Abstract
The growing integration of distributed energy resources and electrification of end users is driving the need for greater system flexibility in modern power grids. Various electrical assets can contribute to this flexibility, either inherently or through external control mechanisms, although their suitability varies even within the same category of assets. This paper presents a novel methodological approach to assess the flexibility potential of electrical assets based on their inherent technical characteristics and their intended installation context. Inspired by the principles of the Smart Readiness Indicator (SRI) for buildings, the proposed method employs a scoring system to evaluate a set of key functionalities that determine an asset’s readiness to contribute to system flexibility, then through a weighted sum a final index is obtained. These scores are combined through a weighted aggregation to produce a single, easy-to-interpret index that synthesizes multiple characteristics, enabling comparisons across different technologies. Unlike the SRI, this approach is not focused on certification but rather on providing a decision-support tool for end-users. The applicability of the method is demonstrated through a case study evaluating a photovoltaic inverter, followed by a sensitivity analysis to assess the robustness of the weighting scheme. Results indicate that the proposed index provides a transparent and replicable means of quantifying flexibility potential, supporting more informed planning and investment decisions.
1. Introduction
The rapid expansion of renewable energy sources in modern power systems has introduced considerable variability and uncertainty in the electricity supply. As generation from wind, solar, and other intermittent resources increases, maintaining the balance between supply and demand becomes more complex. Technically, enhancing system flexibility has emerged as the most effective strategy to manage this variability and ensure reliable grid operation [1]. In Europe alone, it is estimated that system flexibility must nearly double by 2030 to accommodate the growing share of variable energy production [2].
Traditionally, grid flexibility has been provided by conventional peak load power plants, which ramp up or down to match demand peaks [3]. However, maintaining such excess generation capacity is costly, slow to deploy, and often underutilized; running only a few hours per year. This approach also conflicts with the European Commission’s goal of achieving climate neutrality by 2050 [4].
To meet decarbonization targets, demand-side flexibility (DSF) has gained global attention as a critical solution [5]. The Council of European Energy Regulators defines DSF as “the capacity to change electricity usage by end-use customers in response to market signals, such as time-variable electricity prices or incentive payments, or in response to acceptance of the consumer’s bid” [6]. By shifting or shedding load, DSF can reduce operational costs, defer grid investments, and enhance the integration of renewables—yielding benefits for system operators, market participants, and consumers alike [7].
Quantitative studies have demonstrated the system-wide potential value of DSF: The Det Norske Veritas (DNV), one of the world’s leading technical advisors in the energy sector [8], estimates that widespread adoption of flexibility measures across Europe by 2030 could result in over €71 billion in annual electricity cost savings for providers and €300 billion in indirect savings for consumers. Grid operators could defer €11–29 billion in yearly network investments, while renewable energy producers could avoid curtailment of 15.5 TWh, corresponding to 37.5 Mt of yearly carbon emissions savings [9]. This assessment excluded the potential contribution of smart residential appliances.
Other researchers have shown that smart appliances could play a vital role in advancing the energy transition [10]. Notably, in 2023, households accounted for 26.3% of the EU’s final energy consumption [11].
Despite the considerable potential of DSF, its practical implementation remains hindered by a range of technical, regulatory, and socio-economic challenges [12]. Adoption remains limited, with pilot programs often achieving less than 10% participation [13]. Key barriers include insufficient financial incentives [3], regulatory constraints in flexibility markets [14], low consumer awareness [15], and a lack of standardized tools to evaluate which devices can provide flexibility [16].
Existing work falls into two broad strands. On the one hand, qualitative taxonomies classify residential loads by storage capability, response speed, and predictability [17,18], but these taxonomies often aggregate device classes whose actual flexibility potential differs substantially and tend to focus narrowly on electrical attributes while neglecting observability and controllability. On the other hand, quantitative studies estimate the flexibility potential of specific technologies or installations using consumption measurements and usage patterns (e.g., cooling systems [19], EV chargers [20]), but such approaches are inherently context dependent and do not provide a general, design-centric measure of inherent flexibility.
This paper presents a novel decision-support tool aimed at quantifying the inherent flexibility potential of electrical assets, along with the influence of the installation context. Building on the modular logic of the Smart Readiness Indicator (SRI) [21], the proposed approach utilizes four indices:
- Static Flexibility Index (SFI): Evaluates the asset’s inherent technical properties, grouped into three categories: electrical characteristics, observability, and controllability;
- Dynamic Flexibility Index (DFI): Accounts for environmental conditions and usage behaviors that may affect inherent potential;
- Global Flexibility Index (GFI) and Individual Flexibility Index (IFI): Combine the SFI and DFI into a composite score that supports benchmarking and prioritization.
The originality of this work lies in three main aspects. First, it provides a device-level, design-centric measure of inherent flexibility that is distinct from installation-specific consumption studies. Second, it explicitly incorporates observability and controllability alongside electrical characteristics, thereby capturing dimensions that qualitative taxonomies and many prior studies overlook. Third, it yields a single, comparable score (and associated subgroup scores) computed from clearly defined functionality levels, enabling straightforward comparison, ranking, and decision support across heterogeneous assets and contexts.
The principal motivation of this framework is to provide users with a simple and transparent tool to identify which devices can realistically deliver flexibility services, thereby promoting broader participation in flexibility markets.
The main contributions of this paper are as follows:
- A formalized methodology to compute the Static Flexibility Index (SFI) and Dynamic Flexibility Index (DFI) for electrical assets, each based on modular service groups and discrete functionality levels.
- The definition and specification of functionality levels for services across the groups: Electrical Characteristics, Observability, Controllability, Ambient Factors, and Usage Flexibility, together with a reproducible scoring and aggregation procedure.
- Introduction of the Global Flexibility Index (GFI) and Individual Flexibility Index (IFI) as practical composites that combine design and contextual effects for benchmarking and user-specific assessment.
