Review Reports
- Lucyna Florkowska 1,*,
- Izabela Bryt-Nitarska 1 and
- Karolina Białasek 1
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis paper introduces an extended three-channel conceptual–probabilistic model that unifies predisposing, triggering, and causative factors within a coherent causal framework. The present study focuses on the theoretical foundations of the model and on the hierarchical classification of thirteen key predisposing factors defining the long-term susceptibility of the rock mass.
- The overall text lacks logical consistency, for example, in the abstract section, it is mentioned what the model is used for and its practical significance.
- Line 98, the formula derivation and its rationale only appear in the second part of the study, so it should not be used in the first part as its validity has not been verified.
- Section 2.12, the general classification of surface deformation and linear deformation may obscure specific forms of deformation; it is advisable to add whether the forms of deformation have practical significance in engineering applications.
- Latest research work related with this topic can be referred. Diffusion evolution rules of grouting slurry in mining-induced cracks in overlying strata.Determination method of rational position for working face entries in coordinated mining of section coal pillars and lower sub-layer.
- The overall research lacks depth, and the basis for classification and practical value are missing; it is recommended to improve these aspects.
- In the classification work, does the causal factor refer to external forces exceeding the rock mass's load-bearing capacity, leading to discontinuous deformation of the rock mass? Does this factor fall within the original classification or is it already covered?
- There are several grammar mistakes in the paper, please revise and double-check throughout the whole manuscript. The language could benefit from further editing and polishing.
Author Response
We sincerely thank the Reviewer for the careful assessment of our manuscript and for the constructive remarks provided. We appreciate the precise recognition of the aims of Part I, which is devoted to establishing the theoretical foundations of the extended three-channel conceptual–probabilistic model and to developing the hierarchical organisation of the predisposing factors governing long-term rock-mass susceptibility. As the opening contribution to a two-part study, this manuscript is intentionally focused on formulating the conceptual architecture, terminology, and causal structure that underpin the subsequent analysis of the triggering and causative domains presented in Part II. In response to the Reviewer’s comments, we have introduced a number of clarifications and refinements that, in our view, strengthen the logical coherence, terminological precision, and overall readability of the manuscript. Below we provide detailed responses to each of the Reviewer’s comments.
“The overall text lacks logical consistency, for example, in the abstract section, it is mentioned what the model is used for and its practical significance.”
We thank the Reviewer for raising this point. The structure adopted in the manuscript was chosen deliberately. Part I introduces the complete form of the proposed conceptual–probabilistic model, after which the subsequent sections gradually elaborate on its individual components and the underlying causal relationships. This top-down organisation is a common approach in theoretical work, as it provides readers with a clear overview of the framework before guiding them through the detailed explanations.
To ensure that the abstract cannot be interpreted as implying an applied or operational focus, we have refined its wording so that the scope of Part I is unambiguously presented as theoretical. The revised abstract now emphasises only the causal architecture of the model and the classification of predisposing factors, while methodological, predictive, and implementation aspects are explicitly deferred to Part II of the study.
All changes introduced in response to this comment are highlighted in red in the revised manuscript.
“Line 98, the formula derivation and its rationale only appear in the second part of the study, so it should not be used in the first part as its validity has not been verified.”
We thank the Reviewer for raising this point. The expression referred to in line 98 is introduced in Part I as a fundamental element of the conceptual–probabilistic architecture of the model, and its role and interpretation are fully explained within this part. The aim of Part I is to present the complete structure of the three causal channels and to provide a detailed discussion of the predisposing domain, which forms the foundation of the framework and defines its long-term susceptibility structure.
Part II naturally continues this development by extending the analysis to the remaining two process domains—triggering factors and causative factors. In doing so, it completes the description of the full causal mechanism while preserving the conceptual logic and coherence established in Part I.
We believe that presenting the full conceptual framework at the outset, followed by a structured elaboration of its individual domains, offers a clear and consistent theoretical narrative for the reader.
“Section 2.12, the general classification of surface deformation and linear deformation may obscure specific forms of deformation; it is advisable to add whether the forms of deformation have practical significance in engineering applications.”
