Review Reports
- Guiqi Li 1,
- Yunhan He 2 and
- Li Fan 4
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Yougen Yi Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe fiber-optic sensor structure proposed in this manuscript is interesting and contributes to the development of fiber-optic sensing techniques for two-dimensional strain measurement. The manuscript demonstrates clear novelty and provides a relatively comprehensive theoretical analysis. The experimental results further validate the feasibility and functionality of the proposed sensor. Therefore, I recommend that the manuscript be accepted for publication after minor revision. My comments are as follows.
1. What impact does the size of flexible film have on the sensing performance of sensors?
2. What is the reason for a serious deviation in sensor 1 during the strain unloading process in Figure 12 (b)? Does it affect the subsequent use of the sensor?
3. Why is the wavelength in Figure 14 (b) very close to the wavelength at 3% strain when the strain is 6%? Please explain clearly.
4. Why does the sensor measure 10%, can the measurement range be further expanded, and what factors affect the measurement range?
5. What is the minimum resolution for strain measurement of this sensor?
6. The theoretical analysis section provides a matrix and its function.
Author Response
Dear Editor and Reviewers,
Thank you for your constructive comments. We have made targeted clarifications in the relevant sections, as explained below. Additions and replacement wording are marked in red. Deleted or superseded original wording is retained in red with strikethrough. Quotations below show the revised wording without the deleted text. Page and continuous line numbers refer to the accompanying revised manuscript; paragraph openings are also provided for reference.
Reviewer 1
Comments 1: What impact does the size of flexible film have on the sensing performance of sensors?
Response 1: We have specified the actual film dimensions of 88 × 82 × 0.9 mm and the 70 mm initial clamp separation in both loading directions. The added discussion explains how film dimensions influence gauge length, fiber-path layout, lateral constraint, flexibility, and strain transfer. At a fixed displacement, increasing gauge length reduces nominal strain. Because different film sizes were not compared experimentally, the discussion is qualitative.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 3, paragraph beginning “After settling, place the mold in a…” (p. 10, lines 265–285); Section 4, paragraph beginning “To verify the strain response capability of…” (p. 12, lines 313–329).
“The actual film dimensions are 88 × 82 × 0.9 mm, corresponding to the mold cavity. Film length affects the available gauge length and fiber-path layout, while width and thickness influence lateral constraint, flexibility, and deformation transfer to the bonded fiber. At a fixed clamp displacement, a longer gauge produces a smaller nominal strain. These effects also depend on bonding and clamping conditions; no comparison among different film sizes was performed.”
Comments 2: What is the reason for a serious deviation in sensor 1 during the strain unloading process in Figure 12 (b)? Does it affect the subsequent use of the sensor?
Response 2: We checked the first-cycle FBGy1 unloading record at 7% strain: 1539.644 nm, corresponding to a 0.034 nm shift from its initial value. Together with the other two cycles, this gives the plotted mean of 0.366333 nm. Slip or a peak-tracking disturbance is possible, but no independent evidence identifies the cause. We have retained the datum and added a concise explanation. Its effect on precise unloading measurement cannot be dismissed; repeat measurement and independent peak verification are needed.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 4, paragraph beginning “The 7% unloading point in Figure 12(b)…” (p. 13, lines 375–381).
“The 7% unloading point in Figure 12(b) was checked against the original records. The first-cycle FBGy1 wavelength is 1539.644 nm, giving a shift of 0.034 nm from its initial 1539.610 nm value. Together with the second- and third-cycle shifts of 0.508 and 0.557 nm, the three-cycle mean is 0.366333 nm, consistent with the plotted value. Slip or a peak-tracking disturbance is possible but unconfirmed. The point is retained; repeat measurement and independent peak verification are needed before precise unloading measurements can be claimed.”
Comments 3: Why is the wavelength in Figure 14 (b) very close to the wavelength at 3% strain when the strain is 6%? Please explain clearly.
