Abstract
Reflective practice is an essential component of initial teacher education (ITE) programs in Australia that supports the development of preservice teachers’ responsive decision-making, planning, and ongoing professional growth. Yet, many preservice teachers continue to produce reflections that are descriptive, superficial, or disconnected from evidence of their practice. In response to this challenge, this study examines how mentor teachers support preservice teachers’ professional learning through reflection on video captures of their own teaching. Applying a qualitative study design, data collected using online surveys with mentor teachers indicate that retrospective video analysis enables mentors to identify pedagogically significant moments for reflection that support evidence-based dialogue. Video functions as a teaching microscope, requiring mentors to adjust the focus, direct preservice teachers’ attention, and scaffold their interpretation of what is observed. However, practical and systemic barriers significantly impact sustained implementation. This study highlights the potential of teacher mentors’ use of retrospective video analysis in ITE to enhance preservice teachers’ reflective practice, offering insights into how this approach can be effectively incorporated and scaled.
1. Introduction
Reflective practice is a foundational aspect of teacher professional learning (Feiman-Nemser, 2001; Zeichner & Liston, 1987), supporting responsive pedagogical decision-making and deliberate planning (Korthagen, 2017; Schön, 1983). Yet, a significant challenge in initial teacher education (ITE) is how to prepare preservice teachers to reflect deeply (Suphasri & Chinokul, 2021). While frequently required to reflect, preservice teachers’ efforts are often descriptive or surface-level (Le Maistre & Paré, 2010). This lack of depth is not necessarily due to insufficient effort or motivation on the part of either preservice teachers or their ITE providers, but rather to a deeper ambiguity around what constitutes effective reflection and how it is meaningfully enacted (Beauchamp, 2014).
Within school-based ITE experiences in Australia, mentor teachers are well placed to support reflective practice by employing communicative conversations (Goldshaft & Sjølie, 2024) to guide preservice teachers to attend to significant classroom events, interpret their pedagogical meaning, and consider possible responses (Sherin & van Es, 2009). In this study, mentor-led reflection is conceptualised as the development of professional noticing; the capacity to identify and interpret pedagogically significant features of classroom practice (Sherin & van Es, 2009; Jacobs et al., 2010).
Mentors’ proximity to classroom practice, during professional experience placements, offers invaluable opportunities to look back at preservice teachers’ teaching, and to prompt and guide reflective thinking. Yet, despite this, relatively little is known about how mentors actively support preservice teachers’ reflection in evidence-informed and pedagogically focused ways (Edwards-Groves, 2014).
One promising, yet underused, approach is mentor-guided retrospective video analysis, a process in which video recordings of preservice teachers’ own classroom teaching serve as the basis for guided reflection (Land, 2018). While curated videos are frequently used in ITE to demonstrate ‘best practice,’ limited studies have explored how mentors use video captures of preservice teachers’ practice to scaffold reflection during school-based placements. This distinction is important. Watching videos of others’ teaching illustrates possibilities; reviewing one’s own teaching with a knowledgeable mentor grounds reflection in observable classroom practice. As video analysis itself is not inherently effective without purposeful facilitation (van Es, 2009), the mentoring process is essential in mediating meaningful reflection.
Applying a basic qualitative study design (Tisdell et al., 2025), this research explores how mentor teachers use retrospective video analysis, by questioning: How do mentor teachers support preservice teachers’ professional learning through reflection on video captures of their own teaching? Data from online surveys provide insight into how mentors integrate retrospective video analysis as shared evidence of preservice teachers’ practice.
2. Literature Review: Teacher Mentors’ Use of Video with Preservice Teachers
While this study focuses on video-supported mentoring, it is important to situate this work within broader research on teacher mentoring. Mentoring in ITE is widely understood as a practice through which experienced teachers support preservice teachers’ professional learning through observation, feedback, and guided participation in teaching (Feiman-Nemser, 2001; Hudson, 2013). Research highlights the importance of mentoring conversations and feedback practices, as well as the variability and complexity of mentoring relationships (Ambrosetti, 2014). It also emphasises that learning from practice is not automatic, but is mediated through the mentor’s ability to make teaching visible, interpret practice, and scaffold professional learning (Feiman-Nemser, 2001; Richter et al., 2013).
Mentors play a critical role in making classroom practice visible and supporting shared analysis of teaching, and video provides a shared reference for this work (Sherin & van Es, 2009). Video is widely used in education for self-review, peer-assessment, and observation (Tripp & Rich, 2012), or for modelling best practice (Seidel et al., 2013). However, most research describes video use generally, with few studies considering its integration into ITE mentoring practices. A recent scoping review by the paper’s authors identified eight studies (2012–2025) that examined mentor teachers’ use of video to observe, assess, and support preservice teachers during school-based placements (author under review). Across the reviewed studies, mentor-guided video use can be understood through three interrelated dimensions: enhanced observation capabilities, evidence-based assessment, and structured mentor support.
2.1. Enhanced Observation Capabilities
Video capture provided teachers with an objective lens for reflection-on-action (van Es & Sherin, 2008). Key literature identifies that it enables viewers to notice practices often missed in real time and to examine teaching at a depth that may have been impossible through traditional in-the-moment experiences (Cavanagh, 2021; Dann & Richardson, 2015; Land, 2018). It becomes a reflective tool to focus observations based on concrete, reviewable evidence (Seung et al., 2014).
Significantly, video shifted the focus from teacher-centred actions to student learning (Cavanagh, 2021). The distance provided by the video facilitated a broader scope for mentors to examine how pedagogical choices affect student engagement and understanding (Dann & Richardson, 2015).
