Abstract
The poor long-term stability of aerobic granular sludge (AGS) remains the principal obstacle to its full-scale engineering application. Guided by a two-stage framework of “granule formation–long-term maintenance” and a three-dimensional perspective of “physical structure–functional performance–resilience to disturbance”, this review systematically synthesizes AGS stability research published from 2006 to May 2026. We applied a predefined evidence hierarchy to distinguish long-term maintenance evidence from formation/mechanism evidence and negative evidence. Accelerated granule formation and short-term improvements in settleability are explicitly separated from evidence of sustained structural and functional stability under extended operation and disturbance. The available evidence shows that no universally optimal single operating parameter exists for AGS stability; instead, stage-specific dynamic regulation is required across start-up, long-term maintenance, and shock load recovery phases. The best-supported boundary was a feast–famine ratio < 0.5 (feast phase ≤ 25% of the cycle), with an initial organic loading rate of 8–12 kg COD/(m3·d) for formation shifting to 6 kg COD/(m3·d) for maintenance and an SRT of 15 d for combined COD/N/P removal. Most exogenous additives improve granule formation and short-term stability, but no positive additive meets the long-term maintenance criteria: the long-term effectiveness of biochar and lignocellulose and the risk of inorganic accumulation remain unverified, while N-acyl homoserine lactone-based quorum sensing molecules and functional microbial inocula are constrained by rapid degradation and poor colonization. For microbial management, key extracellular polymeric substance-producing bacteria and functional groups correlate with stability, but presence does not equal activity, and expression-level mechanistic validation is still lacking. Future research should prioritize long-term longitudinal monitoring with standardized disturbance–recovery tests, functional omics-based elucidation, mechanism-constrained predictive early warning, and a unified stability assessment and regulation framework along the lab-scale–pilot-scale–full-scale evidence chain.