Abstract
This article asks how authentic Christian faith holds together right believing (Orthodoxy), right being (Orthocompassio), and right doing (Orthopraxis), and how this triad relates to the theological virtues of faith, love, and hope. It argues for an ordered yet reciprocal grammar in which the gospel grounds the Spirit’s reordering of desire and issues in hopeful practice. Aristotle and Augustine are related through asymmetrical retrieval rather than a simple doing–being contrast, Aristotle supplies an account of habituated character, practical wisdom, friendship, and contemplation, while Augustine relocates these capacities within creation, sin, grace, and beatitude in God. In dialogue with Aquinas and contemporary work on infused virtue, the article distinguishes acquired capacities from faith, hope, and love as gifts of grace without severing divine action from embodied practice. Its Trinitarian account is a limited appropriation grounded in the missions of the Son and Spirit and the Father’s sending relation, while maintaining the inseparability of divine action. South African engagement with ubuntu, relational personhood, hospitality, and public witness tests the proposal contextually. The result is a constructive Evangelical account of doctrine, desire, and action ordered towards communion with God and faithful participation in God’s promised future.
1. Introduction
Evangelical theology and practice repeatedly confront the question whether authentic faith is principally a matter of right believing, right being, or right doing. Different movements have given different weight to these dimensions: the Reformation foregrounded the reception and confession of the gospel; monastic, Pietist, and spiritual-formation traditions emphasised transformed character; and Social Gospel and liberationist traditions stressed public practice. These broad patterns should not reduce complex traditions to a single concern. They instead identify a constructive theological problem: how doctrine, desire, and action belong together, whether one grounds another, and how faith, love, and hope animate all three.
This article proposes, from an Evangelical perspective, that Orthodoxy (right believing), Orthocompassio (right being) and Orthopraxis (right doing) are best understood through an ordered yet reciprocal theological grammar: Orthodoxy grounds Orthocompassio, which expresses itself in Orthopraxis. ‘Orthocompassio’ is used here as the author’s constructive term. It is not presented as a term coined by Louw, Trementozzi or Woodbridge.
Land’s (1993, pp. 41–46) orthodoxy–orthopathy–orthopraxy configuration offers a Pentecostal comparison with this proposal, while the present model gives ontological and Christological weight to compassion. The ordering is one of theological dependence rather than chronological sequence; mature believers inhabit all three dimensions simultaneously. It reflects the Pauline movement from doctrinal exposition (Rom. 1–11), through transformed life (Rom. 12:1–2), to concrete ethical engagement (Rom. 12:3–15:13), and the pattern of grace, new creation, and good works in Eph. 2:8–10.
This article employs constructive systematic theology in dialogue with biblical, historical, philosophical, Evangelical, and South African contextual theology. The sources are not treated as co-equal. Scripture supplies the normative narrative and grammar of the gospel; the classical Trinitarian and Christological tradition provides dogmatic constraints for interpreting that narrative; historical theologians function as authoritative but revisable witnesses; philosophical ethics offers conceptual and diagnostic resources; and contemporary Evangelical and South African scholarship tests the proposal’s ecclesial and contextual adequacy. When these sources conflict, Scripture read within the church’s Trinitarian confession has adjudicative priority, while contextual theology exposes applications and blind spots that an abstract construction may miss.
Aristotle and Augustine are therefore engaged as unequal but indispensable interlocutors, not as alternatives to scriptural normativity. Augustine’s (1997, II.40.60) strategy of ‘spoiling the Egyptians’ permits genuine philosophical insight to be appropriated and transformed within a Christological and pneumatological framework. Calvin’s (1960, II.2.12–17, pp. 270–75) doctrine of common grace offers a related Evangelical rationale: pagan moral wisdom may be received as providential gift without being granted soteriological sufficiency.
Why Aristotle Rather than Plato?
The choice of Aristotle rather than Plato requires a methodological clarification. Augustine’s intellectual formation was profoundly shaped by Platonist sources, and Plato remains an important background to his account of participation, ascent, and the ordered love of God. This article does not claim that Aristotle was Augustine’s direct historical dialogue partner, nor that Aristotle displaced Platonism in Augustine’s thought. Aristotle is chosen for a constructive reason. The article’s central question concerns how desire becomes stable character and how faith is embodied in practical judgement, friendship, communal life, and contemplation. The Nicomachean Ethics and Politics provide especially precise conceptual resources for habituation, phronesis, civic formation, and the relation between activity and human fulfilment (Aristotle 1998, I.2; 1999, II.1, VI.5, X.7–8). These resources allow Augustine’s theology of grace, sin, caritas, and beatitude to be tested against a robust account of acquired virtue. Plato remains a necessary interlocutor for Augustine’s metaphysical and participatory horizon, but the present dialogue is deliberately Aristotelian at the level of moral formation. The aim is therefore asymmetrical retrieval, not a claim about direct historical influence.
Smith’s (2009, pp. 18–24; 2016, pp. 8–22) explains how embodied practices and cultural liturgies shape human desire. His work therefore supports the account of Orthocompassio as a love-formed identity developed through worship, habit, and communal practice. N. T. Wright’s (2010, pp. 66, 103–4) connects Christian virtue with God’s future and new creation. His virtue-eschatology helps explain how hope gives present Christian action its direction and purpose, thereby informing the account of Orthopraxisvirtue-eschatology, and Vanhoozer’s (2005, p. 179; 2014, pp. 1–2) presents doctrine as something performed within the church’s theo-drama rather than merely affirmed intellectually. His work supports the argument that Orthodoxy is a lived and formative confession that shapes Christian perception, character, and action. The theo-dramatic account of doctrine serve as contemporary Evangelical interlocutors. These texts were chosen because each addresses a different dimension of the article’s central argument. Together, these authors provide contemporary Evangelical perspectives on desire, hope, doctrine, and practice, while complementing the article’s dialogue between Aristotle and Augustine. South African scholarship on reconciliation, ubuntu, relational ontology, hospitality, and vulnerable leadership provides the contextual test for the investigation.
2. Defining the Triad: Orthodoxy, Orthopraxis, and Orthocompassio
2.1. Orthodoxy: Right Believing as the Doctrinal Foundation
Orthodoxy (from the Greek orthos, ‘right,’ and doxa, ‘belief’ or ‘glory’) designates the dimension of Christian faith that concerns the content of belief: more specifically, belief in the God who has revealed himself as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit in the narrative of Scripture and, in its most concentrated form, in the gospel of Jesus Christ. In Evangelical theology, Orthodoxy is not merely intellectual assent to propositions but trust in the God to whom those propositions point. The confession that ‘Jesus is Lord’ (Rom. 10:9) entails entrusting one’s whole existence to the One who died and rose again. Grenz (1994, pp. 1–2) identifies narrative and community as central to Evangelical theological identity: Orthodoxy concerns the story of the Triune God’s redemptive engagement with creation, received and confessed within the worshipping community.
