Abstract
Contemporary Korean Buddhism circulates through an expanding network of material and mediated forms that operate without explicitly demanding doctrinal commitment or institutional affiliation. Against the prevailing frameworks of secularization and commodification, this article proposes material affordance as an alternative analytical vocabulary, asking not what Buddhist objects and spaces signify but what they do to those who encounter them. Through this lens, the article analyzes four affordance types through which the Jogye Order of Korean Buddhism sustains its cultural presence in a disaffiliating society: access infrastructures, affective attunement devices, aesthetic identity markers, and public-cultural interfaces. Together, these modalities constitute what this article terms the mediated turn in Korean Buddhism, a structural transformation in which the tradition extends its reach not through the intensification of belief or the recruitment of formal members, but through the proliferation of designed material environments that make Buddhist sensibilities, aesthetics, and affects available to those who may never self-identify as Buddhist. Central to this analysis is the Korean paradox of mediated Buddhism: that de-institutionalization is itself institutionally engineered, inverting Grace Davie’s formulation of “believing without belonging” into something more radical: encountering without either.
1. Introduction
On a July evening in 2025, a Buddhist monk appeared online, not through a camera but through an animated virtual avatar. Broadcasting live on a Korean streaming platform, the monk conducted a cheondoje, a traditional ritual for the repose of the dead, for fictional K-pop idol characters from K-pop Demon Hunters (Kang and Appelhans 2025), a Netflix animated series that had recently captured a global fanbase. At its peak, over four thousand viewers joined simultaneously, flooding the chat with messages: “This is cyber detox,” “We’ve arrived at the Pure Land.” The monk later explained his motivation simply: “I just want people to feel a little closer to Buddhism.” Within months, his YouTube channel had accumulated over sixty-six thousand subscribers.
This episode is not an anomaly. It is one node in a sprawling and analytically undertheorized network of material and mediated forms through which Korean Buddhism circulates in contemporary society. This network includes standardized Templestay facilities hosted by over one hundred forty Buddhist monasteries nationwide and drawing three hundred fifty thousand participants annually; urban Seon centers that rebrand monastic practice as a “global Seon playground” open to backpackers, meditators, and the religiously curious alike; a temple food movement repositioned as national intangible heritage and a global wellness cuisine; and an annual Buddhist expo that defines itself not as a religious gathering but as “Korea’s only comprehensive traditional cultural industry fair.” The institution at the center of this network is the Jogye Order of Korean Buddhism, the largest and most institutionally powerful Buddhist organization in the country. Accordingly, this article focuses primarily on the Jogye Order and the material environments it produces and administers, without claiming to represent the full diversity of Korean Buddhist institutional life. which administers the majority of Korea’s Buddhist monasteries, temples, and cultural programs. What holds these heterogeneous phenomena together is not a shared doctrine, a common ritual form, or a unified institutional strategy. It is, this article argues, a shared logic of material affordance.
Scholarly accounts of Korean Buddhism’s contemporary situation have tended to organize themselves around two interpretive poles. The first diagnoses the expanding presence of Buddhist material culture in public life as evidence of secularization: a tradition accommodating itself to market logic (Kaplan 2010; Gauthier 2025), therapeutic culture (McMahan 2008; Purser 2019), and entertainment demand at the cost of doctrinal coherence and soteriological depth (Baker 2008; Kim and Park 2022). The second reads the same phenomena as commodification: the packaging of monastic heritage for cultural tourism (Kaplan 2010; Kendall 2010), state-sponsored soft power projection (Watson 2013), and the monetization of sacred space (Kitiarsa 2008; Zhu 2025). Both frameworks are not without merit. They correctly identify real pressures and real transformations. But they share a foundational limitation: they treat materiality as a symptom, an index of social forces acting upon religion from the outside, rather than as an active medium through which religious life is constituted, extended, and renegotiated from within.
This article proposes an alternative analytical vocabulary. Drawing on Justin Thomas McDaniel’s study of Asian Buddhist visual and material culture, Architects of Buddhist Leisure (McDaniel 2016), and engaging the concept of affordance as developed across ecological psychology, design theory, and material religion studies, we argue that the materiality of contemporary Korean Buddhism is best understood not in terms of what it represents but in terms of what it does. Rather than asking what Buddhist objects and spaces signify, whether doctrinal commitments, economic interests, or cultural nostalgia, we ask what possibilities for action, feeling, orientation, and identification they open up for those who encounter them. Where McDaniel demonstrated that pleasure, aesthetic delight, and entertainment are constitutive rather than corrosive of Buddhist practice, this article extends his affordance-oriented sensibility to the Korean context while marking a crucial structural difference.
That difference is what we call the Korean paradox of mediated Buddhism. In the cases McDaniel analyzed across Asia, non-institutional Buddhist leisure culture arose largely through lay visionaries operating outside formal monastic structures (McDaniel 2016, pp. 13, 17). In Korea, the trajectory was different and more complex. What began as a series of adaptive responses to the mounting pressures of mass disaffiliation, demographic change, and intensifying competition for cultural attention accumulated, through repetition and refinement, into something more than the sum of its parts. As Templestay programs were standardized, urban meditation centers proliferated, digital platforms were developed, and cultural events were scaled, these responses coalesced into a systematic institutional architecture in which affiliation-free encounter with Buddhist culture has become the norm rather than the exception. The paradox, then, is not that the Jogye Order set out to engineer de-institutionalization, but that its successive adaptations to a disaffiliating society produced, as their aggregate effect, precisely that. Pressure came first; strategy followed; and the assemblage that resulted now exceeds the intentions of any single actor within it. The Templestay program is a Jogye Order initiative underwritten by state tourism policy. The virtual Buddhist broadcaster who conducted the cheondoje described above is an ordained monk. “NewJeansNim,” a lay comedian who performs EDM DJ sets in monastic costume, carries a dharma-inflected stage name bestowed by an actual monk, and his performances have been actively endorsed by the president of the Jogye Order himself. The Seoul International Buddhist Expo (BEXPO) is an annual production of the Jogye Order’s central administration. A private Buddhist cultural foundation whose halls served as the venue for the APEC CEO Summit welcome dinner operates under the aesthetic and symbolic canopy of Korean Buddhist heritage. What appears as spontaneous, affiliation-free encounter with Buddhist culture is, in the Korean case, architecturally planned: a paradox in which de-institutionalization is itself institutionally engineered. This structural feature distinguishes Korean Buddhist material culture from McDaniel’s cases and, we argue, from the secularization and commodification narratives alike. It is neither religion retreating nor religion being consumed, but religion strategically redesigning its own thresholds.
This study develops this argument across three sections. The Background situates the analysis within three intersecting bodies of scholarship: the affordance tradition from Gibson through material religion studies, the philosophical reorientation of new materialism, and existing frameworks for Korean Buddhist modernity, before introducing metamodern spirituality and the mediated turn as the integrating analytical concepts. The analytical core examines four affordance types through which Korean Buddhist material culture operates in practice: access infrastructures, affective attunement devices, aesthetic identity markers, and public-cultural interfaces. The Discussion draws these threads together to examine the broader significance of the Korean paradox of mediated Buddhism across three axes: religious re-contextualization, temple economy diversification, and the persistence of Korean Buddhism in conditions of mass disaffiliation.
The empirical cases examined in this article were selected according to three criteria: institutional significance within the Korean Buddhist field, analytical representativeness across the four affordance modalities, and documentary availability through institutional sources, official reports, and Buddhist and secular press coverage. No ethnographic fieldwork or primary interview data were collected; this limitation is acknowledged and identified as a direction for future research.
2. Background
This section develops the theoretical framework through which the materiality of contemporary Korean Buddhism will be analyzed. It proceeds in three movements. The first traces the concept of affordance from James Gibson’s ecological theory of perception through Donald Norman’s design theory to its elaboration in the material religion scholarship of David Morgan and Birgit Meyer, arguing that this trajectory provides the conceptual vocabulary for understanding what Buddhist objects, spaces, and media do rather than what they mean. The second situates this affordance-theoretical approach within the broader philosophical reorientation of new materialism and draws out its implications for the study of religious life. The third engages existing scholarship on Korean Buddhist modernity and religious change, introducing the concept of metamodern spirituality as a framework for understanding the cultural sensibilities to which Korean Buddhist material culture responds, and proposing the mediated turn as the integrating analytical concept.
