Review Reports
- Aleksandar Rajkovic 1,
- Amador GarcĂa-Ramos 2,3,* and
- Dragan M. Mirkov 1
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Heidar Sajedi
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors- The manuscript defines bilateral deficit (BD) methodologically as the ratio between bilateral force and the summed unilateral forces. However, it remains unclear whether higher BD values reflect better or worse neuromuscular performance. In addition, the manuscript does not specify what magnitude of BD should be considered practically meaningful. Providing additional relevant literature and a clearer conceptual explanation would greatly improve interpretability.
- In the Results section (p.5), BD is described as “higher” in the seated position; however, this corresponds to lower ratio values (i.e., a greater deficit). This wording may confuse readers. Clarifying the direction of interpretation (e.g., lower ratio = greater deficit) would improve clarity.
- It would be helpful to include a short paragraph clarifying whether a greater BD is desirable or undesirable in sport and performance contexts. Additionally, briefly explaining how BD relates to performance outcomes (e.g., sprinting, change of direction, injury risk) would strengthen the applied relevance. Including a short explanatory equation in the Methods section may also enhance transparency. Without these clarifications, interpretation of the findings remains somewhat ambiguous.
- The reported mean height of 179 ± 10 cm for a mixed sample of 10 males and 10 females (p.2) appears unusually high. Given the equal sex distribution, this value suggests either an exceptionally tall female subgroup or a possible reporting issue. It would be helpful to report height separately for males and females and to clarify the recruitment population (e.g., sport science students, trained athletes, volleyball players, etc.). If the value is correct, a brief justification would prevent readers from questioning sampling accuracy.
- The sampling method requires further clarification. The manuscript states that “twenty physically active, healthy young subjects volunteered,” but does not specify the recruitment strategy (e.g., convenience sample, university cohort, local athletes). Given that BD may be influenced by training background—particularly unilateral versus bilateral training exposure—additional information is important. Please clarify recruitment source, inclusion criteria (e.g., minimum weekly activity level), sport background (if applicable), and whether leg dominance was recorded and analyzed. These details are necessary to assess external validity.
- Please clarify whether participants received any form of incentive for participation. If so, it would be helpful to describe how the incentive was managed to ensure ethical appropriateness.
- The Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval is mentioned, but please ensure that the official reference or approval number is clearly reported.
- The study design describes one familiarization session and three experimental sessions, with at least 48 hours between sessions. Given this structure, it appears that each participant required at least one week to complete the protocol. However, the timeline is not fully clear. Additional clarification would be helpful regarding: Whether all participants completed testing within the same timeframe, How the eight testing conditions were distributed across sessions, The total duration of each session, Whether unilateral and bilateral trials were performed consecutively, and Whether participants were tested individually or simultaneously. Considering the high contraction volume (nine contractions per condition across multiple conditions), fatigue management is an important methodological consideration.
- Please specify the approximate duration of each experimental session.
- Clarify whether participants performed the experiments individually or in group settings.
- To enhance methodological transparency, it is recommended to provide a schematic timeline figure illustrating the sequence of sessions and testing conditions. Please also clarify: Total time per session, Total study duration per participant, Whether session procedures were standardized across participants, The order of unilateral versus bilateral testing. Such additions would significantly improve clarity and reproducibility.
- In the Results section, adding a summary table may help readers more easily grasp the key findings.
- Although Table 1 presents unilateral and bilateral values, the BD values themselves are not tabulated and are only displayed in Figure 2. It would improve readability and reproducibility to provide a table summarizing BD (mean ± SD), along with main effects, interaction effects, and effect sizes.
- The Discussion section would benefit from subheadings to improve organization and readability. Currently, it is presented as one continuous section. Structuring it with subheadings such as “Position Effects on BD,” “Angle Effects on BD,” “Neuromechanical Mechanisms,” “Practical Implications,” and “Limitations and Future Research” would make the argument clearer and easier to follow.
- The Discussion primarily emphasizes conditions with the highest BD (e.g., seated position). A more balanced interpretation would also consider conditions with the lowest BD. Specifically, it would be helpful to discuss why prone and supine positions showed lower deficits, whether these conditions may better reflect “true” neuromuscular capacity, and whether bilateral facilitation occurred in any condition. Addressing these points would provide a more comprehensive interpretation.
- Overall, this is a strong and well-designed experimental study. Nevertheless, improvements in conceptual clarity, sampling transparency, procedural detail, and balance in the Discussion would further strengthen the manuscript.
- Overall Recommendation: Major Revision Recommended
This manuscript examines a relevant and well-designed study on position- and angle-specific effects on bilateral deficit (BD) in hamstring isometric strength, with clear methodological and applied value. The analyses are appropriate and the findings are potentially meaningful for performance and rehabilitation contexts. However, several key issues require clarification. First, greater conceptual clarity is needed regarding the interpretation of BD—specifically whether higher or lower values reflect better performance and what magnitude is practically meaningful. This ambiguity affects interpretation of the Results and Discussion.
Second, methodological transparency must be improved. The sampling method, participant characteristics (including the unusually high mean height), recruitment source, training background, and leg dominance are insufficiently described. Additional detail regarding the experimental timeline, session structure, fatigue management, and testing procedures is also necessary. A schematic timeline figure would enhance clarity.
Finally, results presentation and discussion structure could be strengthened, including tabulation of BD values and a more balanced interpretation across conditions. Overall, the study has strong potential, but revisions are needed to improve conceptual clarity, methodological transparency, and interpretative balance before publication.
Author Response
Response to Reviewers
Manuscript: “Position- and Angle-Specific Variation of the Bilateral Deficit in Hamstring Isometric Strength: A Comparative Analysis”
Journal: Applied Sciences (MDPI)
We sincerely appreciate the constructive feedback provided by the Academic Editor and both reviewers. In response, we have revised the manuscript as follows: (i) clarified the definition and interpretation of BD ratios and included an explicit equation; (ii) corrected and expanded participant information (n = 30, 15 males and 15 females), with added sex-specific anthropometric and recruitment details; (iii) improved procedural transparency by including a schematic session timeline (new Figure 2) and providing further details on fatigue management; (iv) added a new summary Table 2 presenting BD ratios and model main effects/interactions; and (v) reorganized and strengthened the Discussion with subheadings and a more balanced interpretation across conditions.