2.2. Evidence-Based Assessment
In this study, evidence-based refers to the use of video recordings as observable evidence of classroom practice, providing a shared basis for analysis and discussion. Video offered a concrete representation of classroom interactions as a shared basis for analysis and reflection (Stice & Gannon, 2023), and as evidence to link to national teaching standards and course objectives (Dann & Richardson, 2015). It supported what was described as closing the “gap-in-knowledge” by scaffolding preservice teachers through professional conversations that reflected on the why and the how (Dann & Richardson, 2015, p. 64).
2.3. Structured Professional Support
Retrospective video analysis, particularly when combined with critical discourse analysis, was applied to strengthen critical awareness of language, identity, and power dynamics (Land, 2018). The recordings were used to provide space for mentors to engage in critical discussions about societal power structures and classroom hierarchies. Similarly, in Hunskaar and Gudmundsdottir’s (2023) study, video tools provided a structural framework for mentoring conversations to build preservice teacher agency, using tangible data to drive their professional development.
Video analysis was applied to reflective learning conversations to move discussions from abstract concepts to specific, observable moments (Dann & Richardson, 2015). In collaborative learning modes, video sharing enabled multiple perspectives and distributed expertise among preservice teachers, mentors, and university supervisors (Liesa et al., 2023). Timestamped comments were essential for targeting feedback directly to specific lesson segments and for providing actionable feedback (Cavanagh, 2021). Additionally, video enabled university supervisor engagement to extend beyond traditional, limited visits (Cavanagh, 2021).
2.4. Challenges and Implementation Considerations
While the benefits of mentor-guided video analysis were evident across these studies, significant challenges hindered sustained implementation. Significantly, simply viewing a video of one’s own practice did not, by itself, ensure professional learning. Instead, preservice teachers required support to watch their practice and make sense of it in pedagogically meaningful ways. Without guidance, video analysis risks becoming a superficial recount or a description of the lesson (Sherin & van Es, 2009; van Es, 2009), as preservice teachers struggle to connect pedagogical features to video episodes appropriately and may retain teacher-centred rather than student-focused perspectives (Seung et al., 2014).
These studies suggest that the value of video in ITE mentoring is not in the technology itself, but in how it is adopted within a mentoring relationship to support the development of professional noticing and evidence-informed reflection. Mentors facilitate reflection by actively shaping what is noticed, how it is interpreted, and how it is connected to future teaching. The three identified dimensions reflect the interconnected aspect of mentoring as a practice of making teaching visible, interpretable, and open to improvement.
3. Reflection: Developing Professional Noticing
Reflective practice has long been positioned as central to teacher professional learning (Feiman-Nemser, 2001). Schön’s (1983) distinction between reflection-in-action and reflection-on-action provides a useful lens for understanding the challenges preservice teachers face when reflecting. Reflection-in-action occurs during practice and involves intuitive, in-the-moment responses while engaging in the activity. However, because this form of reflection is often tacit or intuitive, the teacher may not be able to articulate what they know.
In contrast, reflection-on-action occurs retrospectively, creating conditions for more systematic analysis of teaching decisions and their consequences (Schön, 1983). While Schön’s work remains foundational, contemporary research suggests that reflection does not occur automatically, but depends on the development of professional noticing: the capacity to interpret and make meaning from significant events in classroom practice (Sherin & van Es, 2009).
Professional noticing includes the interrelated process of attending to classroom events, interpreting their pedagogical significance, and deciding how to respond (Jacobs et al., 2010). From this perspective, the challenge for preservice teachers is not simply engaging in reflection, but learning what to attend to and how to interpret it. Early reflections are often dominated by surface-level aspects of teaching, such as delivery, confidence, or classroom presence, rather than analysis of student learning and engagement.
Research on video-based professional learning demonstrates that this capacity to notice is developed through structured opportunities to examine practice, including selecting, revisiting, and discussing specific teaching moments (van Es & Sherin, 2008; Sherin & van Es, 2009). Without such guidance, reflection risks remaining descriptive rather than analytical.
This limitation can be further understood through a Dunning–Kruger lens (Kruger & Dunning, 1999). As novices, preservice teachers may not have acquired the knowledge, skills, or experiences required to evaluate their own practice or recognise what they may have overlooked. Therefore, the issue is not simply misjudgment, but a limited capacity to identify alternative strategies or approaches. Consequently, unguided video reflection may reinforce existing misconceptions rather than disrupt them.
Viewed together, these perspectives suggest that reflection-on-action is not simply a retrospective activity, but a scaffolded process of developing professional noticing. This process requires structured support to direct attention, scaffold interpretations, and expand what preservice teachers are able to see in their own practice.
4. Study Context
While video can support preservice teachers’ reflective capacity, research shows that it is most effective when accompanied by external input from supervisors, mentors, or peers (Cornish, 2024). The challenge, therefore, is not just using video as a tool, but carefully considering how it is used and who supports the interpretive aspect of this work. This study examines how a small group of mentor teachers support preservice teachers’ professional learning through reflection on video captures of their own teaching.
In the Australian context, ITE programs include substantial school-based placements, during which preservice teachers are mentored by classroom teachers. Mentors are responsible for supporting preservice teachers’ professional learning, providing feedback on their teaching, and contributing to their assessment (Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership, 2024) against national teaching standards (Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership, 2011). Mentoring work occurs in addition to the mentor’s regular teaching responsibilities and is not always accompanied by formal training, resulting in variability in mentoring approaches and practices (Byth, 2025).
The study took place at a primary school in metropolitan Melbourne, Australia, and involved 12 experienced primary school teachers mentoring 12 preservice teachers during their school-based placements. All mentor participants were qualified primary classroom teachers with previous experience supervising preservice teachers. Their teaching experience ranged from early-career to highly experienced teachers, and all were generalist primary teachers responsible for teaching across multiple subject areas. The preservice teachers included those in the first to fourth years of their studies. They were enrolled in various educational degrees at diverse institutions.
