Skip to Content
HeritageHeritage
  • Article
  • Open Access

20 November 2026

72 Pages

New Building Design and Conservation Development Plan Provisions in Historic Environments: A Comparative Case Study from Ürgüp, Cappadocia, Türkiye

,
and
1
Faculty of Architecture, Niğde Ömer Halisdemir University, Niğde 51240, Türkiye
2
Faculty of Fine Arts and Architecture, Necmettin Erbakan University, Konya 42040, Türkiye
3
Institute of Science, Niğde Ömer Halisdemir University, Niğde 51240, Türkiye
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
This article belongs to the Section Architectural Heritage

Abstract

New building design in historic urban areas requires an understanding of how contemporary needs can be accommodated while retaining the spatial and architectural characteristics of the historic setting. This study examines how the provisions of the Ürgüp Conservation Development Plan relate to two completed developments within the Ürgüp Urban Conservation Area in Cappadocia, Türkiye. Located on Parcels 1 and 13, each development comprises two principal building masses. Together, they represent all completed new developments within the selected block at the time of fieldwork. The comparative case study combines systematic document analysis, dimensioned architectural drawings, field observations, and block-scale spatial analyses to examine parcel layout, massing, street relationships, façade composition, materials, and architectural details. The plan combines measurable conditions with explicit requirements for contextual compatibility and recognisably contemporary design. Both developments incorporate local architectural references, evident in projecting bays, window surrounds, parapets, and arched balconies, but differ in the placement, repetition, and prominence of these elements. Although both developments share the same floor arrangement, the sloping terrain exposes the basements on Parcel 1 along Karağandere Street, whereas only the ground and first floors are visible on the examined façades of Parcel 13. In the second mass on Parcel 1, ground-floor opening ratios range from 16.20% on Karağandere Street to 27.61% on the western commercial façade. Differences in project context and incomplete revision records limit causal attribution. The findings support site-specific design guidance that clarifies measurement conventions, illustrates local architectural relationships, and documents the reasoning behind assessments of compatibility and contemporary expression.

1. Introduction

Historic environments constitute multi-layered heritage sites that convey the cultural, social, and spatial legacies of past societies to the present, reflecting the modes of habitation and architectural production characteristic of different historical periods [1] (pp. 90–91), [2] (pp. 10–13), [3] (p. 24), [4]. Their conservation encompasses not only the physical integrity of individual buildings but also the continuity of urban fabric, spatial character, silhouettes, material practices, and cultural identities formed over time [5] (p. 22), [6] (pp. 3–7). At the same time, historic environments are inhabited places that change in response to societal needs, economic conditions, population movements, and evolving patterns of use [7] (pp. 90–94). Demands for accommodation, commerce, housing, and services can generate pressure for both the adaptation of existing buildings and new construction. Managing these changes while sustaining heritage values remains a central concern of architectural conservation [2,8,9] (pp. 15–16).
New building design within historic environments requires consideration of inherited spatial characteristics and contemporary requirements. New interventions are expected to respect the significance and character of their surroundings while accommodating present-day uses and expressing their status as recent additions to the built environment [10,11] (pp. 29–34, 64–69). This involves relationships among conservation principles, planning provisions, site conditions, building programmes, and design decisions [12] (pp. 6–10). Understanding the historical, cultural, and spatial characteristics of a setting is therefore essential to establishing meaningful relationships between new architecture and the existing environment [13,14] (p. 43).
The international literature discusses these relationships through approaches including replication, compatibility, interpretation, continuity, and deliberate contrast [15,16,17,18]. These approaches offer perspectives for examining interventions, although their boundaries are not necessarily exclusive. A building may combine traditional details, contemporary construction systems, familiar materials, and new spatial arrangements. Its relationship with the historic environment consequently requires examination across several scales, including massing, proportion, rhythm, material expression, urban fabric, and spatial continuity [2,19] (pp. 3–11). The presence of a traditional architectural element alone does not establish contextual compatibility, just as formal contrast does not independently demonstrate the appropriateness of an interventionn.
Research on conservation and contemporary architectural practice also connects these concerns to sustainability. Studies of adaptive reuse emphasize the potential contribution of continued building use to cultural continuity and environmental, economic, and social sustainability [20,21,22]. Although adaptive reuse and independent new construction involve different interventions, both address the accommodation of contemporary needs within inherited environments. Research on Heritage Impact Assessment, design processes, and decision-making further directs attention to the implications of interventions for heritage values and their settings [23,24,25]. In their study of new exterior additions to historic buildings, Yüceer and İpekoğlu examine environmental relationships, building–lot relationships, massing, and façade composition [26]. While independent new buildings present a different intervention type, these dimensions offer relevant perspectives for architectural comparison. Discussions of compatibility likewise emphasize relationships with the characteristic qualities of a setting rather than visual resemblance alone [27]. Traditional design approaches remain legitimate within this debate; their evaluation requires an explanation of how particular architectural choices relate to the surrounding context.
International conservation documents provide reference points at different scales and for different intervention types [28] (pp. 7–24). The Venice Charter (1964) [29] addresses conservation and restoration, including the replacement of missing parts and additions to monuments. Its provisions concerning distinguishability should be interpreted within this scope rather than treated as a universal requirement for stylistic contrast in all independent new buildings. The Washington Charter (1987) [30] addresses historic towns and urban areas, emphasizing existing spatial layouts, scale, and relationships when introducing new construction. The Xi’an Declaration [31] extends attention to the settings of heritage structures, sites, and areas, while the Valletta Principles (2011) [32] address the management of change in historic towns and urban areas. Together, these documents support consideration of intervention type, setting, and relationships with the existing fabric [33] (pp. 747–760).
The translation of conservation principles into practice depends on the planning instruments, institutional responsibilities, and regulatory provisions operating in particular jurisdictions. These arrangements differ between countries and localities, even where they address shared conservation concerns. Conservation planning in Türkiye should therefore be considered within the wider discussion of how heritage objectives are translated into locally applicable development conditions. Conservation Development Plans (CDPs) provide a principal framework for development within designated conservation areas [34], alongside decisions by the competent conservation authorities. Their provisions may address development intensity, building height, façade composition, materials, roof forms, and architectural details. Madran and Özgönül (2005) discuss the extension of conservation planning provisions into architectural design and the possibility of standardized solutions, while emphasizing contemporary responses grounded in an understanding of the historic environment [35]. This raises questions about the relationship between regulatory specificity, contextual interpretation, and the range of architectural solutions possible within a local planning framework.
The present study focuses on the relationship between individual plan provisions and the documented architectural characteristics of completed developments. This inquiry complements research tracing proposals through submission, revision, approval, rejection, suspension, and construction. Process-based investigations can explain the reasons underlying decisions, whereas studies of completed developments establish how specified requirements relate to the characteristics of completed buildings. The latter requires explicit connections between regulatory provisions, architectural documentation, and field evidence. It also requires measurable conditions to be distinguished from qualitative expectations: correspondence with a dimensional limit does not, by itself, establish contextual compatibility or the perceived contemporaneity of a design.
Ürgüp, in Türkiye’s Cappadocia Region, provides the local setting for this investigation. Rock-cut spaces, stone architecture, and settlement forms associated with the region’s topography constitute important elements of its architectural context. Cappadocia also contains the UNESCO World Heritage property Göreme National Park and the Rock Sites of Cappadocia. The present study concerns the Ürgüp Urban Conservation Area and examines its specific local planning context. The coexistence of traditional buildings, accommodation and commercial uses, and new construction makes this setting relevant to investigating the relationship between conservation provisions and architectural change [36].
The study examines two completed developments on Parcels 1 and 13 in Block 1467 in the Karağandere neighbourhood. Their shared historic setting provides a basis for comparing how their documented architectural characteristics relate to the Ürgüp CDP provisions [37]. Particular attention is given to the plan’s requirement that new designs refer to local architectural characteristics while remaining compatible with their surroundings and recognisably contemporary.
The main research question is: “How do the documented architectural characteristics of new buildings on two parcels within the same historic setting relate to the measurable conditions and qualitative design principles of the relevant Conservation Development Plan?” This question is addressed through three subquestions:
(i)
What measurable conditions and qualitative design expectations are defined by the relevant plan provisions?
(ii)
In what respects do the documented architectural characteristics of the two cases correspond to or differ from these provisions?
(iii)
How are local architectural references expressed through massing, façade composition, materials, and architectural elements in relation to the plan’s principles of compatibility and contemporary expression?
The research adopts a comparative case-study approach combining document analysis, architectural documentation, field observations, and block-scale spatial analyses. It examines completed architectural outcomes without reconstructing the full approval histories or attributing particular design decisions to institutional requests. Architectural characteristics are compared through common criteria, without assigning overall “replicative” or “interpretive” classifications. The involvement of the designer of Parcel 1 as a co-author, as well as its implications for the assessment, are addressed in the Methodology section and conflict-of-interest disclosure.
The study contributes a comparison linking individual planning provisions to architectural evidence at parcel, building, and detail scales. It distinguishes correspondence with particular requirements from broader judgments of architectural compatibility and identifies where measurement conventions, documented local examples, and explanatory guidance could support the application of existing principles. Its wider relevance lies in making the relationship between conservation provisions and architectural evidence explicit, while retaining the particular spatial and regulatory conditions of the Ürgüp cases.

2. Literature Review

2.1. New Building Design and Contextual Relationships in Historic Environments

Historic environments embody social, cultural, economic, and spatial layers accumulated over successive periods [38]. Their significance extends beyond individual monuments to include street patterns, parcel configurations, topography, open spaces, material characteristics, and relationships among buildings. Conservation involves sustaining these relationships while accommodating changing uses and social needs [39] (p. 206). Where tourism, commerce, and housing generate development pressures, the relationship between new construction and the existing fabric becomes particularly important [40] (pp. 50–51), [41].
New building design engages with an existing context through scale, massing, proportion, rhythm, silhouette, materials, and spatial continuity [2,42] (pp. 92–93). These relationships operate at several scales. At the urban scale, they concern building placement, street definition, open spaces, and views. At the building scale, they involve the organization of masses, façades, and openings. At the detail scale, they concern architectural elements, surface treatments, and constructional expression. Correspondence at one scale does not necessarily establish compatibility at another: stone façades, for example, do not by themselves explain a building’s relationship with neighbouring masses or the street silhouette.
Contextual relationships therefore require examination through identifiable architectural characteristics. Traditional elements may be reproduced, simplified, rearranged, or combined with different spatial and constructional solutions. Conversely, a visually differentiated building may retain relationships with local scale, rhythm, or parcel structure. These possibilities support an assessment that considers the arrangement and relationships of architectural features rather than treating stylistic resemblance as a sufficient measure of compatibility.

2.2. Design Approaches and Their Relevance to Vernacular Settings

International conservation documents address interventions at different scales. The Venice Charter [29], concerns the conservation and restoration of monuments, including additions and the replacement of missing parts. The Amsterdam Declaration [43] and the UNESCO Nairobi Recommendation [44] extend attention to integrated conservation and historic areas, while the Washington Charter [30] addresses urban layouts, scale, and relationships within historic towns. These documents provide principles for considering interventions without prescribing a single architectural language for every setting.
The relationship between resemblance and differentiation has been discussed through several classifications. Drawing on Erkartal and Özüer (2016) [45], Tanaç (2010) [2] and related studies, five approaches are reviewed here: stylistic imitation, traditional reinterpretation, a respectful approach, abstract reference, and contrast [2] (pp. 65–68), [45,46,47], [48] (p. 147), [49,50,51,52,53,54,55,56] (Figure 1). These approaches provide a theoretical background for the discussion rather than the classification system applied to the study cases (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Design approaches to new buildings in historic settings. Adapted from Erkartal and Özüer [45] and synthesized by the authors. The approaches represent positions discussed in the literature and are not used to classify the cases examined in this study. The yellow-to-red gradient indicates the progression from imitation toward disregard for the historic context (Tables prepared by the authors.)
Stylistic imitation emphasizes the reproduction of historical forms and details. Traditional reinterpretation retains recognizable references while modifying their composition or expression. A respectful approach seeks a restrained relationship with the existing setting, whereas abstract reference draws on characteristics such as proportion, rhythm, texture, or material. Contrast emphasizes differentiation between the intervention and its surroundings [56] (pp. 395–396), [57,58]. These approaches may overlap within the same building, and their appropriateness depends on the intervention and its context.
Sack [59] presents contrast as a means of distinguishing contemporary interventions from historical fabric. This position does not make contrast universally preferable. In vernacular settings, the continued use of familiar materials, architectural elements, and building practices may contribute to cultural continuity. Traditional design approaches should therefore be examined through their specific architectural relationships rather than be treated as inherently less legitimate than contrasting interventions.
Table 1 presents four examples of contemporary architecture within established village or historic urban settings: Atelier Bardill in Scharans [60], the Jerwood Gallery in Hastings [61], the Inujima Art House Project [62], and B2 House in Büyükhüsun [63]. These examples illustrate different ways in which contemporary interventions respond to local settlement patterns, building forms, and materials. Their relevance to Ürgüp lies in these architectural relationships, although their programmes, scales, and regulatory contexts differ from those of the two developments examined here.
Table 1. Selected architectural references in village and historic urban settings. (Table prepared by the authors.)
Examples such as Moderna Museet Malmö [64,65] (pp. 102–109), the Museum Hotel in Antakya [66], Odunpazarı Modern Museum [67], Beyazıt State Library [68], and Santral İstanbul [69] extend the discussion to museum, archaeological, library, and industrial settings, although their scales and functions limit direct comparison with the Ürgüp cases.
For the present study, comparison focuses on features such as window surrounds, parapets, cornices, arched compositions, entrances, and projections. Relationships with local examples are described through form, position, proportion, repetition, and material expression. Formal similarity does not establish that a specific precedent was intentionally copied, nor does reduced ornamentation independently establish contemporary expression. Consistent with the urban-scale concerns of the Washington Charter [30] and the Valletta Principles [32], these details are considered alongside massing, parcel structure, and street relationships.

2.3. Conservation Instruments and the Regulation of New Building Design

In Türkiye, new construction within historic environments is assessed through conservation legislation, planning provisions, administrative procedures, and decisions by competent authorities [70] (pp. 292–313), [71] (pp. 62–68), [72]. Law No. 2863 on the Conservation of Cultural and Natural Assets provides a principal legal basis for the protection of cultural assets and conservation areas [73]. Within this framework, Conservation Development Plans establish area-specific development and intervention conditions [34]. Their provisions may address land use, development intensity, height, setbacks, façade organization, roofs, materials, and architectural details.
Institutional responsibilities and assessment procedures depend on conservation status, location, the applicable framework, and the date of assessment. For the Cappadocia cases, the responsible authority and relevant documents must therefore be identified for each project. Table 2 distinguishes the principal functions and documentary evidence associated with project assessment and implementation. It provides a framework for understanding the evidence required to investigate these processes rather than reconstructing the approval histories of the two cases.
Table 2. Principal functions and documentary evidence associated with new-building assessment and implementation in historic environments. (Table prepared by the authors.)
Conservation provisions require different forms of architectural evidence. Numerical limits can be examined through dimensions and area calculations. Material and detail requirements require specifications, drawings, and observations appropriate to the feature being assessed. Qualitative principles, including contextual compatibility and contemporary expression, require explanation of architectural relationships. Table 3 distinguishes these domains without assuming that every plan contains identical requirements or that the existence of a provision guarantees its intended outcome.
Table 3. Conservation provision domains and their relevance to architectural assessment.
Detailed provisions can clarify permissible development while raising questions about the scope for alternative architectural solutions. Madran and Özgönül discuss the potential for architectural prescriptions to encourage standardized or typologically similar responses, while emphasizing that compatibility need not depend on direct imitation [35] (p. 33). This is a question for empirical investigation: architectural similarities may also reflect shared local references, comparable programmes, material availability, or design choices.
Prescriptive conservation instruments are not unique to Türkiye. Bologna’s planning and building regulations provide an example of locally defined intervention categories within an Italian conservation context [76]. In England, conservation-area appraisal and management guidance connects the identification of local character with the assessment and management of change. Historic England explicitly relates this guidance to local plans and the evaluation of proposals within conservation areas. These examples involve different legal and institutional arrangements, but they demonstrate that architectural decisions in historic settings are mediated by conservation instruments in several national contexts [77].
The comparison should therefore concern what an instrument protects, how its conditions are defined, and what evidence is used to assess proposals. Questions about restrictions on design diversity [35] can be considered alongside the role of explicit provisions in communicating conservation objectives. This shifts attention from a general opposition between regulation and design towards the content and application of particular conservation tools.
The Ürgüp CDP is relevant to this discussion because it combines dimensional, material, and architectural-detail requirements with an expectation that new designs refer to local architecture while remaining compatible and recognizably contemporary. Evaluating this relationship requires both close reading of the provisions and appropriate architectural evidence. Completed developments reveal how particular features correspond to the examined text; their appearance alone does not identify the reasons for approval or the alternatives considered during design and assessment.

