Review Reports
- Norainy Abdul Razak 1,*,
- Mohamad Izani Zainal Abidin 2 and
- Hanan Elgendi 4
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Jill Channing Reviewer 2: Viktor Wang Reviewer 3: Anonymous Reviewer 4: Rina Zviel Girshin Reviewer 5: Alessio Di Paolo
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis study addresses a timely and important topic, and its focus on an Egyptian university context is one of its strongest contributions. Much of the current AI-in-education literature is centered on Western contexts and often emphasizes STEM fields, so this setting adds value to the conversation. The mixed-methods design is appropriate for the study’s purpose, and the manuscript is generally well organized. However, in its current form, the paper has several significant issues that should be addressed.
The most important concern is the lack of theoretical grounding in creativity research. The manuscript uses “creativity” as a central concept, but it does not clearly define what creativity means in this study. Foundational scholars such as Amabile, Csikszentmihalyi, Guilford, and Runco are not discussed, even though their work would be directly relevant. As a result, the literature review reads more like a short overview of recent AI-in-education studies than a meaningful engagement with creativity as a theoretical construct. Before the authors can make claims about AI’s effect on creativity, they need to explain how creativity is being defined, understood, and measured in relation to existing educational and psychological research.
This issue also affects the interpretation of the data. In the open-ended responses, students often describe AI as helping them save time, complete assignments more quickly, and organize content. These responses point more toward efficiency and task completion than creativity as it is traditionally understood in the literature. The authors briefly acknowledge this tension in section 4.5, but they move past it too quickly. In fact, this may be one of the most interesting findings in the study. The possible shift from “creativity as original or novel thinking” to “creativity as efficient task completion” deserves much fuller attention in the discussion. The authors should consider how this reframing compares with established definitions of creativity and what it means pedagogically if students are equating fluency, speed, or productivity with creative work.
The manuscript would also benefit from clearly stated research questions. The general purpose of the study can be inferred from the introduction, but the research questions themselves are not formally presented. This makes it harder to judge whether the methods align with the study’s aims and weakens the overall structure of the paper. Clear research questions would help guide the reader and provide a stronger framework for the findings.
The methodology section also needs additional development. The survey instrument should be included in full, either in the manuscript or as a supplementary file. The three Likert-scale items described in the paper, which focus on understanding digital media concepts, assignment efficiency, and knowledge applicable to future coursework, seem to measure perceived usefulness and efficiency more than creativity itself. The authors need to explain why these items are appropriate measures of creativity, or they should revise the instrument to include items more directly connected to creativity as a construct. Reliability statistics are also needed. At minimum, the authors should report Cronbach’s alpha or another appropriate measure of internal consistency. The decision to exclude demographic variables is explained as theoretically motivated, and that choice is not necessarily unreasonable. However, the manuscript also states that no significant demographic differences were found during a preliminary review. If those analyses were conducted, the results should be briefly reported rather than simply asserted.
There is also a factual inconsistency that needs to be corrected. The abstract reports the correlation as r = .31, p < .01, while Table 4 and the body of the manuscript report p < .001. This should be reconciled so the statistical findings are reported consistently throughout the paper. The authors should also be more measured in how they discuss the strength of the correlation. Although the relationship is statistically significant, it is modest in size.
The qualitative analysis section is underdeveloped. The manuscript states that inter-coder agreement was established through repeated coder consensus and saturation evaluation processes, but it does not provide a quantitative reliability measure such as Cohen’s kappa. Since the authors reference Braun and Clarke’s approach, they should describe the thematic analysis process in more detail. The current discussion of themes is fairly thin. Each theme is supported by only a few short quotations, and the manuscript does not explain how the team moved from initial codes to final themes. It also does not address whether negative cases or conflicting responses were identified and how those were handled.
The discussion section needs to do more than restate the findings. It does not engage deeply enough with the existing literature. The connection to Vygotsky’s zone of proximal development is introduced briefly, but it is not developed in a meaningful way. Cognitive load theory would also be a natural fit for the authors’ argument that AI reduces cognitive load, but Sweller’s work is not cited. Also, Sternberg is listed in the references but not substantively discussed. This is especially important because Sternberg’s 2024 work argues that generative AI may compromise human creativity, which is in tension with the claims made in this manuscript. The authors should address that tension directly rather than leaving it unresolved.
