Abstract
Negative staining electron microscopy methods can be employed for the diagnosis of viral particles in animal samples. In fact, negative staining electron microscopy methods are used to identify viruses, especially in minor species and wild animals, when no other methods are available and in cases of rare, emerging or re-emerging infections. In particular, immune-electron-microscopy with convalescent sera is employed to detect etiological agents when there are undiagnosed clinical outbreaks, when alternative diagnostic methods fail due to the lack of immunological reagents and primers, and when there is no indicative clinical suspect. An overview of immune-electron-microscopy with convalescent sera’s use in the diagnosis of new and unsuspected viruses in animals of domestic and wild species is provided through the descriptions of the following four diagnostic veterinary cases: (I) enteric viruses of pigs: Porcine Rotavirus, Porcine Epidemic Diarrhea Virus, Porcine Circovirus and Porcine Torovirus; (II) Rotavirus and astrovirus in young turkeys with enteritis; (III) Parvovirus-like particles in pheasants; and (IV) Lagoviruses: Rabbit Hemorrhagic Disease Virus and European Brown Hare Syndrome Virus.
1. Introduction
In the last thirty years, the use of negative staining electron microscopy methods (ns-EM), and immune-electron microscopy (IEM), has permitted the detection and identification of different viral particles in samples from several animal species. Compared with other diagnostic techniques, ns-EM excels in speed and “open view”, the ability to detect the “unexpected” without the need for specific reagents [1]. Therefore, ns-EM methods are very useful for identifying the causal agents as viruses when we are confronted with rare infections and new viruses, as well as for viral infections in minor species and wild animals, when no other standardized methods and/or diagnostic reagents are available [2,3,4].
The most relevant IEM method for diagnostic EM of viruses is immuno-aggregation electron microscopy (IAEM). Antibodies are mixed with virus suspensions to form differently sized aggregates of morphologically similar particles which are surrounded by a fuzzy halo of antibodies. In addition to the primary serum’s induction of aggregates and clumps of virions, a secondary step to improve the detection of virus-antibody complexes may be added. Electron-dense colloidal gold particles can be used to enhance (decorate) the visibility of antigen-antibody complexes. The combined techniques, commonly defined as IEM-gold methods, may employ as the “detector” either Protein A or G-gold conjugates that can bind the antibody heavy chains of several species or even secondary anti-species antibodies to which colloidal gold particles have been electrostatically adsorbed [5,6].
IAEM is more specific than other ns-EM methods, combining a morphological identification with antigen specificity, and it is more sensitive, making the identification of known and unknown viruses possible and easier, as well as improving the ability to locate viruses, especially under one of the following conditions: (a) when virions are pleomorphic and difficult to identify because they do not have a typical viral morphology, such as defined symmetry, presence and shape of spikes, particle size, and/or number and arrangement of capsomers; (b) when the viral concentration is low (this technique can provide a 102–103 enrichment [2]); or (c) when the samples are “dirty” because the aggregated complexes are more easily observed.
IAEM may employ, as primary antibody, hyperimmune sera, produced in the same species or in heterologous species, or monoclonal antibodies. Additionally, convalescent sera can also be used. According to Hazelton and Gelderblom [4], convalescent phase sera collected from a case-patients (single surviving animal or animals from the same herd/flock/group, in the case of outbreaks occurring in farm animals) 4–6 weeks after the onset of illness are powerful diagnostic reagents. If no agent has been identified by standard detection procedures, such as ns-EM, tissue culture, immunoassay or nucleic acid amplification techniques, these serum samples may be used to improve the sensitivity of the EM method and to detect the causal agent.
Our objective is to provide an overview of the use of IAEM with convalescent sera for the diagnosis of new and unsuspected viruses in animals of domestic and wild species by describing four diagnostic veterinary cases.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Preparation of Convalescent Sera
Convalescent sera are normally taken 20–30 days after clinical signs are observed from a variable number of animals. Serum can be taken from a single animal or pooled from a group of up to 20 animals, based on the species and size of the group/herd/flock. The pooled sera are centrifuged at 12,800× g for 30 min, inactivated by heating at 56 °C for 30 min and passed through 22 µm filters. Prior to use, convalescent sera are examined using standard direct ns-EM to ensure that they are free from viral particles, and lipid and protein debris. Grids are prepared using the Airfuge method (see Section 2.2 for details) and defined as clean (“blank”), after random screening of the grid for 15 min (at least 5 grid squares).
Determination of the Optimal Dilution of Sera
To achieve good results using the IAEM method, and particularly to induce a proper aggregation/precipitation of virions, it is essential that virions and antibodies are at equal concentrations (“zone phenomenon”) [7]. The dilution is optimal when the immunoaggregates are of adequate size, the halo of antibodies around the virions is not too thick and the virion’s morphology is not altered. To ascertain the optimal dilution, one sample is tested using serial dilutions of the pooled convalescent sera. Initially, 1:2, 1:20, 1:200 and 1:1000 dilutions in phosphate buffer saline (PBS) are tested, and then, based on the results obtained, appropriate intermediate dilutions (1:10, 1:50, 1:100, 1:500, etc.) are used. The determination of the optimal dilution is visual. The observer determines the best combination of aggregate size, antibody halo and virion morphological integrity.
