Review Reports
- Hamza Tami 1,
- Youssef Ezzaky 1,2 and
- Fouad Achemchem 1,3,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsIn this study, lactic acid bacteria (LAB) stains were isolated from goat meat in local regions. Six outstanding strains were adopted as research materials. The obtained results can provide the technological references for isolation and application of lactic acid bacteria in local regions. In my opinion, the article can be published in Applied Microbiology after minor revision. The corresponding questions and suggestions are as follows:
- Line 101: What are the components of buffered peptone water? The authors should mention it in detail. In addition, did the meat pieces need to be crushed? In my opinion, the authors should illustrate the isolation method for bacteria strains in detail.
- Line 156 to Line 160: Did the antibiotic disks refer to paper disk? If the authors adopted paper disk in experiments, how did the authors calculate the weight of each antibiotic (Line 157 to Line 160) on the paper disk?
- Table 2: In this table, the strain codes (MG1117, MG1612, MG1706, MG1714, MG1924 and MG4013) and the corresponding the accession numbers (Line 174 to Line 176) should be shown simultaneously.
- Figure 1: The statistical results of antibacterial activities of the six strains were shown in this figure. In my opinion, if it is possible, the photos of antibacterial results of the strains can be provided in Supplementary materials. This depends on the authors´decision.
- Line 420 to Line 423: The outstanding characteristics of the strain MG4013 should be mentioned in Abstract.
The article was well written in English.
Author Response
General Comment: In this study, lactic acid bacteria (LAB) stains were isolated from goat meat in local regions. Six outstanding strains were adopted as research materials. The obtained results can provide the technological references for isolation and application of lactic acid bacteria in local regions. In my opinion, the article can be published in Applied Microbiology after minor revision. The corresponding questions and suggestions are as follows:
Response : We sincerely thank the reviewer for the thorough and constructive evaluation of our manuscript. We have carefully considered all comments and revised the manuscript accordingly. Detailed point-by-point responses are provided below, and all corresponding changes are clearly highlighted in green color in the resubmitted files.
Comments 1: [Line 101: What are the components of buffered peptone water? The authors should mention it in detail. In addition, did the meat pieces need to be crushed? In my opinion, the authors should illustrate the isolation method for bacteria strains in detail.]
Response 1: We appreciate this important points raised by the reviewer.
a. The components of buffered peptone water are: [The medium was made in dehydrated form at 25.5 g/L and contains peptone (10.0 g/L), sodium chloride (5.0 g/L), disodium hydrogen phosphate dodecahydrate (9.0 g/L) and potassium dihydrogen phosphate (1.5 g/L).] Thank you for pointing this out. We agree with this comment. Therefore, we have added the components of buffer peptone water in the manuscript. [The medium was made in dehydrated form at 25.5 g/L and contains peptone (10.0 g/L), sodium chloride (5.0 g/L), disodium hydrogen phosphate dodecahydrate (9.0 g/L) and potassium dihydrogen phosphate (1.5 g/L). The medium was dissolved in distilled water, poured into appropriate containers and sterilized by autoclaving at 121 °C for 15 min. The final pH was 7.0 ± 0.2 at 25 °C. The phosphate-buffering technique provided near-neutral conditions during sample preparation and thereby facilitated recovery of stressed or sub-lethally wounded bacteria]. [ page number 3, Materials and Methods section, 2.2. Microbiological Isolation, line 137-144.]
b. Did the meat pieces need to be crushed: Yes, experiments were performed using ground meat product. In the manuscript you will find the following rectification: “[Twenty-five grams of ground meat product of each sample were homogenized in 225 mL buffered peptone water]- [ page number 3, Materials and Methods section, 2.2. Microbiological Isolation, line136-138]”
Comments 2: [Line 156 to Line 160: Did the antibiotic disks refer to paper disk? If the authors adopted paper disk in experiments, how did the authors calculate the weight of each antibiotic (Line 157 to Line 160) on the paper disk?]
Response 2: Thank you for this important comment. [The antibiotic weight was not calculated or weighed by the authors. Antibiotic discs were obtained commercially from Mast Group Ltd, Bootle, Merseyside, United Kingdom. European distributor listed on the product box is likewise Mast Diagnostica GmbH, Reinfeld, Germany. The antibiotic content indicated in the manuscript (µg or units per disc) corresponds to the potency specified by the manufacturer. Therefore, each disc was used directly without additional antibiotic preparation, weighing, or impregnation]. We have clarified this point in the revised manuscript by inserting this content “Commercial antibiotic impregnated paper discs were used according to the manufac-turer’s instructions. Antibiotic discs were obtained commercially from Mast Group Ltd, Bootle, Merseyside, United Kingdom. European distributor listed on the product box is likewise Mast Diagnostica GmbH, Reinfeld, Germany. The listed concentrations are the standardized antibiotic potencies per disc, not calculated or manually prepared by the authors.” [ page 5, Section: Materials and Methods Paragraph 2.7. Safety-Related Traits, line 202-207].