- A user-friendly, implementable framework (suitable for spreadsheet or database implementation) that produces a single synthesizing score and subgroup breakdowns to aid prioritization and decision making.
This framework thus fills a gap between high-level qualitative classifications and narrowly scoped quantitative studies, providing a standardized and implementable approach to assess inherent device flexibility, facilitate comparison and prioritization, and support practical interventions that promote DSF adoption.
The remainder of the paper is structured as follows: Section 2 reviews power system flexibility, the SRI methodology, and relevant device classification schemes. Section 3 presents the proposed indices and scoring methodology. Section 4 demonstrates the application of the proposed methodology through the evaluation of a photovoltaic inverter and further provides a sensitivity analysis of the SFI. Section 5 presents the discussion of the methodology, including its strengths, limitations, and potential research directions. Section 6 concludes the paper, summarizing the main findings, highlighting the robustness and usability of the proposed framework, and outlining avenues for future work.
2. Background
2.1. Flexibility in Power Systems
Flexibility can be defined as the ability of a power system to reliably adjust the energy demand and generation to account for predictable and unpredictable fluctuations covering time horizons from the short to the long term [22].
Flexibility in modern power systems can be enhanced by ensuring that all key system assets are capable of adapting to variable conditions [23]. This involves:
- Generation assets with the ability to adjust output rapidly, operate efficiently at partial loads, and achieve deep turndowns;
- Transmission infrastructure with minimal congestion, sufficient capacity to access diverse balancing resources (including cross-border exchanges), and advanced control technologies to optimize network usage;
- Demand-side resources enabled by smart grid functionalities to support demand response, energy storage, and responsive distributed generation;
- Operational practices that maximize the flexibility of existing assets, such as near-real-time decision-making, integration of improved forecasting for variable renewables, and enhanced coordination among system operators.
Once this flexibility is unlocked, it can be harnessed to deliver a range of flexibility services, effectively functioning as ancillary services provided by flexible assets [24]. The flexibility services an asset can provide are intrinsically linked to its technical capabilities.
Table 1 summarizes these services together with three key technical requirements for their provision, based on the information in [25,26]. The values are provided as reference only and may vary depending on flexibility market design, system operator specifications, or national regulations.
Table 1.
Technical requirements of flexibility services.
Beyond the three technical characteristics outlined in Table 1, the provision of flexibility services may also depend on additional asset-specific attributes, such as power flow direction, electrical composition (e.g., energy-to-power ratio), and predictability [27]. Consequently, the ability to deliver particular flexibility services is often restricted to certain asset types, and in some cases, only a subset of assets may be capable of contributing to any service at all.
On that matter, understanding how capable an asset is of providing flexibility and which services it can support constitutes an essential decision-making tool for system operators and stakeholders.
2.2. Existing Assessment Frameworks
In this section, some evaluation and classification frameworks are reviewed. The discussion begins with the Smart Readiness Indicator (SRI), originally developed for smart buildings but incorporating concepts that are highly relevant to flexible assets. Subsequently, three classification approaches proposed in the literature are presented, each offering distinct perspectives on how to assess and categorize flexibility potential.
2.2.1. Smart Readiness Indicator (SRI)
The SRI is a standardized European methodology designed to assess the smart readiness of buildings. It was introduced as part of the 2018 revision of the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive (EPBD), which sought to improve energy efficiency and promote the integration of digital technologies within the building sector across EU member states.
Within this framework, smartness describes a building’s capacity to detect, analyze, communicate, and adapt proactively and efficiently to shifts in its technical systems, the surrounding environment (including the power grid), and the requirements of its occupants.
The outcome of the SRI assessment is expressed as an overall score that reflects how close a building is to maximum smart readiness, complemented by specific scores in key dimensions of building smartness [28].
The methodology evaluates seven impact criteria across nine technical domains:
- Technical domains: heating, cooling, domestic hot water, ventilation, lighting, dynamic building envelope, electricity, electric vehicle charging, and monitoring and control;
- Impact criteria: energy efficiency, maintenance and fault prediction, comfort, convenience, health, well-being and accessibility, information to occupants, and energy flexibility and storage.
The SRI methodology involves three main steps:
- Identification of technical domains present in the building. Each domain is marked as: 0: absent and non-mandatory (not penalized), 1: present, 2: absent but mandatory (penalized in scoring).
- Evaluation of smart-ready services within each domain. Services are scored according to a functionality level (0–4), with a weight reflecting their coverage (full building = 100%, or partial share).
- Aggregation of results into overall and domain-specific scores, with the possibility of adjusting weights according to geographical context (e.g., prioritizing air conditioning efficiency in southern regions).
The methodological approach applied in the SRI has been examined in detail, as specific elements such as functionality levels and weighted scoring are used as reference in the flexibility assessment methodology proposed in this study.
2.2.2. Classification of Flexible Assets
In the literature, various approaches have been proposed to classify and group flexible assets For household appliances, a widely used classification distinguishes three categories [14]:
- Uncontrollable devices, which are unable to provide flexibility;
- Thermostatically Controlled Appliances (TCAs), which operate based on thermal dynamics and can leverage the heat-to-power coupling to deliver significant flexibility;
- Non-Thermostatically Controlled Appliances (NTCAs), which generally provide a more limited degree of flexibility compared to TCAs.
This classification provides some insight into the flexibility potential of different assets but does not directly link them to specific flexibility services. To address this gap, another classification proposed by the authors in [17] gives a better understanding on what type of services an asset can deliver:
- Storable loads: Loads in which energy consumption and end-use service are decoupled through storage, such as batteries (electrochemical) or thermal inertia;
- Shiftable loads: Consumption can be shifted in time without compromising the service, typically involving non-interruptible processes that require scheduling (e.g., laundry cycles);
- Curtailable loads: Consumption cannot be shifted without affecting the service but can be instantly interrupted when necessary;
- Base loads: Services that require continuous, immediate power supply and cannot be shifted or interrupted;
- Self-generation: On-site electricity production by consumers, which reduces net demand. When dispatchable, it can also serve as backup supply.
