Review Reports
- Elizaveta Galperina 1,2,*,
- Olga Kruchinina 1,2 and
- Alexander Kornev 1,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe frontal brain region tunes letter/non-letter processing during literacy acquisition: An ERP study on dyslexic and typically developing children in second and fourth grades
Languages
Summary:
The current study provides interesting findings regarding how particular event-related potentials (ERPs), specifically the P1, N2, P2, N2 and LPC, changed in amplitude across children in ages 7-8 and 9-11 years that were grouped into Dyslexic and TD status. ERP amplitudes were examined in response to a letter/non-letter classification task as well as behavioral results of classification accuracy. In the younger age group (7-8), there was a significant difference in behavioral accuracy for the TD and DYS subgroups, but this difference diminished in the older age group, suggesting the DYS group improved over time and the TD group did not. Although behavioral results on the task were similar, there were significant differences in ERP amplitudes between the DYS and TD groups at older ages, suggesting unique cognitive processing mechanisms. The authors suggest this could be related to compensatory mechanisms such as executive function. The authors have presented a robust amount of data that are very helpful to the field; however, I believe the manuscript should be improved before being accepted for publication. Specifically, I suggest more detail is provided that would help clarify the unique patterns that are present across the ERP data points. Further, I believe the authors need to provide more information, specifically in the introduction, to support their argument that these differences in ERPs may be related to executive functions. More specific comments and major revisions are included below and organized by section:
General Concept Comments and Major Revisions:
- Introduction and Literature Review – I believe the introduction, should be restructured to aid clarity. I suggest the authors use subheadings, such as Cognitive Processes of Reading, ERPs related to Print Recognition, Differences in these ERPs for DYS and TD children, and Current Study to organize the introduction.
- I suggest the authors reorganize the first couple of paragraphs of the introduction and add additional details where some are missing. From reading, I believe the first two paragraphs are meant to detail the cognitive processes that are involved in reading, specifically those related to print recognition that will be of focus for the paper. I think this can be more clearly laid out as some of the sentences are confusing, especially that on lines 50-52.
- While I commend the authors for investigating multiple ERP components, I think it would be helpful to explicitly connect each ERP to the cognitive components of reading that are mentioned in the beginning paragraphs if possible.
- If the authors want to hypothesize that the difference in the ERP components between DYS and TD kids in the older age groups, when they have similar behavioral scores, is due to EF, I think more time needs to be spent justifying this argument. I can empathize with the fact that there is a lot of EF literature to cover and that, in general, its role as a compensatory mechanism for reading in DYS children is complex and somewhat unclear, but the fact that it is only briefly touched in the introduction when it seems like it is currently written as a central hypothesis is concerning. I think it would be best to either choose to leave it as a central hypothesis and provide more detail in the introduction or to include it as future thoughts for discussion in the discussion without including it as a hypothesis. While some of the background on EF and reading is included, particularly regarding differences in activation of the frontal lobe, I think it would be beneficial to discuss what this “dysfunction” may look like within ERPs.
- I like how the authors included some relevant literature from fMRI, but I think it would be beneficial to include a more detailed discussion of how the ERPs investigated in the paper relate to the fMRI literature.
- Finally, I suggest the authors include a current study section, which describes (in order) the study, its specific research questions, and the authors’ hypotheses. Currently the final paragraphs list the hypotheses of the study before describing the experiment and listing the research questions.
- Method – The methodology is clear, but I have a couple of suggestions that I believe would enhance interpretation of the study.
- Is it common practice to use the SARS/SRQ to define dyslexia vs TD readers? If so, can citations be included? If not, I believe more of a justification is necessary. It would also be good to clarify if these DYS readers are likely to have a DYS diagnosis.
- Results – While the abstract provides a straightforward summary of the results that help to aid interpretation, I believe the results and discussion section could be improved.
- I think it would be helpful to have each ERP listed as its own subheading in the results section and then go into age and group effects within each ERP. While this was done for the N1 (N170) the other ERPs were discussed based on their region, which was confusing to me as the reader
- From some preliminary ERP work myself, I know that there is variability in when these ERP components peak due to skill, like as discussed here, and there can be a lot of nuance in interpreting these affects when aspects, like latency, vary; however, I think the authors could report how they derived the ERP time windows from the data and use extant literature to support their choices.
- If the authors choose to create subheadings in the results section based on each ERP of interest, I think it would be nice to have the first sentence clarify where this ERP was obtained from (what electrodes) and what time frame was used (for each group and age if needed). Additionally, I think this information is presented well in the table and then also presented in the discussion, so it would just be reorganizing it for clarity in the results
Discussion
- I think the discussion does a good job summarizing the many results reported in the paper.
- In the paragraph found on lines 548-558, could the authors please add how this better reasoning relates to the current findings of the paper?
- As mentioned in the introduction, I suggest that if the authors choose to keep the EF part in the paper, a more substantial discussion of how the results support this hypothesis as well as what future work needs to be done to confirm this hypothesis is needed in the discussion
Specific Comments and Minor Revisions:
- Ln 50-52, please include this sentence in the paragraph above
- Ln 108-117, this paragraph currently does not contain any citations which I think would be beneficial to add
- Ln 643-644. There is a repeated sentence
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
We would like to sincerely thank the reviewer for their thorough and insightful evaluation of our manuscript “The frontal brain region tunes letter/non-letter processing during literacy acquisition: An ERP study on dyslexic and typically developing children in second and fourth grades.”
We greatly appreciate the reviewer’s constructive comments and valuable suggestions, which have significantly contributed to improving the clarity, structure, and overall quality of our paper. In response, we have carefully revised the manuscript—changing the title, rewriting the introduction and discussion, and reorganizing several sections as recommended. Below, we address each comment in detail and describe the corresponding modifications made to the manuscript.
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
The frontal brain region tunes letter/non-letter processing during literacy acquisition: An ERP study on dyslexic and typically developing children in second and fourth grades
Languages
Summary:
The current study provides interesting findings regarding how particular event-related potentials (ERPs), specifically the P1, N2, P2, N2 and LPC, changed in amplitude across children in ages 7-8 and 9-11 years that were grouped into Dyslexic and TD status. ERP amplitudes were examined in response to a letter/non-letter classification task as well as behavioral results of classification accuracy. In the younger age group (7-8), there was a significant difference in behavioral accuracy for the TD and DYS subgroups, but this difference diminished in the older age group, suggesting the DYS group improved over time and the TD group did not. Although behavioral results on the task were similar, there were significant differences in ERP amplitudes between the DYS and TD groups at older ages, suggesting unique cognitive processing mechanisms. The authors suggest this could be related to compensatory mechanisms such as executive function. The authors have presented a robust amount of data that are very helpful to the field; however, I believe the manuscript should be improved before being accepted for publication. Specifically, I suggest more detail is provided that would help clarify the unique patterns that are present across the ERP data points. Further, I believe the authors need to provide more information, specifically in the introduction, to support their argument that these differences in ERPs may be related to executive functions. More specific comments and major revisions are included below and organized by section:
General Concept Comments and Major Revisions:
- Introduction and Literature Review – I believe the introduction, should be restructured to aid clarity. I suggest the authors use subheadings, such as Cognitive Processes of Reading, ERPs related to Print Recognition, Differences in these ERPs for DYS and TD children, and Current Study to organize the introduction.