The manuscript would benefit from careful editing for style and clarity. Several sentences are awkward, overly long, or unnecessarily repetitive, especially in the methodology and results sections. Clarifying the language would make the argument clearer and help the manuscript read more professionally.
This paper has promise. The topic is relevant, the context is valuable, and the mixed-methods approach could yield useful insights. However, the authors need to strengthen the theoretical grounding, clarify the research questions, better justify the measurement of creativity, expand the qualitative analysis, and engage more deeply with the literature before the manuscript is ready for publication.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe methodology section opens with the sentence, “The reasons why we are using an exploratory cross-sectionally-designed research approach is because it will allow us to be able to find new emerging themes and patterns.” This sentence is awkward and repetitive. “The reasons why” can be shortened, “allow us to be able to” can simply be “allow us to,” and “new emerging themes” is redundant because emerging themes are, by definition, new. The phrase “cross-sectionally-designed” is also awkward; “cross-sectional” would be clearer and more conventional. The next sentence makes essentially the same point again by stating that the approach allows flexibility in examining different student-AI interaction experiences. These two sentences should be combined into one clearer sentence.
There is also a subject-verb agreement problem in that same opening sentence. “The reasons...is because” is grammatically incorrect. The sentence should either use “reasons...are” or, better yet, be rewritten entirely for clarity.
The manuscript also confuses “i.e.” and “e.g.” in more than one place. In the introduction, the authors write “i.e., creativity, collaboration, and problem solving” when referring to 21st-century skills. Since those are examples rather than a complete definition, “e.g.” would be the correct abbreviation. The same issue appears again in the methodology section. These may seem like small errors, but they signal that the manuscript needs more careful proofreading.
Semicolons are also used incorrectly in several places. For instance, the sentence “Using a mixed-methodology approach; both quantitative and qualitative methodologies were employed” does not use the semicolon correctly. A semicolon should connect two independent clauses, and the first part of this sentence is not an independent clause. A comma, colon, or full sentence revision would work better. A similar problem appears later in section 4.2 with the sentence, “There may be several reasons why this could occur; possible explanations include increased confidence or better use of tools.” This sentence would also benefit from revision.
The introduction includes one sentence that is incorrect as written: “Generative AI, like chatbots that are used by ChatGPT and Bing Chat.” ChatGPT and Bing Chat are not tools that use chatbots; they are chatbots. A clearer version would be something like, “Generative AI tools such as ChatGPT and Bing Chat, which function as AI-powered chatbots, have been widely adopted.”
There are also capitalization issues throughout the literature review. In section 2.3, terms such as “Quantitative Data,” “Qualitative Insights,” and “Mixed-Methods Research Designs” are capitalized in the middle of ordinary sentences. These are not proper nouns and should not be capitalized.
The discussion section opens with a sentence that is difficult to understand: “A major outcome of each data source was a creative notion of creativity.” The meaning seems to be that students viewed creativity in a practical or functional way, but the current phrasing is circular. A clearer version might be: “Across both data sources, a consistent finding was that students’ conceptions of creativity were more functional than expressive.”
Tense also needs attention. The methodology section shifts between present tense, such as “is used” and “has been developed,” and past tense, such as “were collected” and “were employed,” when describing the same completed study. In empirical research, completed procedures are typically described in the past tense. The authors should apply past tense consistently in the methodology and results sections.
There are also some places where word choice should be adjusted. In section 3.1, the authors state that demographic characteristics were “eliminated” from the primary analysis. “Excluded” would be more appropriate because it suggests that the variables were intentionally left out by design. “Eliminated” can imply that the variables were removed after being found problematic. Similarly, in section 3.2, the manuscript refers to survey responses as a “database.” In this context, “dataset” or “sample” would be more accurate.
The results section includes the sentence, “Overall sentiment toward AI-assisted creative efforts is shown by Figure 1 to be generally favourable.” This construction is awkward because it delays the main subject and action of the sentence. A clearer version would be: “Figure 1 shows that overall student sentiment toward AI-assisted creative efforts was generally favorable.” This revision is more direct and also uses past tense appropriately.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript addresses a timely and relevant topic concerning the role of AI tools in supporting creativity and learning within higher education environments. The mixed-methods approach is appropriate for the research questions, and the study provides useful insight into student perceptions of AI-assisted creative learning within a non-Western educational context. The discussion regarding AI as a form of cognitive scaffolding is particularly valuable and represents one of the manuscript’s strongest conceptual contributions.