2.2. IAEM Method
Different types of samples, either taken in vivo, such as feces, fluids or swabs, or post-mortem during necropsy, such as viscera or organ contents, may be examined by ns-IAEM. In the first case, the convalescent sera may be taken from the same clinically affected animals, while in the second case, animals of the same group/herd/flock are sampled. Fecal materials and fluids are diluted 1:10 (v/v) in sterile distilled water. Swabs (ocular, nasal, tracheal, fecal etc.) are re-suspended in 1 mL sterile distilled water. Organs (spleen, liver, kidney, lung etc.) extracts (1:10 w/v in sterile distilled water) are obtained by mechanical homogenization using Ultraturrax (IKA®-Werke GmbH & Co. KG, Staufen, Germany).
The samples are first frozen, thawed twice, and then centrifuged at 5500× g for 20 min and at 12,800× g for 10 min for clarification. The second supernatant (85 µL) is mixed with the same amount of each serial dilution of the convalescent sera and then incubated for 1 h at 37 °C before ultracentrifugation using an Airfuge (Beckman Instruments, Palo Alto, CA, USA) for 15 min at 21 psi (82,000× g). The Airfuge is fitted with an A-100/18 rotor holding six 175 µL test tubes containing specific hand-made adapters with 3 mm grids, which allow direct pelleting of viral particles onto a glow-discharged EM sample support (300 mesh copper grid, covered with a carbon reinforced plastic film). The adapters are almost identical to those provided in the past by Beckman. They are made of Plexiglas and shaped to fit perfectly into the tubes. The 3-mm grids are put in a slot obtained on the face of the adapter which has a slant cut with the same angle of the rotor (18°) in order to permit direct pelleting of particles on their surface. Grids are then stained using 2% sodium phosphotungstate (NaPT; Fluka Chemie AG, Buchs, Switzerland), pH 6.8, for 1.5 min and observed with a TEM operating at 80–85 kV, 30,000×. At IZSLER, a Siemens Elmiskop 102 TEM was used till 1988, from 1988 to 2011 a Philips CM10 TEM was used and since August 2011 a FEI Tecnai G2 Spirit Biotwin (FEI, Eindhoven, The Netherlands) TEM was used.
2.3. Controls
The controls employed to ascertain the correctness and accuracy of the IAEM reaction include: (I) preparation of the sample with no serum; (II) incubation with a pre-serum (if available); and/or (III) incubation with another serum. Both negative control sera were used at fixed dilutions of 1:5 and 1:50. Basically, the use of controls at fixed dilutions is a compromise. In the execution of routine diagnostic IAEM tests, negative controls are used with the aim of excluding spontaneous aggregations of virions. The assumption is that both of the employed negative sera will not aggregate all of the virions potentially present in the sample. Therefore, their use at fixed dilutions is conventionally accepted because it is not the intent to detect and evaluate real differences in the levels of binding. They can, therefore, be considered as qualitative and not quantitative controls.
3. Results and Discussion
Some field cases of diagnosing animal diseases are representative of the results obtained by IAEM using convalescent sera to detect “new” and emerging viruses, but also mixed viral infections and non-cultivable viruses. In the subsequent paragraphs we describe the detection of viruses in clinical outbreaks pertaining to different species: enteritis in pigs and turkeys, and hepatitis in pheasant, rabbits and hares.
3.2. Rotavirus and Astrovirus in Young Turkeys with Enteritis
Rotaviruses (RVs) are the major etiological agents of enteric viral diseases in young individuals of several mammalian and avian species [29,30]. In turkey, RVs are often associated with astrovirus (AstV) [31] and cause, with a synergistic effect, clinical enteritis ranging from subclinical to severe [32]. Because of the antigenic variability of turkey RVs, which belong to different groups (A, D, F, and G), the inability to cultivate in vitro both AstV and non-A RVs, and the scarcity of established molecular techniques, EM methods are still useful to quickly achieve a diagnosis of viral enteritis. In particular, IAEM with convalescent sera could simplify and improve viral detection of RVs and AstVs by concentrating and increasing the number of visible particles through their aggregation to form immunocomplexes. Thus, IAEM with convalescent sera has been extensively used for diagnostic examinations of viral enteric infections.
During the period of 1994–2004, 481 fecal and gut samples derived from outbreaks of enteritis in commercial turkeys, which occurred mostly in northern Italy, were conferred to the laboratory and examined by IAEM [33]. All of the birds sampled were between 1 and 5 weeks old and were suffering from systemic and enteric symptoms characterized by growth retardation, lethargy, anorexia, dehydration, wet droppings and/or diarrhea, which led to weight loss, decreased flock uniformity and increased mortality. A pool of sera, taken three weeks after a clinical episode of enteritis caused by RVs and AstVs, was obtained from convalescent turkeys and used to perform IAEM. The results are reported in Table 3. Viral particles were observed in 51.4% of the examined samples and rotavirus (26.6%) and astrovirus (25.8%) mostly clumped in medium-large aggregates, were the most frequently detected particles (Figure 5A). The presence of antibody halos did not hamper the identification of virions, particularly of rotavirus, which, at the serum dilution used, were mostly showing a typical morphology (Figure 5B). AstVs were identified when the 28–30 nm picornavirus-like icosahedral particles displayed the characteristic 5–6 pointed star-shaped surface. However, since the typical star-shaped configuration is usually visible in only approximately 10%–20% of the particles [34], and it may sometimes be obscured by antibodies when examining stools by IAEM [35], we classified particles of this size-class as AstV if they showed a somehow structured surface (Figure 5C).
