Review Reports
- Noriko Sato 1,2,*,
- Hiiro Terasaki 2 and
- Shigenobu Shibata 3,5
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Mauro Fisberg Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe study by the Sato group in the paper Day-to-Day Variability in Meal Timing and Its Association 2 with Body Mass Index: A Study Using Data from a Japanese 3 Food-Logging Mobile Application, which evaluates the regularity of meals (e.g., breakfast), chronotype, and nutritional composition, is fascinating.
The fact that they used an app that had already been tested in several studies, with proper meal-based interpretation of food intake, and the possibility of using photos and QR codes, greatly facilitated the analysis of a large group of respondents.
The definitions of breakfast with a minimum intake and the classification of the meal type to which a given intake refers determine the quality of the data. One caveat is that when there was no record for a given day, the previous day's record was used. Could this be an unrecorded day, a day when quantities were exceeded?
However, the use of a self-completed application excludes judgments. But because it allows assessment of the quantity and quality of the diet, there may be significant changes in food intake to correct it. Another important factor—wouldn't those who complete the application regularly already have a more adequate diet?
As the paper concerns only the quantity of the specific meal and its regularity, not its nutritional quality, we believe the analysis is correct.
The specific findings for chronotype and diet regularity, shown in the graphs, show minimal variability, which is statistically significant given the large number of subjects and the type of analysis.
Another aspect is that most respondents are female, tend to be older, and are disciplined enough to complete at least 25 of the 30 days required. Doesn't the cultural characteristic strictly imply a culture of eating three meals a day? The Japanese dietary standard may bias data interpretation. Almost 60% of the articles cited are national.
In conclusion, the published project is exquisite and demonstrates the feasibility of electronic food recording for analyzing chronotypes and their effects on associated health variables.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript presents an original and well-structured investigation into the relationship between day-to-day variability in meal timing and body mass index using a large dataset from a Japanese mobile food-logging application. The topic is timely and relevant in the context of chrono-nutrition and public health, and the use of long-term (1-month) high-frequency data provides a notable methodological advantage. The paper is clearly written, methodologically sound, and makes a valuable contribution to understanding how mealtime regularity affects metabolic health. Nevertheless, I have a few major comments for the authors that will contribute to improving the quality of the article and increase its attractiveness to the wider scientific community.
- The abbreviation „HbA1c“ in the introduction should be explained. (Line 52)
- The discussion should be expanded to include results from recent original studies that have investigated similar topics and support the conclusions drawn from the present study (such as your finding that the chronotype was strongly associated with BMI in younger women). Recent findings indicate that unhealthy sleep routines (evening/late chronotype) and eating habits (such as late-night eating), as well as meal structure (including skipping breakfast and breakfast irregularity), are associated with unfavorable body composition (e.g., higher BMI, normal-weight obesity, etc.) („Sex-specific interrelationships of sleeping and nutritional habits with somatic health indicators in young adults“; „The prevalence of normal weight obesity in Slovak young adults and its relationship with body composition and lifestyle habits“).
- I noticed an unclear wording in the sentence in the limitations section of the study. „First, basic participant data, such as age, sex, weight, and height, were self-reported rather than directly measured.“ Variables such as age and gender are not considered measurable data.
- „Second, potential confounding factors that may influence dietary habits—such as socioeconomic status,living situation, or menopausal status...“ I would recommend that menopausal status be removed as a confounding factor of dietary habits.
- The discussion could briefly explore why this relationship was not observed in men (e.g., hormonal, lifestyle, or social factors).
- The section on biological mechanisms (ghrelin, food anticipatory response) is strong but could be shortened slightly to maintain focus on the study’s own contributions.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsI am satisfied with the revisions made by the authors. The manuscript has been substantially improved and now meets the journal’s standards for clarity, structure, and scientific rigor.