Although this second classification provides a better mapping of assets to potential services, it still overlooks the technical characteristics required by flexibility services, as discussed in Section 2.1. As a result, assets with different technical profiles may still fall under the same category. To address this limitation, the authors in [18] propose further distinguishing assets within each type according to key attributes such as energy-to-power ratio, response direction, response speed, response duration, availability (frequency and timing of activation), and predictability (accuracy of availability forecasts).
Building on this, Ref. [29] introduces a more granular classification, dividing flexibility resources into seven groups: shiftable advance, shiftable delay, shiftable advance/delay, supply-side (dispatchable power plants), stationary storage (standalone), stationary storage with generation, mobile storage (e.g., electric vehicles), and operational flexibility (e.g., network reconfiguration and dynamic line rating). This approach refines the shiftable load category by considering temporal characteristics and differentiates storage resources by location.
In addition, the authors characterize flexibility resources and services using 18 parameters, including power and energy capacity, ramping capability, service and reaction duration, rebound and recovery effects, ramp frequency, efficiency, energy loss, lifetime, location, credibility, and predictability. This multidimensional framework enables a richer yet still simplified qualitative mapping between services and resources. However, a quantitative assessment combined with cost–benefit analysis remains necessary to determine the most suitable assets for providing specific services.
2.3. Justification for a Novel Approach
As shown in the previous subsection, the literature offers several classifications and characterizations of flexible assets that help to identify whether a device is potentially flexible and, in some cases, to map it to specific flexibility services. However, we did not identify a published methodology that (i) assesses the inherent flexibility readiness of devices in a way that is clear, comparable and reproducible, and (ii) reports that readiness as a concise, user-friendly score that can be used for quick decision making. This constitutes an important gap: existing schemes either remain qualitative, are tailored to particular asset families, or require extensive context-specific data and simulation to produce comparable results.
The methodology proposed in this paper addresses that gap. Rather than replacing prior classifications, it builds on them and on the structural logic of the SRI to produce a practical, device-level evaluation framework. The objective is not certification but to provide a transparent, reproducible decision-support tool and knowledge base for end-users, manufacturers and system planners. The resulting score enables rapid comparisons across technologies, informs procurement and deployment decisions, and highlights which assets merit deeper quantitative assessment or field trials.
Key advantages of the proposed approach are its device-level focus, its combination of qualitative and quantitative criteria, and its explicit modelling of contextual effects (location and usage) on flexibility potential. These characteristics make the methodology both operationally useful (fast, interpretable) and scientifically sound (grounded on established classifications and on SRI principles). In the next section we present the methodology in detail, including the indicator definitions, functionality levels and scoring rules.
3. Methodology
This section presents the methodological framework developed to assess the flexibility potential of electrical assets. Inspired by the structure and logic of the SRI, the proposed method combines qualitative and quantitative criteria to evaluate the ability of an asset to contribute to system flexibility. The methodology is composed of two complementary indices, Static Flexibility Index (SFI) and Dynamic Flexibility Index (DFI), as well as two combined indices, the Global Flexibility Index (GFI) and the Individual Flexibility Index (IFI), which integrate the SFI and DFI. Together form a coherent decision-support tool for benchmarking, classification and deployment planning.
3.1. Overview of the Proposed Method
The proposed method is based on a modular, scalable and replicable framework designed to classify flexible energy assets in a consistent and technology-neutral way. Inspired by the multi-criteria assessment approach, SRI, it evaluates both the technical characteristics of the assets and the framework where it is installed.
The methodology comprises four key indices:
- Static Flexibility Index (SFI): Focuses on the own properties of the asset, such as electrical capacity, observability and controllability. These features are normally independent of the installation site and are derived from manufacturer specifications or performance data.
- Dynamic Flexibility Index (DFI): Captures external factors that influence the flexibility potential of the asset. These include climatic conditions, usage patterns, grid interaction capability and environmental framework. The DFI is calculated based on a set of scenarios and user-defined parameters that reflect generic local conditions.
- Global Flexibility Index (GFI) and Individual Flexibility Index (IFI): Aggregate the SFI and DFI into a single score, providing a comprehensive representation of the flexibility potential of an asset. This score would support asset prioritization, potential user investment planning and integration into digital platforms and marketplaces. The GFI aggregates the DFI across multiple users, while the IFI reflects the flexibility potential for a specific user.
Each index is computed independently, based on normalized functionality levels and weighted criteria adapted to the characteristics of different asset types. The method is designed to support a wide range of stakeholders or users —including asset manufacturers, devices purchasers, aggregators and distribution system operators among others— while ensuring compatibility with existing asset catalogues. Furthermore, it is structured to enable future integration into interoperable platforms such as flexibility marketplaces and energy management systems.
3.2. Static Flexibility Index (SFI)
The methodology for computing the SFI and the DFI follows the structure of the SRI framework for buildings, as described in the previous section. It covers nine asset domains:
- Heating;
- Domestic Hot Water (DHW);
- Cooling;
- Ventilation;
- Electric Vehicle Charging;
- Energy Storage System (BESS);
- Photovoltaic System (PV);
- White appliances;
- Lighting.
For the SFI, each domain is evaluated across three service groups: Electrical Characteristics, Observability, and Controllability. The criteria in each group are designed to capture different aspects of static flexibility. The criteria draw upon a qualitative evaluation framework proposed in [29], emphasizing parameters that are intrinsic to the assets, and build upon the concepts of the SRI. Furthermore, they were refined and validated through workshops with experts from ten different institutions as part of the REEFLEX project [30], ensuring that the selected criteria reflect both theoretical considerations and practical knowledge:
- Electrical Characteristics considers attributes such as bidirectional power flow, energy storage capability, and reactive power support.
