Review Reports
- Juan L. Valle 1,
- Marco A. Panduro 1,* and
- David H. Covarrubias 1
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous Reviewer 4: Gia Khanh Tran
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsComment 1:
Line 27-29: this needs to be extended since it appears too weak: why/to which extend does the Fibonachi approach shows superiority over purely random or fractral-inspired approaches?
Comment 2:
The reviewer has quite some experience with implementations of phased antennas and faced the problem in the past. Typically, problems arise with limited phase resolutions of antenna transceiver chips, packing density in bands > 15 GHz, thermal design and so forth. The authors shall point out if/how the Fibonacci approach realy solves problems which maybe overwhelmed by other more important real-world circuit design problems.
Comment 3:
Figure 1, generally: please elaborate more on the advantages of the Fibonacci approach when it comes to non-teslating sub-array partitioning. Typical antenna transceiver chips have 6 input/output HF lines which makes uniform sub-array portioning a straight-foreward solution. I do not realy get the argument of the authors why the non-uniform Fibonacci partitioning is good in terms of routing etc.
Comment 4:
Equation (1), Eq. (4) both vectors r_n,m and s are line vectors which makes the vector multiplication impossible. I guess the authors missed a vector transposition.
Comment 5:
I don’t understand why the simulation time of testing possible sub-array partitions is a figure of merit. In a real-world product design, spending 1-2 days of simulation or optimization is not problematic. Please explain. The reported 2 hours of line 225 are not a problem and should not the anticipated aims of the paper.
Comment 6:
Line 172, line 176: how is the 48.44% phase shifter reduction explained? Where does this number came from?
Comment 7:
Lines 173-175: I don’t understand this statement. In 3.1 the Random search was tested. In the mentioned lines, the results are referred as result of the Fibonacci approach. This is unclear.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 1 Comments
Comment 1:
Line 27-29: this needs to be extended since it appears too weak: why/to which extend does the Fibonachi approach shows superiority over purely random or fractral-inspired approaches?
Response: This was corrected in the revised version of our manuscript. Please see the revised version.
Comment 2:
The reviewer has quite some experience with implementations of phased antennas and faced the problem in the past. Typically, problems arise with limited phase resolutions of antenna transceiver chips, packing density in bands > 15 GHz, thermal design and so forth. The authors shall point out if/how the Fibonacci approach really solves problems which maybe overwhelmed by other more important real-world circuit design problems.
Response: Although a several number of effects such as mutual coupling and phase quantization are not addressed in the scope of this work, the Fibonacci tessellation methodology provides indirect structural properties that contribute to mitigate these undesired conditions. The irregular distribution of subarrays allows to reduce the strong coupling from nearest elements compared to periodic arrangements added to the raised cosine tapering which ensures a flat level of excitation to mitigate element perturbations. Additionally, by reducing the number of phase shifters this approach minimizes the total impact of quantization which can be validated in future work under realistic implementation constraints.
This was added to the Section 4 of our paper. Please see the revised version of our paper.
Comment 3:
Figure 1, generally: please elaborate more on the advantages of the Fibonacci approach when it comes to non-teslating sub-array partitioning. Typical antenna transceiver chips have 6 input/output HF lines which makes uniform sub-array portioning a straight-foreward solution. I do not realy get the argument of the authors why the non-uniform Fibonacci partitioning is good in terms of routing etc.
Response: A new discrete framework for the design of planar phased arrays based on the Fibonacci sequence is introduced in this work; which is intended to generate fast and feasible planar array designs from a discrete and constrained mathematical perspective. This approach offers the designer some advantages over random unconstrained methods, such as the ability to determine beforehand the number of phase lines for the feeding network or to choose the permissible sizes of subarrays in the array. The Fibonacci sequence is a series of integer numbers where each number is the sum of the two preceding ones, defined by
Fn = Fn−1 + Fn−2, (13)
where F0 = 0 and F1 = 1. The scalability of this methodology is bounded by multiples of this sequence embedded in the dimensions of the N × M quadrangular array. Thus, the total number of antenna elements per axis in the matrix is given by
N = M = (Fn + Fn−3) | n ≥ 3. (14)
The latter expression restricts the dimensions of the achievable planar array designs to the sequence N = M ∈ {2, 4, 6, 10, 16, 26, 42 . . .}, providing a discrete boundary for both antenna elements and phase shifters prior to the search for optimal solutions.
This was added to the Section 2.3 of our paper. Please see the revised version of our paper.