Orthodoxy is therefore not self-generated by detached cognition. The community receives it through apostolic proclamation, Scripture, ecclesial teaching, worship, and participation in practices that make confession intelligible. Faith comes by hearing (Rom. 10:17), but hearing is clarified and purified as it is enacted in love. A believer may act mercifully before being able to articulate a full doctrinal account, and a formally correct confession may remain uninhabited. Orthodoxy and orthopraxis are therefore distinct but mutually formative. The triad names theological priority, not a universal chronology.
Vanhoozer (2014, pp. 1–2) presents doctrine as direction for the church’s faithful witness and performance of the gospel. Doctrine is therefore not merely a set of cognitive propositions but a formative orientation towards reality that shapes perception, desire, and action. The crucial insight for the ordering proposed in this article is that Orthodoxy is not merely the first element of the triad but its active foundation: because the gospel is true, because Jesus Christ died and rose, and because the Spirit has been poured out, the transformation of the human person (Orthocompassio) is both possible and commanded. The indicative of the gospel (Orthodoxy) grounds the imperatives of transformation (Orthocompassio) and engagement (Orthopraxis). N. T. Wright’s (1992, pp. 32–46) account of worldview similarly shows how Christian belief supplies a comprehensive orientation of story, symbols, values, and praxis.
2.2. Orthopraxis: Right Doing as the Outward Expression
Orthopraxis (from praxis, ‘action’ or ‘practice’) designates the dimension of Christian faith that concerns concrete, world-directed engagement: the actions, practices, and habits through which Christian identity becomes visible in the world. The concept achieved prominence in liberation theology, where Gutiérrez (1988, pp. 3–15) describes theology as critical reflection on praxis in the light of God’s word. The prophetic tradition of the Hebrew Bible insists that knowledge of God (da’at elohim) is inseparable from justice (Jer. 22:16). Bosch (1991, p. 412) likewise argues that Christian mission must hold proclamation together with justice, mercy, and peace.
Within the ordering proposed here, Orthopraxis is the outward expression of Orthodoxy mediated through Orthocompassio. C. J. H. Wright (2006, pp. 315–16) locates mission within God’s purpose to be known among the nations and embodied by the covenant community. Right action is ordinarily the fruit of right being, but practice can also become a site where love discloses and deepens faith. This does not diminish the urgency of Orthopraxis; it grounds it. Orthopraxis divorced from Orthodoxy and Orthocompassio risks becoming activism without a distinctly Christian theological grammar. Grounded in them, it becomes eschatological witness to the Kingdom.
2.3. Orthocompassio: Right Being—Definition and Terminological Defence
The term Orthocompassio, from orthos and the Latin compassio (com + pati, ‘to suffer with’), is used in this article as the author’s constructive term for the dimension of Christian faith concerning character, desire, affection, and relational orientation. This terminology must be distinguished from the Orthopathy frameworks of Woodbridge (2010, pp. 1–6) and Trementozzi (2018), and from Louw’s (2016, pp. 336–54) account of Missio Dei as the embodiment of Passio Dei. Louw’s movement from imperial or power-oriented divine images towards pathos, vulnerability, and compassion is an important theological precursor, but he does not coin the term Orthocompassio.
Orthopathy helpfully identifies the affective dimension of Christian formation, but Orthocompassio is preferred here for three reasons. First, compassion ‘suffering with’ has a specifically Christological resonance: Christ’s compassion is not merely an emotion but an orientation of his whole life towards suffering others. Second, Orthocompassio designates an ontological and relational reality, not merely a psychological state. In Augustine, caritas concerns the orientation of the whole person towards God and neighbour. Third, Smith’s (2016, p. 9) claim that human beings are defined by what they love identifies the depth of desire-formed identity that this term seeks to name. Because compassio can sound passive, the term must be specified. Orthocompassio means a love-constituted mode of being-in-action. It names the disposition from which attention, solidarity, mercy, and concrete service arise. “Being” therefore refers to formed participation in a way of life, not to inert feeling or mere emotional identification. In Augustine’s terms, caritas is active love, and the test of the disposition is what it does.
Smith’s (2009, pp. 18–24) anthropology likewise resists reducing the human person to cognition alone: embodied practices form desire and orient persons towards visions of the good life. Orthopathy names an indispensable affective dimension; Orthocompassio is proposed here to name the deeper, love-constituted and compassion-oriented identity from which faithful practice proceeds. The present study therefore develops Orthocompassio constructively in conversation with Augustine, Smith, and Louw’s Passio Dei, while retaining responsibility for the term itself.
2.4. The Evangelical Ordering: Orthodoxy → Orthocompassio → Orthopraxis
The proposed ordering begins with Orthodoxy as doctrinal foundation, Orthocompassio as the interior reordering effected by the Spirit through the gospel, and Orthopraxis as the outward expression of that formation. Land’s (1993, pp. 41–46) Pentecostal triad treats orthodoxy, orthopathy, and orthopraxy as mutually implicating dimensions of spirituality; the present model agrees that they cannot be isolated but argues for a theological relation of grounding and expression. This is not a claim that intellectual knowledge mechanically produces holiness. Zizioulas (1985) offers a qualified counter-perspective by treating knowledge of God as participatory and relational, thereby complicating any simple linear sequence from knowing to being. The Pauline indicative–imperative remains decisive for this Evangelical proposal: what God has done in Christ grounds transformation and action.
The ordering of Orthodoxy → Orthocompassio → Orthopraxis should not be treated as a one-way ladder. They identify a normative relation of grounding and expression, while lived Christian formation is recursive. Orthodoxy gives the norm and promise by which practices are judged, but practices can expose false belief, train attention, and become occasions through which love illuminates understanding. Augustine’s account of charity supports this reciprocity: love is not an optional sentiment added after faith but the active condition in which faith becomes truthful in the life of the believer (Augustine 2002, VIII.4.6; 2008, VIII.5).
The same ordering appears in Eph 2:8–10: “For by grace you have been saved through faith [Orthodoxy, the doctrinal reality of grace received]… we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus (Orthocompassio, the new ontological identity constituted by the Spirit’s re-creative work) for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them (Orthopraxis, the concrete works that flow from the new creation identity).” Phil 2:12–13 confirms: “Work out your own salvation with fear and trembling (Orthopraxis), for it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure (Orthocompassio, the Spirit’s transformation of the will).” The divine work in the believer (Orthocompassio) precedes and enables the human work of faithful action (Orthopraxis), and both rest on the gospel (Orthodoxy). This orientation operates precisely through the transformation of the inner person. Ephesians 2:8–10 should accordingly be read as a grammar of grace and vocation, not as a denial that works can educate desire or that embodied obedience can deepen understanding. The gospel remains the source and norm, yet the movement between confession, love, and action is dialogical and sustained across the believer’s pilgrimage.