Led by the school’s ITE placement coordinator, all mentor teachers were informed of the opportunity to be involved in the project and 12 chose to participate. Mentors were not provided with formal training specific to video analysis prior to the study, but drew on their existing mentoring practices and professional judgement to integrate video into their conversations with preservice teachers. Participation required that these mentors incorporate retrospective video analysis alongside their regular mentoring practice. A minimum of two retrospective video analysis conferences were required, involving mentors recording each preservice teacher’s teaching twice: once early and again later in the placement period. The adopted mentoring process of reviewing and analysing each video with the preservice teacher was at the mentors’ discretion. After each review, mentors were required to complete an online survey documenting their approaches, decisions, and reflections on the process.
The intent of this survey was two-fold. It served as data collection for this research and as a catalyst for mentor reflection on the role they play in retrospective video analysis. The survey questions were provocative, focusing their attention on the analysis process and prompting them to consider their scaffolding decisions about when to view the video, what to highlight, how much to lead, and how much to let the preservice teachers lead. This process aligned with the study’s aim to identify strategies that support meaningful retrospective video reflection while acknowledging the practical realities, constraints, and additional workload associated with this mentoring process.
5. Methodology
The study employed a qualitative research design (Tisdell et al., 2025) to investigate mentor teachers’ experiences and approaches when using retrospective video analysis with preservice teachers. Consistent with interpretivist principles, the study aimed to understand mentors’ strategies by exploring the “meanings that the people involved bring to them” (Denzin & Lincoln, 2013, p. 7). This served a dual purpose: to examine the pedagogical approaches, processes, and resource requirements associated with mentor-guided video analysis; and second, to inform decisions about narrowing or broadening the scope of subsequent research phases. As a context-specific inquiry, the study did not seek generalisable conclusions; instead, we recognised that mentors’ practices were shaped by relational, contextual, and institutional parameters.
5.1. Participants and Data Collection
Convenience sampling (Tisdell et al., 2025) was used to recruit 12 volunteer mentors (from a potential teaching staff of 24) from one primary school. All 12 mentors voluntarily consented to participate and to complete an online survey following each video mentoring interaction (a sample of the questions is shown in Table 1).
Table 1.
Participant Roles, Numbers, Data Collection Methods, Questions.
It should be noted that because participants self-selected into the study, the results may reflect mentors with a high level of commitment and enthusiasm for mentoring preservice teachers, and may not represent the broader mentor cohort.
Following ethical approval from the University and the Department of Education and Training, Victoria, Australia, all mentor participants received detailed information about the research. Data collection occurred across three school mentoring cycles in 2025. The preservice teachers were informed that the mentors intended to capture video recordings (either lesson segments or complete lessons) as a mentoring tool. All preservice teachers provided written consent for their teaching to be recorded. In accordance with ethics protocols, the videos were recorded on school devices, viewed only on the school premises, and subsequently deleted.
5.2. Data Analysis
Applying Braun and Clarke’s (2022) reflexive thematic analysis, a six-phase process was used to analyse the mentors’ responses. The analysis was primarily inductive, as codes were developed through repeated engagement with the dataset rather than from a predetermined coding framework. The analysis was informed by the research question and the researchers’ interest in how mentors scaffold preservice teachers’ reflective practice and professional noticing.
The researchers became familiar with the dataset by repeatedly reading the 143 responses, manually noting recurring ideas about the use of video in mentoring. Initial analysis involved both descriptive and interpretive coding to capture semantic accounts of practice as well as latent meanings regarding mentors’ pedagogical intentions and assumptions. Descriptive codes captured what mentors reported doing (e.g., independent viewing, pause-and-replay, asking the preservice teacher to speak first), while interpretive codes captured what these actions revealed about the mentors’ pedagogical work. This included scaffolding noticing, supporting reflective ownership, redirecting attention to student learning, and using video to strengthen feedback.
Codes were then grouped into themes, with related codes clustered into broader patterns of meaning. For example, codes relating to independent viewing, joint review, pausing, and replaying were grouped into an initial category around structured viewing. Similarly, codes relating to preservice teacher ownership, self-assessment, and mentor restraint were grouped into a category concerned with balancing independence and support.
These codes were iteratively reviewed against both coded extracts and the full dataset to ensure distinctiveness, before being refined into themes. Throughout this process, the researchers defined and refined themes that captured how mentors used video to: scaffold preservice teacher noticing, promote reflective ownership, broaden classroom awareness, and provide evidence-based feedback.
Consistent with reflexive thematic analysis, the focus was not on achieving coder agreement, but on ensuring analytic rigor through transparency in the coding process. This was addressed through repeated engagement with the data, and careful documentation of how themes were developed and refined. Some codes were merged, renamed, or repositioned as the central organising idea of each theme became clearer. For instance, early codes relating to background behaviours, missed student cues, and classroom dynamics were brought together within the theme Widening the Perspective: From Teacher-Centred to Student-Centred Noticing. Similarly, codes relating to disagreement, self-criticism, and the credibility of feedback were refined into Evidence: Resolving Contested Interpretations.
6. Results
Data were organised into six key themes, which are used to present the results in the following sections.
- Toward Structured Incremental Viewing;
- Balancing Agency and Expertise: The Self-Reflection Paradox;
- Widening Perspective: From Teacher-Centred to Student-Centred Noticing;
- Evidence: Resolving Contested Interpretations;
- The Implementation Gap;
- Mentor-Generated Design Aspirations: Imagining Better Tools.
These themes highlight how reflective practice was enacted through the development of professional noticing, with mentors actively scaffolding what preservice teachers attended to, how they interpreted classroom events, and how they connected these interpretations to future pedagogical actions.