Comment 4:
Equation (1), Eq. (4) both vectors r_n,m and s are line vectors which makes the vector multiplication impossible. I guess the authors missed a vector transposition.
Response: This was corrected by using other set of equations easier and more illustrative. Please see the revised version of our paper.
Comment 5:
I don’t understand why the simulation time of testing possible sub-array partitions is a figure of merit. In a real-world product design, spending 1-2 days of simulation or optimization is not problematic. Please explain. The reported 2 hours of line 225 are not a problem and should not the anticipated aims of the paper.
Response: In order to provide an insight about the exponential growth of an unconstrained solution search space, consider that each subproblem in the segment can be partitioned as the maximum size of the subproblem itself, therefore, the total number of solutions for the unconstrained case is given by (40963 )(1282 )(16)(4) ≈ 7.21 × 1016. Taking into account that each solution is computed with an average time of 20 ms, this search would take approximately 45.7 million years to execute using an exhaustive approach. From here the importance of discretizing the design problem to exhaustively search bounded solution spaces based on the user needs and application requirements.
This paragraph was added in the Section 2.3 (page 5) of the revised version of our paper.
Comment 6:
Line 172, line 176: how is the 48.44% phase shifter reduction explained? Where does this number came from?
Response: The phase shifter reduction percentage is defined by the division of the total number of subarrays in the array with respect to the conventional case, where each antenna element is independently fed with amplitude and phase values. Given that the array is divided by four symmetric segments, the phase shifter reduction percentage is calculated by
Equation 24 of the revised manuscript
where PStotal represents the total number of subarrays used for all sets Cm of one segment with eight subproblems, such that 1 ≤ m ≤ 8.
This was added to the Section 3 (page 7) of the revised manuscript.
Comment 7:
Lines 173-175: I don’t understand this statement. In 3.1 the Random search was tested. In the mentioned lines, the results are referred as result of the Fibonacci approach. This is unclear.
Response: This was corrected in our revised manuscript.
Thanks for your comments!
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript presents a Fibonacci tessellation–based approach for optimizing phased array design in satellite communication. I have some comments about the paper.
- The novelty relative to existing aperiodic and partition-based array design methods is not emphasized clearly.
- The evaluation is limited to idealized isotropic elements; a short discussion of practical factors such as mutual coupling or quantization effects would increase credibility.
- Enhanced Channel Estimation for Hybrid-Field XL-MIMO Systems Using Joint Sparse Bayesian Learning, This work highlights how embedding structural priors into communication system design can improve robustness and efficiency, which resonates with the philosophy of your proposed tessellation strategy.
- The scalability of the method to larger arrays and its general computational cost should be outlined.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 2 Comments
The manuscript presents a Fibonacci tessellation–based approach for optimizing phased array design in satellite communication. I have some comments about the paper.
1. The novelty relative to existing aperiodic and partition-based array design methods is not emphasized clearly.
Response: The novelty relative to existing partition-based array design was emphasized in a clear way. Please see the Introduction Section of our revised manuscript.
2. The evaluation is limited to idealized isotropic elements; a short discussion of practical factors such as mutual coupling or quantization effects would increase credibility.
Response: Although a several number of effects such as mutual coupling and phase quantization are not addressed in the scope of this work, the Fibonacci tessellation methodology provides indirect structural properties that contribute to mitigate these undesired conditions. The irregular distribution of subarrays allows to reduce the strong coupling from nearest elements compared to periodic arrangements added to the raised cosine tapering which ensures a flat level of excitation to mitigate element perturbations. Additionally, by reducing the number of phase shifters this approach minimizes the total impact of quantization which can be validated in future work under realistic implementation constraints.
This was added to the Section 4 of our paper. Please see the revised version of our paper.
3. Enhanced Channel Estimation for Hybrid-Field XL-MIMO Systems Using Joint Sparse Bayesian Learning, This work highlights how embedding structural priors into communication system design can improve robustness and efficiency, which resonates with the philosophy of your proposed tessellation strategy.
Response: This work was considered in the Introduction of the revised version of our paper to contribute to the state of art. Please see page 2 of the revised version of our manuscript.