The manuscript is generally well organized and adequately referenced with current scholarship related to AI, creativity, and higher education. The integration of quantitative and qualitative findings is also handled reasonably well, and the study contributes to ongoing discussions regarding AI-enhanced learning environments.
However, several areas would benefit from revision prior to publication consideration. First, the manuscript occasionally overstates its findings, particularly regarding “creativity enhancement.” The study primarily measures students’ perceptions of creativity support rather than objective creativity outcomes. This distinction should be clarified more consistently throughout the manuscript, especially in the discussion and conclusion sections.
Second, the statistical analysis is relatively modest and should be interpreted more cautiously. The reported correlations are meaningful but moderate in strength. Additional discussion regarding the limitations of self-reported perception data and exploratory cross-sectional design would strengthen the manuscript’s academic rigor.
Third, the literature review could engage more deeply with creativity theory, constructivist learning theory, and human–AI collaboration scholarship. The current review adequately summarizes prior work but could provide a stronger theoretical foundation for the study’s conceptual framing.
Finally, the manuscript would benefit from additional language editing and stylistic refinement. While the paper is understandable overall, there are repetitive phrases, awkward sentence constructions, and grammatical inconsistencies that occasionally reduce clarity. Tightening the prose would substantially improve readability and scholarly presentation.
Overall, the study addresses an important contemporary issue and demonstrates publishable potential following moderate revision.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe manuscript is generally understandable and communicates the research objectives, methodology, and findings adequately. However, the quality of English language expression would benefit from further refinement prior to publication. Several sections contain repetitive wording, awkward sentence structures, grammatical inconsistencies, and overly long sentences that occasionally reduce clarity and readability. Additional language editing and stylistic polishing would strengthen the manuscript’s scholarly presentation and improve overall flow.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe literature review is too brief and lacks key sources. The theoretical concepts of mediated learning and zones of proximal development (ZPD), referenced via Vygotsky (lines 283–285), appear only in the Discussion, not in the theoretical background where they belong. More critically, despite explicitly identifying the lack of research in non-Western/non-STEM contexts as the main gap this study addresses (lines 85–86), the literature review cites no scholarship on creativity in non-Western educational settings or on digital media education as a discipline. This gap must be addressed before publication.
No explicit research questions or hypotheses are stated anywhere in the manuscript. These must be formulated clearly at the end of the Introduction section.
Regarding methodology, three issues require attention. First, the exclusion of demographic variables is justified post-hoc ("no significant differences were found upon reviewing the preliminary data," lines 105–106), which inverts standard methodological practice. Inclusion and exclusion criteria must be established prior to analysis on theoretical or design grounds, not derived from the data themselves. Second, Section 3.3 conflates instrument components with sample characterization variables in a confusing way; the structure of the survey and the descriptive variables should be presented separately and clearly. Third, the single-institution, single-country design limits generalizability beyond what is currently acknowledged, and this should be stated more explicitly in the Limitations.
The claim that AI is driving a "redefinition of creativity" (lines 253–256) is not sufficiently supported by the data presented, which primarily evidence gains in task efficiency, content organization, and information access — not a conceptual shift in how creativity is understood. This assertion should either be substantiated with stronger evidence from the data or reframed explicitly as a hypothesis for future research. Additionally, student concerns about over-reliance and loss of originality are raised in Section 5.4 but do not appear as a distinct theme in the thematic analysis reported in Section 4.4. This internal inconsistency must be resolved — either by incorporating these concerns into the thematic structure or by explaining their analytical status.
The conclusion states that the study proposes "a conceptual framework for AI-enhanced creative learning" (line 323). No such framework is developed, presented, or formalized anywhere in the manuscript. This claim must either be substantiated with an actual framework or removed.
The acknowledgements describe using AI tools to analyze "the complex relationships between different social media platforms and student outcomes" (lines 335–336). This study does not address social media platforms. This text appears to have been carried over from a different manuscript and must be corrected before publication, as it raises concerns about the integrity and careful preparation of the submission.