2.4. Research Gap and Positioning of the Present Study

The literature reviewed above addresses contextual design approaches, conservation principles, and the instruments used to guide interventions in historic environments. Studies such as Yüceer and İpekoğlu (2012) [26], examining new exterior additions to historic buildings, and Hu et al. (2017) [42], addressing the quantitative assessment of infill development, provide methodological references for examining architectural relationships within existing settings. Their approaches inform the consideration of contextual relationships, dimensions, and proportions in the present study. Here, these concerns are brought into a provision-by-provision comparison between a local conservation plan and the documented characteristics of completed new-building developments.
The research gap addressed is therefore the connection between regulatory provisions and architectural evidence at parcel, building, and detail scales. Descriptions of design approaches alone do not establish whether a dimensional requirement is met; equally, conformity with a numerical limit does not establish contextual compatibility or the perceived contemporaneity of a building. Examining these relationships requires measurable conditions, material and detail requirements, and qualitative design principles to be distinguished while remaining within a common analytical framework. The present study applies this framework to the Ürgüp Conservation Development Plan (CDP), linking its provisions to dimensioned architectural drawings, field observations, and identifiable local architectural references.
This focus on completed developments also distinguishes the study from investigations of design and approval processes. Studies encompassing revised, rejected, suspended, or abandoned proposals can explain how conservation instruments affect professional practice and project outcomes. Such investigations require successive proposals, assessment records, institutional correspondence, and, where appropriate, interviews. The present study examines the architectural outcomes accessible through project documents and field evidence; it does not reconstruct the institutional origins of individual design decisions.
The two parcel-based cases comprise all completed new-building developments within the selected block at the time of investigation. Their shared historic setting enables comparison, while differences in parcel size, topography, programme, design authorship, completion period, and approval authority preclude attributing architectural differences solely to the plan. The contribution lies in making the relationship between individual provisions and documented architectural characteristics explicit, without assigning overall stylistic categories or compatibility scores. This comparison supports discussion of how measurement conventions, local architectural references, and explanatory design guidance can assist the interpretation and application of existing provisions. Its wider relevance concerns the transparency of this analytical approach, rather than a universal design model or a general judgment on the performance of conservation planning.

3. Materials and Methods

This study adopts a comparative case-study approach to examine the documented architectural characteristics of two completed new-building developments within the same block in the Ürgüp Urban Conservation Area in relation to the provisions of the Conservation Development Plan (CDP). Systematic document analysis, examination of dimensioned architectural drawings, and field observations were used together. The investigation focuses on the relationships between the measurable development conditions and qualitative design principles established by the plan and the architectural characteristics of the completed buildings.
The research recognizes that plan provisions concerning new construction include qualitative expectations for architectural design alongside physical restrictions. A central basis for comparison is the provision requiring references to local façade characteristics and designs that evoke traditional architecture, remain compatible with their surroundings, and are recognizably new and contemporary. Architectural characteristics associated with this principle were examined through parcel–building–street relationships, massing, façade composition, openings, materials, and architectural elements.
The comparison was conducted at two levels. First, measurable plan conditions were compared with dimensions and area values obtained from architectural drawings. Second, architectural characteristics associated with qualitative design principles were assessed under common examination criteria and in relation to documented traditional examples. The buildings were not assigned overall design categories such as “replicative” or “interpretive”; no aggregate compatibility score or architectural performance ranking was produced. The use of traditional elements and arrangements differing from them were described through the relevant building components and architectural details.
The study examines completed architectural outcomes. In investigating relationships between plan provisions and documented building characteristics, it does not offer causal explanations of design and approval processes. Research stages, data sources, and analytical outputs are presented in Table 4.
Table 4. Research stages, data sources, and analytical outputs. Source: Prepared by the authors.
The study area is Block 1467 in the Karağandere Neighborhood of Ürgüp, Nevşehir, within the Ürgüp Urban Conservation Area. The selection was informed by the coexistence within one block of traditional buildings identified under the G groups in the CDP and completed new-building developments. The block scale enables examination of relationships not only within the new-building parcels but also with neighbouring buildings, streets, open spaces, and topography.
The block comprises eleven parcels. Seven contain traditional buildings or building components identified under the plan’s G groups, one is designated as green space, and three are subject to new development. At the time of the field investigation, developments on Parcels 1 and 13 had been completed, while construction on Parcel 2 was at the foundation stage. Accordingly, the building-scale comparison covers all completed new-building developments within the selected block. The cases were not selected because they represented particular design approaches or appeared different from one another.
The unit of comparison is the parcel. Parcel 1 and Parcel 13 were treated as two separate cases, each containing two main building masses. The four main masses are components of these two cases. Their architectural characteristics and relationships with one another, with internal open spaces, and with surrounding streets were examined.
Because the massing, façades, and architectural details of the development on Parcel 2 were not yet complete, this parcel was excluded from the building-scale comparison but included in the block-scale assessment of existing conditions. Traditional buildings and open spaces provided the historical and spatial context. Building value groups in the plan were considered according to their own definitions; designation within a G group was not interpreted as indicating that all traditional buildings shared the same legal registration status.
Parcel 1 contains buildings designed for commercial and accommodation functions, whereas Parcel 13 contains buildings used as a hotel. During the field investigation, the buildings on Parcel 1 were complete but not yet in use, while those on Parcel 13 were operational. Although the shared historic setting provides a spatial basis for comparison, it does not eliminate differences in parcel size, topography, use, designer, construction period, or approval authority. These characteristics were treated as contextual variables.
The principal materials comprise the 2014 Ürgüp Conservation Development Plan Provisions [37] and Research Report prepared by UTTA [37] dimensioned architectural drawings for both cases, photographs of the initial building permits, field observations, and photographic records. Base plans and a 2024 unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) orthophoto were also used for block-scale examination.
Architectural drawings for both cases were obtained from the respective designers’ archives. Drawings for Parcel 1 were supplied from the archive of designer Zeki Derin; those for Parcel 13 were obtained from the archive of designer Aziz Güngör through his son, architect Osman Güngör. Site plans, floor plans, sections, and elevations were used to establish parcel layouts, mass dimensions, storey arrangements, façade openings, and area information.
Initial building permit details were transcribed from photographs of the municipal records obtained by Zeki Derin. Table 8 lists the date and number of the first permit for each parcel. These records establish when the permits were issued. The dates of conservation decisions, architectural approvals, and completion are distinct milestones.
Fieldwork was conducted between April and June 2026. Façade arrangements, visible material characteristics, architectural details, open spaces, and street relationships of the completed buildings were documented through observation and photography. Dimensioned architectural drawings constituted the principal source for dimensional and area data. Field records were used to examine the visible built counterparts of elements shown in the drawings. Fieldwork did not imply that all project dimensions were remeasured on site; values based on field measurements were identified separately in the relevant comparisons.
Sources were distinguished according to the conditions they represented. The plan text records regulatory conditions, architectural drawings represent the design as documented, and field records show existing conditions at the time of investigation. Area calculations were identified as values derived from project data. The 2024 orthophoto and 2026 field records were not treated as contemporaneous documents. Block-scale maps were used to explain the spatial context of the compared cases; no analysis was undertaken to calculate historical changes in development density or the effects of planning decisions over time.
The regulatory reference for the comparison is the examined 2014 CDP text. Comparison with this text was not treated as a retrospective audit of every regulation and institutional decision in force when the two projects were approved. Documentation of the initial permits alone does not establish which plan version governed approval or the reasons underlying design decisions.
Bowen’s (2009) [78] systematic document analysis approach informed the examination of the plan text. The analysis comprised identifying relevant provisions, classifying them according to the characteristics they regulate, and relating them to building evidence. General provisions concerning undeveloped parcels (Section V.1.2.3.1) and relevant special provisions were considered together.
For each provision, the article number, regulated characteristic, condition of application or exception, and type of evidence available for comparison were considered. Provisions for undeveloped parcels were assessed alongside the plan designations and land-use decisions applicable to the examined parcels. Provisions dependent on use, façade orientation, or a specific architectural element were included only where the relevant condition applied to the examined building component. Commercial or accommodation use alone was not accepted as proof that a building belonged to a particular plan land-use category.
Provisions were examined in terms of measurable conditions, material and architectural-element requirements, and qualitative design principles. Site coverage ratio, façade length, plinth height, window dimensions, projection dimensions, and roof pitch were subjects of numerical comparison. References to local architecture, compatibility with surroundings, and the recognizably contemporary character of new construction were discussed through documented architectural relationships. Provisions combining numerical limits with qualitative statements or exceptions were evaluated without separating these components from one another.
At block scale, parcel arrangement, distribution of buildings and open spaces, street-visible storeys, use, building value groups in the plan, structural systems, and street silhouette were examined. Solid–void analysis represents the spatial distribution of building masses, courtyards, gardens, and other open spaces. It was not used to calculate historical changes in the percentage of block coverage.
The storey analysis distinguished basement, ground, and first-floor arrangements defined in project drawings from the number of storeys perceived from different street levels. The land-use analysis separately identified planned use, existing use, and intended functions of buildings not yet operational. Structural-system information was not conflated with façade cladding or visible surface characteristics.
For each parcel, the footprints of the two examined main building masses were summed and divided by the parcel area. The resulting ratios represent the proportion of the parcel occupied by the main masses included in the calculation. They were not substituted for calculations encompassing all building components on the parcel. Total construction area, including basements, was distinguished from floor area counted for development-intensity purposes; no E/KAKS value was derived from total construction area.
Façade lengths were compared with the relevant building mass and façade segment identified. The lengths of independent masses and the open distances between them were recorded separately; a dimension belonging to one façade segment was not presented as the length of the entire façade. Physically separate masses and subdivisions of a single mass achieved through façade articulation were treated as distinct conditions.
Heights were assessed with reference to the relevant façade orientation, starting elevation, and upper termination point. Standard and raised parapet sections were distinguished, and changes in visible façade height resulting from topography were related to sections and elevation drawings. Plan requirements concerning perceived storeys and street silhouette were not interpreted solely from overall height or the number of project-defined storeys.
Widths and heights of window types were obtained from measured drawings, and their width-to-height ratios were compared with the conditions in the relevant plan provision. In addition to the positions, arrangements, and relationships of openings to wall surfaces, the ratios of opening area to total façade area were calculated for selected street façades.
Calculations covered the examined Karağandere Street-facing façades of both cases and the western façade of Parcel 1 at the intersection of Karağandere Street and İstiklal Avenue. Where only a particular façade segment of a mass was examined, the calculation boundary was identified and the results were not generalized to the entire façade. For calculations by storey, the gross façade area before deducting openings was used:
Opening ratio (%) = Total opening area/Examined façade area × 100
Non-opening surface ratio (%) = 100 − Opening ratio (%)
Door, window, and garage openings were included in the opening area of the relevant storey. In the upper-storey analysis of Parcel 1’s western façade, arched balcony voids were also counted as openings and identified as a distinct opening type from doors and windows. Their areas were determined from the geometries shown in the drawings rather than their rectangular bounding areas. Ratios including semi-open balcony voids were not interpreted as indicators with the same physical meaning as ratios based solely on doors and windows. The complementary ratio calculated for these surfaces represents the façade projection outside the openings.
Only portions of basement storeys exposed along the street façade were included; basements not visible from the street were excluded from total visible façade area. Overall façade ratios were calculated by dividing the sum of opening areas across the relevant storeys by the sum of their façade areas, rather than by taking the arithmetic mean of storey percentages. Results were rounded to two decimal places.
Provision Ysz/8, requiring ground-floor street façades to remain as solid as possible, was considered using ground-floor values. Basement and first-floor ratios were used to describe façade composition, not as direct indicators of compliance with the ground-floor provision. Because the provision specifies no numerical threshold, no new acceptance limit was derived from the calculated ratios.
The main examination headings were based on the parcel–building–street relationship, number of storeys, mass proportions, façade openings, and façade materials identified in the “Evaluation of New Buildings” section of the CDP Research Report [79] (pp. 214–215). These headings, also included in Article III.4.1.2.1 of the Plan Provisions [37], established a locally grounded analytical framework. The building value groups defined in the documents were not directly assigned to the examined cases; instead, the relevant criteria informed systematic comparison of architectural characteristics.
This framework was supported by the approaches to environmental relationships, dimensions, and proportions in Yüceer and İpekoğlu’s (2012) [26] study of the architectural assessment of new exterior additions to historic buildings and Hu et al.’s (2017) [42] quantitative examination of infill development compatibility in historic environments. Differences in their objects and aims of investigation were acknowledged. The comparison used here does not constitute direct application of the assessment or scoring systems of those studies.
The same examination headings were applied to both cases. Parcel–building–street relationships were considered through placement, street boundaries, entrances, courtyards, and open-space connections. Massing, storeys, and façade heights were assessed in relation to topography. Façades were compared in terms of opening dimensions, proportions, and arrangements, horizontal and vertical articulation, architectural elements, and surface characteristics.
Material assessment considered materials specified in project documentation together with surface characteristics observed on site. Structural systems, cladding, and ornamental elements were treated separately. As no calibrated colour measurement was undertaken, colour was described qualitatively; load-bearing function, stone type and provenance, material composition, and application technique were not determined from external appearance alone.
Local architectural references were selected on the basis that the examples were located in Ürgüp’s historic environment, contained the architectural characteristic being compared, and could be documented visually or dimensionally. The identity of each reference building and the source of its image were indicated alongside the comparison. Elements such as arches, window surrounds, projections, and parapets were examined in terms of their form, position on the building, and relationships within façade composition. Formal similarity alone was not treated as evidence of an identical spatial arrangement, use, or design intention.
The plan’s principles of compatibility and contemporary expression guided discussion of how local architectural characteristics were used in the new buildings and how particular arrangements differed from them. The use of traditional elements was not automatically classified as “imitation”, nor was reduced ornamentation automatically classified as “contemporaneity”. Examination criteria, procedures, and data sources are summarized in Table 5.
Table 5. Criteria for comparative architectural examination of completed new-building developments. Source: Prepared by the authors; examination headings are related to UTTA [37], Yüceer and İpekoğlu [26], and Hu et al. [42].
Comparison results were presented in a plan provision–building evidence–assessment format. For measurable conditions, correspondence with or divergence from a provision was explained where the necessary evidence and applicability of the provision could be established. Results obtained for partial façades, particular window types, or selected architectural elements were confined to their defined scope. Meeting one condition was not interpreted as establishing compliance with all plan provisions or overall architectural compatibility with the historic environment.
One of the authors, Zeki Derin, designed the buildings on Parcel 1. The designer of the buildings on Parcel 13, Aziz Güngör, is not among the authors. This professional relationship is disclosed to clarify the researcher’s position and the possibility of assessment bias. Architectural drawings for both cases were available, and comparison was conducted using common document types and examination headings.
To support analytical traceability, links between each plan provision, the building evidence used, and the assessment were made explicit. Numerical values were associated with the relevant drawings and calculation boundaries; visual observations were linked to photographs and the locations of the architectural elements examined. Project information, field observations, calculated values, and researcher interpretations were distinguished. Personal explanations by the designer were not used as evidence of undocumented design or approval processes.
Comparison of specific characteristics was preferred to overall stylistic categories, aggregate compatibility scores, or architectural performance rankings. Nevertheless, the use of common criteria and explicit presentation of evidence does not entirely eliminate researcher interpretation or potential bias. No independent external expert assessment was conducted, and inter-rater reliability was not measured. Qualitative findings are therefore not presented as judgments validated through independent expert consensus.
Although the study covers all completed new-building developments within the selected block, it is limited to one block and two parcels. Findings are not generalized to Ürgüp as a whole or to other conservation plans. The effects of parcel geometry, topography, use, designer, investor expectations, construction period, and approval authority were not isolated from one another. Because the influence of investor expectations on design decisions was not separately investigated, observed architectural similarities and differences are not attributed solely to CDP provisions.
Access to architectural drawings for both cases enabled comparison using common document types. However, the drawings do not represent every stage of the design and approval processes. No documentary chain was available to establish comparative links among earlier project versions, institutional revision requests, and reasons for final decisions. Accordingly, the actor or stage responsible for a particular architectural solution could not be determined. Correspondence between a characteristic and a plan provision was not taken as proof that the design decision resulted solely from that provision. Rejected, suspended, or modified proposals were outside the study scope.
Comparison between project data and existing conditions was limited to elements observable during fieldwork and relatable to documentary evidence. Not all project dimensions were remeasured on site. Concealed building components, cladding connections, physical and chemical material properties, and long-term performance were not investigated. Technical characteristics such as stone provenance, cladding thickness, mortar composition, and production techniques of ornamental elements were not inferred from visual similarities where verifiable documentation was unavailable.
Area and opening calculations were restricted to defined building components and façade boundaries. Ratios calculated from the footprints of the main masses were not used as substitutes for a comprehensive account of all building components on a parcel. An opening ratio obtained from a particular façade segment was not generalized to all façades of a building. Because comparisons of street-visible surfaces also reflect topographic effects, aggregate ratios for different façades were interpreted with these differences in scope in mind.
The study does not measure users’ or independent experts’ perceptions of compatibility and contemporaneity. These principles were discussed in relation to documented architectural characteristics and local references. Compliance with a measurable plan condition or formal similarity to a traditional example was not treated, on its own, as evidence of overall architectural quality, compatibility with the historic environment, or perceived contemporaneity.

