedao”: Li Bai’s Distance from Medieval Daoism
1 At dawn I rode a white deer, 清曉騎白鹿, 2 Straight to the Heaven Gate Mountain. 直上天門山。 3 Upon the mountain I met a feathered transcendent, 山際逢羽人, 4 With square pupils and a radiant face. 方瞳好容顔。 (Six Poems on Touring Mount Tai, No. 2, Bai Li 2015, p. 390)
1 The deity has an ancient appearance, 神人多古貌, 2 His ears hang down to his shoulders. 雙耳下垂肩。 3 Emperor Wu of Han met him in Song Mountain, 嵩岳逢漢武, 4 Suspecting he was the God of Jiuyi. 疑是九疑仙。 5 “I came to harvest calamus, 我來採菖蒲, 6 Eating it can prolong life.” 服食可延年。 7 After speaking, he suddenly disappeared, 言終忽不見, 8 His shadow vanishing into clouds and mist. 滅影入雲烟。 9 The emperor did not understand, 喻帝竟莫悟, 10 Finally heading to Maoling Field. 終歸茂陵田。 (The Calamus Harvester in Song Mountain, Bai Li 2015, p. 190)
His words are profound and comprehensive, his literary talent radiant. Every time he completes a work, it is widely copied by the public. Even Li Bai’s unconstrained style and Du Fu’s magnificent style—can anyone combine them except Wu Yun?
詞理宏通,文彩煥發,每製一篇,人皆傳寫。雖李白之放蕩,杜甫之壯麗,能兼之者,其唯筠乎!(X. Liu 1975, p. 5130)
I have been unable to trace the outlines of a master plan that might reveal the sense of the entire set… but we may imagine that a more complete comprehension of the sequence has been prevented by the shuffling of the stanzas in transmission, so as to obscure or obliterate their interconnections.(Schafer 1981–1983, p. 344)
1 The realm of high realized ones is truly remote and rarefied, 高真誠寥邈, 2 Being matched with the Dao, I shall not be left outside of it. 道合不我遺。 (Saunters in Sylphdom, No. 8; Schafer 1981–1983, p. 320; DZ 1051, 23, p. 665c)
1 Looking back to the primordial beginning, 返視太初先, 2 I merge with the Dao in perfect unity. 與道冥至一。 3 The void condenses true essence, 空洞凝真精, 4 Becoming substance within emptiness. 乃爲虚中實。 5 Transformation follows inherent laws, 變通有常性, 6 Union and dispersion lack fixed form. 合散無定質。 7 I move swifter than lightning without traveling, 不行迅飛電, 8 Concealing my radiance beneath the bright sun. 隱曜光白日。 9 In profound stillness, I forget profundity itself; 玄棲忘玄深, 10 Without clinging to gain, I fear no loss. 無得固無失。 (Saunters in Sylphdom, No. 24; DZ 1051, 23, p. 666b)
4. Li Bai and the Diversity of Daoism
1 In the morning, she beats the heavenly drum, 清晨鳴天鼓, 2 Biao and Xu, the two dragons soar. 飆歘騰雙龍。 (Poem of the Immortal Princess Yuzhen 玉真仙人詞, Bai Li 2015, p. 107)
Li Po should picture the imperial votaress ascending subsequently to the sky behind a brace of heaven-destined dragons.(Kroll 1986, p. 104)
Always at cockcrow, actualize green qi from the east emanating from the sun… Kiss the teeth nine times and swallow saliva nine times… At dusk, sit calmly, close your eyes, and actualize two streams of white qi from the moon entering the soles of your feet. After a prolonged period, each sole will give rise to a white dragon—one on the left and one on the right. The left dragon is named Biaojing, and the right dragon Xuting. Both dragons exhale white smoke into my nostrils.
常以鷄鳴時,存東方青氣從日中來,……叩齒九通,咽液九過,……晡時平坐,臨目存月中有兩白氣,俓來入兩足底蹠心中,良久,足底各化生兩白龍,在我之左右也。左龍名曰飈精,右龍名曰歘亭,二龍並吐白煙,入我鼻兩孔中。(DZ 405, 6, p. 546b–c)
He encountered Zhenren and received the technique called “Chidan Yangjing Shijing Shuimu.” Thus, he constantly inhales the Flying Root and swallows the Solar Soul, practicing these in secrecy.
遇諸真人,受赤丹陽精石景水母,故常吸飛根,吞日魂,密而修之.(Bai Li 2015, p. 1805)
Shangqing Jinque Lingshu Ziwen teaches the method of ingesting the Flying Root and swallowing solar essence. This method was originally transmitted by the Great Supreme Heaven Emperor and is also known as the “The Scripture of ‘Chidan Yangjing Shijing Shuimu’” … Within the flowing light of the sun, there exists purple qi as large as a pupil, layered dozens of times and radiant amid five-colored lights. This is precisely why the method has been termed the “Flying Root Water Mother”.
