Abstract
For the spiritual situation at the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries, it is appropriate to speak of the project of the new man, which was caused by a grandiose revolution that had various dimensions, including scientific, technological, and artistic aspects. From this perspective, it is useful to distinguish between two models of the relationship between experimental art and science and technology. According to the first model, art assists science and technology to create the new man, with science and technology playing a fundamental role (Futurism). According to the second model, art opposes science and technology, which poses a threat to the individual and humanity as a whole. Bely is closer to the second model, but with important clarifications. The treatise The History of the Formation of the Self-conscious soul occupies a central place among his philosophical texts. In this treatise, the author examined the development of culture from Christ to the beginning of the 20th century. Bely worked on The History in the USSR, but did not plan to publish it. Therefore, he freely used the anthroposophical methodology and conceptual methodology, which led to the radically experimental (avant-garde) character of the treatise. In The History, science and technology are an important expression of culture, but by no means the highest. Their significance is determined by when and how they contribute to understanding the spiritual laws of the universe. At the same time, Bely published a review of Fyodor Gladkov’s novel Energy in the Soviet magazine Novy Mir, in which he continued to criticize the cult of science and technology being self-sufficient. Finally, in his experimental novel Moscow, Bely explored the tragedy of the scientist in modern society. The protagonist of the novel makes a scientific discovery that has potential for industrial (military) applications. The character realizes the danger of the discovery, and he is tortured, but he does not reveal the discovery to either foreign spies or the communists. In other words, in his Soviet-era writings, Bely did not so much deny the importance of science and technology as he did prioritize spiritual work and art. Thus, his texts express the type of interference between scientific reflection and avant-garde art that R. Poggioli described as “general dynamism”.
***
In defining the correlation of avant-garde art and modern science in connection with Andrei Bely’s works, it would be reasonable to look at the works of the Russian journalists before 1917 who made the problem an object of philosophical thought. In particular, in N. A. Berdyaev’s heritage one can single out the cycle of articles The Fate of Russia—written, according to him “during the war up to the revolution” (for the first time as a book—1918; Berdyaev 1990, p. 3; see also the full translation of The Fate of Russia into English: Berdyaev 2016).
Similarly, the intriguing title of his article Futurism in the War (October 1914; not included in The Fate of Russia cycle) dramatically combines the themes of the World War and the scandalous movement of Futurism. Berdyaev begins by recalling recent polemics in Russian society:
The interests of the previous period were largely dominated by the shadow of Futurism. A countless number of public lectures, published articles, and private conversations were dedicated to the Futurist hype. As always happens with fashionable topics, its significance was greatly exaggerated.(Berdyaev 2004, p. 17)
During the hard years of wartime, Berdyaev argues, the “theme of Futurism” naturally was transformed into “the historical epoch”:
In the methods and tactics which the Germans use to wage the war, there is a great deal of Futuristic features <…> In the militarism of the newest German Empire, not a trace remains of the chivalric spirit which characterized the old Germans. This is a phenomenon of the twentieth century, armed with all the methods and devices of the latest technology and industry. German militarism is a typically Futuristic mechanization and automation of the human mass and of human life itself.(Berdyaev 2004, p. 17)
By the time Berdyaev’s article was published, the accusation of German militarism of it being Futurist had already been a key theme of Russian journalism. According to A. V. Krusanov, “the war exacerbated the tendency of spreading the concept of ‘Futurism’ beyond the bounds of art and simultaneously changed its perception: the theme of destruction came to the fore, replacing eccentricity, scandal, and the negation of common sense” (Krusanov 2010, p. 485). The researcher quotes contemporary opinions from newspapers of September–October 1914:
At first glance, comparing the Germans to Futurists may seem a paradox, for what could militant Germans, who have set themselves the task of conquering the entire world, have in common with peaceful Futurists like our Burliuks or the Italian Marinetti? But they do share something. The Futurists have set themselves the goal of destroying ancient art. The Germans pursue this same goal, barbarically destroying all ancient monuments of art they stumble upon.(Krusanov 2010, p. 485)
However, Berdyaev speculates upon this journalistic cliché in his own way, developing an original philosophical “plot”:
In Germany, Futurism was least represented in literature and art. The cradle of Futurism was the Latin countries, which wished to free themselves from the heavy burden of their great past. But in Germany, a Futurism of another kind was brewing, far more substantial and ominous—a living Futurism in its militarism and its industry.(Berdyaev 2004, p. 19)
If Futurism “in literature and art” is a product of Italy, then “living Futurism,” conversely, is a product of German culture.
According to Futurism in the War:
This Futurism imperceptibly extinguished the human spirit, turning man into a means for a monstrous, soulless mechanism. The dualism of spirit and matter is stronger in Germany than anywhere else <…> Organic life, elemental life in flesh and blood, is there transformed into an “automotive” mechanism, subjected to mechanical discipline <…> In the Germans, a primal barbaric coarseness inherent to their race has merged with the barbarism born of civilization.(Berdyaev 2004, pp. 19–20)
The alternative to Futurism—both the Latin “Futurism in literature and art” and the German “living Futurism”—is presented as Slavonic messianism:
And I believe that in Slavdom, in Russia, there is that freedom of spirit which can be opposed to the Futuristic war with its automized mechanical monsters. This different spirit must also be manifested in the different spirit of our army, in the predominance of spiritual factors over mechanical and automatic ones <…>. Slavdom must reveal to the world a higher type than the German, not because it is technically backward, less civilized, and clings to old foundations, but because it encompasses higher technical potential, which is oriented toward the future, not the past.(Berdyaev 2004, p. 20)
The formula “freedom of spirit,” opposed to the “Futuristic war with its automatic monsters,” is elaborated in the article The Spirit and Machine, with which Berdyaev pointedly crowned his book The Fate of Russia. With provocative, half-jesting irony, calling his position “spiritual Marxism,” the philosopher calls for not idealizing agrarian society and technical backwardness: “But to the enslaving power of advanced technology, one can oppose a high and free spirit, but one cannot oppose a backward and primitive level of technology. Material backwardness and low level are not the strength of the spirit” (Berdyaev 1990, p. 217).
D.S. Merezhkovsky (in his article Another Step of the Coming Ham, June 1914), proceeding from the idea that “Futurism is a slave’s song to the machine, the mistress of the world,” diagnosed a new apocalypse: “From God—to the Beast, from the Beast—to the Automaton, which is a soulless mechanism—such is the path of descent, begun by Futurism, but not foretold by it” (Merezhkovsky 2001, pp. 344–53).