4. Results

4.1. Spatial and Morphological Characteristics of the Study Area

Ürgüp is located in the Cappadocia Region, one of Türkiye’s significant cultural landscape areas, approximately 20 km east of Nevşehir city centre (Figure 2). The settlement encompasses cultural layers from the Hittite, Roman, Byzantine, Seljuk, and Ottoman periods, which have contributed to its multilayered historic fabric. Until the 1923 Greek–Turkish Population Exchange, Ürgüp was inhabited by Muslim and non-Muslim communities and was one of the region’s most significant Greek Orthodox settlements [80]. Rock-cut spaces, stone dwellings, religious buildings, and other examples of vernacular architecture surviving from different periods constitute important components of its cultural heritage. This historical accumulation allows the physical and cultural traces of successive periods to be read together within Ürgüp’s urban fabric.
Figure 2. Location of the study area: Türkiye, Cappadocia Region, Nevşehir Province, and Ürgüp District.
Ürgüp’s historic urban fabric is characterised by rock-cut spaces shaped in relation to the natural topography, the use of local stone, traditional dwellings, and an organic street pattern (Figure 3). Accommodation, commercial, and service uses within the historic environment occupy both traditional and new buildings. The coexistence of buildings from different periods provides a setting for examining the relationship between the conservation of the historic fabric and contemporary use requirements at the scale of individual buildings and their immediate surroundings.
Figure 3. General View of Ürgüp [81].
Ürgüp’s traditional residential fabric comprises streets adapted to the topography and stone buildings arranged in relation to them (Figure 4). Two-storey houses organised around courtyards are prominent among the traditional residential examples. Their façades feature finely dressed stonework, symmetrical compositions, stone-framed doors and windows, moulded stone stringcourses and cornices, projecting bays supported by stone corbels, and stone ornamentation. Divanhane spaces intended for seasonal use are prominent elements of the façade compositions of houses incorporating them. Stone craftsmanship is particularly evident in window surrounds, lintels, parapets, mouldings, and corbels, while timber is used for door and window joinery as well as interior architectural elements [82,83,84]. These features provide a basis for examining local architectural examples in terms of massing, façade openings, materials, and architectural details.
Figure 4. The historic urban fabric of Ürgüp: (a,b) examples of two-storey courtyard houses with divanhane spaces on the upper floors; (c) rock-cut and stone buildings associated with the topography; (d–f) buildings with cut-stone façades. Photographs: Authors, 2026.
Block 1467, which constitutes the study area, is located in the Karağandere Neighbourhood, west of Ürgüp, within the boundaries of the Ürgüp Urban Conservation Area (Figure 5). The neighbourhood’s rock-cut spaces, cut-stone buildings, traditional houses, and narrow street network reflect the architectural and spatial characteristics of Cappadocian settlements. The winding street layout, street spaces defined by stone building façades and courtyard walls, and small focal points formed by public buildings such as mosques and fountains are among the fundamental components of the historic environment [83]. These characteristics establish the local context within which the plot layouts, relationships with the street, building massing arrangements, and façade features of the new buildings under investigation are evaluated.
Figure 5. Location of the study area within the Ürgüp Urban Conservation Area. The authors highlighted the conservation area and the study block on Google Earth satellite imagery using the Ürgüp Conservation Development Plan map as the source for the boundaries.
Block 1467 contains traditional buildings classified within the CDP’s G categories. The block also contains new developments and open spaces. The building groups on Plots 1 and 13, which represented all the completed new-build examples within the block at the time the fieldwork was completed, constitute the two cases examined in this comparative study. As each plot contains two main building masses, the building group on each plot was defined as the unit of comparison, while the individual masses were examined separately with regard to their relevant architectural characteristics. Traditional buildings, neighboring plots, streets, and open spaces provide the historical and spatial context for this comparison.
The current uses of traditional buildings and the functions of new buildings within the study block were examined as part of the assessment of existing conditions. The distribution of residential, accommodation, commercial, religious, and open-space uses at the plot scale is presented in the following sections. The block-scale analyses illustrate the locations of building footprints and open spaces, the visibility of storeys from the street, the distribution of uses, and the building categories defined in the CDP. These analyses serve as baseline data for describing the relationships between the two completed cases and their surroundings; they are not intended to measure historical increases in building development or determine the effects of planning decisions over time.
The traditional architectural characteristics and spatial relationships described in this section provide the basis for examining the relationships between the new buildings and the local historic environment. In the subsequent architectural analysis, building massing arrangements, the use of stone materials, window configurations, and façade details are examined in relation to local examples whose locations or documentary sources are identified. The similarities and differences observed are discussed in relation to the CDP’s principles of compatibility and contemporary design; they are not translated into an overall compatibility score or a ranking of architectural quality.

4.1.1. Existing Condition of Block 1467 at the Parcel Level

Block 1467, located in the Karağandere Neighborhood of Ürgüp, comprises a total of 11 plots. Under the Ürgüp Conservation Development Plan (CDP), traditional buildings or building components on Plots 3, 5, 7, 9, 10, 12, and 20 are identified within the G-group categories. These buildings constitute the block’s historic building stock and form the immediate surroundings of the new buildings examined in this study. Since the G-group categories encompass different conservation classifications, the general G designation has not been treated as sufficient evidence of the statutory registration status of all buildings. The distribution of these categories is examined separately in Section Distribution of Buildings by Conservation Status and Planning Categories.
The orthophoto in Figure 6 represents the physical conditions in 2024, whereas the land-use and development information in Table 6 and the field photographs represent the conditions observed in 2026. Field surveys conducted in 2026 established that the buildings on Plots 3, 9, and 10 are used for residential purposes; those on Plots 5, 12, and 20 function as hotels; and the building on Plot 7 is used as a mosque (Table 6). In addition to these plots containing traditional buildings, Plots 1, 2, and 13 are subject to new development. Plot 8 is designated as green space in the plan (Figure 7). During the field survey, this plot was observed to be used as a car park and children’s playground; the planned land-use designation and the actual use were recorded separately. This distribution indicates the coexistence of residential, accommodation, religious, and open-space uses within the block.
Figure 6. Orthophoto of Block 1467 in the Karağandere Neighborhood and its plot layout. Purple shading indicates buildings displaying traditional architectural characteristics, red lines indicate plot boundaries, and numbers identify the plots. These annotations are superimposed on the orthophoto to show their spatial relationships. The UAV orthophoto was commissioned by one of the authors in 2024; annotations were added by the authors.
The hotel buildings on Plot 13, comprising two main building masses, were completed and opened for use in 2020. The building group on Plot 1, also comprising two main masses and designed for commercial and accommodation uses, was completed in 2026 but had not yet opened for use at the time the fieldwork was completed. On Plot 2, construction of the building, whose function is identified as a guesthouse on the construction site sign, was at the foundation stage during the field survey. Thus, of the three plots designated for new development within the block, two contain completed building groups, while construction is ongoing on the third.
Table 6 distinguishes the CDP designation of each parcel from its use and stage of development as recorded during the 2026 field survey.
Table 6. Conservation status/planning designation, current use and development status of the plots within Block 1467, as well as field photographs taken in 2026 1.

4.1.2. Spatial Analyses at the Scale of Block 1467

Figure–Ground Analysis
The figure–ground analysis of Block 1467 shows that building footprints are predominantly arranged along İstiklal Avenue and Karağandere Street (Figure 7). While the building masses located along the perimeter of the block contribute to defining the street boundaries, gardens, courtyards, and other open spaces are situated between buildings and within individual plots. On the eastern side of the block, Plot 8, designated as green space in the plan, was observed to be used as a car park and children’s playground during the field survey. Its open-space character distinguishes this plot from the building footprints in its surroundings.
The completed building groups on Plots 1 and 13 constitute part of the existing figure–ground pattern of the block. On Parcel 1, the space between the two main building masses is shown as an open terrace in the project drawings. Field observations documented glazing between its columns. On Parcel 13, the two main building masses stand apart, with open space between them. The positions of these masses in relation to the street boundary, their distances from neighbouring buildings, and the open spaces retained around them provide the spatial basis for the building-scale comparison.
The figure–ground plan is used to describe the existing distribution of building footprints and open spaces. No overall building coverage percentage or changes in development density between different periods have been calculated for the block. The arrangement of buildings along the streets has not, in itself, been considered an indicator of architectural compatibility with the historic environment; building proportions, façade compositions, and architectural details are examined separately in the subsequent comparative analysis.
Figure 7. Solid–void analysis of cadastral Block 1467 in the study area.
Storey Count Analysis
The storey count analysis of Block 1467 was prepared based on the storeys visible from the Karağandere Street side (Figure 8). Although one- and two-storey building masses predominate across the block, the number of storeys visible on façades facing different streets varies in some buildings due to the sloping terrain. Accordingly, the analysis distinguishes between the storey configuration specified in the architectural projects and the number of storeys visible from the street.
Figure 8. Building Height Analysis of Block 1467.
The building group on Plot 1 comprises a basement, ground floor, and first floor. Although the building masses appear to be two storeys high from the upper street level, the exposure of their basement levels along Karağandere Street creates a three-storey façade appearance. However, the basement façades differ in their opening configurations: the basement façade of the first building mass consists of a solid surface, whereas the second mass contains openings for garage access. Thus, the contribution of the exposed basement levels to the street-facing appearance differs not only in terms of visible storey count but also in terms of façade composition.
Both main building masses on Plot 13 also comprise a basement, ground floor, and first floor. However, since the basement levels are not visible on the façades examined along Karağandere Street, the street-facing appearance is limited to the ground and first floors. Thus, although the two plots share the same storey configuration in their architectural projects, the number of storeys visible from the street differs due to topographic conditions and the positioning of the building masses.
The storey count analysis illustrates the vertical arrangement of the buildings as perceived from the street. The number of visible storeys has not been treated as equivalent to building height measured in metres or as evidence of compliance with the plan’s height restrictions. Height requirements have been assessed separately, with reference to the reference elevations defined in the relevant planning provision and the dimensioned sectional and elevation drawings.
Land-Use Analysis
The land-use analysis of Block 1467 reveals a mix of commercial, residential, religious, and recreational uses within the study area (Figure 9). Commercial and accommodation uses are concentrated primarily along İstiklal Street, while residential use predominates in the interior of the block. The Kurtuluş Mosque retains its religious function. Although Parcel No. 8 is designated as an urban green space in the Conservation Development Plan, field observations indicate that it is currently used as a car park and children’s playground.
Figure 9. Existing uses across Block 1467, as observed during the 2026 field survey, and intended functions of buildings not yet opened for use.
The land-use distribution indicates that Block 1467 is characterized by a mixed-use urban fabric rather than a monofunctional structure, with diverse functions coexisting within the study area. The concentration of commercial and accommodation uses along İstiklal Street, the primary circulation axis, highlights its role as a focal point of economic and social activity. In contrast, the persistence of residential use within the interior of the block, together with the open-space use of the parcel designated as urban green space, indicates that spaces contributing to the quality of life within the historic settlement are also integrated into the urban fabric.
Distribution of Buildings by Conservation Status and Planning Categories
The conservation status and planning categories of buildings on Block 1467 were examined on the basis of the designations in the Ürgüp Conservation Development Plan (CDP) (Figure 10). Plots 3, 5, 7, 9, 10, 12, and 20 contain traditional buildings or building components identified under the G-group categories in the plan. Rather than assigning a single conservation status to each entire plot, the classification was examined at the level of individual buildings and building components as designated in the plan.
In the analysis map, rare registered buildings of original character are classified as G1, typical registered buildings of original character as G2, buildings to be preserved as G3a, and buildings whose footprints and massing proportions are to be preserved as G3b. Non-traditional buildings that are not designated under the registered or preservation categories are also identified using a separate designation. While G1 and G2 refer to categories of registered buildings, G3a and G3b define different conservation requirements under the plan. Accordingly, the general G designation has not been treated as conclusive evidence of the statutory registration status of all buildings.
Figure 10. Distribution of traditional buildings identified by G-group designations in the CDP across Block 1467. Source: Ürgüp CDP; annotations added by the authors.
The distribution of these categories across the block illustrates the adjacency relationships between Plots 1, 2, and 13, which are subject to new development, and the traditional building stock. The completed new buildings examined in this study were evaluated not only in terms of their characteristics within their respective plot boundaries but also in relation to the massing, façades, and street interfaces of neighbouring buildings. Adjacency to traditional buildings defines the historic-environmental context of the comparison but does not, in itself, constitute a basis for determining the architectural compatibility of the new buildings.
Construction Techniques Analysis
The analysis of construction techniques and structural systems on Block 1467 reveals the coexistence of masonry, reinforced concrete, and timber-frame buildings, as well as rock-cut spaces (Figure 11). The building masses classified as masonry in the analysis map are concentrated particularly in the northern and southeastern parts of the block. Rock-cut spaces are located in the southeastern part, while buildings or building sections identified as timber-frame structures are scattered across the block. This distribution demonstrates the coexistence of different construction techniques and structural systems within the study area.
Figure 11. Distribution of construction techniques and structural systems across Block 1467.
The two main building masses on each of Plots 1 and 13 included in the comparative analysis have reinforced concrete structural systems. However, another building section within the boundaries of Plot 13 is identified as timber-frame construction in the analysis map. Accordingly, structural system classifications have not been generalised to the entire plot but have been restricted to the relevant building masses.
The reinforced concrete structural systems of the new buildings and the use of stone on their exterior façades have been considered as distinct characteristics. Although the use of stone in traditional masonry buildings and stone cladding on reinforced concrete buildings may produce a similar material appearance on the façade, they do not represent the same structural system or construction technique. Therefore, the comparison with traditional buildings considers not only the presence of stone surfaces but also the manner in which the material is used, surface characteristics, façade composition, and architectural details. Visual similarity has not been taken as evidence that the physical properties or performance of the materials are equivalent.
Streetscape Analysis
The street skyline analysis of Block 1467 was conducted along İstiklal Avenue and Karağandere Street, which define the boundaries of the block (Figure 12). The relationships of the buildings with these two street corridors were examined in terms of street levels, the number of visible storeys, exposed façade sections, and roofline profiles. Topography and the positioning of building masses in relation to the streets affect the perceived façade height of the same building when viewed from different directions.
Figure 12. Street skylines of Block 1467 viewed from İstiklal Avenue and Karağandere Street.
The higher elevation of İstiklal Avenue limits the portions of the façades of buildings situated along the slope that are visible from this street. Along Karağandere Street, which lies at a lower elevation, the lower floors of some buildings also contribute to the street-facing appearance. This condition is particularly evident in the two main building masses on Plot 1. Although these masses appear to be two storeys high when viewed from the upper street, the exposure of their basement levels along Karağandere Street creates a three-storey façade appearance. By contrast, the basement levels are not visible on the façades of Plot 13 examined along this street, and only the ground and first floors contribute to the street skyline.
The predominantly two-storey appearance along Karağandere Street is varied by exposed lower floors and differences in the upper termination profiles of the buildings. Accordingly, the skyline has not been interpreted as a continuous line in which all buildings share the same height. Traditional buildings and the new building groups on Plots 1 and 13 collectively shape the existing streetscape through their varying façade heights and massing arrangements.
The skyline analysis illustrates the relationships between the heights and massing of the new buildings and those of their neighbors. However, variations in façade visibility resulting from topographic conditions limit the extent to which these relationships can be explained on the basis of a single street view. The comparison with the CDP provisions concerning storey count and building height was therefore conducted by considering the street skylines together with the reference elevations identified in the dimensioned sections and elevation drawings. This approach distinguishes between the heights perceived from the street and the heights assessed in accordance with the planning provisions.