6.1. Toward Structured Incremental Viewing
Our analysis of mentor practices revealed that those who achieved more productive reflective conversations had intuitively developed what we came to term ‘incremental viewing’ approaches. These mentors understood video not as a single viewing event but as a process requiring careful temporal sequencing. For example, one mentor described:
This mentor recognised the cognitive complexity of teaching and the impossibility of noticing everything in real time and therefore valued video as a tool to recover what was missed in the moment.It’s a great reflection tool when you are in the middle of a lesson, you do reflect, but then a million things are going on, and you can forget what you are reflecting on.
The structure these mentors employed typically involved two distinct phases: independent viewing, followed by collaborative viewing and analysis. The independent phase was deliberately offered to create space for preservice teachers to form their own interpretations before mentor input. This was experienced positively: “My preservice teacher was happy to watch the video on her own, she was taking notes, and then we discussed her findings of the video lesson together”. This was not merely a logistical mentor decision, but a pedagogical decision that positioned preservice teachers as the primary interpreters of their practice.
The mentor role became most visible during the collaborative viewing, particularly through the use of pause-and-replay at pedagogically significant moments. This was to scaffold noticing: “After taking the video I sent the PST off to watch the video individually in her break and come up with some of her own noticing. We then reviewed the video together; I asked the PST what areas they needed to work on what they were wondering. We then replayed the video and gradually stopped/ started the video to have discussions”. Another elaborated on the dialogic nature of this process, “I mostly pointed to noticing and asked the PST what they thought of the situation (e.g., clarity of instruction).” The process of pause-and-replay supported a deeper analysis. This micro-level scaffolding shifted what could be passive viewing into an analytical process.
6.2. Balancing Agency and Expertise: The Self-Reflection Paradox
A tension emerged over the balance between promoting the preservice teachers’ independence and providing the necessary mentoring expertise. One mentor noted:
Watching the video on her [preservice teacher] own gave her the time and space to take notes without feeling pressured or observed, which encouraged more thoughtful personal reflection. As a result, she developed a stronger sense of ownership over her learning as a PST.
Mentors consistently emphasised the need to allow the preservice teachers to speak first: “The PST gave their feedback first… Then I gave the feedback following the same structure.” This sequencing was not arbitrary but reflected the emphasis on giving the preservice teacher ownership of their learning. As one mentor explained, video “allowed my PST to critically reflect on her lessons independently and set her own goals, rather than relying on me to point out areas for improvement.”
We describe this as scaffolding the preservice teachers’ self-directedness. Preservice teachers “questioned what they did and how they could improve next time while watching the video,” with goal-setting becoming increasingly self-initiated rather than mentor-imposed. The video provided temporal distance, allowing preservice teachers to step away from the immediacy of teaching and engage in more deliberate reflection.
Yet, this emphasis on independence was recognised as having limitations. Preservice teachers’ self-reflections, while genuine and thoughtful, often missed the very details that required expert noticing. One mentor captured this, explaining:
I got the PST to watch the video alone, then we came together the following day to watch the video together. We both mentioned things that went really well, but I picked up on things they missed (e.g., students not listening, starting a task when they were still giving instructions).
Mentors not only supported preservice teachers to reflect independently, but also extended their capacity to notice beyond what was immediately visible to them. This addressed the tendency for preservice teachers to identify personal features and challenges but not necessarily notice student understanding or engagement.
6.3. Widening Perspective: From Teacher-Centred to Student-Centred Noticing
Beyond structuring reflection and balancing agency, mentors described a deeper shift in what counted as evidence of teaching quality. This shift became apparent in the gap between what preservice teachers noticed independently and what became visible through mentor-guided viewing. In one situation, a mentor paused a video segment and asked the preservice teacher what they noticed about student learning. The preservice teacher’s response was focused on their teaching performance (instructions, wait time, prompts, and positioning), which were all teacher-centred observations. The mentor’s focus was on the confusion visible in the students’ facial expressions and their sidebar conversations. Without explicit guidance to shift attention from teacher actions to student responses, this preservice teacher naturally leaned toward evaluating their own performance.
Mentors reported that video enabled them to redirect preservice teachers’ attention from their own performance to student learning, allowing them to notice the classroom dynamics they had missed while teaching, including background behaviours, off-task students, and subtle cues. One mentor described:
It was wonderful from both the mentor and PST to be able to see specific things that were happening in the background. It provided opportunities to add extra discussion and immediately pinpoint what happened and how it could be improved next time.
Another mentor highlighted this shift: “Watching the video after the lesson opened the PST’s eyes to things they didn’t notice when teaching (for example, when she was talking, students talked over her).” These observations were not just interesting details; they were pedagogically consequential, showing whether the students were listening, whether the instructions were clear, and if lesson pacing matched student readiness. Consequently, these reflections supported the development of classroom management strategies, such as scanning, positioning, and monitoring.
The process of rewinding and replaying facilitated this perspective, with mentors clarifying the impact of teacher actions on students: “The benefit is that we can see things in the video that the preservice teacher didn’t notice when in front of the class”, and “It was much easier to identify what happened and see the impact on the students.” Mentors directed attention to specific students or small groups, drawing attention to aspects that are often forgotten in preservice teachers’ memory of the lesson. Importantly, this process represented more than simply seeing more; it represented a shift in what counted as evidence of teaching quality. Rather than evaluating teaching based on whether the preservice teacher followed their lesson plan or delivered instructions clearly, mentors focused on the impact the preservice teachers were having based on student engagement.
6.4. Evidence: Resolving Contested Interpretations
One of the most significant benefits was that video provided the evidence needed to resolve disagreements about evaluations of what had occurred. It allowed both parties to see and reflect on what happened.
Using a video to reflect allows both the mentor and the PST to see the same thing and reflect on aspects of what was happening (the evidence was evident to those watching). It allowed the mentor to pause the video when they had questions of their own or reflections for the PST to respond to.
The objectivity of visual evidence was key in circumstances when verbal feedback had not been acted on by the preservice teacher. One mentor explained, “Without the video… my verbal feedback would not have been enough, or he may not have believed me.”