Additional clarification to the Editor (optional): During revision, we identified and corrected a typographical error in the participant number/sex distribution in the originally submitted manuscript. The correct sample was n = 30 (15 males, 15 females). This correction has been implemented consistently throughout the manuscript.
Reviewer 1
R1.1
Comment:
The manuscript defines bilateral deficit (BD) methodologically as the ratio between bilateral force and the summed unilateral forces. However, it remains unclear whether higher BD values reflect better or worse neuromuscular performance. In addition, the manuscript does not specify what magnitude of BD should be considered practically meaningful. Providing additional relevant literature and a clearer conceptual explanation would greatly improve interpretability.
Response:
Thank you for highlighting the need for a clearer interpretation of BD ratios. We've now made it more explicit that a lower ratio indicates a greater bilateral deficit. Since there isn’t a universally accepted threshold for what counts as a “meaningful” BD, we focus on comparing conditions and include effect sizes to help with interpretation.
Changes made:
- Introduction: added a short interpretive paragraph defining BD ratio direction and context.
- Methods (Section 2.3): added an explicit BD equation and clarified interpretation (deficit vs facilitation).
- Results/Discussion: ensured consistent wording and referenced effect sizes (Table 2, Panel B).
Added/modified text (copy-paste):
“Bilateral deficit (BD) was quantified as a ratio: BD ratio = F_bilateral / (F_unilateral_left + F_unilateral_right) … Values < 1 indicate a bilateral deficit, values > 1 indicate bilateral facilitation, and values closer to 1 indicate a smaller deficit.”
“In the present manuscript, BD is expressed as a ratio … values < 1 indicate a bilateral deficit … Because … there is no single universally accepted threshold, we focus on between-condition comparisons and report effect sizes …”
R1.2
Comment:
In the Results section (p.5), BD is described as “higher” in the seated position; however, this corresponds to lower ratio values (i.e., a greater deficit). This wording may confuse readers. Clarifying the direction of interpretation (e.g., lower ratio = greater deficit) would improve clarity.
Response:
Thank you for bringing up this possible confusion. We've updated the manuscript to avoid describing BD as “higher” when the ratio values are actually lower. Throughout, we now use language like “greater bilateral deficit (lower BD ratio)” for clarity.
Changes made:
- Abstract and Results: replaced ambiguous wording with “greater bilateral deficit (lower BD ratios)” and added clarifying phrasing.
R1.3
Comment:
It would be helpful to include a short paragraph clarifying whether a greater BD is desirable or undesirable in sport and performance contexts. Additionally, briefly explaining how BD relates to performance outcomes (e.g., sprinting, change of direction, injury risk) would strengthen the applied relevance. Including a short explanatory equation in the Methods section may also enhance transparency. Without these clarifications, interpretation of the findings remains somewhat ambiguous.
Response:
Thank you for making this suggestion. We added a short paragraph explaining that a greater BD isn’t always “good” or “bad”—it really depends on the specific sport or activity. We also included the requested equation in the Methods section.
Changes made:
- Introduction: added an applied-interpretation paragraph on BD.
- Methods (Section 2.3): added the BD equation and interpretation.
R1.4
Comment:
The reported mean height of 179 ± 10 cm for a mixed sample of 10 males and 10 females (p.2) appears unusually high. Given the equal sex distribution, this value suggests either an exceptionally tall female subgroup or a possible reporting issue. It would be helpful to report height separately for males and females and to clarify the recruitment population (e.g., sport science students, trained athletes, volleyball players, etc.). If the value is correct, a brief justification would prevent readers from questioning sampling accuracy.
Response:
We appreciate the reviewer’s careful attention to this detail. The participant number and sex distribution were reported incorrectly in the original submission. The correct sample included 30 physically active participants (15 males, 15 females), and all analyses were performed on the full dataset. The error was only present in the written description. We have now corrected this in all relevant sections and added sex-specific anthropometric details to clarify the overall mean height.
Changes made:
- Abstract: corrected sample size/sex distribution.
- Methods (Section 2.1 Participants): corrected sample size/sex distribution and added sex-specific age/height values.
- Methods (Section 2.1): clarified recruitment population (sport science students).
Added/modified text (copy-paste):
“Participant characteristics (mean ± SD) were: males—age 24.2 ± 3.1 years, height 187.6 ± 6.3 cm; females—age 23.1 ± 2.0 years, height 170.8 ± 6.8 cm; total sample—age 23.7 ± 2.6 years, height 179.2 ± 10.7 cm, body mass 75 ± 14 kg.”
R1.5
Comment:
The sampling method requires further clarification. The manuscript states that “twenty physically active, healthy young subjects volunteered,” but does not specify the recruitment strategy (e.g., convenience sample, university cohort, local athletes). Given that BD may be influenced by training background—particularly unilateral versus bilateral training exposure—additional information is important. Please clarify recruitment source, inclusion criteria (e.g., minimum weekly activity level), sport background (if applicable), and whether leg dominance was recorded and analyzed. These details are necessary to assess external validity.
Response:
We agree that clarification was necessary. We have expanded the Participants section to specify the recruitment source, inclusion and exclusion criteria, and how leg dominance was recorded. We also acknowledge that we did not examine training-history variables as potential moderators and have noted this as a limitation and direction for future research.
Changes made:
- Methods (Section 2.1 Participants): added recruitment source, IPAQ-based physical-activity criterion, injury exclusion, and leg dominance recording.
- Discussion (Limitations): added statement that training-history variables were not examined as moderators.
R1.6
Comment:
Please clarify whether participants received any form of incentive for participation. If so, it would be helpful to describe how the incentive was managed to ensure ethical appropriateness.
Response:
To address this point, we added an explicit statement to the manuscript confirming that participants did not receive any financial or other incentives for their participation.
Changes made:
- Methods (Section 2.1 Participants): added “No financial or other incentives were provided.”
R1.7
Comment:
The Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval is mentioned, but please ensure that the official reference or approval number is clearly reported.
Response:
We have confirmed that the formal IRB approval number and date are now reported clearly in the Participants section and remain included in the IRB Statement.
Changes made:
- Methods (Section 2.1 Participants): added approval No. 02-993/23-1 and date.
