Review Reports
- Abdelbari El Agy 1,
- Ismail Mansouri 2,* and
- Lahsen El Ghadraoui 1
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Malihe Erfani Reviewer 2: Reuven Yosef Reviewer 3: Jorge Mario Becoche Mosquera
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsManuscript ID: birds-4383072
Title: Harnessing Social Media for Monitoring Threatened Avifauna in Morocco: Spatiotemporal Distribution, Habitat Use, Population Structure, and Behavioral Ecology
Using social network data and examining data over ten years is valuable, especially for threatened species. However, some methodological and presentation cautions are necessary, as outlined in the article's comments section.
Comments:
Title and abstract
Data derived from social media platforms require careful interpretation, as they reflect human-accessible environments rather than the full distributional range of the four avian species under investigation. Consequently, this constraint should be unequivocally recognized within the study's framework and, when applicable, manifested in the title.
It should also be noted that much of the image capture is done with the aim of capturing attractive and beautiful images, not with the aim of documenting habitat, population structure, or ecological behaviors. Therefore, these data may be subject to significant bias.
Despite these limitations, such data could have the potential to provide conservation indicators, such as identifying sensitive seasonal periods, observing threatened chicks and nests, or reporting new distribution patterns in social networks. However, the abstract of the article does not sufficiently explain a clear and operational connection between these findings and management and conservation applications.
Introduction
Although the Introduction discusses the usefulness of social media for conservation (Lines 81–98; 100–111), it does not explicitly address key methodological limitations such as spatial bias toward human-accessible areas, observer effort bias, and detectability bias. These limitations are critical for interpreting species distribution and ecological inferences.
The manuscript claims a “novel methodological framework” (Lines 112–130) integrating multi-lingual and multi-platform social media data with ecological indicators. However, this appears to be an incremental extension of existing social media–based biodiversity monitoring approaches rather than a fundamentally new framework. The novelty should be more cautiously framed.
Statements regarding “real-time data,” “real-time tracking,” and improved monitoring capacity (Lines 100–106)are potentially overstated. Social media records are opportunistic and non-standardized, and without correction for sampling effort, they cannot reliably support real-time population or distribution monitoring.
The research gap is described mainly in terms of “lack of real-time monitoring” and “public engagement,” (Lines 112–118) but the Introduction does not clearly justify why social media data are sufficient to address these gaps, nor does it critically assess their limitations in the Moroccan ecological context.
The proposed integration of ecological indicators (e.g., behavior, reproduction) with anthropogenic pressure variables (e.g., hunting, mortality) is conceptually interesting (Lines 122–127), but would benefit from a clearer statement in the Introduction regarding how these variables are inferred from social media data and how such interpretations are constrained by data source limitations.
- Materials and Methods
2.1. Materials
The methodology employed is extensive and systematically organized; however, it fails to adequately address the critical issues of sampling bias, the procedures for data validation, and the quantification of uncertainty, all of which are indispensable for deriving reliable inferences from ecological datasets sourced from social media.
The caption of Figure 1 is too brief and should be more descriptive to clearly reflect the workflow. The figure resolution is low, and the light blue background is not suitable for publication; a higher-quality image with a neutral background is recommended. The figure does not use arrows to clearly indicate flow between boxes. In addition, some text extends beyond the boundaries of the boxes.
The current numbering structure is not appropriate, as all subsections (2.1.4 and 2.1.5) are incorrectly placed under “2.1 Materials”, although they describe methodological and analytical procedures.
- Results and Discussion
The current numbering structure in this section needs revision, as all subsections are incorrectly organized under “3.1”.
The Results and Discussion segment (Lines 239–538) offers significant confirmatory and supplementary insights. Nevertheless, the outcomes predominantly coincide with previously established ecological knowledge pertaining to the examined species and fail to unequivocally illustrate novel ecological findings that extend beyond what has already been documented in the referenced literature throughout the section (e.g., Lines 263–281, 307–323, 344–359, and 408–422).
The research predominantly corroborates recognized trends (including seasonal migration maxima, habitat specialization, and documented spatial distributions) as opposed to uncovering novel ecological mechanisms, previously unrecorded populations, or unforeseen range expansions.
The manuscript uses one-way ANOVA for multiple comparisons; however, it does not include any testing of the underlying assumptions. This includes checks for normality (for example, the Shapiro–Wilk test) and for homogeneity of variance (for example, Levene’s test).
Given that the analyses appear to be based on count-derived and opportunistically collected social media records, the suitability of parametric ANOVA should be more clearly justified. If the underlying data are count-based and non-normally distributed, generalized linear models (e.g., Poisson or negative binomial models) may provide a more appropriate analytical framework.
The Correspondence Analysis results lack essential statistical reporting, including eigenvalues, inertia values, and the contribution of axes.
- Conclusion
The conclusion section (Lines 540–564) mostly reiterates findings that were already presented in the Results and Discussion section (Lines 239–538). In particular, it covers species distribution patterns, temporal dynamics, habitat associations, and the contributions of different platforms. For that reason, it serves more as a brief summary of the results than as an integrative synthesis of the study’s wider ecological and methodological value.
Furthermore, the claim that the study “demonstrates the growing importance of social media as an effective source of biodiversity information” (Lines 555–557) seems somewhat exaggerated considering the previously mentioned methodological limitations, especially the absence of adjustments for sampling bias, observer bias, and spatial variability.
While limitations are appropriately mentioned (Lines 560–563), additional sources of bias such as platform-driven visibility effects and detectability bias are not explicitly acknowledged.
Finally, the suggested future directions (Lines 563–564), although relevant, remain rather general and would benefit from being more directly linked to specific methodological improvements in social media–based ecological monitoring.
Author Response
Title: Harnessing Social Media for Monitoring Threatened Avifauna in Morocco: Spatiotemporal Distribution, Habitat Use, Population Structure, and Behavioral Ecology
Using social network data and examining data over ten years is valuable, especially for threatened species. However, some methodological and presentation cautions are necessary, as outlined in the article's comments section.
Response: Thank you for your positive assessment. We agree that the use of social media data over ten years offers valuable insights into threatened avifauna in Morocco. We appreciate the methodological and presentation concerns raised and will carefully be addressed to improve the rigor, clarity, and interpretation of our findings.
Comments:
Title and abstract
Data derived from social media platforms require careful interpretation, as they reflect human-accessible environments rather than the full distributional range of the four avian species under investigation. Consequently, this constraint should be unequivocally recognized within the study's framework and, when applicable, manifested in the title.
Response: Thank you for this important comment. done as recommended in all sections (results, discussion, limitations, and conclusion).
Results:
It should be emphasized that these patterns reflect the frequency of social media observations in human-accessible, digitally connected environments rather than the actual population structure or abundance. Therefore, differences among species and life stages may partly result from observer preferences, species detectability, and reporting biases.
Ultimately, these temporal and monthly variations primarily reflect reporting effort, observer activity, and the accessibility of human-inhabited environments rather than true demographic or ecological changes in species. Consequently, observed peaks and declines across species should be interpreted as indicators of social media detectability and engagement biases, not population dynamics in the field.
At the end, these findings indicate that recorded occurrences are strongly shaped by platform-specific user behavior and visibility rather than true species abundance or ecological distribution patterns. Consequently, social media-derived records primarily reflect human engagement biases and platform accessibility, which should be considered when interpreting interspecific differences across digital sources.
These patterns suggest that avian occurrence data are primarily driven by informal social media pages, with structured scientific or official sources contributing relatively little to the overall dataset. Consequently, observed species distributions and recording frequencies largely reflect user-generated content bias, emphasizing the need for cautious ecological interpretation.
These spatial patterns of our results should be interpreted cautiously, as they are likely influenced by uneven human reporting effort across regions rather than solely by true ecological abundance. Therefore, the apparent regional concentrations may partially reflect accessibility and visibility biases inherent to social media–derived observations.
From another angle, these activity-based records likely reflect the differential detectability of behaviors on social media, where conspicuous actions such as feeding and resting are more frequently documented than cryptic processes like nesting. Consequently, observed behavioral patterns should be interpreted as representation biases of online visibility rather than comprehensive ethological profiles of the studied species.
However, given that the data originate from social media observations, the results likely emphasize human-accessible habitats, potentially underrepresenting more remote ecological niches.
Firstly, these patterns likely reflect bias toward human-visible events in accessible areas, suggesting that actual ecological impacts in less monitored habitats may be underrepresented.
Limits of the study
Despite the broad coverage provided by social media platforms, several methodological limitations should be acknowledged. First, the dataset relies on opportunistic observations generated by users rather than standardized field surveys, which may introduce spatial, temporal, and taxonomic biases. Areas with higher internet connectivity, tourism activity, or birdwatching communities are likely to be overrepresented, whereas remote regions may remain underreported. In addition, species identification based on photographs, videos, or textual descriptions may occasionally be inaccurate, particularly for rare or morphologically similar species. The unequal popularity and accessibility of social media platforms may also influence the volume and distribution of records.
