Skip to Content
  • Article
  • Open Access

1 July 2003

Tarsal Coalitions. Activity Levels With and Without Surgery

and
Department of Sports Medicine, Palo Alto Medical Foundation, Palo Alto, CA
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.

Abstract

This study compares activity levels of patients with tarsal coalitions who did and did not have surgery and quantifies the return-to-activity time after tarsal coalition surgery. Thirty-one patients (mean ± SD age, 22.1 ± 11.6 years) with 39 coalitions (28 talocalcaneal, 1 complete talonavicular, and 10 calcaneonavicular) were included. The mean postoperative review time was 3 years. Fifteen patients (17 feet) who underwent resection had a mean ± SD return-to-activity time of 10.3 ± 5.8 weeks. There was no statistically significant difference in the return-to-activity time between talocalcaneal and calcaneonavicular coalitions. Thirteen patients (21 feet) quit sports; 11 (17 feet) were from the nonsurgical group. Three nonsurgical patients continued playing sports. The Fisher exact test was used to determine whether those forgoing surgery had a decreased ability to achieve desired activity levels. The correlation of surgery and failure to achieve the desired activity level was low (–0.69). Therefore, tarsal coalition excision is not correlated with failure of patients to reach desired activity levels. Patients forgoing surgery could not reach desired activity levels. Surgical excision of tarsal coalitions has a favorable outcome. (J Am Podiatr Med Assoc 93(4): 259-263, 2003)
Tarsal coalition is a common cause of pain in the foot among active adolescents and young adults.[1] Tarsal coalition is the fusion of two or more bones in the midfoot or rearfoot.[1,2] This can be a fibrous union, a cartilaginous union (synchondrosis), or an osseous union (synostosis).[2,3,4] Tarsal coalition results from a failure of separation of the developing mesenchyme, and it is an autosomal dominant inherited disorder.[2,4,5] The prevalence is approximately 1% of the population.[2,5,6] Talocalcaneal and calcaneonavicular coalitions are the most common types.[2,5] The disorder was first described by Buffon in 1769 and then by Zucherkandl in 1872.[3,5,6]
The most common symptoms are pain in the subtalar joint or rearfoot, usually associated with activity and decreased with rest, and an increase in ankle sprains.[2,3,4,5,7] The symptoms usually occur in the second decade of life, as the patients approach skeletal maturity.[4,5] The clinical signs are rigid flatfoot, peroneal spasticity, pain with inversion of the foot, a decrease in subtalar joint motion, absence of heel varus on tiptoes, and the inability to stand on the lateral border of the foot.[3,4,5] Common radiographic signs are talar beaking, flattening of the lateral process of the calcaneus, narrowing of the talocalcaneal joint, closure of the sinus tarsi, and a ball-and-socket ankle joint.[2,4,56] The advent of computed tomography (CT) has made the diagnosis of tarsal coalition easier and is the most reliable imaging technology for determining the extent of the lesion.[6,7]
The late clinical expression is due to the progressive ossification of the coalition and is the result of increased body weight and strenuous physical activity during adolescence.[3,4] There is a positive correlation between participation in sports and the onset of symptoms.[5] In the past, treatment has been triple arthrodesis when conservative measures failed.[4,7,8,910] In 1960, Hark described surgical resection as a motion-preserving technique for the management of tarsal coalitions.[8] The advantages of resection include maintenance of subtalar joint motion and elimination of the painful bar. The adolescent athlete requires as much mobility and function as possible for maximum performance; this points to consideration of resection of the tarsal coalition for patients who want to be athletically active.
There have been many studies on the surgical resection of tarsal coalitions. Comfort and Johnson[7] resected 20 coalitions in 16 patients with an average age of 14 years. In their study, the extent of the involvement of the coalition averaged 29.8% of the total joint area. They had good or excellent results in 60% of cases and fair or poor results in 40%. They found that if the coalition occupied more than one-third of the total joint surface, then 75% of the results were fair or poor, and if the coalition occupied less than one-third of the total joint surface, then 75% of the results were good or excellent.
Some authors have advocated resection for patients so that they can return to sports. Dutoit[3] performed surgical resection on eight patients with nine coalitions. After surgery, all of the patients were pain-free and could participate in sports without any restrictions. Elkus[2] resected 25 coalitions in 20 patients. He found that most patients had relief from pain, that subtalar joint motion increased, and that all of the patients returned to athletic activity. Neither Elkus nor Dutoit specified how soon their patients returned to athletic activity.
Luhmann and Schoenecker[8] studied the resection of 25 coalitions in 20 patients with a mean age of 12.5 years. The mean tarsal coalition cross-sectional area as a percentage of the mean surface area of the posterior facet was 53.4%, and the mean rearfoot valgus was 17.8°. The results showed that 19 feet (76%) had good or excellent results and that 6 feet (24%) had poor results. They found that a rearfoot valgus greater than 21° was associated with poor results.
Morgan and Crawford[5] conducted a study of surgical resection in eight patients with 12 coalitions. They found that seven patients returned to competitive athletics after the surgical procedure. The poor results in the remaining patient seemed to be due to inadequate excision, and the patient had arthritic changes in the talocalcaneal joint. Morgan and Crawford recorded their patients’ activity levels. The time to return to full activity was not presented.
Salomao et al[6] reviewed 22 patients with 32 coalitions treated with excision of the bar. They found that 78.1% became completely pain-free and that 21.8% achieved some relief of pain. They also found an improvement of the foot deformity in 68.7% of the patients and an increase in range of motion in 75%.
Scranton[9] reviewed 18 patients (9 who received resections and 9 who received either conservative treatment or triple arthrodesis). He found that eight patients with surgical resection had good results and that one patient had satisfactory results; in the latter patient, the coalition was about half the width of the joint. The results of conservative therapy and triple arthrodesis were all rated satisfactory.
Wilde et al[10] studied 17 patients with 20 coalitions. Their results were excellent or good in the 10 feet in which the area of the coalition measured 50% or less of the area of the posterior facet, the heel valgus was less than 16°, and there were no signs of arthritis in the joints. Their results were fair or poor in the 10 feet in which the area of the coalition was greater than 50%, the heel valgus was greater than 16°, and there were arthritic changes in the joints.
From review of the literature, it seems that resection of tarsal coalition has a favorable outcome. However, there is still some debate as to whether resection really improves activity level. Therefore, the purpose of the present study was twofold. First, the authors wanted to compare the activity levels of patients with tarsal coalitions who did and did not have surgery, and to see whether these patients maintained their desired activity level. Second, the authors wanted to quantify how long it took for patients who had surgery to return to activity.