“Other authors have chosen to embed structural information and hardware restrictions prior to system design [11] reducing the dimensionality of the search space”
4. The scalability of the method to larger arrays and its general computational cost should be outlined.
Response: A new discrete framework for the design of planar phased arrays based on the Fibonacci sequence is introduced in this work; which is intended to generate fast and feasible planar array designs from a discrete and constrained mathematical perspective. This approach offers the designer some advantages over random unconstrained methods, such as the ability to determine beforehand the number of phase lines for the feeding network or to choose the permissible sizes of subarrays in the array. The Fibonacci sequence is a series of integer numbers where each number is the sum of the two preceding ones, defined by
Fn = Fn−1 + Fn−2, (13)
where F0 = 0 and F1 = 1. The scalability of this methodology is bounded by multiples of this sequence embedded in the dimensions of the N × M quadrangular array. Thus, the total number of antenna elements per axis in the matrix is given by
N = M = (Fn + Fn−3) | n ≥ 3. (14)
The latter expression restricts the dimensions of the achievable planar array designs to the sequence N = M ∈ {2, 4, 6, 10, 16, 26, 42 . . .}, providing a discrete boundary for both antenna elements and phase shifters prior to the search for optimal solutions.
This was added to the Section 2.3 of our paper. Please see the revised version of our paper.
Thanks for your comments!
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe paper introduces a Fibonacci based tessellation that partitions 16x16 planar phased array into bands with row level compositions, so that layouts reuse a small set of subproblems while keeping four fold symmetry. The method explores discrete spaces of layouts and selects solutions by a two objective scheme that trades SLL and FNBW while reducing total number of phase shifters.
I have the following comments:
- The introduction can be better organized to state clearly the related works that already exist in the literature regarding phased array in general and methodologies followed in the state of the art.
- The paper can also benefit from adding a paragraph on the need for antenna RF calibration for multi-antenna satellites [REF01]. Please include and explain.
- Kindly justify better the two objective construction. What other optimization frameworks can be used to attain the same objective ?
- Please describe gains in the domain of the array factor when utilizing the Fibonacci based tessellation.
- Explain the weight update and its effect on the archive extracted. In equations (17) and (18), it seems that it is set $w_1$ and $w_2$ using min and max over an archive. For that, it would be good to describe the acceptance rule for that archive and when the weights are recomputed. If you change weights during the search, show a plot of the value of $f_1$ and $f_2$ for accepted solutions over time so that the reader sees the effect of the update rule. Sec. 2.4 . (1) copy_t
- It can be good to explain better the FNBW extraction method. In particular, describe how you locate the first two zeros of $A F\left(\theta, \phi ; \theta_0, \phi_0\right)$ on each elevation cut and how you interpolate between samples to get the beamwidth.
- Please explain the raised cosine in geometric terms
- It seems that hardware complexity has not been derived. Can authors at least give a hint on minimizing hardware complexity.
- It can be good to validate the claim of geometric balance with a moment check. The four segment replication in Fig. 1 is meant to preserve scan balance. Compute the first spatial moments $\sum I_{n, m} x_{n, m}$ and $\sum I_{n, m} y_{n, m}$ for a representative layout and show they are zero at broadside, and compute the second moments as well.
- There are typos like “capabillity” which should be “capability”. Please revise the paper for such typos.
References
[REF01] “Blind on board wideband antenna RF calibration for multi-antenna satellites,” 2017 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing (ICASSP), New Orleans, LA, USA, 2017, pp. 6294-6298, doi: 10.1109/ICASSP.2017.7953367
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe English could be improved to more clearly express the research.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 3 Comments
The paper introduces a Fibonacci based tessellation that partitions 16x16 planar phased array into bands with row level compositions, so that layouts reuse a small set of subproblems while keeping four fold symmetry. The method explores discrete spaces of layouts and selects solutions by a two objective scheme that trades SLL and FNBW while reducing total number of phase shifters.
I have the following comments:
1. The introduction can be better organized to state clearly the related works that already exist in the literature regarding phased array in general and methodologies followed in the state of the art.
Response: The introduction was corrected to be better organized to state clearly the related works that already exist in the literature. Please see the revised version of our paper.
2. The paper can also benefit from adding a paragraph on the need for antenna RF calibration for multi-antenna satellites [REF01]. Please include and explain.
References
[REF01] “Blind on board wideband antenna RF calibration for multi-antenna satellites,” 2017 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing (ICASSP), New Orleans, LA, USA, 2017, pp. 6294-6298, doi: 10.1109/ICASSP.2017.7953367
Response: The next paragraph about of the need for antenna calibration for multi-antenna satellites was added to the revised version of our paper. Furthermore, the suggested reference was added to our references list.