In contrast, Berdyaev defines the machine as “the path of the spirit in the process of its liberation from materialism” (Berdyaev 1990, p. 216). The article The Spirit and Machine (and the entire collection The Fate of Russia) concludes with an optimistic prescription:
If Russia wants to be a great Empire and play a role in history, this imposes upon it the obligation to embark on the path of material technical development. Without this decision, Russia finds itself in a hopeless position. Only on this path will the spirit of Russia be liberated and its depth revealed.(Berdyaev 1990, p. 223)
The final paragraph of Futurism in the War, summarizing the article’s content, goes back to the aesthetic aspects of Futurism: “Behind the name ‘Futurism’ genuinely new quests in poetry and painting and the new, not yet fully manifested world-perceptions are concealed” (Berdyaev 2004, p. 21). Indeed, in his article Picasso (first published 1914; included in the 1918 book The Crisis of Art), Berdyaev analyzed the artistic avant-garde using approximately the same categories he applied to modern technology: “Painting is plunging into the depths of matter, and there, in the furthest layers, it no longer finds materialism. If one were to resort to theosophical terminology, one could say that painting is passing from physical bodies to etheric and astral bodies” (Berdyaev 1994, p. 421). The discussion of Futurism is thus projected onto an occult plane.
In the article Picasso—as in Futurism in the War—Berdyaev asserts that Futurist poetry proper “has so far produced nothing significant.” Here, however, he names the writer who has realized these new spiritual currents:
But here is Andrei Bely, whom I consider the most original, significant, and close-to-genius phenomenon in Russian literature—he may be called a Cubist in literature. In his novel Petersburg, one can discover the same process of stratification, of layering the cosmic life, as in a painting by Picasso.(Berdyaev 1994, p. 422)
Identifying Bely’s literary position with Futurism or Cubism naturally sparks debate. On the one hand, the similarity is undeniable (Spivak 2014, pp. 181–93). On the other hand, Bely distanced himself from Futurism. Quoting Merezhkovsky’s article (as Berdyaev did), he declared in his philosophical essay The Crisis of Life: “<…> Futurist manifestos on the destruction of art will turn into reality; the tomahawk of the ‘coming Ham’ threatens the Gioconda” (Bely 1918, p. 82). Yet Berdyaev is prepared to accept Andrei Bely as a Cubist writer, precisely because he does not glorify the “machine” but reveals the spiritual truth it symbolizes.
It is logical that Berdyaev’s article detailing the analysis of Petersburg (1916; included in The Crisis of Art) is declaratively titled “The Astral Novel.” It is also logical that in the summarizing article The Crisis of Art, specially written for the 1918 book and giving it its title, Berdyaev definitively assigns Bely not only to Cubism but also to Futurism:
All these whirlwinds are astral whirlwinds, not the whirlwinds of the physical world or the human-spiritual world. The Futurist world-perception and Futurist creativity of A. Bely differ radically from other Futurists in that they are connected in him with a greater spiritual knowledge, and with the contemplation of other planes of being.(Berdyaev 1994, p. 411)
Thus, analyzing Futurism (the avant-garde) against the background of the World War, Berdyaev interpreted it on three levels: cultural-philosophical, messianic, and occult (“astral”). Simultaneously, he testified that even before 1917, Futurism (the avant-garde) had been implied in the context of social crises and the scientific-technical revolution, and that within this context, Bely’s work could be perceived as truly “Futuristic.”
By 1923—after the revolution of 1917—Y.I. Zamyatin, in his article New Russian Prose, had already formulated the general directive as a manifesto:
But today, when exact science has blown up the very reality of matter, realism has no roots; it is the lot of old men and young old men. In exact science, analysis is increasingly being replaced by synthesis, microscopic tasks—<…> by tasks of space, time, and the universe. And, evidently, these new beacons stand before new literature: from daily life [“byt”] to existence [“bytie”], from physics to philosophy, and from analysis to synthesis.(Zamyatin 1999, p. 93)
***
Bely had touched upon the problem of the dangerous consequences of scientific development in his famous Symbolist article The Apocalypse in Russian Poetry (1905):
<…> inept specialization gives rise to a multitude of engineers and technicians with a mask of learning on their faces and the chaotic madness of unprincipledness in their hearts. The immoral application of science creates the horrors of the modern war with Japan—a war in which we see a symbol of the rising chaos <…>.(Bely 2012, p. 480)
The horrors of the First World War compelled Bely not merely to return to this theme but to delve into it seriously and develop it—first in the articles for Birzhevye Vedomosti in 1915–1916, then in the philosophical essay The Crisis of Life (Petrograd: Alkonost, 1918), and later in the novel Moscow.
Moscow is Bely’s central artistic work after 1917 and after his return to Soviet Russia (1923) (the two parts of the first volume—1926, the second volume—1932). From the point of view of the genre (and the language, which is not being considered in the present article) it is a provocatively experimental (i.e., truly avant-garde) novel, and at the heart of its plot are the antinomies of modern science.
In 1922, the ideologist Nikolai Bukharin formulated the official Party line for a loyal novel with an adventure plot. In response to this government order, a popular type of novel emerged (modeled on H.G. Wells), based on the struggle for possession of a discovery. Researchers identify two varieties: (1) the struggle for the discovery unfolds in the capitalist world (e.g., the 1928 story The Eternal Bread by the science fiction master Alexander Belyaev); (2) the struggle against capitalists involves Soviet people (e.g., Alexei Tolstoy’s 1925–1926 novel The Hyperboloid of Engineer Garin) (Dubin and Rejtblat 1988, pp. 33–39). Incidentally, Tolstoy’s novel The Hyperboloid of Engineer Garin, like Mikhail Bulgakov’s story The Heart of a Dog (1925 had not been published in the author’s lifetime), testifies to the writers’ awareness of the scientist’s responsibility for the catastrophic consequences of his discovery.
The novel Moscow is set in the past: it begins in 1913 and ends with the February Revolution. The protagonist of the novel is a Moscow mathematics professor, Ivan Ivanovich Korobkin, who makes a discovery with prospects for industrial (military) application. Here, Bely undoubtedly sought to respond to the Party and publisher’s directive yet he hardly reproduced existing Soviet models and, true to his habit, wanted to realize a concept that was personally important to him.
In the preface to Masks (the second volume of Moscow), Bely outlines the plot of the entire novel in the following way:
The eccentric absent-minded professor stumbles upon a discovery of enormous importance, lying in the sphere of mathematics which borders on theoretical mechanics; from a priori deductions follows the still abstract assumption that the discovery is applicable to technology and, in particular, to military affairs, opening the possibility for rays of such destructive force that no power can withstand them; of course, military agents of the “great” powers get wind of this; acting through the adventurist Mandro <…> they surround the professor with spies; Mandro <…> decides on an extreme measure: to wrest from the professor by force all papers relating to the discovery <…>.(Bely 1989a, p. 761)
For the mathematician Korobkin, the discovery initially had a purely theoretical character: “He was reviewing his integrals. In their multitude, the mathematical discovery had ripened, allowing application to the sphere of mechanics; even—who knows—this application might one day overturn all of science, changing the limit of speeds—to… to… the speed—damn it—of the ray of light” (Bely 1989a, p. 50). Professor Korobkin does not yet suspect that behind the rows of “new modules, differentials, and integrals” lies a “prophetic silence of formulas, ready to blast fragments of steamship and locomotive boilers, sink squadrons in the oceans, and hurl engines into the air, at the sight of which, of course, the chiefs of the general staffs of all countries would drop dead” (Bely 1989a, p. 51).