4.2. CDP Provisions Concerning New Development

The 2014 Plan Provisions of the Ürgüp Conservation Development Plan (CDP) examined in this study contain both measurable requirements for new development and qualitative principles governing architectural design. The documentable architectural characteristics of the completed building groups on Parcels 1 and 13 are compared with the relevant provisions. Although the examined plan text provides the documentary basis for this comparison, it is not assumed that the same version of the plan and the same specific conditions applied at the time of approval of both projects. This distinction separates the assessment of existing architectural characteristics in relation to the plan provisions from the evaluation of past approval processes.
The provisions entitled “Undeveloped Parcel (Ysz)” under Article V.1.2.3.1 of the plan regulate the relationship between new development and the plot, street, and immediate surroundings. The first provision requires the preparation of a site plan that also covers the immediate surroundings of the plot, irrespective of whether a building setback boundary has been designated. It further stipulates that implementation projects should be submitted following the Regional Conservation Board’s favourable opinion on this site plan. The institutional authority and procedural sequence specified here reflect the content of the dated plan text examined in this study; they do not, in themselves, explain how subsequent changes in institutional responsibilities were applied to the two projects.
The Ysz provisions include regulations such as a maximum site coverage ratio (TAKS) of 0.50, a maximum plinth height of 1.00 m, a maximum street-facing façade length of 10 m, and a prohibition on attic and recessed floors. The provision concerning façade length also specifies façade arrangements that emphasise the distinction between separate buildings where the 10 m limit is exceeded in attached buildings. The height regulation is not based solely on the number of storeys; it also considers the appearance of the building on the elevation from which its level is established, its impact on the urban silhouette, and, where necessary, the Board’s assessment based on a street-silhouette and building-envelope study.
The provision requiring ground-floor street façades to be kept as solid as possible does not specify a numerical threshold. Accordingly, the opening and solid surface ratios calculated for the examined ground-floor façades have been used to document the solid–void relationships of the relevant façades, without introducing an additional compliance threshold established by the researchers. The text of the provisions and the assessment topics associated with them in this study are presented in Table 7.
Table 7. Ürgüp CDP Article V.1.2.3.1: Provisions for Undeveloped Plots and Related Assessment Topics. Source: Ürgüp Conservation Development Plan Provisions [37], Section V.1.2.3.1. Translated from Turkish by the authors. The “Assessment topic” column was prepared by the authors.
Ysz/5 requires new designs to refer to local façade types and establish a relationship with traditional architecture through openings, dimensions, arrangements, and façade modulation. The same provision stipulates that, in addition to being compatible with the surrounding context, the design should be recognisable as new and contemporary. Provision b, concerning architectural elements, permits the use of projections, cihannüma, yazlık kemer, eaves, and other architectural elements found in local examples, while restricting decorative features for which no precedent exists in the traditional fabric. Accordingly, the use of a traditional architectural element has not, in itself, been interpreted as conflicting with the plan’s principle of contemporary design. The analysis considers the element’s position within the building, its proportions, its relationship with other façade components, and its similarities to local examples that can be documented.
The material-related provisions also impose different requirements. While the use of local or traditional materials and techniques is permitted under provision a.1, the use of stone or stone cladding on exterior façades is required under provision a.3. Prohibitions concerning artificial cladding materials and certain decorative materials, as well as regulations governing stone surfaces and joint arrangements, are specified separately. Therefore, the presence of a stone-like appearance on a façade does not demonstrate compliance with all material-related provisions. Similarly, the assessment of provisions concerning windows, doors, roofs, projections, and courtyard walls has been undertaken by distinguishing the dimensional, formal, material, and locational requirements applicable to each element.
The provisions concerning new development should be evaluated together with the plan’s general regulations and specific provisions related to land-use designations. For example, Article V.1.3.4.4, concerning commercial areas, permits three-storey development for buildings designated as new construction, provided that the provisions of V.1.2.3.1 are observed. The applicability of this provision to a particular plot should be determined on the basis of the relevant planning designation and building category, rather than solely on whether the building is used or designed for commercial purposes. Accordingly, a three-storey appearance from the street has not, in itself, been interpreted as evidence of non-compliance with the plan provisions.
The examination of the plan text demonstrates that qualitative design principles for new development are already established. The focus of this study is not primarily on whether such principles exist, but on the relationship between measurable requirements and qualitative expectations and the documentable architectural characteristics of completed buildings. In the following section, quantitative requirements are examined using dimensioned project data, provisions concerning materials and architectural elements are assessed through project documentation and field records, and qualitative design principles are evaluated through the architectural relationships established with local examples.

4.3. Comparative Analysis of the New Buildings on Plots 1 and 13

Table 8 summarises the project records, parcel areas, building footprints, and floor arrangements for the two developments.
Although both cases comprise two main building masses, they differ in terms of plot size, building footprint areas, and open-space arrangements. On Plot 1, an intermediate space 3.20 m wide is located between the two main building masses. Although this space was designed as an open terrace in the architectural project, the field survey revealed that the gaps between the columns had been enclosed with glazing. On Plot 13, the distance between the independent building masses is 6.00 m. The combined footprint area of the main building masses examined on Plot 1 is 146.60 m2, compared with 345.32 m2 on Plot 13. Although both cases comprise a basement, ground floor, and first floor, the visibility of the storeys from the street and the height of the exposed façades vary due to topographic conditions and the positioning of the buildings.
Section 4.3.1 and Section 4.3.2 examine the architectural characteristics of each development, and Section 4.3.3 compares the findings provision by provision.
Table 8. Technical characteristics of the examined plots Source: Dimensioned architectural drawings obtained from the designers’ archives; photographs of the initial building permit documents obtained from the municipality by Zeki Derin; and area calculations by the authors.

4.3.1. Architectural Characteristics of the Building on Plot 1

The first case is the development on Plot 1 in Block 1467. The plot has an area of 333.60 m2 and contains two main building masses. The project drawings show a 3.20 m-wide terrace between the masses, with open bays between its columns. Glazing was observed between the columns during the field survey. The development comprises a basement, ground floor, and first floor, with a total floor area of 657.00 m2, including the basements. The two masses have footprints of 75.20 m2 and 71.40 m2, giving a combined footprint of 146.60 m2. These masses occupy 43.94% of the parcel area, corresponding to a ratio of 0.4394, below the limit of 0.50 specified in provision Ysz/2. The site and floor plans show the positions of the masses, the terrace as originally designed, and the floor layouts (Figure 13).
Figure 13. Site layout and floor plans of the building group on Parcel 1 of Block 1467: (a) site plan; (b) ground-floor plan; (c) basement-floor plan. Source: Zeki Derin’s architectural design archive.
The street-facing façades of the two main building masses measure 9.60 m and 6.80 m, respectively. Their combined length is 16.40 m. The overall span along the same axis is 19.60 m when the 3.20 m distance between the masses is included. For the comparison with provision Ysz/7, each façade length was recorded separately, and the 3.20 m dimension was reported as the distance between the masses.
The height of the building group as viewed from the streets varies according to the differences in ground levels. On the south-facing façades overlooking Karağandere Street, the exposure of the basement floors gives the buildings a three-storey appearance. The height in this direction is 10.20 m, including the parapet. On the north-facing façade overlooking İstiklal Avenue and the west-facing façade at the street intersection, the height is 7.10 m. Thus, while the building masses appear to have two storeys when viewed from the upper street, they present a different vertical profile from the lower street, where the basement floors are also exposed at façade level. The upper and lower ground levels used for the height measurements, together with the terrain profiles and floor levels, are indicated in the section and elevation drawings (Figure 14).
Figure 14. Sections and elevation drawings of the building group on Parcel 1: (a) Section A; (b) Section B; (c) north elevation; (d) south elevation; (e) east elevation; (f) west elevation, showing ground levels, floor levels, the open terrace between the building masses, façade lengths, and heights including parapets. Source: Zeki Derin’s design archive.
Stone cladding is used on the façades. The light cream-coloured stone surfaces, which are close to white in tone, establish a consistent material and colour scheme across the two building masses. The façade corners are accentuated with prominent stone elements, while the intermediate floor bands and eaves mouldings feature simple profiles. The horizontal bands, window arrangements and parapet lines are repeated in a similar manner across both masses. The façade composition combines rectangular openings, arched entrances, open and enclosed projections, and semi-open spaces. In contrast to the decorative mouldings and parapets of Plot 13, the façades of Plot 1 are characterised by simple stone profiles (Figure 15).
Figure 15. Façade Views of the New Building on Parcel 1: (a,b) south façade; (c,d) west façade; (e) north façade; (f) north and east façades. Photographs: Authors, 2026.
Both building masses are covered by flat terrace roofs with a 3% slope and natural stone covering. The parapets are designed in the same form and height on both masses, with undecorated surfaces at their upper edges. Stone-clad chimneys are the roof elements visible from the street. No other roof equipment was identified from the street locations included in the field survey. The repetition of the roof and parapet arrangements establishes visual continuity between the upper terminations of the two masses.
The windows are rectangular, with timber frames and plain stone surrounds. The dimensioned drawings show two window types: 80 × 160 cm (width-to-height ratio 1:2) and 80 × 120 cm (1:1.5). On the façade facing Karağandere Street, the basement of the first mass has no openings, while the basement of the second mass contains two windows of the 80 × 120 cm type. The windows have six-pane timber frames. Both window types fall within the width, height, and proportion ranges specified in provision Ysz/d.1. The plain stone surrounds frame the openings, while the horizontal mouldings and prominent corner elements articulate the façades (Figure 14 and Figure 15). Each building mass has a separate entrance. Timber doors are used in the depressed-arched entrance openings. The doors have an asymmetrical double-leaf arrangement, consisting of a wider main leaf and a narrower, operable secondary leaf. It was observed that the wrought-iron element shown in front of the main entrance in the project drawings had not been implemented on site. This difference was recorded as a discrepancy between the project drawings and the completed building; no inference was made regarding the reason for the alteration.
Courtyard and garage access points are arranged separately from the building entrances. The garage door is a single-piece timber door measuring 300 × 270 cm, set within a depressed-arched opening. The courtyard entrance is closed by a double-leaf timber gate framed by stone side elements and a flat lintel. In terms of the formation of the opening, the stone frame and its position within the courtyard wall, the courtyard gate resembles the flat-lintel stone entrances found in traditional Ürgüp houses (Figure 16).
Figure 16. Comparison of entrance openings with flat stone lintels in traditional Ürgüp houses and the courtyard gate on Plot 1: (a–c) examples of traditional entrances; (d) courtyard gate on Plot 1. Source: (a–c) [83]; (d) Authors, 2026.
The west façade features a large, arched opening with timber framing, designed as an entrance and shopfront for commercial use. The glazed surface, incorporating a double-leaf entrance, is a prominent element of the ground floor on this façade. While the other façades are predominantly characterised by stone wall surfaces and relatively small rectangular windows, a substantially wider opening is provided on the west façade. Consequently, the solid-to-void relationship at ground-floor level varies between the façades (Figure 14 and Figure 15). As the building group had not yet opened for use at the time of completion of the fieldwork, this opening is considered as the architectural expression of the intended function rather than as evidence of an ongoing commercial activity.
Opening ratios were calculated separately for each storey of the western façades, distinguishing between the types of openings (Table 9). The narrow street-facing façade section of the first building mass has no openings at either ground-floor or first-floor level. In the second mass, the commercial entrance and shopfront opening at ground-floor level, together with the arched balcony openings on the first floor, constitute distinct types of openings. Since the basement floors of both masses are not visible from this direction, they were excluded from the calculations.
Table 9. Opening and non-opening surface ratios by storey on the western façades of the two building masses on Parcel 1. Source: Authors’ calculations based on dimensioned architectural drawings obtained from the designer’s archive.
On the west façade of the second building mass, the opening ratio is 27.61% at ground-floor level, while the ratio of the arched balcony openings on the first floor is 24.95%. When the two storeys are considered together, the overall opening ratio is calculated as 26.16%. This figure includes not only door and window openings but also the voids defined by the arches of the semi-open balcony. In the comparison with provision Ysz/8, however, only the ground-floor solid-surface ratio of 72.39% has been taken into account. The fact that the opening ratio at ground-floor level on the same building mass’s façade facing Karağandere Street is 16.20% quantitatively demonstrates the variation between the façades.
An intermediate space measuring 3.20 m in width is located between the two main building masses on Plot 1. In the architectural project, this space was designed as an open terrace defined by columns, with a wrought-iron railing proposed along its upper edge at first-floor level. During the field survey, however, it was observed that the openings between the columns enclosing the terrace had been glazed. Thus, the terrace, originally designed as an open space, has been transformed into a glazed-enclosed space in the as-built condition. Although the rhythm created by the columns remains legible on the façade, the glazed surfaces alter the open character of the intermediate space and its relationship with the external environment.
The basement levels of both main building masses are visible from Karağandere Street on the southern side of Parcel 1. The basement façade of the first mass is entirely solid, with no openings. The basement façade of the second mass contains two rectangular windows measuring 80 × 120 cm and a garage door. The combined area of the windows is 1.92 m2, while the total opening area, including the garage door, is 9.32 m2. For the 27.00 m2 basement façade of the second mass visible from the street, the opening ratio is calculated as 34.52% and the solid-surface ratio as 65.48% (Table 10).
Table 10. Opening and solid-surface ratios by storey on the Karağandere Street-facing façades of the building masses on Plot 1 Source: Authors’ calculations based on dimensioned architectural drawings obtained from the designer’s archive.
With reference to provision Ysz/8, the solid surface ratios of the ground-floor façades facing Karağandere Street are 88.57% for the first building mass and 83.80% for the second. Solid surfaces account for most of the examined ground-floor façade area in both masses. However, because the provision does not specify a numerical threshold, these ratios were not used as conclusive indicators of compliance. The ratios for the façades facing Karağandere Street and those facing west were assessed within the measurement boundaries defined separately for each façade. The results were not generalised to façades outside the scope of the analysis.
At first-floor level, the balcony on the eastern façade, the arched composition on the western façade, and the openings associated with the terrace between the two building masses articulate the relationship between the façades and spaces designed as semi-open areas. The eastern balcony projects 1.25 m from the façade plane and is open on three sides. The western façade features a composition of four arches separated by three columns. Wrought-iron railings are used on the balconies. These arrangements share formal characteristics with the yazlık kemer and semi-open upper-floor arrangements of traditional Ürgüp houses, particularly in the repetition of arches, subdivision by vertical supports, and articulation of open-space boundaries within the façade. As these elements are associated with balconies and terraces in Parcel 1, comparisons with traditional examples focus on their spatial position and visible façade characteristics (Figure 17).
Figure 17. Comparison of arched upper-floor arrangements in traditional Ürgüp houses and on Parcel 1: (a) an example of a traditional divanhane, (b) a listed building near the study area, (c) the section between the two masses on the southern façade, (d) the balcony on the eastern façade, and (e) the arched section on the western façade. Photographs: Authors, 2026.
The southern façade features an enclosed rectangular projecting bay formed by the first-floor volume extending 0.30 m beyond the plane of the external wall below. Drawing on Binan’s classification, the explanatory report for the Ürgüp CDP identifies two types of enclosed projecting bays in the local architecture: angled and rectangular bays. It describes the latter as generally supported by spaced, moulded stone corbels [79]. The enclosed bay in Parcel 1 and the traditional example documented in the report share several features: the projection of the upper-floor volume beyond the façade plane, the spaced repetition of corbel-shaped elements beneath the bay, and the articulation of its lower edge by a horizontal moulding. The front face of the bay in the new building contains two windows, whereas the traditional example differs in the dimensions and arrangement of its openings. Thus, although the overall form and underside treatment share common features, the window composition is not repeated in the same manner (Figure 18).
Figure 18. Comparison of enclosed rectangular projecting bays in Ürgüp: (a) a traditional example documented in the explanatory report for the Ürgüp CDP; (b) the enclosed rectangular projecting bay on the southern façade of Parcel 1. Sources: (a) [79]; (b) Authors, 2026.
The enclosed bay’s projection of 0.30 m exceeds the upper value of 0.25 m in the 15–25 cm range specified in provision Ysz/f.3. This dimensional difference was recorded separately from the formal similarities identified with the local example. The projection depth of the open balcony and the number of openings in the arched composition are also examined in Section 4.3.3, with reference to the locations and architectural elements to which the relevant provisions apply.
The arched commercial opening on the western façade was compared with traditional eyvan examples in terms of its form. The explanatory report for the Ürgüp CDP defines eyvans as semi-open spaces providing a transition between the courtyard and the enclosed rooms of a dwelling [77]. In Parcel 1, however, the arched opening is enclosed with timber joinery and glazing and accommodates a commercial entrance and shopfront. The similarity lies in the composition of the broad arched opening within the façade, while the degree of enclosure and intended function differ. Accordingly, the arrangement in Parcel 1 is described as an arched commercial opening bearing a formal resemblance to traditional eyvans, rather than as an eyvan itself (Figure 19).
Figure 19. Comparison of traditional eyvan examples and the arched commercial opening in Parcel 1: (a) a traditional eyvan in Ürgüp; (b) eyvans of a traditional building within the study block; (c) the arched entrance and shopfront arrangement on the western façade of Parcel 1. Sources: (a) [79]; (b,c) Authors, 2026.
The courtyard walls are constructed of stone masonry. Their heights vary between 2.10 and 2.50 m in response to the sloping terrain, and their upper edges are finished with stone coping. The solid wall surfaces and timber courtyard gate restrict visual connections between the street and the courtyard. In addition to the timber courtyard gate, a separate iron gate provides access to the garage. The recorded wall heights meet the minimum requirement of 2.00 m specified in provision Ysz/k.2, while the stone coping corresponds to the coping treatment required by provision Ysz/k.4. Wall materials and joint characteristics were assessed separately (Figure 15).
The architectural character of Parcel 1 is defined by two principal building masses with an intervening space designed as an open terrace but enclosed with glazing between the columns in the built condition, façade heights that vary with the topography, light-coloured stone cladding, prominent corner elements, and simple horizontal mouldings. The enclosed rectangular projecting bay, arched balcony and terrace arrangements, and courtyard gateway with a flat lintel are the principal elements sharing formal characteristics with local traditional examples. The broad commercial opening on the western façade creates a ground-floor composition distinct from those of the other façades. The repetition of materials, window types, mouldings, and parapets across the two masses establishes a consistent façade treatment, while the relationship of these features to the plan provisions is assessed separately for each criterion.