Figure 5.
Electron micrographs of ultracentrifuged gut contents from 12—to 15-day-old turkeys. (A) Aggregates of both larger, roundish, 60–70 nm rotaviruses (⇧) and smaller, icosahedral non-enveloped 25–27 nm astroviruses (
), surrounded by a fuzzy halo of antibodies are visible; (B) Higher magnification of rotavirus particles: the presence of a halo of antibodies does not mask the typical single—and double-shelled morphology of rotaviruses; (C) Higher magnification of astrovirus particles: the surface of aggregated virions, even if not always distinctively showing the 5–6 star-shaped pattern, do not have a completely homogeneous or featureless surface, which is highly indicative of astroviruses; (D) IAEM negative control: one isolated rotavirus (
) and one astrovirus-like particle (⇧) are visible. Immuno-aggregation electron microscopy (IAEM) preparation with convalescent sera diluted 1:40. Negative staining (2% sodium phosphotungstate). TEM Philips CM10, 80 kV. Bar = 100 nm.
), surrounded by a fuzzy halo of antibodies are visible; (B) Higher magnification of rotavirus particles: the presence of a halo of antibodies does not mask the typical single—and double-shelled morphology of rotaviruses; (C) Higher magnification of astrovirus particles: the surface of aggregated virions, even if not always distinctively showing the 5–6 star-shaped pattern, do not have a completely homogeneous or featureless surface, which is highly indicative of astroviruses; (D) IAEM negative control: one isolated rotavirus (
) and one astrovirus-like particle (⇧) are visible. Immuno-aggregation electron microscopy (IAEM) preparation with convalescent sera diluted 1:40. Negative staining (2% sodium phosphotungstate). TEM Philips CM10, 80 kV. Bar = 100 nm.
Table 3.
Distribution of viral positivity by year and type of virus in fecal samples of 1–5 week old turkey poults showing enteritis. The numbers in italics indicate the percentages calculated based on the total examinations performed each year. The percentage of the positives exams is based on the total examinations although some examinations resulted in more than one positive identification due to the occurrence of multiple infections with two or more viruses in association.
During the observation of samples prepared using the IAEM method, we also identified other virions, which were sparsely distributed or even in small groups, but were not surrounded or immersed in a halo of antibodies. These included 6.9% enterovirus-like particles (possibly AstVs displaying an undefined morphology and a featureless surface), 4.4% of 18–22 nm parvovirus-like particles, 2.1% coronaviruses (the diagnosis was, in this case confirmed using a hyperimmune serum against turkey coronavirus, kindly provided by Prof. Mo Saif, Ohio State University, Wooster, OH, USA), 1.9% adenovirus and 0.6% rod-shaped virus-like particles (RSVLP) [36]. Often (79 cases), we simultaneously observed in the same sample two or more different viruses in a mixed infection. The combination of RVs plus AstVs was the most common (57 cases), supporting their pathogenic roles and importance as primary agents of enteritis (Table 4).
To better characterize and identify those particles observed using ns-EM methods that were morphologically classified as small round viruses (SRVs), AstVs and enterovirus-like viruses (ELVs), we further analyzed samples of different avian commercial species, including turkey, with RT-PCR targeting the open reading frame (ORF)-1b of AstV, which encodes an RNA-dependent polymerase. We then sequenced and genetically analyzed the RT-PCR positive samples, and we performed a phylogenetic analysis to distinguish and type them [37]. This study also permitted us to compare the results obtained by the two diagnostic methods (RT-PCR vs. ns-EM) and to draw some conclusions regarding their respective advantages and disadvantages. ns-EM was confirmed as a very useful method for an initial diagnosis of viral enteritis and for the identification and screening of RVs, SRVs, AstVs and ELVs in avian intestinal and fecal samples because it is fast, can identify viruses that cannot be isolated or identified using other methods, and is also able to distinguish mixed infections and particles that are unable to replicate. Nevertheless, it is only sensitive enough to identify the viral particles when the clinical symptoms of enteritis are present, and it does not allow for the further discrimination and characterization of similar viruses, which require the combined use of PCR and sequencing. Based on these conclusions, presently, in routine laboratory procedures, all of the samples from turkey pullets showing enteritis are examined using IAEM with a 1:40 dilution of the original convalescent sera. Samples are simultaneously subjected to RT-PCR to identify the RV and define the Group (A, D, F or G) [38], as well as to identify and type the AstV [37].
Table 4.
Number and type of multiple infections (association of two of more viruses) observed using IAEM.
