Review Reports
- Weihao Lun 1,
- Shihao Shi 1 and
- Yisong Lin 2
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Alexey Vishnevskiy Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript contains significant scientific and presentation issues. Please see the attached file for detailed comments.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Several sentences are awkward or unclear. There are run-on sentences and missing articles. A thorough language polish by a native speaker or a professional editing service is recommended.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer, We greatly appreciate your valuable suggestions and hard work. Please check our detailed responses in the attachment.Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe aim of the research described in the manuscript was to investigate the effect of Ti concentration on the microstructure, chemical bond structure, and piezoresistive properties of DLC films.
I suggest adding the research methods used in the work to the abstract.
To understand the manufacturing process, the Materials and Methods section should include the vacuum chamber manufacturer used by the authors. The purity of Ar and C2H2. The diameter and purity of the titanium target. The sputtering time of the titanium target.
The authors do not specify the equipment used to measure hardness, the load, or the measurement time. Specifically, what percentage of the coating thickness was the indentation depth?
Why was the EDS method used to measure carbon and titanium concentration? This method continually deposits carbon on the sample surface—a contamination phenomenon. The EDS method for determining carbon concentration is imprecise and often overestimates its concentration.
In line 134, the authors write, "All films are dense and smooth." It would be useful to clarify this by presenting AFM maps and some roughness parameter.
In line 153, the authors write, "This implies Ti exists in the films in amorphous or clustered states" [25]. In thin films obtained by magnetron sputtering, the resulting metal particles typically have a crystalline structure. However, in the case described by the authors, the XRD method does not necessarily show peaks for crystalline metal particles with sizes below 2-3 nm, which is described in the literature.
In line 170, the authors write, "Since no diffraction peaks corresponding to TiC were found in the XRD patterns, the TiC was expected to exist in the film as an amorphous state". After all, in Figure 12a, the SAED image shows crystalline TiC
In line 270, the authors write, "High-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) images of the DLC-Ti film demonstrate that the film is dominated by amorphous carbon, along with extremely refined grains including α- and β-Ti". The HRTEM images presented in Fig. 12b and c do not allow for the determination of the atomic arrangement (crystalline or amorphous phase). The magnification used is too low. What does clusters mean in Fig. 12b? There is no commentary on this in the manuscript text. Are these 2-3 nm crystalline nanoparticles or 2-3 nm amorphous nanoparticles? The presented images do not answer this question. This is certainly the case as the authors write, but it is not apparent from the HRTEM images in Fig. 12b.
Furthermore, the manuscript lacks information regarding the crystallite sizes of the alpha and beta phases of titanium and TiC, depending on the titanium concentration. The authors should determine this from TEM image analysis and XRD patterns, and link this relationship to piezoresistive properties. After all, the authors state that the aim of the work was to investigate the effect of Ti concentration on the microstructure of DLC films.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer, We greatly appreciate your valuable suggestions and hard work. Please check our detailed responses in the attachment.Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsGeneral formatting and notation:
1. En-dash → hyphen, Lines 9 (twice), 17, 126, 181, 186 (spin-split), 265, 266, 268, 270 (twice), 296 (twice), 298 (twice), 301, 303 (twice), 305, 326, 332, 349, 357, 375 (low-energy), 392 (short-range), 393, 422, 445, 447, 452, 453, 465, 507 (in-plane), 516 (thrice), 517 (twice: β- to α-Ti), 525 (β-Ti), 528 (twice), 529, 530 (twice), 533, 541, 548 (twice) – please check carefully.
2. Lines 19, 225, 544; Fig. 6b: The reported value –9.04×10⁻² GPa⁻¹ has two decimal places, but the error bars in Figure 6b range from about ±0.1×10⁻² to ±0.4×10⁻² making the last digit insignificant. Please round to one decimal place.
3. Line 39: "DLC: W" → " DLC:W" (without space).
4. Line 53: The authors changed "normal stress" to "applied stress" but kept the unit "g" (grams?). Stress cannot be measured in grams. Please either replace "stress" with "mass" or convert the value to pascals using the contact area.