With 16 references, the bibliographic coverage is insufficient for a mixed-methods article of this scope. Key missing areas include creativity in non-Western educational contexts, digital media as a pedagogical discipline, and survey methodology in non-Western institutional settings. The concepts of mediated learning and zones of proximal development are cited without contemporary sources that would anchor them within current debates on AI-assisted learning.
In short, this manuscript addresses a relevant and timely question, and the mixed-methods approach is appropriate for the study's objectives. The quantitative results are clearly reported and the qualitative themes are supported by representative student quotes. However, the manuscript requires substantial revision before it can be considered for publication. The main concerns are: the absence of explicit research questions and hypotheses; a literature review that is too brief and disconnected from the theoretical concepts used in the discussion; methodological decisions that are not adequately justified; discussion claims that go beyond what the data support; and a factual error in the acknowledgements that must be corrected as a matter of priority. Addressing these issues systematically would significantly strengthen the manuscript's contribution to the field.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe manuscript is generally readable, but the writing lacks the precision and fluency expected at this level of academic publication. A professional English review is strongly recommended before resubmission. The methodology section in particular presents overly complex and repetitive sentence structures that hinder clarity. Some formulations appear formulaic or artificially constructed, which affects the overall academic register of the manuscript. The authors are encouraged to prioritize concision and naturalness, particularly in Sections 3 and 4, where dense phrasing sometimes obscures rather than communicates the methodological choices made.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe article will be worthy of publication after some minor changes.
The authors should be complimented on their interesting research.
It could become a much more valuable reading if the authors expand and add more of the valuable findings and ideas they have accumulated during the research as detailed hereunder.
The research questions are not formulated as clearly and definitively as they should be. They are stated as follows: "This study investigated the perceived effects of AI tools on student creativity in Digital Media coursework. Using a mixed-methodology approach, both quantitative and qualitative methodologies were employed to examine student interactions with AI tools and their effects on creative processes." The 4.Results section could be a little more detailed. On the other hand, some inferences and suggestions could be relocated into the 5. Discussion chapter, like: "Understanding this dis- 261
tinction is particularly significant for teachers who seek to integrate AI tools into educa- 262
tional practices. Teachers must develop a clear understanding regarding when AI tools 263
should be used to reduce cognitive load and when AI tools should be used to provide 264
students with opportunities to think critically and create something uniquely original. "
Some statements are too fuzzy and generalm and should be extended and become more concrete, like:
"A major outcome of each data source was a creative notion of creativity; rather than 269
relating to boundless novelty, students' perceptions of creativity were associated with ide- 270
ational structure, increased speed in completing tasks, and higher-quality outputs. "
The discussion and conclusion chapters should be significantly extended to include much more of the wealth of new knowledge. In particular the 5.5. Implications for Educational Practice is much too short.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 5 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis manuscript addresses a timely and increasingly relevant topic, namely the role of artificial intelligence tools in supporting creativity within higher education learning environments. The focus on Digital Media students in Egypt offers a valuable contribution to a field that is still largely dominated by studies conducted in Western contexts. The mixed-methods design also represents an appropriate methodological choice for exploring both students’ perceptions and the meanings they attribute to AI-supported learning experiences.
The manuscript is generally well organized and the results are presented in a clear and accessible manner. The integration of quantitative and qualitative findings allows readers to gain a broader understanding of how students perceive the relationship between AI use and creativity. The study also highlights practical implications that may be useful for educators seeking to integrate AI tools into creative learning environments.
Several aspects, however, would benefit from further development.
First, the theoretical framing of creativity remains relatively limited. Creativity is treated primarily as a perceived outcome associated with efficiency, idea generation, and task completion. While this interpretation emerges from the data, the manuscript would benefit from a deeper engagement with established theories of creativity and creative learning. The discussion could be strengthened by positioning the findings in relation to contemporary conceptualizations of creativity in educational contexts, particularly those emphasizing originality, divergent thinking, collaborative creativity, and socio-cultural perspectives.
Second, the research design would benefit from greater methodological transparency. The manuscript refers to an exploratory mixed-methods approach but does not explicitly formulate research questions or research objectives beyond a general investigation of student perceptions. Clearly stated research questions would help readers understand the analytical logic guiding the study.