Materials and Methods

Patients from the practice of the senior author (A.S.) had their medical charts reviewed in the fall of 2000. Mean postoperative review time was 3 years. Thirty-one patients with 39 coalitions had appropriate data available for this study. The following data were collected: age, sex, side of coalition, type of coalition (bony, soft tissue), location of coalition, orthoses use, type of surgery, activity/sporting level, and time it took to return to activity. Return to activity (RTA) has been previously defined as initiation of sport activity after undergoing surgery.[11] Radiologic studies, including radiographs, CT, and magnetic resonance imaging, were used to confirm the diagnosis. The Fisher exact test and the Pearson product moment correlation were applied as appropriate. Statistical significance was set at P < .05.

Surgical Technique

Medial talocalcaneal coalitions are approached from medial incisions centered over the subtalar joint with the patient in the prone position. The posterior tibial and flexor digitorum longus tendons are retracted superiorly and inferiorly, respectively. Ligature tape is helpful in retraction. The medial subtalar joint is identified at the level of the sustentaculum tali. A Freer elevator is useful in probing the joint. Often, synovial fluid will extrude. Bone, cartilage, and soft tissue are removed from this portion of the joint using a rongeur, as needed. The subtalar joint is mobilized to ascertain whether range of motion is close to normal. Generally, at least 25° of total range of motion is desired. The coalition occasionally extends proximally toward the posterior subtalar joint. This entire coalition must be excised. Care is taken not to remove normal articular cartilage. After irrigation, bone wax is applied over the resected surfaces, and local fatty tissue is interposed. If the abductor hallucis muscle is hypertrophic and visible through the incision, a portion of it may be harvested and interposed as well. Closure is performed in layers.
Calcaneonavicular coalitions are approached from a modified Ollier incision, coursing from the sinus tarsi distomedially over the cuboideonavicular articulation with the patient in the supine position. Deep dissection is carried down to the calcaneonavicular region; however, care must be taken to avoid transecting the intermediate dorsal cutaneous nerve. The extensor digitorum brevis muscle is reflected distally off of the anterior process of the calcaneus. The coalition can then be identified. Osteotomes and rongeurs are used to remove the coalition; care must be taken to avoid removing a portion of the talar head articular surface. Bone wax is applied over the resected surfaces, and extensor digitorum brevis muscle tissue is interposed in this region. Closure is performed in layers.
Postoperatively, all patients are placed in a mediolateral U-shaped splint. Approximately 2 days postoperatively, patients are placed in a below-the-knee cast for 2 weeks to allow for ligamentous healing and for the interposed tissue to become incorporated. At approximately 2 weeks, the cast and suture are removed, and patients initiate range-of-motion exercises. A weightbearing cast boot is worn for an additional 2 weeks. Formal physical therapy is initiated that includes anti-inflammatory modalities, along with balancing and strengthening maneuvers.

