Skip to Content
GenealogyGenealogy
  • Article
  • Open Access

12 August 2026

16 Pages

Who Supports Transracial Adult Adoptees Through Consciousness? A Secondary Analysis Study

,
,
,
and
1
Department of Counseling, Palo Alto University, Palo Alto, CA 94304, USA
2
School of Social Work and Criminal Justice, University of Washington Tacoma, Tacoma, WA 98402, USA
3
Crown School of Social Work, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 90637, USA
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.

Abstract

This study is a secondary analysis of qualitative research that explored how transracial adoptees experience consciousness using the adoptee consciousness model. The original study involved focus groups in which 23 United States-based, adult transracial adoptee participants discussed their lived experiences of adoptee consciousness. Those focus group transcripts were transcribed, de-identified, and coded by the original research team. The secondary analysis research questions are (1) Who supports transracial adoptees during adoptee consciousness? and (2) How do they support transracial adoptees in the consciousness process? The secondary analysis methodology applied Thematic Analysis to identify patterns and themes from the original dataset transcriptions. Findings shed light on how participants in the study experienced support and/or lack of support. The findings offer guidance on how families, friends, and mental health professionals can provide meaningful support to transracial adoptees as they move through awareness of their understanding of adoption and their identities.

1. Introduction

The Adoptee Consciousness Model ([ACM], Branco et al. 2023) describes a process by which adoptees develop awareness of individual and systems influences that impact their lived experience. In the past several decades, as more information becomes widely known about illicit and questionable adoption practices such as birth mother coercion, child trafficking, and abuse of process (Brown and Roby 2016), adult adoptee activism has propelled global inquiry to examine past and current practices (de Vries et al. 2025; Intercountry Adoptee Voices n.d.). While questionable and illegal adoption practices impact the systemic context, adult adoptees also face individual consequences, including missing birth family information (Tieman et al. 2008), increased mental health and substance abuse concerns (Corral et al. 2021), adoption-related trauma (Brodzinsky et al. 2022), and adoption-based stigma and microaggressions (Baden 2016; Grigoropoulos 2022). Transracial adoptees also cite a lack of cultural socialization (Arnold et al. 2016), which leads to unpreparedness to navigate racism and racial microaggressions (Arnold et al. 2016). Individual and collective adult adoptee experiences paved the way for the creation of the ACM. Consequently, the ACM is widely well received by adult adoptee populations, as evidenced by the model’s inclusion in an array of academic and arts-driven endeavors (https://adopteeconsciousness.com).
In this article, we describe commonalities in transracial adoptee experiences, outline mental health needs, offer what is known about current adoptee support and activism mechanisms, and share the ACM and focus group research to corroborate the model. We present the rationale for the secondary analysis to discover who supports transracial adoptees through consciousness and how they support them, and we share the findings from the secondary analysis. We then provide implications for transracial adoptee family members, friends, and mental health providers.

1.1. Transracial Adoptee Experiences

Transracial adoptees are often situated within the liminal space of access to and acceptance by White majority families and communities, offering “honorary” White privilege status (Baden et al. 2012). However, lack of cultural socialization and eventual independence from White adoptive families can create a “paradox” of sorts (Lee 2003), where transracial adoptees are addressed by the larger community as members of their heritage groups, leaving many transracial adoptees feeling unprepared and unsupported. When transracial adoptees attempt to make sense of these paradoxical experiences, they may be met with “hermeneutical smothering”, a term Samuels (2022) applies to describe the dismissal or discrediting of transracial adoptee narrative experiences. Such experiences contribute to internal and external conflict for transracial adoptees that may influence mental health wellness.

1.2. Mental Health Needs

A meta-analysis on adult adoptee mental health found that adoptee populations experience higher rates of psychological maladjustment, particularly in the areas of anger, depression, and anxiety (Corral et al. 2021). Another emergent contributor to poor mental health outcomes includes general pre- and post-adoption malpractices (O’Driscoll et al. 2024). Adoption malpractices can include an array of illicit practices, including birth family coercion (Brown and Roby 2016), falsified adoption documentation (O’Driscoll et al. 2024), and adoptive family suppression of access to adoption documentation (Branco and Cloonan 2022). The structural barriers to adoptee origins and access to accurate records violate their human right to identity and contribute to significant challenges for identity integration and, consequently, mental health outcomes (Branco and Cloonan 2022; O’Driscoll et al. 2024).