2.1. From Ecological Psychology to Material Religion: The Affordance Tradition
The concept of affordance originates in James Gibson’s The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception (Gibson 1979), a work that fundamentally reoriented the study of perception away from the cognitivist models that dominated mid-twentieth-century psychology. Where prevailing accounts treated perception as an internal process of mental representation, Gibson argued that perception occurs in the dynamic relationship between a perceiving organism and its environment. Central to this framework is the concept of affordance, a term Gibson coined to describe the action possibilities that an environment offers to a particular organism. An affordance is neither a property of the object alone nor a property of the subject alone; it exists only in the relation between them. A horizontal surface affords support to a creature of a given size and weight; a stone affords throwing to a creature with the requisite limb structure. This is Gibson’s most radical claim: that meaning, understood as action relevance, is not imposed on a neutral world by a knowing subject but is immanent in the perceptual encounter itself (Gibson 1979, pp. 127–43).
Two features of Gibson’s framework are especially significant for the analysis that follows. First, the same object affords different things to different organisms. Affordances are thus inherently plural and context-dependent. The same material form can simultaneously afford devotional practice to a committed believer, therapeutic relaxation to a stressed urbanite, aesthetic appreciation to a design-conscious visitor, and cultural curiosity to an international tourist without any of these affordances being more “authentic” than the others. Second, affordances operate independently of the perceiver’s intentions, beliefs, or prior knowledge. This independence from subjective interpretation is what makes the concept analytically powerful for the study of religion: it allows us to ask what material objects and spaces enable or invite without presupposing that those possibilities must pass through the filter of doctrinal knowledge or institutional affiliation.
The application of affordance theory to the study of religion has been developed most systematically within material religion studies. Morgan argues that religious images, objects, and spaces organize the bodily practices, emotional orientations, and social relations of those who engage with them: they direct the gaze, position the body, calibrate affect, and configure the social field (Morgan 2005, pp. 3–7; Morgan 2012). Religious material culture does not merely represent religious meanings to already-constituted religious subjects; it participates in the constitution of those subjects and their relationships to the tradition. Meyer’s concept of “sensational forms” develops this insight in a direction particularly relevant for understanding the institutional dimensions of religious material culture. Meyer defines sensational forms as “authorized modes of invoking and organizing access to the transcendental, thereby creating and sustaining links between believers and invoking a sense of the beyond” (Meyer 2006, p. 7). Sensational forms work not by conveying meanings to minds but by organizing bodies and senses in ways that make certain kinds of religious experience available and others unavailable. The word “authorized” is crucial: sensational forms are produced, sanctioned, and distributed by religious institutions that have interests in shaping what kinds of encounters are possible, for whom, and on what terms (Meyer 2009, pp. 6–10). Architects of Buddhist Leisure McDaniel’s (2016) brings these threads together in the specifically Buddhist context, demonstrating that Buddhist images, decorative objects, and spatial environments function as repetitive affective encounters that teach not through narrative but through immediacy, affording encounters with Buddhism on terms that require neither faith nor expertise, only presence and receptivity (McDaniel 2016, p. 24; Seigworth and Gregg 2010, pp. 1–2).
The affordance framework employed in this article is thus not Gibson’s ecological psychology transposed unchanged into the study of religion. It is a reconstructed concept, developed through the material religion scholarship of Morgan and Meyer and the Buddhist studies framework of McDaniel, in which the relational logic of affordance is applied to institutionally designed and culturally embedded material environments. Its explanatory purchase is deliberately limited: it does not claim to explain why individuals choose to engage with Buddhist material culture, nor does it offer a theory of religious motivation or subjective meaning-making. Its analytical contribution is more precise: it identifies the structural conditions under which specific forms of encounter become possible, asks how material environments are designed to open or foreclose those possibilities, and attends to what those environments do to those who move through them, independently of what either institution or individual intends.
2.2. New Materialism and the Limits of Institutional Design
The affordance-theoretical tradition described above participates in a broader philosophical reorientation known as new materialism, which insists on the agency, generativity, and irreducibility of matter against the textualism and social constructivism that dominated late twentieth-century thought (Coole and Frost 2010, pp. 1–43). The deployment of new materialist frameworks here is methodological rather than metaphysical: not as a philosophical equivalent to Buddhist understandings of matter or non-self, but as analytical tools that attend to what objects and spaces do rather than what they mean.
Four frameworks are employed, each addressing a distinct explanatory problem. Why does the same temple space afford spiritual retreat to one visitor and a wellness experience to another? Barad’s concept of intra-action explains that entities do not pre-exist their encounters but are constituted through them, which is why the same material environment affords strikingly different experiences for different publics and why institutional design cannot determine meaning in advance (Barad 2007, pp. 135–46). Why do ritual objects migrate into fashion accessories and monastic cuisine into global wellness food? Bennett’s thing-power captures the capacity of matter to generate effects that exceed and redirect institutional intent in ways no designer anticipated (Bennett 2010, pp. 2–6). Why do some Buddhist material environments achieve durable public reach while others do not? Latour’s Actor-Network Theory reframes institutional success not as the unilateral imposition of design but as the always-precarious alignment of heterogeneous human and nonhuman actants (Latour 2005, pp. 71–72). How do these dispersed elements cohere into something more than the sum of their parts? The concept of assemblage, understood as a contingent arrangement of heterogeneous elements whose stability is always an achievement rather than a given, provides the overarching structural framework (DeLanda 2006, pp. 3–10).
Together, these frameworks constitute a complementary analytical toolkit grounded in a single explanatory principle: matter is not a passive medium through which institutional intentions are transmitted, but an active participant in the production of religious effects that no single actor fully controls.
2.3. Metamodern Spirituality and the Mediated Turn in Korean Buddhism
Existing scholarship on contemporary Korean Buddhism has approached the tradition’s changing social presence through three main lenses. Buddhist modernism illuminates the rationalization of doctrine and practice for lay audiences but cannot account for the strategic amplification of affective and spectacular material form. Secularization theory tracks declining formal affiliation but cannot attend to the expanding material circulation of Buddhist culture among unaffiliated publics. Political-economic analysis contextualizes institutional strategies but reduces material culture to an instrument of economic or political interest, without attending to what it does to those who encounter it. Each framework captures something real; none is sufficient. What they share is an inability to hold together the institutional and the material, the economic and the affective, the designed and the emergent. It is precisely this gap that the affordance framework, new materialism, and the concept of metamodern spirituality are designed to fill.
Understanding what Buddhist material culture does to those who encounter it requires a theoretical vocabulary sensitive to the particular cultural sensibilities of contemporary Korean youth. The term metamodernism was introduced by Vermeulen and van den Akker to describe a “structure of feeling” characterized by an oscillation between seemingly contradictory orientations such as irony and sincerity, skepticism and hope, and nostalgia and innovation, without resolving these tensions into a stable synthesis (Vermeulen and van den Akker 2010). Freinacht subsequently extended this framework to broader socio-cultural dynamics, characterizing metamodernity as a developmental orientation that integrates traditional, modern, and postmodern value systems while remaining reflexive, plural, and future-oriented (Freinacht 2017). Bargár has further explored the theological dimensions of metamodern sensibility, attending to how this oscillatory structure generates new forms of spiritual inquiry outside traditional institutional frameworks (Bargár 2020). Metamodernism is employed here not as a totalizing explanatory theory but as what Blumer (1954) termed a “sensitizing concept”: a conceptual tool that orients analytical attention without predetermining its conclusions.
The specific structural conditions of South Korean modernity make this framework particularly apt. As Chang (2010) has argued, South Korea’s developmental trajectory is characterized by “compressed modernity”: a social formation in which economic, cultural, and institutional transformations that unfolded across several generations in Western societies have been concentrated into a dramatically shortened historical period, producing a condition in which pre-modern, modern, and postmodern sensibilities coexist, often in tension, within the experience of a single generation. Within this metamodern cultural condition, the relationship between younger generations and Buddhist tradition is characterized by five recurring oscillatory tensions: irony and sincerity in playful yet genuinely curious engagement with Buddhist symbols; faith and skepticism producing appreciation without institutional affiliation; hope and melancholy as employment precarity and achievement pressure drive individuals toward Buddhist material culture as a resource for navigating suffering; tradition and innovation in which Buddhist historical depth carries cultural authority precisely through its contrast with the disposability of digital culture (McDaniel 2016; Kieschnick 2003); and individualism and collectivism as highly selective personal engagement coexists with new forms of loosely connected digital collective participation.
