Review Reports
- Anastasios Alatzas 1,†,
- Despina Samakovli 2,† and
- Polydefkis Hatzopoulos 1,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Muhammad Ali Mumtaz Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe combination of transcriptomic profiling and subcellular localization provides clear mechanistic insights linking light signaling, RNA metabolism, and plastid nucleus coordination. The results are well presented with clear figures and supplementary tables.
Suggestion 1. Transcriptomic data analysis reveals an aberrant light response of lefko 1
The RNA-seq dataset provides details of upregulated and downregulated genes; however, it does not directly support the conclusion that lefko 1 is light-responsive. This claim would be strengthened by showing the change in LEFKOTHEA expression under light versus dark conditions.
Suggestion 2. Many splicing changes are reported, but experimental validation (RT–PCR or isoform-specific qPCR) for representative genes would be a great addition to confirm bioinformatic predictions
Suggestion 3. The text occasionally repeats earlier points about mxe prevalence and light-induced redistribution of LEFKOTHEA. This could be condensed to reinforce the main conceptual model.
Author Response
Reviewer 1
The combination of transcriptomic profiling and subcellular localization provides clear mechanistic insights linking light signaling, RNA metabolism, and plastid nucleus coordination. The results are well presented with clear figures and supplementary tables.
Answer: We would like to thank the reviewer for his/her positive approach to our work.
Suggestion 1. Transcriptomic data analysis reveals an aberrant light response of lefko 1
The RNA-seq dataset provides details of upregulated and downregulated genes; however, it does not directly support the conclusion that lefko 1 is light-responsive. This claim would be strengthened by showing the change in LEFKOTHEA expression under light versus dark conditions.
Answer: We would like to thank the reviewer for the suggestion. To this view we quantified the LEFKO protein levels in all the presented tissues in Figure 5 and Figure 6. Our results show clearly that LEFKOTHEA protein levels increase after exposure to light. (Revised Figures 5 and 6).
Suggestion 2. Many splicing changes are reported, but experimental validation (RT–PCR or isoform-specific qPCR) for representative genes would be a great addition to confirm bioinformatic predictions.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the useful comment. This would be an experiment of great importance, but unfortunately, it would be difficult to perform within the 10-day revision period. However, we checked whether amongst the genes with splicing differences in the RNAseq analysis are those genes that have been analyzed in Daras et al., 2019. We were able to detect At3G53500 and At3g48070
Suggestion 3. The text occasionally repeats earlier points about mxe prevalence and light-induced redistribution of LEFKOTHEA. This could be condensed to reinforce the main conceptual model.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the suggestion. We changed this part in the discussion and now it goes as follows: “While intron retention (IR) is typically the dominant mode of alternative splicing in plants, we observed a high prevalence of mutually exclusive exons (mxe) during light exposure in wild-type seedlings. The high percentage of mxe splicing mode was evident, with almost stable frequency at all the tested time points in wild-type seedlings. In lefko 1 mutants, however, mxe frequency fluctuated significantly peaking abruptly at 24 hours before declining. This suggests that LEFKOTHEA regulates splicing factors through light-induced redistribution; notably, at the 24-hour mark, the protein is no longer detectable in the nucleus, coinciding with the observed splicing defects. This influence is transient, as mxe events become nearly undetectable by 72 hours and in 7-day-old cotyledons [33].”
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis study employs a multidisciplinary approach to systematically explore the role of LEFKOTHEA in light response, demonstrating that it modulates gene expression by regulating alternative splicing and transcriptional output, thereby coordinating nucleus-chloroplast communication and influencing photomorphogenesis. The research addresses a gap in the understanding of splicing factors within light signaling pathways, supported by comprehensive data, with particular highlights in time-series transcriptomic analysis and subcellular localization experiments. However, the paper exhibits limitations in the description of statistical methods, the coherence between results and discussion, and consistency in terminology, which require revision to enhance rigor. Overall, minor revision is recommended, contingent on the authors' effective response to the following points.
- Photosynthetic pigment accumulation analysis shows a monophasic pattern of chlorophyll a and b accumulation in thelefko1mutant, in contrast to the biphasic pattern in the wild type. However, the biological significance of the biphasic accumulation pattern is not explained, nor is it clarified how LEFKOTHEA regulates this process. It is recommended to incorporate discussion based on existing research to enhance the depth of interpretation of these results.