R1.8
Comment:
The study design describes one familiarization session and three experimental sessions, with at least 48 hours between sessions. Given this structure, it appears that each participant required at least one week to complete the protocol. However, the timeline is not fully clear. Additional clarification would be helpful regarding: Whether all participants completed testing within the same timeframe, How the eight testing conditions were distributed across sessions, The total duration of each session, Whether unilateral and bilateral trials were performed consecutively, and Whether participants were tested individually or simultaneously. Considering the high contraction volume (nine contractions per condition across multiple conditions), fatigue management is an important methodological consideration.
Response:
We appreciate the reviewer’s suggestion and recognize that the timeline and session structure required greater clarity. We have expanded Section 2.2 to specify the overall participant timeline (approximately one week), how the eight conditions were distributed across sessions, the duration of each session, the randomization of unilateral and bilateral efforts, the individual testing procedures, and the rest intervals used to manage fatigue. Additionally, we have added a schematic timeline (new Figure 2).
Changes made:
- Methods (Section 2.2): expanded session distribution across days and clarified that participants were tested individually.
- Methods (Section 2.2): added approximate duration of sessions (~80 min for 2-test; ~130 min for 3-test).
- Methods (Section 2.2): clarified within-condition randomization of unilateral/bilateral efforts and increased rest detail (2 min between contractions).
- Methods: added new Figure 2 (schematic timeline).
R1.9
Comment:
Please specify the approximate duration of each experimental session.
Response:
We addressed this point by expanding Section 2.2 and adding a new Figure 2, where session durations are now stated explicitly.
Changes made:
- Methods (Section 2.2): session durations added; Figure 2 added.
R1.10
Comment:
Clarify whether participants performed the experiments individually or in group settings.
Response:
We have clarified that all participants were tested individually.
Changes made:
- Methods (Section 2.2): added “Participants were tested individually.”
R1.11
Comment:
To enhance methodological transparency, it is recommended to provide a schematic timeline figure illustrating the sequence of sessions and testing conditions. Please also clarify: Total time per session, Total study duration per participant, Whether session procedures were standardized across participants, The order of unilateral versus bilateral testing. Such additions would significantly improve clarity and reproducibility.
Response:
To provide greater clarity, we have added a schematic timeline figure that summarizes the sequence of activities and the distribution of tests across sessions (presented as new Figure 2).
Changes made:
- Methods: added Figure 2 and referenced it in Section 2.2.
R1.12
Comment:
In the Results section, adding a summary table may help readers more easily grasp the key findings.
Response:
We agree with the reviewer that a summary table would improve readability. We have therefore added Table 2, which summarizes BD ratios for all position × angle conditions (Panel A) and presents the main effects, interactions, and effect sizes from the linear mixed-model analysis (Panel B).
Changes made:
- Results: added Table 2 immediately after Table 1 and updated Results text to reference Table 2.
R1.13
Comment:
Although Table 1 presents unilateral and bilateral values, the BD values themselves are not tabulated and are only displayed in Figure 2. It would improve readability and reproducibility to provide a table summarizing BD (mean ± SD), along with main effects, interaction effects, and effect sizes.
Response:
We appreciate this point and have addressed it by adding Table 2. This table includes (i) BD ratios (mean (SD)) for each condition (Panel A) and (ii) the main effects, interaction effects, and effect sizes (partial η²) from the linear mixed-model analysis (Panel B).
Changes made:
- Results: added Table 2 and updated narrative accordingly.
R1.14
Comment:
The Discussion section would benefit from subheadings to improve organization and readability. Currently, it is presented as one continuous section. Structuring it with subheadings such as “Position Effects on BD,” “Angle Effects on BD,” “Neuromechanical Mechanisms,” “Practical Implications,” and “Limitations and Future Research” would make the argument clearer and easier to follow.
Response:
We agree that this section needed clarification, and we have reorganized the Discussion using subheadings to improve its structure and readability.
Changes made:
- Discussion: added subheadings (Position Effects; Angle Effects; Potential Mechanisms; Practical Implications; Limitations/Future Research).
R1.15
Comment:
The Discussion primarily emphasizes conditions with the highest BD (e.g., seated position). A more balanced interpretation would also consider conditions with the lowest BD. Specifically, it would be helpful to discuss why prone and supine positions showed lower deficits, whether these conditions may better reflect “true” neuromuscular capacity, and whether bilateral facilitation occurred in any condition. Addressing these points would provide a more comprehensive interpretation.
Response:
We appreciate the reviewer’s suggestion and have expanded the Discussion to address conditions with the smallest deficits (prone and supine). We also clarified that none of the tested conditions showed clear bilateral facilitation (BD ratio > 1.00).
Changes made:
- Discussion: added a balanced interpretation addressing both larger- and smaller-deficit conditions and explicitly noted facilitation was not observed.
R1.16
Comment:
Overall, this is a strong and well-designed experimental study. Nevertheless, improvements in conceptual clarity, sampling transparency, procedural detail, and balance in the Discussion would further strengthen the manuscript.
Response:
We thank the reviewer for the positive overall evaluation. In response to your feedback, we made targeted revisions to strengthen the manuscript’s clarity and transparency. Specifically: (i) we clarified the BD ratio definition, direction of interpretation, and practical context (R1.1–R1.3; Introduction; Methods Section 2.3); (ii) we corrected and expanded participant reporting, including sex-specific anthropometrics, recruitment source, inclusion criteria, and leg dominance (R1.4–R1.6; Methods Section 2.1); (iii) we expanded procedural detail and added a schematic session timeline (Figure 2) to clarify session structure and fatigue-management procedures (R1.7–R1.10; Methods Section 2.2); and (iv) we improved results presentation and the balance of the discussion (Table 2; Discussion subheadings; R1.11–R1.15).
Changes made:
- Introduction and Methods (Section 2.3): clarified BD ratio interpretation and added BD equation (R1.1–R1.3).
- Methods (Section 2.1): corrected sample description (n = 30; 15/15) and expanded participant details (R1.4–R1.6).
- Methods (Section 2.2) + Figure 2: expanded session timeline, rest, and fatigue-management details (R1.7–R1.10).
- Results/Table 2 + Discussion: strengthened tabulation, effect sizes, and interpretive balance (R1.11–R1.15).