The concept that integrates these theoretical resources into a unified analytical orientation is what we term the mediated turn in Korean Buddhism. By this we mean a structural transformation, accelerating over the past two decades, in which Korean Buddhism sustains and extends its cultural presence not primarily through the intensification of belief, the recruitment of formal members, or the reproduction of doctrinal orthodoxy, but through the proliferation of material and media forms that make Buddhist sensibilities, aesthetics, and affects available to those who may never enter a monastery or take refuge in the Three Jewels. This is not secularization, because Buddhism does not retreat from public life. It is not commodification, because the logic at work is not simply economic extraction. It is not Buddhist modernism, because the trajectory is not toward rationalization. It is rather a strategic expansion of the tradition’s material thresholds, conducted under institutional auspices, through designed material environments, with affective and aesthetic rather than doctrinal ends. The new materialist insight that matter actively participates in this process is what distinguishes the present account from both political-economic and institutional-sociological alternatives. The objects, spaces, and media through which Korean Buddhism circulates are not passive instruments of institutional strategy but active co-producers of the encounters they afford.
These theoretical commitments generate four analytically distinct modalities through which the mediated turn operates in practice. Each modality corresponds to a different register of material action and a different dimension of the gap between institutional design and perceived affordance: access infrastructures at the threshold of entry, affective attunement devices at the emotional register, aesthetic identity markers at the level of cultural capital, and public-cultural interfaces at the civic and policy register. It is to the analysis of these four modalities, and the structural paradox that organizes them in the Korean context, that we now turn.
3. Functional Materiality in Korean Buddhism: Four Modalities
This section analyzes four distinct material modalities through which Korean Buddhism continues to operate in contemporary society without requiring institutional affiliation or doctrinal commitment. A phenomenon is analyzed as an affordance here when it meets three criteria: it is immanent in a material or institutional structure rather than dependent on the perceiver’s prior religious disposition; it operates independently of doctrinal knowledge or affiliation; and it generates possibilities for encounter that exceed what institutional designers anticipated or controlled. Access infrastructures operate at the threshold register, lowering conditions of entry for unaffiliated publics. Affective attunement devices operate at the emotional register, calibrating the sensory and psychological states of those who inhabit them. Aesthetic identity markers circulate Buddhist visual and material vocabulary as resources for taste and lifestyle. Public-cultural interfaces position Buddhist heritage within the pathways of state tourism, regional branding, and international diplomacy. Together, these modalities constitute the material architecture of the mediated turn, intersecting and reinforcing one another rather than functioning in isolation.
What demands particular attention is the structural paradox specific to the Korean context. As McDaniel has shown, Buddhist leisure spaces elsewhere in Asia have largely emerged through lay-driven, spontaneous formations with little connection to formal monastic institutions (McDaniel 2016, pp. 13–14). In Korea, by contrast, the cases examined here, including Templestay, BEXPO, JustBe Hongdae Seon Center, Kumuda, and Bulbeop Sunim, are either directly planned by the Jogye Order or operated by monks affiliated with it. Actors outside the Order, including Hwangnyongwon, the Gimcheon Gimbap Festival, and the Buddhist goods market, operate on the cultural ground the Jogye Order has structured. Formal institutional design generates non-institutional points of entry, and non-institutional actors subsequently join the same circuit. This is the distinctive character of the Korean mediated turn.
3.1. Access Infrastructures: Accessing Buddhism Without Affiliation
The first modality encompasses the ensemble of devices designed to make Buddhist culture accessible without requiring religious affiliation. This condition inverts Grace Davie’s classic formulation of “believing without belonging” into something closer to encountering without either (Davie 1994). As McDaniel observes, these spaces are open to all people regardless of their religious faith, practice, or lack thereof, and require neither deep knowledge of Buddhist texts and rituals nor any test of faith (McDaniel 2016, p. 5).
The most emblematic example is the Templestay program. Initiated by the Jogye Order in 2002 in response to the need for visitor accommodation during the FIFA World Cup co-hosted by Korea and Japan, the program expanded from 33 temples with 11,714 participants in its inaugural year to 141 temples with 258,024 participants by 2021 (Korean Buddhist Cultural Heritage Foundation 2022, pp. 272–73). By 2025, annual participation had reached approximately 350,000 (Lee 2026a). The Korean Buddhist Cultural Heritage Foundation’s official promotional language foregrounds not “practice” or “religious cultivation” but “healing,” “traditional cultural experience,” and “meditation in nature” (Templestay n.d.). This discursive framing is not merely rhetorical. In Norman’s terms, it constitutes a deliberately engineered perceived affordance: a calculated communication of possibilities designed to position Templestay as a cultural and wellness product rather than a site of religious discipline, guiding potential participants toward specific modes of engagement while leaving others such as doctrinal instruction, institutional commitment unarticulated. The Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism formally institutionalized this framing in the 2022 Implementation Plan for the Basic Tourism Promotion Plan, designating Templestay as a core project in traditional cultural tourism content and setting annual targets including the expansion of socially inclusive programming and demand-tailored offerings for foreign visitors and underserved populations (MCST and Related Ministries 2022, p. 56). Templestay is not merely a voluntary initiative of the Buddhist institution but a formally embedded component of national tourism policy.
The Seoul International Buddhist Expo (BEXPO), organized annually by the Jogye Order, constitutes another major access infrastructure. Established in 2013 and held each year at COEX in Seoul, the expo defines itself as “Korea’s only comprehensive traditional cultural industry fair, mobilizing Buddhist resources beyond religion for industrial and cultural purposes” (BEXPO n.d.). Integrating traditional cultural product exhibitions, a Buddhist art fair (Buddha Art Fair), meditation programs, the International Seon Meditation Competition, and a Relax Week, BEXPO is structurally designed for entry regardless of religious affiliation, presenting Buddhism through the vocabulary of lifestyle and alternative culture rather than religious belonging. The Temple Food Grand Festival, organized by the Korean Buddhist Cultural Heritage Foundation, similarly positions Buddhist culinary culture at the intersection of contemporary discourses around vegetarianism, slow food, wellness cuisine, and national intangible cultural heritage (Korea Temple Food n.d.). At the fourth festival held in June 2025, 57 percent of the approximately 15,000 pre-registered participants were in their twenties and thirties, signaling that Buddhist food culture, reframed through the languages of traditional heritage, health cuisine, and respect for life, has become a viable access point for non-affiliated publics (Yoo 2025).
In Gibson’s terms, the affordances offered by these infrastructures operate independently of the visitor’s prior faith or knowledge: the possibility of encounter is immanent in the material and institutional structure itself, not in the interior disposition of the subject who enters it (Gibson 1979, pp. 127–43). Applying Norman’s distinction between designed and perceived affordance (Norman 1988, pp. 9–11), what the Jogye Order communicates through the language of “healing” and “traditional cultural experience” constitutes a deliberately engineered affordance. Yet the material environment simultaneously remains structurally open to uses that exceed and were not authorized by institutional design. That Templestay, originally conceived as a program of monastic discipline, has been progressively perceived and appropriated as a cultural tourism product and subsequently incorporated as an official component of national tourism policy is precisely an effect produced by the gap between designed and perceived affordance. It is this gap that continuously generates new publics for Korean Buddhism’s access infrastructure in ways no single institutional actor anticipated or planned.
Digital platforms constitute an equally significant access infrastructure. YouTube and other online video platforms carry a vast volume of Buddhist content, from channels operated directly by monks to vlog-style temple visits, guided meditations, and temple food recipe videos produced by lay creators. A particularly notable case is that of an ordained monk affiliated with the Jogye Order who, acting entirely on his own initiative and without institutional planning or financial support, debuted in July 2025 as a virtual YouTuber under the name Bulbeop sunim. The virtual YouTuber (VTuber) format, in which a broadcaster presents through an animated avatar rather than a camera, allowed the monk to maintain his monastic identity while engaging the public through the conventions of digital entertainment. His debut broadcast took the form of a cheondoje, a traditional Buddhist ritual for the repose of the dead, performed in real time for the fictional K-pop idol group Saja Boys from the Netflix animated series K-pop Demon Hunters (Kang and Appelhans 2025). Broadcast live on the Naver CHZZK platform over approximately two hours, the event attracted a peak concurrent audience of over 4200 viewers; his Twitter/X following reached 9400 immediately after the broadcast (J. Shin 2025). Contemporary press coverage of the broadcast documented a consistent register of audience response across the real-time chat log, of which the following are representative examples reported independently by multiple media outlets: “This is cyber detox,” “We have arrived at the Pure Land,” and “We’re all ascending during a cheondoje” (G. Park 2025). The channel subsequently expanded to YouTube, hosting regular Sunday dharma broadcasts; as of 20 March 2026, the channel had accumulated over 66,500 subscribers. The monk has articulated his purpose in the following terms: “I simply want people to feel a little closer to Buddhism.” Alongside sutras, dharma talks, and Sunday services, the channel incorporates webtoon commentary and game streaming. This configuration, in which a traditional mortuary ritual is streamed for fictional animated characters, illuminates how Buddhist ritual can be grafted onto the affective attachments of fandom without requiring any prior faith. That this grafting now operates through the material infrastructure of Netflix, global fandom, and live streaming marks a significant extension of Korean Buddhism’s access architecture beyond monastery walls and religious language.