《上清金闕靈書紫文》採飲飛根、吞日氣之法。昔受之於太微天帝君,一名《赤丹金精石景水母之經》也。……日光流霞之中,自復有紫氣,大如目童者,累重數十,炫煥在五光之中,名之曰飛根水母也。(DZ 639, 11, p. 381c)
5. Conclusions
Funding
Institutional Review Board Statement
Informed Consent Statement
Data Availability Statement
Acknowledgments
Conflicts of Interest
Abbreviations
| DZ | Daozang 道藏 (Daozang 1988). Citation format: (DZ [Schipper & Chen Number], [Volume Number], [Page and Column]). DZ numbers follow the indexing in Schipper and Chen (1996). The middle element refers to the volume number of the Daozang 1988 edition. The third component indicates the page and column; “a”, “b”, and “c” refer to the top, middle, and bottom horizontal columns, respectively. Example: (DZ 725, 14, p.330c) indicates Text No. 725, located in Volume 14, page 330, bottom column. |
| QTS | Quan Tang Shi 全唐詩 (Qing Shengzu [1961] 1967) |
Appendix A
| DZ No. | Poem Title 1 | Corresponding QTS Poem Order No. 3 | The Main Points |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Open my tomes-peruse the bygone years 啟册觀往載; 2 | 1 | Perception of Dao |
| 2 | At dawn I climb a thousand-fathom pass 晨登千仞嶺; | 17 | Cultivation of Dao |
| 3 | Simurghs and phoenixes roost in the azure-gem forest 鸞鳳棲瑶林; | 2 | Cultivation of Dao |
| 4 | Sympathy with custom leads one to removal and disintegration 愍俗從遷謝; | 3 | Cultivation of Dao |
| 5 | At Western Tortoise they first determined my ordination tablets 西龜初定籙; | 4 | Cultivation of Dao |
| 6 | My congenial spirit lies in the numinous archive 怡神在靈府; | 5 | Cultivation of Dao |
| 7 | My bones are refined -my frame is clarified throughout 骨鍊體彌清; | 18 | Cultivation of Dao |
| 8 | The realm of high realized ones is truly remote and rarefied 高真誠寥邈; | 6 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 9 | The Cyan Sea-its breadth without limits 碧海廣無際; | 7 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 10 | I proposed to pass by way of the Palace of the Grand Thearch 將過太帝宫; | 8 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 11 | Desiring to surmount the boundaries of yang-conduction 欲超洞陽界; | 9 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 12 | Now that I am visiting the Mother of Metal 予因詣金母; | 10 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 13 | At morning I pass to the north of Nhak Water 朝逾弱水北; | 19 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 14 | I raise the parasol-aim for the culmen of the chronograms 揚蓋造辰極; | 20 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 15 | I groom the equipage -take leave of the Five Marchmounts 整駕辭五嶽; | 21 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 16 | The nine dragons-how fluent their undulation 九龍何蜿蜿; | 11 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 17 | I halt my troika by the side of Grand Regalia 停驂太儀側; | 12 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 18 | Forbiddingly steep, brilliantly shining-the Gate of Miracles gapes wide 峻朗妙門闢; | 13 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 19 | I ascend as far as the Font of Yang 予昇至陽原; | 14 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 20 | I call a friend from Purple Solarity to accompany me 招携紫陽友; | 15 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 21 | I ascend high above the Purple Culmen 高昇紫極上; | 16 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 22 | I call a friend from the Three Clarities 予招三清友; | 22 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 23 | I loose my person above the Grand Aurora 縱身太霞上; | 23 | Journey to transcendence world |
| 24 | I look back to the [time] prior to “Grand Antecedence” 返視太初先. | 24 | Perception of Dao |
| 1 | “Canonical Religion Daoism 經教道教” is a concept proposed by Liu, Yi 劉屹 to explicate the defining characteristics of Medieval Daoism from its earlier forms. He states: “The Eastern Jin Dynasty and the early Southern Dynasties were one of the important periods in the history of Chinese Daoism. This was a transitional period from early Daoism to formal Daoism, and a period when Daoism in the true sense took shape. One of its overall characteristics was the transformation from ‘Daoshu Daoism’ to ‘Canonical Religion Daoism’ 東晋和南朝初期,是中國道教史上重要的歷史時期之一。這是由早期道教向正規道教的過渡時期,也是真正意義上的道教形成的時期。其總的特徵之一是由 “道術道教” 向 “經教道教” 轉變.” (Y. Liu 2011, p. 245) Also see Y. Liu (2005, p. 30). |
| 2 | Li, “If Daoism can be considered as a religion, I dare say that no Chinese poet had ever been as devoted to it as Li Bai 假若道教算一種宗教的話,我敢說從來的中國詩人沒有李白這樣信教信得篤的.” (C. Li 1940, p. 34) |
| 3 | From the perspective of the full text, Luo and Qian’s “Immortal Daoism” seems equivalent to the broader concept of Daoism as specialists in Daoist History perceived. For example, Luo explicitly states that Li Bai’s Neidan 内丹 Cultivation originated from the Highest Clarity tradition; Qian includes Wang Yuanzhi 王遠知 (509–635), belonging to the Maoshan Daoist tradition, and Tang Dynasty Daoism with “well-established religious organizations and membership records” within the scope of what he calls “Immortal Daoism.” This expansion of a narrow concept is not an isolated case. In “Tianshi Dao and Its Relationship with Coastal Regions 天師道與濱海地域之關係”, Chen Yinke 陳寅恪 cites witchcraft legends and the Zhang Jiao 張角 (d. 184) Uprising as evidence for the spread of Tianshi Dao 天師道 in eastern China (Yinke Chen [1933] 2001, pp. 1–46). His so-called “Tianshi Dao” is actually a general term for the religious Daoism, including traditional witchcraft, Taiping Dao 太平道, and Tianshi Dao itself (Q. Yu 2022, pp. 44–49). |