Video evidence was also important for addressing preservice teachers’ overly critical self-assessments by providing visual confirmation of their practices: “PSTs can be harsh on themselves… [using video] you can address successes and counter this.” Another mentor noted:
On a few occasions, she was quite self-critical, focusing on perceived negatives in her lesson delivery. Watching the video together provided a valuable opportunity to highlight and reinforce the many positive aspects of her teaching that she may have overlooked.
Using video evidence shifted the dynamic from judgment (the mentor evaluating the preservice teacher) to joint analysis (both parties examining the same evidence). Mentors reflected that video was essential in making feedback credible, particularly when preservice teachers struggled to recognise or accept the issue being discussed.
In one instance, the preservice teacher’s body language and spoken language were perceived by the mentor as too casual to establish a student-teacher relationship. The mentor had several conversations explaining the difference between a ‘friend’ and a ‘teacher’. However, the mentor had perceived that the preservice teacher was reluctant to accept the feedback. Only when viewing the recorded lesson did the preservice teacher recognise what the mentor had been describing. The mentor explained: “Without the video… my verbal feedback would not have been enough; he may not have believed me.” The video provided incontrovertible evidence that transformed the mentor’s feedback from a subjective opinion to an observable reality. “It is amazing if the PST is consistently not taking on feedback, to show them what they are doing.”
Video also supported the development of shared understanding by anchoring feedback in a common point of reference, enabling both the mentor and the preservice teacher to engage with the same evidence and reflect on aspects of what was happening. In one instance, the mentor expressed concern about the low volume of the preservice teacher’s voice, requesting that they project it. The tall preservice teacher, towering above the much smaller students, felt that they were shouting. When they reviewed the video together, with the recording device placed at the back of the classroom, it was evident that the preservice teacher’s voice was difficult to hear. This video evidence was significant in shifting this misperception.
6.5. The Implementation Gap
Despite these pedagogical affordances, mentors identified significant practical and contextual barriers that hindered the integration of video into routine mentoring practices. The most frequently cited challenge was time, not merely the time required to record lessons but the more constraining need to find time for joint viewing. “We recorded this lesson on a Friday, but we had no time to sit down together to watch it. We had to wait till the following Monday.” While this particular mentor noted that having the video meant “we did not need to rely on our memories from the lesson 4 days ago,” the delay between teaching and reflection introduced its own complications.
The practical challenge of capturing the teaching on video was described in terms of the spatial constraints of crowded classrooms: “Lots of bodies in the space made it challenging to capture everything happening as there were two classes in this lesson”. Camera placement required balancing comprehensiveness with practicality, often resulting in compromises. Most mentors addressed this by recording only targeted segments. “I only videoed one part of the lesson (explicit teaching) as I knew we would not have time to sit down and watch the whole lesson.” Eight of the mentors managed this by videoing the entire lesson the first time and then carefully selecting segments based on goals or specific strategies for subsequent video captures.
Privacy considerations added another layer of complexity. One mentor flagged potential concerns about “privacy challenges with permission to video students”; this reflected broader institutional and ethical considerations that video inevitably introduces. While this school had received general media permissions from parents for the use of video for learning, the focus of those recordings may need to be addressed to align with such permissions.
Additionally, there was a gap between mentors’ stated intentions and actual sustained use. All mentors reported they would use video with future preservice teachers, yet anecdotally, they told the research team they had not pursued its use outside the research project. Time constraints and what one mentor described as “the clumsy nature of re-watching lengthy video footage” remained the most significant barriers. This gap between perceived value and actual implementation suggests that without systemic support, including dedicated time and streamlined technology, video analysis risks remaining aspirational rather than a routine practice.
6.6. Mentor-Generated Design Aspirations: Imagining Better Tools
The practical challenges mentors faced led to specific suggestions for redesigning video tools to support their mentoring work. These suggestions were not abstract but practice-grounded solutions to problems they had directly encountered.
Mentors all used a school iPad propped on a stand or a Kaboodle (standing desk) at the back of the room for filming. They often focused on the explicit teaching section of the lesson. One commented, “I propped the recording device on the table and set and forgot, which actually captured a lot of footage”. Many suggested additional recording features would be useful:
The ability to add timestamps, write comments and highlight key moments in the video. This would allow both the PST and me to note specific areas of focus. It would help create a more structured and targeted reflection process.
This simple feature would address a core challenge of marking significant moments during or immediately after recording so that joint viewing sessions could focus efficiently on what mattered most. As one mentor explained, “Whilst filming, I was writing notes next to the camera, noting timings. This saved me time to review the film again.” The workaround was the catalyst for the suggested technological support for this.
For analysis, mentors suggested automated quantification of teaching practices: “Another potentially helpful feature could be an automatic counter—for example, a tool that tracks and tallies the number of questions the PST asks students during the lesson.” Other suggestions pointed more towards sophisticated analytical capabilities. The idea of side-by-side video comparison emerged from mentors’ experiences tracking growth over time: “Since we were recording the same part of the lesson (the explicit teaching), I wonder if it would be useful to have a feature that allows two videos to play side by side for comparison.”
7. Discussion
This study examined the conditions, decisions, and approaches that shaped mentor-led retrospective video analysis. Across the dataset, mentors positioned video as a shared and observable record of practice that enabled more precise professional noticing and supported reflective dialogue. Providing opportunities for preservice teachers to view their teaching strengthened the credibility of the mentor’s feedback and sharpened preservice teachers’ self-reflection.
However, this study highlights that the affordances of video are not automatic but are scaffolded by how mentors structure the viewing and mentoring process. This research therefore contributes new insights into the mentors’ role and the conditions that support the integration of effective retrospective video analysis in one ITE context. Specifically, it reveals that video’s potential as a reflective tool is realised not through the technology itself, but through the ways mentors structure, mediate, and scaffold preservice teachers’ engagement with evidence of practice. This aligns with broader research on mentoring, which emphasises that professional learning is mediated through interaction, feedback, and guided participation (Ambrosetti, 2014).