1.3. Adoptee Support and Activism

In response to structural adoption-related oppression, many transracial adoptees collectively unite to advocate for their human rights and provide peer communal support (Cherot 2006; Harris 2014; Huggins and Flynn 2025). Collective adult transracial and transnational adult adoptee groups have also collaborated with legal teams, human rights advocates, and journalists to challenge the dominant adoption discourse and enact policy change (Hübinette 2024). Their work has successfully led to several European countries pursuing both domestic and international investigations on illicit transnational adoption practices (Denéchère and Macedo 2023; Dutch Government 2021; Norwegian Government 2025; Ramsauer et al. 2023; Swedish Foundation for Human Rights and Plan Ángel Foundation 2022).

2. Adoptee Consciousness Model

The ACM is a cyclical, rather than linear, process that adoptees may revisit throughout their lifespan. Inspired by prominent Latin American scholar consciousness models, including Freire and Martín-Baro, the ACM was templated to Anzaldúa’s “conociemiento” (knowledge) model of coming to consciousness. The ACM describes five touchstones depicting varied awareness experiences: (1) Status Quo (2) Rupture, (3) Dissonance, (4) Expansion, and (5) Agency (previously described as Activism and Forgiveness). Status quo describes an unexamined, questioned, or explored adoption experience and/or acceptance of the dominant societal adoption narrative. Whereas the rupture touchstone reflects new information that alters a previously held adoption-related belief. Dissonance depicts the attempts to make sense of newly discovered adoption-related information, while Expansion represents actions undertaken to integrate the information into one’s identity. Agency represents a variety of outward- or inward-facing experiences such as individual and/or collective activism for social change and/or forgiveness towards societal, individual, or collective harms.

3. Materials and Methods

The data for the secondary analysis for this research were extracted from an original study, entitled Exploring Transracial Adoptees’ Experiences of Developing Adoptee Consciousness, of which the first author was a co-investigator. In the original research, the co-investigators conducted three focus groups with 23 adult transracial adoptees to learn about their experiences of developing consciousness. Please see Table 1 for a description of the original study participants. We applied a directed qualitative content analysis methodology to deductively code participant responses using the ACM (Branco et al. 2023) as our coding scheme. Next, we utilized inductive consensus coding to organize those codes that fell outside our initial coding framework. An emergent theme of the initial research revealed information about who and how adoptees in the study experienced support or obstruction in their consciousness process. As the theme fell outside the scope of our original research, we conducted a secondary analysis with new research questions, namely, “(1) Who supports transracial adoptees during adoptee consciousness? and (2) How do they support transracial adoptees in the consciousness process?
Table 1. Transracial adoptee participant demographics.
The secondary analysis research team included the first author, a licensed professional counselor, associate professor, a co-investigator of the original ACM research, and transracial adoptee; second author, a doctoral student in counselor education and supervision completing a research internship and second-generation Filipina-American-identifying non-adoptee; third author, a master’s level clinical mental health counseling student, skilled in qualitative research methods, with Soviet heritage, and non-adoptee; fourth author, lead investigator of the original ACM research and transracial adoptee; and the fifth author, a co-investigator of the original ACM research and transracial adoptee.
The first three authors applied Thematic Analysis (Braun and Clarke 2006, 2019) to identify the themes and subthemes. Specifically, we immersed ourselves in the original participant data and individually recorded participant excerpts to identify who did or did not offer support and how support was or was not provided. We then moved to interrater consensus for all coded segments. Next, we identified those entities (who or what) that offered support or lack thereof (Table 2). From there, we grouped codes into themes and subthemes, with multiple rounds of theme refinement until we again reached consensus. In addition, we completed descriptive statistics to analyze the entities, or the “who”, participants considered supportive or unsupportive (Table 1). Appendix A and Appendix B provide the frequency and distribution of supportive and unsupportive entities, respectively.
Table 2. Comparative distribution of supportive and unsupportive “who” by category.

3.1. Trustworthiness

We utilized multiple trustworthiness strategies throughout the research process. To maintain credibility, the first and second authors completed research memos and weekly peer debriefing. Dependability was established via an ongoing audit trail documenting our weekly research progress and a Google Sheet codebook that housed initial and consensus coding and theme organization. We also completed reflexive positionality statements to acknowledge our varied identities for confirmability purposes.

3.2. Limitations

The benefits of secondary analysis research include the opportunity to examine additional research questions, efficiency in data collection, and decreased burden on research participants (Chatfield 2020). Secondary analysis research limitations include the inability to re-interview or use member checking with the original participant sample (Ruggiano and Perry 2019). Despite these limitations, we followed best practice secondary analysis research guidelines by (1) outlining the researcher roles as they relate to the original study, if applicable; (2) describing the original ACM research study; (3) obtaining Institutional Review Board exemption status; (4) utilizing uncoded data from the original research; and (5) collaborating with two co-investigators who were not part of the original research (Ruggiano and Perry 2019).