R1.17
Comment:
Overall Recommendation: Major Revision Recommended
Response:
We appreciate the recommendation and have addressed the major revision points throughout the manuscript. The main changes align with the reviewer’s summary in R1.18–R1.20 and include clarifying BD interpretation and adding the BD equation, correcting and expanding participant reporting, adding the schematic session timeline (Figure 2), and strengthening both the results tabulation (Table 2) and the discussion balance.
Changes made:
- See consolidated revisions described in R1.16 and detailed responses to R1.1–R1.15.
R1.18
Comment:
This manuscript examines a relevant and well-designed study on position- and angle-specific effects on bilateral deficit (BD) in hamstring isometric strength, with clear methodological and applied value. The analyses are appropriate and the findings are potentially meaningful for performance and rehabilitation contexts. However, several key issues require clarification. First, greater conceptual clarity is needed regarding the interpretation of BD—specifically whether higher or lower values reflect better performance and what magnitude is practically meaningful. This ambiguity affects interpretation of the Results and Discussion.
Response:
We thank the reviewer for summarizing the main conceptual issue so clearly. To remove ambiguity, we now explicitly state how to interpret BD ratios (lower ratio = greater bilateral deficit; values > 1 indicate facilitation) and note that there is no single universally accepted threshold across tasks and populations. We also added the BD equation and have aligned all Results/Discussion wording accordingly.
Changes made:
- Introduction: clarified BD interpretation and practical context.
- Methods (Section 2.3): added BD equation and explicit deficit/facilitation interpretation.
- Results/Discussion: aligned wording with BD ratio direction and referenced effect sizes (Table 2).
R1.19
Comment:
Second, methodological transparency must be improved. The sampling method, participant characteristics (including the unusually high mean height), recruitment source, training background, and leg dominance are insufficiently described. Additional detail regarding the experimental timeline, session structure, fatigue management, and testing procedures is also necessary. A schematic timeline figure would enhance clarity.
Response:
We appreciate this thorough summary of methodological points. In response, we expanded the Participants section to detail the recruitment source, inclusion and exclusion criteria, sex-specific anthropometrics, and leg dominance. We also clarified the experimental timeline, session structure, rest intervals, and fatigue-management procedures. Additionally, we included a schematic timeline (Figure 2) to clearly show how testing conditions were distributed across sessions.
Changes made:
- Methods (Section 2.1): corrected/expanded participant characteristics, recruitment, criteria, and leg dominance.
- Methods (Section 2.2): expanded timeline, session structure, and fatigue-management details.
- Figure 2: added schematic session timeline showing distribution of testing conditions.
R1.20
Comment:
Finally, results presentation and discussion structure could be strengthened, including tabulation of BD values and a more balanced interpretation across conditions. Overall, the study has strong potential, but revisions are needed to improve conceptual clarity, methodological transparency, and interpretative balance before publication.
Response:
We thank the reviewer for summarizing the key areas for improvement. In response, we revised the Results section by adding Table 2 (BD ratios and model effects/effect sizes) and reorganized the Discussion with subheadings to ensure a balanced interpretation of both larger- and smaller-deficit conditions. We also refined our terminology so that BD magnitude is described consistently in terms of BD ratio direction.
Changes made:
- Results: added Table 2 summarizing BD ratios and model effects/effect sizes.
- Discussion: reorganized with subheadings and added a more balanced interpretation across conditions.
- Throughout: tightened terminology to consistently interpret BD in terms of BD ratio direction.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsIntroduction
Lines 15–23
The section on the Nordic Hamstring Exercise is detailed, but its direct link to the main aim of the study is not entirely clear. Is this discussion meant to justify the preference for isometric testing in the context of bilateral deficit? If so, could this connection be stated more directly?
Lines 24–33
Bilateral deficit is explained together with possible neural mechanisms such as interhemispheric inhibition. Since your study does not directly measure neural activity, should these mechanisms be presented more cautiously as theoretical background rather than implied explanatory factors?
Lines 34–44
You say it's unknown how body position and joint angle affect bilateral deficit. Has this question been the subject of any prior research? If so, what were the primary methodological limitations of those studies? A succinct description of this would strengthen the case for the research gap.
Lines 45–58
Greater bilateral deficits in the seated posture, particularly at extended joint angles, are predicted by the hypothesis. What particular empirical data supports this expectation? Could you elaborate on whether this is primarily based on theoretical reasoning or is backed up by existing data?
Methods
Participants in Section 2.1
There is no explanation given for the sample size, which consists of 20 people (10 males and 10 females). To ascertain whether this sample size is adequate to identify significant variations in bilateral deficit across conditions, was an a priori power analysis performed? Section 2.2: Experimental Protocol and Study Design
Over several sessions and positions, participants executed a very high number of maximum contractions. Is there proof that performance held steady during sessions, and how was cumulative fatigue tracked or managed outside of the scheduled rest periods?
Section 2.3 Data Collection and Analysis
The point at which the derivative surpassed 5% of the maximal derivative value was referred to as the force onset. Could you elaborate on the reasoning behind choosing this particular criterion and whether this approach has been proven to be reliable or consistently applied in earlier research?
Section 2.4 Statistical Analysis
Linear mixed models were used with repeated measures for position and joint angle. Given the equal number of male and female participants and the established strength variations related to sex, was sex taken into consideration as a potential covariate or interaction factor in the analysis?
Results
Table 1: Characteristic statistics
Although the bilateral values in Table 1 are consistently less than the total of the unilateral values, the table does not display the real bilateral deficit ratios. Would it be easier for the reader to understand the size of the differences if the estimated BD values were also displayed immediately in the table?
Paragraph starting “A linear mixed-model analysis revealed…” (Fmax results)
Particularly around 120° and 150°, the seated position is said to exhibit the greatest bilateral deficit. Could you elaborate on whether, given the indicated impact sizes, these differences are both practically meaningful and statistically significant?
(RFDmax, RFD50ms, RFD200ms) RFD variables
Although a number of noteworthy interactions have been documented, the pattern appears to be complicated across positions and angles. Would it help to briefly summarize the main practical takeaway for each RFD variable instead of listing multiple p-values?
Figure 2 description
Figure 2 is referenced for all main findings, but the text does not describe the variability or overlap between conditions. Are the differences visually clear, or is there substantial overlap between positions and angles that should be acknowledged in the results section?