Response 3: Figure 14(b) records FBGy1 under X loading, for which it has a weak, non-monotonic cross-axis response. The mean wavelengths at 3% and 6% are 1539.652615 and 1539.657308 nm, only 4.69 pm apart, and their observed ranges overlap. We have added this explanation and clarified that FBGx1 provides the principal X-direction response. FBGy1 alone does not reliably distinguish these two X-strain levels.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 4, paragraph beginning “In addition to cyclic tensile testing, constant…” (p. 15, lines 403–418).
“In Figure 14(b), the mean FBGy1 wavelengths at 3% and 6% X strain are 1539.652615 and 1539.657308 nm, respectively, separated by only 4.69 pm with overlapping observed ranges. Their proximity is consistent with the weak, non-monotonic cross-axis response in Figure 11(b). Thus, FBGy1 alone does not reliably distinguish these two X-strain levels; FBGx1 provides the principal X-direction response.”
Comments 4: Why does the sensor measure 10%, can the measurement range be further expanded, and what factors affect the measurement range?
Response 4: The 10% upper test limit corresponds to the limit of the current sensor packaging process. A greater range would require improved packaging and verification of fiber-path unfolding capacity, local fiber strain, bending loss, bonding integrity, and peak tracking. We have added these factors and clarified that higher-deformation simulations do not establish a larger experimentally verified range.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 4, paragraph beginning “The 10% upper test limit corresponds to…” (p. 12, lines 330–335).
“The 10% upper test limit corresponds to the limit of the current sensor packaging process. Further extension would require improvements in packaging and verification of the remaining fiber-path unfolding capacity, allowable local fiber strain, bending loss, adhesive slip or debonding, and reliable reflection-peak tracking. Relaxation and hysteresis may restrict the usable calibrated range before rupture. The simulations at higher deformation do not establish a larger experimentally verified measurement range.”
Comments 5: What is the minimum resolution for strain measurement of this sensor?
Response 5: The interrogator wavelength resolution is 1 pm and its sampling frequency is 1 Hz. We have added the nominal strain-resolution relation δε = 0.001/|S| (%), with S in nm/%. The actual minimum resolvable strain was not established by the 1% calibration steps. We therefore distinguish an instrument-based estimate from an experimentally demonstrated detection limit, which also depends on hysteresis, drift, and calibration uncertainty.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 4, paragraph beginning “To verify the strain response capability of…” (p. 12, lines 313–329); Section 4, paragraph beginning “The interrogator wavelength resolution is 1 pm…” (p. 15, lines 398–402).
“The interrogator wavelength resolution is 1 pm (0.001 nm). The nominal strain-resolution estimate is δε = 0.001/|S| in %, where S is the relevant calibrated sensitivity in nm/%. This instrument-based estimate does not include hysteresis, drift, or calibration uncertainty. The 1% strain steps used here do not establish the minimum experimentally resolvable strain.”
Comments 6: The theoretical analysis section provides a matrix and its function.
Response 6: We have clarified the function and applicability of the existing sensitivity matrix. Its coefficients describe the principal and cross-axis responses of FBGx1 and FBGy1, in nm/%. Matrix inversion accounts for cross-axis sensitivity and requires a nonzero determinant and consistent reference wavelengths. The existing statement that simultaneous X–Y loading is needed to validate two-dimensional reconstruction is retained. No new numerical matrix fit has been introduced.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 2, paragraph beginning “After constant temperature or temperature compensation, the…” (p. 5, lines 154–155); Section 2, paragraph beginning “where Kxx and Kxy denote the sensitivities…” (p. 5, lines 157–164); Section 2, paragraph beginning “The cross-axis coefficients are therefore retained rather…” (p. 5, lines 166–170).