4. Results

4.1. Quantitative Analysis Findings

We analyzed the “who” mentioned across participant interviews for supportive dynamics. We found that 17 participants identified 45 unique entities or “who”, led by adoptive family at 40% (n = 18), friends at 24% (n = 11), and the broader community at 18% (n = 8). Conversely, when mapping systemic gaps and negative experiences, 19 participants identified 49 unsupportive entities or “who”. This unsupportive group was overwhelmingly dominated by adoptive family at 55% (n = 27), followed by community at 16% (n = 8), and friends at 14% (n = 7). Across both datasets, minor mentions (≤9%) were distributed among self-reliance, mental health professionals, partners/chosen family, and birth family.
A comparative synthesis of these categories (Table 2) reveals a duality, particularly within the adoptive family system. Although the immediate family serves as the cohort’s largest single group of positive support (40%), it simultaneously constitutes most of the negative experiences (55%), proving to be a volatile environment leaning toward distress. Conversely, friends emerged as a consistently reliable group, yielding nearly double the rate of supportive mentions (24%) compared with unsupportive ones (14%). Meanwhile, the broader community layer was evenly split, with a neutral position (18% supportive versus 16% unsupportive), indicating highly variable environments where validation and isolation are equally possible. Ultimately, while peer friendships offer the safest interpersonal space, immediate adoptive families retain the greatest overall systemic impact on participant well-being. More detailed information on the frequency and distribution of supportive and unsupportive entities can be found in Appendix A and Appendix B, respectively.

4.2. Qualitative Analysis Findings

  • Supportive
In analyzing the “how” mentioned across participant responses, four themes emerged in describing how adoptees felt positively supported in developing their own adoptee consciousness: (1) non-adoptee allyship, (2) lateral validation, (3) embodied safety, and (4) reliable foundation. Participants reflected on and discussed a range of relational, communal, and somatic experiences that affirmed their identities as adoptees. The sources of support were both extrinsic and intrinsic, creating space for adoptees to both deepen their understanding of themselves and, at times, find healing. These sources of support discussed by participants included individuals who were not adoptees themselves but who were open and willing to learn about the adoptee experience, individuals who were adoptees themselves and had a mutual understanding of the adoptee experience that did not require explanation, body-centered practices that allowed participants to process their experiences as adoptees, and the consistent provision of having basic needs met, providing space for adoptee consciousness to form.

4.2.1. Non-Adoptee Allyship

This theme yielded eight examples and signifies how participants felt supported by individuals from outside the adoptee community, including family members, colleagues, friends, and sometimes mental health therapists, who were willing to listen, learn, and hold space for the adoptee’s experiences. Non-adoptee allyship indicates, for adoptees, a sense of being seen by others who do not share the same lived experience but are open to learning, make an effort to understand, or simply hold space.
Participants’ friends who were non-adoptees themselves were noted as providing a unique source of support, mainly because these friends were far removed from the complexity of familial ties that can exist.
But really where I got the biggest support is from my friends, because they don’t have the additional tie that that family complexity shows and showcases.
(Group 3, P4)
Participant Group 1, P5 described finding value in support from friends and co-workers who were willing to have conversations about the adoptee experience, noting a positive, affirming exchange in simply hearing them say, “thank you”, “you’ve taught me something,” or “I didn’t realize that”.
Adoptive family members were also found to be a source of support for some participants. One participant noted that they felt supported early on in childhood by their adoptive mother, who encouraged them to ask questions about their identity, have discussions about any grief they experienced around their adoption, and validate their complex emotions about their lived experience.
I guess I always start by saying I feel like my mom was someone who really inspired me and helped raise me to be the person I am today as far as my attitude towards adoption. So I guess not necessarily the rethinking part, but just having the consciousness very early on…[she] was not afraid of having me ask questions, she’d encourage it and said, like, “it’s okay that you’re sad, like, I couldn’t imagine being you,” that kind of stuff.
(Group1, P6)
These examples show how non-adoptee allies support adoptee consciousness by nurturing a safe space for adoptees to discuss and reflect on their lived experiences, and by receiving their experiences without judgment or forcing their own perspective on the adoptee experience. Through the provision of such supportive space, adoptees are heard and seen.