2.5. Faith, Love, and Hope: Infused Virtues Within the Ordered Triad
The relationship between the triad and the theological virtues is analogical rather than a rigid one-to-one equivalence. Faith corresponds most directly to Orthodoxy because it receives God’s self-disclosure and entrusts the believer to the gospel’s truth. Yet faith is not correct cognition alone; it is an infused orientation to God that becomes articulate through confession, obedience, and acquired capacities. Knobel (2021, pp. 149–65) argues that infused faith and acquired intellectual and moral habits should neither be collapsed nor separated. Orthodoxy is therefore Christian only as the doctrinal form of living faith. Faith therefore does not stand before love as a detachable cognitive act. It is a living reception of God’s truth, and its truthfulness is disclosed as love takes practical form. Augustine’s insistence that love illuminates the intellect prevents the correspondence between faith and Orthodoxy from becoming a purely intellectualist claim (Augustine 2002, VIII.4.6; 2008, VIII.5).
Love corresponds most directly to Orthocompassio. Augustine’s ordo amoris identifies virtue with the healing and ordering of desire towards God and neighbour. Aquinas (1948, I–II, q. 62, aa. 1–4) distinguishes acquired moral virtues from theological virtues that have God as their immediate object and are divinely infused. Pelser (2021, pp. 191–210) further shows that treating Christian love as God’s gift does not render practices irrelevant: worship, attention, friendship, and works of mercy can dispose and train agents to receive and enact charity without producing it autonomously. Orthocompassio names the relational form of this graced reordering. Here Augustine’s own account is primary (Augustine 1997, I.3.3–I.4.4). Aquinas is retained as a later systematic clarification of the distinction between acquired and infused virtue, not as the source of Augustine’s ordo amoris. The order at issue is not a ranking of neighbours. It is the right ordering of every created good in relation to God, so that no creature is loved more than God or as though it were God.
Hope corresponds most directly to Orthopraxis because Christian action anticipates God’s promised future. Hope is neither passive optimism nor confidence in human progress. DeYoung (2021, pp. 166–90) presents hope as reliance upon God that is cultivated through prayer, worship, friendship, and practices of perseverance. N. T. Wright’s (2010, pp. 66, 103–4) eschatological account likewise locates present character and action within God’s new creation. Orthopraxis is therefore hope enacted: patient, courageous, and reparative participation that neither constructs the Kingdom autonomously nor withdraws from present responsibility.
Faith, love, and hope remain mutually implicating and each informs the whole triad. Faith works through love; love seeks the neighbour’s promised good; and hope depends upon the truthfulness of the God whom faith confesses. The correspondences therefore identify dominant emphases rather than exclusive allocations. Orthodoxy without love and hope becomes sterile correctness; Orthocompassio without faith and hope loses its specifically theological orientation; and Orthopraxis without faith and love loses its grounding in grace and communion.
3. Aristotle’s Virtue Ethics: Character, Habituation, Friendship, and Contemplation
3.1. Eudaimonia as the Supreme Good
Aristotle (1999, I.1, I.7) opens the Nicomachean Ethics by observing that every art, enquiry, action, and pursuit aims at some good and identifies eudaimonia—activity of the soul in accordance with virtue—as the highest human good. Eudaimonia is therefore not a static possession but the sustained exercise of distinctively human capacities across a complete life. N. T. Wright (2010) offers a Christian transformation of this teleological structure by locating virtue within God’s promised new creation.
3.2. Virtue as Habituation and the Formation of Character
Aristotle (1999, II.1, II.3) argues that moral virtues are acquired through habituation: people become just by doing just acts, temperate by doing temperate acts, and brave by doing brave acts. Character is formed through repeated actions that embody the kind of person one is becoming. The virtuous person does not merely comply with an external rule; virtuous action becomes a stable disposition that includes fitting emotion as well as right action.
MacIntyre (1981, pp. 187–203) retrieves the Aristotelian insight that virtue is formed within a narrative life and a community of practice rather than by applying isolated rules. Smith (2009, pp. 18–24) develops a related account of Christian worship as embodied formation: ecclesial practices shape desire and train participation in the Kingdom’s vision of the good life.
3.3. Phronesis: Practical Wisdom as the Master Virtue (NE VI)
Aristotle (1999, VI.5) identifies phronesis, or practical wisdom, as the rational capacity to deliberate well about goods achievable in action. It enables moral agents to perceive the relevant features of a situation and to act fittingly. Phronesis differs from theoretical wisdom because it concerns contingent and particular action rather than universal contemplation. Pieper (1966, pp. 6–7) describes prudence as the virtue that gives measure and direction to the other moral virtues.
Aristotle (1999, X.7–8) presents contemplation as the highest exercise of human excellence. Christian theology can receive Aristotle’s teleological question while contesting the sufficiency of an immanent account of flourishing; Augustine identifies the human creature’s final rest in God as a good not secured by moral achievement alone.
3.4. The Limits of the Aristotelian Framework: A Calvin-Informed Assessment
The appropriate Evangelical response to Aristotle’s ethics is neither wholesale rejection nor uncritical adoption but a Calvin-informed posture of common-grace appropriation. Calvin (1960, II.2.15–16, pp. 273–75) explicitly acknowledges the genuine wisdom of ancient philosophy:
Whenever we come upon these matters in secular writers, let that admirable light of truth shining in them teach us that the mind of man through fallen and perverted from its wholeness, is nevertheless clothed and ornamented with God’s excellent gifts…. Shall we deny that the truth shone upon the ancient jurists who established civic order and discipline with such great equity? Shall we say that the philosophers were blind in their fine observations and artful descriptions of nature? Shall we say that those men were devoid of understanding who conceived the art of disputation and taught us to speak reasonably? Shall we say that they are insane who developed medicine, devoting their labor to our benefit? What shall we say of all the mathematical sciences? Shall we consider them the ravings of madmen? No, we cannot read the writings of the ancients on these subjects without great admiration. We marvel at them because we are compelled to recognized how preeminent they are…. Those men whom Scripture (1 Cor. 2:14) calls ‘natural men’ were, indeed, sharp and penetrating in their investigation of inferior things. Let us, accordingly, learn by their example how many gifts the Lord left to human nature even after it was despoiled of its true good.