“Each coefficient has units of nm/% when strain is expressed in %. The matrix accounts for cross-axis sensitivity, and its inversion requires det(K) = KxxKyy − KxyKyx ≠ 0 and consistent reference wavelengths. Within this calibrated linear model, the corresponding strain components are recovered by matrix inversion:”
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis manuscript proposes a flexible fiber optic sensor that can achieve two-dimensional measurement of large strains at multiple points. The sensor structure has strong innovation. The flexible film and fiber Bragg grating array were well combined. It has a good inspiring effect on the design of sensor structures. The manuscript contains comprehensive theoretical and experimental content, and I suggest making minor revisions.
Please further discuss and clarify the following questions.
- What are the main factors affecting the measurement range of sensors, and it is recommended to discuss them.
- In reference 28, the author also proposed a flexible sensor. Please explain the difference between the two in the introduction to further highlight the innovation point.
- Regarding the optical sensor, some related works need to be mentioned by authors, such as, 3D hybrid arrayed Ag/MOF multi-plasmon resonant cavity system for high-performance SPR sensing; Six-band high-sensitivity terahertz absorption device based on AlCuFe quasicrystals for sensing applications.
- The formatting section in the paper needs to be carefully confirmed, such as the subscript 2 in SiO2 on page 10.
- In Figure 11 (b), the strain measurement after 4% strain is not linear. Can this result be used. What is the relationship between the sensor measurement range of 10% in the subsequent results.
- The sensor also has response characteristics to temperature. Please discuss how to solve the temperature problem.
Author Response
Reviewer 2
Comments 1: What are the main factors affecting the measurement range of sensors, and it is recommended to discuss them.
Response 1: We have added a short discussion of the factors limiting the usable strain range: packaging, remaining geometric unfolding capacity, local fiber strain, bending loss, adhesive slip or debonding, and reflection-peak tracking. Relaxation and hysteresis can limit a usable calibration before rupture. The paragraph also identifies 10% as the current packaging-process limit.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 4, paragraph beginning “The 10% upper test limit corresponds to…” (p. 12, lines 330–335).
“The 10% upper test limit corresponds to the limit of the current sensor packaging process. Further extension would require improvements in packaging and verification of the remaining fiber-path unfolding capacity, allowable local fiber strain, bending loss, adhesive slip or debonding, and reliable reflection-peak tracking. Relaxation and hysteresis may restrict the usable calibrated range before rupture. The simulations at higher deformation do not establish a larger experimentally verified measurement range.”
Comments 2: In reference 28, the author also proposed a flexible sensor. Please explain the difference between the two in the introduction to further highlight the innovation point.
Response 2: The existing comparison with Ref. [28] has been expanded locally. We now state the shared PDMS/SiO₂ hybrid-substrate concept and identify the present focus on an orthogonal bent fiber path, directional response, and cross-axis coupling. This clarifies the contribution without making a new numerical performance comparison.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 1, paragraph beginning “Polymer flexible films have excellent properties such…” (p. 3, lines 72–97).
“The present work shares the PDMS/SiO₂ hybrid-substrate concept, but focuses on an orthogonally arranged bent fiber path and its direction-dependent responses under X- and Y-direction loading. This directional arrangement and the analysis of cross-axis coupling distinguish the focus of the present study from the ultra-large-strain measurement in Ref. [28].”
Comments 3: Regarding the optical sensor, some related works need to be mentioned by authors, such as, 3D hybrid arrayed Ag/MOF multi-plasmon resonant cavity system for high-performance SPR sensing; Six-band high-sensitivity terahertz absorption device based on AlCuFe quasicrystals for sensing applications.
Response 3: We have added a brief discussion of the two suggested works in the Introduction, citing them as Refs. [31] and [32]. Their engineered optical structures provide relevant context for SPR and refractive-index sensing. We distinguish those optical mechanisms from deformation-induced wavelength shifts in the present FBG structure. The two studies have been added to the reference list as entries [31] and [32]; entries [1]–[30] are unchanged.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 1, paragraph beginning “Related optical sensing approaches include “3D hybrid…” (p. 3, lines 98–103).