3.3. Parvovirus-Like Particles in Pheasants
During the 1994 hatching season in northern Italy, a pathological syndrome was observed in three different pheasant (Phasianus colchicus) rearing facilities within a 20-km radius. The disease in 12 to 25-day-old pheasants was characterized by lethargy, anorexia, diarrhea, weight loss, sudden death and a high mortality (~50%). The affected pheasants had identical clinical signs and lesions, blood suffusions or small subcutaneous hemorrhagic areas and muscular scattered pinpoint hemorrhages, with pale livers that were mottled due to hemorrhagic suffusions, catarrhal duodenitis with swelling of the intestinal loops, and the spleen and bursa of Fabricius were frequently atrophied. Since the disease was not similar to any other previously reported in pheasants, several birds from each outbreak were referred to the diagnostic laboratory for necropsy at different times, and different pools of sera were collected from convalescent birds at two affected farms [39].
An EM examination revealed small, non-enveloped icosahedral viral particles, ~18–22 nm in diameter, that morphologically resembling parvovirus and/or circovirus. Virions were present in large quantities, both as single particles and in small groups. IAEM examinations, particularly when using 1:20 sera dilution, revealed immunoaggregates composed of numerous virions surrounded by fuzzy halos of antibodies (Figure 6A,B). Virus-antibody aggregates were observed in samples from all three outbreaks using the two convalescent sera pools. Preformed aggregates were rarely observed in EM directly (Figure 6C).
Figure 6.
Electron micrograph of ultracentrifuged liver homogenate from a 20-day-old pheasant. (A) Aggregates of non-enveloped viral particles, 18–22 nm in diameter, morphologically corresponding to parvovirus, surrounded by fuzzy halos of antibodies are visible. Immuno-aggregation electron microscopy (IAEM) preparation with a pool of convalescent sera diluted 1:20; (B) Higher magnification of (A) showing the group of empty and full parvovirus-like particles; (C) IAEM negative control: single dispersed small viral particles are visible. Negative staining (2% sodium phosphotungstate). TEM Philips CM10, 80 kV. Bar = 100 nm.
Further attempts to characterize and precisely identify the taxonomy of such viruses were unsuccessful. The possibility that they were circovirus was excluded (Lavazza A. and Todd D., unpublished results) by using the same molecular approach that led to the first identification of the canary circovirus [40]. Unless their taxonomy can be stated, the definition “parvovirus-like virus” seems to be appropriate. With regard to diagnosis, no other methods have been developed and convalescent sera are still commonly applied to diagnose pheasant hepatitis, a disease that is almost regularly observed in game birds and farms every year during the hatching season.
3.4. Lagoviruses: Rabbit Hemorrhagic Disease Virus (RHDV) of Rabbits and European Brown Hare Syndrome Virus (EBHSV) of Hares
The genus Lagovirus is contained in the family Caliciviridae and includes virus species affecting only lagomorphs (rabbits and hares). RHDV, which was first described in China in 1984, causes a highly contagious and usually fatal (70%–90% mortality) disease of wild and domestic rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus) [41]. The gross lesions include hyperemia, congestion and diffuse hemorrhages, liver degeneration, necrosis and splenomegaly [42]. When RHD initially appeared in Europe, in late 1986, its etiology was not yet defined and different hypotheses, including intoxication and bacterial or viral infection, had been put forward. However, similarities to the existing EBHS described in brown hares (Lepus europaeus), which had been almost endemic in Europe since the early ’80s, became apparent. Unfortunately, the etiology of EBHS was still unclear [43].
The identification and the characterization of the viral agents of both diseases, RHDV and EBHSV, which are highly related but classified as phylogenetically distinct, was particularly challenging since the viral agents are difficult to isolate in vitro and there were severe lesions in non-target organs, such as the lungs and kidneys. We attempted to use ns-EM to identify the etiological agent (Figure 7A,B), but the existence of icosahedral virions of ~30–32 nm with tiny and short external projections, morphologically resembling calicivirus, was only obtained by IAEM using convalescent sera taken from animals that survived experimental infections. In fact, we observed compact groups of a variable number of viral units, surrounded by a dense halo of antibodies (Figure 8A) in most of the samples taken from animals showing typical signs and lesions [44,45]. By using both the anti-RHDV convalescent sera (Figure 9A) and homologous convalescent hare sera (Figure 9B) for IAEM examinations of liver homogenates of EBHS affected hares, we were able to identify the viral etiological agent (EBHSV) [45,46].
IAEM is no longer used as a routine diagnostic method for the detection of RHDV and EBHSV in clinical samples. In fact, after the initial definition of the viral etiology, many other diagnostic methods, which are more easily performed and applicable for screening surveys and antigenic typing (e.g., antigenic and antibody ELISAs), or have greater sensitivity and specificity (e.g., PCR methods), were developed and validated [47]. Nevertheless, the results obtained using IAEM with convalescent sera, as the first approach in the identification and diagnosis of lagoviruses, are valid proof of its importance and utility for discovering new animal viruses.
Figure 7.