4.3.2. Architectural Characteristics of the Building on Parcel 13

The second case comprises Parcel 13 in Block 1467, which has an area of 2287.00 m2. The parcel contains two independent principal building masses separated by a distance of 6.00 m. One has a near-square plan, while the other is rectangular. Both comprise a basement, ground floor, and first floor. Their respective footprints are 235.32 m2 and 110.00 m2, giving a combined footprint of 345.32 m2. The area calculation on the project sheet records a total floor area of 690.64 m2 across two storeys. Adding the combined basement area of 345.32 m2 gives a total floor area of 1035.96 m2 for the two principal masses, including basements. Their positions within the parcel, the intervening open space, and the floor layouts are illustrated in the site and floor plans (Figure 20).
Figure 20. Site layout and floor plans of the building group on Parcel 13 of Block 1467: (a) site plan showing Units 01 and 02; (b) ground-floor plans of Units 01 and 02; (c) basement-floor plans of Units 01 and 02. Source: Aziz Güngör’s architectural design archive; drawings supplied through Osman Güngör.
The examined street-facing façade of the first mass is 10.00 m long, while the examined street-facing segment of the second mass measures 2.70 m. The latter dimension refers only to the segment included in the analysis, rather than the full façade length of the mass. As these dimensions belong to independent building masses, they were not treated as a single continuous façade length. The 6.00 m open space between the masses was also considered separately from the façade lengths.
On the façades facing Karağandere Street and İstiklal Avenue, as well as on the western façade, the height from the lower reference levels indicated in the drawings to the top of the standard parapet is 7.50 m. This increases to 7.70 m at the raised, ornamented sections of the parapet. Floor levels, upper façade terminations, and parapet arrangements are repeated in a similar manner across the two masses. The basements are not visible on the examined façades facing Karağandere Street; only the ground and first floors are visible from the street. Terrain levels, floor levels, and the lower and upper limits used for height measurements are indicated in the section and elevation drawings (Figure 21).
Figure 21. Sections and elevation drawings of the two building units on Parcel 13: (a) Section A; (b) Section B; (c) north elevations; (d) south elevations; (e) east elevations; (f) west elevations, showing terrain levels, floor levels, the façade lengths examined, and building heights including parapets. Source: Aziz Güngör’s architectural archive; drawings supplied through Osman Güngör.
The external façades are clad in dressed stone. Their light beige and yellowish surfaces display visual colour similarities to nearby traditional stone buildings. These similarities were recorded through field observations and photographs and do not establish that the stones share the same type, provenance, or physical properties. Rectangular window openings, stone surrounds, arched entrances, balconies, and horizontal mouldings are the principal components of the façade composition. Stringcourses and cornices articulate the façades horizontally, while ornamented parapets emphasise their upper termination. The prominent quoin treatment observed in Parcel 1 is absent here. Ornamentation is concentrated primarily on the mouldings, parapets, and selected window surrounds. The repetition of materials and details across the two masses establishes a consistent façade treatment between the independent buildings (Figure 22).
Figure 22. Façade Views of the New Building on Parcel 13. Photographs: Authors, 2026.
Both building masses have flat terrace roofs finished with natural stone and laid to a 2% slope. Parapets define the upper roof edges visible from the street. Stone-clad chimneys are visible roof elements; no other rooftop equipment was identified from the street observation points used during the field survey. The horizontal parapet profiles are interrupted by raised, ornamented sections. These arrangements are repeated in a similar manner across both masses.
Comparison with the traditional building on Parcel 5 within the same block reveals similarities in the form and repetition of geometric motifs and their placement along the upper façade termination. In both examples, ornamentation makes the parapet a prominent component of the façade composition. These shared features establish a formal relationship between the parapet treatment of the new buildings and a specific architectural example in their immediate surroundings (Figure 23). However, visual similarity alone does not demonstrate that this example served as a direct reference during the design process or that the same fabrication technique was used.
Figure 23. Comparison of parapet details: (a) decorative parapet of the listed building on Parcel No. 5; (b) parapet detail of the new building on Parcel No. 13. Photographs: Authors, 2026.
The windows are rectangular, with timber frames and stone surrounds. The principal window type measures 80 × 140 cm, while the secondary type measures 60 × 100 cm. The smaller windows are located on the southern façade at ground- and first-floor levels. The timber frames are divided into eight panes. In the ornamented ground-floor window surrounds, the lower and side sections are plain, while decorative motifs are concentrated in the upper sections. The first-floor windows have unornamented surrounds. Thus, the form of the openings and the materials remain consistent across the storeys, while the detailing of the surrounds varies (Figure 21 and Figure 22).
The ornamented ground-floor window surrounds were compared with window details of the nearby traditional building on Parcel 2 in Block 120. The framing of the openings with stone elements and the concentration of ornamentation above the windows are common to both examples. The similarity is evident in the overall configuration of the surrounds and the placement of ornamentation around the openings (Figure 24). The 80 × 140 cm windows identified in the dimensioned drawings have a width-to-height ratio of 1:1.75, while the 60 × 100 cm windows have a ratio of approximately 1:1.67. The widths, heights, and proportions of the two window types examined fall within the ranges specified in provision Ysz/d.1. Stone surrounds are also among the façade elements permitted under provision Ysz/d.2. These findings are limited to the dimensions of the specified window types and the use of stone surrounds.
Figure 24. Comparison of stone window surrounds and ornamentation above the openings. Left: the traditional building on Parcel 2 in Block 120. Right: the building on Parcel 13 in Block 1467. Photographs: Authors, 2026.
The opening and solid surface ratios of the examined façades facing Karağandere Street were calculated from dimensioned elevation drawings (Table 11). In the first building mass, the opening area is 2.84 m2 on both the ground and first floors. Because the gross façade areas differ, the opening ratio is 8.74% on the ground floor and 8.00% on the first floor. The basement is not visible from the street on this façade. Across the two storeys examined, the overall opening ratio is 8.35%, and the solid surface ratio is 91.65%. The examined façade segment of the second mass facing Karağandere Street contains no door or window openings; its solid surface ratio is therefore 100% on both storeys.
Table 11. Opening and solid surface ratios by storey for the examined façades of the building masses on Parcel 13 facing Karağandere Street. Source: Authors’ calculations based on dimensioned architectural drawings obtained from the designer’s archive.
With reference to provision Ysz/8, the solid surface ratios of the examined ground-floor façades are 91.26% for the first building mass and 100% for the relevant façade segment of the second. These values indicate the predominance of solid surfaces within the areas examined. As the provision does not specify a numerical threshold, the ratios were not treated as conclusive indicators of compliance. Nor were these results generalised to the other façades containing entrances and balconies.
Each building mass has a separate entrance. The entrances are set within semicircular arched openings fitted with double-leaf timber doors. Small balconies defined by arched openings are positioned above the entrances at first-floor level. The repetition of this arrangement across the two masses establishes a vertical relationship between the entrances and the balconies above.
The arched balcony arrangements share formal characteristics with the yazlık kemer and semi-open upper-floor arrangements of traditional Ürgüp houses. The subdivision of the arched composition by vertical supports and the use of railings to define the façade boundary of the semi-open space are common features of the examples compared. In Parcel 13, these elements articulate the balconies above the entrances. The comparison therefore focuses on the arrangement of arches, supports, and railings and their positions within the façade. The presence of similar façade elements was not interpreted as evidence that the spatial organisation or use of the traditional examples had been reproduced in its entirety (Figure 25).
Figure 25. Comparison of arched upper-floor arrangements in traditional Ürgüp houses and Parcel 13: (a,b) traditional examples; (c) the arched balcony arrangement above the entrance in Parcel 13. Photographs: Authors, 2026.
On the western façade, an open balcony above the entrance door projects 1.00 m from the façade plane. Stone corbel-shaped elements beneath the balcony and a wrought-iron railing define its appearance. Like the balcony on the eastern façade of Parcel 1, this element is an open projection; however, it projects 0.25 m less than the 1.25 m deep balcony in Parcel 1 (Figure 20, Figure 21 and Figure 22). Its projection depth is assessed in relation to its location in Section 4.3.3, taking into account that the limit specified in provision Ysz/f.4 applies to street façades.
The courtyard boundary is defined by stone masonry walls 2.00 m high. The walls have no coping. A large wrought-iron gate provides pedestrian and vehicular access to the courtyard. Its openwork design allows visual connections between the courtyard and the street. Unlike Parcel 1, there is no separate second gate providing access to a garage.
The courtyard wall height meets the minimum requirement of 2.00 m specified in provision Ysz/k.2. However, the absence of coping differs from the requirement in provision Ysz/k.4 for the wall tops to be finished using one of the local coping treatments (Figure 22). The wrought-iron courtyard gate also differs from the timber gate requirement specified in provision Ysz/e.1. This distinction was considered separately from the prohibition of wire fencing above walls in provision Ysz/k.4. Wall height, coping, and gate material were therefore recorded individually rather than combined into a single overall compliance judgment.
The architectural character of the building group on Parcel 13 is defined by its independent building masses, dressed-stone-clad façades, horizontal mouldings, ornamented parapets, window surrounds that vary between storeys, and arched balconies. Formal relationships with local architecture are particularly evident in the parapet, window, and semi-open space details. The repetition of these elements across the two masses establishes continuity in materials and façade treatment throughout the parcel. Nevertheless, the formal similarities identified with local examples were not used as substitutes for assessing dimensional and material requirements; each architectural feature was considered separately in relation to the relevant plan provision.