- Observability evaluates the degree of usage detection, real-time monitoring, and dependence on external IoT modules.
- Controllability focuses on the type and location of control, operation mode, and response time.
These three service groups were identified as the most relevant factors influencing the flexibility potential of an asset. Each group is further broken down into specific services, which are assigned functionality levels. These levels, consistent with the SRI approach, reflect the extent to which a device provides a given service. A functionality level of zero represents no contribution to flexibility, while higher values indicate greater potential.
For a given device, the flexibility subindex of a service group is calculated as
where
- SI is the service group flexibility subindex;
- is the functionality level assigned to service i;
- is the maximum possible value for service i;
- is the number of services in the service group.
Once the service group subindices are calculated, weights are assigned to reflect their relative influence on overall flexibility. In this study, weights of 0.3, 0.35, and 0.35 were assigned to Electrical Characteristics, Observability, and Controllability, respectively. This weighting prioritizes monitoring and control capabilities, as these aspects more directly determine the extent to which flexibility can be exploited. The implications of this weighting scheme are further analyzed in Section 4.
The total SFI of the device is then computed as the weighted sum of the three service group subindices:
where
- represents the subindex of service group i (electrical characteristics, observability, and controllability);
- is the assigned weight of service group i.
The functionality levels were defined in close collaboration with asset experts from the REEFLEX project, ensuring that all relevant aspects of flexibility within each service group were considered. To allow comparability across domains, the same set of functionality levels was applied consistently to all asset types.
The following subsections provide definitions of the functionality levels for each service within their respective groups.
3.2.1. Electrical Characteristics
Electrical Characteristics covers all aspects related to the electric properties of the asset, such as power flow direction and phase balancing. All services included in this group, along with their corresponding functionality levels, are presented in Table 2.
Table 2.
Services and Functionality Levels for Electrical Characteristics of SFI.
3.2.2. Observability
Observability pertains to the device’s monitoring capabilities and communication functions. Table 3 presents all services in this group and their associated functionality levels.
Table 3.
Services and Functionality Levels for Observability.
3.2.3. Controllability
Controllability describes how the device can be operated and how it responds to control actions. All services in this group, together with their functionality levels, are summarized in Table 4.
Table 4.
Services and Functionality Levels for Controllability.
3.3. Dynamic Flexibility Index (DFI)
In contrast to SFI, the DFI considers the operational context of assets, reflecting their ability to adapt to changing environmental conditions. This may include factors such as climate, surrounding infrastructure, available services, and the demand patterns of end users.
Similarly to SFI, the DFI builds on three fundamental elements: service groups, services, and functionality levels. Service groups categorize scenarios along three dimensions considered critical for flexibility: ambient factors, electrical characteristics, and usage flexibility. Within each group, services represent specific operational scenarios, understood as sets of conditions that remain consistent over time. Finally, functionality levels quantify the degree to which a service is achieved, using a scale from zero to two.
The service groups, services and functionality levels of the DFI were designed with the involvement of the purchaser in mind. As the tool requires users to select a single level for each service, some of the level definitions are based on official statistical data published by European sources. In all cases, the functionality levels serve as user-friendly guidelines, reflecting typical decisions made on a daily or seasonal basis.
To evaluate the DFI, the first step is to calculate the flexibility subindex for each service group using (1). Subsequently, the DFI is obtained as a weighted sum of the three service group subindices, as expressed in (3). The weighting scheme—0.4 for ambient factors, 0.1 for electrical characteristics, and 0.5 for usage flexibility—was defined in consultation held during REEFLEX project meetings. Feedback was collected from representatives of ten partner institutions, including research centers, technology manufacturers, and energy-sector organizations. During these meetings, each partner provided their perspective on the relative importance of the three flexibility dimensions based on their expertise and field of activity. The final weights were obtained by averaging the values proposed by the participants, ensuring a balanced representation of the different viewpoints within the consortium.
where represents the subindex of service group i (ambient factors, electric characteristics, and usage flexibility), and is the assigned weight to that group.
In line with the procedure applied for the SFI, the following subsections present each service’s functionality levels within their respective groups, along with the relevant application domains. For all services, a functionality level of zero denotes the absence of flexibility, whereas a value of two represents the maximum flexibility achievable by the asset under the given scenario. It is important to highlight that, within the DFI framework, assets operating continuously or not being used at all are assigned a flexibility value of zero, since their load cannot be curtailed or shifted. Conversely, scenarios that permit modulation of asset operation—while still meeting user requirements—are regarded as providing the highest level of flexibility.
3.3.1. Ambient Factors
Ambient Factors evaluate external and internal conditions—such as outdoor temperature, indoor humidity, building characteristics, and user preferences—that influence how frequently and for how long an asset is used. The services included in this group, together with their corresponding functionality levels, are presented in Table 5.
Table 5.
Services and Functionality Levels for Ambient Factors.
3.3.2. Electrical Characteristics
Electrical Characteristics consider, in a simplified manner, the amount of power available to provide flexibility. All services classified under this group and their associated functionality levels are summarized in Table 6.
Table 6.
Services and Functionality Levels for Electrical Characteristics of DFI.
Table 7.
Consumption thresholds to assess the asset consumed power.
3.3.3. Usage Flexibility
Usage Flexibility assesses how adaptable the operation of a device is, for instance, whether its load can be shed or shifted, and within which time frames. The services within this group and their respective functionality levels are detailed in Table 8.
Table 8.
Services and Functionality Levels for Usage Flexibility.