The moral philosophy of Aristotle represents precisely this “admirable light of truth” that Christian theology may appropriate.
However, common grace must be distinguished from saving grace. Calvin (1960, II.2.12–13, pp. 270–73) is equally clear that the corruption of intellect and will means that even sophisticated natural virtue falls short of the righteousness God requires. Luther ([1518] 1957, theses 13, 21) sharpens the critique: free will after the fall cannot raise itself to God, and the theologian of the cross must name human moral incapacity truthfully. Natural virtue, however impressive, cannot by itself reorder the will’s deepest orientation towards God.
The implication for this article’s argument is decisive: Aristotelian habituation describes genuine moral formation that God enables through common grace, but it cannot produce Orthocompassio—the reordering of love towards God—without the Spirit’s transformative work. Smith (2016, p. 22) describes Spirit-led formation as a ‘recalibration of the heart’ through practices that retrain desire. The Spirit does not bypass embodied formation but recontextualises it within saving grace, eschatological transformation, and the community of the church.
4. Augustine’s Theology of Ordered Love: Desire, Grace, and Action
4.1. The Restless Heart and the Ontology of Desire
Augustine (1961, I.1.1) opens the Confessions with the confession that God has made humanity for himself and that the heart remains restless until it rests in God. This restlessness is not merely psychological; it names a creaturely orientation towards a telos beyond the self. Augustine’s theology of desire therefore provides a basis for speaking of Orthocompassio as love-constituted being. Smith’s (2016, pp. 8–9) formulation that human beings are shaped by what they love is a contemporary retrieval of this Augustinian insight.
Augustine therefore supplies the anthropology of desire that the present argument needs. The human person is not merely a rational knower but a lover whose will is moved by what it takes to be good. The restless heart of Confessions I.1.1 and the relation between knowledge and love in De Trinitate VIII.4.6 show that desire is not an optional supplement to cognition. It is the field in which cognition is directed, purified, and enacted. Smith’s language of desiring creatures is strongest when read as a contemporary retrieval of this Augustinian account rather than as an independent anthropology.
Boersma (2009, pp. 33, 225; 2011, pp. 124–26) retrieves what he calls Augustine’s “sacramental ontology” the conviction that the created order participates in the divine life and that the human soul is most truly itself when oriented towards its divine source. This ontology of participation undergirds the concept of Orthocompassio: right being, in the Augustinian framework, is being-in-participation, the soul whose loves are ordered towards God participates, by grace, in the very life of the Triune God. This is a far richer account of Orthocompassio than any psychological account of right feeling (Orthopathy) could provide.
4.2. De Trinitate: The Soul’s Likeness to God as Love
Augustine (2002, VIII.10.14) explores traces of Trinitarian life in the human person throughout Books VIII–XV of The Trinity. Love involves a lover, the beloved, and the love that unites them, and the human image of God reaches its proper orientation when memory, understanding, and love are directed towards God.
In The Trinity 9 and 10, Augustine identifies a first psychological triad in the human mind: mens (mind), notitia (knowledge), and amor (love), or in an alternative formulation, memoria (memory), intelligentia (understanding), and voluntas (will) (The Trinity 9.2.2; 10.11.18). This triad reflects the Trinitarian image insofar as the mind knows itself and loves itself. But the crucial point, developed in Book 14, is that the image of God in the human mind consists not merely in its existence as a rational soul but in its orientation towards God: “the image of God will be complete when the sight of God shall be complete” (The Trinity 14.17.23). The highest form of the psychological trinity is when the mind remembers God (memoria Dei), knows God (intelligentia Dei), and loves God (amor Dei) (The Trinity 14.12.15).
This has direct implications for Orthocompassio. The restoration of the imago Dei is the reordering of the soul’s knowing and loving towards God. The person whose memory, understanding, and love are oriented towards God bears the restored image of the Triune God; this is the ontological ground of right being. Baleng’s (2024, pp. 1–8) reading of Augustine’s conversion through Girardian mimetic theory enriches this analysis: reorientation towards God involves a movement from disordered mimetic desire (cupiditas) towards Christologically ordered desire (caritas). Orthocompassio, in this light, is the Christologically ordered soul, reoriented through the gospel and the Spirit’s transformative work towards Christ as the pattern of its being.
4.3. Ordo Amoris: The Right Ordering of All Loves
Augustine (1997, I.3.3–I.4.4) develops the right ordering of loves most systematically in On Christian Doctrine. The crucial distinction is between frui—enjoyment of something as an end—and uti—the use of something in relation to its proper end. God alone is to be enjoyed for his own sake; creaturely goods are loved in their proper proportion and directed towards God. O’Donovan (1980, p. 25) clarifies that this does not instrumentalise love of neighbour: the neighbour is loved most truly in God, as one who also has God as her ultimate end.
Augustine (2003, XIV.28) describes the two cities in The City of God as constituted by two loves: love of self to the contempt of God and love of God to the contempt of self. Sin is therefore disordered love, an inversion of the ordo amoris. Gregory (2008) develops the public-theological implications of Augustine’s account, showing how civic practices and institutions disclose rival orders of love. This analysis illuminates South African structures ordered around race, wealth, and power.
4.4. Caritas and the Governing Principle of Right Action
Augustine (2008, VII.8) records the celebrated injunction ‘Love and do what you will’ in his Homilies on the First Epistle of John. It is not ethical libertarianism but a claim that rightly ordered love gives moral action its proper orientation. Augustine reconfigures prudence within caritas rather than abolishing phronesis. Yeago (1998, pp. 163–91) supports a non-binary account in which grace reorders and perfects human moral capacities rather than replacing moral agency. Love is consequently a praxis. “Love and do what you will” describes an active form of life in which charity directs perception, choice, and conduct. Orthocompassio is therefore not an interior state opposed to Orthopraxis, but the graced disposition that becomes visible in practices of mercy and solidarity.
5. Aristotle and Augustine: Five Moments of Asymmetrical Retrieval
The relation between Aristotle and Augustine is best described as asymmetrical retrieval. Augustine shares Aristotle’s concern for stable character, practical judgement, friendship, and a teleological account of life, but relocates these within creation, fall, grace, ecclesial formation, and final enjoyment of God. The following tensions are therefore not collisions between ‘doing’ and ‘being’. They show how Aristotelian moral description can be received, criticised, and reordered within an Augustinian and Evangelical theological horizon.