Furthermore, the study does not account for variations in observation effort among users, platforms, or years, which may affect the interpretation of temporal trends and species occurrence patterns. The use of regional percentages as a proxy for distribution reflects reporting intensity rather than actual population abundance. Although duplicate screening and content verification were applied, some records may contain incomplete metadata or imprecise geographic information. Consequently, the findings should be considered complementary to conventional monitoring programs rather than a substitute for systematic ecological surveys and long-term field-based assessments.
Conclusion
Nevertheless, the study remains limited by unequal sampling effort, observer bias, and incomplete geographic coverage related to social media platforms. Future research should integrate artificial intelligence, geospatial modeling, remote sensing, and standardized validation protocols to improve the reliability and predictive capacity of digital biodiversity monitoring systems.
It should also be noted that much of the image capture is done with the aim of capturing attractive and beautiful images, not with the aim of documenting habitat, population structure, or ecological behaviors. Therefore, these data may be subject to significant bias.
Comment: mentioned as recommended.
Despite these limitations, such data could have the potential to provide conservation indicators, such as identifying sensitive seasonal periods, observing threatened chicks and nests, or reporting new distribution patterns in social networks. However, the abstract of the article does not sufficiently explain a clear and operational connection between these findings and management and conservation applications.
Comment: Thank you for this crucial comment. We built a totally new section to relate the results to conservation applications.
Conservation implications
The findings highlight the considerable potential of social media as a citizen-science tool for the conservation of threatened bird species in Morocco. By facilitating the rapid collection and dissemination of occurrence records, social media strengthens collaboration between researchers, conservation organizations, ornithologists, and the general public. The spatial distribution patterns identified through these platforms provide valuable information for prioritizing conservation actions in key ecosystems, including wetlands used by Acrocephalus paludicola, coastal habitats occupied by Geronticus eremita, steppes supporting Chersophilus duponti, and semi-desert landscapes preferred by Chlamydotis undulata. Such information can be used to establish measurable conservation targets, including habitat protection, restoration programs, and long-term monitoring of population trends.
The predominance of predation and hunting among the recorded threats further demonstrates the capacity of social media to identify conservation priorities and support mitigation measures. Monitoring posts and shared observations can help locate threat hotspots, evaluate temporal changes in pressures, and guide actions such as seasonal hunting restrictions, nest protection initiatives, and strengthened surveillance in vulnerable habitats. Previous studies have shown that social media campaigns can increase public engagement, conservation funding, and policy support for threatened species, resulting in measurable improvements in conservation outcomes (Bergman et al., 2022).
Nevertheless, responsible management of online content remains essential. Social media monitoring has successfully revealed illegal wildlife trade networks and the promotion of wildlife as pets, supporting awareness campaigns and law-enforcement interventions (Nunes et al., 2023; Wyatt et al., 2022). For the studied bird species, integrating social media surveillance into conservation programs could help detect illegal capture, trafficking, and commercialization while providing measurable indicators of reporting frequency, public participation, threat occurrence, and management effectiveness.
References:
Bergman, J. N., Buxton, R. T., Lin, H. Y., Lenda, M., Attinello, K., Hajdasz, A. C., ... & Bennett, J. R. (2022). Evaluating the benefits and risks of social media for wildlife conservation. Facets, 7(1), 360-397.
Nunes, V. F., Lopes, P. F., & Ferreira, R. G. (2023). # capuchinmonkeys on social media: a threat for species conservation. Anthrozoös, 36(4), 665-683.
Wyatt, T., Miralles, O., Massé, F., Lima, R., da Costa, T. V., & Giovanini, D. (2022). Wildlife trafficking via social media in Brazil. Biological Conservation, 265, 109420.
Conclusion
The identified distribution patterns, habitat preferences, and threat factors provide practical guidance for prioritizing conservation actions in wetlands, steppes, coastal habitats, and semi-desert ecosystems that support threatened bird populations. Moreover, the integration of social media monitoring into conservation programs may strengthen early detection of hunting pressure, predation hotspots, and illegal wildlife trafficking while enhancing collaboration between scientists, conservation practitioners, and citizen observers for more effective and measurable biodiversity management.
Abstract
The identified habitats and threats provide actionable indicators for prioritizing protection, monitoring, and targeted mitigation measures.
Introduction
Although the Introduction discusses the usefulness of social media for conservation (Lines 81–98; 100–111), it does not explicitly address key methodological limitations such as spatial bias toward human-accessible areas, observer effort bias, and detectability bias. These limitations are critical for interpreting species distribution and ecological inferences.
Response: done as recommended.
Nevertheless, social media-derived biodiversity data should be interpreted cautiously, as records are often biased toward human-accessible locations, uneven observer effort, and species with higher detectability or public interest, potentially influencing perceived distribution patterns and ecological inferences.
The manuscript claims a “novel methodological framework” (Lines 112–130) integrating multi-lingual and multi-platform social media data with ecological indicators. However, this appears to be an incremental extension of existing social media–based biodiversity monitoring approaches rather than a fundamentally new framework. The novelty should be more cautiously framed.
Response: This is dedicated to the Avifauna in Morocco. In fact, this study not only addresses the threatened birds, but it presents the first study to evaluate the capacity of online data to draw a real-time picture of threatened species across a large-scale area and over a long time.
In this context, the present study introduces a novel methodological framework based on the integration of multi-lingual and multi-platform social media data for biodiversity assessment, particularly in Morocco, where all previous studies were based on field investigations
Statements regarding “real-time data,” “real-time tracking,” and improved monitoring capacity (Lines 100–106)are potentially overstated.
Response: replaced by long-time.
Social media records are opportunistic and non-standardized, and without correction for sampling effort, they cannot reliably support real-time population or distribution monitoring.
Response: mentioned in the limits of the methodology.
The research gap is described mainly in terms of “lack of real-time monitoring” and “public engagement,” (Lines 112–118) but the Introduction does not clearly justify why social media data are sufficient to address these gaps, nor does it critically assess their limitations in the Moroccan ecological context.
Response: done as recommended.
In fact, online data are easily accessible (groups, accounts, etc.), target a wide range of scales (travel of citizens, nomads, explorers), and have long-term availability, which is not easy by field research that requires institutional investment.
nor does it critically assess their limitations in the Moroccan ecological context (not clear for me (please explain).
The proposed integration of ecological indicators (e.g., behavior, reproduction) with anthropogenic pressure variables (e.g., hunting, mortality) is conceptually interesting (Lines 122–127), but would benefit from a clearer statement in the Introduction regarding how these variables are inferred from social media data and how such interpretations are constrained by data source limitations.
Response: done as recommended. We added examples of ecological indicators and factors that are collected from social media for wild species. Then we clarified how they are collected (observations of citizens, and geotagged publications (geotagged permits the location, while observation of citizens replaces the field sortie of the researcher (not 100%). We included new references.
These platforms can report the ecological features of species, such as breeding habitats (Chowdhury et al 2026) and threatening factors such as hunting and trafficking of wild species (Xu et al 2020, Wyatt et al 2022). Similarly, they provide online data through geotagged posts and citizen observations
However, their dual role requires careful management, as they may simultaneously present biases in data collection (loss of microhabitat details and surrounding climatic conditions) and facilitate harmful activities
References:
Chowdhury, S., Debnath, R., Hawladar, N., Howard, S. R., Hodgins, K. A., Wong, B. B., & Jarić, I. (2026). Social media data reveal novel habitats for invasive species. Biological Conservation, 314, 111668.
Wyatt, T., Miralles, O., Massé, F., Lima, R., da Costa, T. V., & Giovanini, D. (2022). Wildlife trafficking via social media in Brazil. Biological Conservation, 265, 109420.
Xu, Q., Cai, M., & Mackey, T. K. (2020). The illegal wildlife digital market: an analysis of Chinese wildlife marketing and sale on Facebook. Environmental conservation, 47(3), 206-212.
- Materials and Methods
2.1. Materials
The methodology employed is extensive and systematically organized; however, it fails to adequately address the critical issues of sampling bias, the procedures for data validation, and the quantification of uncertainty, all of which are indispensable for deriving reliable inferences from ecological datasets sourced from social media.
Response: done as recommended. We added a new subsection for this.
Data clearance and validation
To improve data quality and reduce potential biases associated with social media datasets, all retrieved records underwent a multi-step cleaning procedure before analysis. First, duplicate records originating from reposts, shared content, or multiple appearances of the same observation across platforms were identified and removed. Records lacking sufficient information for species identification, geographic attribution to Morocco, or ecological interpretation were excluded.
