Review Reports
- Amiel Sharchaton 1,2,
- Shilat Parsha 2 and
- Eyal Kurzbaum 1,2,7,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript under review is quite interesting and well executed in the biochemical part, but the mycological part raises questions. It's unclear from the presented data why the authors believe all the studied strains belong to a single species—Psilocybe cubensis. This is crucial, as all studies rely on differences in tryptamine content in different strains of a single species. However, there is no evidence that all the strains belong to a single species. But there are lack of any proofs on strains taxonomy. We have very limited information about the strains, and other than their unusual names, we know nothing about their geographic origin, year of isolation, culture characteristics, NCBI accession numbers—all the information that typically accompanies the description of studied fungal strains or herbarium specimens. Despite the low image quality, it is clear that the plant basidiomes shown in Figure 1 are quite variable and could easily belong to different species. There is no other morphological or molecular evidence that all 14 strains studied belong to the same species. Should we take the authors' word for it? It is known that morphological study, especially of cultivated basidiomata, does not guarantee reliable identification of fungi to the species level. I think it is the weakest point of the study. I would also suggest adding to biochemical part tryptamine analysis of the strains' mycelium.
The findings of different tryptamine contents in individual basidiomes of the same strain are unexpected, so analysis of mycelium for tryptamine content would be useful as a control to verify the correctness of the methods used.
The manuscript requires significant revision:
1) ITS sequencing of the strains should be performed and deposited at NCBI to prove that all strains belong to the same species;
2) Add data on the tryptamine content of the strains' mycelium;
3) Add information to the "Materials and Methods" section about the origin of the strains and the substrate preparation method (see comments in the text);
4) Improve the image quality in Figure 1 and add scale bars;
5) The strain names are quite unique. What does the "x" in "Jack Frost × Golden Teacher" and "Jack Frost × Shakti" mean? Are they hybrids?
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
General response from the authors:
We thank the reviewer for the careful review and for this important comment. We fully agree with the reviewer’s concern regarding the need for taxonomic confirmation of the studied strains. Following this comment, we performed ITS based molecular identification for all strains. The results confirmed that all strains belong to Psilocybe cubensis.
We have now added the relevant taxonomic information to the revised manuscript, including the molecular identification methods, sequence information, and NCBI accession numbers. We believe that these additions directly address the reviewer’s concern and substantially strengthen the mycological basis of the study.
In addition, we have incorporated all corrections based on the comments provided in the reviewer’s attached PDF and the reviewer’s specific additional suggestions. All changes were made using Track Changes mode in our revised word file.
Response to specific comments:
1) ITS sequencing of the strains should be performed and deposited at NCBI to prove that all strains belong to the same species;
Authors’ response: We thank the reviewer for this important comment. As requested, ITS sequencing was performed for all studied strains, and the sequences were deposited in NCBI. The results confirmed that all strains belong to Psilocybe cubensis. The revised manuscript now includes the ITS sequencing method, the identification results, and the corresponding NCBI accession numbers.
2) Add data on the tryptamine content of the strains' mycelium;
Authors’ response:
We thank the reviewer for this helpful suggestion. The present manuscript is a brief report, and the main focus was on fruiting bodies, which are the fungal material most commonly used in therapeutic, retreat, and ceremonial settings worldwide. In contrast, mycelium is generally not used in these contexts and has been reported to contain negligible amounts of psilocybin compared with fruiting bodies.
Nevertheless, we agree that this point should be addressed. We have therefore added a clarification and relevant references to the revised manuscript in the end of the discussion.
3) Add information to the "Materials and Methods" section about the origin of the strains and the substrate preparation method (see comments in the text);
Authors’ response: Done.
4) Improve the image quality in Figure 1 and add scale bars;
Authors’ response:
We thank the reviewer for this comment. We have rechecked the original image files and found that, during the editing service, a lower-resolution photo was used. We have now added a higher resolution one (we paste it as CVG graphics.
Regarding the scale bars, we regret that the fruiting bodies were not photographed with a ruler or another calibrated reference object. Therefore, we cannot add accurate scale bars retrospectively. However, we believe that even without scale bars, the figure still shows relevant morphological characteristics of the studied fruiting bodies and may be valuable for researchers working in this specific field.
Nevertheless, we agree that this limits the value of the figure as a formal morphological reference. If the editor considers this issue important, we will be happy to move Figure 1 to the Supplementary Material, so that it serves only as an illustrative image rather than as a central figure in the main text.
5) The strain names are quite unique. What does the "x" in "Jack Frost × Golden Teacher" and "Jack Frost × Shakti" mean? Are they hybrids?
Authors’ response:
We thank the reviewer for this comment. In the specific field of Psilocybe cubensis cultivation and breeding, some strain names are well known, while others are unique designations given by individual breeders or growers. In the present case, these names were provided by the original culture collection of Dave Wombat from Wombat Labs, USA. All stains were puschased by Psilotion LTD. (Israel) which provided the strains to this study with the names.
The symbol “×” is commonly used in breeding to indicate a cross between two distinct cultivated strains. These crosses do not necessarily represent formally described taxonomic hybrids or strains with an officially recognized name. Rather, they usually refer to breeding lines that are reported to display stable morphological characteristics that differ from those of the parental strains.
We have clarified this point in the revised manuscript to avoid confusion (under table 1).
------
see pdf attched for our answers in the text as well
Thank you!!
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Authors,
Manuscript ID jof-4223984 entitled “Surprising Variability in Tryptamine Profiles of Psilocybe cubensis Fruiting Bodies: Inter- and Intra-Strain Differences Across 14 Strains Cultivated Under Controlled Conditions " which submitted to Journal of Fungi.