Answer
In response to the reviewer's valuable recommendations, the introduction was restructured and rewritten, and new subsections were added.
- I suggest the authors reorganize the first couple of paragraphs of the introduction and add additional details where some are missing. From reading, I believe the first two paragraphs are meant to detail the cognitive processes that are involved in reading, specifically those related to print recognition that will be of focus for the paper. I think this can be more clearly laid out as some of the sentences are confusing, especially that on lines 50-52.
Answer
The introduction has been revised for clarity and flow.
- While I commend the authors for investigating multiple ERP components, I think it would be helpful to explicitly connect each ERP to the cognitive components of reading that are mentioned in the beginning paragraphs if possible.
Answer
Section 1.2. “ERPs Related to Print Recognition” has been added.
- If the authors want to hypothesize that the difference in the ERP components between DYS and TD kids in the older age groups, when they have similar behavioral scores, is due to EF, I think more time needs to be spent justifying this argument. I can empathize with the fact that there is a lot of EF literature to cover and that, in general, its role as a compensatory mechanism for reading in DYS children is complex and somewhat unclear, but the fact that it is only briefly touched in the introduction when it seems like it is currently written as a central hypothesis is concerning. I think it would be best to either choose to leave it as a central hypothesis and provide more detail in the introduction or to include it as future thoughts for discussion in the discussion without including it as a hypothesis. While some of the background on EF and reading is included, particularly regarding differences in activation of the frontal lobe, I think it would be beneficial to discuss what this “dysfunction” may look like within ERPs.
Answer
Thanks to the reviewers' comments, we adopted a more thorough approach to the statistical processing of the obtained data and the justification of our results. We plan to address this factor in a separate study; in this article, we excluded any assumptions regarding executive function.
- I like how the authors included some relevant literature from fMRI, but I think it would be beneficial to include a more detailed discussion of how the ERPs investigated in the paper relate to the fMRI literature.
Answer
The discussion has been revised for clarity and flow.
- Finally, I suggest the authors include a current study section, which describes (in order) the study, its specific research questions, and the authors’ hypotheses. Currently the final paragraphs list the hypotheses of the study before describing the experiment and listing the research questions.
Answer
This section was included (1.5).
- Method – The methodology is clear, but I have a couple of suggestions that I believe would enhance interpretation of the study.
- Is it common practice to use the SARS/SRQ to define dyslexia vs TD readers? If so, can citations be included? If not, I believe more of a justification is necessary. It would also be good to clarify if these DYS readers are likely to have a DYS diagnosis.
Answer
Added section 2.2.1, which provides a detailed description of the reading testing methodology.
- Results – While the abstract provides a straightforward summary of the results that help to aid interpretation, I believe the results and discussion section could be improved.
- I think it would be helpful to have each ERP listed as its own subheading in the results section and then go into age and group effects within each ERP. While this was done for the N1 (N170) the other ERPs were discussed based on their region, which was confusing to me as the reader
Answer
Each ERP had a separate subheading in the Results section. The effects of the within-subject factor Stimulus (Letter, Non-Letter) and the between-subject factors Status, Age, and their interactions were examined within each ERP.
- From some preliminary ERP work myself, I know that there is variability in when these ERP components peak due to skill, like as discussed here, and there can be a lot of nuance in interpreting these affects when aspects, like latency, vary; however, I think the authors could report how they derived the ERP time windows from the data and use extant literature to support their choices.
Answer
We clearly outlined our process for determining ERP time windows for our dataset and supported our choice with relevant literature (1.2. ERPs Related to Print Recognition, 2.4.2.2. Regions of interest, fig. 2).
- If the authors choose to create subheadings in the results section based on each ERP of interest, I think it would be nice to have the first sentence clarify where this ERP was obtained from (what electrodes) and what time frame was used (for each group and age if needed). Additionally, I think this information is presented well in the table and then also presented in the discussion, so it would just be reorganizing it for clarity in the results
Answer
Made following the recommendations.
Discussion
- I think the discussion does a good job summarizing the many results reported in the paper.
- In the paragraph found on lines 548-558, could the authors please add how this better reasoning relates to the current findings of the paper?
- As mentioned in the introduction, I suggest that if the authors choose to keep the EF part in the paper, a more substantial discussion of how the results support this hypothesis as well as what future work needs to be done to confirm this hypothesis is needed in the discussion
Answer
In light of the reviewers' recommendations, we recalculated the statistics with greater care, structured the results more clearly, and revised the discussion accordingly.
Specific Comments and Minor Revisions:
- Ln 50-52, please include this sentence in the paragraph above
- Ln 108-117, this paragraph currently does not contain any citations which I think would be beneficial to add
- Ln 643-644. There is a repeated sentence
Answer
All typos and inaccuracies have been corrected.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis is an interesting and important developmental ERP study addressing age-related changes in letter vs. non-letter processing in dyslexic (DYS) and typically developing (TD) children. The multimodal approach (behavior + ERPs), the relatively large overall N for pediatric ERP work (n = 71), and the focus on frontal as well as posterior ROIs are strengths. However, before this manuscript can be accepted, several methodological clarifications, additional (or alternative) analyses, and tempering of interpretation are required. Below I summarise the paper briefly, then give major issues (actionable), recommended analyses and checks, and a list of smaller points and editorial suggestions.
The authors tested 71 Russian-speaking children (38 DYS, 33 TD), divided into two age groups (7–8 and 9–11 years). Children performed a letter/non-letter classification task while 31-channel EEG was recorded. Behaviourally, younger TD children outperformed younger DYS children; differences diminished in older subgroups. ERP results show a print-sensitivity N1 effect in younger TD but not in DYS. Age-related trajectories diverged: TD children showed decreases in early/mid components (P1, N1, P2) and increases in late positive components (LPC) with age, whereas DYS children showed the opposite. Frontal N2/LPC differences are interpreted as related to executive function and compensatory strategies in dyslexia.
Major concerns (must be addressed):
1) Many ANOVA F-statistics report dfs such as F1,418 or F1,596 which are not immediately interpretable given N=71 (and dyadic grouping into 4 subgroups). Please correct and clearly report: (a) the exact model used, (b) numerator and denominator dfs, (c) subject/sample sizes associated with each test, and (d) whether tests are at single-electrode, ROI or time-window level. The manuscript reports numerous tests across multiple time windows and ROIs. Running many separate rmANOVAs inflates Type I error. Replace or supplement with appropriate correction procedures (see recommended analyses below). Provide a clear table or text block with the exact statistical model(s), sample sizes for each comparison, dfs, exact p-values, effect sizes with 95% CIs, and an explicit description of how multiple comparisons were controlled across ROIs, time windows and components.
2) The manuscript reports many significant effects across ROIs, age groups, components and stimulus types. It is unclear whether reported p-values survive family-wise correction across all comparisons (not only pairwise Sidak). A correction across time-electrode space (or use of cluster-based permutation tests) is the recommended approach for ERP data. Re-run key ERP analyses using cluster-based permutation tests across time and electrodes (or at least across time within ROIs) to identify significant spatio-temporal clusters that survive control for multiple comparisons. At minimum report FDR-adjusted p-values or Bonferroni-corrected thresholds across the number of tests performed.