- Alternative splicing mode analysis reveals a sharp increase in mutually exclusive exon (mxe) events in thelefko1mutant at 24 h, followed by a decline. However, the specific genes corresponding to these mxe events and their functions are not identified, nor is it investigated how changes in the mxe mode affect the plant's light response. It is suggested to supplement the functional annotation and enrichment analysis of differentially alternatively spliced genes to clarify the key splicing events and their biological significance. The authors attribute this to the absence of LEFKOTHEA from the nucleus at this time point but do not provide direct evidence of protein localization (e.g., nucleo-cytoplasmic fractionation followed by Western blot). It is recommended to add such experiments or at least support the argument with cited literature in the discussion.
- Stromules are tubular extensions of chloroplasts, and LEFKOTHEA is localized to stromules. However, its specific function within stromules—such as whether it participates in signal transmission between chloroplasts and the nucleus—is not addressed. It is advisable to supplement relevant experiments based on known functions of stromules to clarify the role of LEFKOTHEA in these structures.
- Several formatting inconsistencies or errors are present in the text, for example, in lines 201, 145, 652, and 659. A thorough proofreading is recommended to ensure consistency in terminology, figure references, and numerical notation throughout the manuscript.
Author Response
Reviewer 2
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
This study employs a multidisciplinary approach to systematically explore the role of LEFKOTHEA in light response, demonstrating that it modulates gene expression by regulating alternative splicing and transcriptional output, thereby coordinating nucleus-chloroplast communication and influencing photomorphogenesis. The research addresses a gap in the understanding of splicing factors within light signaling pathways, supported by comprehensive data, with particular highlights in time-series transcriptomic analysis and subcellular localization experiments. However, the paper exhibits limitations in the description of statistical methods, the coherence between results and discussion, and consistency in terminology, which require revision to enhance rigor. Overall, minor revision is recommended, contingent on the authors' effective response to the following points.
- Photosynthetic pigment accumulation analysis shows a monophasic pattern of chlorophyll a and b accumulation in thelefko1mutant, in contrast to the biphasic pattern in the wild type. However, the biological significance of the biphasic accumulation pattern is not explained, nor is it clarified how LEFKOTHEA regulates this process. It is recommended to incorporate discussion based on existing research to enhance the depth of interpretation of these results.
- Answer: We thank the reviewer for the suggestion. In order to discuss the significance of the observed monophasic pattern of chlorophyll biosynthesis versus the typical biphasic in wild-type plants, we added some comments in the respective paragraph in results as well as in the discussion part.
Lines 188-196. Furthermore, while wild-type plants showed the typical biphasic pattern of chlorophyll biosynthesis, which is characterized by an initial rapid surge that protects etiolated seedlings from photooxidative stress, followed by a secondary, more substantial ac-cumulation phase as the plant transitions to photoautotrophic growth. In lefko1 seedlings this pattern is disturbed and becomes monophasic. Given that the biphasic nature of chlorophyll synthesis depends on the successful transition from etioplast to chloroplast, the monophasic pattern in lefko 1 indicates that the mutant has difficulties entering the second phase of chloroplast expansion, which is common in mutants defective in plastid-to-nucleus signaling, such as gun1 [36].
Lines 625-630: While light promotes rapid chlorophyll accumulation during chloroplast structure establishment, followed by sustained increase during chloroplast proliferation [35], in this study the lefko2 mutant showed defects in chlorophyll levels relative to WT. Since the development of photosynthetic capacity relies on efficient chloroplast biogenesis, it is anticipated that disruptions in chlorophyll biosynthesis stall chloroplast differentiation during de-etiolation in lefko2 seedlings.
Lines 691-700: In addition, the localization of LEFKOTHEA in stromule-like structures that align with plasmodesmata at the cell wall was evident, especially after exposure of dark-grown plants to light. This localization points toward a potential function in cell-to-cell signaling. Based on our results, we propose that LEFKOTHEA—targeted to both the nucleus and chloroplast—acts as a molecular module that synchronizes gene expression by modulating nuclear pre-mRNA and plastid group II intron splicing. In lefko 1 mutants, the disruption of this dual targeting causes a post-transcriptional bottleneck and creates incorrect or confusing signals between organelles. This uncoupling of nuclear transcription from chloroplast assembly prevents the plant from accurately responding to light stimuli during early development to become photosynthetically efficient.