“Practical phased array implementations in satellite applications require a diligent RF calibration due to parameters such as gain and phase errors introduced by the RF chains. Some works addressed this problem by proposing algorithms to calibrate wideband multi-antenna satellites by estimating the angle of arrival (AoA) and other calibration parameters related to the frequency [18]. In contrast, this work addresses the problem from a design stage perspective by reducing the number of phased shifters by up to approximately 60%. This reduction decreases the calibration load by minimizing the number of RF chains that need to be calibrated during operation”
Please see the Section 4 of the revised version of our paper.
3. Kindly justify better the two objective construction. What other optimization frameworks can be used to attain the same objective?
Response: A better justification was added to the two objectives construction. Other frameworks or functions can be used to attain the same objectives. However, the proposed functions can represent adequately the desired objectives. Please see page 6 of the revised version of our paper.
4. Please describe gains in the domain of the array factor when utilizing the Fibonacci based tessellation.
Response: The gains in the domain of the array factor when utilizing the Fibonacci based tessellation are focused in reaching three objectives: the minimization of SLL, FNBW, and the reduction of the total number of phase shifters. This is described in the revised version of our paper.
5. Explain the weight update and its effect on the archive extracted. In equations (17) and (18), it seems that it is set $w_1$ and $w_2$ using min and max over an archive. For that, it would be good to describe the acceptance rule for that archive and when the weights are recomputed. If you change weights during the search, show a plot of the value of $f_1$ and $f_2$ for accepted solutions over time so that the reader sees the effect of the update rule. Sec. 2.4 . (1) copy_t
Response: The main reason for choosing the weights w1 and w2 as parameters of SLL and FNBW levels is to obtain a real number between the interval 0 < w1 ≤ w2 < 1, which is defined according to the ratio between the best and worst stored values in a solutions archive, extracted from the search with permissible SLL threshold. These weights are used with the sole purpose of scaling and are not updated during the optimization process.
This paragraph is set in Section 2.4 (page 6) of the revised version of our paper.
6. It can be good to explain better the FNBW extraction method. In particular, describe how you locate the first two zeros of $A F\left(\theta, \phi ; \theta_0, \phi_0\right)$ on each elevation cut and how you interpolate between samples to get the beamwidth.
Response: The FNBW represents the angular distance between the first two nulls adjacent to the mainlobe in the radiation pattern. It is calculated by searching for the first increment of value in the y-axis, starting at 0 dB (θ0), while displacing through the x-axis (representing the elevation plane) in both left and right directions. Each cut of AF(θ0, ϕ) with steps of ∆ϕ = 15◦ computes for a distinct FNBW value, which in some cases, an average value considering multiple cuts is calculated.
This paragraph was added to the Section 3 (page 7) of the revised version of our paper.
7. Please explain the raised cosine in geometric terms
Response: In the context of subarray distribution, the same distance equation applies by using an average distance of each subarray (centroid) to the array center replacing dn,m with
Equation 7 of the revised manuscript
while preserving a smoother taper despite an irregular subarray distribution and geometric shape. The centroid distance is computed by averaging each element coordinates of each subarray with Ns elements and then using that distance in the raised cosine tapering equation expressed in (5).
This paragraph was added to the Section 2.1 (page 3) of the revised version of our paper.
8. It seems that hardware complexity has not been derived. Can authors at least give a hint on minimizing hardware complexity.
Response: The hardware complexity has been derived as the phase shifter reduction percentage. This is defined by the division of the total number of subarrays in the array with respect to the conventional case, where each antenna element is independently fed with amplitude and phase values. Given that the array is divided by four symmetric segments, the phase shifter reduction percentage is calculated by
Equation 24 of the revised manuscript
where PStotal represents the total number of subarrays used for all sets Cm of one segment with eight subproblems, such that 1 ≤ m ≤ 8.
This was added to the Section 3 (page 7) of the revised manuscript.
9. It can be good to validate the claim of geometric balance with a moment check. The four segment replication in Fig. 1 is meant to preserve scan balance. Compute the first spatial moments $\sum I_{n, m} x_{n, m}$ and $\sum I_{n, m} y_{n, m}$ for a representative layout and show they are zero at broadside, and compute the second moments as well.