3) The paper uses component labels inconsistently (N1 vs N170; N300 vs N2, etc.) and time windows appear shifted (e.g., posterior N1 reported at 200–280 ms with peak ~240 ms). These choices may be valid for children (latencies are often delayed) but require justification and consistent naming. Peaks and time windows should be defined a priori or with a data-driven procedure (e.g. peak detection within pre-specified windows, or mass univariate tests). (a) Provide clear rationale for component time windows and naming conventions in children (cite developmental latency literature). (b) Consider presenting both peak-based and mean-amplitude (fixed-window) analyses to ensure robustness. (c) Use consistent component labels throughout.
4) The manuscript states ICA was used to remove ocular and myographic components and that artifact-containing epochs were visually rejected. However, details are missing: how many ICA components removed on average; how many epochs rejected per subject/group; were ERP results sensitive to the number of trials? Low-frequency components and frontal channels are particularly vulnerable to movement and muscle/speech artifacts — this is critical given the frontal N2/LPC interpretations. Motor responses (left/right button) were used; handedness and motor lateralization can influence frontal and central ERPs. Provide explicit preprocessing details: average trials retained per condition (already partly provided), average trials rejected, number and criteria for ICA component rejection, whether results change when excluding subjects with low trial counts. Report whether handedness was recorded and test whether response mapping or handedness affected ERP amplitudes (or include as covariate). If possible, perform control analyses that exclude epochs during or immediately after motor response to check for motor contamination.
5) The TD subgroups show much higher SRQ means than DYS, as expected, but the groups are not matched on reading ability (by definition). However, many ERP differences may be driven by continuous reading skill or attention rather than categorical diagnosis. Also the subgroups are somewhat imbalanced (TD2 n=14, TD1 n=19, DYS1 n=20, DYS2 n=18). Potential confounds (IQ, attention/ADHD symptoms, SES, comorbid language impairment) are not reported. (a) Re-run key ERP analyses with SRQ (reading fluency) as a covariate (or use mixed-effects regression with SRQ and age as predictors) to test whether effects remain after accounting for reading skill. (b) If data on IQ, attention, or comorbidity exist, include them as covariates or report group comparisons. (c) Report and discuss group sample sizes and imbalance explicitly.
6) The claim that increased frontal N2 in DYS reflects decreased executive function is plausible but speculative without direct EF measurements. Executive function deficits are heterogeneous; without behavioral EF measures (working memory, inhibition), this remains a conjecture. Temper causal language. Ideally include correlations between frontal ERP indices and independent measures of EF (if collected) or SRQ. If such measures were not collected, explicitly state this as a limitation and avoid strong claims linking ERP differences to EF deficits.
7) The authors make developmental claims (e.g., redistribution of resources with automatization) from cross-sectional data. This is acceptable if framed cautiously, but the manuscript sometimes implies longitudinal inference. Rephrase to avoid implying longitudinal change. Emphasize cross-sectional nature and propose longitudinal follow-up (you mention planned longitudinal work — highlight it as necessary to distinguish delay vs atypical trajectory).
Minor points:
- Make component labels and latency windows consistent and justify any delayed latencies given that the sample consists of children.
- Specify the exact ERP baseline period used for averaging and report whether baseline differences across groups were tested.
- Clarify the recording and offline filtering by stating the rationale for recording at 0.53 to 70 Hz and then applying an offline 0.3 to 30 Hz filter and describe the order in which filters were applied.
- Describe the EOG preprocessing method and state whether vertical and horizontal EOG regression or independent component analysis was used for ocular artifact removal and report how blink rates compared between groups.
- Provide full trial count statistics including the distribution, the minimum number of trials retained per condition, and whether any subjects were excluded for having too few trials.
- Report normality test outcomes from the Shapiro Wilk test and sphericity test outcomes from Mauchly including Greenhouse Geisser epsilon values when sphericity was violated and explain how multiple comparisons were controlled.
- In figures and tables include the sample size N for each subgroup and indicate which comparisons were corrected for multiple testing and consider adding scalp topographies for key components to visually support the region of interest claims.
- Avoid asserting that the N1 effect follows an inverted U shape unless you present multiple age points that map the full curve because two age groups are insufficient to support that claim.
- Report handedness counts and if there were no left handed children state that explicitly.
- Shorten and streamline long repetitive sentences in the Results and Discussion to improve clarity and readability.
All in all, this manuscript addresses an important question and contains promising results. However, before it can be accepted it requires major revisions: clearer and correct statistical reporting; more robust control for multiple comparisons; clearer and justified component/time-window definitions; transparency about preprocessing and artifact rejection; additional analyses (cluster permutation and/or mixed models) to establish robustness; and tempering of causal interpretations (especially linking frontal effects to executive functions without EF measures). If the authors perform the recommended analyses, clarify methods, and moderate speculative claims, the paper would make an important contribution to developmental cognitive neuroscience of reading and dyslexia.
Author Response
Answers to the Reviewer 2
We are deeply grateful to Reviewer 2 for their thorough and insightful evaluation of our manuscript and for the many constructive suggestions that have substantially improved the quality of our work. We sincerely appreciate the reviewer’s attention to methodological detail and statistical rigor, which prompted us to revise the statistical design, clarify and expand the Methods section, and rewrite the Results section for greater transparency and coherence. We carefully considered all comments and have implemented the recommended analyses and clarifications. Below, we address each point in detail and describe the corresponding revisions made throughout the manuscript.
1) Many ANOVA F-statistics report dfs such as F1,418 or F1,596 which are not immediately interpretable given N=71 (and dyadic grouping into 4 subgroups). Please correct and clearly report: (a) the exact model used, (b) numerator and denominator dfs, (c) subject/sample sizes associated with each test, and (d) whether tests are at single-electrode, ROI or time-window level. The manuscript reports numerous tests across multiple time windows and ROIs. Running many separate rmANOVAs inflates Type I error. Replace or supplement with appropriate correction procedures (see recommended analyses below). Provide a clear table or text block with the exact statistical model(s), sample sizes for each comparison, dfs, exact p-values, effect sizes with 95% CIs, and an explicit description of how multiple comparisons were controlled across ROIs, time windows and components.
Answer
First of all, we would like to thank the reviewer for the careful reading and suggestions for revision. We thoroughly reviewed the relevant literature and consulted with colleagues to determine the most adequate statistical model for our study design and hypothesis. Thanks to your recommendations, we conducted additional statistical analyses, which enabled us to more accurately estimate the effects in our study. The corresponding changes have been made to the Methodology section.
A mixed-design ANOVA was conducted with Stimuli (letters, non-letters) as the within-subjects factor, and Status (TD, DYS) and Age (7-8 / 9-11 years old) as between-subjects factors, separately for regions of interest (ROIs) in the left and right hemispheres. The ROIs included the occipito-parieto-temporal cortex (left: P3, T5, O1; right: P4, T6, O2) and the inferior frontal cortex (left: F7, F3, FT3, FC3; right: F8, F4, FT4, FC4). The influence of within- and between-subject factors was assessed using the mean amplitudes of components calculated at half-maximum for each ROI.