These infrastructures may appear to be products of individual voluntary exploration, yet they are structurally organized upon the institutional planning and financial support of the Jogye Order. De-institutional access is, paradoxically, the product of powerful institutional design. These access infrastructures do more than lower thresholds of entry. What accumulates through repeated encounter with their material environments is what McDaniel, following Seigworth and Gregg, terms “supple incrementalism”: a slow, non-discursive accretion of Buddhist familiarity that requires neither doctrinal knowledge nor institutional commitment, only presence and receptivity (McDaniel 2016, p. 24; Seigworth and Gregg 2010, pp. 1–2). It is this cumulative logic that connects the design of access to the production of affect, and that leads to the second modality examined below.
3.2. Affective Attunement Devices: Materiality Producing Feeling
The second modality comprises devices that mediate Buddhism not through doctrine but through the techniques of emotional regulation, self-care, and restorative experience. In this modality, materiality operates through spatial design, including directionality, fragrance, sound, and circulation paths, and through content packaging, including program structure, goods, and branding, to produce specific affective states. Drawing on Gregory Seigworth and Melissa Gregg, McDaniel characterizes the study of affect as the study of “an accumulative beside-ness, a supple incrementalism” in which the senses continuously accumulate images, feelings, scents, and sounds, forming “the slow accretion of knowledge in the form of nondiscursive impressions” (McDaniel 2016, p. 24). Buddhist images, decorative items, and gardens, he argues, become “repetitious affective encounters” like ritual and music, teaching “not through narrative, but through immediacy” (McDaniel 2016, p. 24). This means that the fragrance, acoustic environment, lighting conditions, and spatial choreography of a meditation space are not incidental background but deliberately designed elements for producing specific affective experiences.
In Korea, this modality manifests most visibly in the explosive proliferation of mindfulness and meditation discourse. Keywords such as mindfulness, healing meditation, and Buddhist meditation have migrated far beyond the specialist vocabulary of practitioners, intersecting extensively with self-help markets, psychotherapeutic discourse, and corporate wellness programs. Buddhist meditation is frequently repackaged as a scientifically validated stress-reduction technique stripped of sectarian identity; nonetheless, the Buddhist spatial environment, material objects, and atmosphere continue to function as constitutive media of that experience, sustaining its materiality.
JustBe Hongdae Seon Center in the Hongik University district of Seoul provides a concrete illustration (JustBe n.d.). The center officially describes itself as a “global Seon practice playground,” presenting as a meditation guesthouse co-operated by monks and young laypeople. Beginning each day with 108 prostrations and seated meditation, the space offers a range of programs including Seon meditation, sound meditation, Seon taijiquan, tea ceremony, yoga, free dance, and drawing. The first-floor tea lounge operates as “a space open to all,” welcoming anyone regardless of whether they are staying at the guesthouse to drink tea and converse with monks. The center provides vegetarian and vegan meals, maintains a rooftop garden, and offers international exchange programming, all structured to permit free entry without prior Buddhist knowledge. Visitor reviews repeatedly describe the experience as “a hostel and a temple in the same space” and “a uniquely special experience,” registering how Buddhist space is consumed as a compound venue for leisure, culture, and meditation without religious demarcation (Google Maps n.d.). Kumuda, a cultural arts organization located in the Songjeong neighborhood of Haeundae, Busan, represents another configuration of this modality. Operating under the stated mission of “offering encouragement and solace through culture and art” (Kumuda n.d.), Kumuda integrates a performance hall (Nolda, “to play”), a cafe (Moida, “to gather”), a Korean restaurant and fine dining venue (Mukda, “to eat”), a video studio and cultural lecture space (Boda, “to see”), and lodging facilities (Jada, “to sleep”), running regular performances in classical music, jazz, and traditional Korean music alongside meditation and humanities lectures. Buddhist values are presented here not in the language of practice but in the language of culture, art, and healing. Dongguk University’s Buddhist temple Jeonggakwon offers an institutional parallel: alongside regular dharma services, it offers a separately branded program titled Ready to Meditate, designed to support the mental health and stress management of university community members irrespective of religious affiliation, drawing on singing bowl meditation, yoga, tea ceremony, and aromatherapy and art therapy (Dongguk University Jeonggakwon n.d.). This case exemplifies how Buddhist meditation becomes institutionalized as a mental health resource within a secular educational institution, extended through the language of wellness rather than religious obligation.
Meyer’s concept of sensational forms (Meyer 2006, p. 7) captures precisely how these spaces operate. The timber surfaces, fragrance, low lighting, and choreographed circulation of JustBe and Kumuda are not incidental aesthetic choices but authorized material modes of organizing access to Buddhist sensibility, arranging bodies and senses in ways that make certain affective experiences available without doctrinal instruction. The visitor feels Buddhism before understanding it. This is Meyer’s central claim: that sensational forms work not by conveying meanings to minds but by positioning bodies and calibrating affect (Meyer 2009, pp. 6–10). Television and OTT platforms constitute additional material channels for this modality. A notable recent case is The Chefs of the Offering Hall (Gongyanggan-ui Chefdeul), a four-part food reality series released exclusively on Wavve in February 2026, featuring six Jogye Order temple food masters and repositioning temple food as content “spotlighted as global food in alignment with the worldwide vegetarian and wellness trend,” framing Buddhist food culture through the philosophical question of why one prepares and eats in a particular way (Lee 2026b). This form of media representation reinforces across the social field the cultural imagination that locates Buddhism as a resource for psychological restoration and a way of being in the world.
3.3. Aesthetic Identity Markers: Buddhist Taste Without Belief
The third modality concerns the way in which the visual and material elements of Buddhism circulate as markers of taste, lifestyle, and cultural capital once divested of their devotional significance. The color schemes of dancheong, traditional polychrome decorative painting on Buddhist wooden architecture, decorative painting, the geometry of pagodas, the aesthetics of Seon, tea culture, and the tactile quality of yeomju, prayer bead bracelets, are today consumed not as tokens of faith but as signs through which a particular aesthetic sensibility and orientation toward life is articulated. As Daniel Miller observes, certain objects are significant precisely because “we do not ‘see’ them,” and “the less we are aware of them, the more powerfully they can determine our expectations by setting the scene and ensuring normative behavior, without being open to challenge” (Miller, cited in (McDaniel 2016, p. 22)). When Buddhist material objects quietly infiltrate everyday space, they form, without being consciously recognized, the background of particular sensibilities and values. De-sacralization, in this sense, signifies not the disappearance of Buddhism but the redistribution of Buddhist materiality.
This redistribution is concretely traceable in consumer markets. Interior design products evoking “temple aesthetics,” design stationery organized around Seon aesthetics, and fashion items reinterpreting Buddhist iconography circulate through online platforms, with purchasing motivations articulated not through faith but through affinity with the life philosophy of slowness, emptiness, and naturalness. The Buddhist goods brand Buddhi offers a paradigmatic case. Launched in 2020 by Jeong A-hyeon, a doctoral candidate in Buddhist art at Dongguk University, the brand initially produced interior objects, including decorative clocks and sleep lamps, drawing on the iconography of the Medicine Buddha, responding to heightened demand during the COVID-19 pandemic. It subsequently expanded its product range to include fashion accessories such as yeomju and mugs, as well as everyday household goods (S. Shin 2022). The designer has articulated her approach as follows: “I try to design in a way that is not too Buddhist, while still carrying Buddhist values.” This statement condenses the operating logic of this modality. Tea culture operates by the same principle. Rooted in the ceremonial tea practices of Buddhist monasteries, tea culture has been appropriated into the discourses of slow living and mindfulness, transforming the act of drinking tea from an extension of practice into a “ritual for cultivating the quality of life.” Yeomju similarly migrate from devotional instrument to bracelet and interior object, consumed by wearers through the vocabulary of meditative sensibility and East Asian aesthetics rather than explicit Buddhist identity.