7.1. The Pedagogy of Video-Based Mentoring
While the existing literature establishes that video enables retrospective noticing and evidence-based feedback (Cavanagh, 2021; Dann & Richardson, 2015), this study’s findings suggest that specific mentoring practices maximise these outcomes. The findings challenge a prevalent assumption that providing video recordings to preservice teachers will naturally generate pedagogical reflection. Instead, the data demonstrate that unguided video viewing produces what might be termed self-observation, in which preservice teachers reflect on their actions (or inactions) rather than analysing pedagogical decisions or student learning.
Therefore, building on Brouwer et al.’s (2017) research a key finding of this study is the need for mentors to structure video analysis deliberately. The incremental opportunities mentors created supported preservice teachers to slow down, notice nuances, and engage in deeper reflection. This occurred through a combination of independent and joint viewing, as well as pause-and-replay analysis. These were necessary steps, as without mentor guidance, video reflection risks becoming superficial or descriptive (Brouwer et al., 2017; Sherin & van Es, 2009; Tripp & Rich, 2012).
Schön’s (1983) framework suggests that temporal distance supports deeper analysis. However, his later work (Schön, 1991) highlights that reflection requires structured guidance. Building on this, the present study suggests that reflection-on-action is most productively understood as a scaffolded process of developing professional noticing, rather than a naturally occurring outcome of retrospective review. Distance without direction allows preservice teachers more time to engage in unproductive self-evaluation. Therefore, mentors play a critical role in directing attention, supporting interpretation, and helping preservice teachers connect observations to future pedagogical action, thereby scaffolding the core processes of professional noticing (Jacobs et al., 2010).
Through strategic pausing, questioning, and replaying, mentors effectively taught noticing (Sherin & van Es, 2009), directing preservice teachers’ attention toward pedagogically consequential details that would otherwise remain invisible. They highlighted significant classroom events and supported preservice teachers to interpret their pedagogical significance, and to consider possible responses.
Only through mentor-guided viewing did preservice teachers’ attention shift from teacher performance to student learning. This shift signals the emergence of professional noticing and supports more substantive reflection-on-action to develop pedagogical reasoning. However, what was made visible and discussed in these moments was shaped by each mentor’s professional knowledge, experience, and priorities. As such, noticing was not neutral but mediated through these interpretive lenses.
The concept of incremental viewing that emerged from mentor practices extends existing research. Previous research has documented the value of video for targeting specific moments (Cavanagh, 2021) and supporting structured conversations (Dann & Richardson, 2015), but has not articulated how the temporal sequencing of independent-then-collaborative viewing functions pedagogically. This study builds on this work by showing how such sequencing positioning preservice teachers as active interpreters before mentor expertise is introduced. The sequence matters: allowing preservice teachers to form initial observations preserves their agency while laying a foundation for mentors to build more sophisticated noticing.
7.2. The Dunning–Kruger Effect in Video-Based Reflection
We suggest that the problem is not simply that preservice teachers don’t know what they don’t know (Kruger & Dunning, 1999) but also that their attention gravitates toward self-evaluation. They question (Am I good? How do I look? Do I sound professional?) rather than pedagogical analysis (What are students learning? How did my choices affect engagement?). Unguided video, therefore, may enable more sophisticated self-judgment but not necessarily more sophisticated pedagogical reasoning.
This pattern can be somewhat understood through a Dunning–Kruger lens (Kruger & Dunning, 1999), where, as novices, preservice teachers may lack the knowledge required to accurately evaluate their own practice. However, the issue is not simply one of misjudgment, but of limited capacity to attend to and interpret pedagogically significant features of classroom interaction, reinforcing that early reflection is constrained not by willingness but by an underdeveloped capacity for professional noticing. The challenge is not only that preservice teachers don’t know what they don’t know (Kruger & Dunning, 1999), but that their attention is often directed towards less consequential aspects of their practice.
Mentors’ scaffolding supported preservice teachers’ ownership of their learning by providing opportunities for them to be active in their reflective development. Mentors’ direct questioning—What do you notice about student learning? rather than how do you think you did?—represents a reorientation of the analytical frame from preservice teacher performance to student experience. This shift from a teacher-centred to student-centred focus reiterates findings from Cavanagh (2021) and Seung et al. (2014) and reflects the development of professional noticing.
Importantly, this process was not uniform, but mediated through the mentor’s pedagogical lens. What was identified as significant, and how it was interpreted, depended on what mentors framed as relevant or important. While video provided a shared reference point, it did not remove the interpretive influence of mentoring, but situated it within a common evidentiary context.
This study highlights how resistant preservice teachers are to making this shift independently and how essential mentor guidance is in accomplishing it. At the same time, this reorientation is shaped by their mentor’s framing of what is considered relevant or important, meaning that each preservice teacher’s developing interpretations are mediated through the mentor’s pedagogical lens.
7.3. Evidence as Persuasion: Seeing Is Believing
Mentors used video as shared evidence of practice to counteract excessive self-criticism, which is often based on a dichotomy of ‘good’ and ‘bad’ (Byth, 2026), which is counterproductive to deepening reflection and considering alternate actions. This use of video to calibrate self-assessment represents a critical but under-theorised dimension of video-based ITE mentoring.
The use of video strengthened both the credibility and the focus of the mentor’s feedback, consistent with findings from Hunskaar and Gudmundsdottir’s (2023) study. In this research, it specifically resolved misunderstandings by providing evidence of practice that mentors used to challenge preservice teachers’ perceptions.