We thank the Reviewer for this thoughtful comment. The classification of surface and linear deformation presented in Section 2.12 follows a long-established convention in engineering geology and in the geomorphological analysis of discontinuous ground movement. Its role is to distinguish the two principal modes in which discontinuous processes appear at the ground surface. This general framework does not obscure specific deformation forms; rather, it provides the conceptual envelope within which detailed geometric expressions—such as sinkholes, fissures, cracks, scarps, “tooth-like” steps or edge-collapse features—are routinely interpreted in geological practice. These forms represent concrete manifestations of either surface or linear deformation.
The displacement-based classification introduced in Section 2.1.2 serves a different purpose. Adapted from classical fracture mechanics, it organises the mechanical modes of displacement occurring along discontinuity planes (e.g., shear, dilation, block movement). It therefore complements—but does not overlap with—the surface/linear distinction, as it describes the underlying deformation mechanisms rather than their surface expression. Together, the two classifications operate at different descriptive levels and contribute distinct, but mutually reinforcing, interpretative functions.
Both classifications have practical engineering relevance. The surface/linear distinction assists in structuring field observations and in the preliminary identification of process characteristics, while the displacement-based typology enables these observations to be linked to the governing deformation mechanisms—an essential step for hazard assessment and for formulating appropriate mitigation strategies.
Their inclusion in Part I provides the coherent conceptual background required for subsequent stages of the analysis. The engineering implications of individual deformation forms, in combination with the triggering and causative domains, will be further developed in Part II of the study.
“Latest research work related with this topic can be referred. Diffusion evolution rules of grouting slurry in mining-induced cracks in overlying strata. Determination method of rational position for working face entries in coordinated mining of section coal pillars and lower sub-layer.”
We thank the Reviewer for drawing attention to these recent publications on mining-related engineering practices. The cited studies focus on specialised operational and design issues—such as the diffusion behaviour of grouting slurry within mining-induced fracture networks or the determination of optimal entry positions in coordinated extraction of coal pillars and sub-layers. These contributions are valuable within the context of mining technology and production engineering; however, they address objectives and methodologies that differ fundamentally from those of the present work.
Our study is concerned with developing a conceptual–probabilistic causal framework for discontinuous ground deformations, centred on the integration of the predisposing, triggering, and causative domains. As a theoretical construct, the model does not examine grouting processes, the hydraulics of slurry diffusion, or design optimisation in underground workings. Incorporating the suggested references would therefore not enhance the conceptual argument developed in Part I of the study, nor would it align with the analytical goals of the framework.
We nonetheless appreciate the Reviewer’s indication of recent work in this broader field.
“The overall research lacks depth, and the basis for classification and practical value are missing; it is recommended to improve these aspects.”
We thank the Reviewer for these comments. This manuscript, which opens a two-part study, is devoted to establishing the theoretical structure and essential premises of the proposed causal framework for discontinuous ground deformation. Its role is to define the conceptual architecture, terminology, and logical boundaries within which the subsequent analytical components are developed.
In a work of conceptual orientation, analytical depth does not reside in the enumeration of applications or case-specific demonstrations. It is instead expressed through the precision and consistency of the theoretical formulation, the clarity of the causal relations, and the coherence of the classificatory principles upon which the model is constructed. In this sense, Part I fulfils its intended function by articulating the susceptibility domain and by developing the hierarchical organisation of predisposing factors that governs the structure of the three-channel framework.
The basis for the classification used in Part I is presented explicitly, as it forms the conceptual nucleus from which the remaining causal pathways originate. An assessment of practical value, however, is meaningful only once the triggering and causative domains are integrated, since these domains complete the causal mechanism responsible for discontinuous deformation. As such, they lie beyond the scope of Part I and are examined in detail in Part II, where the dynamic interplay among long-term susceptibility, external forcing, and energy-driven processes is analysed. Only within this fully developed causal context can the engineering and diagnostic implications of the framework be appropriately demonstrated.
Part I should therefore be read not as an applied contribution, but as the theoretical substratum necessary for the internal coherence and explanatory reach of the model. The form of depth appropriate to this phase is that of conceptual rigour and definitional clarity, while its operationalisation—by design—is the subject of Part II.
“In the classification work, does the causal factor refer to external forces exceeding the rock mass's load-bearing capacity, leading to discontinuous deformation of the rock mass? Does this factor fall within the original classification or is it already covered?”