Electron micrograph of ultracentrifuged trachea and lung extract from rabbits infected with an organ homogenate of Rabbit Hemorrhagic Disease (RHD) from naturally infected rabbits. (A) A few rare calicivirus particles (see rectangle) are in the dirty and rich material, and thus, are hardly visible; (B) enlargement of inset, showing the typical morphology of calicivirus particles (⇧). The presence of RHDV particles in these pictures was done ex post. Thus, only after the definitive characterization of RHDV as a calicivirus were they recognized. Negative staining (2% sodium phosphotungstate). TEM Siemens Elmiskop 102, 80 kV. Bar = 100 nm.
Figure 8.
Electron micrograph of ultracentrifuged liver homogenate from rabbits naturally infected with Rabbit Hemorrhagic Disease. The empty icosahedral virions are ~30–32 nm with tiny, short external projections, surrounded by a dense halo of antibodies. (A) Immuno-aggregation electron microscopy (IAEM) preparation with a pool of convalescent sera diluted 1:40 from experimentally infected rabbits that survived the infection. Negative staining (2% sodium phosphotungstate). TEM Philips CM10, 80 kV. Bar = 100 nm; (B). IAEM negative control: RHDV particles are distributed singly or in small spontaneous groups.
Figure 9.
Electron micrograph of ultracentrifuged liver homogenate from European Brown Hare Syndrome (EBHS)-affected hares. Immuno-aggregation electron microscopy preparation with: (A) anti-Rabbit Hemorrhagic Disease (RHD) RHDV convalescent sera diluted 1:20; (B) anti-EBHSV homologous convalescent hare sera diluted 1:50; (C,D); enlargement of insets, showing the typical morphology of calicivirus particles. The size of aggregates, containing both empty and full particles, and the width of the antibody halo depend on the specificity of the convalescent sera used. Smaller and thinner halos were seen using the heterologous rabbit sera, and larger and thicker halos were seen using the convalescent hare sera; (E) IAEM negative control of EBHSV positive hare liver. Negative staining (2% sodium phosphotungstate). TEM Philips CM10, 80 kV. Bar = 100 nm.
4. Conclusions
IAEM is a very sensitive and specific EM method. Hyperimmune serum and monoclonal antibodies may be used, but, based on our experience, IAEM with convalescent sera is a highly useful technique in the following situations: when an emerging or re-emerging virus is the etiological agent of an undiagnosed clinical outbreak; when the lack of immunological reagents and/or available primers may cause the failure of alternative diagnostic methods; when it is difficult to isolate virions in vitro; and when there is no indicative clinical suspect. The cases described in this paper are a clear demonstrations of such statements: IAEM with convalescent sera was used for (I) the first identification of lagoviruses, pig torovirus and pheasant parvovirus; (II) for an easier diagnosis of non-cultivable viruses, such as non-A rotavirus, turkey astrovirus and PED coronavirus; and (III) for detecting mixed infections, such as rotavirus RV associated with astrovirus in turkey or circovirus associated with enterovirus in pigs.
In terms of methodology, the most critical aspect of IAEM is the determination of the optimal dilution of sera, which induces the formation of immunoaggregates of adequate size with a thin halo of antibodies around the virions and a good conservation of the virion morphology. Indeed, the addition of specific controls to the IAEM reaction permits the validation and assessment of the immunoaggregation. The antibody titer in convalescent sera is usually not very high and, therefore, such sera usually work better at low dilutions (1:5 to 1:50).
However, there are some conditions that can limit the applicability of IAEM and affect obtaining satisfactory results. These include (I) mistakes in sampling (non-target organs); (II) samples taken during the chronic phase of a disease when the viral load is too low or a spontaneous immunoreaction has already occurred; (III) incorrect preservation of samples, causing the destruction and/or alteration of the virion’s morphology; and (IV) the subjectivity of examinations, which is related to the ability and experience of the operator. Nevertheless, some of these adverse conditions may affect other diagnostic techniques as well. Immunoassays may result in false negatives when sampling is not done properly (non-target organs, low viral load or chronic phase) or samples are not well preserved. Even very sensitive molecular methods (PCR) may also be affected by improper preservation of samples due to nucleic acid degradation.
The unique conditions that can limit the results obtained by IAEM are related to the subjectivity of the EM examination, which is highly dependent on the observer. However, the other “modern” technologies show some additional limitations. Antigen assays may fail to detect agents that differ in antigenic make up. Nucleic acid amplification techniques only detect genomic sequences that are known a priori and the PCR reaction may be inhibited by contaminants in the sample. Moreover, for a number of rare agents and, obviously, for the new ones, specific reagents are still lacking.
Apparently, there is no single method for the accurate and rapid laboratory diagnoses of all viral infections. Thus, when such a diagnosis is needed, ns-EM methods, and particularly IAEM, can be employed simultaneously with other front-line methods [6]. In fact, they permit the quick detection of non-cultivable viruses and multiple viral infections. In addition, thanks to the undirected “open view” of conventional TEM and its “catch all” property, emerging and new, or unrecognized, viruses may be identified.