4.2.2. Lateral Validation

The theme of lateral validation describes the support provided by other adoptees who have an innate understanding of the adoptee experience. This shared experience often resulted in a no-explanation-needed zone, mitigating feelings of isolation felt by many adoptees. Seven participant examples consistently identified adoptee-to-adoptee connection as a significant source of support in their development of their adoptee consciousness.
Participants described how the adoptee community is uniquely in-tune and able to hold the weight of adoptee-specific experiences that others outside the community were unable to comprehend fully.
The adoptee community has truly been a lifesaver. To have people that understand that core primal trauma that nobody else is going to understand why it impedes every aspect and every relationship in your life.
(Group 2, P6)
This mutual understanding of adoptee experiences allowed participants to feel more comfortable and at ease in discussing their own experiences and in exploring their own adoptee consciousness, allowing a thought-partnership in processing. Having this support allowed participants to dive deeper and focus more on processing experiences as opposed to taking time and energy to explain what the experiences felt like and the impact they had.
It’s like they totally understand what you mean, you don’t have to explain all this stuff.
(Group 1, P2)
So I have been lucky enough to have a really strong group of friends who are adopted… so I’ve really been lucky to grow up with them and have these really hard conversations.
(Group 1, P1)
Having the space to process and connect with other adoptees was also found to support a process of healing.
I’ll say my biggest supports are always other adoptees just found, like the most healing in connection understanding.
(Group 3, P5)
One participant noted that they found it more supportive, even in a formal therapeutic setting, to have a mental health practitioner who had a shared identity as an adoptee, and they took an intentional step to switch practitioners for this reason.
I switched from a therapist that was, you know, doing fine job, to like a therapist that was also a transnational adoptee and that could kind of relate to my experiences a bit better.
(Group 2, P4)
Lateral validation in both formal and informal settings provided participants with the experience of being fully seen without needing to describe or explain themselves in order to be understood. This saved energy and, in turn, provided many with a space for healing and deeper processing.

4.2.3. Embodied Safety

Seven participant examples described a supportive source of embodied safety for adoptee consciousness that worked somatically in conjunction with cognitive and emotional processing. This theme recognizes that adoptee consciousness is also felt and stored within the physiology of the body and is tangibly processed through the five senses. Participants found safety and healing in processing through somatic, physical, and spiritually grounding practices.
One participant, in processing their association of love and loss based on their lived experience as an adoptee, came to the realization that they could create their own sense of safety for themselves. In doing this, the processing became more manageable for them.
So love means leaving…like love doesn’t have to be associated to abandonment, and like that shame, it freed me up to like hold those paradoxes a little bit more, and freed me up to just be like, Wow! Like I want security. I actually can create it, and the tools to create it, because I am natural. Because, like we are in biologically, inherently wired for that. So just tapping [into] it to that has been really powerful for me.
(Group 3, P1)
Another participant described somatic therapy as a main type of support in their healing process and their understanding of the physical impact of experienced trauma.
In addition to just the, what everybody has already said about unpacking layers and also learning about the physical effects of preverbal trauma and figuring out that somatic therapy was amazing.
(Group 2, P7)
Somatic practices done in community also served as a source of support for some participants. Examples are given of participants who utilized yoga and spiritual rituals, specifically geared towards communities of color, as a shared space to process both racial trauma and adoptee experiences.
So I was in one of those cities, and I had just finished a yoga teacher training, which was a Black owned yoga studio and our goal is to get more black yoga teachers out there, and to kind of just provide healing for people of color in the space, or we’re not really represented, and especially in the Yoga world. And so I did a lot of healing and still do surrounding racial trauma through yoga and meditation.
(Group 3, P2)
I just want to name like we’re going to be talking about lots of heavy things, so I have a practice around. I have leaves burning as to sort of a way to support us and our energy in the conversation.
(Group 3, P5)
The presence of embodied safety brought about not just a one-time experience for participants but also more so of an ongoing practice to continue the exploration of adoptee consciousness.
It’s always an ongoing process with me is thinking about adoption as a somatic experience, and questioning and checking into my body, and seeing where, like all of my adoption, trauma or not even trauma, but feelings where they live, and how it impacts like my body as well.
(Group 3, P3)
The theme of embodied safety brings to light that adoptee consciousness is not simply a cognitive or narrative process, but that greater awareness of the impact on physiology can be a source of continued healing and processing.

