Review Reports
- Giuseppe Giardullo 1,2,
- Manuele Taleb 1,2 and
- Rosario Ceruso 1,2
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Adam Baxter-Jones Reviewer 2: Nicholas Ripley Reviewer 3: Angelos Kyranoudis Reviewer 4: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsPlease see the attachment.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
We sincerely thank Reviewer 1 for the thoughtful and constructive feedback. We have revised the manuscript accordingly, and we provide point-by-point responses below.
Comment: This paper identifies the importance of growth, development, maturation and sport specific training on the development of performance in youth athletes. It is noted that there is great variability during the pubertal years in size related to maturity status. The aim of this investigation is to control size in age groupings and then determine performance. The results show what is expected that performance increases with age category. However, although organized into age categories, no attempt was made to describe their maturity. This is surprising given there are many ways to predict either PHV or percentage adult stature. This seems problematic given the author’s indication of its importance to performance. This is important because its not just physical size that affects performance but also metabolic changes associated with maturity.
Response: We agree that biological maturation can substantially influence performance through both anthropometric and physiological changes. In this study, we did not collect the information required to compute maturity indicators (e.g., maturity offset/years from PHV or % predicted adult stature). We therefore (i) strengthened the Limitations section to explicitly acknowledge the absence of maturation assessment as a major limitation; (ii) revised the Introduction and Discussion to avoid over-emphasizing PHV as an explanatory variable; and (iii) clarified that our intent was to describe age-category differences under applied academy constraints using routinely available measures (age, stature, body mass), and that mechanistic inferences regarding maturation cannot be made. We also added a clear recommendation for future work to integrate validated maturation assessments.
Comment: The Lines 40-56. First paragraph provides a well thought out and concise review of the issues between growth, development, maturation and performance in sporting youth. Suggest it concludes with what this paper will add to this body of literature.
Response: We revised the end of this paragraph to more explicitly state the knowledge gap and what our study adds (i.e., an applied, field-based description of physical performance profiles across academy age categories while statistically accounting for body size), and we stated our specific study purpose immediately thereafter.
Comment: Line 62: Define peak height velocity.
Response: We have defined peak height velocity (PHV) at first mention as the period during adolescence at which the rate of increase in stature is maximal (i.e., the peak of the growth spurt), and we clarified why PHV is commonly used as a maturation-related reference point in youth-sport research.
Comment: Line 102: the participants are well described, however, their level of talent within age groups is not identified.
Response: We agree and have clarified the competitive/talent level of the players within each age group (academy tier and training/competition context) in the Participants subsection. Where formal selection level/ranking was not available, we have stated this explicitly and described the academy setting to aid interpretation and reproducibility.
Comment: The study design and assessment procedures used are well described and the results well described. Performance improved with age. One thing missing is the parameters associated with the prediction of each specific task..
Response: Thank you for this suggestion. We added the key calculation parameters for each test (e.g., how sprint time was derived, how jump height was computed, and how 45-15 performance was summarized), and we clarified any device/software used where applicable. This information is now reported in the Assessment Procedures subsection to improve transparency and replicability.
Comment: The discussion is relevant to the results presented. However not measuring maturity is a major concern and its inclusion would improve the understanding of the results.
Response: We agree. We expanded the Discussion to more carefully separate the effects of age category and body size from unmeasured biological maturation, and we tempered interpretations accordingly. We also added explicit language indicating that maturation-related neuromuscular and metabolic changes may partly explain the between-category differences observed, but cannot be quantified in the present dataset.
Comment: At present the results are not novel and just indicate (in a small sample) what is already known.
Response: We understand this concern. To improve the contribution of the manuscript, we (i) clarified the applied rationale (field-based profiling using routinely collected data), (ii) strengthened the practical implications for practitioners working in academy settings, and (iii) explicitly positioned the findings as descriptive and exploratory, rather than claiming novelty in the age-related trend itself.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsGeneral comments
This is a nice study with some interesting implications for practitioners; there is a good level of analysis and detail provided. However, further identification of limitation and aspects related to performance should be acknowledged.
Specific comments
L15 – Some identification and exploration within the methods around some of these characteristics being non-modifiable should be performed to support the findings of the manuscript.
L18 – A study is inanimate and can not aim, this should be amended throughout.
L22 – What age is junior?
L33 – delete “in the present sample” as this takes away from your findings.
Key words – ensure they are not replicated within the introduction. They should be unique but associated words.