| 4 | Owen, Stephen, “Li Po was even less a religious poet than Wang Wei 王維 (701–761) was: he was deeply concerned neither with the cosmic principles of Taoism nor with the protoscience of Taoist alchemy.” (Owen 1981, p. 140) |
| 5 | As Rolf A. Stein has argued against, “Everything that did not seem purely Buddhist or Confucian in China has been called ‘Taoist (Stein 1979, p. 53).’” |
| 6 | Liu Yi categorizes Daoism prior to the Jin and Tang dynasties as “Daoshu Daoism,” which refers to “witchcraft and immortality techniques, including the witchcraft practices of kowtowing to confess sins, healing with talisman water, and praying to eliminate misfortune transmitted by early Daoism in the late Han dynasty, as well as the immortality-seeking techniques such as alchemy, medicine concoction, daoyin, breath circulation, and grain avoidance inherited from the immortality cults of the Warring States Period to Han periods 指巫術和仙術,即漢末早期道教傳習的叩頭首過、符水治病、請禱除厄等巫術,以及自戰國秦漢的神仙家以來的煉丹、合藥、導引、行氣、辟穀等求仙方術.” (Y. Liu 2011, p. 245). This definition is not directly adopted here because Liu places greater emphasis on the “Daoshu” 道術 (technical practice) dimension of pre-Jin-Tang Daoism. While Li Bai’s poems do incorporate numerous esoteric techniques, traced to ancient practices of the Han dynasty and earlier, some of which were directly inherited by later Daoism and retained a persistent role in Medieval Daoism, making complete differentiation infeasible. More importantly, the larger portion of Li Bai’s corpus focuses on his exploration of longevity, pursuit of transcendents, and interpretation of myths, elements that distinguish his practices significantly from Medieval Daoism. Thus, the term “Immortal Daoism” is ultimately chosen for reference. |
| 7 | Shi Ming 釋名 (Explaining Names) states: “The term ‘xian 仙’ derives from ‘qian 遷’ (to relocate), meaning to relocate to the mountains. Hence, the character is formed by combining ‘ren 人’ (person) and ‘shan 山’ (mountain).” (X. Wang 1984, p. 150) For a diachronic analysis of the evolution of the character from xian 僊 to xian 仙, see Y. Liu (2005, pp. 448–60). Tsuda further argues that this orthographic shift in the Chinese term for transcendent occurred during the early Eastern Han Dynasty (Tsuda [1966] 1987, pp. 174–77). |
| 8 | Regarding the number of Daoist monasteries in the Tang Dynasty, Du Guangting 杜光庭 (850–933) recorded that approximately 1900 new official Daoist monasteries were built in Tang Dynasty (DZ 593, 11, p. 7b). Before the Tang Dynasty, the Southern Dynasties had over 200 Daoist halls (not fully institutionalized as formal monasteries), while such institutions were extremely rare in the Northern Dynasties 北朝 (Sun 2014, pp. 99–102). In the Sui Dynasty 隋朝, all ten documented Daoist monasteries were concentrated in Daxing 大興, which later became Chang’an, the capital of the Tang Dynasty (Wei 2020, p. 67). The comparison across pre-Tang and Tang periods reveals that the majority of Daoist monasteries were newly constructed during the Tang Dynasty. The proliferation of Tang-Dynasty Daoist monasteries was driven by imperial decrees. During the reigns of Emperor Gaozu 高祖 (r. 618–626) and Emperor Taizong 太宗 (r. 626–649), no large-scale construction was undertaken as society was still in the process of stabilizing. Emperor Gaozong 高宗 (r. 649–683) (DZ 725, 14, p. 325b; Song 2008, p. 15), Zhongzong 中宗 (r. 683–684 and 705–710) (DZ 774, 18, p. 30c; X. Liu 1975, p. 137), and Xuanzong (DZ 774, 18, p. 30c; Song 2008, p. 54) all issued explicit edicts for the large-scale construction of Daoist monasteries nationwide. Although Emperor Ruizong 睿宗 (r. 684–690 and 710–712) was under the control of Wu Zetian 武則天 (r. 684–705) during 684–690 and only ruled formally in 710–712, he nevertheless commissioned the construction of grand Daoist monasteries at enormous expense for his two daughters, Princess Jinxian 金仙公主 (689–732) and Yuzhen (Q. Wang 2006, p. 557; G. Sima 1956, p. 6659). The relationship between Li Bai and Daoist monasteries will receive further examination in the subsequent sections. |
| 9 | Shanhai Jing 山海經 (Records of Mountains and Seas) documents supernatural entities such as immortal people, immortal kingdoms, immortal trees, and elixirs of immortality. These beings all share the trait of habiting isolated regions inaccessible to mundane individuals (Guo and Hao 2010, pp. 4890–91, 4985, 4939, 4940). |
| 10 | In shiji of Fengshan Shu 封禪書, Fangshi 方士 (practitioners of Fang Xiandao) claimed to have visited the three sacred mountains where transcendent beings resided, though the journey was extremely arduous (Q. Sima 1982, pp. 1369–70). |
| 11 | The narrative of recluses rejecting official duties can be traced back to Xu You 許由 (ca. 23rd century BCE). He was not a transcendent being. Xu You repeatedly declined Emperor Yao’s 堯 (ca. 23rd century BCE) offers to ascend to the throne or serve in an official capacity, spending his final years in the mountains (Q. Sima 1982, p. 2121). It marks the establishment of Chinese reclusive tradition. |
| 12 | In the two extant editions of Li Bai’s collected works from the Song Dynasty, this poem is titled “Reply to a Layperson in the Mountains 山中答俗人”. The title suggests that Li Bai, residing on Green Mountain and having transcended the mundane world, was responding to an individual from the secular realm. This framing highlights the clear distinction Li Bai aimed to draw between himself and the ordinary society. |