3.4. Scoring Framework: Individual and Global Flexibility Indices
To incorporate the influence of the operational context on the theoretical flexibility potential (derived from the technical specifications of assets), two indices are defined: the Individual Flexibility Index (IFI) and the Global Flexibility Index (GFI). These indices provide a final score that integrates both the static and dynamic aspects of asset flexibility.
The IFI quantifies the flexibility potential of a specific asset in a given operational context. It is computed as the product of the SFI, which reflects the intrinsic technical capabilities of the asset, and the DFI, which captures the impact of the operational environment and usage conditions as provided by the user:
IFI = SFI × DFI.
In contrast, the GFI evaluates the flexibility potential of a given asset type at a specific location by averaging the dynamic indices reported by multiple users. This value reflects a more general and location-dependent perspective:
where represents the mean DFI calculated across all users for the same asset type and geographical context.
The objective of these indices is to enable comparisons between different technologies, supporting quick decision-making in planning. The following is a guideline for interpretation:
- A score of 0% indicates that the device is not flexible;
- A score around 50% suggests that the device could provide flexibility with external support, such as an Energy Management System (EMS);
- A score of 100% indicates that the device is fully capable of delivering flexibility without requiring external control systems.
It is important to emphasize that these indices are designed as a simplified quantitative decision-support tool. They indicate the degree to which an asset is flexible, but not the actual amount of flexibility it can deliver. The magnitude of flexibility must still be quantified through more detailed assessment methods.
3.5. Implementation of the Methodological Framework
The methodological framework was implemented within the REEFLEX project through a Python-based tool—built in Python 3.12—that enables users to evaluate devices and automatically compute their Static, Dynamic, and Global Flexibility Indices. The tool gathers technical and contextual data through validated input forms and stores all results in a collaborative catalogue.
To ensure accessibility and multi-user participation, the catalogue is hosted on a Microsoft Azure relational database located in Dublin, Ireland. A Python-based REST API manages all interactions, performing validation, securing communication, and ensuring data integrity. The data model follows a normalized schema with migration support. API endpoints provide pagination, server-side filtering, and batched writes to maintain low latency at moderate loads. This architecture provides a reliable and scalable solution, allowing the catalogue to grow while maintaining performance and security.
3.6. Summary of the Methodology
In summary, Section 3 presents the methodology developed to evaluate the flexibility potential of assets across nine domains. Two complementary indices are defined: the Static Flexibility Index (SFI), which assesses design-related attributes grouped as Electrical Characteristics, Observability, and Controllability; and the Dynamic Flexibility Index (DFI), which captures operational and contextual influences grouped as Ambient Factors, Electrical Characteristics (with emphasis on available installation power), and Usage Flexibility. Both indices follow a structure inspired by the Smart Readiness Indicator (SRI): each service within a group is assigned a functionality level (0–3) according to the definitions given in this section, service scores are aggregated into weighted group scores, and these group scores are combined to yield the SFI and DFI. Building on these, the Global Flexibility Index (GFI) and the Individual Flexibility Index (IFI) integrate the DFI’s operational effects with the SFI’s design assessment: the GFI represents an average DFI across installations/users, while the IFI pertains to a specific installation or user. This framework provides the basis for the analysis in Section 4.
4. Results
In this section, the proposed methodology is applied to evaluate the flexibility potential of a commercial photovoltaic (PV) inverter, providing a concrete example of its use. Following this case study, a sensitivity analysis is carried out using eight different commercial solutions. This analysis examines how changes in the weighting assigned to each service group affect the resulting static flexibility index, thereby highlighting the robustness and adaptability of the methodology.
4.1. Case Study: Flexibility Evaluation of a PV Inverter
This subsection presents the application of the proposed methodology to a commercial PV system inverter, the INGECON SUN 3, which corresponds to one of the flexible assets installed at the CIRCE Technology Center, part of the REEFLEX project pilot site. The inverter was selected for the case study based on the availability of detailed technical information, allowing a clear illustration of the methodology. The static and dynamic flexibility indices are calculated to illustrate how the methodology can be used to quantify the flexibility potential of an individual asset.
As the first step of the methodology, the flexibility subindex of each service group contributing to the SFI is calculated with Equation (1). Once the subindices are obtained, they are combined through a weighted sum to derive the overall SFI using Equation (2).
As detailed in the previous section, each service group is composed of several individual services, which are assessed according to predefined functionality levels. The results of these evaluations are summarized in the following tables: Table 9 presents the evaluation of electrical characteristics, Table 10 corresponds to observability, and Table 11 covers controllability. To simplify presentation, the table shows only the functionality level applicable to the PV inverter. A complete breakdown of functionality levels for all services is available in Section 3.
Table 9.
Evaluation of electrical characteristics of PV inverter.
Table 10.
Evaluation of PV inverter observability.
Table 11.
Controllability evaluation of the PV inverter.
Based on these results, the SFI is calculated with Equation (2), yielding a value of 71%:
This result shows that, when only the technical specifications are considered, the device can be classified as flexible. However, its full flexibility potential may not be accessible without external support. For instance, an additional IoT module is required to enable advanced communication and control functions. Moreover, the flexibility it can provide remains limited, as it only supports one-way power flow. To overcome this limitation and significantly enhance its flexibility potential, the device would need to be integrated with a battery storage system.
To evaluate how operational context influences flexibility, the next step is the calculation of the DFI. Table 12 presents the results for each service group contributing to this index, considering a Mediterranean location as the reference context. For clarity, the table displays only the functionality level relevant to the device. Detailed functionality levels for each service can be found in Section 3.
Table 12.
Dynamic Flexibility Evaluation by Service Group for a PV Inverter in a Mediterranean Context.