The literature described video’s value for evidence-based assessment (Dann & Richardson, 2015), but did not fully explore what happens when verbal feedback fails and visual evidence succeeds. This study examined cases in which preservice teachers rejected mentor feedback until they viewed video evidence. We note that this was not because they were defiant, but because their lived experience contradicted the mentor’s observations. Preservice teachers who felt they were shouting or believed their casual demeanour was appropriate were not resisting feedback per se. They were operating from personal perspectives that the mentor’s verbal explanations were unable to address. The video provided what might be termed a perceptual correction, enabling preservice teachers to see themselves as others (students, mentors) experienced them rather than how they saw themselves.
Reflection requires not just temporal distance but perceptual distance—the ability to step outside one’s own embodied experience and view practice from another perspective. Video uniquely enables this perceptual shift, but we suggest that this occurs only when it is viewed collaboratively. The mentor’s role is to bridge the gap between the preservice teacher’s felt experience (I felt like I was shouting) and the observable reality (Your voice is barely audible on the recording). This process can be understood as expanding what preservice teachers can notice and interpret within their own practice (Jacobs et al., 2010).
7.4. Balancing Pedagogical Intent with Practical Realities
Retrospective video analysis was more effective when focused on selected segments of teaching rather than entire lessons, with mentors shifting from recording full lessons to targeting specific teaching episodes aligned with preservice teachers’ goals. This selective approach addressed time constraints while also strengthening the pedagogical quality of reflection by enabling more analytic engagement with practice (van Es & Sherin, 2008; Sherin & van Es, 2009).
However, the practical barriers to embedding video in crowded classrooms, including time constraints, lesson length, camera placement, and coordinating joint viewing times, must be acknowledged. Despite unanimous agreement among mentors about the value of using retrospective video analysis for mentoring, no mentor continued its use beyond the research project.
This discontinuity reveals a critical implementation paradox: the very features that make video pedagogically powerful (its capacity to capture preservice teachers’ practice, enable repeated viewing, and support detailed analysis) also make it practically too challenging to implement within the time and resource constraints of ITE mentoring. This implementation gap suggests that without systemic support, including dedicated time for joint viewing and access to improved, streamlined technology, retrospective video analysis will remain an aspirational idea rather than a routine practice.
8. Limitations of This Study
As a study conducted in a small metropolitan school with 12 mentor teachers and 12 preservice teachers, the participant sample was deliberately small to enable in-depth qualitative insights. However, the findings may not reflect the broader population of mentor teachers and may not be generalisable to other school settings or mentoring contexts, although they may help to inform larger, multi-site studies and the development of scalable video-reflection practices.
Data were collected through mentor surveys and therefore represent mentors’ perspectives only. This study did not include the preservice teachers’ experiences or independent observational analysis of video use. Further studies incorporating the preservice teachers’ perspectives, alongside additional sources of data, would provide a more comprehensive understanding of retrospective video analysis in mentoring.
9. Conclusions
In this study, retrospective video analysis functioned as a pedagogical microscope, enabling both the mentor and the preservice teacher to examine specific moments that were not visible during teaching. It transformed subjective memory into objective evidence for targeted professional conversation. The findings suggest its effectiveness depends on how mentors structure and scaffold the viewing process. Specifically, this includes how mentors adjust the focus, direct preservice teachers’ attention, and support interpretation towards future pedagogical action.
Through this process, video is repositioned from a passive recording device to an active pedagogical tool that reshapes three key aspects of ITE mentoring. First, it creates temporal distance by moving reflection from during teaching (in-action) to after teaching (on-action), while demonstrating that such distance alone is insufficient without guidance. Second, it enables perceptual shifts, supporting preservice teachers to move beyond their lived experience and develop professional noticing by attending to and interpreting pedagogically significant moments. Third, video transforms interpersonal dynamics through mentoring conversations based on shared visual evidence rather than subjective opinion or recall. Together these findings suggest that reflection-on-action is not only a retrospective activity but a scaffolded process of developing professional noticing.
However, this study revealed an implementation paradox: despite unanimous recognition of the value of retrospective video analysis as a mentoring strategy, no mentors sustained its use beyond the research project. Mentors identified the need for technological features, including timestamping and tagging for efficient navigation, goal-tracking systems, automated counts of teaching practices, and side-by-side comparison capabilities to support sustained use. This study suggests that current video tools are designed for general recording rather than for specialised mentoring work. These practice-generated insights, absent from existing research, point to the need for purpose-built video platforms that reduce logistical burdens while preserving the interpretive work that only skilled mentors can provide.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, A.B.; methodology, A.B. and J.B.; software, A.B.; validation, A.B. and J.B.; formal analysis, A.B.; investigation, A.B. and J.B.; resources, A.B.; data curation, A.B. and J.B.; writing—original draft preparation, A.B.; writing—review and editing, A.B. and J.B.; project administration, A.B.; funding acquisition, A.B. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
This research was partially funded by the Australian Teacher Education Association Partnership Award 2024.
Institutional Review Board Statement
The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki, and approved by the Monash University Human Research Ethics Committee (MUHREC) (protocol code 47732 and period of approval 6 April 2025–6 April 2030), and the Ethics Committee of Victorian Government Department of Education (RISEC) (protocol code 24-09-437 and period of approval 19 December 2024–18 December 2027).
Informed Consent Statement
Informed consent was obtained from all subjects involved in the study.
Data Availability Statement
The original contributions presented in this study are included in the article. Further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.
Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge the support and partnership of the participating mentor teachers and the school community who generously contributed their time, expertise, and continual commitment to the mentoring of preservice teachers.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Abbreviations
The following abbreviations are used in this manuscript:
| PST | Preservice Teacher |
References
- Ambrosetti, A. (2014). Are you ready to be a mentor? Preparing teachers for mentoring pre-service teachers. Australian Journal of Teacher Education, 39(6), 30–42. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership. (2011). Australian professional standards for teachers. Available online: https://www.aitsl.edu.au/teach/standards (accessed on 18 December 2025).
- Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership. (2024). Australian professional experience guidelines. Available online: https://www.aitsl.edu.au/docs/default-source/initial-teacher-education-resources/professional-experience-guidelines/australian-professional-experience-guidelines-2024_10_18.pdf (accessed on 18 December 2025).
- Beauchamp, C. (2014). Reflection in teacher education: Issues emerging from a review of current literature. Reflective Practice, 16(1), 123–141. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2022). Thematic analysis: A practical guide. Sage. [Google Scholar]
- Brouwer, N., Besselink, E., & Oosterheert, I. (2017). The power of video feedback with structured viewing guides. Teaching and Teacher Education, 66, 60–73. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Byth, A. (2025). Addressing the hidden labour of mentoring preservice teachers. The Australian Educational Researcher, 52, 1451–1469. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Byth, A. (2026). Rethinking the gradual release of responsibility in ITE mentoring: An andragogical perspective. The Australian Educational Researcher, 53(1), 21. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cavanagh, M. (2021). Pre-service teacher reflection and feedback using an online video platform during professional experience. The Australian Journal of Teacher Education, 46(2), 72–85. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cornish, L. (2024). Reflective practice and professional development. In L. Cornish (Ed.), (Re)learning as reflective practitioners (pp. 109–128). Springer. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Dann, C., & Richardson, T. (2015). Deepening understanding of “pedagogical outcomes” through video data collection: A catalyst for guided reflective learning conversations. International Journal of Pedagogies & Learning, 10(1), 62–80. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Denzin, N. K., & Lincoln, Y. S. (2013). Collecting and interpreting qualitative materials. Sage. [Google Scholar]
- Edwards-Groves, C. J. (2014). Learning teaching practices: The role of critical mentoring conversations in teacher education. Journal of Education and Training Studies, 2(2), 343. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Feiman-Nemser, S. (2001). From preparation to practice: Designing a continuum to strengthen and sustain teaching. Teachers College Record, 103(6), 1013–1055. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Goldshaft, B., & Sjølie, E. (2024). Creating communicative learning spaces in initial teacher education (ITE) with observation-grounded co-mentoring practices. Professional Development in Education, 50(3), 533–550. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Hudson, P. (2013). Strategies for mentoring pedagogical knowledge. Teachers and Teaching, Theory and Practice, 19(4), 363–381. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Hunskaar, T. S., & Gudmundsdottir, G. B. (2023). Tool-based mentoring conversations in teacher education: New structures, opportunities and the role of adaptive expertise. International Journal of Mentoring and Coaching in Education, 12(4), 424–439. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Jacobs, V. R., Lamb, L. L. C., & Philipp, R. A. (2010). Professional noticing of children’s mathematical thinking. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 41(2), 169–202. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Korthagen, F. (2017). Inconvenient truths about teacher learning: Towards professional development 3.0. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice, 23(4), 387–405. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Kruger, J., & Dunning, D. (1999). Unskilled and unaware of it: How difficulties in recognising one’s own incompetence lead to inflated self-assessments. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 77(6), 1121–1134. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Land, C. L. (2018). Examples of c/critical coaching: An analysis of conversation between cooperating and preservice teachers. Journal of Teacher Education, 69(5), 493–507. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Le Maistre, C., & Paré, A. (2010). Whatever it takes: How beginning teachers learn to survive. Teaching and Teacher Education, 26(3), 559–564. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Liesa, E., Mayoral, P., Giralt-Romeu, M., & Angulo, S. (2023). Video-based feedback for collaborative reflection among mentors, university tutors and students. Education Sciences, 13(9), 879. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Richter, D., Kunter, M., Lüdtke, O., Klusmann, U., Anders, Y., & Baumert, J. (2013). How different mentoring approaches affect beginning teachers’ development in the first years of practice. Teaching and Teacher Education, 36, 166–177. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Schön, D. A. (1983). The reflective practitioner: How professionals think in action. Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Schön, D. A. (1991). The reflective turn: Case studies in and on educational practice. Teachers College Press. [Google Scholar]
- Seidel, T., Blomberg, G., & Renkl, A. (2013). Instructional strategies for using video in teacher education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 34, 56–65. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Seung, E., Park, S., & Jung, J. (2014). Exploring preservice elementary teachers’ understanding of the essential features of inquiry-based science teaching using evidence-based reflection. Research in Science Education, 44(4), 507–529. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Sherin, M. G., & van Es, E. A. (2009). Effects of video club participation on teachers’ professional vision. Journal of Teacher Education, 60(1), 20–37. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Stice, S., & Gannon, M. (2023). “I’m starved for that”: Preservice teachers’ experiences with video analysis. Journal of Language and Literacy Education, 19(1), n1. [Google Scholar]
- Suphasri, P., & Chinokul, S. (2021). Reflective practice in teacher education: Issues, challenges, and considerations. PASAA: Journal of Language Teaching and Learning in Thailand, 62(1), 236–264. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Tisdell, E. J., Merriam, S. B., & Stuckey-Peyrot, H. L. (2025). Qualitative research: A guide to design and implementation (5th ed.). Wiley. [Google Scholar]
- Tripp, T., & Rich, P. (2012). Using video to analyse one’s own teaching. British Journal of Educational Technology, 43(4), 678–704. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- van Es, E. A. (2009). Participants’ roles in the context of a video club. Journal of the Learning Sciences, 18(1), 100–137. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- van Es, E. A., & Sherin, M. G. (2008). Mathematics teachers’ “learning to notice” in the context of a video club. Teaching and Teacher Education, 24(2), 244–276. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Zeichner, K. M., & Liston, D. P. (1987). Teaching student teachers to reflect. Harvard Educational Review, 57(1), 23–48. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.