| 13 | As a figure with dual identities as a royal princess and a Daoist priestess, as well as her interactions with Li Bai, Princess Yuzhen’s life has become an ideal lens for scholars to examine politics, religion, and literature in the High Tang period. For studies on Princess Yuzhen’s Daoist practice, see Schafer (1985, pp. 1–23), Tsuchiya (2002, pp. 133–49; 2003, pp. 317–42), and Jia (2018, pp. 32–47). |
| 14 | Li Bai also opposed emperors’ pursuits of Daoism. He wrote numerous works mocking the famous history-seeking emperors Qin Shi Huang 秦始皇 (r. 221–210 BCE) and Han Wudi, using their actions as allegories for the reigning Emperor Xuanzong. A significant portion of his works (e.g., Climb the High Hill and Gaze at the Distant Sea; Ancient Style Poems, No. 3; Ancient Style Poems, No. 43) employed Daoist-themed parables to satirize Xuanzong’s moral and governance failures, while expressing Li Bai’s own frustrations with his political setbacks. |
| 15 | |
| 16 | Reference may also be made to the account of Qin Shi Huang in Shiji. He dispatched alchemists to search for the Three Divine Mountains, Penglai, Fangzhang 方丈 (also called Fanghu), and Yingzhou at sea (Q. Sima 1982, pp. 247–48), an act that contributed to the enduring craze for seeking transcendent beings offshore. |
| 17 | Schafer translated “遊仙詩” as “Saunters in Sylphdom poetry”, explaining that “this is a verb-object construction meaning ‘a relaxed journey to the world above; a saunter in secret sylphdom; easy transition into transcendence.’” (Schafer 1981–1983, p. 310), as referenced in my work. Regarding the relationship between Immortal Daoism and literature, Li Fengmao 李豐楙 examined the development of Daoism and Saunters in Sylphdom poetry from the Wei to early Sui period in chronological order (F. Li [1983] 2010a, pp. 1–26). In his study, he employed a broad concept of Daoism, without identifying distinct Daoist schools, but acknowledged that most Daoist elements used in Saunters in Sylphdom poetry derive from Immortal mythology (F. Li [1983] 2010a, p. 25). For a comprehensive analysis of how Tang dynasty Saunters in Sylphdom poetry inherited and further developed the Six Dynasties tradition in terms of title conventions, language, imagery, and metaphorical techniques, see Li (F. Li [1984] 2010b, pp. 27–50). |
| 18 | |
| 19 | |
| 20 | Like Lushan Yao Ji Lu Shiyu Xuzhou (Ballad of Mount Lu Sent to Censor Lu Xuzhou) and Mengyou Tianmu Yin Liubie 夢遊天姥吟留别 (A Dream Journey to Tianmu Mountain: A Song of Farewell), among others. |
| 21 | The earliest archaeological artifact depicting a feathered transcendent being is a jade pendant unearthed in 1989 from a Shang Dynasty 商朝 tomb in Xingan 新幹, Jiangxi Province (Su 1999. p. 174). |
| 22 | Kroll marvels at the high degree of consistency between the detailed depiction of the Shangyuan Furen in Li Bai’s poetry and the records in Han Wudi Neizhuan. He argues that since the subject of the writing is a Daoist deity, personal imagination and creative elaboration are not permitted, and the composition must adhere strictly to canonical records (Kroll 1986, p. 101). However, strict adherence to canonical records is not a universal principle in Li Bai’s Daoist-themed poetry. Instead, it represents an optional feature of one’s poetic adaptations of transcendent narratives from original texts, and such adherence does not preclude the possibility of poetic innovation. |
| 23 | Research on Wu Yun’s life, thought, and literary creation is extensive, among which “Wu Yun’s Biography, Thought, and Literature” by Mugiya Kunio stands out for its comprehensiveness (Mugiya 2018, pp. 70–99). Additionally, readers may refer to the specialized discussions by scholars such as Shoko Kanzuka 神塚淑子, Lu Renlong 盧仁龍, Huang Junming 黄君名, and Zhan Shichuang 詹石窗, as listed in Mugiya’s article (Mugiya 2018, p. 70). |
| 24 | The account in the Old Book of Tang has long been regarded as credible historical record. However, textual research by Yu Xianhao 郁賢皓 and others has demonstrated that no verifiable interactions existed between Wu Yun and Li Bai (X. Yu 1981, pp. 40–46). Also refer to Li (Baojun Li 1981, pp. 71–74). |
| 25 | In his preface, Quan Deyu stated, “Among those who have engaged in religions and created poetries in recent antiquity, Master Wu truly leads the way 近古遊方外而言六義者,先生實主盟焉.” (DZ 1051, 23, p. 653b). This comment positions Wu Yun as a literary leader within the religious community. |
| 26 | Schafer conducted specialized translation and research on Wu Yun’s “Bu Xu” (Schafer 1977, pp. 242–47; 1981, pp. 377–415). |
| 27 | The only potential concern arises from the poet’s reference to mountain climbing in the second poem: “At dawn I climb a thousand-ren peak, looking down at the abodes of mortals 晨登千仞嶺,俯瞰四人居.” (DZ 1051, 23, p. 665b) However, a holistic analysis of the entire poem reveals that the subsequent line—“In that distant dust, they rush to the path of fame and profit 眇彼埃塵中,爭奔聲利途” (DZ 1051, 23, p. 665b)—clarifies Wu Yun’s complete message. After climbing the mountain, he observes the vain pursuit of fame and profit in the human world, expressing his disdain for such desires. In contrast, mountain climbing in Six Dynasties Saunters in Sylphdom poetry typically serves as a prerequisite for encountering transcendent beings. Thus, the “mountain climbing” motif in Wu’s poem is spiritually antithetical to the traditional motif in Six Dynasties poetry. |