Component latencies were determined for the frontal and occipital-temporal-parietal ROIs based on literature data and the dataset from this study. The latencies observed were as follows: P 120-180 ms, N 200-252 ms, P 300-400 ms, N 440-560 ms, and P 640-680 ms for the occipito-parieto-temporal cortex (left: P3, T5, O1; right: P4, T6, O2). For the inferior frontal cortex, the latencies were N 132-184 ms, P 224-284 ms, N 336-448 ms, and P 520-868 ms (left: F7, F3, FT3, FC3; right: F8, F4, FT4, FC4). To identify intragroup differences, a post-hoc Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons was applied.
2) The manuscript reports many significant effects across ROIs, age groups, components and stimulus types. It is unclear whether reported p-values survive family-wise correction across all comparisons (not only pairwise Sidak). A correction across time-electrode space (or use of cluster-based permutation tests) is the recommended approach for ERP data. Re-run key ERP analyses using cluster-based permutation tests across time and electrodes (or at least across time within ROIs) to identify significant spatio-temporal clusters that survive control for multiple comparisons. At minimum report FDR-adjusted p-values or Bonferroni-corrected thresholds across the number of tests performed.
Answer
We agree with the concerns regarding the large number of effects we previously obtained. To ensure a proper analysis, we conducted a mixed-design ANOVA with Stimuli (letters, non-letters) as the within-subjects factor, and Status (TD, DYS) and Age (7-8 / 9-11 years old) as between-subjects factors, as described in the answer to Question 1. We averaged data across electrodes within ROIs to avoid inflating the significance of differences. The relevant changes are reflected in Sections Methods 2.4, 2.3, and Results (3.2). At the reviewer's recommendation, we applied the Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons. Since some results from the original version were not confirmed, and others were modified, we significantly revised the Introduction, Discussion, and Conclusion.
3) The paper uses component labels inconsistently (N1 vs N170; N300 vs N2, etc.) and time windows appear shifted (e.g., posterior N1 reported at 200–280 ms with peak ~240 ms). These choices may be valid for children (latencies are often delayed) but require justification and consistent naming. Peaks and time windows should be defined a priori or with a data-driven procedure (e.g. peak detection within pre-specified windows, or mass univariate tests). (a) Provide clear rationale for component time windows and naming conventions in children (cite developmental latency literature). (b) Consider presenting both peak-based and mean-amplitude (fixed-window) analyses to ensure robustness. (c) Use consistent component labels throughout.
Answer
We have changed the component names and provided rationales for the latency changes in relation to generally accepted standards. An additional subsection has been added to the Introduction (1.5) Methods section (2.4.2.2., Fig. 2), to more clearly identify all the components being described. The rationale for components’ latencies in children is detailed in Section 1.2.
4) The manuscript states ICA was used to remove ocular and myographic components and that artifact-containing epochs were visually rejected. However, details are missing: how many ICA components removed on average; how many epochs rejected per subject/group; were ERP results sensitive to the number of trials? Low-frequency components and frontal channels are particularly vulnerable to movement and muscle/speech artifacts — this is critical given the frontal N2/LPC interpretations. Motor responses (left/right button) were used; handedness and motor lateralization can influence frontal and central ERPs. Provide explicit preprocessing details: average trials retained per condition (already partly provided), average trials rejected, number and criteria for ICA component rejection, whether results change when excluding subjects with low trial counts. Report whether handedness was recorded and test whether response mapping or handedness affected ERP amplitudes (or include as covariate). If possible, perform control analyses that exclude epochs during or immediately after motor response to check for motor contamination.
Answer
We averaged 99.5 ± 15.7 for letters and 101.8 ± 17.4 for non-letters, both derived from artifact-free trials for each stimulus type, as described at 2.4.2.1. On average, 2 to 4 ICA components were removed for each entry.
We excluded one TD subject from the ERP analysis due to EEG artifacts, resulting in the analysis of 71 records, described at lines 174-175.
Vertical eye movements are most prominently reflected in the Fp1 and Fp2 channels. Therefore, we excluded these channels when analyzing the frontal leads, focusing our region of interest (ROI) on channels F3 (F4), FC3 (FC4), F7 (F8), and FT7 (FT8). To reduce the impact of vertical and horizontal movements, as well as blinks, we employed Independent Component Analysis (ICA), selecting the component that most accurately represented the localization of oculomotor activity by topographically matching the leads Fp1, Fp2, and Fpz. Consequently, the aforementioned channels were not included in the averaging across the frontal ROIs, even after the cleaning process.
The number of selected ICA components ranged from 2 to 4. Specifically, 1 to 2 components were allocated to vertical eye movements and blinks in the frontal leads (for example see togogramm 1 on fig. below), 1 component was allocated to horizontal eye movements in the anterior temporal leads (for example see togogram 4 on fig. below), and 1 component was assigned to occipital activity or to address local canal noise if it occurred.
No differences were observed in the number of artifacts removed between dyslexic children and typically developing children (U = 1842.5, p = 0.9). Therefore, no subjects were excluded from the group due to a high number of artifacts. This is likely because the stimulus presentation time of 500 ms was intentionally chosen to exceed the average duration required for simple stimulus recognition, as indicated in the literature. Additionally, the poststimulus and interstimulus intervals (see study design) during which the subjects made a motor response were extended. This extension was intentional to ensure that time would not be a limiting factor for individuals with dyslexia.
The test design incorporated a motor response time to minimize the contribution of the motor component to the presented stimulus. Event-related potentials (ERPs) were analyzed from the onset of stimulus presentation to 1000 ms, and the motor response was recorded from 100 to 2100 ms. On average, the motor response time for individuals with dyslexia was 768 ± 136 ms, compared to 743 ± 158 ms for typically developing individuals. This design effectively neutralized the influence of the motor components described in the study.
We did not analyze the statistical differences in the number of blinks among the subgroups separately.
There were a total of 248 trials, with the number of correct trials indicated in the article (p. 0000000). We deemed it unnecessary to include rejected trials. The percentage of artifacts (rejected trials) was 0.85±2.6% in dyslexics and 0.5±1.5% in typically developing (TD) individuals. No statistical differences were found between the groups or subgroups regarding these indicators. This information was excluded from the article to enhance readability.
The average number of trials depends on the effect size and study design. In studies involving children, it is essential to establish a minimum number of trials sufficient to avoid detecting the fatigue effect. Most cognitive studies use 30 to 50 trials for averaging (for example Amodio DM, Bartholow BD, Ito TA. Tracking the dynamics of the social brain: ERP approaches for social cognitive and affective neuroscience. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2014 Mar;9(3):385-93. doi: 10.1093/scan/nst177. Epub 2013 Dec 5. PMID: 24319116; PMCID: PMC3980796.).
All subjects were right-handed. Trials were designed so that half of the subjects responded to each response type with their right hand for the Letter and their left hand for the Symbol, while the other half did the opposite. This approach was implemented to neutralize lateral preferences among the subjects. (Relevant information was added to the text of the article 2.2.3.) Trials in which the motor response corresponded to the analyzed portion of the ERP were excluded from the analysis.