Alternative splicing mode analysis reveals a sharp increase in mutually exclusive exon (mxe) events in thelefko1mutant at 24 h, followed by a decline. However, the specific genes corresponding to these mxe events and their functions are not identified, nor is it investigated how changes in the mxe mode affect the plant's light response. It is suggested to supplement the functional annotation and enrichment analysis of differentially alternatively spliced genes to clarify the key splicing events and their biological significance. The authors attribute this to the absence of LEFKOTHEA from the nucleus at this time point but do not provide direct evidence of protein localization (e.g., nucleo-cytoplasmic fractionation followed by Western blot). It is recommended to add such experiments or at least support the argument with cited literature in the discussion.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the valuable comments.
- Regarding the specific genes corresponding to mxe, among other splicing events, there is a detailed description in the Supplementary Table S5. In this Table we refer to all the genes with splicing differences in each time point in the RNAseq analysis.
- There is a detailed KEGG and GO pathway analysis of total alternative splicing events identified in all lefko1 and Col-0 samples compared to the first time-point t=0 presented in Supplementary Table S3.
- In addition, we performed functional annotation and enrichment analysis of the alternative splicing with mutually exclusive exon mode at the time point of 24h light and we show that the highest enrichment was in metabolic pathways related to carbon fixation in photosynthetic organisms, glycolysis/gluconeogenesis and carbon metabolism; however, metabolic pathways involving spliceosome were also present. Chloroplast and plastids were the cellular compartments with the highest fold enrichment, while there was significant fold enrichment in plasmodesmata and cell junction cellular compartments.
- Concerning the suggested nucleo-cytoplasmic fractionation and the Western blot analysis, we need to say that the nuclear localization is evident only in specific cells under certain conditions. This is the reason why we believe that such an experiment is difficult to show the dynamic localization of LEFKOTHEA protein between cytoplasm and nucleus. Instead of this we have quantified the nuclear signal of LEFKO in the petiole and cotyledon cells under different light regimes. The results are presented in the Figure 6.
Stromules are tubular extensions of chloroplasts, and LEFKOTHEA is localized to stromules. However, its specific function within stromules—such as whether it participates in signal transmission between chloroplasts and the nucleus—is not addressed. It is advisable to supplement relevant experiments based on known functions of stromules to clarify the role of LEFKOTHEA in these structures.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the comment. The localization of LEFKOTHEA proteins in such tubular extensions of the chloroplasts, resembling stromules, gained our interest from the beginning. In Figures 5 and 6, we present images showing plasmodesmata at the cell wall where these tubular extensions of the chloroplasts, stromules-like structures with tubular extensions, end up. This indicates that a possible function of LEFKO protein in these stromule-like structures is intercellular signal transition or communication. Please check: Hanson, M.R.; Hines, K.M. Stromules: Probing formation and function. Plant Physiol. 2018, 176, 128-137.
Several formatting inconsistencies or errors are present in the text, for example, in lines 201, 145, 652, and 659. A thorough proofreading is recommended to ensure consistency in terminology, figure references, and numerical notation throughout the manuscript.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for pointing out these formatting errors. We have corrected the indicated points.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsIn this manuscript, the authors analyze the role of LEFKOTHEA during the early light response in Arabidopsis, combining phenotypic analyses, a time-course RNA-seq comparison of wild type and lefko1, and confocal localization studies of LEFKOTHEA under different light regimes. The RNA-seq data reveal extensive changes in gene expression and alternative splicing over time, and the authors interpret these as regulatory roles of LEFKOTHEA in photosynthetic pigment biosynthesis and splicing control. In addition, the manuscript presents light-dependent changes in the subcellular and tissue-specific localization of LEFKOTHEA, which constitute the most interesting and potentially novel aspect of the study. The dramatic change in petioles from a nuclear localization of LEFKOTHEA in etiolated tissue to a plastid one is the highlight of the story. However, the conclusions drawn from both the transcriptomic and localization data are often overstated. In particular, the gene expression analyses are strongly confounded by the massive pleiotropic effects expected from impaired chloroplast development in a stable lefkothea mutant, and the localization claims are weakened by the lack of quantitative image analysis and insufficient information on imaging comparability.