| 28 | For a detailed analysis of Emperor Xuanzong’s political measures to promote Daoism and their social consequences, see Barrett, especially the sections “Taoism in the Mid-K’ai-Yuan Period” and “Taoism in the T’ien-Pao Era” (Barrett 1995, pp. 54–73). |
| 29 | Liu Zhi’s 柳識 (fl. 713–779) “Epitaph for Master Xuanjing of the Ziyang Temple on Maoshan in Tang Dynasty 唐茅山紫陽觀玄静先生碑” stated: “The Huayang Grotto of the Daoist tradition is comparable to the Zhu and Si Rivers of Confucianism, for it is here that the metaphysical transformation flourished 道門華陽,亦儒門洙泗,蓋玄化振於此也” (Liu and Jiang 2016, p. 320). The term “Huayang” refers to the Huayang Grotto Archive 華陽洞天 on Maoshan, as documented in Zhengao 真誥 (Declarations of the Perfected), Vol. 11: “There are thirty-six grotto heaven beneath the earth. The eighth is the grotto of Juqu Mountain, which spans 150 li in circumference and is named the Golden Altar Huayang Heaven 有地中之洞天三十六所。其第八是句曲山之洞,週迴一百五十里,名曰金壇華陽之天” (DZ 1016, 20, p. 555a–b). The “Zhu and Si Rivers” denote the location where Confucius once taught, as recorded in Liji (Book of Rites): “I studied with you under the Master by the Zhu and Si Rivers 吾與女事夫子於洙泗之間” (X. Zheng 2021, p. 79). Thus, Liu Zhi analogizes the status of the Maoshan Daoist tradition in Daoism to that of Confucius in Confucianism. Yan Zhenqing 顔真卿 (709–785) offers a more explicit assessment in “Preface to Epitaph for Master Li of Guangling, the Xuanjing Master of Maoshan in the Tang Dynasty 有唐茅山玄静先生廣陵李君碑銘并序”: “Maoshan has become the ancestral source of Daoist learning in the world 所以茅山爲天下學道之所宗矣.” (Liu and Jiang 2016, p. 324). |
| 30 | The academic community has traditionally equated the Maoshan Daoist tradition with the Highest Clarity tradition. Recent research by Bai Zhaojie demonstrated that identifying with Highest Clarity tradition in the Tang Dynasty was gradually constructed, with Sima Chengzhen and Li Hanguang 李含光 (682–769), Hu Ziyang’s teacher, serving as critical figures in this process. This argument is credible (Bai 2024, pp. 87–111). For Li Bai, since his interactions were primarily with Sima Chengzhen and Hu Ziyang, both the Highest Clarity tradition practitioners, this scholarly revision does not challenge the core of our discussion. |
| 31 | |
| 32 | |
| 33 | This terminology might also relate to Li Bai’s preference for purple (Kroll 1997, pp. 21–37). |
| 34 | Tsuchiya studied Li Bai’s interactions with Daoist priests rooted in the Highest Clarity tradition, including Jiao Jingzhen, Princess Yuzhen, and Hu Ziyang. His analysis demonstrates that Li Bai was influenced by the Highest Clarity tradition (Tsuchiya 2006, pp. 105–11). |
| 35 | Cao Cao 曹操 (155–220) lamented, “Life is like the morning dew; the days gone by are sorely many. Though I sing of joy, my sorrows linger unforgotten.” (Cao 2013, p. 5) Ji Kang’s 嵇康 (224–263) Treatise on Nourishing Life 養生論 constitutes a philosophical inquiry into and response to existential anxiety, in which he posits that ordinary individuals can effectively extend their lifespan through rational practices (Ji 2014, pp. 252–55). His contemporary and peer Ruan Ji 阮籍 (210–263) repeatedly articulated concerns about the fragility of life in his Yonghuai 詠懷 series (Ruan 2012, pp. 199–404). |
References
- Bai, Zhaojie 白照傑. 2017. Tang Qianqi (618–755) Daojiao Fawei Zhidu Lizheng 唐前期 (618–755) 道教法位制度釐證 [Verification of the Daoist Ordination Rank System in the Early Tang Dynasty (618–755)]. Religious Studies 宗教學研究 1: 63–79. [Google Scholar]
- Bai, Zhaojie. 2024. Tangdai Shangqingdao De Shenfen Juexing Yu Famai Jiangou 唐代 “上清道” 的身份覺醒與法脉建構 [The Identity Awakening and Lineage Construction of the Highest Clarity Tradition in the Tang Dynasty]. Wenshi 文史 1: 87–111. [Google Scholar]
- Barrett, Timothy Hugh. 1995. Taoism Under the T’ang: Religion and Empire During a Golden Age of Chinese History. London: The Wellsweep Press, pp. 54–73. [Google Scholar]
- Benn, Charles D. 1991. The Cavern-Mystery Transmission: A Taoist Ordination Rite of A.D. 711. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, pp. 16–19. [Google Scholar]
- Benn, Charles D. 2000. Daoist Ordination and Zhai Rituals. In Daoism Handbook. Edited by Livia Kohn. Leiden: Brill, pp. 311–22. [Google Scholar]
- Bradbury, Malcolm. 2001. The Atlas of Literature. London: Greenwich Editions, p. 8. [Google Scholar]
- Cao, Cao. 2013. Cao Cao Ji 曹操集 [The Collection of Cao Cao]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, p. 5. [Google Scholar]
- Chen, Yinke 陳寅恪. 2001. Tianshidao Yu Binhai Diyu Zhi Guanxi 天師道與濱海地域之關係 [The Relationship Between the Tianshi Daoism and Coastal Regions]. In Jinmingguan Conggao Chubian 金明館叢稿初編 [Collected Drafts of Jinming Hall (First Series)]. Collected Papers of Institute of History and Philology, Academia Sinica, vol. 3, No. 4. Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing Company, pp. 1–46. First published 1933. [Google Scholar]
- Chen, Yixin. 1961. The Political Purposes of Reclusion and Immortality-Seeking Among Some Intellectuals in the Tang Dynasty: With a Discussion of Li Bai’s Political Ideals and Paths to Officialdom 唐代某些知識分子隱逸求仙的政治目的——兼論李白的政治理想和從政途徑. Journal of Peking University 北京大學學報 3: 30–33. [Google Scholar]
- Chen, Yuan 陳垣. 1988. Daojia Jinshi Lue 道家金石略 [A Compendium of Daoist Epigraphy]. Beijing: Cultural Relics Press, pp. 139–40. [Google Scholar]