5) The TD subgroups show much higher SRQ means than DYS, as expected, but the groups are not matched on reading ability (by definition). However, many ERP differences may be driven by continuous reading skill or attention rather than categorical diagnosis. Also the subgroups are somewhat imbalanced (TD2 n=14, TD1 n=19, DYS1 n=20, DYS2 n=18). Potential confounds (IQ, attention/ADHD symptoms, SES, comorbid language impairment) are not reported. (a) Re-run key ERP analyses with SRQ (reading fluency) as a covariate (or use mixed-effects regression with SRQ and age as predictors) to test whether effects remain after accounting for reading skill. (b) If data on IQ, attention, or comorbidity exist, include them as covariates or report group comparisons. (c) Report and discuss group sample sizes and imbalance explicitly.
Answer:
Reviewer 2 correctly notes that groups of children with dyslexia differ from TD groups in terms of reading skills, which may affect some ERP indicators. This difference is consistent with the main objective of this study, which is to assess the state of the brain mechanisms involved in processing printed text. It is correctly noted that in addition to the categorical diagnosis of “dyslexia,” i.e., a specific reading disorder, or learning disorders related to reading disability, children usually have comorbid symptoms and deficits. These vary among children with this diagnosis. This part of the variance is extremely difficult to control, and scientists usually simply accept it as a fact. Our subjects did not have any serious speech impairments. ADHD symptoms, comorbid language impairment, and intellectual disability were exclusion criteria. Socioeconomic status was not evaluated. In the Methods and Subjects section, we added information about the subjects' reading abilities and specified the exclusion criteria for speech disorders.
Regarding subgroup imbalance in age-related studies involving children, it is not uncommon for group sizes to differ. For instance, in the study by Hasko et al. (2013), the DD group consisted of 52 participants, while the control group had only 29. (Hasko S, Groth K, Bruder J, Bartling J, Schulte-Körne G. The time course of reading processes in children with and without dyslexia: an ERP study. Front Hum Neurosci. 2013 Oct 7;7:570. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2013.00570. PMID: 24109444; PMCID: PMC3791381).In Miki et al., 2015 The 82 subjects were divided into 6 age groups; i.e., into 8-year-olds (n = 11, 3 males, mean age: 8.6 ± 0.24-years-old), 9-year-olds (n = 17, 7 males, mean age: 9.4 ± 0.22-years-old), 10-year-olds (n = 15, 10 males, mean age: 10.2 ± 0.15-years-old), 11-year-olds (n = 12, 4 males, mean age: 11.1 ± 0.27-years-old), 12-year-olds (n = 10, 7 males, mean age: 12.5 ± 0.20-years-old), and 13-year-olds (n = 17, 8 males, mean age: 13.4 ± 0.30-years-old). (Miki K, Honda Y, Takeshima Y, Watanabe S, Kakigi R. Differential age-related changes in N170 responses to upright faces, inverted faces, and eyes in Japanese children. Front Hum Neurosci. 2015 Jun 2;9:263. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2015.00263. PMID: 26082700; PMCID: PMC4451338). In Wang et al, 2023 3 groups presented: 15 kindergarteners (11 males, m = 5.9 years, s = 0.4 years), 16 first graders (9 males, m = 6.9 years, s = 0.3 years, and 17 second graders (7 males, m = 7.6 years, s = 0.3 years) (Wang F, Nguyen QTH, Kaneshiro B, Hasak L, Wang AM, Toomarian EY, Norcia AM, McCandliss BD. Lexical and sublexical cortical tuning for print revealed by Steady-State Visual Evoked Potentials (SSVEPs) in early readers. Dev Sci. 2023 Jul;26(4):e13352. doi: 10.1111/desc.13352. Epub 2022 Dec 8. PMID: 36413170; PMCID: PMC10881121.
Small differences in the sizes of subgroups, as we have, are acceptable because ANOVA automatically accounts for these variations when calculating the F statistics. Group sample sizes and imbalance explicitly discussed in Limitation section
6) The claim that increased frontal N2 in DYS reflects decreased executive function is plausible but speculative without direct EF measurements. Executive function deficits are heterogeneous; without behavioral EF measures (working memory, inhibition), this remains a conjecture. Temper causal language. Ideally include correlations between frontal ERP indices and independent measures of EF (if collected) or SRQ. If such measures were not collected, explicitly state this as a limitation and avoid strong claims linking ERP differences to EF deficits.
Answer: Thanks to the reviewer's comments, we adopted a more rigorous approach to substantiating our findings. We plan to control for this factor in a separate study; in this article, we have removed any speculation regarding executive function.
7) The authors make developmental claims (e.g., redistribution of resources with automatization) from cross-sectional data. This is acceptable if framed cautiously, but the manuscript sometimes implies longitudinal inference. Rephrase to avoid implying longitudinal change. Emphasize cross-sectional nature and propose longitudinal follow-up (you mention planned longitudinal work — highlight it as necessary to distinguish delay vs atypical trajectory).
Answer: We agree with the reviewer that longitudinal studies, in addition to cross-sectional ones, are essential for drawing conclusions about developmental trajectory. We have softened the wording of our conclusions and included these as limitations in a dedicated section.
Minor points:
- Make component labels and latency windows consistent and justify any delayed latencies given that the sample consists of children.
Done. Section Methods
- Specify the exact ERP baseline period used for averaging and report whether baseline differences across groups were tested.
Done 2.4.2.1.
- Clarify the recording and offline filtering by stating the rationale for recording at 0.53 to 70 Hz and then applying an offline 0.3 to 30 Hz filter and describe the order in which filters were applied.
Done 2.4.2.1.
- Describe the EOG preprocessing method and state whether vertical and horizontal EOG regression or independent component analysis was used for ocular artifact removal and report how blink rates compared between groups.
Done 2.4.2.1. except blink rates.
- Provide full trial count statistics including the distribution, the minimum number of trials retained per condition, and whether any subjects were excluded for having too few trials.
Done 2.4.2.1.
- Report normality test outcomes from the Shapiro Wilk test and sphericity test outcomes from Mauchly including Greenhouse Geisser epsilon values when sphericity was violated and explain how multiple comparisons were controlled.
Done 2.4.2.3. After consulting with a data analysis specialist, it was clarified that Mauchly's sphericity is not assessed in this analysis design due to the numerous comparisons involved.
- In figures and tables include the sample size N for each subgroup and indicate which comparisons were corrected for multiple testing and consider adding scalp topographies for key components to visually support the region of interest claims.
Done Figs 4-6.
- Avoid asserting that the N1 effect follows an inverted U shape unless you present multiple age points that map the full curve because two age groups are insufficient to support that claim.
This data are according literature, corresponding citation is provided
- Report handedness counts and if there were no left handed children state that explicitly.
Done
- Shorten and streamline long repetitive sentences in the Results and Discussion to improve clarity and readability.
We have significantly revised the text of the article
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsPrint exposure interaction with neural tuning on letter/non-letter processing during literacy acquisition: An ERP study on dyslexic and typically developing children
Languages
Revision 2
Summary Statement: I appreciate the time the authors have taken to make the adjustments that were previously recommended. I believe the revisions the authors made improved the manuscript, particularly its scope. I appreciate that the authors took the suggestions of adding section headings and designating a current study section, which flows very logically, in the introduction. Further, I believe the results and discussion are much improved, particularly in how the many results are clearly synthesized before being related to the general literature more broadly. However, below I list areas that I believe should be improved before the article is accepted for publication. Most of the revisions include providing more detail and context in the introduction and discussion as well as clarifying some patterns of results.