Major points
- The authors frequently use the term “regulates” to describe the function of LEFKOTHEA, particularly in section headers (e.g. “2.4. LEFKOTHEA regulates the mode of alternative splicing events” and “2.2. LEFKOTHEA regulates the biosynthesis of photosynthetic pigments during the early light response”). However, the RNA-seq analysis is correlative and, more importantly, is heavily influenced by the strong pleiotropic effects that are expected in mutants that globally impair chloroplast development.
Given that LEFKOTHEA is a chloroplast splicing factor and that this function is well established, it is known that defects in the splicing of introns in key chloroplast genes (e.g. ribosomal proteins) lead to embryo lethality in strong alleles. Thus, even in the viable lefko1 allele, a strong reduction of chloroplast gene expression and chloroplast development is expected to cause massive secondary effects on both chloroplast and nuclear gene expression. On top of this, LEFKOTHEA has also been described as a nuclear splicing factor, adding yet another layer of indirect gene expression changes and pleiotropic effects.
Since the mutant used here is a stable mutant, the transcriptome profiles necessarily reflect end-point effects that are massive by nature and cannot be directly linked to a specific regulatory function of LEFKOTHEA. Consequently, causal wording such as “regulates” or “modulates” is not justified. Although the manuscript title uses “modulate” instead of “regulate”, this still implies a direct functional link that is not demonstrated. A more appropriate wording for the title would be, for example:“Loss of LEFKOTHEA leads to global transcriptional and post-transcriptional changes in gene expression during the early light response.”
- The RNA-seq time-course analysis contains interesting observations, but there are also surprising shifts in DEG patterns. For example, the strong early change in photosynthetic gene expression appears to be largely lost at 1 hour, only to reappear at 3 hours. In this context, it is essential to demonstrate the quality and reproducibility of the RNA-seq data. In the supplementary material, standard RNA-seq quality control analyses should be shown to demonstrate that the observed patterns are robust. Since RNA-seq data drive main conclusions, the manuscript should minimally include:
- PCA or MDS analysis for sample clustering and replicate consistency
- Read depth and mapping statistics per sample
- Gene expression distribution and expression complexity across samples
All should be supplemental.
- In Figures 5 and 6, the authors make several claims about changes in LEFKOTHEA localization that are not supported by quantitative analysis.
For Figure 5a, the authors state that there is a “significantly lower [signal] in the pericycle and the central cylinder”. However, the exposure appears to have been adjusted to accommodate the much stronger overall signal after four days of light exposure. Because peripheral tissues show a strong increase in signal, the apparent decrease in the center of the root could be an artefact. Any statement invoking “significance” requires quantitative analysis of signal intensities.
In Figure 5b, the authors state that “there was a low but detectable signal in the nucleus”. However, the middle panel appears to show a generally elevated background, with a weak green signal throughout the cell, making it unclear whether the nuclear signal is real or background-related. Similarly, the claim that leucoplasts assemble “around the nucleus” is not supported, as the nucleus is not stained and no distance or spatial measurements are provided.
In Figure 6, similar issues persist. It is unclear whether the stronger cytoplasmic signal observed in the dark-grown samples reflects true biological differences or differences in microscope settings. A clearer description is required of how background was determined and how laser power and detector settings were controlled across samples. Statements such as: “LEFKOTHEA protein was found to localize at the chloroplasts of cells belonging mainly to the stomatal lineage and less in pavement cells” require quantitative analysis across multiple cells and biological replicates.
4. The authors claim that LEFKOTHEA is mainly localized to stromules in some root cells. To support this, co-localization with a stromal or plastid marker is required to demonstrate enrichment in stromules. As presented, it is not even conclusively shown that the observed structures are plastids. Nor is it a strong argument to show that proteins known to reside in stromules show gene expression differences in the mutant (and by the way, these proteins are also found in the stroma, not only in the stromules).
Minor points
- Line 93: “possesses” instead of “processes”.
- Line 95: “while its nuclear compartmentalization confines chloroplast biogenesis” is unclear what is meant by “confines” and should be rephrased.