4.3.3. Comparative Assessment in Relation to the Ürgüp Conservation Development Plan Provisions

The comparison of the building groups on Parcels 1 and 13 relates the characteristics documented through dimensioned architectural drawings and field surveys to the relevant CDP provisions. The assessment addresses parcel layout and building footprints, façade length, height, roofs, materials, openings, architectural elements, and courtyard arrangements. Conditions specifying numerical limits were assessed through dimensions and area calculations, while qualitative design principles were examined through documented architectural characteristics and relationships with local examples. The findings describe relationships between the plan text examined and the documented characteristics of the buildings; they do not constitute an assessment of the correctness of past approval procedures or institutional decisions.
Parcel Layout and Building Footprints
The combined footprint of the two principal building masses examined is 146.60 m2 on Parcel 1 and 345.32 m2 on Parcel 13. Dividing these values by the respective parcel areas gives ratios of 0.4394 (43.94%) and 0.1510 (15.10%). Both ratios, calculated for the principal masses examined, fall below the limit of 0.50 specified in provision Ysz/2 (Table 12).
Although the principal masses on Parcel 13 have a larger combined footprint, they occupy a smaller proportion of their parcel because of its greater area. On Parcel 1, the principal masses occupy a larger proportion of the parcel. This difference is considered alongside the arrangement of open spaces and the distances between the masses. A lower footprint-to-parcel-area ratio does not, by itself, indicate greater architectural compatibility with the historic environment.
Table 12. Footprints of the principal building masses examined, their ratios to parcel area, and comparison with provision Ysz/2. Source: Dimensioned architectural drawings, the Ürgüp CDP provisions, and the authors’ calculations.
Façade Lengths and Articulation of Building Masses
Both cases comprise two principal building masses. On Parcel 1, the intervening space is 3.20 m wide and was designed as an open terrace, although field observations identified glazing between its columns. On Parcel 13, the independent masses are separated by 6.00 m. The examined street-facing façades of Parcel 1 measure 9.60 m and 6.80 m. On Parcel 13, the examined street-facing façade of the first mass measures 10.00 m, while the examined street-facing segment of the second mass measures 2.70 m (Table 13).
Compared with the 10.00 m limit specified in provision Ysz/7, both examined façades of Parcel 1 are below the limit, while the examined façade of the first mass on Parcel 13 is at the limit. As the 2.70 m dimension on Parcel 13 refers only to a specific façade segment, it does not establish compliance for the full façade length of the second mass. The façade lengths of separate masses and the intervening distances were not treated as a single continuous façade length.
The requirement in Ysz/7 for façades exceeding 10 m in attached buildings to be articulated so that they are perceived as separate buildings must be considered in relation to the actual arrangement of the masses. Adding the lengths of the examined façade sections does not, by itself, establish the presence of a continuous façade to which this requirement applies.
Table 13. Street-facing façade lengths of the building masses and distances between them.
Building Height, Visible Storeys, and Plinth Height
Although both cases comprise a basement, ground floor, and first floor, the number of storeys visible from the street and the façade heights differ. On Parcel 1, the exposure of the basement levels towards Karağandere Street creates a three-storey appearance, with a height of 10.20 m including the parapet. On the northern and western façades, this height is 7.10 m. On Parcel 13, the height of the examined façades is 7.50 m including the standard parapet, increasing to 7.70 m at the raised, ornamented parapet sections. As the basements are not visible on the examined façades facing Karağandere Street, Parcel 13 presents only its ground and first floors to the streetscape (Table 14).
Table 14. Comparison of façade heights, numbers of storeys visible from Karağandere Street, and plinth heights on Parcels 1 and 13.
Rather than prescribing a fixed height limit in metres, provision Ysz/4 regulates the apparent number of storeys on the façade from which the building takes its reference level and its relationship to the urban silhouette. The provision also allows for Conservation Board assessment based on streetscape and building-envelope studies where necessary. Special provisions associated with the designated land use are also relevant to this assessment. Accordingly, the three-storey appearance of Parcel 1’s southern façade constitutes an important comparative finding but was not used to determine compliance independently of the reference level and any special provisions applicable to the parcel.
The plinth heights are 0.05 m on Parcel 1 and 0.50 m on Parcel 13. Both values are below the maximum of 1.00 m specified in provision Ysz/6. Plinth height and the exposure of a basement on another façade due to sloping terrain were treated as distinct characteristics.
Roof and Parapet Arrangements
Both cases have flat terrace roofs, one of the roof forms permitted under provision Ysz/c.1. The roof surfaces are finished with natural stone. However, Ysz/c.4 specifies not only a material type but also the use of local stone or materials compatible with its colour and texture. The presence of natural stone alone therefore does not establish that all aspects of the provision are satisfied.
The terrace roof slopes are 3% on Parcel 1 and 2% on Parcel 13. These values describe drainage falls on terrace roofs and are not assessed against the 40% limit specified for pitched roofs in provision Ysz/c.2. Neither roof storeys nor setback storeys are present in the documented floor arrangements. Stone-clad chimneys were the roof elements visible from the street during the field survey; no solar energy equipment was visible from the observation points used.
The principal difference between the cases concerns their parapet treatment. Parcel 1 has plain, unornamented parapets, whereas Parcel 13 features motifs and locally raised sections that articulate the upper façade termination. Within each parcel, the same parapet arrangement is repeated across the two building masses (Table 15).
Table 15. Comparison of roofs, parapets, and roof elements visible from the street.
Façade Materials and Ornamentation
Both cases have stone-clad façades. This feature corresponds to the requirement for stone or stone cladding on external façades in provision Ysz/a.3. Parcel 1 displays light cream tones approaching white, whereas Parcel 13 exhibits light beige and yellowish tones. The colour comparison is a qualitative assessment based on field observations and photographs; it does not represent measured colour values or establish a common provenance for the stones.
The treatment of stone surfaces and the distribution of architectural details distinguish the two cases. Parcel 1 features prominent corner elements, plain stringcourses and cornices, and unornamented parapets. Parcel 13 is characterised by ornamented mouldings and parapets, with decorative details also concentrated above selected ground-floor windows. The comparisons in the preceding subsections identify formal similarities between the parapet and window details of Parcel 13 and specific traditional examples.
Provision Ysz/b permits the use of architectural elements and ornamentation found in the traditional fabric in new buildings. Accordingly, neither the presence nor the concentration of ornamentation was treated as an inherently negative assessment criterion. The findings show that elements associated with local architectural references are incorporated into different façade compositions in the two cases (Table 16).
Table 16. Comparison of façade materials and visible architectural details.
The lithological type and quarry provenance of the stone, cladding thickness and fixing system, mortar composition, and joint dimensions cannot be inferred from visual similarities between façades. Correspondence with the stone-finish requirement was therefore not interpreted as demonstrating compliance with all aspects of the Ysz/a provisions or physical compatibility between new and traditional materials.
Window Dimensions and Façade Openings
Both cases feature rectangular windows with timber frames and stone surrounds. The window types identified measure 80 × 160 cm and 80 × 120 cm on Parcel 1, and 80 × 140 cm and 60 × 100 cm on Parcel 13. On Parcel 1, the basement façade of the first mass facing Karağandere Street has no openings. The basement façade of the second mass contains two windows measuring 80 × 120 cm. On Parcel 13, the 60 × 100 cm windows are located on the southern façade at ground- and first-floor levels.
The widths, heights, and width-to-height ratios of the window types examined fall within the ranges specified in provision Ysz/d.1. Timber frames correspond to the material requirement of the same provision, while stone surrounds are among the façade elements permitted under Ysz/d.2 (Table 17 and Table 18). These findings do not establish that other requirements, such as frame surface treatments or the vertical alignment of all windows, are also satisfied.
Table 17. Window types, frames, and surround characteristics.
Table 18. Comparison of the examined window characteristics with the Ysz/d provisions.
The subdivision of the frames and the detailing of the surrounds differ between the two cases. Parcel 1 has six-pane windows, whereas Parcel 13 has eight-pane windows. The surrounds on Parcel 1 have plain profiles. On Parcel 13, ornamentation appears in the upper sections of selected ground-floor window surrounds, while the first-floor surrounds are plainer.
Building Entrances, Courtyard Gates, and Commercial Openings
In both cases, the building masses have separate entrances fitted with timber doors. Parcel 1 features an asymmetrical arrangement comprising a wide main leaf and a narrow secondary leaf within a segmental-arched opening. Parcel 13 has double-leaf doors within semicircular arched openings. These arch forms are among those permitted under provision Ysz/e.4.
Different arrangements are used for courtyard and vehicular access. Parcel 1 has a double-leaf timber courtyard gate beneath a flat lintel and separate garage access, whereas pedestrian and vehicular access to Parcel 13 is provided through a wrought-iron courtyard gate. The wrought-iron courtyard gate on Parcel 13 and the additional iron gate providing access to the garage on Parcel 1 differ in material from the timber requirement specified in Ysz/e.1. These elements were assessed separately from the timber building entrance doors.
The garage door on Parcel 1 measures 300 × 270 cm, differing from the dimensions specified for street and courtyard gates in Ysz/e.2. As provision Ysz/e.4 allows designs with different dimensions to be assessed by the Conservation Board, the dimensional difference was recorded without drawing conclusions about the grounds for its approval. The wrought-iron element shown in front of the entrance in the project drawings but not installed on site was not treated as a component of the completed building (Table 19).
Table 19. Comparison of building entrances, courtyard gates, and commercial openings.
Traditional Architectural Elements and Projecting Bays and Balconies
Both cases incorporate semi-open upper-floor spaces defined by arched openings. In Parcel 1, these arrangements are associated with balconies and the space between the masses designed as an open terrace, where glazing between the columns was observed in the built condition. In Parcel 13, they are associated with small balconies above the entrances. Formal similarities with traditional examples concern the repetition of arches, subdivision by vertical supports, and the use of railings to define the boundaries of semi-open spaces.
Provision Ysz/b permits the use of local architectural elements, while Ysz/h defines the spatial and formal arrangement of the yazlık kemer. The four-opening composition on the western façade of Parcel 1 differs from the two- or three-opening arrangement specified in Ysz/h. However, rather than classifying every arched balcony as a yazlık kemer, the spatial character and position of each element within the building were considered. The difference in the number of openings was recorded within this typological comparison.
Parcel 1 has an enclosed rectangular projecting bay on its southern façade and an open projecting balcony on its eastern façade, while Parcel 13 has an open projecting balcony on its western façade. The enclosed bay on Parcel 1 shares formal characteristics with traditional examples through the projection of the upper-floor volume and the repetition of corbel-shaped elements beneath it. Nevertheless, a relationship with a local architectural form and compliance with a numerical projection-depth requirement constitute separate findings.
The enclosed bay on Parcel 1 projects 30 cm from the façade, exceeding the upper value of 25 cm in the 15–25 cm range specified in Ysz/f.3 by 5 cm. The open balconies project 125 cm on Parcel 1 and 100 cm on Parcel 13. These dimensions exceed the 80 cm value specified in Ysz/f.4 by 45 cm and 20 cm, respectively. However, this limit applies specifically to open projections on street façades. The numerical differences and the applicability of the provision to each projection were therefore considered separately. An eastern or western orientation alone was not treated as evidence that a projection is located on a street façade (Table 20).
Table 20. Comparison of semi-open spaces, projecting bays and balconies, and relevant plan conditions.
Solid–Void Relationships in Ground-Floor Façades
Provision Ysz/8 requires street-facing ground-floor façades to remain as solid as possible but does not specify a numerical threshold. Accordingly, the opening and solid surface ratios calculated for the examined ground-floor façades facing Karağandere Street and the western façades of Parcel 1 were compared. Detailed calculations by storey are presented in Section 4.3.1 and Section 4.3.2, while the ground-floor results are summarised in Table 21.
Table 21. Opening and solid surface ratios of the examined street-facing ground-floor façades.
Solid surfaces predominate on all the ground-floor façades and façade segments examined (Table 21). The highest opening ratio occurs on the western façade of the second mass on Parcel 1, where the commercial entrance and shopfront occupy a larger proportion of the façade than the openings facing Karağandere Street. Two of the measured surfaces contain no openings: the examined western segment of the first mass on Parcel 1 and the examined segment facing Karağandere Street on the second mass on Parcel 13. In both instances, the result applies only to the measured segment.
Courtyard Walls and Their Relationship to the Street
The courtyard walls of both parcels are constructed of stone masonry. On Parcel 1, their heights vary between 2.10 and 2.50 m in response to the sloping terrain, while those on Parcel 13 are 2.00 m high. These dimensions satisfy the minimum height requirement of 2.00 m specified in Ysz/k.2 at the measured sections. Although stone masonry corresponds to the construction method required by Ysz/k.3, stone provenance, dressing, and joint characteristics require separate assessment.
A clear difference concerns the treatment of the wall tops. The walls on Parcel 1 are finished with stone coping, whereas those on Parcel 13 have no coping. The latter condition does not satisfy the requirement in Ysz/k.4 for wall tops to be finished using one of the local coping treatments. Compliance with the wall-height requirement therefore does not establish that the coping requirement is also satisfied.
The courtyard gates create different visual relationships with the street. The main timber courtyard gate on Parcel 1 restricts views, while the wrought-iron gate on Parcel 13 allows the courtyard to be seen from the street. This characteristic relates to the gate’s degree of openness and was considered separately from wall height and solidity (Table 22). The wrought-iron gate was assessed with reference to the gate-material provisions in Ysz/e. The prohibition of wire fencing above walls in Ysz/k.4 was not interpreted as a prohibition of wrought-iron gates.
Table 22. Comparison of courtyard walls, coping, and access arrangements.
Architectural Continuity Between the Building Masses
The two principal masses within each parcel share characteristics in terms of façade materials, window types, floor levels, mouldings, and parapets. Plain profiles and unornamented parapets are repeated on Parcel 1, while ornamented mouldings and upper façade terminations recur on Parcel 13. Although window numbers differ between the masses on Parcel 13, the same window types and details are used. These repetitions establish a consistent façade treatment within each parcel (Table 23).
Table 23. Architectural relationships between the two principal building masses within each parcel.
Continuity between the masses describes the architectural relationships within each building group. Compatibility with the historic environment is considered separately in relation to street scale, neighbouring buildings, massing proportions, and local architectural examples.
Synthesis of Relationships with the Plan Provisions
The comparison demonstrates that the conditions within the same plan text require assessment through different architectural characteristics and types of evidence. The footprint-to-parcel-area ratios of the principal masses examined, plinth heights, and dimensions of the specified window types fall within the relevant numerical limits. Stone-clad façades, timber window frames, and flat terrace roofs also correspond to particular components of the relevant provisions. Conversely, the 30 cm projection of the enclosed bay on Parcel 1, the absence of coping on the courtyard walls of Parcel 13, and the metal gates in different locations in both cases depart from the relevant dimensional or material requirements. For open balconies, the numerical differences in projection depth must be considered alongside the condition that the provision applies to street façades.
With reference to Ysz/5, both cases incorporate elements that can be related to local architecture. On Parcel 1, these include the enclosed rectangular projecting bay, the courtyard gateway with a flat lintel, and arched arrangements associated with balconies and the space designed as an open terrace. On Parcel 13, parapet, window-surround, and arched balcony details provide documented evidence of such relationships. However, the presence of a local architectural element or a formal similarity to a traditional example does not, by itself, establish that the expectation for designs to be recognisably new and contemporary is satisfied. Similarly, plain detailing was not treated as inherently contemporary, nor ornamented detailing as inherently imitative.
Rather than assigning the building groups to overall categories such as “compatible/incompatible” or “interpretive/replicative”, the results identify which architectural characteristics correspond to particular provisions, which differ dimensionally or formally, and which conditions cannot be assessed using the available evidence. The comparative synthesis is presented in Table 24.
Table 24. Comparative synthesis of the Ysz provisions and the building characteristics examined.

5. Discussion

5.1. Qualitative Design Principles and Architectural Differentiation

The Ürgüp Conservation Development Plan regulates new development through more than numerical limits: it requires both compatibility with local architecture and the legibility of a building’s contemporary character. Provision Ysz/5 calls for designs that refer to local façade types and recall traditional architecture through their openings, dimensions, arrangement, and façade modulation, while remaining recognisably new and contemporary. Architectural differentiation between the cases examined therefore cannot be explained by an absence of qualitative design principles in the plan. The question concerns which architectural characteristics should inform the assessment of these principles and how the reasoning underlying that assessment can be documented.
The comparative findings show that both building groups incorporate local architectural elements but arrange them within different façade compositions. Parcel 1 is characterised by plain mouldings and parapets, prominent corner elements, an enclosed rectangular projecting bay, arched balcony and terrace arrangements, and a broad commercial opening. Parcel 13 features ornamented mouldings and parapets, decoration above selected ground-floor windows, and arched balconies. Detailed comparisons with local examples explain these relationships through identifiable architectural components. The difference between the cases lies less in whether they refer to local architecture than in the positioning, proportions, repetition, and compositional prominence of the selected elements.
The provisions permitting traditional architectural elements are important when interpreting these findings. The use of traditional forms and details is not, in itself, a negative design choice in a vernacular setting. Ornamented elements are insufficient to classify a building as inherently “replicative”, just as plain profiles do not establish that it is “contemporary”. Moreover, formal similarities with a traditional example do not demonstrate that it served as a direct design reference, that its spatial arrangement was reproduced, or that the same construction technique was used. Accordingly, this study describes formal similarities at the level of specific architectural elements, separately from interpretations of design intent.
Numerical conditions and architectural relationships with the historic environment also represent distinct levels of assessment. The footprint-to-parcel-area ratios of the principal masses examined fall below the limit specified in Ysz/2. This finding alone, however, does not establish the quality of façade composition, relationships with open spaces, or the legibility of contemporary design. In particular, the exposure of basement levels towards Karağandere Street on Parcel 1 demonstrates the need to consider the floor designations in the drawings alongside the storeys visible from the street. Two cases with the same floor arrangement can produce different streetscape appearances because of their relationships with the topography.
The contrast between the two ground-floor façades of the second mass on Parcel 1 illustrates why Ysz/8 calls for assessment at the level of the individual street façade. A single ratio for the building would obscure the larger share of openings on the western façade, where the entrance and shopfront serve the intended commercial use. Ysz/8 requires street-facing ground floors to remain as solid as possible but specifies no numerical threshold. The measured proportions therefore document how each façade relates to the provision, while any judgement of compliance requires an explicit rationale.
Formal relationships with local architecture do not establish that all relevant dimensional and detailing requirements are satisfied. The enclosed bay on Parcel 1 projects 30 cm, exceeding the upper value of 25 cm specified in Ysz/f.3. On Parcel 13, the absence of coping on the courtyard walls does not satisfy the wall-top treatment requirement in Ysz/k.4. These findings demonstrate that characteristics corresponding to plan provisions and details departing from them can coexist within the same case. However, how these differences arose during design or approval cannot be explained without revision records and documented decisions.
Within this framework, different architectural outcomes do not directly establish either the failure of the plan or inconsistency between approval authorities. The findings highlight the importance of an approach that extends beyond identifying individual elements, explains relationships between massing, façades, and streets, and specifies the scope of assessment when addressing compatibility and contemporary expression. The extent to which users or independent experts perceive these buildings as contemporary was not measured. The contribution of the study lies in presenting the architectural characteristics and their relationships to the provisions in a traceable manner, providing evidence that can inform such assessments without claiming to establish a perceptual judgment.