Additional Revisions
- Introduction
- Could you please provide explicit reasoning for why these factors need to be studied in Russian. Although I agree that all languages need to be uniquely studied, I think your rationale should be explicitly listed for the reader’s understanding (Ln 234 and ln 304).
- You indicate how it is relatively transparent in ln 298 but this should be introduced earlier and expanded upon in section 1.4
- Thank you for revising the manuscript to include section 1.2. I think this greatly helps clarify the rest of the paper. I have a couple of suggestions on how it can be even further improved:
- Sentence 245 should come before you introduce the individual components. It could be followed by a brief description of what ERPs are and how they are used to understand the cognitive processes of reading
- Could you please provide more information about the N/P150? How is it thought to be different than the N170? Also in that paragraph, what are the reduced amplitude of these early components in dyslexic readers though to reflect (broadly as you go into this later)? (ln 248)
- I think the description of the P2, N3, and LPC is great, but a sentence indicating how these ERPs are altered or thought to be altered in relation to dyslexia would be beneficial (I know this is expanded on in section 1.3)
- In section 1.3, can you please provide more detail about how these patterns of functional impairments are related to dyslexia? (ln 285)
- I like the addition of section 1.4, could you please indicate on line 300-301 why disruptions in integration, reanalysis, and higher-order cognitive control may also be related to dyslexia – are you connecting this to compensatory mechanisms as suggested in aim 3?
- In the current study section, please briefly describe the general pattern of developmental changes Di Pietro and colleagues (2023) observed (lns 319-322)
- Also in this section, please list hypotheses, even if general, for each of the listed aims
- Could you please provide explicit reasoning for why these factors need to be studied in Russian. Although I agree that all languages need to be uniquely studied, I think your rationale should be explicitly listed for the reader’s understanding (Ln 234 and ln 304).
- Method
- I think it would be beneficial to list the p values for the group differences that are listed in text, in Table 1 to help the reader. Would it be possible to change the overall column headings to Time 1 and Time 2 before changing the column order to: TD1, DYS1 (p value); TD2, DYS2 (p value)?
- In section 2.4.2.3 – Ln 518, the names of the components are not listed when describing the time windows, also later on in that paragraph the authors indicate the time windows for each ERP were determined 2 ways which made me confused as the reader
- In section 2.4.2.3, please clarify what type of statistical analysis was conducted (ln 539)
- Results
- For all results, I think it would be beneficial to label the within-subject factor as within-subject factor of stimulus type (or stimulus type alone).
- For section 3.2.5, was there an interaction between stimulus type * status (DYS or TD)? The authors say there was a nonsignificant interaction, but indicate the effect was more pronounced in the DYS than in TD. This deserves more clarification.
- If the authors are describing descriptive effects within the stimulus contrast, please list this explicitly while confirming there is no significant interaction effect. This should be similarly clarified for all results and group comparisons.
- Discussion
- This is the first instance where print experience and schooling are brought up. In the introduction, the authors discuss aging but do not include any background on how aging relates to schooling and greater print experience. Could you please make these connections more explicit and explain why print experience and schooling are thought to affect the ERP amplitudes of choice?
- Ln 896, can you please elaborate more on what you mean here? I agree your results indicate early tuning to print occurs for both groups, but would be interested to hear more about what you think goes on differently later – you hit at it with the consolidation, but a more detailed interpretation and hypothesis would be helpful to the reader
- In ln 1139, please cite sources that corroborate this interpretation and include context that more research is needed to confirm this hypothesis
Minor Revisions
- Ln 223, the word “into” is written twice
- Ln 239, occupy should be changed to occupies
- Ln 231 needs a citation. It would also be great if you could connect this sentence to the previous one more clearly
- Ln 264, should have a comma after “in contrast to adults,”
- Ln 290, is confusing to read
- Ln 310, number the aims
- Ln 339, please include the mean age of participants and the standard deviation
- Ln 389, the number 2 is used twice
- Ln 857, the “is” should be changed to “are”… These data are in concordance
- Ln 945, “In the frontal ROI” is repeated twice
- Ln 948, sentence needs clarification,
- Ln 954, sentence is repeated twice
Again, I thank the authors for taking the time to respond to the previous comments in detail. I hope the authors agree that the suggested revisions will further improve the manuscript. I look forward to seeing an updated version.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
We sincerely appreciate the Reviewer 1 for his/her thoughtful and constructive feedback, which has significantly enhanced the clarity, rigor, and overall quality of our work. In response, we have made comprehensive revisions to the manuscript.
Introduction
- Could you please provide explicit reasoning for why these factors need to be studied in Russian. Although I agree that all languages need to be uniquely studied, I think your rationale should be explicitly listed for the reader’s understanding (Ln 234 and ln 304).
Answer: A paragraph discussing the peculiarities of the Russian language was added to section 1.1.
- You indicate how it is relatively transparent in ln 298 but this should be introduced earlier and expanded upon in section 1.4
Answer: It was added to section 1.1.
- Thank you for revising the manuscript to include section 1.2. I think this greatly helps clarify the rest of the paper. I have a couple of suggestions on how it can be even further improved:
Sentence 245 should come before you introduce the individual components. It could be followed by a brief description of what ERPs are and how they are used to understand the cognitive processes of reading
Answer: We have added an explanation (1.2).
- Could you please provide more information about the N/P150? How is it thought to be different than the N170? Also in that paragraph, what are the reduced amplitude of these early components in dyslexic readers though to reflect (broadly as you go into this later)? (ln 248)
Answer: We formulated it more clearly (1.2).
- I think the description of the P2, N3, and LPC is great, but a sentence indicating how these ERPs are altered or thought to be altered in relation to dyslexia would be beneficial (I know this is expanded on in section 1.3)
Answer: We have added an explanation (1.2).
- In section 1.3, can you please provide more detail about how these patterns of functional impairments are related to dyslexia? (ln 285)
Answer: Done.
- I like the addition of section 1.4, could you please indicate on line 300-301 why disruptions in integration, reanalysis, and higher-order cognitive control may also be related to dyslexia – are you connecting this to compensatory mechanisms as suggested in aim 3?
Answer: A detailed explanation of the mechanisms was provided in paragraph 1.3. We added information on dyslexia in paragraph 1.4.
- In the current study section, please briefly describe the general pattern of developmental changes Di Pietro and colleagues (2023) observed (lns 319-322)
Answer: Done
- Also in this section, please list hypotheses, even if general, for each of the listed aims
Answer: Done
Method
- I think it would be beneficial to list the p values for the group differences that are listed in text, in Table 1 to help the reader. Would it be possible to change the overall column headings to Time 1 and Time 2 before changing the column order to: TD1, DYS1 (p value); TD2, DYS2 (p value)?
Answer: We agree that it is customary to present the most complete data in a table. However, we believe that rearranging the columns of Table 1 and introducing a column for between-group differences is inappropriate in this case, as the vast majority of values will be unreliable and could visually clutter the table. Therefore, only reliable values have been included in the table.