The simple-mindedness of the honest servant of science is contrasted in the novel with the representatives and agents of the “great” powers, primarily Germany. The first mention in the novel that Professor Korobkin has made a discovery with military applications, as well as that war is imminent, is delivered in German (Bely 1989a, p. 27). Subsequently, the “German interest” in the discovery is further emphasized. Mandro is joined by Solomon Samuilovich Kavalever, whose arrival “always signalled a certain meaning: dealings with foreign firms” (Bely 1989a, p. 89). In this instance, Kavalever has come from Berlin and “quickly launched into proving the idea that war is inevitable” (Bely 1989a, p. 67). He is informed about the fate of the sheet with calculations stolen from Korobkin and shown a “facsimile of the copy over which mathematicians in Berlin are now laboring” (Bely 1989a, p. 72). It is Berlin that organizes and finances the further surveillance of the professor, the goal of which is to obtain the discovery by any means necessary (Bely 1989a, p. 63).
Bely does not limit himself to hints of German espionage and Berlin money; he directly names those interested in attaining the discovery. They turn out to be not fictional characters but real historical figures. In a conversation between Kavalever and Mandro, their names are uttered: Rathenau, Krupp (Bely 1989a, p. 67).
Walther Rathenau, a well-known German industrialist and banker, later a political figure, became director in 1899 and chairman in 1915 of the German General Electric Company, the largest electrical engineering conglomerate. The part of Korobkin’s discovery related to creating a “ray of destructive force”, could fall within Rathenau’s sphere of activity: “One cannot give electricity to the masses <…>. The understanding of the ruling classes on this matter is… pathetic.” Professor Korobkin reflects on the sad fate of his own invention and the threat looming over him and, as he begins to suspect, over the world: “Just think: the possibility of utilizing electronic energy by the first, shall we say between ourselves, blockhead… <…> …does not guarantee us… <…> …from the explosion of worlds <…>” (Bely 1989a, pp. 270–71).
The name Krupp is even more significant. By the early 20th century, Friedrich Krupp AG had become a mighty empire, a world leader in arms production. A “mathematical discovery, admitting application to the sphere of mechanics” (most likely ballistics) naturally concerned the interests of this corporation most directly. In the years depicted by Bely, the chairman of the board of directors of the factories was Gustav Krupp von Bohlen und Halbach, the husband of Bertha Krupp, great-granddaughter of the founding producer Friedrich Krupp. It was presumably of him that Mandro and Kavalever were speaking.
The Krupp factories gained particular fame for their long-range artillery—unprecedented in destructive power, mounted on railway platforms, capable of hitting targets far beyond the line of sight. Built according to the latest scientific achievements and technologies, colossal in size and almost unimaginable in weight, Krupp’s guns formed the basis of German military strategy, and defined the new terrifying face of war, and caused universal shock.
The thunder of Krupp guns became an emblem of the First World War even for Andrei Bely, who spent 1914, 1915, and 1916 in neutral Switzerland. He did not see the war—he heard it. For Bely, the war sounded like the roar of cannon fire, coming from the German border to the tranquil Dornach, the peaceful Arlesheim, and the serene Basel.
A few days after the declaration of war—I remember, we had finished our work <…> and were descending from the construction site, listening to a strange phenomenon: thunder (short and muffled) without clouds; the sounds came from the direction of Alsace, where the distance seemed veiled in a light, dark haze; <…> now it turned out that, perhaps, the light dark haze on the horizon was gun smoke. This invasion of the sounds of war into our peaceful valley seemed like madness to me; until that moment, I had thought: “The war is somewhere far away.” But it had moved closer to us;—we all seemed to be engulfed by it.(Bely 2016, p. 180)
Thus, Bely’s very sensation of the war became associated with the cannonade breaking into peaceful life and the fear of coming under sudden bombardment:
It was said to be inevitable: <…> this entire area would be shelled by heavy artillery from Baden, at which point they indicated the chain of Baden Heights, located several kilometers away from us; and—they said: that entire ridge is full of cannons; not a trace will remain of Dornach and Arlesheim; everything will be swept away by the guns <…>.(Bely 2016, p. 178)
Building on his immediate impressions, Bely creates his own imagery and formulates his own concept of war. In The Crisis of Life, war for him is not battle scenes, not a clash of opposing forces, but the thunder of cannons, fraught with the shaking of the earth, the rattling of windows, cracks in facades, and, finally, the threat of an explosion:
My little window looks out onto the valley <…> in the bluish haze—the border; sometimes it seems as if the air parts there: especially before bad weather; and the dark ridges of Alsace become visible.It is from there that it flies:—“Roo-roo-rooo”…<…>This is how these guns have been speaking—for days, for months: the nineteenth month; here, in Switzerland, the guns are silent; but the silence here is ripped with a deafening, growing explosion; there will be explosions everywhere; and from the breast, like from a cannon’s muzzle, tearing away from its veins, like a bomb, the bloody, naked heart will explode….(Bely 1918, p. 14–15)
“‘Thundering silence’! For the nineteenth month it has been with me in the dead rustle of cities, in the dead run of clocks; morning, night, and day—everything thunders from the horizon” (Bely 1918, p. 7)—this is the beginning of the essay, not just setting a leitmotif but defining the main theme of the work, repeated many times and in various ways. The Crisis of Life “thunders” on almost every page, and the real, “autobiographical” cannon that so frightened Bely in Dornach becomes, under the artist’s pen, a cannon-symbol, a cannon-metaphor. In “cannon” terms, Bely speaks of the crisis of consciousness (“man <…> is like a cannon: he is loaded with crisis”—Bely 1918, p. 15) and the crisis of culture (“all culture is dangerously positioned; it is all under fire”—Bely 1918, p. 16).
And where there is a cannon, there is Krupp: “<…> they sit and fire forty-eight-inch suitcases (“The suitcases” were called artillery shells of a very powerful caliber.), starting from Leibniz and Descartes, which are recommended to Krupp…” (Bely 1918, pp. 57–58).
The Krupp dynasty had gained worldwide fame and deep dislike among Russians long before the First World War broke out. But it was the war that turned Krupp into a symbol of German aggression, German militarism, German might, and even planetary evil. In this capacity, Krupp appears, for example, in M. I. Tsvetaeva’s notebooks (Tsvetaeva 2001, p. 299), in V. V. Mayakovsky’s poem A Cloud in Trousers and V. Khlebnikov’s Ladomir.