Data validation was performed through manual verification of species identity whenever photographs or videos were available. Records based solely on textual descriptions were retained only when species names were explicitly stated and consistent with known distributions. Nevertheless, social media data remains subject to observer effort, detectability, and accessibility biases, as observations are more likely to originate from human-accessible areas and conspicuous species. Consequently, the results should be interpreted as indicators of ecological patterns rather than precise estimates of population size or distribution.
The caption of Figure 1 is too brief and should be more descriptive to clearly reflect the workflow. The figure resolution is low, and the light blue background is not suitable for publication; a higher-quality image with a neutral background is recommended. The figure does not use arrows to clearly indicate flow between boxes. In addition, some text extends beyond the boundaries of the boxes.
Response: The entire figure was rebuilt to clarify the steps, details, and clear text.
The current numbering structure is not appropriate, as all subsections (2.1.4 and 2.1.5) are incorrectly placed under “2.1 Materials”, although they describe methodological and analytical procedures.
Response: done as recommended.
- Results and Discussion
The current numbering structure in this section needs revision, as all subsections are incorrectly organized under “3.1”.
Response: done
The Results and Discussion segment (Lines 239–538) offers significant confirmatory and supplementary insights. Nevertheless, the outcomes predominantly coincide with previously established ecological knowledge pertaining to the examined species and fail to unequivocally illustrate novel ecological findings that extend beyond what has already been documented in the referenced literature throughout the section (e.g., Lines 263–281, 307–323, 344–359, and 408–422).
Response: done as recommended. We clarified the specificity of our findings compared to the previous studies.
In contrast, quantitative population estimates remain extremely limited in Morocco for A. paludicola, C. duponti, and C. undulata in previous papers, unlike the relatively well-documented turtle dove populations. Therefore, this study is the first to evaluate the structure and age of birds among A. paludicola, C. duponti, and C. undulata in Moroccan and northwest African ecosystems.
Despite the importance of previous studies in clarifying time variables of study species, they rely on short-term field observations, while these findings show long-term records (2015–2025) provide a unique and continuous temporal resolution of A. paludicola, C. duponti, and C. undulata in the northwest African range, enabling simultaneous detection of interannual declines and seasonal peaks.
Compared to field-based studies, characterized by a limited geographical range, these findings reported new areas where these species had never been documented. This permitted the first map of A. paludicola, C. duponti, and C. undulata in Morocco.
Based on a deep literature review, this study is the first to evaluate the activity budgets, mainly for A. paludicola, C. duponti, and C. undulata, revealing statistically robust differences in behavior frequencies and providing a novel, scalable proxy for comparative behavioral ecology in human-accessible landscapes.
This study evaluated large-scale habitat use among the studied species compared to field studies concentrated on limited space and habitats.
Unlike previous Moroccan research that has rarely quantified or comparatively assessed anthropogenic and ecological threats beyond well-studied species such as turtle doves and northern bald ibis, these results uniquely identify and rank multi-species threat drivers, revealing species-specific vulnerability profiles, thereby providing a novel, scalable framework for conservation risk inference across poorly documented avifauna.
The research predominantly corroborates recognized trends (including seasonal migration maxima, habitat specialization, and documented spatial distributions) as opposed to uncovering novel ecological mechanisms, previously unrecorded populations, or unforeseen range expansions.
Response: addressed as recommended. We clarified the unique features and findings of this study.
The manuscript uses one-way ANOVA for multiple comparisons; however, it does not include any testing of the underlying assumptions. This includes checks for normality (for example, the Shapiro–Wilk test) and for homogeneity of variance (for example, Levene’s test).
Response: Yes, we used the Shapiro–Wilk test first to analyse the normality of data. The data was grouped into months of the years (number of records per month for each species) to avoid the random records. Since the variables follow a normal distribution, we used parametric tests: one-way ANOVA when the number of groups is above two. Further, Tukey’s post-hoc test was used to clarify the differences among groups.
The non-parametric test considered to be equivalent if the data were non-normal, is Kruskal-Wallis. But the non-parametric tests are not fiable and serve for data where the number of records is limited. In our case, we recorded 1000 publications.
Given that the analyses appear to be based on count-derived and opportunistically collected social media records, the suitability of parametric ANOVA should be more clearly justified. If the underlying data are count-based and non-normally distributed, generalized linear models (e.g., Poisson or negative binomial models) may provide a more appropriate analytical framework.
The Correspondence Analysis results lack essential statistical reporting, including eigenvalues, inertia values, and the contribution of axes.
Response: the selected axis were with eigenvalues superior and % of variance superior to 50 %. We don’t present eigenvalues in results, instead we present the % of variance to clarify the credibility of the plot. But see the example of test from the software:
EX2: Eigenvalues for Figure 6:
Figure 10.
- Conclusion
The conclusion section (Lines 540–564) mostly reiterates findings that were already presented in the Results and Discussion section (Lines 239–538). In particular, it covers species distribution patterns, temporal dynamics, habitat associations, and the contributions of different platforms. For that reason, it serves more as a brief summary of the results than as an integrative synthesis of the study’s wider ecological and methodological value.
Furthermore, the claim that the study “demonstrates the growing importance of social media as an effective source of biodiversity information” (Lines 555–557) seems somewhat exaggerated considering the previously mentioned methodological limitations, especially the absence of adjustments for sampling bias, observer bias, and spatial variability.
Response: Done as recommended.
Conclusion
This study investigated the potential of social media platforms as complementary ecological monitoring tools for threatened and rare bird species in Morocco. By analyzing records collected between 2015 and 2025 from multiple digital platforms, the study assessed species occurrence, temporal dynamics, habitat preferences, behavioral activities, spatial distribution, and observed population structure of Streptopelia turtur turtur, Geronticus eremita, Chlamydotis undulata, Chersophilus duponti, and Acrocephalus paludicola. The results revealed significant interspecific differences, with the European turtle dove recording the highest abundance, while adults represented the dominant observed category across all species. Strong ecological specialization was evident, with species associated with coastal, steppe, desert, and wetland habitats. Temporal analyses revealed spring peaks linked to migration and breeding. Facebook, TikTok, Instagram, photographs, and videos were the main data sources. These findings highlight the growing value of social media for biodiversity monitoring and documenting threats affecting bird species.
The study highlights the novelty and scientific relevance of social media as a passive citizen-science approach capable of generating large-scale ecological datasets for poorly monitored avifauna. These findings have important implications for biodiversity conservation, ecological surveillance, and adaptive management strategies in Morocco. The identified distribution patterns, habitat preferences, and threat factors provide practical guidance for prioritizing conservation actions in wetlands, steppes, coastal habitats, and semi-desert ecosystems that support threatened bird populations. Moreover, the integration of social media monitoring into conservation programs may strengthen early detection of hunting pressure, predation hotspots, and illegal wildlife trafficking while enhancing collaboration between scientists, conservation practitioners, and citizen observers for more effective and measurable biodiversity management.
While limitations are appropriately mentioned (Lines 560–563), additional sources of bias such as platform-driven visibility effects and detectability bias are not explicitly acknowledged.
Response: Nevertheless, the study remains limited by unequal sampling effort, observer bias, and incomplete geographic coverage related to social media platforms.
Finally, the suggested future directions (Lines 563–564), although relevant, remain rather general and would benefit from being more directly linked to specific methodological improvements in social media–based ecological monitoring.
Response: Future research should integrate artificial intelligence, geospatial modeling, remote sensing, and standardized validation protocols to improve the reliability and predictive capacity of digital biodiversity monitoring systems.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors present a study that explores the emerging role of social media as a complementary tool for monitoring threatened avifauna in Morocco. Addressing the logistical and financial limitations of conventional field surveys, the authors evaluate whether public platforms can provide meaningful ecological data on species distribution, habitat use, and population structure. Focusing on five threatened avian species—Streptopelia turtur turtur, Geronticus eremita, Chlamydotis undulata, Chersophilus duponti, and Acrocephalus paludicola—the study employs a multilingual, multi-platform data collection strategy. The paper situates social media within the broader context of citizen science and conservation monitoring, highlighting its potential for informing avian conservation efforts. Overall, the study makes a valuable contribution by exploring an innovative and increasingly relevant data source for conservation monitoring, but addressing the above points would substantially strengthen its methodological transparency, interpretive depth, and applicability.
The study makes an important contribution by exploring an innovative and increasingly relevant data source for conservation monitoring, but the paper needs to be revised to strengthen its methodological transparency, interpretive depth, and applicability.
The manuscript presents appropriate and generally well-applied statistical procedures that align with the stated research objectives. The writing is clear, concise, and well organized.