4.2.4. Reliable Foundation

The final supportive theme that emerged, described by six participants, is one that speaks to the impact of a stable environment where basic needs are consistently met. The provision of basic needs such as finances, education, a stable home environment, and transportation, establishes a foundational sense of security from which adoptees could engage in an exploration of adoptee consciousness more freely. This theme also surfaces the limitations of basic needs provision, often material in nature.
Most participants who mentioned the provision of a reliable foundation or components thereof also experienced consistent support in their identity exploration as adoptees. One participant noted that their adoptive family supported their adoptee consciousness from an early age, “And my parents and my family have been very supportive in building my identity, adoptee consciousness” (Group 1, P1), while another described their upbringing as a secure and safe place that allowed them more capacity to engage with their adoptee consciousness exploration, “Briefly, yeah, I guess in my experience I also kind of felt like I grew up in a relatively stable and secure household”. (Group 2, P4). For another participant, a reliable foundation provided a sense of genuine belongingness.
I’ll say, like for me, like my positives, are basically like I had like a great family that was providing for me, and also like educating me well and also like I was a part of a family who I came to rely on.
(Group 3, P6)
One participant pointed out that, although a reliable foundation was present for them, it did not provide a complete sense of support for their adoptee consciousness development. They mentioned that what was missing in their experience was an emotional support component which, for them, posed a huge gap.
So my family has always supported me like financially, and you know, from the logistics, but they have very they pretty much didn’t support me emotionally.
(Group 3, P8)
Reliable foundation, then, is a supportive theme with an embedded nuance that describes how basic needs provision can provide a sense of stability, but that such provision alone is not fully supportive. There exists a need for emotional support to provide a fuller support system for adoptee consciousness development.
There is not one singular support theme discussed above that can be concluded as a singular dynamic that supports adoptee consciousness. Rather, an intersection of what these supportive themes provided for adoptees—being fully seen, having a source of mutual understanding, being able to care for and regulate one’s own somatic system, and having a consistent provision of basic needs and a stable relational environment with emotional support—is where adoptees found support for their adoptee consciousness. Such supports were experienced with peers, other individuals, within communities, within professional therapeutic settings, and within oneself. These findings suggest that supporting adoptee consciousness requires an approach where interpersonal, communal, and somatic experiences are honored.
  • Unsupportive
Five unsupportive themes emerged in the analysis process: (1) inflexibility, (2) misattunement, (3) invalidation, (4) identity dismissal, and (5) information control. These themes describe how the transracial adoptee participants experienced opposition to, undermining of, or an overall lack of help in their consciousness process. We explore each theme with relevant participant examples next.

4.2.5. Inflexibility

Twelve participant examples described how adoptive family members, friends, both adoptees and non-adoptees, and various community members were unable to move to actions that allowed for space for consciousness exploration. Many of these actions were perceived as rigid, unable to decenter their own perspectives, or actively oppositional. For example, one participant shared,
So my family has always supported me like financially, and you know, from the logistics, but they have very they pretty much didn’t support me emotionally, and they didn’t support me looking for my family, and they literally opposed it and it has been very hurtful because they it could have been the end of the relationship if I wouldn’t try to always get over the things that you would usually wouldn’t get over like things that have been said that are so unsayable.
(Group 3, P8)
The same participant described inflexibility showing up as emotionally unsafe places within the adoptee community itself:
I really enjoy being in the community. But there’s also there have been also a lot of trauma that triggering and abusive experiences because of yeah, because we’re in our journey to healing and a lot of people are heard, and a lot of people have like learned a lot of unhealthy things that we trying to unlearn together. And it has not always been like the safest space to be in
(Group 3, P8)
Another participant lamented their efforts to share their feelings and experiences with their adoptive family with no success.
It was a lot of like, well, we can’t unadopt you, or like very—things that stuck in my brain as not good—for many, many attempts at trying to approach different people in different ways. Then this has never really worked out, I think, because in so many ways those people couldn’t decenter themselves in that conversation. And so, everything that they responded with was about their own feelings, and at no point could they acknowledge this like, really intense grief I was or anger, whatever it was I was trying to express to them
(Group 2, P5)

4.2.6. Misattunement

This theme is characterized by perceived attempts to be supportive, or at minimum, not in opposition to the transracial adoptee’s consciousness exploration; however, these attempts fell short. Twelve participant examples offered experiences that aligned with misattunement. For example, a participant shared how their adoptive family was trying to be supportive, yet the efforts did not meet what the participant fully needed.
I’ve always had family wanting to support. I think it’s coming from a well-intended space of support, but because of the biases that they carry, and the unawareness of really what’s going on with the adoption communities.and, like my parents, just have strong fears like they’re just afraid of what they don’t know. And so I think there’s all these levels that really also did a huge detriment to my growth and development.
(Group 3, P4)
Lack of attunement also showed up as a lack of interest or curiosity about the transracial adoptee participant’s experience. One participant shared the distance they experienced with their friend group who did not engage with them about their adoption experiences.
A lot of my friends are white, and a lot of them, like they don’t really ask, ‘cause they don’t know that I’m, you know, going through this stuff. And I share if I feel like it, but generally, you know, I don’t just like bring it up out of the blue.
(Group 1, P2)