We thank the Reviewer for the question. In the proposed model, the “causative” domain should not be interpreted as the mere exceedance of rock mass strength under external loading. Instead, it denotes the internal suite of energy-mediated processes that directly govern the onset and subsequent evolution of discontinuous deformation once the system has transitioned into a metastable or critically perturbed state.
Functionally, this domain occupies a conceptual tier that is distinct from both predisposing and triggering classifications. Predisposing factors quantify the long-term susceptibility of the rock mass arising from its structural configuration, material contrasts, and hydro-mechanical behaviour. Triggering factors capture time-dependent external perturbations that displace the system toward a critical threshold. By contrast, causative factors describe the intrinsic dynamic response of the rock mass: the redistribution and concentration of stresses, the emergence of localised deformation bands, the nucleation and propagation of rupture surfaces, and the release, dissipation, or transfer of mechanical energy that drives the irreversible transition from incipient instability to a fully developed discontinuity.
This domain is therefore neither implicit nor contained within the traditional predisposing or triggering categories. Its introduction is conceptually necessary to represent the process-level mechanics that classical classifications do not articulate. The causative channel provides a dedicated representation of the physical mechanisms controlling the initiation trajectory, propagation behaviour, and geometric expression of discontinuous ground deformation. In this capacity, it complements—rather than replicates—the existing classifications and ensures a clear separation between susceptibility, external forcing, and the intrinsic physics of failure evolution.
“There are several grammar mistakes in the paper, please revise and double-check throughout the whole manuscript. The language could benefit from further editing and polishing.”
We thank the Reviewer for this valuable remark. In response, we have conducted a comprehensive, line-by-line revision of the entire manuscript, correcting all grammatical inaccuracies, eliminating stylistic inconsistencies, and improving the clarity and precision of the scientific narrative. The text has been thoroughly edited for tense consistency, syntactic structure, and terminological exactness. In addition, the manuscript has undergone professional English-language polishing to ensure that its wording, flow, and overall readability meet the standards expected in an international scientific journal.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis paper represents the first part of the two-part study on discontinuous ground deformations. In this particular study, the authors propose a three-channel causal architecture that comprises predisposing factors (permanent ground properties defining susceptibility S, triggering factors (time-dependent external stimuli initiating deformation hₖ), and driving/causative components (direct, energy-driven phenomena represented by the additional causal channel λC). The paper is well written and organized, and I would recommend it for publication after a minor revision in compliance with the following.
- Please translate Table 1 into English.
- It would be very helpful to readers if the English language and style were edited by a professional or native speaker.
- In Section 5.2, the authors mention that “geological structure and lithology critically control the spatial distribution and orientation of potential instability zones.” They also mention “surface” several times.
- What are the depths of the stratigraphic profiles and local geology that should or must be analyzed?
- Do the authors plan to analyze only discontinuities that are visible at the surface, or will a borehole or similar investigation be performed?
- Please translate Table 1 into English.
- It would be very helpful to readers if the English language and style were edited by a professional or native speaker.
Author Response
We sincerely thank the Reviewer for the constructive evaluation of our manuscript and for the clear summary of its scope and purpose. As noted, Part I of this two-part study is devoted to establishing the theoretical structure of the extended three-channel conceptual–probabilistic model for discontinuous ground deformation, with particular emphasis on defining the susceptibility domain and developing the hierarchical organisation of the predisposing factors. We appreciate the Reviewer’s insights and have introduced the refinements described below to strengthen the clarity, consistency, and readability of the manuscript. Detailed responses to all comments are provided beneath each remark.
“Please translate Table 1 into English.”
We thank the Reviewer for this comment. Table 1 has been fully translated into English, and the revised version is now incorporated into the updated manuscript.
“It would be very helpful to readers if the English language and style were edited by a professional or native speaker.”
We thank the Reviewer for this insightful recommendation. The manuscript has now been thoroughly edited by a professional English-language editor to ensure linguistic accuracy, stylistic refinement, and overall clarity of presentation.
“In Section 5.2, the authors mention that ‘geological structure and lithology critically control the spatial distribution and orientation of potential instability zones.’ They also mention ‘surface’ several times.”