We can encounter Krupp also in the memoirs of V.V. Shulgin, with the memoirist not forgetting to emphasize the role of science (“professors”) in developing war technology and in unleashing it:
And over Germany, the war cry—“Drang nach Osten”—sounded incessantly, and the dull blows of Krupp’s hammer resounded… And what was bound to happen, happened: German professors threw the German army against Russia.(Shulgin 1990, p. 375)
The thought of V. F. Ern progressed especially successfully in the search for a “philosophy of the cannon,” who proclaimed a thesis that shocked many: “From Kant to Krupp.” He delivered a speech with this title on 6 October 1914, at a meeting of the Moscow Religious-Philosophical Society. Ern declared:
I am convinced, firstly, that the turbulent uprising of Germanism was predetermined by Kant’s Analytic; I am convinced, secondly, that Krupp’s guns are full of the profoundest philosophy; I am convinced, thirdly, that the internal transcription of the German spirit in Kant’s philosophy lawfully and fatally converges with the external transcription of the very same German spirit in Krupp’s guns.(Ern 1991, pp. 308–9)
The speech caused a huge resonance and numerous responses in the press. The ensuing wave of disputes prompted Ern to return to the topic “Kant and Krupp” a second time and deliver another explanatory report, The Essence of German Phenomenology. In it, in a more delicate and nuanced tone, Ern proved his previous idea that “Kant, in the most characteristic and original moments of his philosophy, dialectically states Krupp. And Krupp, in the most brilliant creations of his, gives a material expression” of Kant’s philosophy (Ern 1991, p. 316).
The fact that “the philosophy faculty of the University of Bonn elected Krupp and the director of the Krupp plants of Ausenberg, as doctors honoris causa” (Ern 1991, p. 320) became for Ern further proof of the correctness of his “calculations” concerning Krupp.
Although Bely was in Dornach, far from Russia, at that time, Ern’s scandalous speech did not pass him by: it was soon published in the journal Russkaya Mysl (1914. No. 12). In a letter to Ivanov-Razumnik on March 3/16, 1915, Bely mentioned and condemned Ern, however, just like other Russian writers who played the patriotic and nationalist anti-German card: “<…> to read flashy reports like ‘from Kant to Krupp’ <…> seems to me now, in these serious days, an ‘idle pastime’” (Bely and Ivanov-Razumnik 1998, p. 51 and note).
Rejecting “idle pastimes,” Bely in The Crisis of Life contrasts the destructive “slaughter of nations” with the creative work that united anthroposophists of different nationalities in Dornach. The essay concludes with a hymn in praise of the Goetheanum and its builders:
Artists, musicians, writers, mystics, engineers, sculptors—from Munich, Amsterdam, Paris, Norway, Poland, Russia, and England—extended a brotherly hand to each other here before the terrible slaughter of nations; here, on the initiative of the well-known anthroposophist-writer Rudolf Steiner, an attempt arose: to lay the first stone for the realization in the future of a new spiritual culture of the arts <…>.The tip of the front thunders continuously; behind it, the front thunders continuously: all four hundred kilometers, perhaps, thunder incessantly; many fronts thunder; and Russia thunders in the east.I know distinctly that all new hundreds of thousands of people, like rye into threshers, will be thrown into the roaring, thundering strip; probably, I too will be thrown into it; I will leave here; but while I am here,—I will affirm humanity—in a new way: in an inhuman moment.(Bely 1918, pp. 115–6)
In The Crisis of Life, Bely entered into direct polemics with Ern: “We now curse Krupp. A public figure has been found with links to Krupp and with… the philosopher Kant” (Bely 1918, pp. 12–13). Bely did not name the “public figure,” but it is obvious. Literally repeating Ern’s question—“From Kant to Krupp… Why Kant? Why to Krupp? I begin with Kant as the greatest milestone in the manifestation of the German spirit” (Ern 1991, p. 308)—Bely in The Crisis of Life proposed an alternative answer, replacing one German philosopher with another, Kant with Leibniz: “But… why precisely Kant?… <…> Leibniz is the culprit of the present slaughter of nations…” (Bely 1918, p. 13).
Leibniz’s genius manifested itself in two spheres equally significant for Bely’s thought—philosophy and mathematics. To Leibniz—the preacher of the doctrine of teleological optimism and the theory of pre-established harmony—Bely opposed his own philosophy of “crisis.” He challenged Leibniz’s thesis about the existing world as the “best of all possible worlds” by pointing to the “mass extermination of people,” and the “worldwide slaughter.” In mathematics, Leibniz’s greatest scientific discovery was differential calculus, productively used in ballistics and therefore considered by Bely in direct connection with the thundering war, with Krupp’s cannons:
Differential calculus turned out to be applied… to the cannon: Leibniz, Newton, Descartes entered the service of the “solid” Krupp; the forty-eight-pound gun shouted to the scientists:
—Vivat!And in praise of science, it suddenly began to hurl “suitcases” over the towers of temples.(Bely 1918, p. 56)
Unlike the accuser of Kant—V. F. Ern—Bely does not place the full responsibility for creating war technology on Leibniz personally. Speaking of the scientist’s and philosopher’s guilt, Bely, on the contrary, points to the non-malicious intent of Leibniz’s research, including ballistic ones:
Two respectable sciences about the destruction of one’s own kind were brilliantly developed; and we did apply Leibniz’s selfless discovery (differential calculus) to war <…>. And had Leibniz known that in the best of worlds his discovery would lie in the future as the mass extermination of people, the most colossal slaughter of the world,– who knows: perhaps he would have burned his discovery.(Bely 1918, p. 12)
Bely searches for the origins of what happened in such an “attitude towards the phenomena of life,” formed long before Leibniz, in which “living ideals” turn into “a dotted line on paper, drawing in signs the laws… of ballistics.” Having established a connection between the character of modern humanity’s thinking and the nature of modern war, Bely naturally turns already in The Crisis of Life to the theme of science and the image of the scientist:
<…> in the theoretical conclusions of specialized branches of knowledge, we have before us not the world, but at best… a projective dotted line <…> scientific engineers depicted possible instruments of destruction as a projective dotted line; sciences about the destruction of one’s own kind arose <…>.(Bely 1918, pp. 11–12)
The scientist’s mathematical apparatus—Leibniz’s differential calculus—is considered by Bely as a kind of antithesis to “living ideals,” and the scientist himself, armed with Leibniz’s discovery, is turned by the writer into a sinister symbol of modern man in general:
The man of the twentieth century is a fleshless skeleton, swollen with fat; instead of knowledge and a heartfelt attitude towards life, he is dominated by two ways of assimilating life: with the help of the brain and with the help of the functions of the stomach; the first assimilation—“speckling on nothing” (i.e., the speckling of electrons over the abyss); and with the help of this “differential speckling” he lays out on paper little blueprints of cannons….(Bely 1918, p. 14)
This scientist, the heir of Leibniz, who so occupied the author of the essay The Crisis of Life, is turned into a character in the novel Moscow—Professor Korobkin. The postulated thesis about the connection between modern war and science and philosophy, i.e., the connection between “Krupp” and “Leibniz,” receives further development and figurative embodiment in Moscow.