4.2.7. Invalidation

The invalidation theme describes how family, friends, and community members, including mental health providers, dismissed, diminished, or outright rejected the adoptee participants’ consciousness efforts. Eleven participant examples described instances when their consciousness efforts were invalidated in some manner. One participant shared their frustration when trying to explain their adoptive family circumstances,
You can tell people that you were abused. You can tell people that, you know this wasn’t great, but then they look at the fact you went to Disneyland every year. … it amazes me how people can’t think past this little scope of it being a “better life.”
(Group 2, P6)
Another expressed how their experience was discredited by a former mental health therapist,
I was trying to talk to my previous therapist about it. But she was going, Oh! Well, this is just a regular part of human development that you’re trying to individuate from your parents. And this is just a part of life, and I knew it was something deeper.
(Group 2, P7)

4.2.8. Identity Dismissal

This theme highlights the ways in which participants’ attempts to share consciousness experiences directly related to a salient identity, such as racial, ethnic, cultural, gender, and sexual orientation, were ignored, diminished, and generally dismissed as unimportant. Six participant examples described instances of identity dismissal in their consciousness development. Several shared how the acts that did not welcome or validate their important identities contributed to weakening their relationships with their adoptive families. One participant recalled a standout identity dismissal instance that “decimated” their relationship with their adoptive family.
And I think it was kind of that moment where I was like, “Oh, I have this narrative of like, people adopt children because they, you know, are these great parents that were like picked out of applications, and they’re supposed to, like, provide these resources and love, that like, your birth parents cannot provide.” And I think when, yeah, when I came out to them, and it was like a very, you know, negative reaction that ended in, like, conversion therapy and all these things that I then had to, yeah, kind of question and be like, “Oh, wait! Like I’ve been told this narrative that only loving parents are able to adopt, so like what’s happening here?” And that kind of led me down this huge path of kind of questioning adoption and who’s kind of able to adopt and who’s not allowed to adopt.
(Group 1, P4)
Another explained how their attempts to describe a racially motivated microaggressive incident was met with pushback, prompting the participant to avoid sharing any further experiences.
“Oh, what did you expect was going to happen?” And I was like, “Wow, that’s really victim blaming.” Okay, clearly, I’m never gonna tell you about the actual, like, harm and physical violence I experienced? Because, you’re gonna dismiss it like, what?
(Group 2, P7)

4.2.9. Information Control

Three participants offered experiences reflecting suppression, omission, or obfuscation of important adoption-related identity information, which we described as information control. A participant recounted the startling realization that they had a biological twin sibling, information withheld from them by their adoptive parents,
I later had asked, you know, why did you tell me when I was 4 that I’d never be able to find my family yet didn’t tell me I had a twin, till I was 11, and they were like “well, when you were younger we just wanted to be honest with you, but telling you how you had a twin. We didn’t think you were emotionally able to handle it”, but I already knew I had other siblings at that point from the very sparse paperwork that I had.
(Group 2, P7)
Similarly, another participant shared how multiple entities, starting with their orphanage and continuing with their adoptive family, maintained secrecy about their origins.
After that when I returned back a year later, I was able to meet a few years later after that the founder of my orphanage, who was able to confirm that the story that I was being told about my adoption was probably not true, and gave me the probable of what it looked like at for those during that timeframe of how I was probably found, and why, and that helped me then have a conversation with my, you know, adoptive parents and my mom, my adoptive mom, mentioned she was also told, said story of what actually probably happened to me, and “we decided then in there that she was never going to tell it to me”, because it was too sad.
(Group 3, P4)
The unsupportive themes illuminate how the confluence of relational misalignment or misattunement and inability to center adoptee voices to allow for active listening and understanding, as noted in inflexibility and invalidation, set the stage for potential long-standing relationship barriers between adoptive families, friends, and sometimes mental health providers and transracial adoptees in this study. Both themes foster an environment where identity dismissal and information control tactics can surface repeatedly throughout the relational lifespan. All themes reinforced the transracial adoptee participants’ experiences of being unheard and obstructed in their consciousness process.