The DFI is then calculated similarly to the SFI, by taking the weighted sum of the evaluated subindices for each service group:
Finally, the IFI for this inverter, considering a Mediterranean location, is calculated using Equation (4):
IFI = SFI × DFI = 71% × 80% = 56.8%,
This result indicates that the inverter can provide flexibility; however, its potential is limited because it is not paired with a battery energy storage system (BESS), meaning that some of the generated power may remain unused.
The example presented highlights the ease of use of the methodology, providing a clear framework to assess the flexibility potential of different devices across various contexts without requiring advanced technical expertise.
4.2. Sensitivity Analysis of the Static Flexibility Index
To assess the robustness of the methodology, a sensitivity analysis is performed using eight different commercial assets. These assets correspond to flexible equipment located at one of the REEFLEX project pilot sites, implemented at the CIRCE Technology Center. These assets were included in the analysis due to the availability of detailed technical information.
The analysis investigates how variations in the weights assigned to each service group influence the resulting SFI. This provides insight into the extent to which weighing choices affect the evaluation outcome.
Table 13 presents the evaluation results for each service comprising the SFI, as well as the overall SFI calculated using the defined weights: 0.3 for electrical characteristics, 0.35 for observability, and 0.35 for controllability. The assets are sorted in descending order based on their SFI values.
Table 13.
Static flexibility results for eight commercial assets.
The sensitivity analysis was performed by varying the service group weights by ±0.1 and ±0.2 in all possible combinations. As summarized in Table 14, a ±0.1 variation produced only minor changes in the SFI, and the ranking of devices remained stable. In contrast, a ±0.2 variation occasionally altered the ranking, particularly when weights were highly unbalanced (e.g., 0.1 for electrical characteristics and 0.55 for observability), favoring devices strong in a single attribute. Such skewed weighting is not advisable, as it underrepresents essential characteristics that are critical to assessing flexibility potential.
Table 14.
Summary of sensibility analysis for the Static Flexibility Index.
5. Discussion
The proposed methodology offers a structured and practical approach to evaluate the flexibility potential of electrical assets. One of its major strengths lies in its accessibility and simplicity, particularly for manufacturers, resellers, and technology integrators who already possess the required technical specifications to populate the asset forms. By relying on predefined criteria and drop-down scoring options, the method facilitates rapid data entry, minimizes ambiguity, and ensures consistent evaluation across asset types and locations. The integration of the method into a lightweight, user-friendly application further enhances its usability, avoiding complex modeling or intrusive data collection.
Another key advantage is its privacy-preserving design. Since the method does not require high-resolution user behavior data or real-time monitoring, it can be applied without compromising consumer privacy. This makes it especially suitable for large-scale implementation across distributed assets in residential and commercial sectors.
The framework also draws strength from its conceptual alignment with the Smart Readiness Indicator (SRI), a methodology already recognized and promoted at the European policy level. By leveraging the SRI’s structure and adapting it to a flexibility-focused context, the method benefits from a certain degree of legitimacy and interoperability with existing building assessment schemes.
In relation to existing approaches, several studies have proposed qualitative classifications to assess the flexibility of electrical assets. As discussed in Section 2.2.2, the frameworks proposed by Golmohamadi et al. [14] and He et al. [17] offer valuable first attempts but rely on a limited number of criteria, often grouping assets with significantly different technical capabilities under the same category. This restricts their practical applicability when comparing assets of varying complexity or control potential. The classification proposed by Degefa et al. [29] provides a more granular and technically grounded categorization, addressing some of these shortcomings; however, the resulting framework can be difficult to interpret and apply for comparative purposes. The methodology proposed in this paper builds upon and extends the work of Degefa et al. by incorporating additional criteria and introducing a quantitative scoring approach. This structure facilitates more intuitive comparisons between assets, while the breakdown into service groups—Electrical Characteristics, Observability, and Controllability—enables users to focus on the aspects most relevant to their objectives. In doing so, the proposed method bridges the gap between qualitative taxonomies and highly detailed quantitative models, advancing both the practical usability and scientific rigor of flexibility assessment.
Nonetheless, the approach also presents some limitations. First, its effective use by prosumers or end-users may be challenging, as they may not be familiar with all the required technical inputs—such as battery state-of-charge thresholds, Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning (HVAC) control interfaces, or PV system configuration modes. While the methodology is designed to be simple, its full value may only be realized when completed by a knowledgeable third party (e.g., installer or aggregator). Second, the current version of the tool is limited to a defined set of asset types, primarily residential in nature. Although these represent a significant portion of flexible demand, broader coverage is needed to address industrial and commercial systems, as well as more complex control architectures.
Despite these constraints, the proposed method constitutes a promising first step toward the standardization of asset-level flexibility classification. Its modular structure provides a strong foundation for future enhancements, including the extension to new asset categories (e.g., industrial chillers, process loads, building energy management systems), or the development of custom scoring profiles for different user types and market contexts.
Another promising research direction would be the creation of an aggregated Flexibility Readiness Indicator at the prosumer or building level, combining individual asset scores with behavioral metrics such as historical participation in flexibility programs or response to external signals. This would enable aggregators, DSOs, or local energy communities to benchmark and optimize the flexible capacity of their user base.
From a broader perspective, this tool contributes to the democratization and operationalization of flexibility assessment. It allows stakeholders to shift from qualitative assumptions to quantifiable metrics, paving the way for greater transparency, interoperability, and inclusion of smaller players in flexibility markets. The standardized cataloging of assets could facilitate automated onboarding processes in digital platforms, improving scalability and reducing administrative burden.
6. Conclusions
In summary, while improvements are still needed—particularly in terms of scope, automation, and personalization—the proposed method already provides valuable functionality and fills a key gap in current flexibility assessment frameworks. The analysis presented in Section 4 demonstrates the methodology’s ease of implementation and highlights the robustness of the proposed Static Flexibility Index (SFI) across different asset categories.
