Review Reports
- Luis Santiago Criollo 1,*,
- Oswaldo Moscoso-Zea 2 and
- Sergio Luján-Mora 6
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Javier Vega Ramirez Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis article presents the results of an exploratory study which measured and analysed the effectiveness of an AR resource on student learning, comparing the pre- and post-test results of the experimental group with those of the control group. In this respect, both methodologically and theoretically, it is a high-quality study: well-organised, well-founded and well-designed.
Regarding the reference authors cited, whilst there is a wider range of authors being used today, the choice of authors focusing mainly on the last five years indicates that the work is up-to-date and relevant.
As for the graphs used, they are all interesting and appropriate. Only Figure 13 (word cloud) is considered less valuable, as it is a perceptual indicator carrying greater weight than the measurements presented in the preceding graphs.
As for the conclusions, whilst they are correct, they could be developed in greater depth, highlighting the importance of evaluating tools generated using AR as opposed to the research currently abounding on the use of AI.
Furthermore, the economic aspect associated with the use of META devices in educational settings could be considered a factor worth mentioning in the final section on projections and discussion.
Author Response
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of the manuscript’s theoretical foundation, methodology, organization, and graphical presentation. We appreciate the suggestions for improving the focus and implications of the study.
Response: We agree that the word cloud provides descriptive information about participants’ perceptions rather than a direct measure of learning. To maintain the focus on the assessment scores and completion-time analyses, we have removed Figure 13 and its accompanying descriptive paragraph from the main manuscript. This change does not affect the quantitative analyses or their interpretation.
We have revised the Conclusions section to explain more clearly the contribution of empirically evaluating augmented reality applications through measured learning outcomes. The revised text emphasizes that AR tools warrant educational evaluation alongside interest in artificial intelligence. We have also clarified that our study does not compare the effectiveness of AR and AI and therefore does not establish the superiority of either technology.
We have added a discussion of practical and economic considerations, including equipment acquisition and availability, maintenance, cleaning, software updates, technical support, teacher preparation, and shared-device arrangements. We explicitly acknowledge that the study did not collect implementation-cost data and therefore cannot establish cost-effectiveness. A formal evaluation of implementation costs in relation to learning outcomes and the number of students served has been identified as a direction for future research.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsOverall, this paper has great potential. It just needs the reference format fixed and a few minor adjustments to the limitations section. The study on the HistARium app is very interesting, the methodology is solid, and the statistical analysis is strong. The writing is also clear and easy to follow.
However, there are a few changes needed before it is ready for publication:
Reference Formatting: The reference format in this manuscript needs to be fixed. There is a clear mismatch between your in-text citations and the reference list at the end of the document.
Study Limitations: It would be good to note in the Discussion or Conclusion that the excitement of using new VR tech could still have affected their performance, despite the familiarization session.
Author Response
We thank the reviewer for the encouraging assessment of HistARium, the study methodology, the statistical analysis, and the clarity of the manuscript. We have addressed the requested changes as follows.
Response: We have revised the citations and reference list to follow format. Numerical in-text citations have been replaced with the corresponding author---date citations, and the reference list has been checked for consistent formatting and alphabetical ordering. We have also checked the correspondence between in-text citations and reference entries, including author names, publication years, and bibliographic details.
We agree that the familiarization session cannot rule out a residual novelty effect. We have added an explicit limitation explaining that excitement or interest associated with the immersive experience may have contributed to the observed performance differences. We clarify that novelty was not directly measured and that the conventional control condition does not allow its contribution to be isolated. We have identified longer exposure periods, repeated assessments, and an active technology-based control condition as appropriate approaches for future studies.
We have also moderated the interpretation of completion time to avoid presenting longer duration as direct evidence of deeper cognitive processing.