Discussion
First paragraph (novelty claim)
You claim that this is the first study to methodically look at how location and tilt affect bilateral hamstring deficiency. Can you be fully certain about this claim, and have you clearly demonstrated how your study differs from previous work on bilateral deficit or hamstring testing conditions?
Paragraphs explaining mechanisms (seated position and neural factors)
The results are explained by a number of neurological mechanisms, including altered motor unit recruitment, spinal inhibition, and reflex activation. Should these hypotheses be offered more cautiously as potential interpretations rather than indicated mechanisms, given that no EMG or brain data were taken?
Section on clinical implications (seated position underestimation)
You suggest that seated testing may underestimate true maximal capacity due to exaggerated bilateral inhibition. Is this conclusion too strong based only on isometric laboratory data, and could other practical factors also influence these results?
Conclusion section
In addition to suggesting useful implications for training and rehabilitation, the finding highlights the necessity of consistent protocols. Should these recommendations be more cautiously worded to prevent overgeneralization outside the studied population, considering that the sample consisted solely of healthy young adults?
Author Response
Response to Reviewers
Manuscript: “Position- and Angle-Specific Variation of the Bilateral Deficit in Hamstring Isometric Strength: A Comparative Analysis”
Journal: Applied Sciences (MDPI)
We sincerely appreciate the constructive feedback provided by the Academic Editor and both reviewers. In response, we have revised the manuscript as follows: (i) clarified the definition and interpretation of BD ratios and included an explicit equation; (ii) corrected and expanded participant information (n = 30, 15 males and 15 females), with added sex-specific anthropometric and recruitment details; (iii) improved procedural transparency by including a schematic session timeline (new Figure 2) and providing further details on fatigue management; (iv) added a new summary Table 2 presenting BD ratios and model main effects/interactions; and (v) reorganized and strengthened the Discussion with subheadings and a more balanced interpretation across conditions.
Additional clarification to the Editor (optional): During revision, we identified and corrected a typographical error in the participant number/sex distribution in the originally submitted manuscript. The correct sample was n = 30 (15 males, 15 females). This correction has been implemented consistently throughout the manuscript.
Reviewer 2
R2.1
Comment:
Lines 15–23
The section on the Nordic Hamstring Exercise is detailed, but its direct link to the main aim of the study is not entirely clear. Is this discussion meant to justify the preference for isometric testing in the context of bilateral deficit? If so, could this connection be stated more directly?
Response:
We agree with the reviewer’s observation and have now stated the connection more directly. While retaining the NHE background, we added a sentence linking those limitations to our motivation for using controlled isometric testing to quantify BD across standardized joint configurations.
Changes made:
- Introduction (NHE paragraph): added an explicit linking sentence to the study aim.
R2.2
Comment:
Lines 24–33
Bilateral deficit is explained together with possible neural mechanisms such as interhemispheric inhibition. Since your study does not directly measure neural activity, should these mechanisms be presented more cautiously as theoretical background rather than implied explanatory factors?
Response:
We appreciate this observation. We revised the BD background and Discussion to present neural mechanisms as theoretical possibilities rather than as confirmed explanations, and we explicitly noted that neural activity (e.g., EMG) was not measured in our study.
Changes made:
- Introduction (BD paragraph): revised wording to “proposed to reflect…” and noted mechanisms were not directly measured.
- Discussion (Potential Neuromechanical Explanations; Limitations): strengthened cautious language and reiterated absence of EMG.
R2.3
Comment:
Lines 34–44
You say it's unknown how body position and joint angle affect bilateral deficit. Has this question been the subject of any prior research? If so, what were the primary methodological limitations of those studies? A succinct description of this would strengthen the case for the research gap.
Response:
To clarify, we added a brief statement in the Introduction noting that previous research has shown that position and joint configuration can influence hamstring isometric force and activation. However, the specific impact of these methodological factors on BD ratios across different conditions remains unclear, thus supporting the research gap addressed in our study.
Changes made:
- Introduction (aim paragraph): added a brief sentence clarifying prior work and the BD-specific gap.
R2.4
Comment:
Lines 45–58
Greater bilateral deficits in the seated posture, particularly at extended joint angles, are predicted by the hypothesis. What particular empirical data supports this expectation? Could you elaborate on whether this is primarily based on theoretical reasoning or is backed up by existing data?
Response:
We clarified that our hypothesis was based primarily on length–tension relationships and theoretical considerations, and we have adjusted the wording to reflect this.
Changes made:
- Introduction (hypothesis sentence): revised to emphasize theoretical basis and avoid overstatement of empirical support.
R2.5
Comment:
Participants in Section 2.1
There is no explanation given for the sample size, which consists of 20 people (10 males and 10 females). To ascertain whether this sample size is adequate to identify significant variations in bilateral deficit across conditions, was an a priori power analysis performed?
Response:
We did not perform an a priori power analysis. We have now added this as a limitation and have noted that future studies should include formal sample-size planning. If requested by the editor, we are prepared to perform and report an a priori or post hoc power analysis based on the mixed-model effects.
Changes made:
- Discussion (Limitations and Future Research): added statement that no a priori power analysis was performed.
R2.6
Comment:
Section 2.2: Experimental Protocol and Study Design
Over several sessions and positions, participants executed a very high number of maximum contractions. Is there proof that performance held steady during sessions, and how was cumulative fatigue tracked or managed outside of the scheduled rest periods?
Response:
We agree that clarification was necessary and that cumulative fatigue and session structure should be clearly described. We have expanded Section 2.2 to specify the distribution of conditions across sessions, rest intervals, within-condition randomization, and approximate session duration, and we have added a schematic timeline (new Figure 2). We did not formally quantify within-session performance decrements; if requested, we can add an analysis of within-session trends across repeated trials.
Changes made:
- Methods (Section 2.2): expanded fatigue-management details and clarified session structure.
- Methods: added Figure 2 (schematic timeline).
R2.7
Comment:
Section 2.3 Data Collection and Analysis
The point at which the derivative surpassed 5% of the maximal derivative value was referred to as the force onset. Could you elaborate on the reasoning behind choosing this particular criterion and whether this approach has been proven to be reliable or consistently applied in earlier research?
Response:
To clarify, we have added a brief rationale for using a relative (5% peak-derivative) threshold for onset detection, emphasizing that it ensures consistency across trials and reduces sensitivity to baseline noise.