The methodology offers a practical pathway toward wider integration of distributed assets in smart grids and demand-side response strategies. Its accessibility, privacy-preserving design, and modular structure make it a useful decision-support tool for a range of stakeholders, from manufacturers and technology integrators to aggregators and policymakers, supporting more informed deployment and participation in flexibility markets.
The main limitation of this work is that it was not possible to evaluate a sufficient number of commercial assets to draw statistically significant conclusions about current market tendencies. Addressing this limitation and extending the dataset to include a broader variety of assets represents a clear direction for future work, enabling a more comprehensive assessment of flexibility potential across real-world installations.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, G.F., B.M., N.S. and P.H.; methodology, L.C.P., G.F., R.C.R., B.M., N.S. and P.H.; software, L.C.P. and R.C.R.; validation, L.C.P., G.F. and R.C.R.; formal analysis, L.C.P. and G.F.; investigation, L.C.P., G.F., B.M., N.S. and P.H.; resources, L.C.P. and G.F.; writing—original draft preparation, L.C.P., G.F., R.C.R., B.M., N.S. and P.H.; writing—review and editing, L.C.P., G.F. and P.H.; visualization, L.C.P.; supervision, L.C.P. and G.F.; project administration, G.F.; funding acquisition, G.F. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
REEFLEX has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon Europe Research and Innovation program under Grant Agreement No 101096192.
Data Availability Statement
The Python-based tool implementing the proposed methodology is openly available at https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/folders/1EVb-oNbee2f-Guk8P6BFR2mi-hpSEK-S (accessed on 19 September 2025).
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to sincerely thank all REEFLEX consortium partners for their valuable contributions, collaborative spirit and continuous commitment throughout the development of this work. The outcomes presented in this paper would not have been possible without their effort in stakeholder engagement, technical insights and shared vision. Their teamwork has been essential in shaping the participatory approach adopted by the REEFLEX project.
Conflicts of Interest
Author Nikolas Spiliopoulos was employed by the company Que Technologies. The remaining authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Abbreviations
The following abbreviations are used in this manuscript:
| SRI | Smart Readiness Indicator |
| SFI | Static Flexibility Index |
| DFI | Dynamic Flexibility Index |
| GFI | Global Flexibility Index |
| IFI | Individual Flexibility Index |
| DSO | Distribution System Operator |
| EMS | Energy Management Systems |
| PV | Photovoltaic |
| IoT | Internet of Things |
| DHW | Domestic Hot Water |
| BESS | Battery Energy Storage System |
| HVAC | Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning |
| REEFLEX | Replicable, interoperable, cross-sector solutions and Energy services for demand side Flexibility markets |
References
- Ma, J.; Silva, V.; Ochoa, L.F.; Kirschen, D.S.; Belhomme, R. Evaluating the Profitability of Flexibility. In Proceedings of the 2012 IEEE Power and Energy Society General Meeting, San Diego, CA, USA, 22–26 July 2012; pp. 1–8. [Google Scholar]
- European Environment Agency. Flexibility Solutions to Support a Decarbonised and Secure EU Electricity System; Publications Office: Luxembourg, 2023. [Google Scholar]
- El Gohary, F. The Price Signal Paradigm—On the Evolution and Limitations of Demand-Side Flexibility in the EU. Energy Policy 2024, 192, 114239. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Regulation (EU) 2021/1119 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 June 2021 Establishing the Framework for Achieving Climate Neutrality and Amending Regulations (EC) No 401/2009 and (EU) 2018/1999 (‘European Climate Law’). Off. J. Eur. Union 2021, L 243, 1–17.
- IRENA. Demand-Side Flexibility for Power Sector Transformation; International Renewable Energy Agency: Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, 2019; ISBN 978-92-9260-159-1. [Google Scholar]
- CEER. Advice on Ensuring Market and Regulatory Arrangements Help Deliver Demand-Side Flexibility; Council of European Energy Regulators: Brussels, Belgium, 2014. [Google Scholar]
- Regulatory Recommendations for the Deployment of Flexibility; Smart Grid Task Force: Brussels, Belgium, 2015.
- About DNV. Available online: https://www.dnv.com/about/ (accessed on 23 September 2025).
- Armenteros, A.S.; de Heer, H.; Fiorini, L.; Castillo, M.M.; Slot, T. Demand-Side Flexibility: Quantification of Benefits in the EU; DNV: Greater Oslo, Norway, 2022. [Google Scholar]
- Li, P.-H.; Pye, S. Assessing the Benefits of Demand-Side Flexibility in Residential and Transport Sectors from an Integrated Energy Systems Perspective. Appl. Energy 2018, 228, 965–979. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Energy Statistics—An Overview. Available online: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Energy_statistics_-_an_overview (accessed on 23 June 2025).
- Kim, J.-H.; Shcherbakova, A. Common Failures of Demand Response. Energy 2011, 36, 873–880. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Parrish, B.; Gross, R.; Heptonstall, P. On Demand: Can Demand Response Live up to Expectations in Managing Electricity Systems? Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 2019, 51, 107–118. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Golmohamadi, H. Demand-Side Flexibility in Power Systems: A Survey of Residential, Industrial, Commercial, and Agricultural Sectors. Sustainability 2022, 14, 7916. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- European Smart Grids Task Force. Demand Side Flexibility: Perceived Barriers and Proposed Recommendations; EG3; European Smart Grids Task Force: Brussels, Belgium, 2019. [Google Scholar]
- Paterakis, N.G.; Erdinç, O.; Catalão, J.P.S. An Overview of Demand Response: Key-Elements and International Experience. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 2017, 69, 871–891. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- He, X.; Keyaerts, N.; Azevedo, I.; Meeus, L.; Hancher, L.; Glachant, J.-M. How to Engage Consumers in Demand Response: A Contract Perspective. Util. Policy 2013, 27, 108–122. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Plaum, F.; Ahmadiahangar, R.; Rosin, A.; Kilter, J. Aggregated Demand-Side Energy Flexibility: A Comprehensive Review on Characterization, Forecasting and Market Prospects. Energy Rep. 2022, 8, 9344–9362. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Khabdullin, A.; Khabdullina, Z.; Khabdullin, A.; Khabdullina, G.; Lauka, D.; Blumberga, D. Analysis of Industrial Electricity Consumption Flexibility. Assessment of Saving Potential in Latvia and Kazakhstan. Energy Procedia 2017, 113, 450–453. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Striani, S.; Unterluggauer, T.; Andersen, P.B.; Marinelli, M. Flexibility Potential Quantification of Electric Vehicle Charging Clusters. Sustain. Energy Grids Netw. 2024, 40, 101547. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- European Commission. Smart Readiness Indicator. European Commission. Available online: https://energy.ec.europa.eu/topics/energy-efficiency/energy-efficient-buildings/smart-readiness-indicator_en (accessed on 23 June 2025).