What these circulating Buddhist material objects collectively constitute is, in McDaniel’s formulation, something that is “united but not uniform, collected but not concise, a gathering, not a movement” (McDaniel 2016, p. 170). Applying Morgan’s argument (Morgan 2012), the act of wearing a yeomju bracelet or purchasing an interior object bearing dancheong patterns is not the expression of an already-formed Buddhist identity. It works in the opposite direction. Repeated material contact shapes bodily habits and sensory registers, and through that process constitutes the very relationship with Buddhism itself. De-sacralization, in this sense, signifies not the disappearance of Buddhist materiality but a reorientation in the direction of subject formation: from affiliation to contact, from declaration to sensation. Bennett’s concept of thing-power (Bennett 2010, pp. 2–6) explains why this process consistently exceeds the reach of any institutional actor. That yeomju migrate into fashion accessories, that the ceremonial tea practices of Buddhist monasteries are absorbed into the global discourse of slow living, and that Buddhist iconography is reinterpreted as lifestyle design are outcomes that neither the Jogye Order’s cultural programming nor the deliberate designs of brands such as Buddhi fully anticipated or controlled. Matter itself participates as an active agent in generating new publics, opening new circuits of meaning, and diffusing Buddhist sensibility across the social field in ways no single designer planned. The de-institutional spread of Buddhist material culture is not, then, simply the product of institutional intent. It is an effect produced by the agency of things.
3.4. Public-Cultural Interfaces: Buddhism Through the Pathways of Policy and Heritage
The fourth modality concerns the ways in which Buddhism intervenes in the public sphere not through direct social engagement (engaged Buddhism) but through the pathways of cultural heritage policy, tourism, and regional branding. The dissolution of the secular-religious binary that McDaniel identifies as characteristic of Asian Buddhist public culture (McDaniel 2016, p. 7) finds concrete expression in Korea at the intersection of state cultural policy and Buddhist institutional practice.
Hwangryongwon (Imperial Dragon Court) in Gyeongju’s Bomun Tourist Complex offers a clear illustration. This privately operated facility, run by a foundation established by Dongguk Industry, reinterprets the architectural vocabulary of the Nine-Story Wooden Pagoda of Silla’s Hwangryongsa Temple through contemporary construction methods, functioning as a cultural retreat and conference space. The facility defines itself not as a religious venue but as “a space for spiritual culture and consciousness education,” offering meditation programs, practice retreats, humanities lectures, and cultural events to both corporate and general audiences (Hwangnyongwon n.d.). Particularly notable is the fact that this private Buddhist cultural space has been designated a Korea Unique Venue by the Korea Tourism Organization and served as the venue for the Gyeongsangbuk-do provincial government’s welcome dinner for global CEOs at the 2025 APEC CEO Summit (Han 2025). The aesthetics of Buddhist architecture here function not as a medium of faith but as infrastructure for national cultural tourism strategy and international diplomacy.
A revealing variation in this modality appears in the format of regional festivals. Samyeong Daesa Park in Gimcheon, North Gyeongsang Province, is a space that transforms the historical significance of the Venerable Samyeong Daesa, a Buddhist monk who commanded righteous armies during the Japanese invasions of 1592–1598 and an eminent monk of Jikjisa Temple, into urban landscape and tourism infrastructure, anchored by the 41.5 m Peace Pagoda as its landmark (Jeong 2026). Yet what the city of Gimcheon has organized annually in this park since 2024 is not a Buddhist cultural event but the Gimcheon Gimbap Festival. The festival originated in a 2023 survey of MZ-generation respondents in which “gimbap” ranked first as the word most associated with “Gimcheon,” a finding rooted in the widespread youth slang practice of abbreviating the ubiquitous franchise restaurant name “Gimbap Cheonguk” (Gimbap Heaven) to “Gimcheon.” The city responded by actively incorporating this generational linguistic culture into its urban branding strategy. The result was a first-year attendance in 2024 of 100,000 visitors, more than three times the anticipated figure of 30,000; in 2025, the second festival drew 150,000 participants, exceeding the city’s own population of 130,000 (Jeon 2025). The convergence of Buddhist historical provenance, K-food discourse, and deliberate municipal branding within a single public event illustrates the Korean variant of what McDaniel identifies in Asian Buddhist public culture: the non-contradictory mixing of religious provenance and secular leisure. The Jogyesa-Insadong cluster in central Seoul presents a further configuration. Jogyesa, one of the head temples of the Jogye Order, shares its compound with the Order’s central administrative headquarters, and its precincts open directly onto Insadong-gil, a street defined by traditional craft shops, antique dealers, teahouses, and galleries. The cultural clusters formed by these adjacent spaces combine Buddhist ambiance with secular consumption in ways that require no religious intention on the part of those who move through them, exemplifying the characteristic form of the Korean Buddhist public-cultural interface: institutional presence transformed, through spatial adjacency and urban circulation, into diffuse cultural atmosphere.
The cases examined in this modality extend Meyer’s concept of sensational forms into the public sphere (Meyer 2006, p. 7). In the cases analyzed here, the authorizing agents are not religious institutions but state tourism policy and municipal administration. The designation of Hwangryongwon as a Korea Unique Venue, the incorporation of Samyeong Daesa Park into regional festival programming, and the positioning of the Jogyesa-Insadong cluster as a flagship cultural tourism destination are institutional decisions that determine which Buddhist material environments become accessible to which publics, on what terms, and through what sensory arrangements. The locus of authorization has shifted from the sangha to the state, yet Meyer’s core insight that material environments organize public sensibility is thereby not weakened but confirmed on a wider scale. Barad’s concept of intra-action (Barad 2007, pp. 135–46) accounts for what happens within these authorized encounters: Hwangryongwon acquired new significance as a stage for international diplomacy while the APEC summit acquired a new register of cultural depth through the aesthetic vocabulary of Buddhist architecture. What these entities are and what they can do is produced through the encounter itself, confirming that Buddhist material culture functions in public life not as a stable religious object but as a generative participant in the ongoing production of cultural meaning.
The four modalities examined above provide an analytical framework for understanding how the mediated turn in Korean Buddhism operates. They are layered and mutually reinforcing: the Templestay participant becomes a consumer of temple aesthetics; the YouTube meditation viewer migrates into the purchaser of Buddhist craft objects; the regional festival visitor becomes a consumer of Buddhist heritage tourism. These flows sustain one another. At no point in this transformation is doctrinal commitment or community membership required as a precondition. Buddhism persists not through belief but through experience, not through affiliation but through access, not through practice but through sensation. This is the core of the mediated turn in contemporary Korean Buddhism.
4. Discussion: The Mediated Turn and Its Significance and Limitation
The four affordance types examined in the preceding section are not isolated phenomena. They constitute the material architecture of what this article has called the mediated turn in Korean Buddhism: a structural transformation in which the tradition sustains and extends its cultural presence not through the intensification of belief or the recruitment of formal members, but through the proliferation of designed material environments that make Buddhist sensibilities, aesthetics, and affects available to those who may never self-identify as Buddhist. This section draws out the broader significance of this transformation along three axes, religious re-contextualization, temple economy diversification, and the persistence of Korean Buddhism, before turning to the questions and challenges that the mediated turn leaves open.
4.1. Religious Re-Contextualization: Expanding the Meaning Field
Religious re-contextualization is the process by which Buddhist material culture is articulated across registers, including the therapeutic, culinary, touristic, aesthetic, and diplomatic, in ways that expand rather than evacuate its capacity to generate meaning. The prevailing critical vocabulary treats this process as one of dilution or corruption, in which authentic Buddhist content is hollowed out as its material forms are repurposed for secular ends. The affordance-theoretical and new materialist frameworks developed in this article suggest a different reading.
When Buddhist material environments are rearticulated as wellness resources, heritage experiences, or aesthetic lifestyle references, they do not simply lose their religious significance. They acquire new significance for new publics, generating affordances that the original institutional contexts did not and could not produce. The meditator who first encounters Buddhist practice through a mindfulness app, the tourist who first enters a Buddhist space through a Templestay program, the young urban consumer who first engages with Buddhist aesthetics through a temple food festival: none of these encounters is reducible to the doctrinal content of Buddhist teaching, but none is therefore without religious significance. Each constitutes what McDaniel (2016), following Seigworth and Gregg (2010), calls an affective encounter, a moment of sensory and emotional contact with a tradition that accumulates, incrementally and non-discursively, as a form of Buddhist familiarity.