Changes made:
- Methods (Section 2.3): added rationale sentence for the force-onset criterion.
R2.8
Comment:
Section 2.4 Statistical Analysis
Linear mixed models were used with repeated measures for position and joint angle. Given the equal number of male and female participants and the established strength variations related to sex, was sex taken into consideration as a potential covariate or interaction factor in the analysis?
Response:
Sex was not included as a covariate or interaction term in the primary analyses because our aim was to characterize BD across positions and angles in the cohort as a whole. Although our sample was balanced by sex, the study was not designed to provide sufficient statistical power for sex-by-condition interactions across multiple outcomes. We have added this rationale to the Statistical Analysis section and noted it as a limitation.
Changes made:
- Methods (Section 2.4): added rationale for not modelling sex as a covariate/interaction.
- Discussion (Limitations): added statement that sex-specific effects were not examined.
R2.9
Comment:
Table 1: Characteristic statistics
Although the bilateral values in Table 1 are consistently less than the total of the unilateral values, the table does not display the real bilateral deficit ratios. Would it be easier for the reader to understand the size of the differences if the estimated BD values were also displayed immediately in the table?
Response:
We appreciate the reviewer’s suggestion and have added Table 2 (Panel A), which reports BD ratios (mean (SD)) for all tested conditions.
Changes made:
- Results: added Table 2 (Panel A) immediately after Table 1.
R2.10
Comment:
Paragraph starting “A linear mixed-model analysis revealed…” (Fmax results)
Particularly around 120° and 150°, the seated position is said to exhibit the greatest bilateral deficit. Could you elaborate on whether, given the indicated impact sizes, these differences are both practically meaningful and statistically significant?
Response:
We clarified the practical meaning by reporting absolute BD ratios in Table 2 and highlighting representative between-condition differences (for example, a ~0.10 difference in Fmax BD ratio between seated 150° and prone 150°). We also emphasize model effect sizes (partial η²) in Table 2, Panel B.
Changes made:
- Results: revised narrative to reference Table 2 and included a concise statement on the magnitude of differences.
R2.11
Comment:
(RFDmax, RFD50ms, RFD200ms) RFD variables
Although a number of noteworthy interactions have been documented, the pattern appears to be complicated across positions and angles. Would it help to briefly summarize the main practical takeaway for each RFD variable instead of listing multiple p-values?
Response:
We agree with the reviewer and have revised the Results section to provide a concise practical takeaway for each RFD variable, minimizing repetitive p-value listings. We also synthesized these implications in the Discussion section.
Changes made:
- Results: revised the main Results paragraph to summarize RFD patterns succinctly.
- Discussion: added subheaded synthesis of the key takeaways.
R2.12
Comment:
Figure 2 description
Figure 2 is referenced for all main findings, but the text does not describe the variability or overlap between conditions. Are the differences visually clear, or is there substantial overlap between positions and angles that should be acknowledged in the results section?
Response:
To clarify, we added a sentence acknowledging that standard deviation overlap exists across conditions (especially for RFD measures) and clarified that the overall patterns remain consistent. Additionally, after adding the schematic timeline as Figure 2, the BD plot has been renumbered to Figure 3 in the revised manuscript.
Changes made:
- Results: added a sentence on variability/overlap when describing Figure 3.
R2.13
Comment:
First paragraph (novelty claim)
You claim that this is the first study to methodically look at how location and tilt affect bilateral hamstring deficiency. Can you be fully certain about this claim, and have you clearly demonstrated how your study differs from previous work on bilateral deficit or hamstring testing conditions?
Response:
We have revised the novelty statement to avoid overclaiming and now describe our work as a systematic comparison of commonly used testing configurations, without asserting that it is definitively the first study of its kind.
Changes made:
- Discussion opening: revised novelty wording.
R2.14
Comment:
Paragraphs explaining mechanisms (seated position and neural factors)
The results are explained by a number of neurological mechanisms, including altered motor unit recruitment, spinal inhibition, and reflex activation. Should these hypotheses be offered more cautiously as potential interpretations rather than indicated mechanisms, given that no EMG or brain data were taken?
Response:
We appreciate this point and have strengthened our language to present neuromechanical explanations as plausible interpretations, explicitly noting the absence of EMG or brain measurements.
Changes made:
- Discussion (Potential Neuromechanical Explanations; Limitations): revised to cautious interpretive wording.
R2.15
Comment:
Section on clinical implications (seated position underestimation)
You suggest that seated testing may underestimate true maximal capacity due to exaggerated bilateral inhibition. Is this conclusion too strong based only on isometric laboratory data, and could other practical factors also influence these results?
Response:
We have tempered the statement regarding potential underestimation of true maximal capacity in the seated position. We now frame this as configuration-dependent differences in BD, emphasizing that these findings should be interpreted cautiously in applied settings.
Changes made:
- Discussion (Practical Implications): revised to more cautious language.
R2.16
Comment:
Conclusion section
In addition to suggesting useful implications for training and rehabilitation, the finding highlights the necessity of consistent protocols. Should these recommendations be more cautiously worded to prevent overgeneralization outside the studied population, considering that the sample consisted solely of healthy young adults?
Response:
We have revised the conclusion to avoid overgeneralizing the findings beyond the studied population and specific testing configurations.
Changes made:
- Conclusion paragraph in Discussion: revised to more cautious wording.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors- In the Introduction (second paragraph), the term “EMG-based comparisons” is used. Please define EMG (electromyography) at its first occurrence for clarity.
- In the Introduction (fourth paragraph), the statement that “the practical meaning of a given BD magnitude can depend on the task and sport context and there is no single universally accepted threshold” would benefit from supporting references. Please provide relevant literature to substantiate this claim.
- In the equation presented in the Introduction (fourth paragraph), “BD ratio = F_bilateral / (F_unilateral_left + F_unilateral_right),” please clarify what the symbol “F” represents (e.g., force, peak force, mean force). This should be explicitly defined for precision.
- In the final paragraph of the Introduction, the hypothesis is said to be based on “length–tension relationships and theoretical neurophysiological considerations.” Please elaborate on how these neurophysiological considerations logically support the stated hypothesis. Providing clearer reasoning and relevant references would strengthen the theoretical foundation.