***
In the novel Moscow, Professor Korobkin acts as a student and heir of Leibniz’s work and simultaneously as his peculiar double, a substitute.
Korobkin, like Leibniz, makes a great discovery in the field of differential calculus. Korobkin’s discovery, like Leibniz’s, turns out to be applicable to military engineering, i.e., in the words of the author of The Crisis of Life,—it can be put “into the service of the ‘solid’ Krupp”: agents of Krupp begin to prowl around Korobkin, striving by any means to obtain the professor’s drafts. Like Leibniz, Professor Korobkin is selfless in his scientific pursuits; he does not think about the possible deadly consequences of his purely scientific studies. Finally, Professor Korobkin in the novel attempts to do precisely what, in the opinion of the author of The Crisis of Life, Leibniz would undoubtedly have done if he had learned that his “selfless discovery” would “lead in the future to the most colossal slaughter of the world.” Leibniz, as Bely assumes, “would have burned his discovery.” The offer from the villain Mandro to sell the discovery, the blow from a carriage shaft that knocked the professor out of his set rhythm of life and made him think about many things—all this leads to Korobkin beginning to guess about what Leibniz had not suspected. The realization of the devastating impact of his own brilliant discovery pushes Korobkin towards making a difficult decision—a “Leibnizian” one:
It became clear to him that he had to put an end to the discovery; and he—would destroy it <…>. Sighing heavily, he decided to go to Moscow immediately, so once there, having examined the papers, to consign them to burning: to destroy the traces….(Bely 1989a, p. 323)
On the way to carrying out this decision, on the road to Moscow, Korobkin was captured by Mandro, in order to undergo all the torturing and severe trials prepared for him by the author of the novel.
It seems obvious to us that this very significant “segment” of the plot genetically goes back to The Crisis of Life: reflections on the fate of Leibniz’s discovery in the era of the First World War are inserted into a novel about wartime. With the exception that the brilliant mathematician Leibniz is replaced by another brilliant mathematician who made another brilliant discovery—Professor Korobkin.
As for Leibniz himself, in the novel he is for Korobkin a teacher who gave him in his youth both a philosophy and a mathematical apparatus for shielding himself against life, against its problems, complexities, and “incoherence” (Bely 1989a, p. 34). For the mature Korobkin, already a celebrated mathematician, Leibniz remains an idol, the highest authority, a teacher of life who avoids life: “<…> he delved into his perspectives, which he climbed with the help of Jacob’s ladder, <…> he integrated the world, agreeing with Leibniz: the world is the best” (Bely 1989a, p. 39).
Bely constantly emphasizes Leibniz’s presence in Korobkin’s world, and, moreover, presence in the literal sense of the word: a plaster bust of Leibniz, placed on a pedestal, adorns the professor’s wretched study:
The little study was small and had two windows <…>, two armchairs: one—by the window <…>; the other stood under a small column, where a bust of Leibniz evidently proved the fact that the world is the best….(Bely 1989a, pp. 21, 86)
Leibniz’s presence in the scene where Korobkin is tortured is especially significant and symbolic. Leibniz becomes an important witness to the committed crime, a “person” directly drawn into the action. People rushing to Korobkin’s aid follow the bloody trail into the study but find neither the victim nor the executioner there, only a scene of destruction and—the bust of Leibniz, which “showed white with its plaster curl; and on the plaster curl—a tiny blood spot” (Bely 1989a, p. 359). Leibniz was stained with the blood of his pupil and follower—the blood of Korobkin.
***
As is well-known, the prototype for Professor Korobkin in the novel Moscow was the writer’s father, the mathematician and philosopher Nikolai Vasilyevich Bugaev. Leibniz for Professor Bugaev was just as much a cult figure as for Professor Korobkin: in mathematics, Nikolai Vasilyevich conducted research in the field of function theory, and in philosophy he developed the ideas of Leibniz’s Monadology. This is described in detail in Bely’s memoirs (Bely 1989b, pp. 172, 188; 1990, p. 112).
Many parallels can be drawn between the biography of Professor Korobkin and the biography of Professor Bugaev, as told in the memoirs of his son. However, the memoir trilogy does not answer one essential question. This is the question of why the son allowed himself to place on the shoulders of his beloved father the burden of such a heavy scientific and moral responsibility for the First World War which entailed the “most colossal slaughter of the world.” After all, Professor Bugaev did not make a discovery capable of interesting “Krupp.” Moreover, Nikolai Vasilyevich Bugaev died in 1903; that is, ten years before his double Ivan Ivanovich Korobkin made his discovery in 1913. It seems that the explanation for this paradox is again found in The Crisis of Life, in a small passage about his father in his memoir. This is woven into the coherent pattern of the author’s reasoning about the causes of the thundering war:
<…> I will never forget: while still a schoolboy, I found on my father’s table two most respectable bricks, covered inside with hook-like signs of integrals and functions; these were two manuals; one was called: On External Ballistics (on the movement of a projectile outside the cannon barrel); the other was called: On Internal Ballistics. Two respectable sciences about the destruction of one’s own kind were brilliantly developed; and we did apply Leibniz’s selfless discovery (differential calculus) to war <…>.(Bely 1918, p. 12)
Thus, already in The Crisis of Life, not only the connection between “Leibniz,” i.e., pure science, and “Krupp’s cannons” is outlined, but also that in Moscow, the strong connection between “Krupp” and “Leibniz” would be not just some scientist-mathematician, but a character whose prototype is the writer’s father.
According to Bely’s concept, the war was the logical result of the flawed thinking of modern man; in it, the crisis of consciousness of people of the 20th century was extrapolated. In The Crisis of Life, the vices of modern humanity’s consciousness are fully embodied in the academic circles. For instance, in Moscow, all the sins of the academics are concentrated in one character, Korobkin: he represents modern man in general, and the war accordingly becomes an extrapolation of Korobkin’s inner world. Thus, the threat of war grows, approaches, as Korobkin progresses in his research. The worship of Leibniz and the desire to escape following Leibniz from incoherence lead to tragedy for both the hero and the world. Therefore, simultaneously, both the threat of war and the threat of an attack on Korobkin by Mandro are realized.
At the same time, Bely shows in the novel how Korobkin’s consciousness goes through a crisis and changes. A symptom of the occurred “break” is the change in attitude towards the former unconditional authority and idol—Leibniz. “Leibniz’s calculus has been eaten by the engineer!”, Korobkin (who ends up in a psychiatric hospital after torture) keeps repeating this phrase (Bely 1989a, p. 473). This barely coherent muttering of a scientist who has not yet recovered from his illness is identical in meaning to the reasoning of the author of The Crisis of Life. That is, we did apply “Leibniz’s discovery <…> to war; in other words, the method to kill one’s neighbors was developed by mathematicians, engineers, mechanics and technicians of the most cultured and civilized countries <…>” (Bely 1918, p. 12).