“Related optical sensing approaches include “3D hybrid arrayed Ag/MOF multi-plasmon resonant cavity system for high-performance SPR sensing” [31] and “Six-band high-sensitivity terahertz absorption device based on AlCuFe quasicrystals for sensing applications” [32]. These studies illustrate how engineered structures tailor optical responses for SPR and refractive-index sensing, respectively, whereas the present FBG structure converts film deformation into wavelength shifts.”
Comments 4: The formatting section in the paper needs to be carefully confirmed, such as the subscript 2 in SiO2 on page 10.
Response 4: We have corrected the inconsistent SiO₂ notation in the body text, including the space within the chemical formula and the subscript 2. The correction is confined to text; the existing figures and reference entries [1]–[30] are retained.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 2, paragraph beginning “The proposed two-dimensional large strain flexible FBG…” (p. 4, lines 118–126); Section 3, paragraph beginning “PDMS/SiO₂ mixed flexible substrate was prepared by…” (p. 9, lines 245–254).
“The proposed two-dimensional large strain flexible FBG sensor consists of a PDMS/SiO₂ hybrid flexible film, an integrated orthogonal bending optical fiber bonded to the surface, and four FBG sensing units.”
Comments 5: In Figure 11 (b), the strain measurement after 4% strain is not linear. Can this result be used. What is the relationship between the sensor measurement range of 10% in the subsequent results.
Response 5: Figure 11(b) shows the FBGy1 cross-axis response under X loading. We have clarified that its non-monotonic behavior beyond 4% cannot be used as an independent linear X-strain calibration. The observed principal-channel response over 0–10% is a separate result; it does not remove this cross-axis limitation. A brief explanation has been added without changing the plotted data or fitted curves.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 4, paragraph beginning “In the X-direction cyclic test, the sensor…” (pp. 12–13, lines 338–361).
“Figure 11(b) is the cross-axis response of FBGy1 under X loading. Its non-monotonic behavior beyond 4% cannot be used as an independent linear X-strain calibration. It does not negate the principal-channel response measured over 0–10%, but limits a single linear calibration for both directions throughout loading and unloading.”
Comments 6: The sensor also has response characteristics to temperature. Please discuss how to solve the temperature problem.
Response 6: We have specified that the strain tests were performed at constant temperature and added a possible compensation method for variable-temperature use. An independent temperature measurement can be used to subtract each packaged sensing FBG’s calibrated thermal shift before strain inversion. Calibration should reflect mounting conditions and thermal history because the heating and cooling branches differ. The method is identified as a proposal; compensated strain accuracy was not measured.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 4, paragraph beginning “To verify the strain response capability of…” (p. 12, lines 313–329); Section 4, paragraph beginning “Fig.17 (a) , (b) , (c) and…” (p. 17, lines 463–489).
“For variable-temperature operation, a nearby thermometer or a mechanically isolated, thermally coupled reference FBG can provide an independent temperature measurement. The calibrated thermal shift of each packaged sensing FBG can then be subtracted before strain inversion: ε = K⁻¹(Δλ − kTΔT), where kT contains the sensing gratings’ temperature coefficients. Calibration should reproduce the mounting conditions and heating or cooling history because the two thermal branches differ. This is a proposed compensation approach; compensated strain accuracy was not tested here.”
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Authors,
Your work is interesting, well-presented, and of good quality. However, I feel that several points require further clarification before publication. My detailed remarks are the following:
Figures 3–6: Are the theoretical results (simulations) produced using commercial software or a custom-built program? Please clarify this in the text.
Figure 11b: Why is there such a significant discrepancy between the loading and unloading curves? Please provide a physical comment or explanation.
Figure 12b: In the unloading curve, there is a data point that might indicate an experimental error. Please check this data point and correct it if necessary.
Scalability: Please provide details on how your experimental setup could be scaled up for larger structural applications—such as monitoring a building or a bridge under heavy loads. This addition would make the paper highly interesting to both physicists and engineering communities.