The re-contextualization of Buddhism across therapeutic, aesthetic, and cultural registers is not a departure from religion but a transformation in its mode of operation. It reflects what Birgit Meyer identifies as the capacity of religious traditions to generate new sensational forms, that is, new authorized modes of organizing access to the transcendent, in response to changing cultural conditions (Meyer 2006, p. 7). The Jogye Order’s cultivation of Buddhist aesthetic environments, its investment in temple food culture, its production of digital media content, and its design of urban meditation spaces oriented toward psychological self-care are not concessions to secularization. They are instances of sensational form production: the deliberate fabrication of material environments that afford encounters with Buddhist tradition on terms that resonate with the existential concerns and cultural sensibilities of contemporary Koreans. The metamodern oscillation between irony and sincerity, and between skepticism and genuine spiritual seeking, that characterizes contemporary Korean youth spirituality is not an obstacle to Buddhist engagement. It is precisely the cultural condition to which re-contextualized Buddhist material culture is addressed. Buddhism, rearticulated as a resource for navigating the tensions of compressed modernity, does not thereby cease to be Buddhism. It becomes Buddhism in a new key.
4.2. Temple Economy Diversification: Material Conditions of Religious Sustainability
The second dimension of significance concerns the relationship between the material affordances analyzed in this article and the economic conditions of Buddhist institutional life. The commodification framework that dominates critical accounts of Korean Buddhist material culture treats economic diversification as straightforwardly problematic: the monetization of sacred space corrupts its religious character, subordinating spiritual ends to market logic. The analysis developed in this article suggests a more complex account.
Temple economy diversification must be understood against the structural conditions that have made it necessary. Korean Buddhist temples, particularly those within the Jogye Order, have historically relied on two primary revenue sources: lay donations and productive activities, with donations constituting the larger share, accounting for between half and two-thirds of income at major temples (Cho 2024, p. 222). As religious affiliation has declined, the donor base has contracted correspondingly, rendering donation-driven temple finance increasingly precarious. This is not a new predicament. Korean Buddhist temples have historically adapted to socioeconomic pressure through diversification, from the monastic lending operations and agricultural landholdings of the Goryeo period to the cooperative mutual aid associations of the suppressed Joseon era (Kwon 2025, pp. 2–8). What is distinctive about the contemporary moment is the scale and visibility of this diversification, and the extent to which it has generated material forms that afford encounters with Buddhism for precisely those populations no longer present in the donor base.
From a new materialist perspective, this diversification is not simply a concession to commercial pressure. It is the creation of the material conditions under which specific affordances become possible and sustainable. A Templestay facility that generates revenue through program fees is simultaneously a revenue strategy and an access infrastructure. Its economic viability is the condition of its continued existence as a threshold through which unaffiliated publics can encounter Buddhist practice. The meditation center that charges for mindfulness courses is simultaneously a commercial operation and an affective attunement device. Its economic sustainability is the condition of its continued capacity to calibrate the emotional registers of those who inhabit it. Buddhist social enterprises, emerging since 2011 as a model that integrates financial sustainability with core Buddhist values of compassion and interdependence, extend this logic further, creating employment for marginalized communities while sustaining the material presence of Buddhist culture in everyday social life (Kwon 2025, pp. 11–14). In each case, economic diversification and affordance production are not in tension but mutually constitutive. The economic logic sustains the material infrastructure through which the religious affordances are generated.
This does not mean that temple economy diversification is without risks or contradictions. The pressure to generate revenue can distort the design of material environments in ways that compromise their affordance capacity, producing Templestay programs optimized for tourist satisfaction rather than contemplative encounter, or temple food festivals oriented toward commercial spectacle rather than the transmission of Buddhist culinary philosophy. The alignment between economic sustainability and affordance quality is not automatic. It requires deliberate institutional attention and what might be called material stewardship: ongoing care for the integrity of the material environments through which Buddhist affordances are produced. The Jogye Order’s investment in standardizing Templestay quality, training temple food masters, and regulating the aesthetic standards of Buddhist cultural productions reflects an institutional awareness, however imperfect in its execution, that economic viability and affordance quality are interdependent rather than opposed. As Kwon notes, ensuring that transparency, right livelihood, and mission integrity remain operative constraints on diversification is among the most pressing institutional challenges Korean Buddhism currently faces (Kwon 2025, pp. 14–15).
4.3. The Persistence of Korean Buddhism: Cultural Saturation and Its Paradox
The third and most theoretically consequential axis of significance concerns the question of how Korean Buddhism persists and what kind of persistence the mediated turn produces. The secularization framework answers this question with a narrative of decline: as formal affiliation decreases, the tradition weakens, and its ultimate trajectory is one of social marginalization and eventual irrelevance. The evidence examined in this article points in a different direction.
Korean Buddhism persists not primarily through the reproduction of doctrinal communities, the training of monastics, or the performance of traditional ritual, though all of these continue, but through what might be called cultural saturation: the pervasive presence of Buddhist material culture, aesthetic language, and affective register across the domains of everyday life. The young Korean who has never identified as Buddhist may nonetheless have participated in a Templestay, eaten at a temple food restaurant, followed a Buddhist-affiliated mindfulness app, watched a documentary featuring a Buddhist monk, worn a prayer bead bracelet, and visited a Buddhist heritage site as a tourist. Each of these encounters leaves a residue. McDaniel calls this the slow “accretion of knowledge in the form of nondiscursive impressions” (McDaniel 2016, p. 24). It constitutes a form of Buddhist familiarity without doctrinal commitment. Buddhism persists, in this mode, not as a system of beliefs held by identified adherents but as a sensory and aesthetic background to contemporary Korean life: present without being declared, familiar without being claimed.
This mode of persistence requires a theoretical vocabulary that secularization theory does not provide. Grace Davie’s influential concept of “believing without belonging” (Davie 1994) described a condition in which religious belief persists in the absence of institutional affiliation, meaning faith retained but community abandoned. The Korean case inverts and extends this formulation. What the mediated turn produces is not believing without belonging but something closer to encountering without either: a condition in which neither doctrinal conviction nor institutional membership is required for Buddhism to exert a palpable presence in the sensory landscape, aesthetic vocabulary, and affective repertoire of everyday life. The relevant question is therefore not how many Koreans identify as Buddhist but how Buddhism continues to shape the texture of Korean experience and how institutional actors organize the material conditions through which this shaping occurs. Secularization theory, with its dependence on formal affiliation as the primary measure of religious vitality, is constitutively unable to attend to this question. Korean Buddhism’s mediated turn is not an evidence that secularization has failed. It is evidence that secularization theory, as currently formulated, asks the wrong questions.
The dialectic between de-institutionalization and institutional design does not only produce this diffuse cultural presence; in some cases, it generates new conditions for more committed forms of engagement. A striking example is the rapid growth of Buddhist student clubs at Dongguk University, the Jogye Order’s flagship educational institution. Beginning in 2024, Buddhist clubs were established across all nineteen departments of the university’s Seoul campus, drawing a total membership of 5152 students as of March 2026, with an institutional target of seven thousand ordinations at the Seoul campus and ten thousand across both campuses in the 2026 academic year. The university’s engineering college club alone enrolled 846 members, making it the largest single Buddhist student organization on campus (I. Park 2026). One club’s membership of 580 was built in part through a soccer tournament that required club membership to participate: a design in which recreational affordances generated pathways into Buddhist practice. The trajectory from soccer tournament to ordination ceremony is not incidental; it is the mediated turn’s most generative possibility. In most religious contexts, de-institutionalization tends to occur at the expense of institutional power. In Korea, the inverse obtains. The tradition spreads precisely because it does not demand commitment; it becomes culturally pervasive precisely because it does not insist on doctrinal identity.
4.4. Open Questions: What Kind of Persistence?
The significance of the mediated turn should not be overstated. The mode of persistence it produces is not without its own tensions, vulnerabilities, and costs. The most fundamental question is this: what kind of persistence is it? Cultural saturation and doctrinal community are not the same thing. The Buddhism that persists through the mediated turn, diffuse, aesthetically rich, affectively available, institutionally designed, and doctrinally uncommitted, is a different Buddhism from the tradition of monastic discipline, textual scholarship, ritual community, and soteriological commitment that has historically defined the tradition. This difference should not be evaluated simply as decline or corruption, but it should be named and examined rather than glossed over.