From being an object of criticism and polemics, Korobkin gradually turns into a mouthpiece for Bely’s ideas. “<…> hundreds of thousands of the killed were killed even before birth: they were destined to be killed.” Such is the opinion of the author of The Crisis of Life, the reverse side to the development of modern science. Korobkin gains a similar insight:
It became visible;——he,——over the table calculates some “psi,” threatening cities, locomotive boilers, armored squadrons; he calculated it through: the possibility of destruction was realized,—of boilers, cities, armored squadrons.Well, and—he?He good-naturedly scratched his back <…> paced about, rubbing his palms:—So, my dear sir,—so: a complete takeover of the entire military affair!—Was it said? Itwas.——So, he was a murderer not of cities, locomotive boilers, armored squadrons—but of human beings.He sat down with his legs crossed, grabbed with two fingers a dyed tuft of his beard, chuckled quietly into his moustache over——children, over those not yet born, but doomed over a series of centuries to be torn apart by the action of “psi”:——the year thirteen: autumn!(Bely 1989a, p. 625)
Korobkin’s transition from the positions of Bugaev the father to the positions of Bugaev the son is connected with the further course of Moscow. On the plot level, Professor Korobkin realizes the danger of his scientific constructions, he undergoes torment, but he does not hand over the discovery either to foreign spies or, later, to the revolutionary Bolsheviks. On the spiritual level, Korobkin overcomes his life crisis, which extends his consciousness, and he acquires new truths. The professor’s life path turns out to be a kind of illustration of Bely’s thoughts about possible ways out of the historical impasse into which humanity has fallen.
***
Bely conceptualized the problem of science and technology also in his theoretical opus magnum of the Soviet period—The History of the Formation of the Self-Conscious Soul. The History, which was created simultaneously with Moscow from the end of 1925 to 1931 (it remained unfinished), is a two-volume work dedicated to the development of culture from Christ to the 20th century, “our epoch.” However, The History of the Formation of the Self-Conscious Soul is not merely a scholarly treatise: its genre is undefined and synthetic. Within its genre, this work has just as a radically experimental (avant-garde) character as the novel Moscow. It is enough to note that Bely consistently used in the History a methodology and conceptual framework arising from Steiner’s anthroposophy. However, he did not comment on them in any way in the text of the tract. This specific technique not only excluded the possibility of publishing the History in the USSR but also demonstratively complicated its understanding.
Simplifying and schematizing, the ideological basis of the tract can be reconstructed as follows: the development of culture realizes the so-called “historical curve.” Namely, humanity—like an individual person—in its spiritual development passes through stages corresponding to the parts of the “I” (as interpreted by anthroposophy). Progressive development assumes that from Ancient Greece to the era of scholasticism, the Intellectual Soul dominated; within its depths, the Self-Conscious Soul was formed and reached its peak in the 15th century (the Renaissance)—the highest form accessible to the “ensouled man”. Then an ascent into the realm of spirit should follow, but first, humanity must descend, “transfiguring”—in reverse order—the Intellectual Soul, the Sentient Soul, and even the Astral Body. Only the transformation of the Astral Body will open the possibility for a breakthrough into the realm of spirit. The descending movement covers the period from the Renaissance to the 20th century. Moreover, each stage of descent, on the one hand, removes humanity from the pinnacle point of the Renaissance, and on the other hand, humanity now retains the cultural memory of the achievements of the Self-Conscious Soul and approaches the realm of spirit (see also: Spivak and Odesskiy 2024).
Accordingly, the place of science in the “History” falls precisely on the descending segment of the “curve”: it signifies the immersion of the Self-Conscious Soul into the realm of the Intellectual Soul. In the second volume of the tract (chapter The 16th and 17th Centuries), Bely finds an effective symbol for this transformation:
The symbol of this descent is the intersection of the death of the great Michelangelo with the moment of Galileo’s appearance in the world; from that time—the refinement of compositional tasks, naturally leading, as it were, from painting to astrophysics, or the scientific composition of the world; after the era of fulfilling magnificent artistic tasks. So a new era sets in: the fulfillment of magnificent compositional-scientific tasks; the flowering of astronomy.(Bely 2020a, vol. 2, p. 41)
As humanity spiritually descends, the time of astronomy passes and science poses ever new fundamental questions to humanity. Each time, the author strives to prove that the materialistic interpretation of new discoveries and theories is naive and incomplete, and that in reality, science reveals deep conflicts inherent in spiritual development. This applies both to mathematics (chapters Sociology and Mathematics and The Self-Conscious Soul as Composition), where Bely relies on the ideas of N. V. Bugaev (Szilard 2011, pp. 137–57), and biology. In this case, the writer actualized Goethe’s natural science views in their anthroposophical interpretation (chapter Biological Transformism in Transformism; see also: Goethe 2014–2023).
For example, in the aforementioned chapter The Self-Conscious Soul as Composition, the author of the History postulates a specific sense of “composition” as an attribute of the Self-Conscious Soul, which remains effective after descending into the lower spheres. Then Bely illustrates his thesis by analyzing D. I. Mendeleev’s periodic table from the point of view of “composition” (Bely 2020a, vol. 2, pp. 270–73), which, incidentally, echoes his memories of studying at the Natural Sciences department of the Faculty of Physics and Mathematics at Moscow University and his chemistry studies with the outstanding scientist N. D. Zelinsky (Bely 1989b, p. 405).
In the same chapter, “composition” is also coupled with hydrodynamics:
Physics, or the science of material quantities (in a very banal, partly already outdated aspect) through the application of mathematical mechanics to it is already permeable to new concepts, deposited by mathematical logic; and composition has already found application in it. In other words, the relativity of time, the multiplicity of times in mathematical composition is the correlation of certain kinds of axial system, or—coordinates, opening up for us the possibility of transitioning from one system to another; a system of fluid axes appeared instead of a system of fixed axes; so,—one physicist told me that the system of fluid axes is more conveniently applicable to hydrodynamics than to statics <…>.(Bely 2020a, vol. 2, p. 266)
“One physicist” is Professor Mikhail Andreevich Velikanov, who headed the Hydrological Station in Kuchino (near Moscow) and on whose invitation Bely himself moved to Kuchino in 1925. In a letter to a close friend on 19 February 1927, Bely related the content of these conversations with Velikanov: “And M. A. Velikanov told me long ago that the laws of fluids must be studied using a system of fluid axes, otherwise nothing will come of hydrodynamics, because fixed axes are for ‘solid bodies’ and for Newton’s law of gravity <…>” (Bely and Ivanov-Razumnik 1998, p. 452).