- In section 2.4.2.3 – Ln 518, the names of the components are not listed when describing the time windows, also later on in that paragraph the authors indicate the time windows for each ERP were determined 2 ways which made me confused as the reader
Answer: The names of the components and their time intervals are listed in Section 2.4.2.2, which was created specifically for this purpose. The text regarding the determination of time intervals in this study has been rewritten for greater clarity to avoid the impression that there were two methods rather than two stages.
- In section 2.4.2.3, please clarify what type of statistical analysis was conducted (ln 539)
Answer: A statistical analysis was run in IBM SPSS Statistics version 26. The data were tested for normal distribution using the Shapiro-Wilk test (p = 0.2), Levene's test was used to assess the equality of variances (homogeneity of variance) for a variable across groups (p = 0.5). A mixed-design ANOVA was conducted with Stimuli (letters, non-letters) as the within-subjects factor and Status (TD, DYS) and Age (7-8 years old, 9-11 years old) as between-subjects factors, separately for the ROIs in the left and right hemispheres. Statistical analysis of within- and between-subject effects was performed on the mean amplitude of each component. To identify intragroup differences the Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons was used.
Results
- For all results, I think it would be beneficial to label the within-subject factor as within-subject factor of stimulus type (or stimulus type alone).
Answer: Done
- For section 3.2.5, was there an interaction between stimulus type * status (DYS or TD)? The authors say there was a nonsignificant interaction, but indicate the effect was more pronounced in the DYS than in TD. This deserves more clarification.
Answer: We added a description of the absence of an interaction effect between factors to the results subsections (3.2.2., 3.2.3., 3.2.5.).
3.2.2. “A significant main effect of stimulus type was found. To further explore this effect, simple effects analyses were conducted. The absence of a significant interaction between stimulus type and status indicates that the notable difference between letters and non-letters is a consistent pattern observed across younger children, although the magnitude of this effect varies”.
- If the authors are describing descriptive effects within the stimulus contrast, please list this explicitly while confirming there is no significant interaction effect. This should be similarly clarified for all results and group comparisons.
Answer: We have noted in the text that there is no significant interaction effect between Stimulus Type and Status.
Discussion
- This is the first instance where print experience and schooling are brought up. In the introduction, the authors discuss aging but do not include any background on how aging relates to schooling and greater print experience. Could you please make these connections more explicit and explain why print experience and schooling are thought to affect the ERP amplitudes of choice?
Answer: We added brief information on schooling affected ERPs in 1.2.
- Ln 896, can you please elaborate more on what you mean here? I agree your results indicate early tuning to print occurs for both groups, but would be interested to hear more about what you think goes on differently later – you hit at it with the consolidation, but a more detailed interpretation and hypothesis would be helpful to the reader
Answer: We added an explanation: “Typical readers efficiently integrate, reanalyze, and consolidate these representations, resulting in more robust and automated reading networks. In contrast, individuals with dyslexia may depend more on laborious and general control processes rather than efficient, specialized circuits. This is consistent with previous ERP and fMRI findings showing reduced late frontal positivity and atypical frontotemporal connections [71].”
- In ln 1139, please cite sources that corroborate this interpretation and include context that more research is needed to confirm this hypothesis
Answer: Done
Minor Revisions
- Ln 223, the word “into” is written twice
Answer: Done
- Ln 239, occupy should be changed to occupies
Answer: Done
- Ln 231 needs a citation. It would also be great if you could connect this sentence to the previous one more clearly
Answer: Done
- Ln 264, should have a comma after “in contrast to adults,”
Answer: Done
- Ln 290, is confusing to read
Answer:A clarification about U-shaped developmental trajectories has been added above in In 72-75.
- Ln 310, number the aims
Answer: Done
- Ln 339, please include the mean age of participants and the standard deviation
Answer: Done
- Ln 389, the number 2 is used twice
Answer: Done
- Ln 857, the “is” should be changed to “are”… These data are in concordance
Answer:Done
- Ln 945, “In the frontal ROI” is repeated twice
Answer: Done
- Ln 948, sentence needs clarification,
Answer: Done
- Ln 954, sentence is repeated twice
Answer: Done
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsI would like to sincerely thank the authors for their extensive and thoughtful revisions in response to my earlier comments. The revised manuscript demonstrates a clear and substantial improvement in methodological transparency, statistical rigor, and overall clarity of presentation.
I appreciate the authors’ careful attention to the issues raised regarding the ANOVA design, correction for multiple comparisons, component labeling, and artifact control. The detailed description of preprocessing steps, inclusion of ROI-based averaging, and the use of appropriate correction procedures (Bonferroni) considerably strengthen the reliability of the reported ERP results. The updated Methods and Results sections are now well structured and coherent.
The authors have also addressed broader conceptual points — for example, by tempering causal claims regarding executive functions, clarifying the cross-sectional nature of the study, and explicitly discussing limitations and future longitudinal directions. These revisions reflect a responsible and scientifically rigorous approach.
Minor issues, such as component naming consistency, reporting of baseline and filtering parameters, and sample size specifications, have been carefully resolved. Figures are clearer and more informative, and the manuscript reads much more fluently overall.
In summary, I find that all major and minor concerns have been adequately addressed, and the revised version meets the standards for publication. I commend the authors for the diligence, transparency, and precision with which they have implemented the revisions.
Author Response
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the exceptionally thoughtful and encouraging evaluation of our revised manuscript. We deeply appreciate the time and care invested in re-examining the paper, as well as the constructive guidance provided throughout the review process.
We are pleased that the expanded methodological description, clarification of the statistical procedures, and refinements to ERP component labeling and preprocessing were found to enhance the transparency and robustness of the work. The reviewer’s comments played an important role in helping us strengthen the rigor and clarity of the analyses and presentation.
We are also grateful for the reviewer’s acknowledgement of the conceptual revisions. The suggestions regarding causal interpretation, executive function terminology, and the limitations of cross-sectional work significantly improved the precision and balance of the discussion. We hope that the added remarks on future longitudinal directions and developmental mechanisms will contribute to the broader field.
Finally, we appreciate the recognition of the improvements to figures, terminology consistency, and overall readability. It was our priority to address every point raised as carefully and systematically as possible, and we are pleased that the revisions have contributed positively to the manuscript.
We would like to express our sincere gratitude once again for the reviewer’s constructive engagement and supportive evaluation. The feedback has substantially improved the quality of the final paper.
Round 3
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsPrint exposure interaction with neural tuning on letter/non-letter processing during literacy acquisition: An ERP study on dyslexic and typically developing children
Languages
Revision 3
Summary Statement: I appreciate the time the authors have taken to make the adjustments that were previously recommended. I believe the revisions the authors made have further improved the manuscript. I appreciate that the authors addressed the additional comments. Below are additional revisions that I believe should be addressed before the article is accepted for publication. I believe the authors did a great job summarizing all of the findings in the discussion in a way that helps the reader get the key take aways from the paper.