- Chen, Zhongqi 陳仲奇. 2001. Dōkyō sensetsu no seiritsu ni tsuite 道教神仙説の成立について [On the Formation of Taoist Immortal Theories]. In Sōgō Seisaku Ronsō 総合政策論叢 [Journal of Comprehensive Policy Studies]. Hamada: Shimane Prefectural University, Society of Comprehensive Policy Studies 島根県立大学総合政策学会, vol. 1, pp. 149–70. [Google Scholar]
- Daozang. 1988. Daozang, Sanjia ed. Shanghai: Cultural Relics Press, Shanghai Bookstore, Tianjin Ancient Book Press. [Google Scholar]
- Du, Fu. 1979. Dushi Xiangzhu 杜詩詳注 [Detailed Annotations on Du Fu’s Poetry]. Annotated by Zhao’ao Qiu 仇兆鰲. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 33, 55. [Google Scholar]
- Ge, Hong 葛洪. 1985. Baopuzi Neipian Jiaoshi 抱朴子内篇校釋 [The Collation and Annotation of ‘Baopuzi Neipian’]. Corrected and Annotated by Ming Wang 王明. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 70–87. [Google Scholar]
- Ge, Hong. 2010. Shenxian Zhuan Jiaoshi 神仙傳校釋 [The Collation and Annotation of ‘Shenxian Zhuan’]. Corrected and Annotated by Shouwei Hu 胡守爲. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 93–95, 354. [Google Scholar]
- Guo, Maoqian 郭茂倩. 1979. Yuefu Shiji 樂府詩集 [The Collection of Yuefu Poetry]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 230, 926. [Google Scholar]
- Guo, Pu, and Yixing Hao 郝懿行. 2010. Shanhai Jing Jianshu 山海經箋疏 [The Collection and Annotation of ‘Shanhai Jing’]. Collated and Punctuated by Dingsan Zhang 張鼎三 and Tong Mou 牟通. Ji’nan: Shandong Qilu Press Co., Ltd., p. 5000. [Google Scholar]
- Guo, Qingfan 郭慶藩. 1961. Zhuangzi Jishi 莊子集釋 [Collected Annotations to the ‘Zhuangzi’]. Collated and Punctuated by Xiaoyu Wang 王孝魚. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 550–51. [Google Scholar]
- Hawkes, David. 1967. The Quest of the Goddess. Asia Major 13: 71–94. [Google Scholar]
- Holzman, Donald. 1994. Immortality-Seeking in Early Chinese Poetry. In The Power of Culture: Studies in Chinese Cultural History. Edited by Willard J. Peterson, Andrew H. Plaks and Ying-shih Yu. Hong Kong: The Chinese University of Hong Kong Press, Shatin, N.T., p. 111. [Google Scholar]
- Hong, Xingzu 洪興祖. 1983. Chuci Buzhu 楚辭補注 [Supplementary Annotations to ‘Chuci’]. Collated and Punctuated by Huawen Bai 白化文 and Dingxia Li 李鼎霞. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, p. 167. [Google Scholar]
- Ji, Kang 嵇康. 2014. Ji Kang Ji Jiaozhu 嵇康集校注 [The Collation and Annotation of ‘Ji Kang Ji’]. Collated and annotated by Mingyang Dai 戴明揚. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 252–55. [Google Scholar]
- Jia, Jinhua 賈晋華. 2015. Study on the Anthologies of Gatherings and Poet Groups in Tang Dynasty 唐代集會總集與詩人群研究. Beijing: Peking University Press, pp. 358, 366. First published 2001. [Google Scholar]
- Jia, Jinhua. 2018. Gender, Power, and Talent: The Journey of Daoist Priestesses in Tang China. New York: Columbia University Press, pp. 32–47. [Google Scholar]
- Kobayashi, Masami 小林正美. 2003. Tangdai no Dōkyō to Tenshidō 唐代の道教と天師道 [Daoism and Tianshi Daoism in the Tang Dynasty]. Tokyo: Chisen Shokan, pp. 13–63. [Google Scholar]
- Kohn, Livia. 1988. A Mirror of Auras: Chen Tuan on Physiognomy. Asian Folklore Studies 47: 215–56. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Komatsu, Tadashi 小松忠志. 1966. Rihaku no Gūsen ni Tsuite 李白の求仙について [About Li Bai’s Pursuit of Immortality]. Nagano-ken Tanki Daigaku Kiyō 長野県短期大学紀要 [Bulletin of Nagano Prefectural Junior College] 20: 9–20. [Google Scholar]
- Kroll, Paul W. 1986. Li Po’s Transcendent Diction. American Oriental Society 106: 99–117. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Kroll, Paul W. 1997. Li Po’s Purple Haze. Taoist Resources 7: 21–37. [Google Scholar]
- Li, Bai. 1977. Li Taibai Quanji 李太白全集 [The Complete Works of Li Taibai]. Annotated by Qi Wang. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 1152, 1492. [Google Scholar]
- Li, Bai. 2015. Li Bai Quanji Biannian Jianzhu 李白全集編年箋注 [The Annotation of Chronological Collected Works of Li Bai]. Corrected and annotated by Qi An, Tianwei Xue 薛天緯, Qi Yan 閻琦 and Rixi Fang 房日晰. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company. [Google Scholar]
- Li, Baojun 李寶均. 1981. The Clarification of Wu Yun Recommended Li Bai to Chang’an 吴筠薦舉李白入長安辨. Literature, History and Philosophy 文史哲 1: 71–74. [Google Scholar]
- Li, Changzhi. 1940. Daojiaotu De Shiren Li Bai Ji Qi Tongku 道教徒的詩人李白及其痛苦 [Li Bai: The Poet of Daoism and His Spiritual Agony]. Hong Kong: The Commercial Press, p. 34. [Google Scholar]
- Li, Fengmao. 2010a. Liuchao Daojiao Yu Youxianshi De Fazhan 六朝道教與遊仙詩的發展 [Development of Daoism in the Six Dynasties and the ‘Saunters In Sylphdom’ Poetry]. In You Yu You: Liuchao Sui-Tang Xiandao Wenxue 憂與遊:六朝隋唐仙道文學 [Melancholy and Roaming: Taoist Immortality Literature of the Six Dynasties and Sui-Tang Periods]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 1–26. First published 1983 in Zhonghua Xueyuan 中華學苑 [Zhonghua Academy of Chinese Studies] 28: 97–118. [Google Scholar]
- Li, Fengmao. 2010b. Tangren Youxianshi De Chuancheng Yu Chuangxin 唐人遊仙詩的傳承與創新 [Inheritance and Innovation in Tang Dynasty ‘Saunters In Sylphdom’ Poetry]. In You Yu You: Liuchao Sui-Tang Xiandao Wenxue. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 27–50. First published 1984 in Gudian Wenxue 古典文學 [Classical Chinese Literature]. Taibei: Taiwan Xuesheng Shuju 臺灣學生書局, vol. 6, pp. 133–64. [Google Scholar]
- Li, Xian 李賢. 1505. Daming Yitongzhi 大明一統志 [Comprehensive Gazetteer of the Ming Dynasty]. Jianyang 建陽: Shenduzhai 慎獨齋. [Google Scholar]