In summary: in The History of the Formation of the Self-Conscious Soul, science is an important expression of culture, but by no means the highest. Moreover, science is not self-validating: its significance is determined by when and how it contributes to the understanding of the general—essentially spiritual—laws of the universe. With such an understanding of science, it is not surprising that in the History, which included extraordinary surveys of various facts of cultural history, there are nevertheless practically no mentions of discoveries that contributed to technological progress.
***
It might seem that in the texts of the early 1930s—when the axiomatics of grand technical achievements had been established in the USSR—the writer was obliged to adjust his approach to science. But it turns out that he did not so much adjust as superficially adapt.
In 1933, Bely published a panegyric review (journal Novy Mir, No. 4) of the Soviet classic Fyodor Gladkov’s “industrial novel” Energy (book 1, separate edition—1933). The symbolist Bely and the proletarian writer Gladkov are polar opposites, and such a review, at first glance, was dictated only by tactical considerations. For in the situation of the early 1930s, Bely saw Gladkov as a literary ally and patron. However—despite undeniable differences—Energy remotely (!) resembles Moscow: Bely deals with the technical application of a scientific discovery, while Gladkov is concerned with industrialization (which also implied the creation of the spiritually New Socialist man); while Bely features international spies, Gladkov—“wreckers” (as intellectuals were constantly accused of being at that time). Moreover, Gladkov’s novel is characterized (certainly not on the artistic level and scale of Bely’s talent) by a unique combination of techniques of Soviet literature and linguistic experiment. It is logical that in the famous article On Prose, published in the almanac Year Sixteen, A. M. Gorky aggressively rejected both Moscow and Energy for what he considered a meaningless play with language (Gorky 1933, pp. 428–50).
In his review, Bely, in particular, reflects on the significance of technology in socialist construction:
<…> a machine, transported from the West to us, without investing new content into it, is only a dangerous sprout of the capitalist grip on socialist construction, capable of mechanizing life; its mechanization in the West being a consequence of its enslavement by capital, <…> abstract idealism and the retreat of soulless mechanism from the problem of rhythmitization, which affects the pace of work <…>.(Bely 2020b, p. 799)
These reflections were preceded by an exchange of opinions in the correspondence between the two writers, and the opinions turned out to be in agreement. Gladkov wrote:
Machines, the more complex they are, the more humanized they are. In every machine there is the embodiment of the psyche and the most magnificent crystal of artistic imagination. Now man perceives the world—from nature to the electric light bulb (its production is very complex and beautiful)—only in struggle. Not a state, but a transformation, becoming.(Bely and Gladkov 1988, p. 757)
Bely replied:
By the way, regarding your words about machines: it seems to me that the myth about machines <…> exhausted itself in the myths about gnomes, sylphs, undines, and salamanders; the energy of the electric discharge, the mastery of it,—all this forced man to create “myths” about the Salamander; we are now acquainted with these “salamanders” (is this not the question raised by Energy in the thesis: to humanize the machine).(Bely and Gladkov 1988, pp. 760–61)
As one can easily see, Bely in the review of Gladkov’s novel, on the one hand, resorts to official discourse: under capitalism, the machine is a dangerous “mechanization,” while under socialism, it is a condition for the necessary “pace of work.” On the other hand, he continues his previous criticism of the self-validating cult of technology—“soulless mechanization.”
A kind of continuation of the review of Energy can be considered Bely’s last artistic concept, which is believed to be an “industrial novel” about Georgia: the concept was not realized in any way, but, according to A. V. Lavrov’s hypothesis, the depiction of socialist construction there which would have encoded the construction of the anthroposophical center in Switzerland (the Goetheanum), in which Bely himself had once participated (Lavrov 2007, pp. 298–305).
Even more responsible than the review in Novy Mir was Bely’s speech at the plenum of the Organizational Committee of the Union of Soviet Writers, which was just forming at that time (it was printed in the official Literaturnaya Gazeta, 11 November 1932). According to the testimony of Literaturnaya Gazeta, fellow writers reacted with applause to the orator’s emotional declaration:
What evokes enthusiasm in me? The fact that the party’s appeal to me as well resonances with my workbench. If this is so, I must convey to the state in all the features of its fine structure; I must fight to ensure that my workbench is in good order, because a damaged workbench is wrecking society, even if unconsciously.(Bely 2020b, p. 762)
As in the review of Gladkov’s novel, Bely, on the one hand, uses Soviet ideologemes—“wrecking” and “workbench”—reflecting the ideals of socialist construction. On the other hand, by avant-gardely equating the writer’s labor with a “workbench,” Bely was defending his right to creativity, which he hoped to realize freely under any political conditions.
***
For the spiritual situation at the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries, it is legitimate to speak of an aspiration towards a new man, which was conditioned by a grand revolution that had various dimensions, including scientific-technological and artistic. From this point of view, it is advisable to single out two models of experimental art’s relation to science: according to the first model, in the creation of the new man, art helps science and technology, to which the main role is assigned (Futurism). According to the second model, art opposes science and technology, the development of which threatens the individual and all of humanity. Bely, who dreamed of a “humanized” machine, is closer to the second model, but with an important reservation. The son of a dean-mathematician and a natural science student, Bely, who (according to the words of a contemporary) had a “vision of an artist who predetermined the development of science” (Spivak 2010, p. 442), did not deny the significance of science, but he considered true science to be a science based on its anthroposophical interpretation. In other words, he placed spiritual development—and thereby art—above science. This allows us to assert that Andrei Bely’s system was characterized by that type of interference of scientific reflection into the avant-garde art which Renato Poggioli—avoiding nuances—designated as “general dynamism” (Poggioli 1968, p. 139).
Strikingly, Bely used the same term. On 25th December 1926 in his letter to V. Meyerhold he supported the avant-garde production of the comedy “Revisor” and put forward the general thesis: “<…> the task of art is dynamazing” (Bely 2001, p. 137). Commenting on this statement A. V. Lavrov and John E. Malmstad specified that the characteristic quality of Bely’s art is “the changing and impermanent world”, which appears incompatible with the stable “constructive beginning” and it accordingly determines the “unstable artistic substance” of the texts (in our case, the majority of all the experiments with genres) (Bely 2010, pp. 13–14). A similar opinion of a contemporary was quoted earlier: “The Futurist world-perception and the Futurist creativity of A. Bely <…> are connected in him with a greater spiritual knowledge, and with the contemplation of the other planes of being” (Berdyaev 1994, p. 411). Therefore, when Bely reacts to the grandiose problem of the new man, the consideration of which conditioned the whole modernist epoch, he, without being a participant of literary Futurism, obviously clings to the avant-garde poetics.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, M.O. and M.S.; methodology, M.O. and M.S.; investigation, M.O. and M.S.; writing—original draft preparation, M.O. and M.S.; writing—review and editing, M.O. and M.S. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
This research received no external funding.
Institutional Review Board Statement
Not applicable.