This manuscript quantified psilocybin, psilocin, baeocystin, norbaeocystin, aeruginascin, and norpsilocin in the fruiting bodies of 14 distinct strains of Psilocybe cubensis. The manuscript addresses an important and timely topic and provides useful baseline data. However, major methodological and interpretative issues must be resolved before publication.
Major comments:
- The authors must provide the molecular evidences (ITS or multi-locus sequences) to demonstrate the 14 strains as Psilocybe cubensis.
- In the Table 1. The authors list the mean ± SD, while without one-way ANOVA for inter-strain differences
- In 2.4. Experimental Setup. “At least three biological samples” per strain, but unclear whether these are: independent cultures? or pooled from the same batch?
- In “Discussion” section, I don’t know why the authors not discuss with other studies, and without the references?
- Figure 1 lacks scale bars and low scientific value.
Best wishes
Author Response
We thank the reviewer for the careful evaluation of our manuscript and for appreciating the unique subject, importance, and timeliness of our work. We are pleased that the reviewer recognized the value of the baseline data presented in this study.
Comment 1: The authors must provide the molecular evidences (ITS or multi-locus sequences) to demonstrate the 14 strains as Psilocybe cubensis.
Authors’ response 1
We thank the reviewer for this important comment. The first reviewer also raised this point, and we fully agree that molecular confirmation was missing from the original manuscript.
Following these comments, we performed ITS based molecular identification for all 14 strains. The results confirmed that all strains belong to Psilocybe cubensis. We have added the relevant genetic analysis, including the methods, identification results, and NCBI accession numbers, to the revised manuscript using Track Changes mode.
We believe that the manuscript is now substantially improved and that the added molecular data greatly strengthen the taxonomic basis of the study.
Comment 2: In the Table 1. The authors list the mean ± SD, while without one-way ANOVA for inter-strain differences
Authors’ response 2:
We thank the reviewer for this important comment. Table 1 was intended to present the range and diversity of tryptamine concentrations detected among the tested strains, rather than to determine which strains differ significantly from one another. Therefore, no statistical comparison among strains was included in the table. In addition, because the table includes seven columns of tryptamine concentrations, we believe that adding statistical significance markers would make the table difficult to read and visually overloaded, thereby reducing the clarity of the presented results.
Comment 3: In 2.4. Experimental Setup. “At least three biological samples” per strain, but unclear whether these are: independent cultures? or pooled from the same batch?
Authors’ response 3:
We thank the reviewer for pointing out this unclear wording. We have revised the text to clarify that these were technical replicates extracted and analyzed from the dried fruiting body powder obtained for each strain, following harvesting and drying as described in Section 2.1. The wording was corrected in the revised manuscript using Track Changes mode. However, in the intra-strain variations tests (six randomly selected strains) we used 5 individual fruting bodies, thus it is 5 biological replicates. We have added it to the text.
Comment 4: In “Discussion” section, I don’t know why the authors not discuss with other studies, and without the references?
Authors’ response 4:
We thank the reviewer for this important comment. We agree that the Discussion section should better place our findings in the context of previous studies.
As this manuscript is submitted as a brief report, our main focus was on presenting the experimental results and the observed variability in tryptamine profiles among the studied strains. In the original version, much of the relevant background and previous literature was included in the Introduction, where we aimed to highlight the knowledge gap in this unique research area. This gap is partly related to regulatory restrictions, the legal status of these compounds in many countries, and the limited funding and accessibility of research on this topic compared with other areas of fungal biology.
To address the reviewer’s comment, we have added references on this topic. In addition, we have added data and references on the concentrations of P. cubensis in mycelium and fruiting bodies. Additional relevant references were added regarding the clinical potential of treating mental health issues. These changes were made using Track Changes mode. We believe that the revised Discussion now provides a clearer interpretation of our findings in relation to the existing literature.
Comment 5: Figure 1 lacks scale bars and low scientific value.
Authors’ response 5:
Regarding the scale bars, we regret that the fruiting bodies were not photographed with a ruler or another calibrated reference object. Therefore, accurate scale bars cannot be added retrospectively. However, we believe that even without scale bars, the figure still presents relevant morphological characteristics of the studied fruiting bodies and may be useful for researchers working in this specific field.
Nevertheless, we understand the reviewer’s concern regarding the limited scientific value of the figure as a formal morphological reference. If the editor considers this issue important, we will be happy to move Figure 1 to the Supplementary Material, where it can serve as an illustrative image rather than a central figure in the main text. However, we have uploaded a higher-resolution version, as we noticed that the editing services previously pasted it at a lower resolution. It has now been embedded in the Word file as an SVG graphic to ensure higher resolution.
------------------------
We thank the reviewer for helping us improve the manuscript.
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors took into account the reviewer's comments, added missing methodological information, conducted molecular studies of the strains, and expanded the discussion part, which significantly improved the manuscript. The reviewed manuscript is traditionally structured, clearly written, illustrated with figures and tables, molecular data are presented in Supplementary material, and the data are statistically processed. Nevertheless, a few minor corrections should be made before publishing the manuscript. They are listed in comments in the manuscript file.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments, which helped advance and improve our manuscript. As detailed in the attached PDF, all comments have been addressed and marked as “Done.”
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Authors,
Thank for your resubmitted the MS. All the comments are well address.
It is a pleasure to accept your manuscript entitled "Surprising Variability in Tryptamine Profiles of Psilocybe cubensis Fruiting Bodies: Inter- and Intra-Strain Differences Across 14 Strains Cultivated Under Controlled Conditions" in its current form for publication in Jof.
Best wishes
Heng Zhao
Author Response
We sincerely appreciate your time, guidance, and positive feedback throughout the evaluation process. Your constructive comments greatly helped us improve the quality of our work.