The description of the survey instrument also requires further detail. Information regarding instrument development, validation procedures, pilot testing, internal consistency, and the operationalization of key constructs is currently limited. Since creativity perception constitutes the central variable of the study, readers would benefit from a clearer explanation of how this construct was measured and interpreted.
Although the qualitative analysis follows Braun and Clarke’s thematic analysis framework, the coding process remains somewhat underdeveloped. Additional information regarding the coding stages, coder involvement, procedures used to ensure analytical trustworthiness, and examples of coding decisions would strengthen the rigor of the qualitative component.
The discussion section occasionally extends beyond what can be directly supported by the data. In particular, the argument proposing a reconceptualization of creativity as cognitive scaffolding appears theoretically interesting but would require stronger empirical grounding. Given that the study relies exclusively on self-reported perceptions, some statements concerning the nature of creativity itself should be presented more cautiously.
Another aspect deserving attention concerns the distinction between perceived creativity and actual creative performance. The study successfully investigates students’ perceptions, yet several passages imply conclusions about creativity enhancement more broadly. Clarifying this distinction throughout the manuscript would improve conceptual precision.
The manuscript would also benefit from a more critical engagement with the limitations of self-report measures, the single-institution sample, and the potential influence of social desirability bias. While limitations are acknowledged, a more detailed reflection would help contextualize the findings.
Finally, several sections would benefit from linguistic revision. Although the manuscript is fully understandable, there are numerous instances of repetitive phrasing, grammatical inconsistencies, and awkward sentence constructions. Careful proofreading by a native English speaker or professional language editor would improve readability and academic style.
Overall, this study offers an interesting contribution to current discussions on AI-supported learning and student creativity. With further refinement of the theoretical framework, methodological reporting, and discussion of findings, the manuscript has the potential to make a meaningful contribution to the literature on artificial intelligence in higher education.
Comments on the Quality of English Languagehe overall quality of English is adequate and allows readers to follow the study without difficulty. Nevertheless, the manuscript would benefit from minor language revisions aimed at improving sentence structure, stylistic consistency, and academic fluency. Careful proofreading would enhance clarity and readability throughout the text.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript has improved substantially since the earlier version. The revision now offers a clearer conceptual grounding for creativity, especially through the distinction between creativity as novelty/usefulness and the study’s more limited construct of perceived creative support. This distinction is important and helps prevent the manuscript from overstating what the data can show. The addition of formal research questions also strengthens the organization and makes the alignment among purpose, methods, results, and discussion easier to follow.
The revised methodology is also stronger. The authors now describe the study as an exploratory, cross-sectional, convergent mixed-methods design, and the explanation of the questionnaire, the Perceived Creative Support subscale, and the qualitative prompts is clearer. Including the full instrument in the appendix is a helpful addition. The reporting of reliability statistics for both the full 24-item battery and the four-item subscale also improves the credibility of the quantitative analysis. The use of both Pearson and Spearman correlations is appropriate given the ordinal nature of the survey items and the distributional concerns noted by the authors.
The results are clearer than in the previous version. The corrected correlation reporting resolves the earlier inconsistency, and the interpretation of the correlation as small-to-moderate is appropriately cautious. I also appreciate that the manuscript now foregrounds the difference between students’ strong endorsement of AI for efficiency and their weaker endorsement of AI as enhancing creative authorship. This is one of the most interesting findings in the study and should remain central to the article.
The qualitative analysis is much improved. The authors now explain their use of reflexive thematic analysis in greater detail, describe the coding process, and justify why a kappa statistic was not computed. The addition of a fifth theme addressing overreliance, authenticity, and independent thinking makes the qualitative findings more balanced. This helps the article avoid presenting student perceptions of AI in overly positive or one-sided terms.
I recommend acceptance after minor revision. The remaining issues are not major, but the authors should address them before publication.
The manuscript should continue to be careful with causal language. The study is based on cross-sectional, self-report data from one institutional context. The authors generally acknowledge this limitation, but a few claims still read as though AI “supports,” “enhances,” or “scaffolds” creativity directly. In places where the analysis is based on perception data, phrasing such as “students perceived AI as supporting...” or “AI was experienced by students as...” would be more precise.
The discussion should maintain a clear distinction between perceived creative support and demonstrated creativity. The manuscript has improved in this respect, but the distinction is important enough that it should remain visible throughout the abstract, discussion, and conclusion. The study does not measure originality, quality of creative products, or independent expert assessment of student work. Its contribution is better framed as evidence about how students understand and experience AI-assisted creative work.