5.1. Natural Formation, Sin, and the Need for Grace
The deepest divergence between Aristotle and Augustine is anthropological. Aristotle’s ethics presupposes that human beings can acquire the virtues through habituation and thereby pursue eudaimonia. Moral failure is addressed through education, law, habituation and practical judgement rather than through an Augustinian doctrine of original sin. Yet the contrast should not be reduced to a caricature of autonomous moral optimism. As a qualified counter-perspective, Zizioulas’s (1985) relational ontology also complicates any strict opposition between a self-contained nature and an externally added grace: human being is realised in communion.
Augustine (2003, XII.7) introduces a decisive hamartiological qualification by identifying the cause of evil wills as ‘defection from God’. The Fall does not abolish created agency, but it curves the will towards the self and disorders the ends for which acquired capacities are used. Luther ([1518] 1957, theses 13, 21) sharpens this point: free will raise itself to God, and the theologian of the cross must name moral and religious self-deception truthfully. Aristotle’s account can therefore describe real civic and moral formation, but it cannot diagnose or heal the will’s ultimate orientation away from God.
Calvin’s (1960, II.2.12–17, pp. 270–75) doctrine of common grace provides an Evangelical account of this asymmetry. Fallen persons retain genuine intellectual, artistic, civic, and moral gifts under providence, so Aristotle’s ethics may contain real moral wisdom. Saving grace is nevertheless another order of divine action: the Spirit joins persons to Christ, renews faith, reorders love, and establishes hope in God’s promise. Acquired virtue is received rather than discarded, but its governing end must be converted.
5.2. Eudaimonia, Beatitude, and the Virtue of Hope
A second moment concerns the telos of human existence. Aristotle locates eudaimonia in virtuous activity across a complete life, including friendship, political participation, and contemplation. Augustine does not reject earthly formation but locates complete beatitudo in the eschatological enjoyment of God. The difference is therefore not activity versus rest; it is the reordering of finite goods within a hope whose object exceeds every political and psychological achievement.
N. T. Wright (2010, p. 66) describes Christian character as formation for a royal-priestly vocation in God’s new creation rather than for private flourishing alone. DeYoung’s (2021, pp. 166–90) account of practised hope clarifies that this eschatological orientation generates perseverance rather than passivity. Orthodoxy confesses God’s promise; Orthocompassio becomes patient and courageous character; and Orthopraxis anticipates the promised future through works of mercy, justice, and reconciliation.
5.3. Phronesis Reordered by Caritas
Aristotle (1999, VI.5) treats phronesis as the trained rational capacity to deliberate about good action and direct the moral virtues. It is an achievement of practical reason within the conditions of human formation.
Augustine (2008, VII.8) gives caritas priority as the principle that directs practical reason towards its proper end. Right love does not make deliberation unnecessary; it shapes perception, intention, judgement, and the goods towards which practical wisdom is directed. The caritas Augustine gives priority to here is divine charity, not a human plan for arranging the virtues. Divine love exceeds every scheme and reconfigures the agent’s ends over the course of the pilgrim life. Phronesis is therefore converted, not merely rearranged, by a gift it cannot generate for itself.
This reconfiguration preserves rather than negates moral agency. The gospel supplies the truth and promises that the Spirit uses to reorder love; reordered love gives phronesis its theological end; and practical judgement serves faithful action. Pelser (2021, pp. 191–210) helps name the cooperation involved: charity is divinely given, yet embodied practices can cultivate receptivity and expression. Faith, love, and hope thus perfect the orientation of acquired capacities without making those capacities superfluous. Accordingly, charity does not supply a preconceived programme by which the agent masters the future. It summons a long process of discernment in which the whole life is gradually redirected towards God. Acquired practical wisdom remains important, but it is made answerable to a divine love whose excess continually reopens the agent’s understanding of the good.
5.4. Polis and Church as Communities of Formation
For Aristotle (1998, I.2), the polis is the natural context for moral formation because the human being is by nature a political animal. Virtues are formed through participation in the common life of the city. The church’s claim to be a community formed by Word, sacrament, and Spirit does not remove believers from political life, but it contests the polis’s claim to provide the final horizon of human identity.
For Augustine, the church is a pilgrim people whose common love is directed towards God. Volf (1998) develops a Trinitarian ecclesiology of communion, while Smith (2009, pp. 18–24) describes worship as embodied formation. Baptism, the Lord’s Supper, Scripture, prayer, friendship, and works of mercy form faith, love, and hope within a people awaiting God’s future. The church does not replace the political community; it contests every attempt to make the polis the final horizon of identity and trains believers for faithful political presence.
The implications for the triad are concrete in that the community of Orthodoxy is the preaching and teaching church; the community of Orthocompassio is the Spirit-formed body of Christ, shaped by its liturgical practices; and the community of Orthopraxis is the missional church engaged in the world. All three dimensions are ecclesial, not merely individual, and the church is their necessary context not as an Aristotelian natural community but as an eschatological gift of grace.
5.5. Grace and Nature: A Calvin-Informed Evangelical Proposal
The relation between nature and grace requires distinctions that protect both divine initiative and created agency. Aquinas (1948, I–II, q. 62, aa. 1–4) teaches that the theological virtues have God as their immediate object and are infused rather than generated by natural power. Acquired virtues order agents towards goods proportionate to human nature; faith, hope, and love direct the person towards supernatural communion with God. Grace therefore heals and elevates agency rather than substituting for it.
Knobel (2021, pp. 149–65), DeYoung (2021, pp. 166–90), and Pelser (2021, pp. 191–210) show in distinct ways that infused virtue, and practice should not be treated as competitors. Faith requires intellectual and moral articulation; hope is sustained through practices of reliance, worship, and friendship; and love is enacted through habits that dispose persons towards the neighbour’s good. These practices do not cause grace, but they are created means through which graced agents learn to perceive, desire, and act faithfully.
Drawing on Calvin (1960, II.2.12–17, pp. 270–75), an Evangelical proposal can affirm this practical account while retaining the distinction between common and saving grace. Common grace enables genuine moral insight, civic virtue, and habituation; saving grace unites the believer to Christ and reorders the will towards God. Aristotelian formation is therefore neither rejected nor made soteriologically sufficient. It is received within the church as embodied material for Spirit-enabled faith, love, and hope.
6. Evangelical Integration: Trinitarian Missions and the Ordered Triad
6.1. Inseparable Operations, Missions, and Limited Appropriations
The ordering Orthodoxy → Orthocompassio → Orthopraxis is grounded constructively in the Trinitarian economy. Appropriation associates an aspect of inseparable divine action with one person because of that person’s eternal relation and scriptural mission; it does not allocate separate divine tasks. Ayres (2010, pp. 42–71), Emery (2007, pp. 359–60, 363, 375), and Vidu (2021, chap. 1) each insist that the external works of Father, Son, and Spirit are undivided. The following associations are therefore limited pedagogical emphases governed by inseparable operations.