5. Lines 64–65: Redundant abbreviation definition: "HiPIMS" is defined twice (already defined in line 50). Remove the second definition.
6. Line 70: Should change "Temperature Coefficient of Resistance" → "temperature coefficient of resistance" (lowercase).
7. Minus (en-dash), Lines 19, 20, 108, 123 (twice), 149, 150 (twice), 206 (twice), 224 (also on a separate line before the numbers), 225 (twice), 254 (twice), 420, 421, 544 (thrice), 486; Fig. 8.
8. Lines 98–142: When mentioning instrument manufacturers (Liaoning Beiyu Vacuum Technology Co., LEO, Philips Panalytical, Kratos, Merrick, Anton Paar, Rek), provide the city and country.
9. Lines 98, 112: If the authors intend to specify the size, the notations "20 × 20 × 2 mm³" and "470 × 110 × 8 mm³" are incorrect because mm³ denotes volume. Please write them as "20 × 20 × 2 mm" or "20 mm × 20 mm × 2 mm" (linear dimensions, not volume).
10. Lines 98–99: The authors still do not provide details on the substrate (e.g., supplier, crystallographic orientation, preparation method).
11. Lines 109–110: The abbreviation DLC (diamond-like carbon) has already been defined earlier. Introducing "Hydrogenated DLC" in this sentence is inconsistent with the rest of the manuscript, where the films are referred to simply as DLC:Ti. Please either remove "Hydrogenated" or adopt a consistent term throughout (e.g., DLC:Ti:H).
12. Lines 111–112: The authors do not provide details on the Ti target (e.g., supplier, preparation).
13. Lines 120–121: The abbreviation "GIXRD" is not defined. Additionally, the text states a scanning range of 30°–70°, but the XRD patterns in Figures 3 and 9 show only 32.6°–40.4°. Please define the abbreviation and correct the range.
14. Should be in italic font, Lines 124 (h_γ), 498 (I_D/I_G), 512 (I_D/I_G).
15. Line 132: Duplicate word: "calibration was calibrated" → delete the first "calibration".
16. Lines 137–140: Specify the indenter type (Berkovich, etc.).
17. Delta (Δ) and zero (0) symbols should not be italicized, Line 145, Fig. 6a, Fig. 7a–e.
18. Delete the dot symbol after "Figure" in Lines 148, 165, 176, 185, 264, 276, 285, 308, 311, 319, 332, 418.
19. Line 148: "Figure. 1" → "Figure 1a".
20. Line 153: "Figure. 3" → "Figure 1b".
21. Figure 2: "Cross section" → "Cross-section".
22. Hyphen → en-dash, Lines 180, 312 (Ti–C), Figs. 1a, 6, 7.
23. No space symbol after figure numbers before panel indication symbols, Lines: 189, 193, 281.
24. Line 297: The abbreviation "HRTEM" appears before its definition (which is given in line 301). Please define it at first use.
25. Line 486: The repetition of the "~12 GPa" value is redundant. If the point is to illustrate a decrease in hardness beyond an optimal Ti content, the authors may cite appropriate literature without reiterating this specific number. Moreover, the cited paper [46] does not report ~12 GPa for crystalline TiC.
26. Line 553 (end of sentence): ".." (two dots).
27. Line 619 (Reference 26): The year should be 2025 instead of 2022.
The manuscript has been partially improved, but many technical and presentational issues remain. The authors should address the points mentioned above.
If these corrections are made, the paper could be reconsidered for publication.
The text contains language inaccuracies and missing or extra articles, all of which can be easily corrected by the authors themselves using any AI proofreader, such as the free (word-count-limited) Basic plan of WordVice in Light mode.
Author Response
Please see the attached file.
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors of the manuscript responded comprehensively to the comments and made changes to the text.
Author Response
We sincerely appreciate the reviewers' insightful comments and suggestions, and we thank them once again for their time.