Comments 3: [Table 2: In this table, the strain codes (MG1117, MG1612, MG1706, MG1714, MG1924 and MG4013) and the corresponding the accession numbers (Line 174 to Line 176) should be shown simultaneously.]
Response 3: Thank you for this important comment. We add the accession number of these isolates LAB, Enterococcus thailandicus (MG1117 PZ298424), E. faecium (MG1612 PZ068411, MG1706 PZ068436), and Latilactobacillus sakei (MG1714 PZ069392, MG1924 PZ069393, MG4013 PZ069394). As a column in the table 2 [ page number 6, Section: Results. Subsection 3.2. Phenotypic and Physiological Characteristics, line 261.]
Comments 4: [ Figure 1: The statistical results of antibacterial activities of the six strains were shown in this figure. In my opinion, if it is possible, the photos of antibacterial results of the strains can be provided in Supplementary materials. This depends on the authors ‘decision].
Response 4: Photos are provided as Supplementary materials.
Comments 5: Line 420 to Line 423: The outstanding characteristics of the strain MG4013 should be mentioned in Abstract.
Response 5: This content was added in Abstract, thanks. “The sustained inhibition even after neutralization of pH suggested that the antimicrobial effects might be mediated by bacteriocin-like compounds or other non-acidic metabolites. In the strains tested, L. sakei MG4013 gave the best results because of its wide range of antimicrobial activity, absence of hemolytic, gelatinase, proteolytic and lipolytic activities and its favourable antibiotic susceptibility profile”. [ page number 1, Abstract, line 24- line 28.]
Response to Comments on the Quality of English Language: The article was well written in English.
Response 1: Thank you so much for this comment, we appreciate your assessment as a positive comment.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsComments and suggestion are given in the attachment.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 2
- Summary
We thank the reviewer for a detailed and exacting review. The comments on the title, the Abstract, the length and citation of the Introduction, the description of the samples and assays, the duplication between text and tables, and the interpretation of the antibiotic-susceptibility data have each prompted substantive revision. In particular, the observation on citation numbering led us to audit the entire reference apparatus, and the observation on dietary versus post-slaughter influences led us to reframe a central claim of the Discussion.
- Questions for General Evaluation
|
Questions for General Evaluation |
Reviewer's Evaluation |
Response and Revisions |
|
Does the introduction provide sufficient background and include all relevant references? |
Can be improved |
Addressed in Comments 4–8: the Introduction has been condensed and the citation sequence corrected throughout. |
|
Are all the cited references relevant to the research? |
Can be improved |
Addressed in Comments 4 and 10: duplicate entries have been merged and grouped citations reduced to a single source per method. |
|
Is the research design appropriate? |
Can be improved |
Addressed in Comments 9 and 14: the sample set and the criteria for selecting the final isolates are now described in full. |
|
Are the methods adequately described? |
Must be improved |
Addressed in Comments 9–13: sampling, processing and animal parameters are specified, and the number of replicates is stated for every assay. |
|
Are the results clearly presented? |
Yes |
We thank the reviewer for this positive assessment. |
|
Are the conclusions supported by the results? |
Yes |
We thank the reviewer for this positive assessment. The conclusions have additionally been narrowed so that they rest only on the data presented (see Section 5). |
|
Are all figures and tables clear and well-presented? |
Yes |
We thank the reviewer for this positive assessment. |
- Point-by-point response to comments and suggestions for authors
Comment 1: It is repeated twice in the title; suggestion is to delete this.
Response 1: We agree and have removed the redundancy. “Moroccan” has been deleted, so that the country is named only once. The title now reads:
“Isolation and Characterization of Bioprotective Lactic Acid Bacteria from Goat’s Meat Produced in Argan Grove of Morocco”
Comment 2: Animals are reared but meat is produced; suggestion is to change.
Response 2: This is a valid distinction and we have corrected it. “Reared” has been replaced by “Produced” in the title, so that the verb now applies to the meat rather than to the animals.
Comment 3: This seems overstated; please add study limitation and/or additional/future research needed.