Introduction
L43 – “age-appropriate training” such as?
L45 – Chronological age, I would suggest exploring how and why here? Bio banding, playing in year of birth etc.
L48 – A reference is required after “youth football”
Salter, J., Forsdyke, D., Arenas, L., Dawson, Z., King, M., Myhill, N., Robinson, J., Towlson, C., Springham, M., Walsh, L., Mallinson-Howard, S., & Barrett, S. (2026). Differences in physical and technical performance characteristics between 11v11 chronological and bio-banded soccer match-play format in male youth soccer. Journal of science and medicine in sport, 29(3), 296–307. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsams.2025.09.006
L58 – You need to provide a reference after identifying the demands of soccer.
L96 – A study is inanimate and cannot investigate
Methods
L101 – Have you ran a-priori sample size estimation?
L163-164 – Using a contact grid requires a identification within the limitations with large overestimation due to changes in take-off and landing position (i.e., plantar vs. dorsi flexion and any changes in flight.
L164 – Define the calculation used to identify jump height with flight time.
Discussion
L238 – This is the first reference to this being a pilot study? What is it a pilot study too? This should be removed or clearly identified
L245 – What do you mean biological development? We know in academy they typically don’t get stronger relative to their mass but they run and jump faster. Thus, link to injury with increased momentum (greater mass and velocity), with lower ability to provide the required impulse to decelerate body mass.
Morris, Rhys O., et al. "Isometric midthigh pull characteristics in elite youth male soccer players: Comparisons by age and maturity offset." The Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research 34.10 (2020): 2947-295
L265-266 – Interesting that height didn’t have a relationship with jump height, this is despite the 6cm (average) decrease between jump height and U17 / junior. Any further explanation why? Relative contribution of stretch shortening cycle related to mass.
L293 – You don’t know if it is small, I agree it is a convenience but you have not ran sample size estimation so you do not know it is small based on expected findings.
L292 – You need to identify the limitations of the assessment methods used as they are not gold standard and should be identified.
L308 – Again, is it a pilot study?
Author Response
Please see the attachment
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsAbstarct:
- Lines 28 & 30: It must be clarified exactly what the word "category" refers to. Probably "age category".
- Both in abstract and section "Participants" must be clarified the specific age of "Junior", according the same way with U16 and U17.
- Generally, the word "football" or " soccer" must be used in all references (not both).
Introduction:
- Lines 54-56: The authors should analyze this view in greater detail and emphasize in biological maturation.
Study Design:
- The authors must explain with more details the study design. When the two training sessions were conducted in the week? How many days were beetween them? When the familiarisation session executed? When the tests executed? What was the break between tests?
- It is recommended that an image be included to illustrate the process.
- Why the authors used 3 tests to measure the explosiveness?
- The authors have to use a reference about the validity and reliability of the 45-15 test. They, also, have to explain the means that they used for this test (e.g. app?).
Discussion:
- The results' explanation has to take into account the biological maturity and the distance from PHV for each age.
- Did the authors consider whether the total duration of the measurements affected the results?
Author Response
Please see the attachment
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsIntroduction
In line 77, following citation [21], the authors introduce a shift in the focus of the argument that is not fully coherent or well connected with the preceding information. It is suggested to revise the wording, either by removing the section between lines 77 and 82 (prior to citations [21, 22]) or by reformulating it, in order to improve the coherence and flow of the text.
Additionally, one of the main limitations of the introduction is the emphasis placed on peak height velocity (PHV) as an explanatory factor, despite it not being included among the variables measured in the study.
Procedures
Another important limitation concerns the methodological sequence of the procedures. It is unclear how the authors justify the inclusion of physical fitness assessments at the end of a technical–tactical training session. What is the rationale behind this decision? While the aerobic test (45-15) might be administered following prior efforts (although this remains debatable), this approach is not appropriate for tests that assess the ability to produce force over time, such as vertical jump tests.
Results
It is recommended to include explanatory notes below each table.
Furthermore, after Table 2, effect sizes are reported despite not being previously described in the statistical analysis section. These should be formally included in that section, along with their corresponding interpretation criteria.
General comment
The study presents two limitations which, in my view, do not support its recommendation for publication in its current form; however, it could be considered for publication if the identified weaknesses are adequately addressed
- Somatic maturation is presented as a relevant factor for interpreting physical responses in youth soccer players; however, this variable was not included in the data collection. From this perspective, the findings do not provide substantial novelty beyond what is already reported in the literature.
- The inclusion of physical fitness assessments following a full training session compromises the validity of the measurements obtained.
Author Response
Please see the attachment
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authorssince you have variables for age height and weight you can use this method to ascertain if PHV has occurred or when itis likely to occur
Moore, S.A., Brasher, P.M.A., Macdonald, H., Nettlefold, L., Baxter-Jones, A.D.G., Cameron, N., McKay, H.A. 2015. Enhancing a maturity prediction model that uses anthropometric variables. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 47 (8): 1755-64
Author Response
We sincerely thank the reviewer for this valuable and constructive suggestion. We appreciate the recommendation to consider the approach proposed by Moore et al. (2015) for estimating maturity offset and identifying whether peak height velocity (PHV) has occurred or is likely to occur, based on anthropometric variables such as age, height, and weight.
We acknowledge that the incorporation of a maturity estimation model could further strengthen the interpretation of growth-related variables in the study. Accordingly, we have included a reference to this approach in the manuscript as a potential direction for future applications, highlighting its usefulness for enhancing the assessment of biological maturation in similar datasets. We are grateful for this helpful suggestion and for the reference provided, which has contributed to improving the methodological perspective of our work. However, given the cross-sectional design of the present study and the scope of the current analyses, this approach was not implemented. Nevertheless, it has been explicitly acknowledged as a relevant avenue for future research.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsI am happy with all changes made by the authors.
Great job!
Author Response
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the positive evaluation of our revised manuscript and for acknowledging the improvements made. We greatly appreciate the time and effort dedicated to reviewing our work and are pleased that the revisions meet your expectations.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsMinor corrections in "study design" and "assessment procedures". To eliminate repetitions in the sections "study design" and "Assessment procedures".
Author Response
We sincerely thank the reviewer for this helpful and constructive comment. We have carefully revised the manuscript to address the issue of repetition in the “Study Design” and “Assessment Procedures” sections. In particular, we streamlined the text to improve clarity, avoid redundancy, and enhance the overall readability of these sections while preserving all relevant methodological details.
We appreciate this suggestion, which has contributed to improving the quality and conciseness of the manuscript.
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors are sincerely thanked for their thorough and thoughtful revisions in response to the comments provided. The revised manuscript demonstrates a clear effort to address the concerns raised, including improvements in the conceptual framing, methodological transparency, statistical reporting, and discussion of study limitations.
Particularly appreciated is the authors’ openness and willingness to carefully consider and incorporate the suggested modifications. This receptive and constructive approach reflects strong scientific rigor and contributes positively to the overall quality and credibility of the work. The limitations previously identified have now been more appropriately acknowledged and contextualized, and the scope and practical contribution of the study have been clarified.
Overall, the revised version represents a substantial improvement over the original submission, and the concerns raised during the review process have been satisfactorily addressed. Therefore, in its current form, the manuscript can be considered suitable for publication.
Author Response
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the thoughtful and highly positive evaluation of our revised manuscript. We greatly appreciate the recognition of the improvements made across conceptual framing, methodological transparency, statistical reporting, and the discussion of limitations. We are pleased that the revised version meets your expectations and are grateful for your recommendation for publication.
Round 3
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsI thank the authors for considering my suggestion to include a biological age. This is very important in this age group as athletes of same age, but different maturity can show different outcome due to increased maturity. Without including this measure, it leaves the reader questioning the results. As presented we are told outcomes improve with age (but this could be related to maturity), this is already known. What this paper adds to the literature is unclear.
Author Response
Thank you for this important observation. We fully agree that biological maturation is a major determinant of physical performance during adolescence and that athletes of the same chronological age may present substantially different performance profiles due to differences in maturation status. Unfortunately, direct measures of biological maturation (e.g., maturity offset or years from peak height velocity) were not available in the present dataset. We acknowledge that this limitation restricts our ability to distinguish the independent contribution of chronological age from that of biological maturation. To address this concern, we strengthened the Discussion and Limitations sections by explicitly stating that the observed differences between categories should be interpreted as the combined result of chronological age, maturation-related development, and accumulated training exposure. We also clarified that the contribution of the present study lies in examining the overall aerobic and explosive performance profile through a multivariate approach, while comparing the relative association of age category and basic anthropometric characteristics within the same analytical framework. We agree that future studies should include direct assessments of biological maturation to better disentangle the effects of age, growth, and training on youth soccer performance.