First, the decline of the monastic community as a social institution, including declining ordinations, aging monastic populations, and the increasing difficulty of sustaining traditional patterns of monastic education and practice, represents a structural vulnerability that the mediated turn does not address and may, in some respects, exacerbate. The material affordances that the Jogye Order produces for unaffiliated publics depend ultimately on the continued existence of a monastic institution capable of generating, authorizing, and maintaining them. Cultural saturation without institutional depth is a precarious form of religious presence: wide in reach but potentially shallow in root. This points toward the most urgent and undertheorized question facing Korean Buddhism: whether the material architecture of the mediated turn can be designed not only to generate affective encounter but to create pathways toward monastic vocation. The affordance framework has focused primarily on how Buddhist material environments lower thresholds of entry for unaffiliated publics, but affordances are directional; they can be designed to lead as well as to receive. The Dongguk University Buddhist club initiative offers one model: material environments designed initially for casual, recreational engagement can become, through deliberate institutional sequencing, pathways toward ordination and committed practice. Whether this possibility can be systematically cultivated at scale is a question the tradition’s material designers have not yet fully confronted.
Second, the institutionally engineered character of the mediated turn raises questions of legitimacy and authenticity that cannot be dissolved by theoretical analysis. When Buddhist material environments are deliberately designed to attract and engage non-Buddhist publics, questions arise about who benefits, whose Buddhism is being presented, and whose interests are served by the particular forms of encounter that are afforded and withheld. Particularly significant is whether the material environments designed for unaffiliated publics adequately represent the monastic and contemplative dimensions of the tradition, or whether the imperative to attract and retain non-committed publics systematically marginalizes precisely those aspects of Buddhism most essential to its long-term reproduction. These political dimensions of affordance design require ongoing critical examination that this article can only begin.
Third, the question of whether cultural saturation can sustain the conditions for its own reproduction remains open. The slow accretion of Buddhist familiarity through affective encounter may provide the initial conditions for deeper engagement, but it may also produce a form of Buddhist engagement that is perpetually shallow: wide enough to maintain cultural presence but not deep enough to sustain the doctrinal communities, trained monastics, and ritual traditions through which the material affordances are ultimately generated. The assemblage through which this persistence is organized, comprising the Jogye Order, digital platforms, wellness discourse, consumer markets, state tourism policy, and the affective habits of millions of unaffiliated Koreans, is not a stable formation. It is a contingent arrangement whose coherence is always an achievement rather than a given, always capable of generating effects that exceed the intentions of any single actor within it (Deleuze and Guattari 1987; DeLanda 2006, pp. 3–10). The tradition’s most consequential challenge is to design, within this assemblage, material environments capable of converting affective familiarity into the committed engagement on which the monastic institution ultimately depends.
5. Conclusions
This article has argued that the materiality of contemporary Korean Buddhism is best understood not as a symptom of secularization or commodification but as an active medium through which the tradition constitutes, extends, and renegotiates its presence in a society where the majority of the population does not identify as Buddhist. Against scholarly accounts that treat Buddhist material culture as evidence of doctrinal dilution or market accommodation, this article has proposed an alternative analytical vocabulary grounded in the concept of affordance. Drawing on Gibson’s ecological psychology, Norman’s design theory, and the material religion scholarship of Morgan and Meyer, and situating these resources within the broader philosophical reorientation of new materialism, the article has demonstrated that Korean Buddhist objects, spaces, and media are best analyzed not in terms of what they represent but in terms of what they do.
Four affordance types organize this analysis. Access infrastructures lower the thresholds of entry for unaffiliated publics, producing encounters with Buddhism that require neither doctrinal knowledge nor institutional membership. Affective attunement devices mediate Buddhism through the registers of emotional regulation, self-care, and restorative experience, calibrating the sensory and emotional dispositions of those who inhabit them. Aesthetic identity markers circulate the visual and material vocabulary of Buddhism as resources for taste, lifestyle, and cultural capital, generating an affiliation-free familiarity that accumulates without being declared. Public cultural interfaces position Buddhist heritage within the pathways of state tourism policy, regional branding, and international diplomacy, confirming Meyer’s insight that the locus of authorization for sensational forms can shift from the sangha to the state without diminishing their capacity to organize public sensibility. Together, these four modalities constitute the material architecture of the mediated turn in Korean Buddhism. The Korean paradox at the heart of this transformation is that de-institutionalization is itself institutionally engineered: what the Jogye Order’s successive adaptive responses to disaffiliation have produced, without deliberate design, is a systematic architecture for affiliation-free religious presence. This architecture inverts Grace Davie’s formulation of believing without belonging into something more radical, encountering without either, a condition in which Buddhism exerts a palpable presence in the sensory landscape and affective repertoire of everyday Korean life precisely because it has ceased to demand the commitments that once defined it.
Several research agendas remain open. The most urgent concerns the directionality of affordance design: whether Buddhist material environments can be designed to generate pathways toward deeper commitment, including monastic vocation and sustained lay practice, and what institutional sequencing would be required to sustain that trajectory. The second concerns the long-term viability of cultural saturation as a mode of religious persistence. A third concerns the perspectives of those who actually encounter Korean Buddhist material culture; what remains largely absent is the voice of those for whom these environments are designed, including the Templestay participant, the young consumer who wears a yeomju bracelet without identifying as Buddhist, and the international visitor encountering Korean Buddhism for the first time through a streaming platform. A fourth concerns comparative analysis: whether the Korean paradox of institutionally engineered de-institutionalization holds under systematic comparison with analogous cases such as Japanese monastic tourism or Tibetan Buddhist centers in the diaspora, and what such comparison would reveal about the relationship between institutional centralization and affiliation-free cultural reach, are questions this article leaves open for future scholarship. What the affordance framework provides is the analytical precision to distinguish between material persistence and communal persistence, and to identify the conditions under which one might generate the other. The tradition’s most consequential challenge is to understand whether the generation formed through affective encounter rather than doctrinal community will, in time, become the generation that sustains the tradition from within. This year’s Buddhism Expo opens under the slogan “The Gong (空) Game We Like.” The word gong, homophonous in Korean, signifies both “ball” and “emptiness.” What merits careful attention is whether this playful wordplay can meaningfully lead to a deeper sense of peace of mind grounded in the wisdom of emptiness.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, J.K. (Junghyun Kwon) and J.K. (Jahyun Kim); methodology, J.K. (Junghyun Kwon) and J.K. (Jahyun Kim); writing—original draft preparation, J.K. (Junghyun Kwon); writing—review and editing, J.K. (Jahyun Kim); project administration, J.K. (Junghyun Kwon); funding acquisition, J.K. (Jahyun Kim). All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
This work was supported by the Ministry of Education of the Republic of Korea and the National Research Foundation of Korea [(NRF-2021S1A6A3A01097807)].
Institutional Review Board Statement
Not applicable.
Informed Consent Statement
Not applicable.
Data Availability Statement
No new data were created or analyzed in this study. Data sharing is not applicable to this article.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
References
- Baker, Don. 2008. Korean Spirituality. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press. [Google Scholar]
- Barad, Karen. 2007. Meeting the Universe Halfway: Quantum Physics and the Entanglement of Matter and Meaning. Durham: Duke University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Bargár, Pavol. 2020. The Modern, the Postmodern, and ... the Metamodern? Reflections on a Transforming Sensibility from the Perspective of Theological Anthropology. Transformation: An International Journal of Holistic Mission Studies 38: 3–15. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Bennett, Jane. 2010. Vibrant Matter: A Political Ecology of Things. Durham: Duke University Press. [Google Scholar]
- BEXPO (Seoul International Buddhist Expo). n.d.BEXPO Official Website. Available online: https://bexpo.kr/ (accessed on 21 March 2026).
- Blumer, Herbert. 1954. What is Wrong with Social Theory? American Sociological Review 19: 3–10. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Chang, Kyung-Sup. 2010. South Korea Under Compressed Modernity: Familial Political Economy in Transition. London: Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Cho, Kiryong. 2024. Hyundae Hanguk seunggaeui saengsan bulgyo jeonghyang 현대 한국승가의 생산불교 정향 (正向) [The Right Direction of Production Buddhism in Modern Korean Saṃgha]. Journal of the Korean Association of Buddhist Studies 111: 203–36. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Coole, Diana, and Samantha Frost, eds. 2010. New Materialisms: Ontology, Agency, and Politics. Durham: Duke University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Davie, Grace. 1994. Religion in Britain Since 1945: Believing Without Belonging. Oxford: Blackwell. [Google Scholar]
- DeLanda, Manuel. 2006. A New Philosophy of Society: Assemblage Theory and Social Complexity. London: Continuum. [Google Scholar]
- Deleuze, Gilles, and Félix Guattari. 1987. A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia. Translated by Brian Massumi. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. [Google Scholar]
- Dongguk University Jeonggakwon. n.d.Jeonggakwon Official Website. Available online: https://jeonggak.dongguk.edu (accessed on 19 March 2026).