Finally, as demonstrated by several studies that were inspired by our observations and identifications [11,12,15,16,17,22,23,37,40], the results obtained using ns-EM, including IAEM, as a diagnostic method may be the basis for further studies on the antigenic and molecular characterizations of viruses, their pathogenesis and epidemiology.
Acknowledgments
This paper is dedicated to the memory of our friend and colleague, Paolo Cordioli, who prematurely passed away in August 2014. He was of the head of the Virology Department at IZSLER for over 20 years, and had always supported and encouraged us to develop EM methods for the diagnosis of animal viral diseases. The authors would like to thank Cristina Palotta, Giovanni Bozzoni and Giuseppe Bertocchi for their excellent technical support, and Dr. Lesley Benyon (ScienceDocs, Inc., Beaverton, OR, USA) for English editing of the manuscript.
Author Contributions
A.L., C.T. and M.C. performed the examinations and observations. AL wrote the paper. All authors revised the manuscript.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
- Gentile, M.; Gelderblom, H.R. Rapid viral diagnosis: Role of electron microscopy. New Microbiol. 2005, 28, 1–12. [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
- Biel, S.; Gelderblom, H.R. Diagnostic Electron Microscopy is still timely and rewarding method. J. Clin. Virol. 1999, 13, 105–119. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Gelderblom, H.R.; Renz, H.; Özel, M. Negative staining in diagnostic virology. Micron Microsc. Acta 1991, 22, 435–447. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Hazelton, P.R.; Gelderblom, H.R. Electron microscopy for rapid diagnosis of infectious agents in emergent situations. Emerg. Infect. Dis. 2003, 9, 294–303. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Hopley, J.F.A.; Doane, F.W. Development of a sensitive Protein A-Gold immunoelectronmicroscopy method for detecting viral antigen in fluid specimens. J. Virol. Methods 1985, 12, 135–147. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Kjeldsberg, E. Demonstration of calicivirus in human faeces by immunosorbent and immunogold-labelling electron microscopy methods. J. Virol. Methods 1986, 14, 321–333. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Spencer, R.R. The Zone Phenomenon in Agglutination Tests. J. Infect. Dis. 1930, 46, 138–147. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Estes, M.K.; Kapikian, A.Z. Rotaviruses. In Fields Virology, 5th ed.; Knipe, D.M., Howley, P.M., Griffin, M.A., Lamb, R.A., Martin, M.A., Roizman, B., Straus, S.E., Eds.; Lippincott, Williams and Wilkins: Philadelphia, PA, USA, 2007; pp. 1917–1974. [Google Scholar]
- Saif, L.J.; Bohl, E.H.; Theil, K.W.; Cross, R.F.; House, J.A. Rotavirus-like, calicivirus-like, and 23-nm virus-like particles associated with diarrhea in young pigs. J. Clin. Microbiol. 1980, 12, 105–111. [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
- Bridger, J.C. Detection by electron microscopy of caliciviruses, astroviruses and rotavirus-like particles in the faeces of piglets with diarrhea. Vet. Rec. 1980, 107, 532–533. [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
- Martella, V.; Bányai, K.; Lorusso, E.; Bellacicco, A.L.; Decaro, N.; Camero, M.; Bozzo, G.; Moschidou, P.; Arista, S.; Pezzotti, G.; et al. Prevalence of group C rotaviruses in weaning and post-weaning pigs with enteritis. Vet. Microbiol. 2007, 123, 26–33. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Martella, V.; Lorusso, E.; Banyai, K.; Decaro, N.; Corrente, M.; Elia, G.; Cavalli, A.; Radogna, A.; Costantini, V.; Saif, L.J.; et al. Identification of a porcine calicivirus related genetically to human sapoviruses. J. Clin. Microbiol. 2008, 46, 1907–1913. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Bridger, J.C. Novel rotaviruses in animals and men. In Novel Diarrhoea Viruses; Bock, G., Whelan, J., Eds.; John Wiley & Sons LTD: Chichester, UK, 1987; CIBA Foundation Symposium 128, London; 15–17 July 1986; pp. 5–15.
- Lavazza, A.; Tittarelli, C.; Cerioli, M.; Luppi, A.; Alborali, G.; Cordioli, P. Electronmicroscopic detection of viral agents in diarrhoeic pigs during the period 2002–2007 in Northern Italy. In Proceedings of the 20th IPVS International Pig Veterinary Science Congress, Waterkloof, Durban, South Africa, 22–26 June 2008; p. 180.