- In the Discussion, you state that “BD is not universally ‘good’ or ‘bad.’” If so, please clarify the practical relevance of assessing BD or comparing BD across conditions. Expanding on how these findings inform applied practice or theoretical understanding would strengthen the study’s contribution.
- In Figure 1, consider labeling the three positions (seated, prone, supine) directly within panels a), b), and c) as subheadings to improve readability.
- In Section 2.3, the citation format for MATLAB appears inconsistent with standard referencing style (“MATLAB and Statistics Toolbox Release 2023b. The MathWorks, Inc. https://www.mathworks.com/products/matlab.html”). Please revise this according to the journal’s citation guidelines.
- Sections 2.3 (Data Collection and Analysis) and 2.4 (Statistical Analysis) both describe aspects of analysis. Please clarify the distinction between signal processing and statistical analysis, or consider consolidating these sections for improved organization.
- In the Results section, Tables 1 and 2 (Panel A) are presented, but the main descriptive findings from these tables are not clearly summarized in the text. Please add brief explanatory statements highlighting the key observations to guide the reader.
- In the Results, the phrase “some overlap in SD was evident” may be unclear to readers. Please clarify what is meant by “overlap in SD” (e.g., overlapping standard deviation ranges across conditions) and explain its interpretive implication.
- In the Results, the expressions “deficits were higher” and “BD ratios were smallest” appear to describe similar outcomes but are not conceptually identical. Consider using consistent terminology (e.g., consistently referring to lower BD ratios as indicating larger deficits) to avoid confusion.
- In Section 4.2, the symbol “~” is used to indicate approximate values (e.g., ~0.86). Because this symbol may be visually confused with a minus sign, consider replacing it with the word “approximately” or “approx.” for clarity.
- In Section 4.5 (Limitations and Future Research), you note that “sex-specific effects were not examined.” Given that sex-balanced data were collected, the editor or readers may question why such analyses were not conducted. Please justify this decision more explicitly or clarify whether exploratory analyses were considered.
- In Section 4.5, please clarify why “a priori power analysis” is discussed in relation to “formal sample size planning.” The current wording may appear redundant or unclear. Consider specifying whether a prospective power calculation was conducted prior to data collection and, if not, provide justification.
Author Response
We thank the reviewers for their constructive comments. We have revised the manuscript accordingly. Below we provide point-by-point responses and indicate where changes were made in the revised manuscript.
Reviewer 1
- 1
Comment: In the Introduction (second paragraph), the term “EMG-based comparisons” is used. Please define EMG (electromyography) at its first occurrence for clarity.
Response: We have defined EMG at its first occurrence.
Changes made: Introduction, paragraph beginning “Among field-based hamstring strength tests…”: changed to “electromyography (EMG)-based comparisons…”.
- 2
Comment: In the Introduction (fourth paragraph), the statement that “the practical meaning of a given BD magnitude can depend on the task and sport context and there is no single universally accepted threshold” would benefit from supporting references. Please provide relevant literature to substantiate this claim.
Response: We agree and have added supporting references from the BD literature reviews discussing the task- and context-dependence of BD interpretation.
Changes made: Introduction, paragraph defining BD ratio: added citations [98, 104] to support the statement regarding the lack of a universal threshold.
- 3
Comment: In the equation presented in the Introduction (fourth paragraph), “BD ratio = F_bilateral / (F_unilateral_left + F_unilateral_right),” please clarify what the symbol “F” represents (e.g., force, peak force, mean force). This should be explicitly defined for precision.
Response: We have clarified that the symbol used in the BD-ratio equation (now denoted X) represents the outcome metric for which BD is computed (e.g., peak force/Fmax, mean force, RFDmax, RFD50ms, or RFD200ms) obtained under the specified contraction condition.
Changes made: Introduction, paragraph defining BD ratio: revised the equation to use a generic outcome symbol (X) and explicitly defined it as the metric used to compute BD across all reported variables. For consistency, the Table 2 note was also revised to use the same generic outcome symbol.
- 4
Comment: In the final paragraph of the Introduction, the hypothesis is said to be based on “length–tension relationships and theoretical neurophysiological considerations.” Please elaborate on how these neurophysiological considerations logically support the stated hypothesis. Providing clearer reasoning and relevant references would strengthen the theoretical foundation.
Response: We have expanded the rationale by briefly linking bilateral motor-control constraints and inter-hemispheric inhibitory interactions to potential reductions in bilateral neural drive, and we added relevant references.
Changes made: Introduction, final paragraph (aim/hypothesis): added 2 sentences clarifying the neurophysiological rationale and added references [78, 82, 98].
- 5
Comment: In the Discussion, you state that “BD is not universally ‘good’ or ‘bad.’” If so, please clarify the practical relevance of assessing BD or comparing BD across conditions. Expanding on how these findings inform applied practice or theoretical understanding would strengthen the study’s contribution.
Response: We have expanded the applied interpretation to clarify why BD remains a useful, task-specific indicator of bilateral coordination constraints and how it can inform standardized testing and interpretation of longitudinal changes.
Changes made: Discussion, paragraph beginning “From an applied perspective…”: added a sentence on the practical relevance of BD assessment with supporting references [98, 104].
- 6
Comment: In Figure 1, consider labeling the three positions (seated, prone, supine) directly within panels a), b), and c) as subheadings to improve readability.
Response: We have added position labels to the figure panels and clarified the panel mapping in the figure caption.
Changes made: Figure 1: added panel titles (“Seated”, “Prone”, “Supine”) within panels a–c and updated the caption to specify (a) seated; (b) prone; (c) supine.
- 7
Comment: In Section 2.3, the citation format for MATLAB appears inconsistent with standard referencing style (“MATLAB and Statistics Toolbox Release 2023b. The MathWorks, Inc. https://www.mathworks.com/products/matlab.html”). Please revise this according to the journal’s citation guidelines.
Response: We have revised the MATLAB software citation to a standard journal format (software name/version, publisher/location, year, and URL).
Changes made: Methods, Section 2.3 “Data Collection and Analysis”: updated the MATLAB citation in the signal-processing paragraph.
- 8
Comment: Sections 2.3 (Data Collection and Analysis) and 2.4 (Statistical Analysis) both describe aspects of analysis. Please clarify the distinction between signal processing and statistical analysis, or consider consolidating these sections for improved organization.
Response: We clarified the organizational distinction by adding a brief opening sentence to each section: Section 2.3 describes signal processing/outcome derivation, whereas Section 2.4 describes inferential statistical testing.