5.2. Conservation Instruments and the International Context

The assessment of the Ürgüp CDP gains a broader perspective when situated within international principles and local conservation instruments guiding new development in historic environments. UNESCO’s 2011 Recommendation on the Historic Urban Landscape extends the understanding of urban heritage beyond individual monuments or the boundaries of historic centres to encompass topography, historic and contemporary buildings, open spaces, patterns of use, and visual relationships. Paragraph 24 calls for regulatory systems that reflect local conditions and are supported by tools for safeguarding the diverse values of heritage [85].
The block-, parcel-, and street-scale analyses undertaken in this study relate to the physical and spatial dimensions of this approach. Alongside building footprints and façade details, the assessment considers how buildings occupy sloping terrain, relate to open spaces, and present different façades to surrounding streets. However, the study does not comprehensively examine the values attributed to local communities, economic processes, or experiences of use. It therefore does not claim to implement all components of the Historic Urban Landscape approach. The Recommendation is used as a conceptual framework for assessing the local conservation instrument, rather than as a document demonstrated to have directly informed the preparation of the Ürgüp CDP.
The implementation of conservation objectives through detailed local regulations is not unique to Türkiye. A 2021 statement by the Municipality of Bologna explains that local regulations for protecting the historic city encompass not only nationally protected buildings but also other buildings recognised as valuable by the municipality, thereby complementing protection at the national level. The same statement highlights the need to consider conservation requirements alongside interventions intended to improve building energy performance [86]. This example is used to illustrate the complementary operation of national and local conservation instruments, rather than to suggest equivalence with Ürgüp’s legal or approval system. The Ürgüp CDP should therefore be discussed as one of the instruments translating conservation objectives into local development conditions, rather than as an exception detached from international practice.
Applying the Venice Charter [29] to new building design requires consideration of the type and scale of the intervention. Article 9 concerns restoration and necessary additional work; Article 12 addresses the replacement of missing parts; and Article 13 concerns the effects of additions on a building’s significant components, traditional setting, composition, and relationships with its surroundings. Applying these provisions to independent new buildings in historic environments requires acknowledging the distinction between completing an existing monument and designing a building on a separate parcel. Accordingly, this study does not conclude that all new buildings in historic environments must necessarily create a pronounced formal contrast.
The international framework shifts the discussion beyond preferences for traditional or contemporary forms towards the instruments through which conservation objectives are articulated and assessed. For Ürgüp, the central issue is how the plan’s existing qualitative principles can be connected to local architectural characteristics, street relationships, and documented design decisions. Additional planning guidance explaining these connections may make assessment criteria more explicit, but formal amendments remain necessary to change the plan’s binding provisions.

5.3. Institutional Context and Limits of Inference

The project on Parcel 13 was approved by the Regional Conservation Board, while the project on Parcel 1 was approved under the authority of the Cappadocia Area Presidency (Kapadokya Alan Başkanlığı). The initial building permits also place the two developments in different periods, with the permit for Parcel 13 issued in 2018 and that for Parcel 1 in 2023 (Table 8). Between these two permit dates, the institutional framework for conservation in Cappadocia changed with the establishment of the Cappadocia Area Presidency under Presidential Decree No. 38, published in the Official Gazette on 1 June 2019 [87].
The effects of the approval authority, the plan version used in assessment, investor briefs, designer preferences, parcel size, and topography on architectural outcomes were not isolated from one another. Differences between the cases are therefore not presented as evidence that the authorities adopted different design approaches or required particular design decisions. Comparison with the plan text examined likewise does not establish that this text was applied in the same manner throughout all approval stages of both projects.
Dimensioned architectural drawings and photographs of the initial building permits were obtained for both cases. However, this study does not include a sequence of documents allowing changes, revision requests, and design responses to be traced from the initial submission to final approval. It therefore does not claim that a particular façade, massing, or detailing decision resulted from an institutional requirement. As an examination of the architectural characteristics of completed buildings, this study does not represent the experiences of other projects that were rejected, halted, unbuilt, or modified during the process. Assessing the broader performance of the conservation instrument in practice requires research encompassing these project trajectories.
The findings cover all completed new developments in the selected block at the end of the fieldwork period, but their applicability to other parts of Ürgüp or to other conservation areas remains to be examined.
The inclusion of Zeki Derin, the designer of the development on Parcel 1, among the authors is relevant to potential evaluative bias. Applying the same analytical criteria to both cases, distinguishing project data from field observations, and presenting dimensions alongside their sources make the comparison traceable. No overall compatibility scores or rankings of architectural merit were assigned. These methodological choices do not eliminate researcher interpretation or substitute for independent validation. In particular, the selection of local references and the interpretation of qualitative architectural relationships should be considered within this limitation.
Explicit calculation boundaries are also necessary to delimit the inferences drawn. The footprint-to-parcel-area ratios refer to the two principal masses on each parcel; they are not presented as comprehensive site coverage ratio (TAKS) calculations encompassing all building components within the parcels. Total floor area, including basements, was not treated as equivalent to floor area counted towards the floor area ratio. Façade opening ratios likewise represent only the specified façades or façade segments. The arched balcony voids on the western façade of Parcel 1 were identified separately from door and window openings and were excluded from the assessment of the ground-floor provision.
The material assessment is similarly limited to the available documents and observable surface characteristics. Where verified technical data on stone type and provenance, cladding fixings, mortar composition, or the fabrication of ornamental elements were unavailable, physical compatibility was not inferred from appearance. Formal similarity, material performance, and correspondence with plan conditions were thus maintained as distinct areas of assessment.

5.4. Recommendations for the Content of a Design Guide

The comparison identifies specific topics for developing a design guide that explains the existing provisions of the Ürgüp CDP and establishes measurement and documentation conventions. Such a guide should clearly distinguish binding plan provisions from illustrative examples and design recommendations. It should not be used to alter numerical limits or retrospectively deem documented departures compliant. Whether the plan provisions require amendment should be considered through broader evidence from practice and assessment by the relevant authorities.
Measurement and representation conventions. Illustrative drawings should clarify which building components are included in footprint calculations, the distinction between total floor area and floor area counted towards the floor area ratio, the start and end points of façade-length measurements, and the treatment of separate masses and façade segments. On sloping parcels, reference levels, exposed basements, and storeys visible from different streets should be shown in sections and streetscape elevations. Façade opening calculations should specify storey boundaries and explain how door and window openings and the voids of semi-open spaces, such as arched balconies, are treated. Where provisions contain no numerical threshold, calculation results should not automatically be converted into new compliance limits.
Local architectural references and material details. An inventory of traditional examples should be prepared, identifying their locations and documentary sources. Elements such as open and enclosed projections, angled and rectangular projecting bays, yazlık kemer, eyvan, and divanhane should be explained through their spatial organisation and uses as well as their façade forms. Window surrounds, mouldings, corbels, parapets, and coping should be documented through dimensioned drawings and photographs. Material records should include stone type and provenance, cladding thickness and fixings, mortar and joint characteristics, and the fabrication techniques of ornamental elements. The inventory should serve as a reference for understanding local architecture rather than as a catalogue of forms to be reproduced identically.
Explaining compatibility and contemporary expression together. Comparative examples should demonstrate how the same local reference can inform different architectural solutions. Massing proportions, façade rhythm, opening arrangements, materials, and street scale should be considered together, with explicit reasoning concerning the design’s relationship to the historic environment and the expression of its identity as a new building. Contemporary expression should not be defined solely through the absence of ornamentation, nor a relationship with the traditional setting solely through the use of stone or arches. Assessments should distinguish characteristics established through measurement, observation, and interpretation.
Relationships between parcels, open spaces, and streets. In addition to façade details, the guide should address the positioning of masses within parcels, the spaces between them, courtyards and terraces, entrances, and garden boundaries. Courtyard wall heights and coping, the visual permeability of gates, vehicular entrances, and commercial openings should be assessed alongside streetscape elevations. Particularly on sloping sites, the façades of the same building as seen from different streets should be presented together.
Decision-making and implementation records. Project files should link the applicable plan version, relevant provision, assessment date, decision-making authority, rationale, and any revisions. Documenting the grounds on which alternative solutions were assessed and comparing completed developments with approved drawings could establish a traceable documentary basis for subsequent research. Such records could support a more robust examination of the relationships between the application of plan provisions, investor briefs, and designer preferences.
These recommendations do not constitute a scoring system validated within this study or a guide whose effectiveness in practice has been demonstrated. Developing and testing the guide remains a task for further work involving the relevant conservation authorities, local governments, designers, and local stakeholders. The contribution of the two cases is to identify concrete measurement, documentation, and justification procedures that could support the application of existing principles.

6. Conclusions

This study compared the two completed developments on Parcels 1 and 13 in Block 1467 of the Ürgüp Urban Conservation Area against the measurable conditions and qualitative design principles of the CDP.
Examination of the plan text showed that its provisions for new development combine measurable conditions, requirements concerning materials and architectural elements, and expectations of compatibility and contemporary expression. Architectural differences between the cases therefore cannot be explained by an absence of qualitative design principles. Both cases display formal relationships with local architecture, while differing in their selection of elements, distribution of ornamentation, arrangement of openings, and relationships between building masses and streets. These findings were described without assigning the building groups to overall “replicative” or “interpretive” categories.
The footprint-to-parcel-area ratios of the principal masses examined, the plinth heights, and the dimensions of the documented window types fall within the relevant limits. On Parcel 1, openings occupy a greater proportion of the western commercial frontage than of the Karağandere Street frontage of the same building mass, highlighting the importance of assessing each street façade individually.
The comparison also showed that characteristics corresponding to plan conditions and those departing from them can coexist within the same case. The projection depth of the enclosed bay on Parcel 1 and the absence of coping on the courtyard walls of Parcel 13 depart from the conditions specified in the relevant provisions. Consequently, meeting a single numerical limit or incorporating traditional architectural elements should not be interpreted as establishing overall regulatory compliance or architectural compatibility.
The study’s contribution lies in explicitly linking individual plan provisions to documented architectural evidence and the assessments derived from it. It does not establish design intentions or isolate the causal effects of approval authorities on architectural decisions. The findings are limited to one block and two parcel-based cases. The involvement of one author as the designer of the building group on Parcel 1 and the absence of independent expert validation must also be considered, particularly when interpreting the qualitative findings.
A supplementary design guide is recommended to clarify measurement conventions, local architectural references, and assessment rationales associated with the existing plan. Future research encompassing completed developments in other blocks, alongside rejected, halted, and revised projects, could provide a more comprehensive understanding of how conservation instruments operate in practice. Independent expert and user assessments could address perceptions of compatibility and contemporary expression that were not measured in this study.
Although legislation and institutional procedures governing new building design in historic environments vary between countries, safeguarding cultural heritage and transmitting it to future generations remain shared responsibilities. By examining a planning context specific to Cappadocia, this study contributes to the wider discussion through a transparent, evidence-based account of the relationships between local conservation provisions and completed buildings. Its broader relevance lies in this approach to assessment rather than in proposing a particular architectural solution for other settlements. From the perspective of sustainable conservation, the assessment of new development should consider the values of the historic fabric, the continuity of existing buildings, and changing use requirements together. The strength of conservation instruments lies not only in setting limits but also in making explicit the evidence and reasoning used to assess both numerical conditions and qualitative expectations.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, E.E.Y.; methodology, E.E.Y.; validation, E.E.Y.; formal analysis, E.E.Y.; investigation, E.E.Y. and Ö.Ş.; resources, Z.D.; data curation, Ö.Ş.; writing—original draft preparation, E.E.Y.; writing—review and editing, E.E.Y., Ö.Ş. and Z.D.; visualization, Ö.Ş.; supervision, E.E.Y.; project administration, Z.D. Z.D. was the lead architect of the building on Parcel No. 1 examined in this study; this role is declared in the Conflicts of Interest section. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research received no external funding.

Data Availability Statement

The analytical results and supporting illustrations are presented in the article. Publicly available documentary sources are cited in the references. Additional field documentation and calculation data are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. Sharing architectural drawings obtained from designers’ archives is subject to permission from the respective rights holders.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank architect Osman Güngör for providing access to the architectural drawings for Parcel 13 from the archive of his father, architect Aziz Güngör. During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used Claude Sonnet 5.5 (Anthropic) for translation, English-language editing, and assistance with manuscript structure and consistency checks. The authors reviewed and revised the resulting text and take full responsibility for the analyses, interpretations, and final content of the manuscript.

Conflicts of Interest

Zeki Derin, a co-author of this study, was the lead architect of the development on Parcel 1. The development on Parcel 13 was designed by Aziz Güngör, who is not an author of this study. Zeki Derin’s dual role as designer and co-author is disclosed as a potential source of bias in the qualitative assessment of the two developments. The authors declare no other conflicts of interest.