We appreciate the Reviewer’s remark regarding the use of the term surface. Within engineering geology and rock mechanics, this term may indeed denote distinct entities, including:
(i) geometric discontinuity surfaces within the rock mass, and
(ii) the ground (terrain) surface corresponding to the near-surface geological layers.
Your comment prompted a systematic verification of the terminology, and we agree that clarifying these distinctions strengthens the manuscript.
Accordingly, we carried out a detailed review of all instances of surface, ground surface, discontinuity surface, slip surface, and surface deformation. Wherever multiple interpretations were possible, the wording was revised to make the intended meaning explicit. The manuscript now consistently differentiates between:
-
geometric discontinuity surfaces (Γ) within the rock mass,
-
the ground/terrain surface,
-
geometric slip or failure surfaces, and
-
ground-surface expressions of discontinuous deformation.
All modifications introduced in response to this comment are highlighted in blue in the revised manuscript.
The specific revisions include:
-
(174) …manifestation at the ground (terrain) surface…
-
Figure 1 caption: …at every point on this discontinuity surface…
-
(168) …projected onto the terrain surface (a two-dimensional ground-surface expression)…
-
(231–232) Areal deformation represents a discontinuity whose manifestation at the ground (terrain) surface is geometrically two-dimensional…
-
(238) …geometry and depth of the underlying geometric discontinuity surface…
-
(244) Typical discontinuous ground-surface deformations…
-
(259) …expression at the ground (terrain) surface…
-
(261–262) …two-dimensional geometric discontinuity plane…
-
(923–924) …incipient slip surfaces (geometric shear- or tensile-failure surfaces)…
-
(946) …may trigger discontinuous ground-surface deformation…
-
(957) Local terrain-surface morphology…
-
(1407) Excessive loading applied at the terrain surface…
-
(1511) …discontinuous along a geometric discontinuity surface…
-
(1679–1680) Let Γ denote the geometric displacement-discontinuity surface…, and S its trace at the ground (terrain) surface.
These revisions improve terminological precision and align the manuscript with established usage in engineering geology and rock-mass behaviour analysis. We thank the Reviewer for this helpful comment.
“What are the depths of the stratigraphic profiles and local geology that should or must be analyzed?”
The depth required for geological investigation is inherently site-dependent and must be determined with respect to local geological, hydrogeological, mining-related, and structural conditions.
For discontinuous ground deformation, two depth intervals are typically relevant:
-
Near-surface zone affected by weathering, softening, and stress redistribution (commonly 10–30 m), and
-
Deeper rock-mass units where primary causative structures—faults, discontinuity surfaces, voids, or abandoned workings—may occur.
A universal depth cannot be prescribed. The required investigation depth is governed by:
-
the local geological and hydrogeological framework,
-
the mining setting (current, planned, and historical),
-
project-specific structural conditions (loading magnitude, foundation depth, structural influence depth).
Consequently, the investigation programme must be tailored to these constraints and aligned with the predisposing factors defining the deformation potential at the site. Depth requirements may vary significantly—for instance, between a road crossing shallow abandoned workings (~20 m), a heavy building placed on a steep flysch slope, or a tunnel intersecting an active landslide zone.
A detailed discussion of how these conditions integrate into the correct application of the proposed model will be presented in Part II of the study.
“Do the authors plan to analyze only discontinuities that are visible at the surface, or will a borehole or similar investigation be performed?”
The assessment is not restricted to features visible at the ground surface. Surface expressions provide important initial indicators but are insufficient to determine the depth, geometry, or mechanical relevance of the underlying structures.
A reliable evaluation requires combining surface observations with subsurface investigation methods such as:
-
borehole drilling,
-
in situ geotechnical probing,
-
geophysical surveys.
These approaches are essential for identifying concealed discontinuity surfaces, voids, weakened strata, or other features that may not manifest at the terrain surface but are central to the deformation mechanism.
As with depth, the choice and extent of subsurface methods must reflect the site-specific geological, hydrogeological, mining-related, and structural conditions. The methodological framework of our study explicitly assumes the integration of subsurface data whenever necessary to reconstruct the true subsurface architecture and to evaluate discontinuous deformation hazard.
The principles guiding the appropriate application of the model—including the role of subsurface investigations—will be elaborated in Part II of the study.
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authorsaccept