- The statement: “During the first 24 h of light exposure … the downregulated DEGs … therefore, indicating a dominant chloroplast localization” is incorrect. Gene expression changes cannot be used to infer protein localization; the conclusion starting with “indicating…” should be deleted.
- Line 538: “genes located in stromules” should be “proteins”.
Author Response
Reviewer 3
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
In this manuscript, the authors analyze the role of LEFKOTHEA during the early light response in Arabidopsis, combining phenotypic analyses, a time-course RNA-seq comparison of wild type and lefko1, and confocal localization studies of LEFKOTHEA under different light regimes. The RNA-seq data reveal extensive changes in gene expression and alternative splicing over time, and the authors interpret these as regulatory roles of LEFKOTHEA in photosynthetic pigment biosynthesis and splicing control. In addition, the manuscript presents light-dependent changes in the subcellular and tissue-specific localization of LEFKOTHEA, which constitute the most interesting and potentially novel aspect of the study. The dramatic change in petioles from a nuclear localization of LEFKOTHEA in etiolated tissue to a plastid one is the highlight of the story. However, the conclusions drawn from both the transcriptomic and localization data are often overstated. In particular, the gene expression analyses are strongly confounded by the massive pleiotropic effects expected from impaired chloroplast development in a stable lefkothea mutant, and the localization claims are weakened by the lack of quantitative image analysis and insufficient information on imaging comparability.
Answer: We would like to thank the reviewer for the constructive comments. Please find below how we addressed the reviewer’s comments point by point.
Major points
- The authors frequently use the term “regulates” to describe the function of LEFKOTHEA, particularly in section headers (e.g. “2.4. LEFKOTHEA regulates the mode of alternative splicing events” and “2.2. LEFKOTHEA regulates the biosynthesis of photosynthetic pigments during the early light response”). However, the RNA-seq analysis is correlative and, more importantly, is heavily influenced by the strong pleiotropic effects that are expected in mutants that globally impair chloroplast development.
Given that LEFKOTHEA is a chloroplast splicing factor and that this function is well established, it is known that defects in the splicing of introns in key chloroplast genes (e.g. ribosomal proteins) lead to embryo lethality in strong alleles. Thus, even in the viable lefko1 allele, a strong reduction of chloroplast gene expression and chloroplast development is expected to cause massive secondary effects on both chloroplast and nuclear gene expression. On top of this, LEFKOTHEA has also been described as a nuclear splicing factor, adding yet another layer of indirect gene expression changes and pleiotropic effects.
Since the mutant used here is a stable mutant, the transcriptome profiles necessarily reflect end-point effects that are massive by nature and cannot be directly linked to a specific regulatory function of LEFKOTHEA. Consequently, causal wording such as “regulates” or “modulates” is not justified. Although the manuscript title uses “modulate” instead of “regulate”, this still implies a direct functional link that is not demonstrated. A more appropriate wording for the title would be, for example:“Loss of LEFKOTHEA leads to global transcriptional and post-transcriptional changes in gene expression during the early light response.”
Answer: We are grateful for this suggestion. To be more consistent and precise, we have changed the title of the manuscript as the reviewer suggested as well as we have made appropriate alterations in the titles of the paragraphs.
- The RNA-seq time-course analysis contains interesting observations, but there are also surprising shifts in DEG patterns. For example, the strong early change in photosynthetic gene expression appears to be largely lost at 1 hour, only to reappear at 3 hours. In this context, it is essential to demonstrate the quality and reproducibility of the RNA-seq data. In the supplementary material, standard RNA-seq quality control analyses should be shown to demonstrate that the observed patterns are robust. Since RNA-seq data drive main conclusions, the manuscript should minimally include:
Answer: We thank the reviewer for this comment. In the revised manuscript, we have added two Supplementary Figures and additional Supplementary Tables with RNAseq quality metrics and statistics.
- PCA or MDS analysis for sample clustering and replicate consistency.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the suggestion. PCA analysis is presented in Figure S2b.
- Read depth and mapping statistics per sample.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the suggestion. We present this information for mapping statistics in Supplementary Figures S1, Supplementary Figure S2 and Supplementary Table S1.
- Gene expression distribution and expression complexity across samples
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the suggestion. We present this information for mapping statistics in Supplementary Figures S1, Supplementary Figure S2 and Supplementary Table S1.