Response 3: We accept that the concluding claim of the Abstract was too strong for in vitro evidence alone, and have qualified it. The closing sentences now read:
“Goat meat from the Souss–Massa region therefore harbours LAB with biopreservative potential, with potential for use as natural preservatives in traditional meat products or as starter cultures in fermented foods. However, before being used as natural preservatives or starter cultures, they need to be further validated in food matrices.” (page 1, Abstract, from line 30)
The limitations of the study are also set out explicitly at the end of the Discussion, where the culture-dependent isolation strategy, the in vitro nature of the antimicrobial testing and the limited discriminatory power of 16S rRNA sequencing for safety assessment are each acknowledged.
Comment 4: Previous sentence included last reference 5, so here it cannot be 9,12; please check this.
Response 4: We thank the reviewer for detecting this error. The citation sequence was inconsistent because several references were duplicated in the list and because citations were not numbered strictly in order of first appearance. The entire reference apparatus has therefore been audited rather than corrected locally: five duplicate entries were merged, the list was reduced from 61 to 56 entries, and all in-text citations were renumbered so that they now run consecutively from [1] to [56] in order of first appearance. The passage the reviewer identified now cites [8,9], in sequence with the preceding text.
Comment 5: Lines 33–46 can be reduced.
Response 5: We agree. The historical material on goat domestication has been deleted and the paragraph condensed to the information that bears directly on the study context:
“Goat farming is an important source of livelihood for rural people supplying meat, milk and revenue [1]. In Morocco, it is especially important in hilly and desert zones where goat meat is appreciated for its low fat level, nutritional value and cultural importance.” (page 1, Introduction, from line 39)
Comment 6: Line 47 onward: suggestion is to reduce text.
Response 6: The passage has been substantially condensed. Repetitive background on the general properties of LAB has been removed and related ideas combined, while the rationale for selecting indigenous strains has been retained (page 2, Introduction, from line 50)
Comment 7: A repeated phrase in the Introduction.
Response 7: Thank you for noticing this. The duplicated statement on shelf-life extension appeared twice within a few lines; the second occurrence has been deleted, so the point is now made once only.
Comment 8: Suggestion is to reduce text, especially in lines 79–83, that seems too general and over-promising.
Response 8: We accept that the objective was stated too broadly. It has been reduced to a single sentence limited to what the study actually undertakes:
“The aim of this work was to characterize indigenous LAB isolates in terms of their technological, safety and antimicrobial properties and to select promising candidate strains for further evaluation as protective or starter cultures in traditional goat meat products.” (page 2, from line 71)
Comment 9: Please provide more detail about meat — what does “fermented” refer to compared to “dried, fermented”, in which conditions this fermentation and drying occurred, time of fermentation and drying, temperature, place; more detail about animals — age, gender, slaughter conditions.
Response 9: We are grateful for this comment, which has allowed us to describe the sample set far more precisely. Section 2.1 now distinguishes the three product categories and specifies the processing and animal parameters:
“Samples of meat were categorized as fresh, fermented or dried-fermented. Fresh meat was untreated muscle obtained soon after slaughter and was not subjected to seasoning, fermentation or drying. The fermented meat was sliced into slices and mixed with a customary mix of spices and olive oil and fermented spontaneously in covered food-grade containers at ambient temperature (20–25 °C) for around 24–48 h. Dried fermented meat was produced utilizing the same formulation and fermentation technique followed by traditional sun drying for about 5–7 days at daytime temperatures of 25–35 °C, with the meat shielded from dust, insects and other sources of contamination. Samples were collected from male goats aged approximately between 6 and 12 months. Meat samples were taken from the muscle and carcass region within 1-2 h after slaughter and delivered to the laboratory under refrigerated conditions.” (page 2, Section 2.1, from line 81)
Comment 10: In Materials and Methods, for the same method and/or procedure several references are presented; suggestion is to present one and to reduce the number of references that refer to the same citation. The number of references seems too large and could be reduced.
Response 10: We agree, and have acted on this comment throughout the Materials and Methods. Each method or procedure is now supported by a single citation rather than by a group of references. In auditing the list we also identified five entries that had been duplicated under two different numbers; these have been merged. The reference list has consequently been reduced from 61 to 56 entries and renumbered consecutively in order of first appearance.
Comment 11: Was this tested once or in repetitions? (Section 2.4, Antimicrobial Activity by Agar Well Diffusion)
Response 11: All determinations were performed in triplicate, and this is now stated explicitly. The sentence “All assays were performed in triplicate.” has been added at the end of Section 2.4, and the legend of Figure 1 now specifies that the plotted values are means of three independent experiments.
Section 2.4, page 4 (from line 145); Figure 1 legend, page 7.