The discussion could still be clarified slightly. The revised discussion is stronger, but some portions restate the findings before moving into interpretation. The most compelling contribution is the tension between creativity as original or expressive work and creativity as efficiency, organization, and task completion. The authors should consider sharpening the discussion around that tension and making it the through-line of the article.
The limitations section should more directly acknowledge the newly constructed nature of the four-item Perceived Creative Support subscale. The authors do acknowledge that formal validation is needed, but this point should be emphasized because the subscale combines items related to understanding, efficiency, future applicability, and creative authorship. These are related but not identical constructs. Future research should validate the measure and compare self-reported creative support with external assessments of creative products.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe English is generally understandable, and the manuscript is much clearer than the earlier version. However, the article would still benefit from careful copyediting before publication. Some sentences remain lengthy, abstract, or slightly awkward, especially in the literature review and discussion. In several places, the authors use broad terms such as “support,” “enhance,” “innovation,” “creative learning,” and “cognitive scaffold” in ways that could be made more precise.
The authors should pay particular attention to phrasing that may imply causality. Because the study is based on students’ perceptions rather than objective measures of creative performance, the language should consistently reflect that limitation. For example, “AI enhanced creativity” should usually be revised to “students perceived AI as enhancing their creative process” or “students reported that AI supported aspects of their creative work.” This change would improve both accuracy and clarity.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors have substantially improved the manuscript and have addressed the concerns raised during the previous review round. The revised version provides a stronger theoretical foundation by clearly defining creativity, situating the study within constructivist, mediated learning, and cognitive load frameworks, and establishing a clearer rationale for examining AI-assisted creative learning in a non-Western, non-STEM context.
The methodology is now presented more transparently, with clearer descriptions of the convergent mixed-methods design, instrumentation, quantitative analyses, qualitative procedures, and integration of findings. I particularly appreciate the authors’ explicit distinction between perceived creative support and objectively measured creative performance, as this clarification strengthens the validity of the study’s conclusions and prevents overinterpretation of the findings.
The results are clearly presented and effectively integrated across the quantitative and qualitative strands. The inclusion of both positive and critical perspectives regarding AI use, especially concerns related to overreliance, authenticity, and independent thinking, provides a balanced and nuanced discussion. The limitations section has also been strengthened and appropriately acknowledges the constraints of the study design.
The manuscript makes a meaningful contribution to the growing literature on AI-supported learning by providing evidence from an underrepresented educational context and by proposing a theoretically informed framework for understanding AI-augmented creative learning. The conclusions are appropriately cautious and remain aligned with the evidence presented.
I have no further substantive concerns and believe the manuscript is suitable for publication in its current form.
Author Response
Reviewer comment: The authors have substantially improved the manuscript… I have no further substantive concerns and believe the manuscript is suitable for publication in its current form.
Response: We sincerely thank Reviewer 2 for the positive assessment and for recommending acceptance. No further changes were requested. The refinements made in response to Reviewer 1 strengthen the manuscript without altering the findings or conclusions that Reviewer 2 endorsed.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe revised manuscript shows a clear and substantial improvement. The theoretical framework is now well developed, the research questions and mixed-methods design are clearly articulated, and the results are presented in a coherent and transparent way. Your responses successfully address the earlier concerns about conceptual grounding, methodological clarity, and alignment between findings and conclusions. In its current form, the paper is, in my view, suitable for publication, with only very minor wording refinements left to the discretion of the authors and editors if deemed necessary.
Author Response
Reviewer comment: The revised manuscript shows a clear and substantial improvement. The theoretical framework is now well developed, the research questions and mixed-methods design are clearly articulated, and the results are presented in a coherent and transparent way. Your responses successfully address the earlier concerns about conceptual grounding, methodological clarity, and alignment between findings and conclusions. In its current form, the paper is, in my view, suitable for publication, with only very minor wording refinements left to the discretion of the authors and editors if deemed necessary.
Response: We sincerely thank Reviewer 3 for the positive assessment and for recommending acceptance. No further changes were requested. The refinements made in response to Reviewer 1 strengthen the manuscript without altering the findings or conclusions that Reviewer 3 endorsed.