That said, several areas could be strengthened to improve the manuscript. Most notably, the absence of an explicit limitations section is a significant omission. A dedicated discussion of limitations would allow readers to better contextualize the findings and assess their robustness. In particular, the inherent uncertainties associated with user-generated social media data, sampling bias linked to the demographic and behavioral characteristics of social media users overemphasizing more charismatic or accessible species and locations (see also DOI 10.1007/s00114-017-1470-8), the selected study period may not capture longer-term ecological trends, while uneven social media penetration across regions could result in gaps in geographic coverage, variation in users’ expertise and motivations, ethical aspects should be addressed to ensure responsible data use.
Methodologically, authors need to give greater detail regarding data collection and validation procedures. Clarifying criteria for post selection, approaches to species verification, and any filtering steps applied to ensure data reliability. While the current analyses are appropriate, inclusion of more advanced statistical approaches (e.g., regression-based models) will provide deeper insights into the drivers of observed patterns and threats.
The literature review should be expanded to better situate the study within the growing body of work on digital data sources and citizen science in conservation. Drawing comparisons with similar studies from other regions would help contextualize the findings and enhance their broader relevance. The discussion could be strengthened by more explicitly linking results to practical conservation applications, including recommendations for policy, management, or public engagement.
Finally, the authors should articulate future research directions, particularly regarding longitudinal monitoring and the integration of social media data with traditional survey methods.
Author Response
The authors present a study that explores the emerging role of social media as a complementary tool for monitoring threatened avifauna in Morocco. Addressing the logistical and financial limitations of conventional field surveys, the authors evaluate whether public platforms can provide meaningful ecological data on species distribution, habitat use, and population structure. Focusing on five threatened avian species—Streptopelia turtur turtur, Geronticus eremita, Chlamydotis undulata, Chersophilus duponti, and Acrocephalus paludicola—the study employs a multilingual, multi-platform data collection strategy. The paper situates social media within the broader context of citizen science and conservation monitoring, highlighting its potential for informing avian conservation efforts. Overall, the study makes a valuable contribution by exploring an innovative and increasingly relevant data source for conservation monitoring, but addressing the above points would substantially strengthen its methodological transparency, interpretive depth, and applicability.
The study makes an important contribution by exploring an innovative and increasingly relevant data source for conservation monitoring, but the paper needs to be revised to strengthen its methodological transparency, interpretive depth, and applicability.
Response: done as recommended. The entire paper was improved. From the Title to references. See the paper, we added new subsections in methodology, implications, and limits.
The manuscript presents appropriate and generally well-applied statistical procedures that align with the stated research objectives. The writing is clear, concise, and well organized.
Response: thank you.
That said, several areas could be strengthened to improve the manuscript. Most notably, the absence of an explicit limitations section is a significant omission.
Response: added as recommended.
A dedicated discussion of limitations would allow readers to better contextualize the findings and assess their robustness. In particular, the inherent uncertainties associated with user-generated social media data, sampling bias linked to the demographic and behavioral characteristics of social media users overemphasizing more charismatic or accessible species and locations (see also DOI 10.1007/s00114-017-1470-8), the selected study period may not capture longer-term ecological trends, while uneven social media penetration across regions could result in gaps in geographic coverage, variation in users’ expertise and motivations, ethical aspects should be addressed to ensure responsible data use.
Response: done as recommended. We added new references.
Limits
Despite the broad coverage provided by social media platforms, several methodological limitations should be acknowledged. First, the dataset relies on opportunistic observations generated by users rather than standardized field surveys, which may introduce spatial, temporal, and taxonomic biases. Areas with higher internet connectivity, tourism activity, or birdwatching communities are likely to be overrepresented, whereas remote regions may remain underreported. In addition, species identification based on photographs, videos, or textual descriptions may occasionally be inaccurate, particularly for rare or morphologically similar species. The unequal popularity and accessibility of social media platforms may also influence the volume and distribution of records (Dylewski et al 2017, Mondal, S., & Rehena, Z. (2022)).
Furthermore, the study does not account for variations in observation effort among users, platforms, or years, which may affect the interpretation of temporal trends and species occurrence patterns. The use of regional percentages as a proxy for distribution reflects reporting intensity rather than actual population abundance. Although duplicate screening and content verification were applied, some records may contain incomplete metadata or imprecise geographic information. Consequently, the findings should be considered complementary to conventional monitoring programs rather than a substitute for systematic ecological surveys and long-term field-based assessments.
Methodologically, authors need to give greater detail regarding data collection and validation procedures. Clarifying criteria for post selection, approaches to species verification, and any filtering steps applied to ensure data reliability. While the current analyses are appropriate, inclusion of more advanced statistical approaches (e.g., regression-based models) will provide deeper insights into the drivers of observed patterns and threats.
Response: done as recommended.
Data clearance and validation
To improve data quality and reduce potential biases associated with social media datasets, all retrieved records underwent a multi-step cleaning procedure before analysis. First, duplicate records originating from reposts, shared content, or multiple appearances of the same observation across platforms were identified and removed. Records lacking sufficient information for species identification, geographic attribution to Morocco, or ecological interpretation were excluded.
Data validation was performed through manual verification of species identity whenever photographs or videos were available. Records based solely on textual descriptions were retained only when species names were explicitly stated and consistent with known distributions. Nevertheless, social media data remains subject to observer effort, detectability, and accessibility biases, as observations are more likely to originate from human-accessible areas and conspicuous species. Consequently, the results should be interpreted as indicators of ecological patterns rather than precise estimates of population size or distribution.
The literature review should be expanded to better situate the study within the growing body of work on digital data sources and citizen science in conservation.
Response: done as recommended.
Drawing comparisons with similar studies from other regions would help contextualize the findings and enhance their broader relevance.
Response: the discussion was completely improved.
The discussion could be strengthened by more explicitly linking results to practical conservation applications, including recommendations for policy, management, or public engagement.
Response: done as recommended. We added a new subsection to rely results with conservation.
3.9. Conservation implications
The findings highlight the considerable potential of social media as a citizen-science tool for the conservation of threatened bird species in Morocco. By facilitating the rapid collection and dissemination of occurrence records, social media strengthens collaboration between researchers, conservation organizations, ornithologists, and the general public. The spatial distribution patterns identified through these platforms provide valuable information for prioritizing conservation actions in key ecosystems, including wetlands used by Acrocephalus paludicola, coastal habitats occupied by Geronticus eremita, steppes supporting Chersophilus duponti, and semi-desert landscapes preferred by Chlamydotis undulata. Such information can be used to establish measurable conservation targets, including habitat protection, restoration programs, and long-term monitoring of population trends.
The predominance of predation and hunting among the recorded threats further demonstrates the capacity of social media to identify conservation priorities and support mitigation measures. Monitoring posts and shared observations can help locate threat hotspots, evaluate temporal changes in pressures, and guide actions such as seasonal hunting restrictions, nest protection initiatives, and strengthened surveillance in vulnerable habitats. Previous studies have shown that social media campaigns can increase public engagement, conservation funding, and policy support for threatened species, resulting in measurable improvements in conservation outcomes [20].
Nevertheless, responsible management of online content remains essential. Social media monitoring has successfully revealed illegal wildlife trade networks and the promotion of wildlife as pets, supporting awareness campaigns and law-enforcement interventions [23,24]. For the studied bird species, integrating social media surveillance into conservation programs could help detect illegal capture, trafficking, and commercialization while providing measurable indicators of reporting frequency, public participation, threat occurrence, and management effectiveness.
And for the limits, despite the broad coverage provided by social media platforms, several methodological limitations should be acknowledged. First, the dataset relies on opportunistic observations generated by users rather than standardized field surveys, which may introduce spatial, temporal, and taxonomic biases. Areas with higher internet connectivity, tourism activity, or birdwatching communities are likely to be overrepresented, whereas remote regions may remain underreported. In addition, species identification based on photographs, videos, or textual descriptions may occasionally be inaccurate, particularly for rare or morphologically similar species. The unequal popularity and accessibility of social media platforms may also influence the volume and distribution of records [16,99].
Furthermore, the study does not account for variations in observation effort among users, platforms, or years, which may affect the interpretation of temporal trends and species occurrence patterns. The use of regional percentages as a proxy for distribution reflects reporting intensity rather than actual population abundance. Although duplicate screening and content verification were applied, some records may contain incomplete metadata or imprecise geographic information. Consequently, the findings should be considered complementary to conventional monitoring programs rather than a substitute for systematic ecological surveys and long-term field-based assessments.
Finally, the authors should articulate future research directions, particularly regarding longitudinal monitoring and the integration of social media data with traditional survey methods.
Response: added as recommended at the end of the conclusion.