- Liu, Dabin 劉大彬, and Yongnian Jiang 江永年. 2016. Maoshan Zhi 茅山志 [Records of Maoshan]. Collated and Punctuated by Gang Wang 王崗. Shanghai: Shanghai Ancient Book Press, pp. 320, 324. [Google Scholar]
- Liu, Su 劉肅. 1984. Datang Xinyu [New Tales of the Tang]. Collated and Punctuated by Denan Xu 許德楠 and Dingxia Li. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 157–58. [Google Scholar]
- Liu, Xu 劉昫. 1975. Jiutangshu [The Old Book of Tang]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 137, 213, 216, 5053, 5129–30. [Google Scholar]
- Liu, Yi. 2005. Jingtian yu Chongdao—Zhonggu Jingjiao Daojiao Xingcheng de Sixiangshi Beijing 敬天與崇道——中古經教道教形成的思想史背景 [Revering Heaven and Worshipping the Dao: The Intellectual-Historical Background of the Formation of Medieval Canonical Religion Daoism]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 30, 431, 448–60. [Google Scholar]
- Liu, Yi. 2011. Shenge yu Diyu: Han-Tang Jian Daojiao Xinyang Shijie Yanjiu 神格與地域:漢唐間道教信仰世界研究 [Divine Personae and Region: On the Daoist Belief World From Han to Tang]. Shanghai: Shanghai People’s Publishing House, p. 245. [Google Scholar]
- Luo, Zongqiang. 1991. Li Bai’s Belief in Immortal Daoism 李白的神仙道教信仰. In Zhongguo Libai Yanjiu 中國李白研究 [Li Bai Studies in China]. Edited by Chinese Li Bai Research Association and Ma’anshan Li Bai Memorial Hall. Nanjing: Jiangsu Ancient Book Press, pp. 20–33. [Google Scholar]
- Lü, Buwei 吕不韋. 2009. Lüshi Chunqiu Jishi 吕氏春秋集釋 [Collected Annotations to ‘Lüshi Chunqiu’]. Collated and annotated by Weiyu Xu 許維遹. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, p. 614. [Google Scholar]
- Mugiya, Kunio 麥谷邦夫. 2018. Wu, Yün’s Biography, Thought and Literature 吴筠的生平、思想與文學. In The Literary Experience of Daoist Cultivation and Rituals 道教修煉與科儀的文學體驗. Edited by Weiqiang Chen 陳偉强. Nanjing: Phoenix Press, pp. 70–99. [Google Scholar]
- Ouyang, Xiu 歐陽修, and Qi Song 宋祁. 1975. Xintangshu 新唐書 [The New Book of Tang]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 3657, 5604–5. [Google Scholar]
- Owen, Stephen. 1981. The Great Age of Chinese Poetry the High Tang. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, p. 140. [Google Scholar]
- Ōbuchi, Shinji 大淵忍爾. 1991. Shoki no sensetsu 初期の僊説 [Early Immortal Theories]. In Shoki no Dōkyō 初期の道教 [Early Daoism]. Tokyo: Sōbunsha 創文社, pp. 439–62. First published 1952 as Shoki no sensetsu ni tsuite 初期の僊説について [On Early Immortal Theories], Tōhō Shūkyō 東方宗教 [Oriental Religions] 2: 23–43. [Google Scholar]
- Pei, Fei 裴斐. 1981. Li Bai Shilun 李白十論 [Ten Essays on Li Bai]. Chengdu: Sichuan People’s Publishing House, pp. 122–36. [Google Scholar]
- Penny, Benjamin. 2000. Immortality and Transcendence. In Daoism Handbook. Edited by Livia Kohn. Leidon: Brill, pp. 109–15. [Google Scholar]
- Qian, Zhixi. 2015. Li Bai yu Shenxian Daojiao Guanxi Xinlun 李白與神仙道教關係新論 [New Opinion on the Relationship between Li Bai and Immortal Daoism]. Social Sciences in Chinese Higher Education Institutions 中國高校社會科學 5: 66–78, 155. [Google Scholar]
- Qian, Zhixi. 2022. Luelun Li Bai Youxian Shi Tizhi Leixing Ji Yuanyuan Liubian 略論李白遊仙詩體制類型及淵源流變 [A Brief Study on the Formal Types, Origins and Evolution of Li Bai’s Saunters in Sylphdom]. Literary Heritage 文學遺産 4: 92–104. [Google Scholar]
- Qing Shengzu 清聖祖 (r. 1661–1722). 1967. Quan Tang Shi. Taibei: Fuxing Shuju. First published 1961. [Google Scholar]
- Ruan, Ji. 2012. Ruan Ji Ji Jiaozhu 阮籍集校注 [The Collation and Annotation of ‘Ruan Ji Ji’]. Collated and Annotated by Bojun Chen 陳伯君. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 199–404. [Google Scholar]
- Schafer, Edward H. 1977. Pacing the Void: T’ang Approaches to the Stars. Oakland: University of California Press, pp. 242–47. [Google Scholar]
- Schafer, Edward H. 1981. Wu, Yün’s ‘Cantos on Pacing the Void’. Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies 4: 377–415. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Schafer, Edward H. 1981–1983. Wu, Yün’s Stanzas on ‘Saunters in Sylphdom’. Monumenta Serica 35: 309–45. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Schafer, Edward H. 1985. The Princess Realized in Jade. Tang Studies 3: 1–23. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Schipper, Kristofer M., and Yaoting Chen 陳耀庭. 1996. Daozang Suoyin: Wuzhong Banben Daozang Tongjian 道藏索引: 五種版本道藏通檢 [Index to the Daoist Canon: Concordance of the Five Editions of the Daoist Canon]. Shanghai: Shanghai Bookstore. [Google Scholar]
- Sima, Guang 司馬光. 1956. Zizhi Tongjian 資治通鑒 [Comprehensive Mirror for Governance]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, p. 6659. [Google Scholar]
- Sima, Qian 司馬遷. 1982. Shiji. Annotated by Yin Pei 裴駰, Zhen Sima 司馬貞 and Shoujie Zhang 張守節. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 247–48, 1369–70, 1385, 1394, 2121. [Google Scholar]
- Song, Minqiu 宋敏求. 2008. Tang Da Zhaolingji 唐大詔令集 [Collection of the Great Imperial Edicts of the Tang Dynasty]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, p. 15. [Google Scholar]
- Stein, Rolf A. 1979. Religious Taoism and Popular Religion from the Second to Seventh Centuries. In Facets of Taoism: Essays in Chinese Religion. Edited by Holmes Welch and Anna Seidel. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, p. 53. [Google Scholar]
- Su, Bai 宿白. 1999. Zhonghua Renmin Gongheguo Zhongda Kaogu Faxian 中華人民共和國重大考古發現 [Great Archaeological Discoveries of the People’s Republic of China]. Beijing: Cultural Relics Press, p. 174. [Google Scholar]