The Son is associated with Orthodoxy because the eternal Word is incarnate as the content and personal centre of the gospel. This association follows the Son’s mission without implying that the Father and Spirit are absent from revelation. Vanhoozer (2014, p. 180) describes the church’s doctrinal task as witness to the Word. Faith therefore receives the triune God’s self-disclosure in the Son through the Spirit and returns confession to the Father.
The Spirit is associated with Orthocompassio because the Spirit indwells believers, pours divine love into human hearts (Rom. 5:5), and forms the fruit named in Gal. 5:22–23. Smith (2016, p. 22) describes this formation as a recalibration of love. The association follows the Spirit’s mission from the Father through the Son, yet the whole Trinity creates, sustains, and sanctifies the believer. Love is therefore the graced personal form of participation in triune life, not the Spirit’s isolated operation.
The Father’s initiating and sending relation provides a limited point of emphasis for Orthopraxis: the Father sends the Son, and the Father and Son give the Spirit who empowers the church’s mission. Nevertheless, Orthopraxis belongs to the one triune mission rather than to the Father alone. Hopeful action participates in the Father’s purpose, takes its cruciform form from the Son, and receives its power from the Spirit. The mapping thus follows Trinitarian taxis and mission while refusing a division of labour within God.
6.2. Smith’s Cultural Liturgics and the Integration of the Triad
Smith’s (2009, pp. 18–24; 2016, pp. 8–22) Cultural Liturgics project, developed in Desiring the Kingdom and You Are What You Love, integrates Augustinian desire and Aristotelian habituation within an ecclesial framework. Smith argues that human beings are not merely thinking subjects but desiring creatures whose orientation towards the world is formed through embodied practices.
Smith (2009, pp. 23–24) argues that secular liturgies—the repetitive practices of consumer culture, entertainment, and nationalism—shape desire towards rival visions of the good life. Smith (2016, pp. 19–22) describes Christian worship as counter-formation through Scripture, prayer, baptism, Eucharist, and service: an education of love that reorients desire towards God’s Kingdom.
Smith’s project confirms that right being is love-constituted and that embodied practices shape desire. It also shows how Aristotelian habituation can be pneumatologically received: ecclesial practices are not techniques of autonomous self-improvement but created means through which faith, love, and hope are enacted. The proposed ordering offers one theological account of their relation—gospel truth grounds Spirit-formed desire and hopeful action—while recognising that mature Christian existence is reciprocal rather than mechanically linear. This Augustinian priority also reinforces the reciprocal model: practices do not simply express a settled desire. They can reveal, discipline, and redirect what the agent loves.
The present proposal therefore supplements rather than displaces Smith’s cultural liturgics. Cultural liturgics describes the ecclesial and anthropological processes by which desire is trained; the Trinitarian grammar identifies the divine mission within which those processes are received. Neither account licenses an exclusive Son–belief, Spirit–being, or Father–action division.
6.3. The Sermon on the Mount as the Triad’s Scriptural Charter
The Sermon on the Mount (Matt. 5–7) provides a concentrated scriptural articulation of the ordered triad. The declaration ‘Repent, for the kingdom of heaven is at hand’ (Matt. 4:17) supplies the theological reality within which character and action are understood. The Beatitudes (Matt. 5:3–12) describe the character of the Kingdom community before the Sermon develops its practices. N. T. Wright (2010, pp. 103–4) treats the Beatitudes as announcing a new reality and forming habits of meekness, mercy, purity, and peacemaking. In the terminology of this article, the Kingdom’s announcement grounds Orthodoxy, the Beatitudes portray Orthocompassio, and the practices of Matt. 5:21–7:12 enact Orthopraxis.
6.4. The Indicative-Imperative Resolution of the Ordo Salutis Question
The question whether Orthocompassio precedes or follows Orthopraxis is addressed through the New Testament’s indicative–imperative pattern. God’s work in Christ and by the Spirit grounds and enables faithful action. In Phil. 2:12–13, believers are commanded to work out their salvation because God is at work in them. The ordering is therefore theological rather than chronological. As a qualified counter-perspective, Zizioulas (1985) understands knowledge of God as participatory and relational rather than merely as prior intellectual possession; this complicates a simple linear sequence from right knowing to right being. The attempt should therefore be read as an account of Evangelical grounding and reciprocal formation, not as a universal epistemological hierarchy. The sequence may be entered from different points in lived experience. A work of mercy can awaken a question about truth, while a doctrinal confession can expose the inadequacy of an unmerciful practice. What remains ordered is the theological relation to God’s grace, not the timing of every human response.
7. Implications for Christian Formation and South African Evangelical Witness
7.1. The Triad and the Apartheid Church’s Theological Failure
De Gruchy (2002) documents how sections of the Dutch Reformed Church deformed doctrines of creation, covenant, and church in the service of apartheid’s racial ideology. This distorted Orthodoxy formed disordered loves organised around racial identity and generated oppressive practice. South African Christianity therefore offers a sobering case of a fractured triad, confirming Augustine’s diagnosis that cupiditas, or disordered love, produces disordered social relations.
De Gruchy’s (2002, p. 102) work on reconciliation demonstrates the converse: a recovered doctrine of divine reconciliation in Christ generates the character of a reconciled community and issues in truth-telling, restorative justice, and social transformation. The South African context confirms that the triad cannot be treated as optional: the price of a fractured triad is inscribed in the history of theological complicity with injustice.
7.2. Ubuntu, Caritas, and Orthocompassio in the South African Context
The African concept of ubuntu, often expressed as umuntu ngumuntu ngabantu, offers a South African resonance with Orthocompassio. Tutu (1999, p. 31) presents ubuntu as relational personhood marked by belonging and mutuality. Forster (2010, pp. 243–53) develops an African relational ontology while also protecting responsible personal identity. Ubuntu therefore contributes more than communal sentiment: it provides a moral account of persons constituted through relations yet accountable for the quality of those relations.
Vorster (2011, p. 13) grounds relational anthropology in the imago Dei. Magezi and Khlopa (2021, pp. 11–14, 24–25) retrieve ubuntu’s normative emphases on interdependence, hospitality, and neighbourliness while arguing that Christian ethical use requires critical transformation rather than romanticisation. Samuel (2023, pp. 143–59) likewise treats ubuntu as a practice-oriented virtue ethic rather than an abstract slogan. These accounts support an ubuntu-shaped Orthocompassio that is relational, hospitable, and publicly responsible.
Augustinian caritas and ubuntu should therefore be placed in critical conversation rather than identified. Caritas names love ordered towards God as the final good; ubuntu foregrounds the communal conditions and practices through which humane personhood becomes visible. Faith supplies the Christological criterion for discernment, love takes relational and hospitable form, and hope resists both racialised exclusion and despair about communal repair.