Comment 12: Were there any repetitions? (Section 2.5, Phenotypic and Biochemical Characterization)
Response 12: Yes. The statement “All assays were performed in triplicate.” has been added at the end of Section 2.5.
Comment 13: Repetitions? (Section 2.6, Technological Properties)
Response 13: Yes. The statement “All assays were performed in duplicate.” has been added at the end of Section 2.6
Comment 14: This needs to be presented with more details. (Section 3.1, selection of the final isolates)
Response 14: We appreciate this suggestion. The selection criteria are now described explicitly, including the indicator pathogens used, the breadth and intensity of inhibition required, and the additional phenotypic considerations applied:
“These isolates produced the largest inhibition zones among the active cultures and exhibited broad-spectrum antagonistic activity against the investigated indicator pathogens, namely Salmonella enterica, Listeria monocytogenes, and Staphylococcus aureus. Isolates showing weak or narrow-spectrum inhibition were excluded. The final selection also considered distinct phenotypic characteristics and the suitability of the isolates for subsequent safety and technological assessment.” (page 5, Section 3.1, from line 215)
Comment 15: Same results should not be reported both in text and table; interpretation in text should differ. (Section 3.6, Antibiotic Resistance)
Response 15: We agree. The antibiotic-by-antibiotic recitation that duplicated Table 4 has been deleted and replaced by an interpretation of the pattern, and the closing paragraph has been shortened to remove the residual overlap. The revised text reads:
“Table 4 shows the antibiotic susceptibility profiles of the three Enterococcus isolates. Across the thirteen agents tested, every response fell into the susceptible (S) or intermediate (I) category and none of these isolates reached the resistance breakpoint. Antibiotic susceptibility data are not reported here for the three L. sakei isolates. The two E. faecium isolates did not share a common profile, indicating that susceptibility in this collection is strain-dependent rather than species-dependent. Intermediate responses were distributed across β-lactams, aminoglycosides, vancomycin, ciprofloxacin and fusidic acid, whereas all three Enterococcus isolates remained susceptible to penicillin, flumequine, amoxicillin and chloramphenicol. Because an intermediate phenotype does not in itself indicate an acquired or transferable determinant, these responses are interpreted here as an indication for genotypic follow-up rather than as evidence of resistance.” (page 7, Section 3.6, from line 267)
Comment 16: Already presented in Section 3.2. (Section 3.8)
Response 16: Thank you for identifying this duplication. The phenotypic recapitulation that repeated Section 3.2 has been deleted from Section 3.8, which now begins directly with the biochemical and molecular identification.
Comment 17: This belongs to Materials and Methods. (Section 3.8, 16S rRNA / PCR sentence)
Response 17: We agree and have relocated the passage. The description of 16S rRNA gene sequencing and BLASTn comparison, together with the accession numbers, now appears in Section 2.8 rather than in the Results.
Comment 18: Diet is considered a factor that can influence meat microbiota, but primarily gut microbiota; however, post-slaughter processing and storage conditions generally have a greater direct impact on the microbial community that develops on meat during storage.
Response 18: We thank the reviewer for this correction, which we accept. The Discussion no longer implies a direct dietary effect on the meat microbiota. The revised text gives primacy to post-slaughter factors and presents the argan-based diet only as a possible indirect influence:
“Although post-slaughter hygiene, processing, and storage conditions directly shape the microbial communities developing on meat, the argan-based diet may indirectly influence the microbiota by modifying the animals’ gastrointestinal and associated microbial populations, some of which may be transferred to the carcass during slaughter and subsequent handling.” (page 9, Discussion, from line 331)
Comment 19: Results should be discussed, not repeated. (antibiotic resistance discussion)
Response 19: We agree, and the passage has been rewritten as interpretation rather than restatement. It now addresses the strain-specific nature of susceptibility, the variability reported for food-derived enterococci, and the genomic evidence that a susceptible phenotype does not exclude resistance determinants, concluding with the assessment required before any of the strains could be used as a food culture. The paragraph opens:
“Antibiotic susceptibility profiles are presented here only for the Enterococcus isolates (Table 4). Susceptibility is strain specific not species specific and cannot be predicted on the basis of species identity. For instance, L. sakei subsp. sakei 2a [43] was found to be multidrug resistant and positive for vanA, underscoring the importance of safety screening at the strain level.” (page 11, Discussion, from line 385)
- Response to comments on the quality of English language
Comment: The English is fine and does not require any improvement.
Response: We thank the reviewer. The revised text has nonetheless been reviewed for consistency of terminology, units and citation format.