Abstract
Material selection for double-disc straight-groove lapping affects not only interfacial friction and disc wear but also workpiece material removal during free-abrasive processing. Although engineering-material tribology and the third-body approach have been widely investigated, how frictional resistance, disc consumption, and counterbody removal jointly inform material selection under comparable three-body abrasive conditions remains insufficiently clarified. Here, HT250 gray cast iron, AISI 1045 steel, H62 brass, polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), and poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) were compared against GCr15 bearing steel in pin-on-disc tests using a slurry containing W40 white alumina abrasives under normal loads of 15–30 N. Friction coefficients, mass and volumetric wear rates, volumetric lapping ratios, and post-test SEM–EDS observations were examined together. The results revealed material-dependent friction–wear relationships. H62 brass showed an overall decrease in friction with increasing load despite increasing mass wear rate. PMMA combined comparatively high friction with a low mass wear rate; however, density-based conversion demonstrated that low mass loss did not necessarily imply low volumetric consumption. Its volumetric lapping ratio was approximately 0.30 at 30 N. PTFE exhibited a friction coefficient of approximately 0.02–0.03, but its mass loss was near or below the balance resolution, precluding reliable wear and lapping-ratio evaluation. Surface characterization provided local evidence for plowing, plastic deformation, localized material transfer, and shallow abrasion, without directly establishing abrasive motion or dynamic third-body evolution. The contribution of this study lies in a controlled cross-material comparison demonstrating that frictional resistance, volumetric disc consumption, and relative counterbody removal are complementary but noninterchangeable evaluation dimensions. These findings advance application-oriented material screening beyond isolated low-friction or low-wear judgments toward joint assessment of workpiece removal and tool consumption. Practical qualification requires further evaluation of material removal rate, machined surface quality, disc shape retention, and long-term service performance.