Changes made: Methods, Sections 2.3 and 2.4: added opening sentences clarifying the scope of each section.
- 9
Comment: In the Results section, Tables 1 and 2 (Panel A) are presented, but the main descriptive findings from these tables are not clearly summarized in the text. Please add brief explanatory statements highlighting the key observations to guide the reader.
Response: We added a brief descriptive summary emphasizing (i) absolute unilateral/bilateral values (Table 1) and (ii) the key BD ratio patterns across conditions (Table 2, Panel A).
Changes made: Results, immediately after the introductory paragraph that introduces Tables 1–2: inserted a short descriptive summary of Tables 1 and 2 (Panel A).
- 10
Comment: In the Results, the phrase “some overlap in SD was evident” may be unclear to readers. Please clarify what is meant by “overlap in SD” (e.g., overlapping standard deviation ranges across conditions) and explain its interpretive implication.
Response: We clarified this wording by explicitly stating that SD ranges overlapped across some conditions and that interpretation should rely on the mixed-model results/effect sizes rather than visual SD separation.
Changes made: Results, paragraph summarizing the mixed-model findings: revised the sentence to clarify the meaning and implication of SD overlap.
- 11
Comment: In the Results, the expressions “deficits were higher” and “BD ratios were smallest” appear to describe similar outcomes but are not conceptually identical. Consider using consistent terminology (e.g., consistently referring to lower BD ratios as indicating larger deficits) to avoid confusion.
Response: We agree and standardized the Results wording to consistently interpret lower BD ratios as indicating larger deficits.
Changes made: Results, paragraph summarizing the mixed-model findings: revised terminology to consistently link “lower BD ratios” with “larger deficits”.
- 12
Comment: In Section 4.2, the symbol “~” is used to indicate approximate values (e.g., ~0.86). Because this symbol may be visually confused with a minus sign, consider replacing it with the word “approximately” or “approx.” for clarity.
Response: We replaced the “~” symbol with the word “approximately” throughout the manuscript where used to denote approximate values.
Changes made: Methods (session duration statement) and Discussion (approximate BD ratio values): replaced “~” with “approximately”.
- 13
Comment: In Section 4.5 (Limitations and Future Research), you note that “sex-specific effects were not examined.” Given that sex-balanced data were collected, the editor or readers may question why such analyses were not conducted. Please justify this decision more explicitly or clarify whether exploratory analyses were considered.
Response: We added an explicit justification stating that, although sex-balanced, the study was not designed/powered for sex-by-condition interactions across multiple outcomes and therefore focused on cohort-level effects; we highlight this as a direction for future work.
Changes made: Statistical Analysis (Section 2.4) and Limitations (Section 4.5): expanded the justification for not testing sex-by-condition interactions.
- 14
Comment: In Section 4.5, please clarify why “a priori power analysis” is discussed in relation to “formal sample size planning.” The current wording may appear redundant or unclear. Consider specifying whether a prospective power calculation was conducted prior to data collection and, if not, provide justification.
Response: We clarified that no prospective (a priori) power analysis was conducted prior to data collection (i.e., the sample size was not determined via a formal power calculation). We also retained the post hoc sensitivity analysis to contextualize the current sample size.
Changes made: Limitations (Section 4.5): revised the power-analysis sentence to explicitly state that no prospective power analysis was conducted and to clarify the role of formal sample-size planning.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors(R2.5: Power Analysis) Although the limitation regarding the absence of an a priori power analysis has now been acknowledged, the response remains somewhat incomplete from a methodological standpoint. If feasible, providing at least a post hoc power calculation or effect-size–based justification would further strengthen the statistical robustness of the study. (R2.6: Fatigue Control) The expanded description of session structure and rest intervals improves transparency. The manuscript does not, however, yet offer impartial proof that performance held steady during sessions. A quick examination of within-session patterns, such as contrasting early and late trials, would strengthen the validity of the results if the data were available.
Author Response
Reviewer 2
R2.5
Comment: Power Analysis) Although the limitation regarding the absence of an a priori power analysis has now been acknowledged, the response remains somewhat incomplete from a methodological standpoint. If feasible, providing at least a post hoc power calculation or effect-size–based justification would further strengthen the statistical robustness of the study.
Response: Thank you for this helpful suggestion. To strengthen methodological transparency, we added an effect-size–based justification via a post hoc sensitivity analysis aligned with our repeated-measures (within-subject) design. For two-tailed α = 0.05 and n = 30, the study has 80% power to detect paired effects of approximately Cohen’s dz ≥ 0.53. In addition, we now report representative observed paired effect sizes for a key contrast supporting the primary conclusion: the prone vs seated difference in Fmax BD ratio was large at 120° (dz = 1.01) and at 150° (dz = 1.19).
Changes made: Section 2.4 “Statistical Analysis”: Added post hoc sensitivity analysis statement (paired design). Section 3 “Results”: Added representative paired effect sizes (dz) for a key contrast (prone vs seated).
R2.6
Comment: Fatigue Control) The expanded description of session structure and rest intervals improves transparency. The manuscript does not, however, yet offer impartial proof that performance held steady during sessions. A quick examination of within-session patterns, such as contrasting early and late trials, would strengthen the validity of the results if the data were available.
Response: Thank you. We agree and have added an objective within-session stability check using the available trial-by-trial data. We contrasted the 1st vs 3rd MVIC attempts (collapsed across conditions) separately for bilateral and unilateral efforts. Peak force remained stable across attempts (bilateral: +1.06%, p = 0.053; unilateral: +0.45%, p = 0.445). Bilateral RFD showed a small reduction across attempts (RFDmax: −5.60%, p = 0.0035; RFD50ms: −6.64%, p = 0.0033; RFD200ms: −4.94%, p = 0.0038), whereas unilateral RFD did not change (all p ≥ 0.316). Importantly, sensitivity analyses recomputing BD ratios using the 1st attempt only yielded the same between-condition patterns (e.g., seated < prone/supine at 120° and 150°), indicating that the primary conclusions are unchanged.
Changes made: Section 2.4 “Statistical Analysis”: Added within-session stability method (1st vs 3rd attempt). Section 3 “Results”: Added stability results + brief sensitivity statement showing unchanged conclusions.