- Sozzi, E.; Barbieri, I.; Lavazza, A.; Lelli, D.; Moreno, A.; Canelli, E.; Bugnetti, M.; Cordioli, P. Molecular Characterization and Phylogenetic Analysis of VP1 of Porcine Enteric Picornaviruses Isolates in Italy. Transbound. Emerg. Dis. 2010, 57, 434–442. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Martella, V.; Bányai, K.; Ciarlet, M.; Iturriza-Gómara, M.; Lorusso, E.; De Grazia, S.; Arista, S.; Decaro, N.; Elia, G.; Cavalli, A.; et al. Relationships among porcine and human Pp[6] rotaviruses: Evidence that the different human P[6] lineages have originated from multiple interspecies transmission events. Virology 2006, 344, 509–519. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Martella, V.; Ciarlet, M.; Banyai, K.; Lorusso, E.; Arista, S.; Lavazza, A.; Pezzotti, G.; Decaro, N.; Cavalli, A.; Lucente, M.S.; et al. Identification of Group A Porcine Rotavirus Strains Bearing a Novel VP4 (P) Genotype in Italian Swine Herds. J. Clin. Microbiol. 2007, 45, 577–580. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Cerioli, M.; Bozzoni, G.; Lavazza, A. Identificazione di circovirus suino tipo 2 in associazione ad altri agenti patogeni. In Società Italiana di Patologia ed Allevamento dei Suini (SIPAS), Proceedings of the 30th Annual Meeting, “Atti della Società Italiana di Patologia ed Allevamento dei Suini”, Salsomaggiore Terme, Parma, Italia, 25–26 March 2004; pp. 493–500.
- Sala, G.; Rigola, S.; Alborali, G.L.; Brocchi, E.; Cordioli, P. Development of monoclonal antibodies based ELISAS for the detection of antibodies against porcine Circovirus type 1 and type 2. In Veterinary Virology in the New Millennium, Proceedings of the 5th International Congress of the European Society for Veterinary Virology, Brescia, Italy, 27–30 August 2000; Brocchi, E., Lavazza, A., Eds.; Istituto Zooprofilattico Sperimentale della Lombardia e dell’ Emilia Romagna e Fondazione Iniziative Zooprofilattiche e Zootecniche: Brescia, Italy, 2000; pp. 253–254. [Google Scholar]
- Cerioli, M.; Alborali, G.L.; Salogni, C.; Zanoni, M.G.; Pacciarini, M.L.; Lavazza, A. Use of Immunoelectronmicroscopy in Comparison with Immunofluorescence and PCR for the Detection of PMCV-2 from Piglets Clinically Affected by PMWS. In “PRRS, Swine Influenza”, Proceedings of the 4th International Symposium on Emerging and Re-emerging Pig Disease, Rome, Italy, 29 June–2 July 2003; Martelli, P., Cavirani, S., Lavazza, A., Eds.; Faculty of Veterinary medicine: Parma, Italy, 2003; pp. 224–225. [Google Scholar]
- Lavazza, A.; Candotti, P.; Perini, S.; Vezzali, L. Electron Microscopic Identification of Torovirus-like particles in post-weaned piglets with enteritis. In Proceedings of the 14th International Pig Veterinary Society, Bologna, Italy, 7–10 July 1996; Vignola, G., Monetti, P.G., Eds.; Scientific Committee of the 14th IPVS Congress: Bologna, Italy, 1996; p. 131. [Google Scholar]
- Smits, S.L.; Lavazza, A.; Matiz, K.; Horzinek, M.C.; Koopmans, M.P.; De-Groot, R.J. Phylogenetic and evolutionary relationships among torovirus field variants: Evidence for multiple intertypic recombination events. J. Virol. 2003, 77, 9567–9577. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Pignatelli, J.; Jimenez, M.; Luque, J.; Rejas, M.T.; Lavazza, A.; Rodriguez, D. Molecular characterization of a new PToV strain. Evolutionary implications. Virus Res. 2009, 143, 33–43. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Martelli, P.; Lavazza, A.; Nigrelli, A.D.; Merialdi, G.; Alborali, L.G.; Pensaert, M.B. An epidemic of diarrhoea caused by Porcine Epidemic Diarrhoea virus in Italy. Vet. Rec. 2008, 162, 307–310. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Sozzi, E.; Luppi, A.; Lelli, D.; Moreno Martin, A.; Canelli, E.; Brocchi, E.; Lavazza, A.; Cordioli, P. Comparison of enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and RT-PCR for the detection of porcine epidemic diarrhoea virus. Res. Vet. Sci. 2010, 88, 166–168. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Sozzi, E.; Alborali, L.G.; Luppi, A.; Lelli, D.; Moreno, A.; Cordioli, P.; Brocchi, E. ELISA con anticorpi monoclonali per la diagnostica sierologica della diarrea epidemica suina (PED). In Società Italiana di Patologia ed Allevamento dei Suini (SIPAS), Proceedings of the 33th Annual Meeting, “Atti della Società Italiana di Patologia ed Allevamento dei Suini”, Modena, Italy, 29–30 March 2007; pp. 415–420.
- Kim, S.Y.; Song, D.S.; Park, B.K. Differential detection of transmissible gastroenteritis virus and porcine epidemic diarrhoea virus by duplex RT-PCR. J. Vet. Diagn. Investig. 2001, 13, 516–520. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Sozzi, E.; Papetti, A.; Lelli, D.; Boniotti, B.; Moreno, A.; Brocchi, E.; Alborali, L.; Lavazza, A.; Cordioli, P. Diagnosis and investigations on PED in Northern Italy. In Proceedings of the 8th Annual Meeting of EPIZONE, “Primed for tomorrow”, Copenhagen, Denmark, 23–25 September 2014; p. 1.