- Sun, Qi 孫齊. 2014. Tangqian Daoguan Yanjiu 唐前道觀研究 [A Study of the Daoist Monasteries in pre-Tang Dynasties]. Doctoral dissertation, Shandong University, Jinan, China; pp. 99–102. [Google Scholar]
- Tsuchiya, Masaaki 土屋昌明. 2002. Li Bai’s Associates and Daoism—Centered on Yuan Danqiu, Hu Ziyang, and Princess Yuzhen 李白の交遊と道教—元丹丘·胡紫陽·玉真公主を中心に. Annual Report of the Institute of Humanities, Senshu University 32: 133–49. [Google Scholar]
- Tsuchiya, Masaaki. 2003. Daoists Around Princess Yuzhen and Daoism in the Xuanzong Period 玉真公主をめぐる道士と玄宗時期 の道教. In Tōhōgaku no Shin Shiten 東方學の新視點 [New Perspectives on Oriental Studies]. Edited by Fukui Fumimasa 福井文雅. Tokyo: Goyo Shobo, pp. 317–42. [Google Scholar]
- Tsuchiya, Masaaki. 2006. Li Bo’s Works, Daoism and Shang Qing Jing 李白之創作與道士及上清經. Journal of Sichuan University 146: 105–11. [Google Scholar]
- Tsuda, Sokichi. 1987. Shinsen Shisō no Kenkyū 神僊思想の研究 [Studies in Immortal Daoist Thought]. In Tsuda Sōkichi Zenshū 津田左右吉全集 [Collected Works of Tsuda Sokichi], 2nd ed. Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten, pp. 174–77. First published 1966. [Google Scholar]
- Wang, Qinruo 王欽若. 2006. Cefu Yuangui 册府元龜 [Imperial Mirror of the Book Repository]. Collated by Xunchu Zhou 周勛初. Nanjing: Phoenix Press, p. 557. [Google Scholar]
- Wang, Shumin 王叔珉. 2007. Liexian Zhuan Jiaojian 列仙傳校箋 [The Collation and Annotation of ‘Liexian Zhuan’]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 1, 50, 80, 158. [Google Scholar]
- Wang, Xianqian 王先謙. 1984. Shiming Shuzheng Bu 釋名疏證補 [Supplementary Additions of ‘the Annotation of Shiming’]. Shanghai: Shanghai Ancient Book Press, p. 150. [Google Scholar]
- Wei, Shu 韋述. 2020. Liangjing Xinji Jijiao 兩京新記輯校 [Collation and Annotation of ‘New Records of the Two Capitals’]. Reconstructed and collated by Deyong Xin 辛德勇. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, p. 67. [Google Scholar]
- Wen, Yiduo 聞一多. 2006. Shenhua Yu Shi 神話與詩 [Myth and Poetry]. Shanghai: Shanghai People Press, Kaiming Book Store, pp. 120–47. Frist published 1948. [Google Scholar]
- Xiao, Shiyun 蕭士贇. 1271–1368. Fen-Lei Bu-Zhu Li Taibai Shi 分類補注李太白詩. Jian’an 建安: Qinyoutang 勤有堂, vol. 3, pp. 14b–15a. [Google Scholar]
- Yamada, Toshiaki 山田利明. 1990. Shenxiandao 神仙道 [Immortal Daoism]. In Daoism. Edited by Fukui Kōjun 福井康順, Yamazaki Hiroshi 山崎宏, Kimura Eiichi 木村英一 and Sakai Tadao 酒井忠夫. Translated by Zhu Yueli 朱越利. Shanghai: Shanghai Ancient Book Press, vol. 1, pp. 270–305. First published 1983. [Google Scholar]
- Yang, Bojun 楊伯峻. 1979. Liezi Jishi 列子集釋 [The Collection and Annotation of ‘Liezi’]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, pp. 151–54. [Google Scholar]
- Yu, Qin 俞沁. 2022. Liuchao Zhi Ming yu Daojiao Xilun 六朝“之”名與道教析論 [Analysis of Zhi Names and Daoism in the Six Dynasties]. Religious Studies 4: 44–49. [Google Scholar]
- Yu, Xianhao. 1981. A Critical Examination of the Claim That Wu Yun Recommended Li Bai 吴筠薦李白説辨疑. Journal of Nanjing Normal University 南京師大學報 1: 40–46. [Google Scholar]
- Yu, Xianhao. 2008a. Li Bai Yu Zhang Ji Jiaoyou Xinzheng 李白與張垍交遊新證 [New Reasearch on the Interaction between Li Bai and Zhang Ji]. In Li Bai Yu Tangdai Wenshi Kaolun 李白與唐代文史考論 [Studies on Li Bai and Literature and History in Tang Dynasty], 1st ed. Nanjing: Nanjing Normal University Press, vol. 1, pp. 263–67. First published 1978 in Journal of Nanjing Normal School 1. [Google Scholar]
- Yu, Xianhao. 2008b. Zaitan Li Bai Shizhong “Weiwei Zhangqing” He “Yuzhen Gongzhu Bieguan” 再談李白詩中 “衛尉張卿” 和 “玉真公主别館” [Reinvestigating “Guardian Zhang Qing” and “Princess Yuzhen’s Villa” in Li Bai’s Poems]. In Li Bai Yu Tangdai Wenshi Kaolun, 1st ed. Nanjing: Nanjing Normal University Press, vol. 1, pp. 203–15. First published 1994 in Journal of Nanjing Normal University 1. [Google Scholar]
- Yu, Ying-shih 余英時. 1964–1965. Life and Immortality in The Mind of Han China. Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies 25: 80–122. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Yue, Shi 樂史. 2007. Taiping Huanyuji 太平寰宇記 [Universal Geography of the Taiping Era]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, p. 1966. [Google Scholar]
- Zhan, Furui 詹福瑞. 2024. Shengming Juxian yu Li Bai de Youxianzhisi 生命拘限與李白的遊仙之思 [Life’s Constraints and Li Bai’s Thoughts on a relaxed journey to the world above]. Literary Heritage 文學遺産 3: 68–79. [Google Scholar]
- Zheng, Xuan 鄭玄. 2021. Liji Zhu 禮記注 [The Annotation of ‘The Book of Rites’]. Collated and Punctuated by E Wang 王鍔. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, p. 79. [Google Scholar]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the author. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.
Share and Cite
Yu, Q. Tang Dynasty Daoist Diversity: Immortal Daoism as an Offshoot in Li Bai’s Era. Religions 2026, 17, 472. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel17040472
Yu Q. Tang Dynasty Daoist Diversity: Immortal Daoism as an Offshoot in Li Bai’s Era. Religions. 2026; 17(4):472. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel17040472
Chicago/Turabian StyleYu, Qin. 2026. "Tang Dynasty Daoist Diversity: Immortal Daoism as an Offshoot in Li Bai’s Era" Religions 17, no. 4: 472. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel17040472
APA StyleYu, Q. (2026). Tang Dynasty Daoist Diversity: Immortal Daoism as an Offshoot in Li Bai’s Era. Religions, 17(4), 472. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel17040472