Ubuntu shows that Orthocompassio is not a private inward state of compassion, but a socially formed way of being. If people become who they are through relationships, then the reordering of desire described through Augustine’s caritas must be evident in how a community welcomes, listens to, and takes responsibility for its members and neighbours. Ubuntu makes the article’s movement from right being to right doing concrete: hospitality, mutual care, and neighbourliness are not optional applications added after formation, but practices through which compassionate character is cultivated and recognised (Forster 2010, pp. 243–53; Magezi and Khlopa 2021, pp. 11–14, 24–25; Samuel 2023, pp. 143–59).
Ubuntu therefore strengthens this triad ordering. Orthodoxy confesses a God who reconciles in Christ; Orthocompassio forms persons to perceive others as neighbours rather than rivals or seen in racial categories; Orthopraxis embodies that confession and character in accountable practices of inclusion, hospitality, and reconciliation. The theological virtues frame these links as follows: faith receives and discerns the gospel, love assumes communal form, and hope sustains action when reconciliation is costly or incomplete. Ubuntu therefore helps assess whether Christian doctrine and formation produce just relationships, while caritas supplies a distinct theological orientation towards God as the final good. Their critical conversation resists both individualistic piety and the romanticisation of community.
7.3. Orthopraxis and the Prophetic Witness
Allan Boesak’s Black theology represents Orthopraxis rooted in doctrinal conviction and solidarity with those who suffer. Boesak (2014, p. 139) describes Christian hope as ‘too subversive of politics’ whenever political power is treated as the final horizon of possibility. Such hope is neither optimism nor evasion: it trusts the God of resurrection, sustains resistance when outcomes are delayed, and enacts the scriptural promise that God ‘fills the hungry with good things’ (Lk. 1:53).
7.4. The Prosperity Gospel as Cupiditas and the Triad’s Diagnostic Power
Prosperity-gospel movements pose an acute challenge to South African Evangelical witness. In the terms of this article, prosperity teaching can distort all three dimensions: it can replace the gospel of grace with a transactional theology; form self-directed desire for wealth, health and status; and produce an individualised practice with little purchase on structural injustice. Mashau and Kgatle’s (2019) Ubuntu-centred alternative exposes the culture of greed and offers a relational, communal and practically oriented counter-vision.
The triad’s diagnostic force lies in the integration of faithful confession, compassionate character, and hopeful engagement. Kok (2025, pp. 1–9) develops missional leadership from vulnerability and love. Read with Mashau and Kgatle’s (2019, pp. 1–8) critique, this suggests that credible witness requires communities whose doctrine disciplines desire, whose love refuses exploitative practices, and whose hope sustains accountable public action.
7.5. Theological Education and Integrated Formation
Theological education should integrate the triad and the theological virtues across curriculum, worship, mentoring, and public practice. Doctrinal formation (Orthodoxy) should cultivate informed faith rather than information alone. Spiritual formation (Orthocompassio) should cultivate love through prayer, friendship, self-examination, hospitality, and service. Missional formation (Orthopraxis) should cultivate hope through sustained engagement with congregations and communities, especially where justice and reconciliation require perseverance. Assessment should therefore attend to theological judgement, character, and responsible practice without pretending that an institution can manufacture infused virtue.
8. Conclusions
This article has argued that Orthodoxy, Orthocompassio, and Orthopraxis form an ordered yet reciprocal grammar of Christian existence. Faith receives and confesses the gospel; love gives Christian being its God- and neighbour-directed form; and hope renders practice anticipatory of God’s promised future. These are dominant correspondences rather than exclusive allocations, because each theological virtue informs the whole life of believing, being, and doing. Therefore, this ordering is normative and pedagogical rather than linear. Orthodoxy can be deepened through praxis, and praxis can be corrected by doctrine, because both are continually reformed by divine caritas.
The Aristotle–Augustine relation is one of asymmetrical retrieval. Aristotle offers indispensable descriptions of habituated character, friendship, practical wisdom, political formation, and contemplation. Augustine relocates these within sin, grace, ordered love, ecclesial pilgrimage, and beatitude in God. Aquinas and contemporary accounts of infused virtue clarify that faith, hope, and love do not erase acquired capacities; they heal, elevate, and direct them towards communion with God. This asymmetry also explains the choice of Aristotle rather than Plato. Plato remains part of Augustine’s background, but Aristotle offers the more exact account of habituation and practical judgement required for this paper’s constructive question.
The Trinitarian framework remains deliberately limited. The Son’s mission supplies a Christological emphasis for Orthodoxy; the Spirit’s indwelling mission supplies a pneumatological emphasis for Orthocompassio; and the Father’s sending relation provides one emphasis for missional Orthopraxis. Yet every work of revelation, sanctification, and mission is the inseparable work of Father, Son, and Spirit. The appropriations illuminate the triad only when they remain subordinate to this inseparability.
Augustine’s (1961, I.1.1) restless heart remains the theological heartbeat of the proposal. Authentic confession, love, and action arise from the God who addresses, transforms, and sends the church. In the South African context, ubuntu’s relational ethics, critically transformed through the gospel, gives this claim communal and public texture. The church that believes faithfully, loves rightly, and acts hopefully is a people drawn into the indivisible mission of the Triune God.
Funding
This research received no external funding.
Institutional Review Board Statement
Not applicable.
Informed Consent Statement
Not applicable.
Data Availability Statement
No new data were created or analyzed in this study. Data sharing is not applicable to this article.
Conflicts of Interest
The author declares no conflict of interest.