The identified distribution patterns, habitat preferences, and threat factors provide practical guidance for prioritizing conservation actions in wetlands, steppes, coastal habitats, and semi-desert ecosystems that support threatened bird populations. Moreover, the integration of social media monitoring into conservation programs may strengthen early detection of hunting pressure, predation hotspots, and illegal wildlife trafficking while enhancing collaboration between scientists, conservation practitioners, and citizen observers for more effective and measurable biodiversity management. Nevertheless, the study remains limited by unequal sampling effort, observer bias, and incomplete geographic coverage related to social media platforms. Future research should integrate artificial intelligence, geospatial modeling, remote sensing, and standardized validation protocols to improve the reliability and predictive capacity of digital biodiversity monitoring systems.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript addresses a relevant and timely topic: the potential use of social media platforms as complementary tools for monitoring threatened and rare avifauna in Morocco. The study is interesting because it attempts to integrate citizen-generated digital records, spatial analysis, behavioral observations, habitat information, and reported threats. However, the manuscript requires substantial revision before it can be considered scientifically robust. The main concern is that the study frequently interprets social media records as direct evidence of abundance, population structure, habitat preference, distribution, ecological specialization, migration dynamics, and threats, without sufficiently controlling for sampling effort, observer bias, detectability, duplicate records, georeferencing uncertainty, or independent validation.
In the Abstract, the authors should clarify the nature of the data and avoid overstatement. Records extracted from social media should be described as “reported observations” or “digital records,” not as direct measures of abundance or population status. The abstract also contains inconsistencies in reported values, particularly for Geronticus eremita and Chersophilus duponti, and uses unclear statistical expressions such as mean ± standard deviation without explaining the unit of analysis. The authors should revise the abstract to distinguish platforms, sources, and record formats, and use more cautious language such as “suggest,” “indicate,” or “may complement” instead of “confirm” or “demonstrate.”
The Introduction provides a broad background on social media, but it is too general and repetitive. Several paragraphs discuss the history and general scientific value of social media without sufficiently focusing on the ecological problem addressed by the study. The authors should reduce the generic discussion and strengthen the conservation context of threatened birds in Morocco. The introduction should clearly explain the knowledge gap, justify the selection of the five species, and end with explicit objectives or research questions. Claims of methodological novelty should also be better supported by comparison with previous studies using social media, citizen science, eBird, iNaturalist, or similar biodiversity data sources.
The Methods section requires major improvement to ensure reproducibility. The criteria used to select the species are not clearly defined, and the concepts of “threatened” and “rare” are not operationally explained. The authors should provide the full list of keywords, hashtags, languages, search combinations, search dates, inclusion and exclusion criteria, and the procedure used for screening records. It is also essential to distinguish between observation date, publication date, and data extraction date. The validation protocol should be described in detail, including who verified species identification, how doubtful records were handled, how duplicates were removed, and whether independent reviewers or inter-reviewer agreement were used.
The statistical methods also need substantial clarification. The use of ANOVA for count data extracted from social media is not sufficiently justified, especially given the likely presence of unequal sampling effort, non-independence, overdispersion, and platform-specific biases. The unit of analysis must be clearly defined. The authors should consider whether generalized linear models, non-parametric tests, or other approaches would be more appropriate. In addition, Correspondence Analysis should not be described in terms of dependent and independent variables, and the percentage of variance explained should not be interpreted as evidence of credibility or ecological validity.
The Results and Discussion should be revised to avoid overinterpretation. Throughout the manuscript, digital records are treated as evidence of real abundance, population decline, population structure, habitat preference, ecological specialization, migration dynamics, and threat intensity. These interpretations are not fully supported by the methodology. The authors should consistently distinguish between “frequency of social media records” and actual ecological patterns. For example, a decline in records between years does not necessarily indicate population decline, and a higher number of records in a habitat does not demonstrate habitat preference unless habitat availability and sampling effort are considered.
The spatial analysis should also be interpreted more cautiously. Maps based on social media records show the geographic distribution of available digital observations, not necessarily the true distribution or habitat occupancy of the species. The authors should avoid terms such as “absence,” “geographical range,” “habitat occupancy,” and “habitat preference” unless supported by appropriate spatial and ecological analyses. Areas with no social media records should be described as “no records detected,” not as areas where the species is absent.
The sections on behavior and habitat use require careful revision. Activities such as migration, feeding, mating, drinking, or nesting may be difficult to infer from isolated photographs, videos, or posts unless explicit criteria are used. The authors should define how each behavioral category was assigned and acknowledge uncertainty. Similarly, claims about feeding habitat preference, strict habitat association, or ecological requirements are too strong for the type of data used. These should be reformulated as reported habitat contexts or observed associations in digital records.
The pressure/threat section contains one critical numerical error that must be corrected: the statement that predation represented “>780% of recorded cases” is impossible. This error seriously undermines confidence in the results. More broadly, the authors should avoid treating predation, hunting, mortality, and egg destruction as quantified impacts unless independently verified. The data only support discussion of the most frequently reported pressures in social media records. The distinction between natural ecological processes, such as predation, and anthropogenic pressures, such as hunting, should also be made clearer.
The Conclusion should be substantially toned down. The study may show that social media can complement biodiversity monitoring, but it does not directly demonstrate abundance, population structure, habitat preferences, ecological specialization, or real threat intensity. The authors should revise the conclusion to emphasize the exploratory and complementary nature of the approach, while clearly acknowledging limitations related to unequal sampling effort, observer bias, platform algorithms, incomplete geographic coverage, uncertain georeferencing, and incomplete validation.
Overall, the manuscript has potential, but it requires major revision. The main recommendation is to reframe the study as an analysis of social-media-based reported records rather than as a direct ecological monitoring assessment. Strengthening the methodology, correcting statistical and numerical inconsistencies, reducing overinterpretation, and clearly acknowledging the limitations of digital biodiversity data would considerably improve the scientific quality and reliability of the manuscript.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
The manuscript is generally understandable, but the quality of English requires careful revision by a fluent English speaker or professional scientific editor. Several sections contain grammatical errors, awkward phrasing, inconsistent verb tenses, repeated ideas, imprecise terminology, and non-idiomatic expressions such as “impacting factors,” “records the highest total,” and “This indicates the credibility of the results represented.” In addition, some sentences are overly long and promotional, which affects clarity and scientific tone. The manuscript would benefit from substantial language editing to improve precision, readability, coherence between sections, and the appropriate use of cautious scientific language.
Author Response
Comments from PDF
Lines 30-32: corrected as recommended.
Line 36: Abreviation: corrected.
Lines 39-40: Yes, the hunting is anthropogenic, while the predation is natural. However, this part demonstrated the impacting factors (in results and discussion, we detailed the nature of each effect)
First two paragraphs: modified as recommended.
Paragraphs 3 and 4: entirely replaced by discussion of studied parameters (diversity of Moroccan avifauna, studied ecological and conservation parameters).
Lines 117-118: improved as recommended.
Lines 127-130: we clarified that the data from social media is considered to complete the field research, not to replace it.
136-139: We recorded the conservation status of the studied species from the IUCN Red List (https://www.iucnredlist.org/) and the bibliography to clarify the importance of this study and the understanding of their current situation in Morocco.
metrics on platforms, geographical coverage, and the importance of each platform for biodiversity records:
Response: Data collection in Morocco was conducted across a diverse set of social media platforms, including Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, Telegram, X, and LinkedIn, ensuring comprehensive coverage of both informal and professional communication channels. These platforms were selected for their high user engagement and capacity to generate online, user-driven biodiversity data. Collectively exceeding 8 billion active accounts worldwide, these platforms provide extensive geographic coverage. Facebook and Instagram were valuable for photographs and citizen observations, TikTok for behavioural videos, X for real-time sightings, Telegram for specialist ornithological groups, and LinkedIn for contributions from scientists and conservation professionals. Collectively exceeding 8 billion active accounts worldwide, these platforms provide extensive geographic coverage. These platforms were selected for their high user engagement and capacity to generate online, user-driven biodiversity data.
The methods do not specify when searches were conducted, for how long, by whom, from which accounts or locations, whether searches were manual or automated, or how platform algorithms may have biased results.
Response: Clarified as recommended. (Temporal window)
Search covered content published between January 2015 and March 2025. Data collection (extraction) was done from January to April 2026, with manual research to verify the content of records by our team of ornithologists.
Lines 201-205: The data organization and analysis were clarified as recommended.
Quantitative variables related to species occurrence, temporal variation, habitat use, behavioral activities, observation forms, and platform contribution were expressed as mean ± standard deviation of digital records. Data was grouped in months for each year to avoid the interference of sampling efforts, opportunistic data, and non-normal distribution of variables. (when grouped, we avoided the zeros and the qualitative aspect of raw data). (it is possible to use non-parametric tests, but their credibility is limited compared to parametric tests).