- Estes, M.K.; Palmer, E.L.; Obijeski, J.F. Rotaviruses: A review. Curr. Top. Microbiol. 1983, 105, 123–184. [Google Scholar]
- McNulty, M.S.; Todd, D.; Allan, G.M.; McFerran, J.B.; Greene, J.A. Epidemiology of rotavirus infection in broiler chickens: Recognition of four serogroups. Arch. Virol. 1984, 81, 113–121. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Saif, L.J.; Saif, Y.M.; Theil, K.W. Enteric viruses in diarrhoeic turkey poults. Avian Dis. 1985, 29, 798–811. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Reynolds, D.L.; Saif, Y.M.; Theil, K.W. Enteric Viral Infections of Turkey Poults: Incidence of Infection. Avian Dis. 1987, 31, 272–276. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Murgia, M.V.; Battilani, M.; Cecchinato, M.; Catelli, E.; Crudi, M.; Vinco, L.J.; Cerioli, M.; Tosi, G.; Lavazza, A. Preliminary data on the molecular characterization of rotavirus detected in diarrhoeic turkey poults in Italy. In Proceedings of the 5th International Symposium on Turkey Diseases, Berlin, Germany, 16–19 June 2004; Hafez, H.M., Pomeroy, B., Eds.; Deutsche Veterinärmedizinische Gesellschaft: Giessen, Germany, 2004; pp. 211–219. [Google Scholar]
- Doane, F.W.; Anderson, N. Electron Microscopy in Diagnostic Virology: A Practical Guide and Atlas; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1987; pp. 100–102. [Google Scholar]
- Palmer, E.L.; Martin, M.L. Electron Microscopy in Viral Diagnosis; CRC Press Inc.: Boca Raton, FL, USA, 1988; p. 55. [Google Scholar]
- Lavazza, A.; Pascucci, S.; Gelmetti, D. Rod-shaped virus-like particles in intestinal contents of three avian species. Vet. Rec. 1990, 126, 581. [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
- Canelli, E.; Cordioli, P.; Barbieri, I.; Catella, A.; Pennelli, D.; Ceruti, R.; Moreno, A.; Lavazza, A. Astroviruses as causative agents of poultry enteritis: Genetic characterization and longitudinal studies on field conditions. Avian Dis. 2012, 56, 173–182. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Otto, P.H.; Ahmed, M.U.; Hotzel, H.; Machnowska, P.; Reetz, J.; Roth, B.; Trojnar, E.; Johne, R. Detection of avian rotaviruses of groups A, D, F and G in diseased chickens and turkeys from Europe and Bangladesh. Vet. Microbiol. 2012, 156, 8–15. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Gelmetti, D.; Fabbi, M.; Sironi, G.; Grilli, G.; Lavazza, A. Identification of parvovirus-like particles associated with three outbreaks of mortality in young pheasants (Phasianus colchicus). J. Vet. Diagn. Investig. 1996, 8, 108–112. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Todd, D.; Westob, J.; Ball, N.W.; Borghmans, B.J.; Gelmini, L.; Lavazza, A. Nucleotide sequence based identification of a novel circovirus of canaries. Avian Pathol. 2001, 30, 321–325. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Abrantes, J.; van der Loo, W.; Le Pendu, J.; Esteves, J.P. Rabbit haemorrhagic disease (RHD) and rabbit haemorrhagic disease virus (RHDV): A review. Vet. Res. 2012, e43. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Marcato, P.S.; Benazzi, C.; Vecchi, G.; Galeotti, M.; Della Salda, L.; Sarli, G.; Lucidi, P. Clinical and pathological features of viral haemorrhagic disease of rabbits and the European brown hare syndrome. Rev. Sci. Tech. OIE 1991, 10, 371–392. [Google Scholar]
- Lavazza, A.; Vecchi, G. Osservazioni su alcuni episodi di mortalità nella lepre: Evidenziazione al microscopio elettronico di una particella virale: Nota preliminare. Sel. Vet. 1989, 30, 461–468. [Google Scholar]
- Capucci, L.; Scicluna, M.T.; Lavazza, A.; Brocchi, E. Purificazione e caratterizzazione dell’ agente eziologico della malattia emorragica virale del coniglio. Sel. Vet. 1990, 31, 301–312. [Google Scholar]
- Capucci, L.; Scicluna, M.T.; Lavazza, A. Diagnosis of viral haemorrhagic disease of rabbits and the European brown hare syndrome. Rev. Sci. Tech. OIE 1991, 10, 347–370. [Google Scholar]
- Poli, A.; Nigro, M.; Gallazzi, D.; Sironi, G.; Lavazza, A.; Gelmetti, D. Acute hepatosis in the European Brown Hare (Lepus europaeus) in Italy. J. Wildl. Dis. 1991, 27, 621–629. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Lavazza, A.; Capucci, L. How Many Caliciviruses are there in Rabbits? A Review on RHDV and Correlated Viruses. In Lagomorph Biology; Alves, P.C., Ferrand, N., Hacklaender, K., Eds.; Springer: Berlin, Germany, 2007; pp. 263–278. [Google Scholar]
© 2015 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).