- Babatunde, O.M.; Munda, J.L.; Hamam, Y. Power System Flexibility: A Review. Energy Rep. 2020, 6, 101–106. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cochran, J.; Miller, M.; Zinaman, O.; Milligan, M.; Arent, D.; Palmintier, B.; O’Malley, M.; Mueller, S.; Lannoye, E.; Tuohy, A.; et al. Flexibility in 21st Century Power Systems; National Renewable Energy Laboratory: Golden, CO, USA, 2014; p. 1130630. [Google Scholar]
- Heussen, K.; Bondy, D.E.M.; Hu, J.; Gehrke, O.; Hansen, L.H. A Clearinghouse Concept for Distribution-Level Flexibility Services. In Proceedings of the IEEE PES ISGT Europe 2013, Lyngby, Denmark, 6–9 October 2013; pp. 1–5. [Google Scholar]
- Heffner, G.C.; Goldman, C.; Kirby, B. Loads Providing Ancillary Services: Review of International Experience; Berkeley National Laboratory: Berkeley, CA, USA, 2007. [Google Scholar]
- Garttan, G.; Alahakoon, S.; Emami, K.; Jayasinghe, S.G. Battery Energy Storage Systems: Energy Market Review, Challenges, and Opportunities in Frequency Control Ancillary Services. Energies 2025, 18, 4174. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Eid, C.; Codani, P.; Perez, Y.; Reneses, J.; Hakvoort, R. Managing Electric Flexibility from Distributed Energy Resources: A Review of Incentives for Market Design. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 2016, 64, 237–247. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- European Commission. Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2020/2155 of 14 October 2020 Supplementing Directive (EU) 2010/31/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council by Establishing an Optional Common European Union Scheme for Rating the Smart Readiness of Buildings. Off. J. Eur. Union 2020, L 431, 9–24. [Google Scholar]
- Degefa, M.Z.; Sperstad, I.B.; Sæle, H. Comprehensive Classifications and Characterizations of Power System Flexibility Resources. Electr. Power Syst. Res. 2021, 194, 107022. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- REEFLEX Project. REplicable, Interoperable, Cross-Sector Solutions and Energy Services for Demand Side FLEXibility Markets (REEFLEX); Horizon Europe Project, Grant Agreement No. 101096192, 2023–2026; CIRCE Foundation: Zaragoza, Spain. Available online: https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/101096192 (accessed on 22 September 2025).
- European Environment Agency Heating Degree Days. Available online: https://climate-adapt.eea.europa.eu/en/metadata/indicators/heating-degree-days-1 (accessed on 24 July 2025).
- European Environment Agency Cooling Degree Days. Available online: https://climate-adapt.eea.europa.eu/en/metadata/indicators/cooling-degree-days (accessed on 24 July 2025).
- European Environment Agency. Hot Days. Available online: https://climate-adapt.eea.europa.eu/en/metadata/indicators/hot-days (accessed on 25 July 2025).
- European Environment Agency. Frost Days. Available online: https://climate-adapt.eea.europa.eu/en/metadata/indicators/frost-days (accessed on 25 July 2025).
- Ortiz, M.; Itard, L.; Bluyssen, P.M. Indoor Environmental Quality Related Risk Factors with Energy-Efficient Retrofitting of Housing: A Literature Review. Energy Build. 2020, 221, 110102. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- European Commission. Energy Efficient Buildings. Available online: https://energy.ec.europa.eu/topics/energy-efficiency/energy-efficient-buildings_en (accessed on 25 July 2025).
- European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control. Heating, Ventilation and Air-Conditioning Systems in the Context of COVID-19: First Update; ECDC: Solna, Sweden, 2020. [Google Scholar]
- European Environment Agency and European Commission European. Air Quality Index. Available online: https://airindex.eea.europa.eu/AQI/index.html (accessed on 28 July 2025).
- European Commission. How Polluted Is the Air in Urban Areas? Available online: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/-/edn-20210603-1 (accessed on 28 July 2025).
- European Alternative Fuels Observatory. Charging Ahead: Accelerating the Roll-Out of EU Electric Vehicle Charging Infrastructure; European Alternative Fuels Observatory: Brussels, Belgium, 2024. [Google Scholar]
- European Alternative Fuels Observatory. New Study: Accelerating EU Electric Vehicle Charging Infrastructure Roll-Out. Available online: https://alternative-fuels-observatory.ec.europa.eu/general-information/news/new-study-accelerating-eu-electric-vehicle-charging-infrastructure-roll (accessed on 22 September 2025).
- González-Torres, M.; Pérez-Lombard, L.; Coronel, J.F.; Maestre, I.R.; Yan, D. A Review on Buildings Energy Information: Trends, End-Uses, Fuels and Drivers. Energy Rep. 2022, 8, 626–637. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2025 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).