- Freinacht, Hanzi. 2017. The Listening Society: A Metamodern Guide to Politics. Copenhagen: Metamoderna ApS. [Google Scholar]
- Gauthier, François. 2025. Religion in the Market Era: The Rise of Market Islam, the Revenge of Confucius, and Other Stories from a Global Age. New York: Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Gibson, James J. 1979. The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. [Google Scholar]
- Google Maps. n.d.Visitor Reviews, JustBe Hongdae Seon Center. Available online: https://www.google.co.kr/maps/place/JustBe+Temple (accessed on 18 March 2026).
- Han, Areum. 2025. “경주 황룡원, APEC서 국제행사장 역량 발휘” [Hwangnyongwon in Gyeongju Demonstrates Capacity as International Event Venue at APEC]. JoongAng Ilbo. November 10. Available online: https://www.joongang.co.kr/article/25380878 (accessed on 23 March 2026).
- Hwangnyongwon. n.d.Hwangnyongwon Official Website. Available online: https://hwangnyongwon.com (accessed on 23 March 2026).
- Jeon, Hyeongju. 2025. “입소문 난 ’김밥축제’ 올해도 터졌다…15만명 우르르, 대박 비결은?” [The Word-of-Mouth Gimbap Festival Explodes Again This Year: 150,000 Flock In, What Is the Secret to Its Success?]. Money Today. October 26. Available online: https://www.mt.co.kr/society/2025/10/26/2025102616230446892 (accessed on 21 March 2026).
- Jeong, Eunju. 2026. “’직지’의 마음으로 천년을 거닐다…뚜벅뚜벅 김천 시간여행” [Walking Through a Thousand Years with the Spirit of Jikji: A Slow Travel in Gimcheon]. Gyeonghyang Sinmun. March 7. Available online: https://www.khan.co.kr/article/202603070600005/ (accessed on 21 March 2026).
- JustBe Hongdae Seon Center. n.d.JustBe Hongdae Seon Center Official Website. Available online: https://justbetemple.org (accessed on 18 March 2026).
- Kang, Maggie, and Chris Appelhans, dirs. 2025. KPop Demon Hunters. Sony Pictures Animation. Netflix, June 20. [Google Scholar]
- Kaplan, Uri. 2010. Images of Monasticism: The Temple Stay Program and the Re-branding of Korean Buddhist Temples. Korean Studies 34: 127–46. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Kendall, Laurel. 2010. Consuming Korean Tradition in Early and Late Modernity: Commodification, Tourism, and Performance. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press. [Google Scholar]
- Kieschnick, John. 2003. The Impact of Buddhism on Chinese Material Culture. Princeton: Princeton University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Kim, Hwansoo Ilmee, and Jin Y. Park, eds. 2022. New Perspective in Modern Korean Buddhism: Institution, Gender and Secular Society. Albany: State University of New York Press. [Google Scholar]
- Kitiarsa, Pattana, ed. 2008. Religious Commodifications in Asia: Marketing Gods. London: Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Korea Temple Food. n.d.Korea Temple Food Official Website. Available online: https://www.koreatemplefood.com/ (accessed on 22 March 2026).
- Korean Buddhist Cultural Heritage Foundation. 2022. Templestay 20-Nyeonsa 템플스테이 20년사 [A Twenty-Year History of Templestay]. Seoul: Korean Buddhist Cultural Heritage Foundation. [Google Scholar]
- Kumuda. n.d.Kumuda Official Website. Available online: http://kumuda.co.kr/ (accessed on 19 March 2026).
- Kwon, Junghyun. 2025. Practice, Profit, and Public Good: Temple Economies and Social Enterprises in Korean Buddhism. Religions 16: 1139. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Latour, Bruno. 2005. Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor-Network Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Lee, Gyeongmin. 2026a. “35만 다녀간 템플스테이, 세계로 간 사찰음식...세계적 콘텐츠 ‘우뚝’” [Templestay Visited by 350,000, Temple Food Goes Global: Rising as World-Class Cultural Content]. Buddhist Newspaper. February 10. Available online: https://www.ibulgyo.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=435469 (accessed on 21 March 2026).
- Lee, Gyeongmin. 2026b. “사찰음식 명장 6인 출격...‘공양간의 셰프들’” [Six Temple Food Masters Take the Stage: ‘The Chefs of the Offering Hall’]. Buddhist Newspaper. January 30. Available online: http://www.ibulgyo.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=435187 (accessed on 19 March 2026).
- McDaniel, Justin Thomas. 2016. Architects of Buddhist Leisure: Socially Disengaged Buddhism in Asia’s Museums, Monuments, and Amusement Parks. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press. [Google Scholar]
- McMahan, David L. 2008. The Making of Buddhist Modernism. Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Meyer, Birgit. 2006. Religious Sensations: Why Media, Aesthetics and Power Matter in the Study of Contemporary Religion. Inaugural lecture. Amsterdam: Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam. [Google Scholar]
- Meyer, Birgit, ed. 2009. Aesthetic Formations: Media, Religion, and the Senses. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. [Google Scholar]
- Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism (MCST), and Related Ministries. 2022. Gwangwang Jinheung Gibon Gyehoek 2022-nyeon Sihaeng Gyehoek 관광진흥기본계획 2022년 시행계획 [Basic Plan for Tourism Promotion: 2022 Implementation Plan]. Seoul: Related Ministries of the Republic of Korea. [Google Scholar]
- Morgan, David. 2005. The Sacred Gaze: Religious Visual Culture in Theory and Practice. Berkeley: University of California Press. [Google Scholar]
- Morgan, David. 2012. The Embodied Eye: Religious Visual Culture and the Social Life of Feeling. Berkeley: University of California Press. [Google Scholar]
- Norman, Donald A. 1988. The Design of Everyday Things. New York: Basic Books. [Google Scholar]
- Park, Gyeongeun. 2025. “가요계에 플레이브? 불교계엔 불법스님!” [K-pop World Has PLave? Buddhist World Has Bulbeop Sunim!]. Gyeonghyang Sinmun. September 10. Available online: https://www.khan.co.kr/article/202509101137011 (accessed on 22 March 2026).
- Park, Intak. 2026. “영캠프 통해 동국 1만명 수계 실현하자” [Let Us Achieve Ten Thousand Ordinations at Dongguk through the Young Camp]. Buddhist Newspaper. March 20. Available online: https://www.ibulgyo.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=436534 (accessed on 24 March 2026).
- Purser, Ronald E. 2019. McMindfulness: How Mindfulness Became the New Capitalist Spirituality. London: Repeater Books. [Google Scholar]
- Seigworth, Gregory J., and Melissa Gregg. 2010. An Inventory of Shimmers. In The Affect Theory Reader. Edited by Melissa Gregg and Gregory J. Seigworth. Durham: Duke University Press, pp. 1–25. [Google Scholar]
- Shin, Jungil. 2025. “사자보이즈 천도한 ‘스님 버튜버’, 첫방부터 터졌다” [Buddhist VTuber ‘Bulbeop Sunim’ Conducts Cheondoje for Saja Boys: Debut Broadcast Draws Explosive Response]. Hyeonbul News. July 10. Available online: https://www.hyunbulnews.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=420139 (accessed on 22 March 2026).
- Shin, Sungmin. 2022. “[문화, 불교를 입다-굿즈] GOOD한 ‘불교 굿즈’, MZ세대 ‘취향저격’” [[Culture, Wearing Buddhism—Goods] Buddhist Goods Hit the Mark for the MZ Generation]. Hyeonbul News. May 10. Available online: http://www.hyunbulnews.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=404969 (accessed on 19 March 2026).
- Templestay. n.d.Templestay Official Website. Available online: https://www.templestay.com/fe/MI000000000000000020/html/view.do (accessed on 21 March 2026).
- Vermeulen, Timotheus, and Robin van den Akker. 2010. Notes on Metamodernism. Journal of Aesthetics and Culture 2: 5677. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Watson, Iain. 2013. South Korea’s State-led Soft Power Strategies: Limits on Inter-Korean Relations. Asian Journal of Political Science 20: 304–25. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Yoo, Hwaseok. 2025. “한 그릇에 생명을 담다: 제4회 사찰음식 대축제 성황리에 마쳐” [Holding Life in a Single Bowl: The Fourth Temple Food Grand Festival Concludes in Grand Success]. Beopbo Sinmun. June 18. Available online: https://www.beopbo.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=329513 (accessed on 22 March 2026).
- Zhu, Yujie. 2025. Contested sacred space: State power, spatial politics, and heritage tourism. Tourism Geographies May: 1–25. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.