All should be supplemental.
- In Figures 5 and 6, the authors make several claims about changes in LEFKOTHEA localization that are not supported by quantitative analysis.
For Figure 5a, the authors state that there is a “significantly lower [signal] in the pericycle and the central cylinder”. However, the exposure appears to have been adjusted to accommodate the much stronger overall signal after four days of light exposure. Because peripheral tissues show a strong increase in signal, the apparent decrease in the center of the root could be an artefact. Any statement invoking “significance” requires quantitative analysis of signal intensities.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the comment; however, we have to say that the microscope settings are the same for all the presented images in Figures 5 and 6. Please check in the materials and methods sections the microscopy part. In addition, the contrast was adjusted in the same range for each group of images e.g. the contrast is the same for root tips in Figure 5a, the same for root meristematic and transition zone epidermal cells and the same for all the images presented in Figure 6.
In addition, we have quantified the fluorescent signal in two different cell files in the root tips, and the results are presented in Figure 5b. Furthermore, quantifications and statistical analyses of the fluorescent signal of LEFKO-YFP fusion protein in root epidermal cells of the meristematic and transition zones are presented in Figure 5d- e, respectively.
In Figure 5b, the authors state that “there was a low but detectable signal in the nucleus”. However, the middle panel appears to show a generally elevated background, with a weak green signal throughout the cell, making it unclear whether the nuclear signal is real or background-related. Similarly, the claim that leucoplasts assemble “around the nucleus” is not supported, as the nucleus is not stained and no distance or spatial measurements are provided.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the comment. In the revised manuscript, we have rephrased this part. Please check the respective part in the results
In Figure 6, similar issues persist. It is unclear whether the stronger cytoplasmic signal observed in the dark-grown samples reflects true biological differences or differences in microscope settings. A clearer description is required of how background was determined and how laser power and detector settings were controlled across samples. Statements such as: “LEFKOTHEA protein was found to localize at the chloroplasts of cells belonging mainly to the stomatal lineage and less in pavement cells” require quantitative analysis across multiple cells and biological replicates.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the comments. As mentioned above, the microscope settings are the same for all the presented images; therefore, we strongly believe that the strong fluorescent signal, which is evident in the cytoplasm of dark-grown seedlings, reflects the true biological differences and is not an artifact.
Furthermore, we quantified the fluorescent signal in stomatal precursor and pavement cells to support our statement that “LEFKOTHEA protein was found to localize at the chloroplasts of cells belonging mainly to the stomatal lineage and less in pavement cells”. The results are presented in Figure 6f.
- The authors claim that LEFKOTHEA is mainly localized to stromules in some root cells. To support this, co-localization with a stromal or plastid marker is required to demonstrate enrichment in stromules. As presented, it is not even conclusively shown that the observed structures are plastids. Nor is it a strong argument to show that proteins known to reside in stromules show gene expression differences in the mutant (and by the way, these proteins are also found in the stroma, not only in the stromules).
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the comment. Obviously, we cannot perform the suggested co-localization experiments with stromal or plastid markers in such a short revision period of time. Therefore, we have rephrased the respective part in the revised manuscript, where the previously mentioned “stromules” have changed to “leucoplast-like structures with tubular extensions”.
Minor points
- Line 93: “possesses” instead of “processes”.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the indication. The typo mistake was corrected in the revised manuscript.
- Line 95: “while its nuclear compartmentalization confines chloroplast biogenesis” is unclear what is meant by “confines” and should be rephrased.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for pointing out this inconsistency. We have rephrased this sentence as “Although LEFKOTHEA is found in both the nucleus and the chloroplast, its nuclear compartmentalization is essential for promoting early embryonic development in Arabidopsis by repressing chloroplast biogenesis; disruption of this process leads to embryo lethality”
- The statement: “During the first 24 h of light exposure … the downregulated DEGs … therefore, indicating a dominant chloroplast localization” is incorrect. Gene expression changes cannot be used to infer protein localization; the conclusion starting with “indicating…” should be deleted.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for the recommendation; in the revised manuscript we deleted this phrase.
- Line 538: “genes located in stromules” should be “proteins”.
Answer: We thank the reviewer for pointing out this inconsistency. In the revised manuscript we changed genes to proteins