4.3. Discussion

The findings in the secondary analysis study emphasized how consciousness support or obstruction is counterbalanced between identical entities: adoptive families, friend groups, the adoptee community, and mental health practitioners. Notably, the unsupportive themes largely corroborate what is known about transracial adoptees’ lived experiences regarding limited cultural socialization (Lee 2003), racism, and microaggressions (Baden 2016; Grigoropoulos 2022), as described in the identity dismissal, inflexibility, and invalidation themes. Conversely, the supportive theme lateral validation aligns with known adoptee collective support structures (Cherot 2006; Harris 2014; Huggins and Flynn 2025).
Practical implications for adoptive families and friends can be gleaned from both supportive and unsupportive findings. For adoptive families, the unbalanced percentage split of adoptive family supportive (40%) versus unsupportive (55%) actions (Table 1) is a clarion call for families to move beyond good intentions and focus on improved attunement to what transracial adoptees need as they move through their unique consciousness journeys. Specifically, adoptive families can work to center the transracial adoptee voice while seeking their own adoption-informed support strategies to address their fears or engage in their own consciousness exploration. Such work would also support transparency in divulging all adoption-related information to promote an adoptee’s human right to identity and eradicate information control tactics. Adoptive families can provide a stable and secure home base, as described in reliable foundation, which paves the way for consciousness exploration. Friend groups can leverage non-adoptee allyship by providing curiosity and a nonjudgmental space for transracial adoptees to share their consciousness experiences.
The secondary analysis findings also shed light on transracial adoptee participants’ experiences with mental health providers, as evidenced by supportive and unsupportive provider actions. Hence, implications for mental health providers include moving into a non-adoptee allyship stance by exploring and understanding the ACM process to avoid pathologizing or invalidating the adoptee experience. Such work also includes acknowledging the emotional labor of the consciousness process and utilizing somatic-based interventions to support adoptee clients in their healing, as described in the embodied safety theme.

5. Conclusions

The secondary analysis findings offer information on who and how transracial adoptees are supported through consciousness, yet many further areas of inquiry should be considered. These include examining how the ACM touchstones fluctuate across the lifespan and looking more closely at how intersectional identities (i.e., LGBTQIA) influence the consciousness process and respective support (or lack thereof). While the findings of this study reflected strong consciousness support within adoptee communities, the findings also reflected that, at times, these spaces could transition from lateral validation to lateral violence. Qualitative studies can explore this phenomenon. Ultimately, the study’s findings illuminate the relational aspects that underscore supportive and/or obstructive actions towards transracial adoptee consciousness. Future research that expands the Adoptee Consciousness Model (Branco et al. 2023) to examine aspects of lifelong relational attunement and reintegration will be critical.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, S.B., J.K., and G.N.; methodology, S.B., M.E.+A. and A.S.; formal analysis, S.B., M.E.+A. and A.S.; investigation, S.B., J.K., and G.N.; writing—original draft preparation, S.B., M.E.+A. and A.S.; writing—review and editing, S.B., M.E.+A. and A.S. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research received no external funding.

Institutional Review Board Statement

Ethical review and approval were waived for this study, due to the secondary analysis deter-mined as “not human research subject”. Assurance number: FWA 00010885.

Data Availability Statement

The datasets presented in this article are not readily available because they consist of de-identified qualitative focus group transcripts from which a small, specific population of transracial adoptees could potentially be identified, violating confidentiality agreements. Requests to access the datasets should be directed to the corresponding author.

Acknowledgments

During the preparation of this manuscript/study, the authors used Gemini for Google Workspace (Education Edition, Google), for the purposes of initial thematic analysis. The authors have reviewed and edited the output and take full responsibility for the content of this publication.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

Appendix A

Table A1. Frequency and distribution of supportive “who” and categories mentioned by participants (n = 17).

Appendix B

Table A2. Frequency and distribution of unsupportive “who” and categories mentioned by participants (n = 19).