Results

Thirty-one patients with 39 coalitions had their data analyzed. Mean ± SD patient age was 22.1 ± 11.6 years (range, 10 to 47 years). Fifteen patients were younger than 18 years. There were 20 males and 11 females. The left foot was involved in 28 coalitions. Twenty-eight coalitions were bony. There were 28 talocalcaneal, 1 complete talonavicular, and 10 calcaneonavicular coalitions.
Mean ± SD duration of symptoms at the time of treatment was 4.5 ± 5.0 years (range, 0.25 to 20 years). Trauma precipitated symptoms in ten feet; the correlation of trauma and surgery was 0.25. The correlation overall of talocalcaneal or calcaneonavicular coalitions and surgery was 0.44.
Fifteen patients (17 feet) underwent excision of their coalitions; mean ± SD RTA time was 10.3 ± 5.8 weeks (range, 4 to 26 weeks). Two patients with medial talocalcaneal coalitions underwent additional procedures that likely lengthened their RTA time: one with a transverse tarsal fusion and another with an Achilles lengthening and calcaneal osteotomy. Overall, mean ± SD RTA time in nine patients with talocalcaneal coalition excision was 11.1 ± 8.7 weeks and in those with calcaneonavicular coalition excision was 11.2 ± 4.8 weeks. Two patients with calcaneonavicular coalitions had concomitant ankle stabilizations and also had longer RTA times.
Thirteen patients with 21 coalitions stopped participating in sports; 11 (17 feet) of these were from the nonsurgical group. Three patients from the nonsurgical group continued playing sports. One patient with bilateral talocalcaneal coalitions had surgery on only one foot. The nonoperative side continued to limit her activities, whereas the operative side did not. The Fisher exact test was used to determine that lack of surgery was associated with failure to achieve the desired activity level (P < .001). Patients who did not have surgery, therefore, were statistically less likely to regain desired activity levels. Four patients who underwent surgery, including the two with more extensive procedures, reported having lower-than-desired activity levels. Correlation of surgery and failure to achieve desired activity levels was low (–0.69).
Correlation of bone involvement and failure to achieve desired activity levels was negligible at 0.02. Correlation of foot orthoses and failure to achieve desired activity levels was 0.59. Many patients who underwent foot surgery did not use foot orthoses after surgery (correlation, –0.59).
Complications of surgery were minimal. There was one recurrence of a cartilaginous talocalcaneal coalition that developed into an entire bony coalition approximately 1 year after excision. This patient had a ball-and-socket ankle and calcaneal valgus of 17°. He underwent medial displacement calcaneal osteotomy and Achilles tendon lengthening at the time of his initial surgery. He has since undergone additional surgery. None of the other patients with coalition resection underwent additional fusion.