In conclusion, I suggest that this manuscript is suitable for publication after these minor but important improvements are successfully addressed.
Author Response
Reviewer 3
Comments 1: Figures 3–6: Are the theoretical results (simulations) produced using commercial software or a custom-built program? Please clarify this in the text.
Response 1: Figure 3 was produced using COMSOL Multiphysics 6.3, and Figures 4–6 were produced using Abaqus/CAE 2022. We have added these software names to the corresponding simulation descriptions. The existing model dimensions and simulation results are retained.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 2, paragraph beginning “Based on the above equivalent refractive index…” (p. 6, lines 181–198); Section 2, paragraph beginning “The too small bending radius can weaken…” (p. 7, lines 203–212).
“The mechanical simulations in Figures 4–6 were performed using Abaqus/CAE 2022.”
Comments 2: Figure 11b: Why is there such a significant discrepancy between the loading and unloading curves? Please provide a physical comment or explanation.
Response 2: We have qualified the existing physical explanation and added that the cross-axis signal in Figure 11(b) is small. Viscoelastic recovery, recovery of the curved fiber path, and relaxation at the bonding interface may produce a relatively large loading–unloading difference in this small signal. The present data do not isolate the individual contributions of these mechanisms. The added text also states the resulting limitation of a single linear calibration.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 4, paragraph beginning “In the X-direction cyclic test, the sensor…” (pp. 12–13, lines 338–361).
“Because this cross-axis signal is small, changes caused by relaxation and interfacial strain transfer are large relative to the signal; their individual contributions were not isolated.”
Comments 3: Figure 12b: In the unloading curve, there is a data point that might indicate an experimental error. Please check this data point and correct it if necessary.
Response 3: The point was checked against the original worksheet. It originates from the first unloading cycle at 7% strain; recomputing the three-cycle mean reproduces the plotted point. A slip or peak-tracking disturbance is possible, but there is no independent evidence establishing a transcription error or a replacement value. We have retained the record and added an explanation of this uncertainty and its effect on precise unloading measurement.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 4, paragraph beginning “The 7% unloading point in Figure 12(b)…” (p. 13, lines 375–381).
“The 7% unloading point in Figure 12(b) was checked against the original records. The first-cycle FBGy1 wavelength is 1539.644 nm, giving a shift of 0.034 nm from its initial 1539.610 nm value. Together with the second- and third-cycle shifts of 0.508 and 0.557 nm, the three-cycle mean is 0.366333 nm, consistent with the plotted value. Slip or a peak-tracking disturbance is possible but unconfirmed. The point is retained; repeat measurement and independent peak verification are needed before precise unloading measurements can be claimed.”
Comments 4: Scalability: Please provide details on how your experimental setup could be scaled up for larger structural applications—such as monitoring a building or a bridge under heavy loads. This addition would make the paper highly interesting to both physicists and engineering communities.
Response 4: A short paragraph has been added describing multiple sensor patches at selected structural locations, wavelength-multiplexed interrogation, optical power and peak-spacing constraints, strain-transfer verification, protection, and temperature referencing. It also explains how patch spacing and gauge length affect spatial resolution. Small-strain sensitivity, durability, installation repeatability, and dynamic performance would need validation before building or bridge deployment.
Changes in the revised manuscript: Section 4, paragraph beginning “For buildings or bridges, multiple sensor patches…” (p. 18, lines 492–499).
“For buildings or bridges, multiple sensor patches could be attached at selected locations and connected by optical leads for wavelength-multiplexed interrogation. Peak spacing and optical power margins must accommodate strain and temperature shifts, bending loss, and the number of gratings. Reliable strain transfer, protective packaging, and temperature referencing are required at each patch. Patch spacing and gauge length determine spatial resolution. Field use also requires validation of small-strain sensitivity, cyclic durability, and installation repeatability; the present 1 Hz quasi-static tests do not establish dynamic structural-monitoring performance.”