Review Reports
- Jose Antonio Abarca 1,
- Ana M. Ferraria 2 and
- Guillermo Díaz-Sainz 1,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous Reviewer 4: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript is generally readable, but important experimental details are missing, and some inconsistencies need to be clarified; therefore, major revision is required.
- Product analysis completeness: You report very high ethanol Faradaic efficiency (up to 96.7%) at −3 mA cm⁻² (lines ~315–319). Were gaseous products (H₂, CO, CH₄, C₂H₄, etc.) quantified? Can you provide the total FE balance (sum of liquid + gas products) for each condition?
- Low current density regime: The highest selectivity is observed at −3 mA cm⁻², while performance decreases at −6 and −9 mA cm⁻². What is the rationale for focusing on such low current densities in a GDE flow cell? Were higher current densities tested, and if not, why?
- GDE configuration clarity: The description of the electrode orientation (lines ~120–121) is unclear. Does CO₂ reach the catalyst through the gas phase or only via dissolved CO₂ in the electrolyte? Could you clarify the exact cell and GDE configuration, ideally with a schematic?
- Potential scale and iR compensation: Were the reported potentials corrected for ohmic (iR) drop? Where is the Ag/AgCl reference electrode positioned relative to the cathode? Can you report potentials vs RHE for easier comparison with literature?
- Stability and reproducibility: Do you have longer-term stability data beyond 30 min operation? How large are the experimental uncertainties (error bars) for FE and current density?
- SEM/EDS inconsistencies: In the SEM/EDS discussion, Zr is reported as a main element even for SiO₂-supported samples (lines ~247–250). Could you clarify which SEM/EDS results correspond to which support? Why are Pd and Au detected, and how were they introduced?
- XPS interpretation: How confident is the assignment of CuF₂ species in XPS, given the presence of Nafion/PTFE binders? Were XPS measurements performed on fresh or post-electrolysis electrodes?
- Reference and citation checks: Please verify citation numbering in the Introduction (e.g., lines ~77–83) and ensure all references are correctly cited and formatted.
- Data consistency and corrections: Please confirm the correct value of the Faraday constant used in FE calculations (line ~147). Can you clarify detection limits for products reported as “not detected”?
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Authors,
This manuscript is highly stimulating and presents significant results that could be of interest to the scientific community. Nevertheless, some points deserve attention, listed below:
- Could you please include a picture of the experimental setup? That would be very nice for the reader.
- Which anode or counter electrode do you use?
- One general concern that I have across all these studies: Does the use of pure CO2 make sense? Does the use of pure CO2 match a real stream?
- Could you help the reader to understand better the correlation between the binding energy and the conductivity that you find and propose in your work?
- Does F come from the GDL?
- In Figure 4 (line+scatter), who is who?
- Same in Figure 5.
- Line 367, remove the word "slightly".
- Did you measure other C2 products and CH4?
- One general comment: the generation of formate is far from bad. Indeed, you mention that ethanol can be produced from biomass, and, in fact, countries such as Brazil and the USA have mature technologies for this purpose, whereas formate/formic acid, which is not so readily produced from biomass, can be synthesized from CO2 in a green manner. In other words, formate production can also be interesting.
Attention must be given to the raised points.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsTitle of the manuscript
Turning CO₂ into Ethanol: Enhancing Electrochemical Reduction through Cu-Doped Electrodes
1. Summary
The manuscript investigates Cu-based catalysts supported on SiO₂ and ZrO₂, with and without ZnO doping, for the electrochemical reduction of CO₂ to ethanol. Gas diffusion electrodes (GDEs) were prepared and evaluated in a continuous flow-cell under three current densities. Physicochemical characterization (XPS, SEM/EDS) confirmed the presence of Cu²⁺ and Zn²⁺ species and highlighted relevant morphological differences. The 10% Cu–SiO₂ catalyst achieved an exceptional Faradaic efficiency (96%) at –3 mA·cm⁻², outperforming doped samples. Although ZnO enhances surface uniformity and C₂⁺ formation, ethanol selectivity remains lower than that of the undoped catalyst.
2. Findings
The study demonstrates that catalyst composition and support play a decisive role in ethanol selectivity. The 10% Cu–SiO₂ GDE shows the best performance, combining high FE and stable morphology. ZnO doping improves structural compactness and promotes C₂⁺ pathways but causes a shift in operating potentials that reduces ethanol FE compared to the undoped catalyst. Increasing current density leads to a decline in ethanol selectivity for all samples, emphasizing the selectivity–productivity trade-off.
3 Materials and Methods
Gas diffusion electrodes were prepared by airbrushing Cu-based catalysts (5% Cu/ZrO₂, 10% Cu/SiO₂, and ZnO-doped variants) dispersed in IPA/Nafion onto Sigracet 39BB GDLs. Electrochemical tests were performed in a CO₂ flow-cell equipped with a Nafion 117 membrane, Pt counter electrode, and Ag/AgCl reference. CO₂ (200 mL·min⁻¹) and KHCO₃/KOH electrolytes circulated continuously while galvanostatic electrolysis was carried out at –3, –6, and –9 mA·cm⁻². Liquid products were quantified by GC-FID and ion chromatography. Faradaic efficiency and production rates were calculated from charge passed and product concentration.
The paper is good, however before acceptance see the comment
1_In introduction section, add the follow ref to enrich this section
https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202233705003
2_In Equation (1), clarify whether FE is calculated from total charge passed or partial charge.
3_Indicate whether z includes the stoichiometric coefficient (12 e⁻ for ethanol).
4_In Equation (2), is n in mmol consistent with the units used in FE?
5_Add refs to equations (1, 2, ..)
6_The Conclusion is too long
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe problem of utilizing carbon dioxide to produce valuable products is extremely important. The use of inexpensive copper-based catalysts is economically feasible. This paper proposes copper-based composite catalysts using various SiO₂ and ZnO oxides for ethanol production. The relevance of this work is clear. However, several aspects of the paper require improvement before publication:
It is questionable why the 10% Cu–SiO₂ catalyst achieves an outstanding FE of 96% for ethanol at –3 mA cm⁻² despite its uneven composition and structure.
The particle size was not determined from the SEM data in Figure 3.
XRD can provide additional information on the crystallite size and phase composition of the materials.
An extremely important issue is determining the true electrode area for assessing reaction activity per surface area. It is necessary to estimate the active area of the electrodes studied and calculate the activity per real surface area. The work uses normalization based on geometric area, not actual area. What is the electrode surface roughness?
To understand the reaction kinetics, it would be useful to study the dependence of the reaction rate on temperature.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsAfter a successful revision, this paper can be accepted.
Author Response
Thank you very much for reviewing the manuscript and for accepting it for publication.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors have struggled to attend to all my suggestions. I am very satisfied with the answers given. Therefore, I recommend the manuscript's publication.
Author Response
Thank you very much for reviewing the manuscript and for accepting it for publication.
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors answered most of the questions and made the necessary changes. However, a number of issues require clarification.
The authors added the XRD results but did not label the phases in Figure S1. Why is there no reference to Figure S1 in the text of the article and no discussion of "additional information on the crystallite size and phase composition of the materials"?
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf