Abstract
The motivations of young people making a rural life are often poorly understood in comparison to those youth that migrate to metropolitan areas. Recently, however, there has been an increased focus on rural stayers. Drawing on a wealth of rural youth research studies, this article contributes to this burgeoning literature by nuancing understandings of the experiences of young people staying in rural places. Conceptually, we draw on Honneth’s theory of recognition and Cramer’s idea of a rural consciousness built on a politics of resentment to unpack how young people construct a rural belonging and sense of self that sustains their connection to rural areas and ways of being. In this article, we argue that relations to the self and to others are critical to decisions to remain rural. Ultimately, we show that belonging is contingent on the social recognition from different relational sources in place, and that a rural sense of self can be built from a consciousness that derives from the social disrespect that others have towards rural places, people and ways of being.
1. Introduction
The question of young people staying or leaving after completing school has been central to rural youth sociological inquiry. There has long been widespread concern about high rates of youth outmigration from rural areas and the myriad challenges this poses for the short- and long-term sustainability of rural communities (Corbett, 2007; Eriksen et al., 2025). As the forces of urbanisation, globalisation and neoliberalism have progressed over recent decades, mobility has come to be normalised in contemporary society to the extent that it has “displaced fixity as the norm” (Stockdale & Haartsen, 2018, p. 1). Mobility has become particularly valorised and significant in relation to young people, with researchers arguing for the past decades that rural youth are enticed to make the most of the economic and cultural opportunities offered in cities (Corbett, 2007; Cuervo, 2014; Kenway et al., 2006). This is reflected in normative policy and research discourses that consider moving to a metropolitan area the necessary pathway to make a successful transition to adulthood (Cuervo, 2012, 2014; McPherson, 2025; Rönnlund, 2020). In relation to research, Schewel (2019) argues this has emerged as a ‘mobility bias’, where most research with rural youth is focused on migratory experiences and where those who choose to stay in rural areas, and their reasons for doing so, are comparatively poorly understood.
Against this backdrop, decisions to stay in place have often been crudely categorised against mobility, the latter recognised as dynamic, reflective and enterprising. Staying, on the other hand, is typically reduced to ‘immobility’, an unreflective and static status which is often characterised as involuntary and reflective of stayers presumed disadvantage and exclusion (Cuervo, 2014; Cuervo & Cook, 2019; Schewel, 2019). Recently, however, an important array of research has emerged from rural sociology and youth sociology which focuses on the motivations of young adults to stay and make a life in rural places (Adams & Komu, 2022; Stockdale & Haartsen, 2018; Vehkalahti et al., 2026). The findings from this research correspond with Hjalm’s (2014) assertion that staying should be understood as a process that is equally dynamic, complex and diverse as moving. Studies on rural stayers have highlighted that decisions to stay rural are “complex and multi-layered”, involve considerable agency and are built through active processes of decision-making that are themselves shaped by a range of material and personal/relational concerns (see Stockdale & Haartsen, 2018).
A key finding across many studies has been a yearning for belonging among rural young stayers (Ravn, 2022; Ristaniemi et al., 2024). Indeed, researchers have noticed a turn to belonging in youth studies research, in which belonging has become a prevalent form of thinking and talking about rural youth experiences in research (see Ennerberg et al., 2022; Harris et al., 2021; Vehkalahti et al., 2026). The studies mentioned above reflect a similar tendency to the notion and practice of belonging in research on rural youth. Noble (2020, p. xvii), however, argues that “‘belonging’ is a word that is frequently used but rarely with conceptual clarity” (see also Cuervo & McPherson, 2024; Harris et al., 2021). For Wright (2015) and Lähdesmäki et al. (2016), belonging is often understood in intuitive ways, as a self-explanatory concept and practice. This is because it is commonly associated with issues of membership and feeling safe or at home, but is rarely thought through in conceptual work (Habib & Ward, 2020). Similarly, while more attention is now paid to young people who stay in rural areas, how and why they come to do this remains relatively under-theorised. This article attempts to contribute to the theorisation of the slippery and contested concept of such as belonging in relation to rural settings and the young people that inhabit them. However, while we aim to contribute to the theorisation and discussion of rural youth belonging, we are cautious of reifying it through a definition that is more likely to conclude or close a debate than open it up for further rich analysis (see Harris et al., 2021; Lähdesmäki et al., 2016). One of our goals with this article is to begin a conceptual discussion with scholars in the field on young people’s motivations to make a rural life through concepts such as recognition, belonging, identity and so forth.
The aim of this article is to conceptually contribute to understanding how young adults make a life in rural places within a context of high rural outmigration and mobility. We argue that this making a life is underpinned by the development of a rural sense of self for rural youth. This sense of self, we understand, is never constructed in isolation but takes shape through a relational process between individuals and their places, communities of people, and socioeconomic circumstances. To unpack this, we draw on Axel Honneth’s theory of recognition and Katherine Cramer’s development of the concept of rural consciousness and the politics of resentment to re-read some seminal youth research studies that have examined the construction of a rural life by young people. We argue that in the burgeoning field of rural youth studies, including cases of rural staying, the ideas of Honneth and Cramer have rarely been applied to explain young people “going against the grain” (Ristaniemi et al., 2024) in times of high mobility. In this article, we attempt to extend our understanding of this “going against the grain” by further theorising the notion of rural belonging through the theoretical propositions of Honneth and Cramer. In so doing, we also respond to calls to further theorise the idea and practice of belonging in the field of youth studies and in sociology (see Habib & Ward, 2020; Lähdesmäki et al., 2016; Noble, 2020; Wright, 2015).
We are particularly interested in Honneth’s (1995, 2003, 2007) work on intersubjectivity and the struggle for recognition for individuals, which can productively be used to better understand rural youth’s decision to stay in their communities. Honneth, simply put, argues that personhood, our sense of self, is constructed intersubjectively. Our place in the world and our understanding of who we are is built in a relational manner. Honneth’s (1995, p. 92) view that “practical identity-formation presupposes inter-subjective recognition” enables a better understanding of the work and struggle undertaken by young rural stayers to develop a sense of belonging to people, places, and ways of being that matter to them and form the core of their self.
Cramer (2016) focuses on the development of a rural identity by individuals that is anchored on a resentment towards urban people, places and government. This resentment is rooted both in the sense that (urban) decision-makers “routinely ignore rural places and fail to give rural communities their fair share of resources” and, crucially, the belief that rural people have a shared set of values and lifestyles that are distinct from, and disparaged by, urban people and power structures (Cramer, 2016, p. 5). Taken together, recognition and rural consciousness enable a better and deeper understanding of how relations to the self and to others (including institutions) are intrinsically important to decisions to stay in or leave a rural area. They do this work by illuminating how a development of a sense of rural self that is rooted in recognition or misrecognition of their being can anchor individuals to people and place.
To illustrate this, we make use of our recent research with and about rural youth in Australia and Scotland, and we draw on other significant studies in the field of rural youth sociology in the past decade. We acknowledge that the selection of these studies and work of scholars is rather subjective. It is based on our two decades of work in the field, following this line of inquiry, and on the impact (through citation and visibility of work) that these studies and scholars have had on this research space. We do not claim that these are the only studies researching rural youth “stayers” or that this is a definitive list of the most important ones, but we believe they have been significant in the construction of an understanding of this issue. Before turning to this analysis, this article begins with a discussion of Honneth’s theory of recognition and Cramer’s concept of rural consciousness and how they represent valuable conceptual tools for deepening understandings of young people’s decisions to stay in rural areas. The article concludes with several conceptual reflections to make sense of a new way of thinking the motivations for rural youth to stay rural.
2. Dynamics of Recognition, Belonging and Consciousness in Rural Areas
In this article, we argue that Honneth’s (1995, 2003) theory of recognition can offer a reassessment of the motivations behind individuals’ decision to stay. His concept of intersubjective recognition is in many ways an account of how individuals develop a sense of themselves as moral beings and in relation to others. It is in this regard and from recognition by others through interactions that people build and sustain a sense of who they are and a place in the world. That we become who we are particularly through recognition from and interaction with others is explained by Honneth (1995, 2003) through three struggles for recognition: love, rights and solidarity. In some ways, the literature on rural stayers has been attentive to struggles for recognition based on love and care, where relationships have a central role in young people’s decisions to stay (Giardiello & Cuervo, 2018; McPherson, 2025). Here, unconditional love is underpinned by relationships of mutual recognition in which an individual comes to know oneself and be oneself through the emotional support of family members and significant others (Honneth, 1995). This generates a self-confidence that is manifested in stability and continuity of one’s identity and sense of self in relation to the outside world. Honneth’s (1995) second level refers to the provision of full legal rights by institutions and other members of the community. This type of recognition is often ascribed to multiculturalism and matters of the respect for the rights, and diversity and inclusion, of minoritised communities. To put it simply, for Honneth, an individual can expect to be able to develop self-respect when they are given full legal rights and inclusion by other societal members and institutions.
We are mostly interested in Honneth’s third struggle for recognition: self-esteem and solidarity. We are interested in its positive form, which is understood as esteem constructed as a “form of social valuing” of, in this case, young people, in so far as it entails an assessment of worth of the specific traits, characteristics, abilities and achievements of individuals (Honneth, 1995, 2003). This, according to Honneth (1995), involves a recognition of the ways of life of individuals as moral beings and as part of a given community. Individuals’ relation to self is dependent on this recognition, and when recognition is withheld, individuals encounter disrespect and a cultural denigration of their ways of life, which forms an obstacle to their self-realisation (Honneth, 1995, 2007). This negative form of recognition is an insult to the abilities and traits of individuals and of their community of value. To counteract this societal cultural denigration, individuals might search for support and relations of positive esteem and solidarity within one’s social milieu. That is, the response to negative emotions (e.g., indignation, resentment) resulting from insult and denigration of one’s way of life can be the vehicle for an intra-group solidaristic esteem (Honneth, 1995, p. 128). While discussions of (mis)recognition often play out on a philosophical level, a growing number of studies are exploring “particular struggles for recognition in the specific contexts in which they take place” (Pilkington & Acik, 2020, p. 182). As we go on to argue, the work undertaken by young people to belong and make a life in their rural areas represents an important example of this struggle for recognition.
We see Honneth’s negative form of esteem recognition as related to Cramer’s (2016) thesis on the development of a rural consciousness as an individual and collective identity. Seeking to understand how place, class and identity are implicated in people’s voting behaviour and expressions of politics, Cramer carried out ethnographic research in rural areas of Wisconsin in the United States. She found evidence of what she terms ‘rural consciousness’ among rural Wisconsinites; a combination of class- and place-based identities which embodies both an attachment to a given rural place and a resentment towards urban people, places and government. Through this lens of rural consciousness, Cramer (2016) argues, rural people can come to adopt an ‘us and them’ worldview, grounded in the belief that rural people and areas are not given access to a fair share of resources, voice or decision-making power, and urban areas, by extension, are given preferential treatment. This sense of a divide between urban and rural is further underlined, according to Cramer (2016), by a view among rural people that they share the same perspectives, values, and lifestyles, and the sense that not only do these differ from those of city-dwellers, but they are also actively looked down upon by “urban types [who] just [do] not get small-town life”. In this sense, resentment is targeted towards everyday urban citizens as well as towards power structures and elites.
Similar to Honneth’s emphasis on intersubjectivity, for Cramer (2016, p. 23), this rural consciousness is “communicated primarily through interpersonal interaction” and bounded by place. Cramer’s argument is that while many material differences exist between rural and urban areas, and rural- and urban-dwelling people, the most significant points of differentiation pertain to issues of identity and ideology. Cramer (2016) illustrates the power of rural consciousness, which has been mobilised by rural (mostly working-class) citizens—and strategically harnessed by politicians—in retaliation against feeling ignored, disrespected and disadvantaged by urban liberal elites (MacKinnon et al., 2024). This corresponds with Honneth’s (1995, p. 132) argument that “the experience of disrespect… can provide the motivational impetus for social resistance and conflict, indeed, for a struggle for recognition”. A rural sense of self, then, might respond to the misrecognition and cultural denigration by others (e.g., institutions, government and other social groups such as urban elites) through the cultivation of intra-solidarity that is rooted in place, class and a social distrust and dislike of those that denigrate one’s traits, achievements and ways of life.
While neither Honneth’s nor Cramer’s work was formulated specifically in relation to young people, their respective conceptualisations have valuable applications to enrich our understandings of young people’s decisions to stay in their rural areas. Their emphases on the significant impact of feeling (mis)recognised, and how this can cultivate a defensive or affirmative kind of intra-group solidarity, or feelings of belonging and rural sense of self, is useful for producing more nuanced understandings of how and why young people work to belong to their rural communities. This is particularly important in the contemporary context, where the structural forces of urbanisation, globalisation and neoliberalism have emphasised a view of rural areas as increasingly associated with disadvantage and marginalisation (Eriksen et al., 2025). These deficit discourses around rural areas echo in discourses of rural youth, who are often perceived to lack valorised forms of agency and aspirations, and who are presumed to be involuntarily ‘trapped’ in their rural areas (Ravn, 2022). Both rural areas and rural young people can be seen as occupying lower status positions than their urban counterparts, increasing their risks of the misrecognition that Honneth and Cramer differently identify as critical to construction of the self and relationships with people and place. Drawing on Honneth’s concept of the struggle for recognition and Cramer’s concept of rural consciousness and resentment can therefore contribute towards producing richer insights into the intersections between (mis)recognition, identity and agency, and how these may figure in young people’s senses of belonging to, and decisions to stay in, place.
3. The Place of “Rural Youth” in Youth Studies
Traditionally conceptualisations and studies on rural youth lives have focused on motivations to migrate from their communities after completing school (see Corbett, 2007). This is anchored in two reasons: firstly, the idea that educational, labour and lifestyle opportunities flow through urban places and are scarce in rural areas. Secondly, it is supported by what scholars view as crude statistical lenses on life in rural areas that can make it look miserable as outmigration, lack of economic and cultural opportunities, and high morbidity appear to be more prevalent than in big urban centres. This gives room to depictions of the rural as marginalised and disadvantaged, as a peripheral space (Adams & Komu, 2022; Rönnlund, 2020). In recent years, this marginalisation of rural areas has attracted global attention as places of alienation and resentment that help to explain how, apparently, “the rural” contributed to the election of polarising political figures (Cramer, 2016).
In our own work in Australia and Scotland, youth have commented on their experiences of misrecognition and social resentment (Cuervo, 2016; Cuervo et al., 2024; Cuervo & Weerasuriya, 2025; McPherson, 2020, 2025). Our participants’ experiences of misrecognition were strongly rooted in their feeling that rural people, areas and ways of life were unfairly disadvantaged and left behind by urban people and governments. For instance, in Australia, those staying and making a life in rural areas have expressed resentment towards governments and rising concern about a range of structural challenges and spatial inequalities they perceived between rural and urban areas, noting the lack of affordable housing, a lack of vision for the future and response to climate change challenges, and the divide between city and country growing fast (see Cuervo, 2016; Cuervo & Weerasuriya, 2025; Cuervo et al., 2024). There were also concerns around the lack of young people in rural areas due to strong youth out-migration processes fostered by normative discourses on the need for higher education after post-secondary school. In rural Scotland, young people referred to the haunting spectre of deindustrialisation in small communities with its impact on the lack of meaningful employment opportunities compared to their parents’ and grandparents’ time (McPherson, 2025; see also Simpson, 2021).
Participants across both settings also expressed a social dislike of urban areas based on moral assessment. For example, in one of our recent studies in rural Victoria, Australia, young people commented that they choose not to migrate to Melbourne because in the city ‘you just walk past a million people, you don’t know anyone’, and ‘I don’t like the people, even the air is dirty’ (Cuervo et al., 2024, p. 1282). This young woman from a small rural town two hours outside Melbourne also stated: ‘I love walking down the street and having to chat to people and see how they’re going’ (p. 1283). Further, in our research in Scotland, cities were regarded as too busy, unsafe, and unfeeling by many of our participants, who preferred the close-knit community feel of their rural locales (McPherson, 2025). In their narratives, rural youth offered a ‘classed memory of struggle and a sedimented sense of oppression and marginalisation’ (p. 525). Recurrently, rural youth in both contexts expressed sentiments that embodied the ‘rural consciousness’ and resentment that Cramer (2016) describes. This consciousness is built on a social dislike or resentment towards city dwellers and places due to a view of a differential treatment for the two regions; and is based on a perception of different moral values by rural and urban people that resemble traditional sociological conceptualisations of the urban and rural life (see Tönnies, 1957). Our participants, across time and place, have expressed feelings of being “othered”, by social institutions and governments, and a feeling that rural lives and places are inevitably seen as the “other”, and urban areas as plentiful and ubiquitous (Giardiello & Cuervo, 2018). Thus, following Cramer, we speculate that this rural consciousness gives rise to place-based identities that anchor individuals to their local rural community.
A vast array of youth research studies echoes this sentiment of social misrecognition and resentment by rural youth. For instance, Eriksen et al. (2025) refer to cultural rural belongings for Nordic rural youth that are underpinned by views of ‘city people’ as ‘snobbish and stuck up’ (p. 152). In Sørensen and Pless’s (2017, p. 105) study, rural youth acknowledge the material opportunities in urban areas, as well as feeling ‘looked down upon in the city’, often mocked as ‘hillbillies’, due to their inability to follow the cultural codes and social conventions prevalent in cities. Other studies have captured rural youth sentiments of feeling socially invisible and as living in peripheral areas with no relevance to their national and global discussions and socio-economic and cultural trends (see Farrugia, 2020; Pedersen & Gram, 2018). This includes perceptions of being stigmatised as backward, disadvantaged, and “at-risk” compared to their urban counterparts (see Areschoug, 2019; Wenham, 2020). Social misrecognition also was constructed in distributive terms, where rural youth felt that in their local areas there were less resources and structures to pursue their political and cultural interests (Adolfsson, 2024; Pedersen & Gram, 2018). In a sense, these studies have in common rural youth feelings of social misrecognition from urban people and places that help construct a feeling of rurality that differ from city life, positioning the rural outside the norm, “othering” it, as a space “simply out there” (Green & Letts, 2007). Finally, it is important to state that while this research shows a discontent by young people in how they are viewed by others or their perception of a lack of some material resources and opportunities compared to urban settings, it is not our aim to present rural youth as being in a state of constant resentment. As we argue below, decisions to stay rural are also actively and positively made by young people. The point we make here is that the rural youth literature offers cases of young people disliking or feeling misrecognised in urban places or feeling that they do not have a fair share of opportunities in relation to city-dwellers. This resonates with Cramer’s conceptualisation of consciousness as a place-based identity formation due to these forms of misrecognition, which can bind people together. This kind of conceptual work has not been prevalent in youth studies, and we believe it can be fruitful as a form of explaining the formation of rural subjectivities.
4. The Research “Turn” to Rural Stayers
Recently, there has been a research “turn” in rural youth studies with a focus on understanding what lies behind some youth and young adults’ decision to stay local or move/return to rural places. Informing these studies is the idea of community and place, which have become key concepts to make sense of the ways that young people make a rural life (see Adams & Komu, 2022). Against these patterns of rural inequality and disadvantage mentioned in the previous section, the idea and practice of community and place have been offered as antidotes to it. Key here, we argue, is the process of intersubjectivity constructed through close relations and ties between youth and their significant others and the community. That is, a rural sense of self is constituted intersubjectively. Following Honneth (1995), individuals become who they are and find their place in the world through their interactions with others.
A focus on youth and young adults staying or moving to rural places has become core research in youth studies. For instance, we believe that Adams and Komu (2022) can be read as arguing for place attachment in the form of relationships between individuals in the realm of community sports, religious or workplace spaces, to understanding how and why some rural youth defy a historical understanding that a successful transition to adulthood is irremediably marked by a migration to urban places. Belonging to community and being recognised as a member of it could be seen as offsetting the limited educational and work opportunities for Adams and Komu’s participants in rural Finland. As such, the conscious decision by youth to interact with their place and stay rural becomes for the researchers a “radical” move that challenges social norms that demand those that have the means to migrate. While one can read relationality as a form of belonging, Adams and Komu argue that their participants actively focused on a future notion of the “good life” where closeness to nature, affordable housing, and a hesitance at the idea of having to attend higher education were also key in their decision to stay. In this sense, we see these rural youths’ construction of belonging anchored in an idealisation of a future that can be locally fulfilled and not just as part of an intersubjective relational construction.
Other studies reflect on the relevance of intersubjective relationship of recognition to construct and strengthen a robust sense of rural belonging. However, like Adams and Komu’s, some of these studies orient rural belonging towards the possibility of constructing a future rather than a specific focus on the present and how this is built through the formation of a rural identity underpinned by a recognition of a way of being. For example, Ravn’s (2022, p. 1247) study of young women staying in their local rural communities in Australia acknowledges that relationships of care and mutuality with significant others matter in the construction and imagination of ‘good enough futures’ amidst contexts of scarce material opportunities. These ‘good enough futures’ are, however, constructed as an antidote to discourses that paired immobility with ‘feeling stuck’. That is, Ravn argues against this notion of mobility as the ’right’ rural youth aspiration, instead placing the accent on intersubjectivity as the main frame of her study. Similarly, Smette and Hegna (2025) found that, in imagining adulthood in Nordic rural places, a strong sense of belonging was built through intersubjective relationships between generations and different members of the communities. However, the authors also orient the rationale in their study towards the future by delving into the debate of mobility–immobility and arguing against Ravn’s “good enough futures” as depicting an ‘alternative of lesser value’ (p. 234). Other research has argued that youth staying in, and returning to, local communities do so through a resignification of the cultural status of rural places, relationships and landscapes that defy late-modern life with urbanity, or the sense of extraversion that conflates progress and meaningful life with a place away from the rural (Carrasco-Cruz et al., 2025; Rönnlund, 2020; Sørensen & Pless, 2017). Similar to the studies mentioned above, they focus on a future orientation, and they do not theorise the construction of a rural self or identity as a form of intersubjective recognitive process in the present.
In our own research work, positive affirmations of recognition—being seen, related to and treated by someone in ways appropriate to one’s own sense of self and in a manner that approves and affirms one’s qualities as valuable—were found by young adults in community relations and workplace environments. For example, tracking young people’s transition to adulthood in rural Victoria, Australia, we found participants’ challenging deficit views of rural life: “People have quite a negative image of living in a rural area, and it’s not. I have a great lifestyle here… people still care down here” (see Cuervo et al., 2024, p. 1283). This comment by a young woman growing up in a small rural community is supported by her view that rural places contained a cultural ethos of symmetrical relations of recognition, which she often illustrated with the notion of being acknowledged in her everyday life by others. Specifically, her moral values build rural identities, as they are underpinned by a caring ethos and solidarity. Further, for this young woman, her sense of self as a rural community member is anchored on the social recognition and esteem she derives from her involvement in local sports: “I feel like I’m really well respected and I value that, I love being a voice, I love being a positive representative at netball and someone they can rely on” (Cuervo et al., 2024; p. 1283).
Elsewhere, in our work in rural Australia, we also found that routinized performances of belonging were mostly sustained by the intersubjective recognition provided by close family members (see Giardiello & Cuervo, 2018) and by neighbours or community members (see Cook & Cuervo, 2022). In a similar vein, in our work in rural Scotland, we found that community roles, be that in sports, in community centres or social work, provided young people with what Honneth (1995) would see as a type of recognition based on one’s ability, traits, achievements and characteristics. In small villages in Scotland, we found accounts and robust experiences of belonging cemented on this recognition to their contribution to community life in the village. Young people felt seen by community members of different generations and valued for their contribution to their communities in social and voluntary roles (McPherson, 2020).
Throughout our work, we have argued that rural youth build their sense of belonging through the social value that others in the community afford them (Cuervo & Cook, 2019; Cuervo et al., 2024; McPherson, 2020, 2025). In this paper, we wish to move this analytic perspective closer to Honneth’s third form of recognition to contribute to what scholars have understood as an under-theorisation of the concept and practice of belonging (Habib & Ward, 2020; Lähdesmäki et al., 2016; Noble, 2020; Wright, 2015). From Honneth’s (1995, 2003) perspective, the recognition of these rural youth abilities, traits and achievements helping others in the community form the vehicle to their self-realisation, and the construction of rural belonging. In a sense, volunteering through sports and helping children in community centres enables the construction of an intra-solidarity that reaffirms participants’ ideas that rural places are spaces filled with sociality and care, while urban areas are synonymous with alienation and lack of social recognition. It is important to note, however, that a normative caring ethos and expectations of community volunteering and engagement can function as exclusionary and alienating for some in rural places. That is, not being involved in voluntary work in small communities has been found to harm the possibilities of social inclusion for those individuals—generating social stigmatisation and exclusion (see Bryant & Pini, 2009; Cuervo, 2014).
5. Rethinking Rural Youth Belonging Through Recognition, Social Resentment and Consciousness
Growing research evidence around why people choose to stay in rural areas suggest that these decisions are built on a complex web of everyday practices that are located in place and become significant for identity and belonging over time. The analysis of the extant literature and our own research in Australia and Scotland correlates with Cramer’s (2016) argument that a key source of rural resentment is simply, and crudely put, the perception that urban people have access to more resources, earn more money and have easier lives than rural people, who have to work harder to get by. For Cramer (2016, p. 5), these “ideas about who gets what, who has power, what people are like, and who is to blame” can manifest in an ‘us and them’ binary that is strongly “rooted in place and class” (p. 6), where “social identities, the emotion of resentment, and economic insecurity interact” (p. 9). In this sense, rural people are as much bonded to one another and their local areas by a sense of positive recognition and belonging that flows from shared values, experiences and lifestyles as they are by the perception that these shared life experiences and dispositions differ from, and are disparaged by, urban people. Here, we do not wish to argue that rural youth live in constant resentment, but rather want to theoretically acknowledge that Cramer’s notion of rural consciousness built on a class and place-based identity, sustained through a dynamic of “us and them”, contributes to the creation of a rural sense of self that can inform how belonging is constructed, experienced and enacted in rural communities.
The studies presented above also illustrate the potency of recognition theory and the building of rural sense of self for unpacking how young people make a life in their rural communities. Indeed, utilising Honneth’s (1995) theory of recognition highlights how young people’s sense of belonging to their rural places can be contingent upon the social recognition and development of self-esteem which originates from different relational sources. Honneth (1995, p. 25) defines people as “concrete creatures of need”; the need individuals feel for social recognition is what defines us as relational beings, whose identities are constructed dialogically from interactions and experiences with people and places. As such, being positively recognised as worthy members of their communities also generates feelings of belonging for rural youth. For example, in one of our studies (see Cuervo et al., 2024), an individual’s contributions to her community through sports is positively socially recognised and esteemed, providing her with the capacity to build a healthy sense-of-self that can counterbalance any type of isolation that is often ascribed to living in small rural communities (see also Adams & Komu, 2022). We can identify this—what scholars might term a positive form of social recognition (Lepold, 2019)—in rural youth experiences of being positively socially valued for their contributions to their respective communities. This social valuing forms the basis of Honneth’s third type of recognition—self-esteem—which, he argues, acts as a conduit to individual self-realisation. Critically, contrary to love and care (Honneth’s first sphere of social recognition), esteem is not unconditional and is subject to people’s abilities, traits, and achievements.
A different constitution of belonging in relation to recognition is reflected in other research (see Eriksen et al., 2025; Farrugia, 2020; McPherson, 2025) that is built upon what Honneth (2007) would deem as social misrecognition and disrespect for a (rural) way of being. For Honneth (1995, p. 131), being negatively recognised, whereby one’s identity and traits are not respected or perceived as valuable by others, can injure “positive understanding of themselves”, constraining their capacity for self-realisation. As we have shown in other studies, for rural youth, feelings of being misrecognised can be strongly rooted in their sense of rural self and in their feeling that rural people, places and ways of life are unfairly disadvantaged and disrespected by urban people, social institutions, and governments (Cuervo & Weerasuriya, 2025; McPherson, 2020). In this sense, for rural youth, their experiences can contain sentiments that strongly aligned with Cramer’s (2016) concept of rural consciousness as a form of class- and place-based identity grounded in feelings of resentment towards urban ‘others’ and institutions perceived to misrecognise rural communities.
Critically, while some rural youth reject the pressing call to leave their communities for urban places, they might also be cognisant—and resentful—of the socio-structural forces and spatial inequalities that are driving this youth outmigration; that is, a recognition of rural areas as (unfairly) disadvantaged compared to urban settings. Similar to Cramer’s (2016) participants in Wisconsin, in several of the studies presented above, young people feel that their community, and other rural people and places, are being increasingly disadvantaged by growing inequalities between rural and urban settings, disparities that they view as engineered by metrocentric government policies and misrecognition (Adolfsson, 2024; Areschoug, 2019; McPherson, 2025; Pedersen & Gram, 2018; Wyn & Cuervo, 2014). Rural individuals’ sense of self and sense of belonging to their community can be seen as underpinned by a polarity of ‘us and them’ that is identified between rural people and urban actors. This reflects the kind of defensive intra-group solidarity that Honneth (1995) identifies as a response to negative social recognition, and which Cramer (2016) argues forms a key part of rural identity construction.
In the youth studies literature, rural young people are often portrayed holding the view that urban people simply have easier lives than rural people, because of their closer proximity to resources and power (Cuervo & Weerasuriya, 2025; Ravn, 2022; Rönnlund, 2020; Wenham, 2020). This perspective is cultivated, as Cramer (2016) suggests, through the relationship between their rural identities and their lived experiences and perceptions of economic insecurity and geographical inequalities as young people living in rural areas that are increasingly associated with disadvantage in a global contemporary context of rapid urbanisation. Thus, in addition to governments and power structures, rural consciousness can also be grounded firmly in resentment towards everyday urban people. As Cramer (2016, p. 9) argues, in a “politics of resentment, resentment towards fellow citizens is front and centre”, where “people understand their circumstances as the fault of guilty and less deserving social groups, not as the product of broad social, economic, and political forces”. Ultimately, we argue that both positive and negative forms of social recognition help us understand young people’s motivations and factors that shape making a rural life.
6. Conclusions
The motivations of youth to stay rural are often poorly understood compared to those that choose to migrate to urban areas. Additionally, they are often explained through an idea of belonging that is under-theorised (Habib & Ward, 2020; Lähdesmäki et al., 2016; Noble, 2020; Wright, 2015) or that focuses on possible selves in the future (e.g., Adams & Komu, 2022; Ravn, 2022) rather than on the actual formation of belonging and sense of rural self by young people in the present. This article contributes to nuancing understandings of the experiences of young people staying in rural areas and how they form a sense of belonging and rural identity in the present by utilising the conceptual tools of Honneth and Cramer, which we argue have been seldomly used for this purpose within youth studies. We utilised Honneth’s struggle for recognition and Cramer’s conceptualisation of a rural consciousness built on a politics of resentment as conceptual ways of understanding how young people make a rural life. Drawing on key aspects of young people’s lives in rural areas offered in the burgeoning rural youth literature, we show how rural ways of being and formations of belonging can be built through the social recognition of others in the community, and through a rural consciousness underpinned from feelings of social disrespect for rural people and ways of being.
We do not claim here that rural youth belonging and a rural sense of self are only formed through the provision of social recognition or the development of a rural consciousness due to withheld respect by others. Further, we are not arguing that every individual that remains in a rural area feels recognized and belongs to the community. As we mentioned above, any community offers spaces and practices of exclusion and inclusion, and yet individuals for different circumstances remain in it. We also do not want to reify the formation of a rural identity as an a priori subject, as a monolithic and fixed construction, but rather as something that is made and re-made in the everyday interactions of individuals with one another and with social institutions. We are also not able to make generalisable claims for the broader rural youth population from just the experiences of our participants in our projects or from a selected group of important research studies. However, through Honneth’s and Cramer’s frameworks, we argue that, at the core of rural youth satisfaction, being seen through their community roles and their dissatisfaction with the social disrespect towards rural people and rural issues by others (e.g., social institutions and urban elites) is a desire to be treated with dignity. Ultimately, we contribute to the burgeoning research literature of rural youth belonging by showing how social recognition and rural consciousness can be useful frameworks to understand the complex and multifaceted lives of young people making a rural life.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, H.C. and C.M.; formal analysis, H.C. and C.M.; investigation, H.C. and C.M.; writing—original draft preparation, H.C. and C.M.; writing—review and editing, H.C. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
This research received no external funding.
Institutional Review Board Statement
Not applicable.
Informed Consent Statement
Not applicable.
Data Availability Statement
No new data were created or analyzed in this study. Data sharing is not applicable to this article.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
- Adams, R., & Komu, T. (2022). Radically ordinary lives: Young rural stayers and the ingredients of the good life in Finnish Lapland. Young, 30(4), 361–376. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Adolfsson, M. (2024). Place and youth political action: How place shapes political action in rural Sweden. Young, 32(2), 125–141. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Areschoug, S. (2019). Rural failures: Representations of (Im)mobile young masculinities and place in the Swedish countryside. Boyhood Studies, 12(1), 76–96. [Google Scholar]
- Bryant, L., & Pini, B. (2009). Gender, class and rurality: Australian case studies. Journal of Rural Studies, 25(1), 48–57. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Carrasco-Cruz, A., Cruz-Souza, F., & González-Calvo, G. (2025). Roots of rural youth: A five-year systematic review of place attachment. Social Sciences, 14(9), 1–21. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cook, J., & Cuervo, H. (2022). Routinized performances of belonging: Everyday practices and relationships in rural and regional areas during the pandemic. Population, Space and Place, 28(6), e2568. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Corbett, M. (2007). Learning to leave: The irony of schooling in a coastal community. Black Point. [Google Scholar]
- Cramer, K. J. (2016). The politics of resentment: Rural consciousness in Wisconsin and the rise of Scott Walker. University of Chicago Press. [Google Scholar]
- Cuervo, H. (2012). Enlarging the social justice agenda in education: An analysis of rural teachers’ narratives beyond the distributive dimension. Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education, 40(2), 83–95. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cuervo, H. (2014). Critical reflections on youth and equality in the rural context. Journal of Youth Studies, 17(4), 544–557. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cuervo, H. (2016). Understanding social justice in rural education. Palgrave Macmillan. [Google Scholar]
- Cuervo, H., & Cook, J. (2019). Formations of belonging in Australia: The role of nostalgia in experiences of time and place. Population, Space and Place, 25(5), e2214. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cuervo, H., Maire, Q., & Wyn, J. (2024). Dynamics of belonging amid geographical immobility: A longitudinal analysis of youth trajectories in rural Australia. Journal of Youth Studies, 27(9), 1274–1290. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cuervo, H., & McPherson, C. (2024). The usefulness of the concept of belonging in youth transitions. In J. Chesters (Ed.), Research handbook on transitions into adulthood (pp. 55–66). Edward Elgar Publishing. [Google Scholar]
- Cuervo, H., & Weerasuriya, N. (2025). “Coming to uni was isolating, a massive culture shock”: The struggle of working-class rural youth for recognition and belonging at a metropolitan university. Educational Review, 1–15. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ennerberg, E., Lundberg, J., & Axelsson, M. (2022). Local places ruling life: Compromises and restricted career choices in rural Sweden. Journal of Applied Youth Studies, 5(4), 281–295. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Eriksen, I. M., Vehkalahti, K., Ristaniemi, H., Rönnlund, M., Tollefsen, A., Østergaard, J., & Armila, P. (2025). Trajectories of belonging among Nordic rural youth: Strengthening, weakening, or conflicting belonging over time. In K. Vehkalahti, I. M. Eriksen, & J. Østergaard (Eds.), Growing up rural: Qualitative longitudinal explorations of young people living in the Nordic countries (pp. 145–170). Springer. [Google Scholar]
- Farrugia, D. (2020). Class, place and mobility beyond the global city: Stigmatisation and the cosmopolitanisation of the local. Journal of Youth Studies, 23(2), 237–251. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Giardiello, M., & Cuervo, H. (2018). The formation of a sense of belonging: An analysis of young people’s lives in Australian and Italian rural communities. In C. Halse (Ed.), Interrogating belonging for young people in schools (pp. 203–224). Springer International Publishing. [Google Scholar]
- Green, B., & Letts, W. (2007). Space, equity, and rural education. In K. Gulson, & C. Symes (Eds.), Spatial theories of education: Policy and geography matters (pp. 57–76). Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Habib, S., & Ward, M. (Eds.). (2020). Youth, place and theories of belonging. Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Harris, A., Cuervo, H., & Wyn, J. (2021). Thinking about belonging in youth studies. Springer International Publishing. [Google Scholar]
- Hjalm, A. (2014). The ‘stayers’: Dynamics of lifelong sedentary behaviour in an urban context. Population, Space and Place, 20, 569–580. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Honneth, A. (1995). The struggle for recognition: The moral grammar of social conflicts. MIT Press. [Google Scholar]
- Honneth, A. (2003). Redistribution as recognition: A response to Nancy Fraser. In N. Fraser, & A. Honneth (Eds.), Redistribution or recognition? A political-philosophical exchange (pp. 110–197). Verso. [Google Scholar]
- Honneth, A. (2007). Disrespect: The normative foundations of critical theory. Polity Press. [Google Scholar]
- Kenway, J., Kraack, A., & Hickey-Moody, A. (2006). Masculinity beyond the metropolis. Palgrave Macmillan. [Google Scholar]
- Lähdesmäki, T., Saresma, T., Hiltunen, K., Jäntti, S., Sääskilahti, N., Vallius, A., & Ahvenjärvi, K. (2016). Fluidity and flexibility of “belonging” uses of the concept in contemporary research. Acta Sociologica, 59(3), 233–247. [Google Scholar]
- Lepold, K. (2019). Examining Honneth’s positive theory of recognition. Critical Horizons, 20(3), 246–261. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- MacKinnon, D., Beal, V., & Leibert, T. (2024). Rethinking ‘left-behind’ places in a context of rising spatial inequalities and political discontent. Regional Studies, 58(6), 1161–1166, (Correction in 2024, Regional Studies, 58[6], ci). [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- McPherson, C. (2020). The youth transitions of young people of low socioeconomic status in Scotland: Social justice, social generations, and the need for a new policy frame [Doctoral dissertation, University of Stirling]. [Google Scholar]
- McPherson, C. (2025). Haunted aspirations and youth transitions in the contemporary context. Journal of Applied Youth Studies, 8(4), 517–533. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Noble, G. (2020). Foreword. Putting belonging to work. In S. Habib, & M. Ward (Eds.), Youth, place and theories of belonging (pp. xvii–xviii). Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Pedersen, H. D., & Gram, M. (2018). ‘The brainy ones are leaving’: The subtlety of (un) cool places through the eyes of rural youth. Journal of youth studies, 21(5), 620–635. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Pilkington, H., & Acik, N. (2020). Not entitled to talk: (mis)recognition, inequality and social activism of young Muslims. Sociology, 54(1), 181–198. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ravn, S. (2022). Reframing immobility: Young women aspiring to ‘good enough’ local futures. Journal of Youth Studies, 25(9), 1236–1250. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ristaniemi, H., Vehkalahti, K., & Pöysä, V. (2024). Going against the grain? A longitudinal study of the material-discursive practices of staying among young adults in rural Finland. Journal of Youth Studies, 27(9), 1240–1255. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Rönnlund, M. (2020). ‘I love this place, but I won’t stay’: Identification with place and imagined spatial futures among youth living in rural areas in Sweden. Young, 28(2), 123–137. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Schewel, K. (2019). Understanding immobility: Moving beyond the mobility bias in migration studies. International Migration Review, 54(2), 328–355. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Simpson, K. (2021). Social haunting, education, and the working class: A critical Marxist ethnography in a former mining community. Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Smette, I., & Hegna, K. (2025). Understanding rural young women’s pathways towards settledness in Norway: A longitudinal perspective. In K. Vehkalahti, I. M. Eriksen, & J. Østergaard (Eds.), Growing up rural: Qualitative longitudinal explorations of young people living in the Nordic countries (pp. 233–255). Springer. [Google Scholar]
- Sørensen, N. U., & Pless, M. (2017). Living on the periphery of youth: Young people’s narratives of youth life in rural areas. Young, 25(Suppl. S4), 1S–17S. [Google Scholar]
- Stockdale, A., & Haartsen, T. (2018). Editorial introduction: Putting stayers in the spotlight. Population, Space and Place, 24(4), e2414. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Tönnies, F. (1957). Gemeinschaft and gesellschaft. Michigan State University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Vehkalahti, K., Eriksen, I. M., & Østergaard, J. (Eds.). (2026). Growing up rural: Qualitative longitudinal explorations of young people living in the Nordic countries. Springer Nature. [Google Scholar]
- Wenham, A. (2020). “Wish you were here”? Geographies of exclusion: Young people, coastal towns and marginality. Journal of Youth Studies, 23(1), 44–60. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Wright, S. (2015). More-than-human, emergent belongings: A weak theory approach. Progress in Human Geography, 39(4), 391–411. [Google Scholar]
- Wyn, J., & Cuervo, H. (2014, June 16). Pain now, rewards later? Young lives cannot be relived. The Conversation. Available online: https://theconversation.com/pain-now-rewards-later-young-lives-cannot-be-relived-27964 (accessed on 10 November 2026).
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.