Response: For the purpose of verifying that the four segment replication preserves a geometric scan balance, the discrete spatial moments and product of inertia of the complex excitation distribution In,m were computed [17], making use of Case I as design reference. Let dxn,m and dyn,m be each antenna element coordinates with respect to the array center. Then, the first spatial moments are given by
Equation 25 of the revised manuscript
While the second moments and product of inertia are denoted as
Equation 26 of the revised manuscript
Resulting in values of Ax=Ay=0.03 for the normalized first moments, Bx=By=341.7 305 for the second moments, and Bxy=341.7 for the cross moment or product of inertia. The first results indicate that the array is nearly balanced at broadside but not perfectly centered, this is inferred from a small non-zero value of 0.03 obtained for the normalized centroids Ax=Ay, which suggests a slight offset. Additionally, the second moments (equal values) indicate that the aperture has an isotropic spread in both x and y axes, which confirms the array geometric balance. Finally, the product of inertia Bxy is different from zero and equal to Bx and By which reveals that the symmetry of the tessellation is aligned with the diagonals (45◦ ), thus, achieving geometric balance at broadside through a diagonal symmetry rather than a conventional symmetry dependent of aligned axes.
All this was added in the Section 3.5 (Geometric Balance by means of Spatial Moments) of the revised version of our paper.
10. There are typos like “capabillity” which should be “capability”. Please revise the paper for such typos.
Response: This was corrected in the revised version of our paper.
Thanks for your comments!
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript introduced a novel methodology for designing planar phased arrays for LEO satellite communication systems using Fibonacci-based tessellation combined with randomized multi-objective optimization. The approach reduced the number of required phase shifters while maintaining beamforming performance, including sidelobe suppression below −15 dB, wide-angle scanning (θ = −40° to 0°, ϕ = 0–360°), and stable first-null beamwidth. By constraining the array partitioning with Fibonacci sequences, the authors effectively reduce the search space, accelerating computation and enabling practical implementations of large arrays. The results demonstrated reductions of up to 62.5% in phase shifters compared to conventional fully controlled arrays, making the method promising for compact, cost-efficient Ku-band user terminals in satellite internet applications. The following comments might be helpful for improving the manuscript.
1) The work relied entirely on algorithmic modeling and synthetic radiation patterns. No hardware prototypes or experimental measurements are presented to confirm real-world feasibility.
2) While Fibonacci partitioning reduced the search space, exhaustive searches in larger arrays (e.g., 409,600 solutions) still require significant computational effort (≈2 hours). The scalability to larger-than-16×16 arrays is not fully addressed.
3) Although sidelobe levels and phase-shifter reductions were reported, there was limited discussion of the trade-offs in other key metrics such as gain, efficiency, or robustness to mutual coupling and element imperfections.
4) The paper did not provide direct performance comparisons against alternative methods (e.g., fractal, sunflower, or hexagonal arrays), which would strengthen claims of superiority.
5) Implementation aspects such as phase-shifter quantization, manufacturing tolerances, cost analysis, or integration into actual satellite terminals were not considered, which may affect applicability.
6) The authors did not discuss how to deploy the proposed antennas in space.
7) Figure quality (resolution) is low, that should be replaced with better ones.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 4 Comments
The manuscript introduced a novel methodology for designing planar phased arrays for LEO satellite communication systems using Fibonacci-based tessellation combined with randomized multi-objective optimization. The approach reduced the number of required phase shifters while maintaining beamforming performance, including sidelobe suppression below −15 dB, wide-angle scanning (θ = −40° to 0°, ϕ = 0–360°), and stable first-null beamwidth. By constraining the array partitioning with Fibonacci sequences, the authors effectively reduce the search space, accelerating computation and enabling practical implementations of large arrays. The results demonstrated reductions of up to 62.5% in phase shifters compared to conventional fully controlled arrays, making the method promising for compact, cost-efficient Ku-band user terminals in satellite internet applications. The following comments might be helpful for improving the manuscript.
1) The work relied entirely on algorithmic modeling and synthetic radiation patterns. No hardware prototypes or experimental measurements are presented to confirm real-world feasibility.
Response: Practical phased array implementations in satellite applications require a diligent RF calibration due to parameters such as gain and phase errors introduced by the RF chains. Some works addressed this problem by proposing algorithms to calibrate wideband multi-antenna satellites by estimating the angle of arrival (AoA) and other calibration parameters related to the frequency [18]. In contrast, this work addresses the problem from a design stage perspective by reducing the number of phased shifters by up to approximately 60%. This reduction decreases the calibration load by minimizing the number of RF chains that need to be calibrated during operation.
This was added to the Section 4 of the revised version of our paper.