Discussion

This study reveals several interesting findings about tarsal coalitions in general. Many patients who have this condition stop playing sports, with most having declined surgery. It will be interesting to see if patients who are less active encounter other health problems over time, such as obesity and degenerative arthritis. Some conservatively treated patients had very high activity levels. Two patients who did not have lower-than-desired activity levels had fibrous medial talocalcaneal coalitions. One is a world-class track runner, and the other is an ultra-marathoner. Another runner in this series had a complete talonavicular bony coalition. All three of these athletes used foot orthoses.
Most patients who underwent resection in this study returned to sports. This was statistically significant. Previous studies[2,3,5] did not reveal this statistically, although they noted that surgery allowed patients to regain desired activity levels.
Resection of tarsal coalitions has been thought to produce better outcomes in patients younger than 18 years, in calcaneonavicular coalitions, and in nonbony coalitions. The results of this study do not support these findings. Patients older than 18 years had very favorable results, and there was no difference in RTA time in resection of calcaneonavicular versus talocalcaneal coalitions. Furthermore, resection of bony coalitions did not yield a negative correlation in outcome.
Use of foot orthoses has been advocated for patients with tarsal coalitions. Postoperatively, patients were less likely to use orthoses in the present study. Long-term study is needed to determine whether this is favorable. Interestingly, use of foot orthoses was highly correlated with having lower-than-desired activity levels, perhaps because these individuals were less likely to undergo surgery.
The one patient who needed additional surgery had calcaneal valgus of 17°. As noted in the study by Wilde et al,[10] resection has a poorer prognosis with calcaneal valgus greater than 16°, although this patient’s valgus was reduced to 9°. Additional long-term study is planned to determine whether any of the other patients require surgery in the future.
The RTA data presented here are perhaps the first to be documented, as many of the other studies did not quantify RTA time. Surprisingly, RTA time was essentially identical for talocalcaneal and calcaneonavicular resections. This value was extended by one patient in the talocalcaneal group having a transverse tarsal fusion and, therefore, a longer RTA time, and, similarly, two calcaneonavicular patients with lateral ankle stabilizations also having longer RTA times compared with coalition resection alone.
There were some weaknesses in this study. First, the review was not masked, and an objective rating scale was not applied. Because this study was not performed prospectively, accurate preoperative and postoperative scores could not be assessed. More follow-up is needed with this type of condition, particularly because almost half of the patients were younger than 18 years. Admittedly, it is difficult to follow patients after age 18 years because of relocation due to education and employment. Substantiating this point, the other studies reviewed had a range of 9 to 25 patients with similar follow-up or review periods.
The authors could have excluded the one patient in the surgical group who underwent fusion, as he did not have a resection. However, the authors believed that he was “balanced out” by the patient in the nonsurgical group who had a complete talonavicular bony coalition. In addition, the purpose of this study was to ascertain the ability to achieve desired activity levels overall of patients with tarsal coalitions.
Overall, the present study yielded findings similar to those of the other studies reviewed: tarsal coalition resection has a favorable outcome. The authors plan to continue to follow as many patients as possible to determine whether this trend continues or whether patients regress over time. In the future, the authors will review whether the size of the coalition and calcaneal valgus are factors, as noted by others.[7,8] Applying standardized objective rating scales would be helpful; however, none of the other studies to date have done so.

Conclusion

Resection of tarsal coalition has a favorable outcome. Surgery allows patients to maintain their desired activity levels. Patients having talocalcaneal and calcaneonavicular coalition resections return to their desired activities in approximately 2.5 months. Most patients who did not undergo surgery did not achieve desired activity levels, and this correlation was found to be statistically significant. The information presented here is useful to surgeons and patients considering surgery for tarsal coalitions. Further long-term study is needed.

References

  1. Harris R, Beath T: Etiology of the peroneal spastic flatfoot. J Bone Joint Surg Br 30: 624, 1948.
  2. Elkus RA: Tarsal coalition in the young athlete. Am J Sports Med 14: 477, 1986.
  3. Dutoit M: Talocalcaneal bar resection. J Foot Ankle Surg 37: 199, 1998.
  4. Sullivan J: Pediatric flatfoot: evaluation and management. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 7: 44, 1999.
  5. Morgan RC, Crawford AH: Surgical management of tarsal coalition in adolescent athletes. Foot Ankle Int 7: 183, 1986.
  6. Salomao O, Napoli MM, de Carvalho AE, et al: Talocalcaneal coalition: diagnosis and surgical management. Foot Ankle Int 13: 251, 1992.
  7. Comfort TK, Johnson LO: Resection for symptomatic talocalcaneal coalition. J Pediatr Orthop 18: 283, 1998.
  8. Luhmann SJ, Schoenecker PL: Symptomatic talocalcaneal coalition resection: indications and results. J Pediatr Orthop 18: 748, 1998.
  9. Scranton PE: Treatment of symptomatic talocalcaneal coalition. J Bone Joint Surg Am 69: 533, 1987.
  10. Wilde PH, Torode IP, Dickens DR, et al: Resection for symptomatic talocalcaneal coalition. J Bone Joint Surg Br 76: 797, 1994.
  11. Saxena A: Return to athletic activity after foot and ankle surgery: a preliminary report on select procedures. J Foot Ankle Surg 39: 114, 2000.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.