In these analyses, bird species represented dependent variables, whereas habitats, behavioral activities, temporal categories, observation forms, and platform characteristics constituted the independent variables.
Lines 216-217: Explanation of how coordinates were recorded.
Response: done as recommended.
Geographic coordinates were extracted from embedded geotags, location labels, place names mentioned in captions or comments, and recognizable landmarks visible in images or videos.
When necessary, locations were verified and georeferenced using online mapping tools to ensure spatial accuracy and consistency.
Line 225: Percentages: yes the data from each region could be impacted by the access, number of accounts from each region, etc.
Response: The data were considered digital records and digital distribution. Percentages were used to facilitate the comparison of digital records at a regional scale: The resulting digital records were linked to the regional vector layer through an attribute joint based on a common regional identifier. To facilitate comparisons among species (spatial distribution of digital records), a standardized classification scheme was applied using five categories: absent (0%), low (≤25%), moderate (25-50%), high (50-75%), and very high (75%). These percentages were calculated as the proportion of records occurring within each region relative to the total number of records for a given species. Consequently, the assigned percentage classes represent the relative abundance and spatial concentration of digital records in each mapped region rather than actual population abundance, thereby facilitating the visualization and comparison of species occurrence patterns across Morocco.
Comment: percentages of records
Response: Yes, they can be impacted by accessibility or availability of users or their visits. This is mentioned in the interpretations. These are among the limits of the digital data, but it covers a wide range of areas compared to field research that requires investment, logistics, and time.
Comment: lines: 242-244: mean and sd
Response: clarified as recommended.
Lines 264-266: Digital data are not equivalent to field data
Response: Yes, clarified.
Lines 283-285: decline in digital data
Response: yes, the decline of digital data doesn’t mean a reduction in the abundance of birds. It is a decline in social media records.
Lines 320-322: digital records are not capable of recording migration, feeding and other features.
Response: the mentioned aspects of migration, feeding, hunting, were extracted from the comments of the users not a conclusions from publications (see the methodology).
Line 326:
Response: yes, it can be a platform for communication and sensitization.
Lines 394-396: yes, the maps present the digital distribution of social media records, but they also reflect the geographical range of birds, since they are based on geotagged and georeferenced publications.
Lines 444-445: yes.
Line 469: corrected.
Line 473-475: yes.
Lines 483-489: Yes, explained as recommended.
Lines 505-508: yes, but they are in agreement with field research. For example, Mansouri Ismail wrote a thesis on Turtle doves and recorded the impact of hunting and predation. Similarly, digital records demonstrated the higher impacts of predation and hunting.
Lines 529-538: yes, mentioned in the limits.
543-555: the entire conclusion was improved as recommended.
The manuscript addresses a relevant and timely topic: the potential use of social media platforms as complementary tools for monitoring threatened and rare avifauna in Morocco. The study is interesting because it attempts to integrate citizen-generated digital records, spatial analysis, behavioral observations, habitat information, and reported threats. However, the manuscript requires substantial revision before it can be considered scientifically robust. The main concern is that the study frequently interprets social media records as direct evidence of abundance, population structure, habitat preference, distribution, ecological specialization, migration dynamics, and threats, without sufficiently controlling for sampling effort, observer bias, detectability, duplicate records, georeferencing uncertainty, or independent validation.
Response: Thank you for this corrective comment. We addressed these concerns in all sections, including the introduction, methodology, results, discussion, limitations, and conclusion. See the manuscript and responses to the comments of reviewers 1 and 2.
In the Abstract, the authors should clarify the nature of the data and avoid overstatement. Records extracted from social media should be described as “reported observations” or “digital records,” not as direct measures of abundance or population status. The abstract also contains inconsistencies in reported values, particularly for Geronticus eremita and Chersophilus duponti, and uses unclear statistical expressions such as mean ± standard deviation without explaining the unit of analysis. The authors should revise the abstract to distinguish platforms, sources, and record formats, and use more cautious language such as “suggest,” “indicate,” or “may complement” instead of “confirm” or “demonstrate.”
Response: done as recommended.
This study evaluated social media platforms as complementary tools for monitoring threatened and rare bird species in Morocco from 2015 to 2025. Records were extracted from groups, pages, videos, photographs, and ornithological publications based on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, X, LinkedIn, Telegram platforms. Multi-language and validation criteria were used to standardize records, then data were analyzed and mapped to assess spatio-temporal dynamics, habitat preferences, and threatening factors. Results revealed significant interspecific differences (p<0.001), with dominance of Streptopelia turtur turtur (250±48.35 records), followed by Geronticus eremita and C. duponti (222.15±26.58 records), A. paludicola, and C. undulata. Adults dominated records (851.54±364.70 records), while eggs and chicks were weakly recorded. Records were mostly photographs and were from Facebook. Digital records were higher in March and April. Spatial records highlighted ecological specialization, G. eremita in Souss Massa and C. undulata in southeastern desert ecosystems. Results showed associations with steppes, riparian, agricultural, and semi-desert mosaics depending on recorded species. Predation (50±3.54 records) and hunting (49±13.44 records) were the main factors affecting, particularly in S. t. turtur (22.22% and 52.38% of records) and C. undulata (31.25% and 62.5%). The identified habitats and threats provide actionable indicators for prioritizing protection, monitoring, and targeted mitigation measures. These findings show that social media can support passive citizen science and contribute to conservation planning and large-scale ecological monitoring of threatened avifauna. However, future research needs to combine field and digital investigations to reduce biases and present a more comprehensive picture of threatened birds.
The introduction provides a broad background on social media, but it is too general and repetitive. Several paragraphs discuss the history and general scientific value of social media without sufficiently focusing on the ecological problem addressed by the study.
Response: done as recommended. We modified entire paragraphs to discuss the parameters studied in our results, including ecology, habitats, distribution, and conservation.
Equally, social media platforms can monitor and map wild species such as the Mediterranean monk seal (Monachus monachus), in Porto Santo and Madeira, Portugal (Castro and Capinha 2026). The recorded digital data were then used to model the spatial distribution in a highly human-habituated area. Beyond communication, social media has become an essential tool in scientific research, supporting knowledge exchange, academic collaboration, and educational outreach, particularly in specialized fields such as medicine [6], conservation (Dehm et al 2025), and ornithology (Saito et al 2015). In the ornithology field, Spennemann (2025) used Facebook to monitor bird species that feed on the nectar or seeds of Strelitzia reginae and S. nicolai in Australia. These demonstrate the capacity of social platforms to monitor specialized species and the feeding behaviour of birds. However, more attention needs to be paid to research methodology biases (Spennemann 2025).
Social media platforms have emerged as valuable complementary tools for biodiversity monitoring, providing large volumes of user-generated data that can support ecological and conservation research at broad spatial and temporal scales (Chamberlain et al 2018, Otero et al 2024). Platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Flickr, Twitter (X), and YouTube allow researchers to access photographs, videos, comments, and georeferenced observations that document species occurrence, behavior, habitat use, and human–wildlife interactions (Chamberlain, 2018). In ornithological studies, social media data have been successfully applied to monitor bird diversity, distributional dynamics, habitat preferences, migration phenology, breeding activity, and conservation threats affecting both common and endangered species (Hausmann et al., 2019; O’Neill et al., 2023). Recent investigations have demonstrated the usefulness of these platforms for assessing bird behavior and population trends through crowdsourced observations (Spennemann, 2025), while also identifying anthropogenic pressures such as illegal trade, hunting, and habitat disturbance (Elkhouri-Vidarte et al., 2023). Furthermore, the integration of social media records enables the simultaneous evaluation of ecological preferences, spatial distribution patterns, temporal fluctuations, and impacting factors across multiple species. Nevertheless, social media data presents important methodological limitations. Records are often concentrated in accessible and highly populated areas, generating geographical and taxonomic biases, while species detectability depends on observer interest and platform popularity (Mondal & Rehena, 2022). In addition, algorithm-driven content visibility may influence data availability and representativeness (Greene et al., 2022). Consequently, social media observations should be considered complementary rather than substitutes for standardized field surveys and long-term ecological monitoring programs.
The authors should reduce the generic discussion and strengthen the conservation context of threatened birds in Morocco. The introduction should clearly explain the knowledge gap, justify the selection of the five species, and end with explicit objectives or research questions. Claims of methodological novelty should also be better supported by comparison with previous studies using social media, citizen science, eBird, iNaturalist, or similar biodiversity data sources.
Response: done as recommended. We concentrated on the use of digital data in conservation, and we discussed examples and limits related to methodology biases. Then we discussed the biodiversity in Morocco, and we concentrated on birds to clarify the importance of selected species and the merit of the study. We added new references.