References
- Aquinas, Thomas. 1948. Summa Theologica. Translated by the Fathers of the English Dominican Province. 3 vols, New York: Benziger Brothers. [Google Scholar]
- Aristotle. 1998. Politics. Translated by C. D. C. Reeve. Indianapolis: Hackett. [Google Scholar]
- Aristotle. 1999. Nicomachean Ethics, 2nd ed. Translated by Terence Irwin. Indianapolis: Hackett. [Google Scholar]
- Augustine. 1961. Confessions. Translated by R. S. Pine-Coffin. London: Penguin Classics. [Google Scholar]
- Augustine. 1997. On Christian Doctrine. Translated by D. W. Robertson, Jr.. Hoboken: Prentice Hall. [Google Scholar]
- Augustine. 2002. The Trinity. Translated by Edmund Hill. Hyde Park: New City Press. [Google Scholar]
- Augustine. 2003. Concerning the City of God Against the Pagans. Translated by Henry Bettenson. London: Penguin Classics. [Google Scholar]
- Augustine. 2008. Homilies on the First Epistle of John. Translated by Boniface Ramsey. Hyde Park: New City Press. [Google Scholar]
- Ayres, Lewis. 2010. Augustine and the Trinity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Baleng, Godfrey T. 2024. Mimetic Desire in Augustine’s Confessiones as a Model for Natural Theology and Virtue Ethics. In die Skriflig/In Luce Verbi 58. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Boersma, Hans. 2009. Nouvelle Théologie and Sacramental Ontology: A Return to Mystery. Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Boersma, Hans. 2011. Heavenly Participation: The Weaving of a Sacramental Tapestry. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans. [Google Scholar]
- Boesak, Allan Aubrey. 2014. Dare We Speak of Hope? Searching for a Language of Life in Faith and Politics. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans. [Google Scholar]
- Bosch, David J. 1991. Transforming Mission: Paradigm Shifts in Theology of Mission. Maryknoll: Orbis Books. [Google Scholar]
- Calvin, John. 1960. Institutes of the Christian Religion. Edited by John T. McNeill. Translated by Ford Lewis Battles. 2 vols, Philadelphia: Westminster Press. [Google Scholar]
- De Gruchy, John W. 2002. Reconciliation: Restoring Justice. London: SCM Press. [Google Scholar]
- DeYoung, Rebecca Konyndyk. 2021. Practicing Hope. In Faith and Virtue Formation. Edited by Adam C. Pelser and W. Scott Cleveland. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 166–90. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Emery, Gilles. 2007. The Trinitarian Theology of Saint Thomas Aquinas. Translated by Francesca Aran Murphy. Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Forster, Dion A. 2010. African Relational Ontology, Individual Identity, and Christian Theology. Theology 113: 243–53. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Gregory, Eric. 2008. Politics and the Order of Love: An Augustinian Ethic of Democratic Citizenship. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. [Google Scholar]
- Grenz, Stanley J. 1994. Theology for the Community of God. Nashville: Broadman & Holman. [Google Scholar]
- Gutiérrez, Gustavo. 1988. A Theology of Liberation: History, Politics and Salvation. Translated by Caridad Inda, and John Eagleson. Maryknoll: Orbis Books. [Google Scholar]
- Knobel, Angela. 2021. An Instinct for the Divine: Faith and the Formation of Infused Virtue. In Faith and Virtue Formation. Edited by Adam C. Pelser and W. Scott Cleveland. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 149–65. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Kok, Jacobus. 2025. Missional Leadership from an Ethos of Vulnerability and Love. Verbum et Ecclesia 46. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Land, Steven J. 1993. Pentecostal Spirituality: A Passion for the Kingdom. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press. [Google Scholar]
- Louw, Daniël J. 2016. ‘Missio Dei’ as Embodiment of ‘Passio Dei’: The Role of God-Images in the Mission-Outreach and Pastoral Caregiving of the Church—A Hermeneutical Approach. Missionalia 44: 336–54. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit][Green Version]
- Luther, Martin. 1957. Heidelberg Disputation. In Luther’s Works, Career of the Reformer I. Edited by Harold J. Grimm. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, vol. 31, pp. 39–70. First published 1518. [Google Scholar]
- MacIntyre, Alasdair. 1981. After Virtue. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press. [Google Scholar]
- Magezi, Vhumani, and Clement Khlopa. 2021. The Tenet of Ubuntu in South (African) Ethics: Inclusive Hospitality and Christian Ethical Disposition of Effective Pastoral Care in Africa. Stellenbosch Theological Journal 7: 1–32. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Mashau, Thinandavha D., and Mookgo S. Kgatle. 2019. Prosperity Gospel and the Culture of Greed in Post-Colonial Africa: Constructing an Alternative African Christian Theology of Ubuntu. Verbum et Ecclesia 40. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- O’Donovan, Oliver. 1980. The Problem of Self-Love in St. Augustine. New Haven: Yale University Press. [Google Scholar]
- Pelser, Adam C. 2021. Cultivating Christian Love. In Faith and Virtue Formation. Edited by Adam C. Pelser and W. Scott Cleveland. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 191–210. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Pieper, Josef. 1966. The Four Cardinal Virtues. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press. [Google Scholar]
- Samuel, Olusegun Steven. 2023. Practicing Ubuntu. The Philosophical Forum 54: 143–59. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Smith, James K. A. 2009. Desiring the Kingdom: Worship, Worldview, and Cultural Formation. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic. [Google Scholar]
- Smith, James K. A. 2016. You Are What You Love: The Spiritual Power of Habit. Grand Rapids: Brazos Press. [Google Scholar]
- Trementozzi, David. 2018. Salvation in the Flesh: Understanding How Embodiment Shapes Christian Faith. McMaster Theological Studies Series 7; Eugene: Pickwick. [Google Scholar]
- Tutu, Desmond. 1999. No Future Without Forgiveness. New York: Doubleday. [Google Scholar]
- Vanhoozer, Kevin J. 2005. The Drama of Doctrine: A Canonical-Linguistic Approach to Christian Theology. Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press. [Google Scholar]
- Vanhoozer, Kevin J. 2014. Faith Speaking Understanding: Performing the Drama of Doctrine. Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press. [Google Scholar]
- Vidu, Adonis. 2021. The Same God Who Works All Things: Inseparable Operations in Trinitarian Theology. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans. [Google Scholar]
- Volf, Miroslav. 1998. After Our Likeness: The Church as the Image of the Trinity. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans. [Google Scholar]
- Vorster, Nico. 2011. Created in the Image of God: Understanding God’s Relationship with Humanity. Eugene: Pickwick. [Google Scholar]
- Woodbridge, Noel B. 2010. Living Theologically—Towards a Theology of Christian Practice in Terms of the Theological Triad of Orthodoxy, Orthopraxy and Orthopathy as Portrayed in Isaiah 6:1–8: A Narrative Approach. HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies 66. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Wright, Christopher J. H. 2006. The Mission of God: Unlocking the Bible’s Grand Narrative. Downers Grove: IVP Academic. [Google Scholar]
- Wright, Nicholas T. 1992. The New Testament and the People of God. London: SPCK. [Google Scholar]
- Wright, Nicholas T. 2010. After You Believe: Why Christian Character Matters. New York: HarperOne. [Google Scholar]
- Yeago, David S. 1998. Martin Luther on Grace, Law, and Moral Life: Prolegomena to an Ecumenical Discussion of Veritatis Splendor. The Thomist 62: 163–91. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Zizioulas, John D. 1985. Being as Communion: Studies in Personhood and the Church. Crestwood: St Vladimir’s Seminary Press. [Google Scholar]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the author. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.