References

  1. Arnold, Tara, Sopagna Eap Braje, Debra Kawahara, and Tara Shuman. 2016. Ethnic Socialization, Perceived Discrimination, and Psychological Adjustment Among Transracially Adopted and Nonadopted Ethnic Minority Adults. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 86: 540–51. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  2. Baden, Amanda L. 2016. “Do You Know Your Real Parents?” and Other Adoption Microaggressions. Adoption Quarterly 19: 1–25. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  3. Baden, Amanda L., Lisa M. Treweeke, and Muninder K. Ahluwalia. 2012. Reclaiming Culture: Reculturation of Transracial and International Adoptees. Journal of Counseling & Development 90: 387–99. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  4. Branco, Susan, and Veronica Cloonan. 2022. False Narratives: Illicit Colombian transnational adoption practices. Genealogy 6: 80. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  5. Branco, Susan, JaeRan Kim, Grace Newton, Stephanie Cooper-Lewter, and Paula O’Loughlin. 2023. Out of the fog and into consciousness: A model of adoptee awareness. International Body of Psychotherapy Journal 23: 55–66. [Google Scholar]
  6. Braun, Virginia, and Victoria Clarke. 2006. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 3: 77–101. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  7. Braun, Virginia, and Victoria Clarke. 2019. Reflecting on reflexive thematic analysis. Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health 11: 589–97. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  8. Brodzinsky, David, Megan Gunnar, and Jesús Palacios. 2022. Adoption and trauma: Risks, recovery, and the lived experience of adoption. Child Abuse & Neglect 130: 105309. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  9. Brown, Taylor W., and Jini Roby. 2016. Exploitation of intercountry adoption: Toward common understanding and action. Adoption Quarterly 19: 63–80. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  10. Chatfield, Sheryl. 2020. Recommendations for secondary analysis of qualitative data. The Qualitative Report 25: 833–42. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  11. Cherot, Natalie. 2006. Transnational Adoptees: Global Biopolitical Orphans or an Activist Community? Culture Machine 8. Available online: https://culturemachine.net/community/transnational-adoptees/ (accessed on 6 August 2026).
  12. Corral, Susana, Marta Herrero, Nerea Martín, Ane Gordejuela, and David Herrero-Fernández. 2021. Psychological Adjustment in Adult Adoptees: A Meta-Analysis. Psicothema 33: 527–35. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  13. Denéchère, Yves, and Fabio Macedo. 2023. Étude Historique sur les Pratiques Illicites Dans L’adoption Internationale en France [Historical Study on Illicit Practices in Inter-National Adoption in France]. Angers: Université d’Angers. [Google Scholar]
  14. de Vries, Shila Khuki, Sarah Janaki Peshala de Vos, and Kristen E. Cheney. 2025. If We Do Not Speak Out, No One Else Will’: Adoptee Activism and Its Impact on Intercountry Adoption in The Netherlands. Genealogy 9: 133. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  15. Dutch Government, Committee Investigating Intercountry Adoption. 2021. Consideration, Analysis, Conclusions, Recommendations and Summary. The Hague: Dutch Government. [Google Scholar]
  16. Grigoropoulos, Iraklis. 2022. Adoption openness and adoption stigma: A retrospective study of adult adoptees. SN Social Sciences 2: 34. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  17. Harris, Perlita. 2014. I started to feel not ashamed of who I was’: Transracially adopted adults and adoption support. Adoption & Fostering 38: 346–60. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  18. Huggins, Lee, and Catherine Flynn. 2025. The Role of Peer-Based Support Groups in Addressing Support Needs Amongst Adult Adoptees: A Scoping Review. Adoption Quarterly. Advance online publication. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  19. Hübinette, Tobias. 2024. Sweden at a Crossroads: The Struggle for Finding the Truth about Transnational Adoption in the World’s Leading Adopting Nation. Adoption & Culture 12: 159–76. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  20. Intercountry Adoptee Voices. n.d.Understanding Illegal Intercountry Adoptions. Available online: https://intercountryadopteevoices.com/advocacy/understanding-illegal-intercountry-adoptions/ (accessed on 24 March 2026).
  21. Lee, Richard M. 2003. The Transracial Adoption Paradox: History, Research, and Counseling Implications of Cultural Socialization. The Counseling Psychologist 31: 711–44. [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
  22. Norwegian Government, Commission of Inquiry into Intercountry Adoptions. 2025. Interim Report on Ecuador and Colombia. Oslo: Ministry for Children and Families. [Google Scholar]
  23. O’Driscoll, Julia Villanueva, Yana Jaspers, and Niels Vanspauwen. 2024. Transnational Adoption: A Curse or a Blessing? The Psychosocial Impact of Malpractices in Transnational Adoption on Adoptees. Adoption Quarterly 27: 103–33. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  24. Ramsauer, Nadja, Rahel Bühler, and Katja Girschik. 2023. Indications of Illegal Adoptions of Children from Ten Countries of Origin in Switzerland, 1970s to 1990s, Inventory of Documents in the Swiss Federal Archives. Bern: Federal Office of Justice. [Google Scholar]
  25. Ruggiano, Nicole, and Tam E. Perry. 2019. Conducting secondary analysis of qualitative data: Should we, can we, and how? Qualitative Social Work 18: 81–97. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  26. Samuels, Gina E. Miranda. 2022. Epistemic trauma and transracial adoption: Author(iz)ing folkways of knowledge and healing. Child Abuse & Neglect 130: 105588. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  27. Swedish Foundation for Human Rights and Plan Ángel Foundation. 2022. Report About Irregular Intercountry Adoptions of Colombian Children Linked to the Armed Conflict. Stockholm: Swedish Foundation for Human Rights. [Google Scholar]
  28. Tieman, Wendy, Jan van der Ende, and Frank C. Verhulst. 2008. Young adult international adoptees search for birth parents. Journal of Family Psychology 22: 678–87. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.