Furthermore, the next paragraph was added to the Section 1 (Introduction) of the revised version of our paper:
The main scope of this paper is to provide a system-level optimization framework focusing on the design problem, leveraging a low algorithmic computational time produced by the implementation of initial constraints in the combinatorial subarray arrangement. Thus, search spaces that would be unattainable by exhaustive approaches are partially explored by using bio-inspired random algorithms, as a mean of obtaining feasible solutions in a reasonable amount of time.
2) While Fibonacci partitioning reduced the search space, exhaustive searches in larger arrays (e.g., 409,600 solutions) still require significant computational effort (≈2 hours). The scalability to larger-than-16×16 arrays is not fully addressed.
Response: A new discrete framework for the design of planar phased arrays based on the Fibonacci sequence is introduced in this work; which is intended to generate fast and feasible planar array designs from a discrete and constrained mathematical perspective. This approach offers the designer some advantages over random unconstrained methods, such as the ability to determine beforehand the number of phase lines for the feeding network or to choose the permissible sizes of subarrays in the array. The Fibonacci sequence is a series of integer numbers where each number is the sum of the two preceding ones, defined by
Fn = Fn−1 + Fn−2, (13)
where F0 = 0 and F1 = 1. The scalability of this methodology is bounded by multiples of this sequence embedded in the dimensions of the N × M quadrangular array. Thus, the total number of antenna elements per axis in the matrix is given by
N = M = (Fn + Fn−3) | n ≥ 3. (14)
The latter expression restricts the dimensions of the achievable planar array designs to the sequence N = M ∈ {2, 4, 6, 10, 16, 26, 42 . . .}, providing a discrete boundary for both antenna elements and phase shifters prior to the search for optimal solutions.
This was added to the Section 2.3 of our paper. Please see the revised version of our paper.
3) Although sidelobe levels and phase-shifter reductions were reported, there was limited discussion of the trade-offs in other key metrics such as gain, efficiency, or robustness to mutual coupling and element imperfections.
Response: Although a several number of effects such as mutual coupling and phase quantization are not addressed in the scope of this work, the Fibonacci tessellation methodology provides indirect structural properties that contribute to mitigate these undesired conditions. The irregular distribution of subarrays allows to reduce the strong coupling from nearest elements compared to periodic arrangements added to the raised cosine tapering which ensures a flat level of excitation to mitigate element perturbations. Additionally, by reducing the number of phase shifters this approach minimizes the total impact of quantization which can be validated in future work under realistic implementation constraints.
This was added to the Section 4 of our paper. Please see the revised version of our paper.
4) The paper did not provide direct performance comparisons against alternative methods (e.g., fractal, sunflower, or hexagonal arrays), which would strengthen claims of superiority.
Response: A performance comparison analysis against alternative methods was added to the revised version of our paper. Please see Table 7 and page 13 of the revised version of our paper.
5) Implementation aspects such as phase-shifter quantization, manufacturing tolerances, cost analysis, or integration into actual satellite terminals were not considered, which may affect applicability.
Response: As commented previously, although a several number of effects such as mutual coupling and phase quantization are not addressed in the scope of this work, the Fibonacci tessellation methodology provides indirect structural properties that contribute to mitigate these undesired conditions. The irregular distribution of subarrays allows to reduce the strong coupling from nearest elements compared to periodic arrangements added to the raised cosine tapering which ensures a flat level of excitation to mitigate element perturbations. Additionally, by reducing the number of phase shifters this approach minimizes the total impact of quantization which can be validated in future work under realistic implementation constraints.
This was added to the Section 4 of our paper. Please see the revised version of our paper.
6) The authors did not discuss how to deploy the proposed antennas in space.
Response: As commented previously, Practical phased array implementations in satellite applications require a diligent RF calibration due to parameters such as gain and phase errors introduced by the RF chains. Some works addressed this problem by proposing algorithms to calibrate wideband multi-antenna satellites by estimating the angle of arrival (AoA) and other calibration parameters related to the frequency [18]. In contrast, this work addresses the problem from a design stage perspective by reducing the number of phased shifters by up to approximately 60%. This reduction decreases the calibration load by minimizing the number of RF chains that need to be calibrated during operation.
This was added to the Section 4 of the revised version of our paper.
7) Figure quality (resolution) is low, that should be replaced with better ones.
Response: This was corrected in the revised version of our paper.
Thanks for your comments!
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThanks for the clarification. I do not have any more comments.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe reviewer has no more comments.
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors had attempted to resolve all comments of the reviewer so it is recommended for publication now.