Social media platforms and region-specific networks have become increasingly important tools for biodiversity conservation by generating large volumes of digital ecological information (Aravind, 2013; Büscher, 2016). These platforms facilitate the identification of threatening factors affecting wildlife. For example, social media records have documented illegal hunting of migratory birds, disturbance of breeding colonies, habitat degradation, wildlife trade, road mortality, and predation events involving threatened species (Wu et al., 2020; Chowdhury et al., 2024). Such digital observations provide digital and georeferenced information that can support conservation planning by identifying priority areas, monitoring emerging threats, detecting changes in species distributions, and guiding adaptive management strategies (Fox et al., 2022; Chowdhury et al., 2024). Moreover, digital approaches are particularly valuable in developing countries where financial resources, technical infrastructure, and field-survey capacity are often limited. By exploiting freely available online data, conservation practitioners can reduce logistical costs while expanding spatial and temporal monitoring coverage (Bires & Raj, 2021). However, their dual role requires careful management, as they may simultaneously present biases in data collection (loss of microhabitat details and surrounding climatic conditions) and facilitate harmful activities. Overall, social media constitutes a valuable tool for integrating citizen science, improving biodiversity monitoring, and strengthening evidence-based conservation planning in combination with field research [23]
Morocco is recognized as one of the major biodiversity hotspots of the Mediterranean region, encompassing a remarkable diversity of ecosystems ranging from Atlantic and Mediterranean coasts, wetlands, forests, steppes, mountains, and desert landscapes to oasis environments (Menioui, 2018; Arabi et al., 2024). This ecological heterogeneity supports rich plant communities, including diverse wetland and terrestrial floras that provide essential food resources, nesting substrates, shelter, and migration stopovers for numerous animal species, particularly birds (Khabbach et al., 2020; Ennabili et al., 2025). Moroccan avifauna includes a wide range of resident, migratory, and globally threatened species inhabiting wetlands, forests, steppes, and arid ecosystems (Cherkaoui et al., 2015; Mansouri et al., 2021). Notable threatened birds include the Northern Bald Ibis (Geronticus eremita), Houbara Bustard (Chlamydotis undulata), Dupont’s Lark (Chersophilus duponti), Marbled Teal (Marmaronetta angustirostris), Ferruginous Duck (Ferruginous duck), and European Turtle Dove (Streptopelia turtur turtur), whose populations are affected by habitat degradation, water scarcity, agricultural intensification, climate change, hunting pressure, predation, and human disturbance (Garcia et al., 2008; Alonso et al., 2016; Ouassou et al., 2021; Mansouri et al., 2022). Nevertheless, most Moroccan ornithological investigations have focused on relatively abundant or easily detectable species and have relied almost exclusively on conventional field surveys (Squalli et al., 2024). Consequently, rare, elusive, and highly threatened birds remain insufficiently documented. In this context, digital tools, particularly social media and other citizen-generated data sources, offer promising complementary approaches for monitoring poorly known species, expanding spatial coverage, reducing logistical constraints, and supporting conservation decision-making at national scales.
The species selected represent diverse ecological guilds and conservation statuses, reflecting Morocco’s importance as a breeding, wintering, and migratory refuge. The European turtle dove (Streptopelia turtur turtur) was included as a reference species because its ecology, distribution, and population dynamics have been extensively documented through field-based research in Morocco, allowing comparisons between conventional survey results and social media–derived observations. In contrast, the Northern bald ibis (Geronticus eremita), Houbara bustard (Chlamydotis undulata), Dupont’s lark (Chersophilus duponti), and Aquatic warbler (Acrocephalus paludicola) remain relatively understudied, particularly regarding large-scale monitoring, population trends, behavioral ecology, and threat assessment. Consequently, these species provide an ideal framework for evaluating the potential of digital data sources to complement traditional field surveys, fill important knowledge gaps, improve spatial and temporal coverage, and support the conservation of rare and threatened bird species.
The Methods section requires major improvement to ensure reproducibility. The criteria used to select the species are not clearly defined, and the concepts of “threatened” and “rare” are not operationally explained. The authors should provide the full list of keywords, hashtags, languages, search combinations, search dates, inclusion and exclusion criteria, and the procedure used for screening records. It is also essential to distinguish between observation date, publication date, and data extraction date.
Response: done as recommended.
Examples included Streptopelia turtur, turtle dove, tourterelle des bois, اليمامة المطوقة, migration, nesting, breeding, hunting, poaching, predation, mortality, conservation, and equivalent multilingual expressions. Similar search combinations were applied to Geronticus eremita, Chlamydotis undulata, Chersophilus duponti, and Acrocephalus paludicola, using both species-specific and threat-related hashtags (e.g., #TurtleDove, #NorthernBaldIbis, #Houbara, #DupontsLark, #AquaticWarbler, #BirdConservation, #Migration, #Hunting). Search covered content published between January 2015 and March 2025. Screening followed a three-step procedure: (i) preliminary retrieval through keywords and hashtags, (ii) verification of species identity using textual descriptions and available photographs or videos, and (iii) assessment of geographic relevance to Morocco. Records were excluded when species identification was uncertain, locality information was absent, content was duplicated across platforms, or posts were unrelated to the target taxa. Three temporal variables were recorded separately whenever available: observation date (date of species occurrence), publication date (date of online posting), and data extraction date (date of retrieval by researchers), thereby distinguishing biological observations from digital publication and sampling processes.
Data sources were categorized into four main types: individual observers, public pages, thematic groups, and official institutional websites. Each retrieved record was screened against predefined inclusion criteria. Extracted data included the type of content (species name mention, photo, video, or publication), as well as ecological and behavioral information (e.g., observation, feeding, nesting, migration, resting, drinking, mating). Additional variables related to anthropogenic and natural pressures were recorded, including hunting, mortality, predation, and other disturbance factors. This classification enabled a comprehensive assessment of both species occurrence and associated threats within digital environments.
The validation protocol should be described in detail, including who verified species identification, how doubtful records were handled, how duplicates were removed, and whether independent reviewers or inter-reviewer agreement were used.
Response: done as recommended. We added new subsection for Data clearance and validation
The statistical methods also need substantial clarification. The use of ANOVA for count data extracted from social media is not sufficiently justified, especially given the likely presence of unequal sampling effort, non-independence, overdispersion, and platform-specific biases. The unit of analysis must be clearly defined. The authors should consider whether generalized linear models, non-parametric tests, or other approaches would be more appropriate.
Response: Thank you for the comment. Data was grouped in months for each year to avoid the interference of sampling efforts, opportunistic data, and non-normal distribution of variables.
In addition, Correspondence Analysis should not be described in terms of dependent and independent variables, and the percentage of variance explained should not be interpreted as evidence of credibility or ecological validity.
Response: In these analyses, bird species represented dependent variables, whereas habitats, behavioral activities, temporal categories, observation forms, and platform characteristics constituted the independent variables.
The Results and Discussion should be revised to avoid overinterpretation. Throughout the manuscript, digital records are treated as evidence of real abundance, population decline, population structure, habitat preference, ecological specialization, migration dynamics, and threat intensity. These interpretations are not fully supported by the methodology. The authors should consistently distinguish between “frequency of social media records” and actual ecological patterns. For example, a decline in records between years does not necessarily indicate population decline, and a higher number of records in a habitat does not demonstrate habitat preference unless habitat availability and sampling effort are considered.
Response: done as recommended.
The spatial analysis should also be interpreted more cautiously. Maps based on social media records show the geographic distribution of available digital observations, not necessarily the true distribution or habitat occupancy of the species. The authors should avoid terms such as “absence,” “geographical range,” “habitat occupancy,” and “habitat preference” unless supported by appropriate spatial and ecological analyses. Areas with no social media records should be described as “no records detected,” not as areas where the species is absent.
Response: done as recommended.
The sections on behavior and habitat use require careful revision. Activities such as migration, feeding, mating, drinking, or nesting may be difficult to infer from isolated photographs, videos, or posts unless explicit criteria are used. The authors should define how each behavioral category was assigned and acknowledge uncertainty. Similarly, claims about feeding habitat preference, strict habitat association, or ecological requirements are too strong for the type of data used. These should be reformulated as reported habitat contexts or observed associations in digital records.
Response: Thank you for your comments. To extract exact date we separated dates of publication and date of field photograph by the observer. In terms of behaviour, we noted the sequence based on the comment of the observer not only from the photograph. In terms of habitats, habitats were recorded from pictures, videos, post content, and the comments of the observer. We neglected publications with unclear content.
Example:
The pressure/threat section contains one critical numerical error that must be corrected: the statement that predation represented “>780% of recorded cases” is impossible. This error seriously undermines confidence in the results.