Informed Consent Statement
Not applicable.
Data Availability Statement
No new data were created or analyzed in this study. Data sharing is not applicable to this article.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
- Bely, Andrei. 1918. On the Pass. I. The Crisis of Life. Saint Petersburg: Alkonost. [Google Scholar]
- Bely, Andrei. 1989a. Moscow. Foreword, Text Preparation, Commentary and Edited by Svetlana Timina. Moscow: Sovetskaya Rossija. [Google Scholar]
- Bely, Andrei. 1989b. On the Border of the Two Centuries. Foreword, Text Preparation, Commentary and Ed. by Alexander Lavrov. Moscow: Khudozhestvennaja Literatura. [Google Scholar]
- Bely, Andrei. 1990. The Beginning of the Century. Edited, Preparation of the Text and Commentary by Alexander Lavrov. Moscow: Khudozhestvennaja Literatura. [Google Scholar]
- Bely, Andrei. 2001. From the Correspondence of A. Bely: Letters to V. Meyerhold and Z. Raikh. Foreword, Commentary and Edited by John Malmstad. Novoje Literaturnoje Obozrenije 51: 132–58. [Google Scholar]
- Bely, Andrei. 2010. Petersburg: A Historical Drama. Foreword by Alexander V. Lavrov and John Malmstad. Moscow: Progress-Pleiada. [Google Scholar]
- Bely, Andrei. 2012. Collection of Works. Arabesques. A Book of Articles. The Green Grassland. A Book of Articles. Edited, Afterword and Commentary by Larisa Sugai. Moscow: Respublica, Dmitrii Sechin. [Google Scholar]
- Bely, Andrei. 2016. Materials for a Biography. In Autobiographical Vaults: Materials for a Biography. A Diary Perspective. Registration Records. Diaries 1930s. Text Prepared by Alexander V. Lavrov, John Malmstad and Tatyana V. Pavlova, Commentary by Alexander V. Lavrov and John Malmstad. Literaturnoe nasledstvo. Moscow: IMLI RAN, vol. 105, pp. 29–328. [Google Scholar]
- Bely, Andrei. 2020a. Collection of Works. Vol. 17. The Uncollected. Book 2. Compiled by Alexander Lavrov and John Malmstad. Moscow: Dmitrii Sechin. [Google Scholar]
- Bely, Andrei. 2020b. The History of the Formation of the Self-Conscious Soul. Vol. 1–2. Preparation of the Text and Commentary by Mikhail Odesskiy, Monika Spivak and Henrieke Stahl. Literaturnoe Nasledstvo. Moscow: IMLI RAN, vol. 112. [Google Scholar]
- Bely, Andrei, and Fyodor Gladkov. 1988. Correspondence. Published of Svetlana V. Gladkova. In Andrei Bely: The Problems of Creative Writing. Moscow: Sovetskij Pisatel, pp. 753–72. [Google Scholar]
- Bely, Andrei, and Ivanov-Razumnik. 1998. Correspondence. Published, Foreword and Commentary by Alexander V. Lavrov and John Malmstad. St. Petersburg: Atheneum: Fenix. [Google Scholar]
- Berdyaev, Nikolay A. 1990. The Fate of Russia. Moscow: Sovetskij Pisatel. [Google Scholar]
- Berdyaev, Nikolay A. 1994. The Philosophy of Creativity, Culture, and Art. Moscow: Iskusstvo, vol. 2. [Google Scholar]
- Berdyaev, Nikolay A. 2004. Futurism at War: Journalism from the Time of the First World War. Moscow: Kanon+. [Google Scholar]
- Berdyaev, Nikolay A. 2016. The Fate of Russia. Translated by Fr. S. Janos. Mohrsville: Frsj Publications. [Google Scholar]
- Dubin, Boris V., and Abram I. Rejtblat. 1988. Social Imagination in Soviet Science Fiction of the 1920s. In Socio-Cultural Utopias of the 20th Century. Issue 8. Moscow: Institute for Scientific Information in the Social Sciences, pp. 14–48. [Google Scholar]
- Ern, Vladimir F. 1991. Works. Compiled, Text Preparation by Nikolay V. Kotrelev and Elena V. Antonova. Moscow: Pravda. [Google Scholar]
- Goethe, Johann Wolfgang. 2014–2023. Scientific Works. Compiled and Annotated by Sergey V. Kazachkov. Moscow: KMK, vols. 1–3.
- Gorky, Maxim. 1933. On Prose. In The Year Sixteeth. Almanach. Issue 1. Moscow: Sovetskaja literatura, pp. 428–50. [Google Scholar]
- Krusanov, Alexander V. 2010. The Russian Avant-Garde: 1907–1932 (A Historical Survey), 3 vols. Moscow: Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie, vol. 1, Book 2. [Google Scholar]
- Lavrov, Alexander V. 2007. Andrei Bely: Research and Essays. Moscow: Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie. [Google Scholar]
- Merezhkovsky, Dmitrii S. 2001. What Was and Will Be: A Diary. 1910–1914; A Non-Military Diary. 1914–1916. Moscow: Agraf. [Google Scholar]
- Poggioli, Renato. 1968. Theory of the Avant-Garde. Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Shulgin, Vladimir V. 1990. Years. Days. 1920. Moscow: Novosti. [Google Scholar]
- Spivak, Monika L. 2010. “Send the Brain to the Address…”: Vladimir Lenin, Vladimir Mayakovsky, Andrei Bely, Eduard Bagritsky in the Collection of the Moscow Institute of the Brain. Moscow: Astrel, CORPUS. [Google Scholar]
- Spivak, Monika L. 2014. Andrei Bely in 1913: In Search of an Alternative to the Word. In 1913: “The Word as Such”: For the Anniversary Year of Russian Futurism. Compiled by Jean-Philipp Jacqard and Annick Morard. Saint Petersburg: Izdatelstvo Evropejskogo Universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge, pp. 181–93. [Google Scholar]
- Spivak, Monika L., and Mikhail Odesskiy. 2024. “Only in The History of the Formation of the Self-Conscious Soul Did Bugaev Reveal His Ideas about Music”: Music in the System of Andrei Bely. Arts 13: 74. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Szilard, Lena. 2011. “New Mathematics” and the “Philosophy of Mathematics” in The History of the Formation of the Self-Conscious Soul: Aspects of Arithmology and Combinatorics. Russian Literature LXX–I/II: 137–57. [Google Scholar]
- Tsvetaeva, Marina I. 2001. Unpublished: Notebooks. 2 vols. Compiled, text preparation, and notes by Elena B. Korkina and Marina G. Krutikova. Moscow: Ellis Lak, vol. 2. [Google Scholar]
- Zamyatin, Evgeny I. 1999. I Am Afraid: Literary Criticism. Journalism. Memoirs. Compiled and annotated by Alexander Galushkin. Moscow: Nasledie. [Google Scholar]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.