Abbreviations

CDPConservation Development Plan
mMetre
cmCentimetre

References

  1. Ahunbay, Z. Tarihi Çevre Koruma ve Restorasyon, 5th ed.; YEM Yayınları: İstanbul, Türkiye, 2009. [Google Scholar]
  2. Tanaç Zeren, M. Tarihi Çevrede Yeni Ek ve Yeni Yapı Olgusu: Çağdaş Yaklaşım Örnekleri, 1st ed.; Yalın Yayıncılık: İstanbul, Türkiye, 2010. [Google Scholar]
  3. Asatekin, N.G. Kültür ve Doğa Varlıklarımız: Neyi, Niçin, Nasıl Korumalıyız? Kültür Varlıkları ve Müzeler Genel Müdürlüğü Yayınları: Ankara, Türkiye, 2004.
  4. UNESCO. Vienna Memorandum on “World Heritage and Contemporary Architecture—Managing the Historic Urban Landscape” and Decision 29 COM 5D. Available online: https://whc.unesco.org/en/documents/5965 (accessed on 18 June 2026).
  5. Kuban, D. Kültürel Gelişmeler ve Tarihi Çevrenin Korunması. Mimarlık 1975, 5, 21–23. [Google Scholar]
  6. UNESCO. Recommendation on the Historic Urban Landscape. Adopted by the General Conference at its 36th Session, Paris, France, 10 November 2011. Available online: https://whc.unesco.org/document/160163 (accessed on 29 October 2026).
  7. Strappa, G. The Notion of Enclosure in the Formation of a Special Building Type. In Typological Process and Design Theory; Petruccioli, A., Ed.; Aga Khan Program for Islamic Architecture at Harvard University and Massachusetts Institute of Technology: Cambridge, MA, USA, 1988; pp. 90–94. [Google Scholar]
  8. Cambaz, C. Tarihi Kentsel Mekanlarda Yer Duygusu ve Yeni Yapı Tasarımı İlişkisi Üzerine Bir İnceleme. Master’s Thesis, Yıldız Teknik Üniversitesi, İstanbul, Türkiye, 2009. [Google Scholar]
  9. Batur, A. Tarihi Çevre Korumasında Siyasal ve İdeolojik Boyutlar. Mimarlık 1975, 5, 14–17. [Google Scholar]
  10. Kuban, D. Tarihi Çevre Korumanın Mimarlık Boyutu; YEM Yayın: İstanbul, Türkiye, 2000. [Google Scholar]
  11. Alsaç, Ü. Türkiye’de Restorasyon; İletişim Yayınları: İstanbul, Türkiye, 1992. [Google Scholar]
  12. Hazbei, M.; Cucuzzella, C. Revealing a Gap in Parametric Architecture’s Address of “Context”. Buildings 2023, 13, 3136. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  13. Akbıyık, N. Tarihi Çevrede Yeni Yapı Olgusu ve Bağlam İlişkisinin Güncel Uygulamalar Üzerinden İncelenmesi. Master’s Thesis, İstanbul Aydın Üniversitesi, İstanbul, Türkiye, 2013. [Google Scholar]
  14. Kaçar, A.; Semerci, F. Tarihi Yapılara Eklemlenen Yeni Ek Yapının Uyumluluğu: Elbphilharmonie Kültür Merkezi. Turk. Online J. Des. Art. Commun. 2022, 12, 240–257. [Google Scholar]
  15. Cantacuzino, S. New Uses for Old Buildings; Whitney Library of Design: New York, NY, USA, 1975. [Google Scholar]
  16. Brolin, B.C. Architecture in Context: Fitting New Buildings with Old; Van Nostrand Reinhold: New York, NY, USA, 1980. [Google Scholar]
  17. Semes, S.W. The Future of the Past: A Conservation Ethic for Architecture, Urbanism, and Historic Preservation; W.W. Norton & Company: New York, NY, USA, 2009. [Google Scholar]
  18. Arslan, H.D.; Orhan, Ş.B.; Dişli, G. Tarihi Çevrede Yeni Yapı Tasarımının Müze İşlevi Özelinde Değerlendirilmesi. SDÜ ART-E Güzel Sanatlar Fakültesi Sanat Derg. 2020, 13, 71–101. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  19. Saf, H.O. New Building Design in Historic Environments and an Unconventional Example: Kaiserbad. Buildings 2026, 16, 3533. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  20. Rodwell, D. Conservation and Sustainability in Historic Cities; Blackwell Publishing: Oxford, UK, 2007. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  21. Khalil, I.; Üzümcüoğlu, D. Advancing Sustainability and Heritage Preservation through a Novel Framework for the Adaptive Reuse of Mediterranean Earthen Houses. Sustainability 2025, 17, 6447. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  22. Olgun, T.N.; Akarsu, İ.K. Examining the Open Building Movement through the Adaptive Reuse of Toma Church in Turkiye. Open House Int. 2026, 51, 99–127. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  23. Choi, J. Understanding the Role of Processes in Shaping the Compatibility of Contemporary Architecture in Historical Urban Environments. Buildings 2025, 15, 247. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  24. Mısırlısoy, D. New Designs in Historic Context: Starchitecture vs. Architectural Conservation Principles. Civ. Eng. Archit. 2017, 5, 207–214. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  25. Semes, S.W. Differentiated and Compatible: Four Strategies for Additions to Historic Settings. In Sense of Place: Design Guidelines for New Construction in Historic Districts; Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia: Philadelphia, PA, USA, 2007; pp. 4–11. [Google Scholar]
  26. Yüceer, H.; İpekoğlu, B. An Architectural Assessment Method for New Exterior Additions to Historic Buildings. J. Cult. Herit. 2012, 13, 419–425. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  27. Yüceer, H. An Evaluation of Interventions in Architectural Conservation: New Exterior Additions to Historic Buildings. Ph.D. Thesis, İzmir Teknoloji Üniversitesi, İzmir, Türkiye, 2005. [Google Scholar]
  28. Lardinois, S.; Arato Gonçalves, A.P.; Matarese, L.; Macdonald, S. (Eds.) Contemporary Architecture in the Historic Environment: An Annotated Bibliography; The Getty Conservation Institute: Los Angeles, CA, USA, 2015. [Google Scholar]
  29. ICOMOS. Venice Charter. 1964. Available online: https://civvih.icomos.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Charter-of-Venice_1964.pdf (accessed on 10 January 2026).
  30. ICOMOS. Charter For the Conservation of Historic Towns and Urban Areas. 1987. Available online: https://civvih.icomos.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Charter-of-Washington_10_1987.pdf (accessed on 21 July 2026).
  31. ICOMOS. Xi’an Declaration on the Conservation of the Setting of Heritage Structures, Sites and Areas. 2005. Available online: https://www.icomos.org/images/DOCUMENTS/Charters/xian-declaration.pdf (accessed on 16 August 2026).
  32. ICOMOS. The Valletta Principles for the Safeguarding and Management of Historic Cities, Towns and Urban Areas 2011. Available online: https://civvih.icomos.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Valletta-Principles-GA-_EN_FR_28_11_2011.pdf (accessed on 20 May 2026).
  33. Yavuz, Z. Eski Yapılar ile İlişkili Yeni Mimari Tasarımların Güncel Örnekler Üzerinden İncelenmesi. Master’s Thesis, Gazi Üniversitesi, Ankara, Türkiye, 2020. [Google Scholar]
  34. T.C. Kültür ve Turizm Bakanlığı. Koruma Amaçlı İmar Planları ve Çevre Düzenleme Projelerinin Hazırlanması, Gösterimi, Uygulaması, Denetimi ve Müelliflerine İlişkin Usul ve Esaslara Ait Yönetmelik. Resmî Gazete 2005, 25887. [Google Scholar]
  35. Madran, E.; Özgönül, N. Kültürel ve Doğal Değerlerin Korunması; TMMOB Mimarlar Odası Yayınları: Ankara, Türkiye, 2005. [Google Scholar]
  36. UNESCO World Heritage Centre. Göreme National Park and the Rock Sites of Cappadocia—Maps; UNESCO World Heritage Centre: Paris, France, 2012; Available online: https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/357/maps/?utm (accessed on 6 November 2026).
  37. UTTA Planlama Projelendirme Danışmanlık Tic. Ltd. Şti. Ürgüp (Nevşehir) Koruma Amaçlı İmar Planı: Plan Hükümleri; UTTA Planlama Projelendirme Danışmanlık Tic. Ltd. Şti.: Ankara, Türkiye, 2014. Sections III.4.1.1, III.4.1.2.1, V.1.2.3.1 and V.1.3.4.4. (In Turkish) [Google Scholar]
  38. Feilden, M.B. Conservation of Historic Buildings; Butterworth Scientific: London, UK, 1982. [Google Scholar]
  39. Arabacıoğlu, P.; Aydemir, I. Tarihi Çevrelerde Yeniden Değerlendirme Kavramı. Megaron 2007, 2, 204–212. [Google Scholar]
  40. Karakul, Ö. Değişim, Süreklilik, Uyum Üçgeninde Tarihi Çevrede Yeni Yapı. TMMOB Mimar. Odası Ank. Şubesi Dosya Derg. 2009, 14, 50–57. [Google Scholar]
  41. Eldem, N. Tarih Bilinci ve Çağdaş Kişilik. Arradamento Dekor 1992, 5, 100–101. [Google Scholar]
  42. Hu, Y.; Heath, T.; Tang, Y.; Zhang, Q. Using Quantitative Analysis to Assess the Appropriateness of Infill Buildings in Historic Settings. J. Archit. Plan. Res. 2017, 34, 91–113. [Google Scholar]
  43. ICOMOS. Council of Europe. The Declaration of Amsterdam; Congress on the European Architectural Heritage: Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1975; Available online: https://civvih.icomos.org/1975-the-declaration-of-amsterdam/ (accessed on 4 January 2026).
  44. UNESCO. General Conference, Nairobi. 1976. Available online: https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000253534 (accessed on 18 June 2026).
  45. Erkartal, P.Ö.; Özüer, M.O. Tarihi Dokuyu Taklit Etme/Yok Sayma? In Fill in the Blanks: Fener-Balat Çalıştayı 2015; Öymen Gür, Ş., Evcil, A.N., Öktem Erkartal, P., Eds.; Beykent Üniversitesi Yayınları: İstanbul, Türkiye, 2016; pp. 121–129. [Google Scholar]
  46. Davies, M. Design in the Historic Environment. The Building Conservation Presidency. 2003. Available online: https://www.buildingconservation.com/articles/design/design.htm (accessed on 15 May 2026).
  47. Enç, G. Tarihi Kent Dokusunda Yeni Yapı Tasarım Ölçütleri ve Fener Semti Örneğinde Uygulanabilirliğinin İrdelenmesi. Master’s Thesis, Yıldız Teknik Üniversitesi, İstanbul, Türkiye, 2009. [Google Scholar]
  48. Doğrusöz, N.S. Tarihi ve Özgün Çevrelerde Yeni Yapı Sorunu ve “Infill” Olgusuna Farklı Yaklaşımlar. Master’s Thesis, İstanbul Teknik Üniversitesi, İstanbul, Türkiye, 1994. [Google Scholar]
  49. Aydın, E. Tarihi Çevre İçindeki Yeni Yapılaşmaların Uygulama Sonuçları. Master’s Thesis, Mimar Sinan Güzel Sanatlar Üniversitesi, İstanbul, Türkiye, 1998. [Google Scholar]
  50. Düzgün, H. Tarihi Çevrelerde Yeni Yapı Tasarımında Kabuk—Bağlam İlişkisinin Temel ve Güncel Tasarım Kavramları Açısından İncelenmesi. Master’s Thesis, Yıldız Teknik Üniversitesi, İstanbul, Türkiye, 2010. [Google Scholar]
  51. Duralı, İ.K. Tarihi Çevrede Yeni Yapılaşma Uygulamalarının İrdelenmesi. Master’s Thesis, Mimar Sinan Güzel Sanatlar Üniversitesi, İstanbul, Türkiye, 2007. [Google Scholar]
  52. Sivil, L.E.; Dabanlı, Ö. Tasarım ve Koruma İlkeleri Bağlamında Çağdaş Ek. Yapı Dergisi. 2022. Available online: https://yapidergisi.com/tasarim-ve-koruma-ilkeleri-baglaminda-cagdas-ek/ (accessed on 18 June 2026).
  53. Venturi, R. Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture; The Museum of Modern Art: New York, NY, USA, 1966. [Google Scholar]
  54. Büyükmıhçı, G.; Kılıç, A. Tarihi Dokuda Yeni Yapı Uygulamaları: Yasal ve Eylemsel Sınırlar. In Proceedings of the 9th Uluslararası Sinan Sempozyumu, Edirne, Türkiye, 21–22 April 2015; Trakya University: Edirne, Turkey, 2015; pp. 125–132. [Google Scholar]
  55. Özkaraca Özalp, N.; Halaç, H.H.; Özalp, M.F.; Bademci, F. Analyzing the “Opposite” Approach in Additions to Historic Buildings Using Visual Attention Tools: Dresden Military History Museum Case. J. Eye Mov. Res. 2026, 19, 7. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  56. Khalaf, R.W. The Implementation of the UNESCO World Heritage Convention: Continuity and Compatibility as Qualifying Conditions of Integrity. Heritage 2020, 3, 384–401. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  57. Bektaş, C. Çağdaş Tasarımda Gelenekselin Korunması. Tasarım 1990, 7, 108–110. [Google Scholar]
  58. Bilgin Altınöz, A.G. Tarihi Dokuda ‘Yeni’nin İnşası. Ege Mimar. 2010, 75, 18–26. [Google Scholar]
  59. Sack, M. Eski ve Yeninin Bütünleşmesi. Mimar. Derg. 2001, 1, 44–45. [Google Scholar]
  60. Archdaily. Available online: https://www.archdaily.com/58695/atelier-bardill-valerio-olgiati (accessed on 30 October 2026).
  61. E-architect. Available online: https://www.e-architect.com/england/jerwood-gallery-hastings (accessed on 30 October 2026).
  62. Arquitecturaviva. Available online: https://arquitecturaviva.com/works/pabellones-de-arte-de-inujima-7 (accessed on 30 October 2026).
  63. Arquitecturaviva. Available online: https://arquitecturaviva.com/works/casa-b2-buykhusun-#lg=1&slide=0 (accessed on 30 October 2026).
  64. Archdaily. Available online: https://www.archdaily.com/55428/moderna-museet-malmo-tham-videgard-arkitekter (accessed on 1 July 2026).
  65. Bloszies, C. Old Buildings, New Designs: Architectural Transformations, 1st ed.; Princeton Architectural Press: New York, NY, USA, 2012. [Google Scholar]
  66. EAA. Available online: https://emrearolat.com/project/the-museum-hotel-antakya/ (accessed on 1 July 2026).
  67. Arkitektuel. Odunpazarı Modern Müze/Kengo Kuma & Associates. Available online: https://www.arkitektuel.com/odunpazari-modern-muze/ (accessed on 5 November 2026).
  68. Arkitera. Available online: https://www.arkitera.com/proje/beyazit-devlet-kutuphanesi-renovasyon-projesi/ (accessed on 29 October 2026).
  69. EAA. Available online: https://emrearolat.com/project/santralistanbul-contemporary-arts-museum/ (accessed on 1 July 2026).
  70. Özden, P.P. Kentsel Yenileme: Yasal Yönetsel Boyut, Planlama ve Uygulama; İmge Kitabevi Yayınları: Ankara, Türkiye, 2016. [Google Scholar]
  71. Levent, Y. Tarihi Çevre Koruma Mevzuatına Genel Bir Bakış, Tarihi Çevrede Koruma: Yaklaşımlar Uygulamalar. Dosya Derg. 2009, 14, 62–68. [Google Scholar]
  72. Coşkun, B.; Kurt, H. Türkiye’de Kültürel Mirasın Korunması: Tarihsel Gelişim ve Yerel Yönetimlerin Rolü. Türk İdare Derg. 2021, 93, 81–106. [Google Scholar]
  73. T.C. 2863 Sayılı Kültür ve Tabiat Varlıklarını Koruma Kanunu; 1983. T.C. Mevzuat Bilgi Sistemi. Available online: https://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/mevzuat?MevzuatNo=2863&MevzuatTur=1&MevzuatTertip=5 (accessed on 20 May 2026).
  74. T.C. 3194 Sayılı İmar Kanunu; 1985. T.C. Mevzuat Bilgi Sistemi. Available online: https://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/mevzuat?MevzuatNo=3194&MevzuatTur=1&MevzuatTertip=5 (accessed on 20 May 2026).
  75. T.C. 5366 Sayılı Yıpranan Tarihi ve Kültürel Taşınmaz Varlıkların Yenilenerek Korunması ve Yaşatılarak Kullanılması Hakkında Kanun; 16 June 2005. T.C. Mevzuat Bilgi Sistemi. Available online: https://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/mevzuat?MevzuatNo=5366&MevzuatTur=1&MevzuatTertip=5 (accessed on 20 May 2026).
  76. Comune di Bologna. Regolamento Urbanistico Edilizio (RUE); Comune di Bologna: Bologna, Italy, 2009. Available online: https://sit.comune.bologna.it/alfresco/d/d/workspace/SpacesStore/6da15be7-16dd-4f40-af43-056d24a965ab/Rue_vigore.pdf (accessed on 6 November 2026). (In Italian)
  77. Historic England. Available online: https://historicengland.org.uk/ (accessed on 5 November 2026).
  78. Bowen, G.A. Document Analysis as a Qualitative Research Method. Qual. Res. J. 2009, 9, 27–40. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  79. Ürgüp (Nevşehir) Koruma Amaçlı İmar Planı: Araştırma Raporu [Conservation Development Plan of Ürgüp (Nevşehir): Research Report]; UTTA Planlama Projelendirme Danışmanlık Tic. Ltd. Şti.: Ankara, Türkiye, 2014. (In Turkish)
  80. Dırık, A. Geleneksel Sivil Mimari Doku Üzerinden 19. Yüzyıl Gayrimüslim Yapılarının İncelenmesi: Ürgüp Örneği. Master’s Thesis, Hacettepe Üniversitesi, Ankara, Türkiye, 2021. [Google Scholar]
  81. Ürgüp Belediyesi. Available online: https://urgup.bel.tr/tr/urgupte-mimari (accessed on 14 June 2026).
  82. Büyükmıhçı, G.; Akşehirlioğlu, A.; Mengüç, K.G. Tarihi Çevrede Yeni Yapı Tasarımında Birleşim Biçimleri Bağlamında Modern Yaklaşımlar; Güven Plus Grup A.Ş. Yayınları: İstanbul, Türkiye, 2019; pp. 323–350. Available online: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/340226312_ (accessed on 16 December 2020).
  83. Dırık, A. Geleneksel Ürgüp Evlerinde Giriş Kapıları Üzerine Bir Tipoloji Çalışması. Mimar. VE Yaşam Derg. 2022, 7, 123–142. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  84. Esmer, M.A. Avanos’un Eski Evleri; Kültür Bakanlığı Yayınları: Ankara, Türkiye, 1984.
  85. UNESCO. Recommendation on the Historic Urban Landscape, Including a Glossary of Definitions; United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization: Paris, France, 2011; Available online: https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/recommendation-historic-urban-landscape-including-glossary-definitions (accessed on 6 November 2026).
  86. Comune di Bologna. Question Time, Chiarimenti sul Superbonus 110; Comune di Bologna: Bologna, Italy, 2021. Available online: https://www.comune.bologna.it/novita/comunicati-stampa/question-time-chiarimenti-sul-superbonus-110 (accessed on 6 November 2026).
  87. Presidency of the Republic of Türkiye. Kapadokya Alan Başkanlığı Hakkında Cumhurbaşkanlığı Kararnamesi [Presidential Decree on the Cappadocia Area Presidency]; Presidential Decree No. 38; No. 30791; Resmî Gazete: Ankara, Türkiye, 2019. Available online: https://kapadokyaalan.ktb.gov.tr/documents/cbkararname.pdf (accessed on 6 November 2026). (In Turkish)
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Article metric data becomes available approximately 24 hours after publication online.