Response: Corrected as recommended.
(>78% of recorded cases (only mistake in writing)
If you need raw data, we can send it to you for verification.
More broadly, the authors should avoid treating predation, hunting, mortality, and egg destruction as quantified impacts unless independently verified.
Response: All presented data were verified. The abundance of predation is due to the abundance of hunting pages (See the example):
The data only support the discussion of the most frequently reported pressures in social media records. The distinction between natural ecological processes, such as predation, and anthropogenic pressures, such as hunting, should also be made clearer.
Response:
The Conclusion should be substantially toned down. The study may show that social media can complement biodiversity monitoring, but it does not directly demonstrate abundance, population structure, habitat preferences, ecological specialization, or real threat intensity. The authors should revise the conclusion to emphasize the exploratory and complementary nature of the approach, while clearly acknowledging limitations related to unequal sampling effort, observer bias, platform algorithms, incomplete geographic coverage, uncertain georeferencing, and incomplete validation.
Overall, the manuscript has potential, but it requires major revision. The main recommendation is to reframe the study as an analysis of social-media-based reported records rather than as a direct ecological monitoring assessment. Strengthening the methodology, correcting statistical and numerical inconsistencies, reducing overinterpretation, and clearly acknowledging the limitations of digital biodiversity data would considerably improve the scientific quality and reliability of the manuscript.
Comments on the Quality of English Language
The manuscript is generally understandable, but the quality of English requires careful revision by a fluent English speaker or professional scientific editor. Several sections contain grammatical errors, awkward phrasing, inconsistent verb tenses, repeated ideas, imprecise terminology, and non-idiomatic expressions such as “impacting factors,” “records the highest total,” and “This indicates the credibility of the results represented.” In addition, some sentences are overly long and promotional, which affects clarity and scientific tone. The manuscript would benefit from substantial language editing to improve precision, readability, coherence between sections, and the appropriate use of cautious scientific language.
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThank you for your careful and comprehensive revisions. You have addressed my major concerns satisfactorily, and I believe the manuscript has been substantially improved. I have no further comments.
Author Response
thank you for your time and comment
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe revised manuscript is greatly improved with the detailed corrections by the authors. However, there are still a lot of language and editorial glitches that need to be corrected. Here I have listed some of the more glaring ones but the whole manuscript needs to be professionally edited to reduce redundancies, correct phrases and terminology, and edit for grammar and flow of text.
Line 94-97 – the sentence ends abruptly and is unfinished.
Paragraph in lines 155-170 – requires appropriate references to back up the claims.
Please refrain from using these sentence structures “……is presented in Figure 2A.” or “Figure 2B illustrates the distribution…..”. Please state the sentence and add these at the end. For example combine the first two sentences and end as (Fig. 2A). Correct throughout manuscript for consistency.
Line 443 “Despite the importance of previous studies in clarifying …..” Please cite these references.
Line 494 – Please replace “At the end, …..” with a more appropriate term.
Line 616 – same as above “From another angle,……”
Line 685 – “Unlike previous Moroccan research that has rarely….” Please cite these references.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageSee above.
Author Response
The revised manuscript is greatly improved with the detailed corrections by the authors. However, there are still a lot of language and editorial glitches that need to be corrected. Here I have listed some of the more glaring ones but the whole manuscript needs to be professionally edited to reduce redundancies, correct phrases and terminology, and edit for grammar and flow of text.
Line 94-97 – the sentence ends abruptly and is unfinished.
Comment: complemented.
User-generated content, including geotagged images and observations, provides valuable ecological data that can complement traditional monitoring methods, enabling researchers to map species distributions and detect population trends in an online manner, and then use the data to define threatening factors [18,19]
Paragraph in lines 155-170 – requires appropriate references to back up the claims.
Response: done as recommended:
O'Neill, D., Häkkinen, H., Neumann, J., Shaffrey, L., Cheffings, C., Norris, K., & Pettorelli, N. (2023). Investigating the potential of social media and citizen science data to track changes in species' distributions. Ecology and Evolution, 13(5), e10063.
Forti, L. R., da Silva, J. L. C., Ferreira, E. A., & Szabo, J. K. (2024). The implications of estimating rarity in Brazilian reptiles from GBIF data based on contributions from citizen science versus research institutions. Integrative Conservation, 3(2), 112-126.
Kwon, H., Seo, B., Kim, J., & Lee, H. (2025). Crowdsourced indicators of flora and fauna species: comparisons between iNaturalist records and field observations. Land, 14(1), 169.
Please refrain from using these sentence structures “……is presented in Figure 2A.” or “Figure 2B illustrates the distribution…..”. Please state the sentence and add these at the end. For example combine the first two sentences and end as (Fig. 2A). Correct throughout manuscript for consistency.
Response: done as recommended:
Line 443 “Despite the importance of previous studies in clarifying …..” Please cite these references.
Response: added as recommended.
Line 494 – Please replace “At the end, …..” with a more appropriate term.
Response: done as recommended.
Line 616 – same as above “From another angle,……”
Response: done as recommended.
Line 685 – “Unlike previous Moroccan research that has rarely….” Please cite these references.
Response: done as recommended.
References
O'Neill, D., Häkkinen, H., Neumann, J., Shaffrey, L., Cheffings, C., Norris, K., & Pettorelli, N. (2023). Investigating the potential of social media and citizen science data to track changes in species' distributions. Ecology and Evolution, 13(5), e10063.
Forti, L. R., da Silva, J. L. C., Ferreira, E. A., & Szabo, J. K. (2024). The implications of estimating rarity in Brazilian reptiles from GBIF data based on contributions from citizen science versus research institutions. Integrative Conservation, 3(2), 112-126.
Kwon, H., Seo, B., Kim, J., & Lee, H. (2025). Crowdsourced indicators of flora and fauna species: comparisons between iNaturalist records and field observations. Land, 14(1), 169.
Mansouri, I., Ousaaid, D., Squalli, W., El Agy, A., El-Hassani, A., Mounir, M., ... & Dakki, M. (2021). New data on migration time, breeding phenology, and breeding success of European turtle doves in their highest breeding habitats in North Africa. International Journal of Zoology, 2021(1), 6629285.
Browne, S. J., & Aebischer, N. J. (2003). Temporal changes in the migration phenology of turtle doves Streptopelia turtur in Britain, based on sightings from coastal bird observatories. Journal of Avian Biology, 34(1), 65-71.
Flade, M., Lisovski, S., Eigirdas, V., Giessing, B., Jiguet, F., Keišs, O., & Nemtchinov, M. (2023). Migration routes and wintering sites of the Aquatic Warblers Acrocephalus paludicola breeding in Lithuania and North Belarus. bioRxiv, 2023-10.
Hingrat, Y., Jalme, M. S., Ysnel, F., Lacroix, F., Seabury, J., & Rautureau, P. (2004). Relationships between home‐range size, sex and season with reference to the mating system of the houbara bustard Chlamydotis undulata undulata. Ibis, 146(2), 314-322.
Pérez-Granados, C., López-Iborra, G. M., Garza, V., & Traba, J. (2017). Breeding biology of the endangered Dupont’s Lark Chersophilus duponti in two separate Spanish shrub-steppes. Bird Study, 64(3), 328-338.
Mansouri, I., Ousaaid, D., Squalli, W., Sqalli, H., El Ghadraoui, L., & Dakki, M. (2020). The turtle dove (Streptopelia turtur) in Midelt plain, Morocco: nesting preferences and breeding success versus the impact of predation and agricultural practices. Journal of Animal Behaviour and Biometeorology, 8(3), 206-214.
Hanane, S. (2017). The European turtle-dove Streptopelia turtur in Northwest Africa: a review of current knowledge and priorities for future research. Ardeola, 64(2), 273-287.
Cuttelod, A., García, N., Malak, D. A., Temple, H. J., & Katariya, V. (2009). The Mediterranean: a biodiversity hotspot under threat. Wildlife in a Changing World–an analysis of the 2008 IUCN Red List of Threatened Species, 89(9), 1-4.
Bowden, C. G., Smith, K. W., El Bekkay, M., Oubrou, W., Aghnaj, A., & Jimenez-Armesto, M. (2008). Contribution of research to conservation action for the Northern Bald Ibis Geronticus eremita in Morocco. Bird Conservation International, 18(S1), S74-S90.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsI appreciate the authors for adequately addressing the comments raised during the previous round of review. The revised manuscript is noticeably more coherent, with a much better alignment between the methodology, the results, and the discussion. Several sections have been clarified, methodological descriptions have been strengthened, and the interpretation of the findings is now more consistent with the data presented. Overall, the revisions have substantially improved the clarity and internal consistency of the manuscript.
Author Response
thenk you for your time and comment