Introduction
- Combine the first two paragraphs in section 1.1. Thank you for adding information about the importance of studying these factors in Russian; however, I think the structure of these first paragraphs in the introduction should be reworked to aid readability
- On line 195, please provide more detail about the ERPs the authors emphasized as being important predictors of dyslexia
- Also in this section, I would change the wording of line 215 to say “integration, reanalysis, and higher-order cognitive control are IMPLICATED IN rather than affected by dyslexia”.
- In the research gaps section, I would remove line 219 as you already mention in the first research gap sentence, that this is understudied in Russian
- In current study section, can you clarify research question and hypothesis 1? Did you expect the named ERPs to show discrete patterns based on TD or Dys grouping? Or was your research question to determine that the same ERP components in TD children will be those used for print recognition in children with dyslexia? A third option would be that you wanted to describe what each of these components looked like in TD and Dys groups.
Methods
- Can you cite the threshold you used to determine which participants were removed due to having too many artifacts?
Results
- On line 480, change “less amplitude” to “lower amplitude”
- Also in this same sentence (line 482) clarify the part of the sentence: “the younger children demonstrated a tendency for higher amplitude in the older children” I think the “in” should be replaced with “than”
- Can you cite a study that supports you finding an N170 that peaks at 228ms. In the introduction, you mention that this component is delayed in children, but it would be nice to include a statement such as “As in XXX paper, we found the N170 occurred between 200-252ms.
Discussion
- Line 669, please spell out GFP as I believe this is the first time it is mentioned
- Line 779, can you please cite more sources? You mention several existing findings but then only cite one source
Print exposure interaction with neural tuning on letter/non-letter processing during literacy acquisition: An ERP study on dyslexic and typically developing children
Languages
Revision 3
Summary Statement: I appreciate the time the authors have taken to make the adjustments that were previously recommended. I believe the revisions the authors made have further improved the manuscript. I appreciate that the authors addressed the additional comments. Below are additional revisions that I believe should be addressed before the article is accepted for publication. I believe the authors did a great job summarizing all of the findings in the discussion in a way that helps the reader get the key take aways from the paper.
Introduction
- Combine the first two paragraphs in section 1.1. Thank you for adding information about the importance of studying these factors in Russian; however, I think the structure of these first paragraphs in the introduction should be reworked to aid readability
- On line 195, please provide more detail about the ERPs the authors emphasized as being important predictors of dyslexia
- Also in this section, I would change the wording of line 215 to say “integration, reanalysis, and higher-order cognitive control are IMPLICATED IN rather than affected by dyslexia”.
- In the research gaps section, I would remove line 219 as you already mention in the first research gap sentence, that this is understudied in Russian
- In current study section, can you clarify research question and hypothesis 1? Did you expect the named ERPs to show discrete patterns based on TD or Dys grouping? Or was your research question to determine that the same ERP components in TD children will be those used for print recognition in children with dyslexia? A third option would be that you wanted to describe what each of these components looked like in TD and Dys groups.
Methods
- Can you cite the threshold you used to determine which participants were removed due to having too many artifacts?
Results
- On line 480, change “less amplitude” to “lower amplitude”
- Also in this same sentence (line 482) clarify the part of the sentence: “the younger children demonstrated a tendency for higher amplitude in the older children” I think the “in” should be replaced with “than”
- Can you cite a study that supports you finding an N170 that peaks at 228ms. In the introduction, you mention that this component is delayed in children, but it would be nice to include a statement such as “As in XXX paper, we found the N170 occurred between 200-252ms.
Discussion
- Line 669, please spell out GFP as I believe this is the first time it is mentioned
- Line 779, can you please cite more sources? You mention several existing findings but then only cite one source
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
I noticed some typos throughout the manuscript, so I suggest proofreading thoroughly before the next submission. I pointed out some of the errors but likely did not catch all of them.
Author Response
The authors thank the reviewer for their thorough reading of the manuscript and their insightful attention to detail and wording. All comments, suggestions, and recommendations have been carefully considered and addressed. The relevant edits have been incorporated into the manuscript and are highlighted in yellow.
Introduction
- Combine the first two paragraphs in section 1.1. Thank you for adding information about the importance of studying these factors in Russian; however, I think the structure of these first paragraphs in the introduction should be reworked to aid readability
Answer: The text has been revised per the reviewer's recommendations.
- On line 195, please provide more detail about the ERPs the authors emphasized as being important predictors of dyslexia
Answer: The text in this section has been elaborated with further details.
- Also in this section, I would change the wording of line 215 to say “integration, reanalysis, and higher-order cognitive control are IMPLICATED IN rather than affected by dyslexia”.
Answer: Done
- In the research gaps section, I would remove line 219 as you already mention in the first research gap sentence, that this is understudied in Russian
Answer: Done
- In current study section, can you clarify research question and hypothesis 1? Did you expect the named ERPs to show discrete patterns based on TD or Dys grouping? Or was your research question to determine that the same ERP components in TD children will be those used for print recognition in children with dyslexia? A third option would be that you wanted to describe what each of these components looked like in TD and Dys groups.
Answer: The hypothesis 1 has been reformulated.
Methods
- Can you cite the threshold you used to determine which participants were removed due to having too many artifacts?
Answer: Done
Results
- On line 480, change “less amplitude” to “lower amplitude”
Answer: Done
- Also in this same sentence (line 482) clarify the part of the sentence: “the younger children demonstrated a tendency for higher amplitude in the older children” I think the “in” should be replaced with “than”
Answer: Done
- Can you cite a study that supports you finding an N170 that peaks at 228ms. In the introduction, you mention that this component is delayed in children, but it would be nice to include a statement such as “As in XXX paper, we found the N170 occurred between 200-252ms.
Answer: Done
Discussion
- Line 669, please spell out GFP as I believe this is the first time it is mentioned
Answer: The full wording is now included.
- Line 779, can you please cite more sources? You mention several existing findings but then only cite one source
Answer: Additional clarification has been incorporated into the text.
Round 4
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThank you so much for the effort you put into this final draft. I only have one comment left which is just that hypothesis 3 does not match thr third research question. Upon fixing that, I believe the manuscript should be accepted for publication!
Author Response
We sincerely thank the reviewer for their attentive reading and constructive feedback. All comments have been carefully addressed, and the manuscript has been revised accordingly. The changes are highlighted in yellow in the tracked version. A clean version (without tracked changes) is attached as a PDF file for your convenience.
Below, we provide a point-by-point response to the remaining comment:
Reviewer’s comment:
Thank you so much for the effort you put into this final draft. I only have one comment left which is just that hypothesis 3 does not match the third research question. Upon fixing that, I believe the manuscript should be accepted for publication!
Our response:
We thank the reviewer for this important observation. To ensure perfect alignment between the research aims and hypotheses, we have revised the third research aim (Aim 3) as follows:
Previous version (Aim 3):
“To clarify whether dyslexic developmental patterns reflect delay, atypicality, or compensatory adaptation.”
Revised version (Aim 3):
“To test for qualitative differences in the age-related changes of early (N/P150, N170) and late (P600) ERP components associated with letter processing between children with dyslexia and TD children.”
This revision:
Directly corresponds to Hypothesis 3, which predicts differences in age-related amplitude changes between groups.
Reflects the core analytical approach of the study (comparing developmental trajectories via Age × Group interactions).
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf