Review Reports
- Yusra Zaki Aboud
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsYou are exploring an important and controversial topic, one that has implications for many students, schools, and families. You have gathered a solid foundation of useful data on the three cases under investigation, but your analysis and conclusions need considerable rethinking and revision.
- Although the introduction is thoughtful and well-informed, it needs to be rewritten in a way that simply describes the problem under consideration and makes a case for the research questions that motivated this study. The introduction is not the place to provide the results and state the conclusions. Arguments for and discussions of the conclusions should come at the end of the article, following an introduction to the topic and a description of the research that was carried out.
- Study Importance. Normally in my experience, this section would be part of the Introduction. It is awkwardly written, and would benefit from rewriting for clarity and coherence. Also, it seems to me that the study findings are useful for anyone thinking of acceleration anywhere, not just in Saudi Arabia.
3.1. Lit Review, Academic Acceleration. What constitutes giftedness, and the needs and characteristics of gifted learners are highly complex and controversial topics in their own right, and require much more thoughtful treatment than what’s given here, where they’re stated as facts in a few sentences. Because this is an applied study of acceleration, it might make sense to avoid the whole controversial area of definition, needs, and characteristics, and simply describe the population of interest, saying something like this: “Some children are so advanced in one or more subjects that they require some kind of educational adaptation in order to continue learning. Academic acceleration is one approach that has gained considerable research validation, etc.”
Why did you select grade-skipping as the acceleration approach to study? Please explain this decision.
You have covered a lot of important ground in this section, but it’s not organized coherently. Here are some suggestions for taking it apart and putting it back together in a way that readers will be able to follow more easily:
I’d like to see a section where you summarize the social, emotional, and psychological concerns of acceleration, dividing this part of your report into evidence-based strengths and evidence-based concerns in the literature. As written, it’s a confusing mashup of contradictory findings.
You should have a separate paragraph or section on techniques of providing acceleration, rather than interspersing ideas throughout (e.g., technology).
Implementation problems deserve their own paragraph or section too.
4.3. Sample description should include a brief sentence that gives some basic characteristics of each of the subjects under consideration in the study, including ages, grades, sex, and other relevant facts, so that readers can begin to get a sense of the real people you’re discussing. We also need to know at what age/grade the acceleration occurred, how long that was before the research study.
Why did you interview only STEM subject teachers (mathematics, biology, physics, chemistry, and computer science). What about language and linguistic-based subjects, or the arts? Please explain here. Also, this might be something to mention in the Study Limitations/Future Directions area.
4.4.1. Would it be fair to say you designed the PDAS by adapting items on the IAS to the Saudi context? If yes, say it that way, because creating your own scale raises many more questions about test reliability and validity than internal consistency can answer.
- I was initially confused about the description of the subjects’ profiles as even, uneven, and declining even when I read about their CogAT results, as the subjects were selected before you administered the CogAT. It would help prevent that if you reported that the CogAT score pattern reflected the academic profile and was consistent with your categorization of each subject.
Why did you use only STEM subjects in your academic analysis?
- 1. 1. You discuss the acceleration decision in the results section, declaring it good on the basis of your findings, even though your findings came long after the decision had been made. This discussion would be better placed in the Discussion section of the paper.
6.1.2. You describe SL’s academic grades as “alarmingly low” in Math, Physics, and Chemistry, where she achieved grades in the mid- to high 70s, whereas her CogAT scores would suggest she should be failing or having much more serious challenges. Am I missing something here?
In this analysis, as with the first case, you discuss the wisdom of the acceleration decision. The Results section is a place for simply reporting the results of your assessments. Discussion of them and judgements based on them should go in the Discussion section.
Is SL a boy or a girl? At some points you refer to them as a girl and at other times as a boy. Please edit for consistency.
- Discussion. This section needs considerable editing and revision. Your observations here are overstated, given that you have findings only from three cases. By virtue of its design, this study cannot be “conclusive.” Neither can you state that your findings show acceleration to be a “powerful invervention.” The strongest your conclusions can be are tentative and suggestive, consistent with other studies’ findings.
Your cases illustrate the need to go beyond composite ratings, and to consider complex individual differences when making decisions about acceleration. In my opinion, they also illustrate the need to provide support for parents as well as students in the transition process.
Author Response
Reviewer 1
Comment 1: Although the introduction is thoughtful and well-informed, it needs to be rewritten in a way that simply describes the problem under consideration and makes a case for the research questions that motivated this study. The introduction is not the place to provide the results and state the conclusions. Arguments for and discussions of the conclusions should come at the end of the article, following an introduction to the topic and a description of the research that was carried out.
Response: the introduction has been rewritten we removed all statements about findings, outcomes, or recommendations, moved importance statement to a separate section or integrated into the gap statement, added a clear, single central research question, and restructured the problem to reflect evidence for acceleration, implementation challenges in Saudi Arabia, gaps in existing research, and study purpose and research question
Comment 2: Study Importance. Normally in my experience, this section would be part of the Introduction. It is awkwardly written, and would benefit from rewriting for clarity and coherence. Also, it seems to me that the study findings are useful for anyone thinking of acceleration anywhere, not just in Saudi Arabia.
Response: the importance section has been merged to be part of the Introduction and the importance was adjusted to show that assessing acceleration in this way is a methodological innovation that transcends the borders of Saudi Arabia and has international applicability.
Comment 3 : Lit Review, Academic Acceleration. What constitutes giftedness, and the needs and characteristics of gifted learners are highly complex and controversial topics in their own right, and require much more thoughtful treatment than what’s given here, where they’re stated as facts in a few sentences. Because this is an applied study of acceleration, it might make sense to avoid the whole controversial area of definition, needs, and characteristics, and simply describe the population of interest, saying something like this: “Some children are so advanced in one or more subjects that they require some kind of educational adaptation in order to continue learning. Academic acceleration is one approach that has gained considerable research validation, etc.”
Response: An introduction to the academic acceleration literature has been added, focusing on students who need educational adjustments; it also includes an acknowledgment of introductory discussions; and a definition of academic acceleration with an emphasis on skipping grades.
Comment4: Why did you select grade-skipping as the acceleration approach to study? Please explain this decision.
Response: An explanation to this decision has been Added” The choice of skipping-grade acceleration over other acceleration methods is justified by the fact that it is the predominant form of acceleration officially recognized and implemented by the Ministry of Education… etc…
Comment 5: You have covered a lot of important ground in this section, but it’s not organized coherently. Here are some suggestions for taking it apart and putting it back together in a way that readers will be able to follow more easily: Comment 5.1.: I’d like to see a section where you summarize the social, emotional, and psychological concerns of acceleration, dividing this part of your report into evidence-based strengths and evidence-based concerns in the literature. As written, it’s a confusing mashup of contradictory findings; Comment 5.2.: You should have a separate paragraph or section on techniques of providing acceleration, rather than interspersing ideas throughout (e.g., technology); and Comment 5.3. : Implementation problems deserve their own paragraph or section too.
Response to comment 5 and sub comments including below : Separated into distinct subsections: social/emotional outcomes (evidence-based strengths) and implementation challenges (evidence-based concerns).
Comment 6: Sample description should include a brief sentence that gives some basic characteristics of each of the subjects under consideration in the study, including ages, grades, sex, and other relevant facts, so that readers can begin to get a sense of the real people you’re discussing. We also need to know at what age/grade the acceleration occurred, how long that was before the research study.
Response: The sample description was expanded to provide the basic characteristics of each individual being considered in the study, including age, educational stage, gender, and other relevant facts.
Comment7: Why did you interview only STEM subject teachers (mathematics, biology, physics, chemistry, and computer science). What about language and linguistic-based subjects, or the arts? Please explain here. Also, this might be something to mention in the Study Limitations/Future Directions area.
Response: The decision to focus exclusively on STEM subject teachers (mathematics, biology, physics, chemistry, and computer science) was a deliberate methodological choice grounded in three main justifications. First, alignment with cognitive assessment objectives as the CogAT measures quantitative and nonverbal abilities that directly predict performance in STEM subjects, enabling the study to examine the alignment between students' cognitive profiles and their performance in subjects most dependent on these abilities. Second, the demands of grade-skipping acceleration as STEM subjects (particularly mathematics and physics) present the greatest challenges for students with uneven cognitive profiles due to their reliance on cumulative knowledge and abstract reasoning, making them the most evident domain for identifying risks of misalignment or academic decline. Third, the structure of the Saudi acceleration program where STEM subjects constitute 60% of the acceleration qualifying examination (Ministry of Education, 2025), making STEM teachers the primary gatekeepers of program success. We acknowledge that excluding language and arts teachers is a limitation of the study, and we have added this to the limitations section with a recommendation that future research include a broader range of subject teachers to capture a more comprehensive picture of accelerated students' experiences.
Comment 8: Would it be fair to say you designed the PDAS by adapting items on the IAS to the Saudi context? If yes, say it that way, because creating your own scale raises many more questions about test reliability and validity than internal consistency can answer.
Response: The scale description has been rewritten and clarified that the scale is adapted from the IAS scale, which is an existing approved tool; we emphasized that adaptation is methodologically sound and common in cross-cultural research; and we acknowledged adaptation as a limitation and called for future validation studies.
Comment 9: I was initially confused about the description of the subjects’ profiles as even, uneven, and declining even when I read about their CogAT results, as the subjects were selected before you administered the CogAT. It would help prevent that if you reported that the CogAT score pattern reflected the academic profile and was consistent with your categorization of each subject.
Response: in the manuscript sample, study design and result Clarified that profiles were initially identified from academic performance patterns (3 semesters prior); Explicitly stated that CogAT was administered following selection to validate classifications, and we added explicit statements showing how CogAT results confirmed the academic classifications
Comment 10: You discuss the acceleration decision in the results section, declaring it good on the basis of your findings, even though your findings came long after the decision had been made. This discussion would be better placed in the Discussion section of the paper.
Response: The methodological rationale for presenting the acceleration decision data within the Results section rather than the Discussion section can be explained by the fact that in case studies, particularly when using a multidimensional and multi-source design, integrating results from different data sources is essential to presenting the findings, not merely interpreting them. The "Acceleration Decision" subsections in this study do not represent speculative interpretations or subsequent justifications; rather, they are composite results derived from the systematic triangulation of three data sets for each case: cognitive assessment (CogAT), academic performance analysis (predictive modeling), and psychosocial assessment (PDAS and interviews).
Comment 11: You describe SL’s academic grades as “alarmingly low” in Math, Physics, and Chemistry, where she achieved grades in the mid- to high 70s, whereas her CogAT scores would suggest she should be failing or having much more serious challenges. Am I missing something here?
Response: The terminology used to describe S.L.'s academic performance has been revised, particularly the phrase "alarmingly low," which could be considered subjective and might not reflect her actual scores (mid to late 70s). Your important observation that S.L.'s CogAT scores (Quantitative: SAS = 75, PR = 6; Nonverbal: SAS = 75, PR = 6) might suggest failing grades or greater academic challenges is incorrect. Her scores in the 70s actually indicate a level of compensatory success, most likely attributable to her strong verbal abilities (SAS = 124, PR = 93). Therefore, in response to your valuable observation, the description has been revised to be more accurate and objective, acknowledging the compensatory role of her verbal strengths.
Comment 12: In this analysis, as with the first case, you discuss the wisdom of the acceleration decision. The Results section is a place for simply reporting the results of your assessments. Discussion of them and judgements based on them should go in the Discussion section.
Response: The results discussion section has been rewritten and includes a discussion of the acceleration decision in terms of its correctness or incorrectness and the judgments based on it for each of the three cases in the discussion section.
Comment 13: Is SL a boy or a girl? At some points you refer to them as a girl and at other times as a boy. Please edit for consistency.
Response: she is a girl, we fix the problem in her case study
Comment 14: Discussion. This section needs considerable editing and revision. Your observations here are overstated, given that you have findings only from three cases. By virtue of its design, this study cannot be “conclusive.” Neither can you state that your findings show acceleration to be a “powerful invervention.” The strongest your conclusions can be are tentative and suggestive, consistent with other studies’ findings.
Your cases illustrate the need to go beyond composite ratings, and to consider complex individual differences when making decisions about acceleration. In my opinion, they also illustrate the need to provide support for parents as well as students in the transition process."
Response: The discussion section has been rewritten to address the concerns you raised in your important note by adopting a more moderate and reserved tone, explicitly acknowledging the limitations of the study, and framing the findings as illustrative rather than definitive.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThank you for the opportunity to read this very will-written and interesting article. In general, I found it to be a compelling and informative. I appreciate the way the author framed the qualitative research within the context of the Saudi Arabia educational system and acknowledged the pros and cons of the intervention vis-a-vis the individual profiles.
I have just a couple of suggestions — primarily, review the list of references to make sure that all citations are included. The Assouline et al., 2009 citation, which should be for the Iowa Acceleration Scale Manual — 3rd edition was not included in the references. This is a key reference because the foundation for the entire manuscript is found in this extensive manual. Assouline and colleagues (2009) address the importance of making an objective decision about a whole-grade skip based upon multiple factors. This case study reiterates the importance of a decision-making process, especially for students for whom the decision was questionable. The manual also provides case studies.
Assouline and colleagues have now developed a new instrument called the Integrated Acceleration System (2021) that is fully online and interactive with the team; at the conclusion of the process a report with a recommendation is generated. I think that the authors — if it’s not too late — should consider that this format for making the decision would address the concerns with the two students for whom the decision was questionable and may want to discuss that in their conclusions. They could also update the Assouline et al. 2009 by including both. More about the Integrated Acceleration System is found at: https://accelerationsystem.org/. More about academic acceleration, including access to Volume 1 and Volume 2 of A Nation Empowered (please note: the publication date for A Nation Empowered is 2015 -- not 2023; however, the author's citation and reference use the inaccurate date of 2023) at https://www.accelerationinstitute.org/
Author Response
Reviewer 2
Comment 1: review the list of references to make sure that all citations are included. The Assouline et al., 2009 citation, which should be for the Iowa Acceleration Scale Manual — 3rd edition was not included in the references.
Response: The bibliography has been reviewed to ensure all citations are included.
The citation by Assouline et al., 2009, from the Iowa State Accelerometer Manual, 3rd Edition, has also been included in the bibliography. As:
Assouline, S. G., Colangelo, N., Lupkowski-Shoplik, A., Forstadt, L., & Lipscomb, J. (2009). Iowa Acceleration Scale manual: A guide for whole-grade acceleration K-8 (3rd ed.). Great Potential Press.
Comment 2: This is a key reference because the foundation for the entire manuscript is found in this extensive manual. Assouline and colleagues (2009) address the importance of making an objective decision about a whole-grade skip based upon multiple factors. This case study reiterates the importance of a decision-making process, especially for students for whom the decision was questionable. The manual also provides case studies.
Comment 3: Assouline and colleagues have now developed a new instrument called the Integrated Acceleration System (2021) that is fully online and interactive with the team; at the conclusion of the process a report with a recommendation is generated. I think that the authors — if it’s not too late — should consider that this format for making the decision would address the concerns with the two students for whom the decision was questionable and may want to discuss that in their conclusions. They could also update the Assouline et al. 2009 by including both. More about the Integrated Acceleration System is found at: https://accelerationsystem.org/. More about academic acceleration, including access to Volume 1 and Volume 2 of A Nation Empowered
Response: We thank the reviewer for this insightful comment and for bringing the Integrated Acceleration System (IAS) to our attention. We agree that the IAS represents a significant advancement in the field, offering a structured, interactive, and collaborative framework for making acceleration decisions. Its development by Assouline and colleagues (2021) indeed builds upon the foundation of the Iowa Acceleration Scale (IAS, 3rd ed.) that we cited and adapted for our study.
However, we would like to clarify that the central purpose of our study was not to evaluate or compare available decision-making instruments. Instead, our aim was to conduct a critical examination of the existing acceleration policies and procedures as they are actually implemented in the Saudi Arabian context. In this context, decisions for whole-grade acceleration are primarily determined by the Ministry of Education’s National Acceleration Program, which relies heavily on a student’s performance on a composite qualifying examination covering multiple subjects (Ministry of Education, 2025). As we highlight in our manuscript, this score-driven, single-model approach does not systematically incorporate a comprehensive evaluation of cognitive profiles, academic trajectories, or psychosocial readiness—the very elements that the Integrated Acceleration System is designed to capture.
Our case studies of students S.L. and T.M. were selected precisely to illustrate the potential consequences of such a policy-driven, rather than student-centered, decision-making process. Their experiences demonstrate that a uniform, score-based policy can lead to a mismatch between student needs and the demands of an accelerated placement, with resulting academic and psychosocial risks. The "questionable" decisions in these two cases, as the reviewer notes, are not a reflection of a flawed instrument, but rather a direct outcome of a system that, at the time of their acceleration, did not mandate or routinely employ the kind of deep, multi-dimensional evaluation that tools like the IAS or our proposed integrated model provide.
We have revised the manuscript to include the following points in the Discussion and Conclusions sections to address this:
- Acknowledgment of the IAS:We now explicitly cite the Integrated Acceleration System (Assouline et al., 2021) as a contemporary exemplar of the type of comprehensive, team-based, and data-driven approach we advocate for. We have updated the relevant references accordingly.
- Contextual Clarification: We have clarified that the limitations in decision-making observed in our case studies are attributable to the Saudi policy framework in place at the time of the students' acceleration. The decision-making process for these students was constrained by a system that prioritizes qualifying examination scores over the holistic evaluation of the student.
- Implications for Policy: We have strengthened our conclusion to argue that the implementation of a more systematic, evidence-based framework—akin to the IAS or the integrated model our study proposes—is essential to prevent such mismatches. The shift from a score-driven policy to a comprehensive, student-profile-based evaluation methodology is not merely a theoretical recommendation but a critical necessity for ensuring that acceleration is an appropriate and beneficial intervention for all gifted students, especially those with uneven cognitive profiles.
We believe these revisions appropriately contextualize our findings within the existing Saudi system while acknowledging the reviewer's important point about the availability of more advanced decision-making frameworks internationally.
Comment3: (please note: the publication date for A Nation Empowered is 2015 -- not 2023; however, the author's citation and reference use the inaccurate date of 2023) at https://www.accelerationinstitute.org/
Response: thank you very much for the correction, publication date has been changed to 2015
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript addresses an important and contextually relevant issue in gifted education, namely decision-making in academic acceleration within the Saudi educational system. The tri-case study design offers potentially valuable insights into the alignment (or misalignment) between cognitive profile, academic performance, and psychosocial readiness.
However, substantial revisions are required before the manuscript can be considered for publication.
First, the theoretical framework requires strengthening. While the literature review is informative, it remains largely descriptive and does not sufficiently integrate established acceleration decision frameworks (e.g., multi-criteria models such as the Iowa Acceleration Scale, contemporary conceptualizations of twice-exceptionality, or theoretical models of gifted development). The manuscript would benefit from a clearer conceptual model explicitly guiding the study.
Second, the research objectives and design require clarification. The study is described as qualitative-quantitative, yet no explicit mixed-methods framework is articulated. It remains unclear whether the design is exploratory, explanatory, or instrumental. Furthermore, the categories of “Even,” “Uneven,” and “Declining Uneven” profiles should be clarified as either theoretically predefined or analytically derived.
Third, the predictive linear model used to generate academic expectations lacks sufficient methodological transparency. The manuscript should explicitly present the model specification, assumptions, and validation procedures. Without this, interpretation of performance gaps remains largely descriptive.
Fourth, the Psychosocial and Dispositional Assessment Scale (PDAS), being researcher-developed, requires stronger evidence of construct validity beyond internal consistency. Reporting Cronbach’s alpha alone is insufficient to establish instrument validity.
Fifth, causal interpretations linking acceleration to psychosocial distress should be moderated. Given the case study design (n=3), conclusions must remain at the level of analytic generalization rather than policy-level inference. Statements advocating “fundamental transformation” of national policies are currently disproportionate to the scope of the evidence.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
The English language used in the manuscript is generally understandable and grammatically acceptable. However, several sections would benefit from careful linguistic revision to improve clarity, precision, and academic tone. In particular, some formulations are overly assertive or normative, and certain sentences are structurally complex, which may obscure the intended meaning. A thorough professional language editing would enhance readability, conceptual clarity, and overall scholarly quality.
Author Response
Reviewer 3
Comment 1: The theoretical framework requires strengthening. While the literature review is informative, it remains largely descriptive and does not sufficiently integrate established acceleration decision frameworks (e.g., multi-criteria models such as the Iowa Acceleration Scale, contemporary conceptualizations of twice-exceptionality, or theoretical models of gifted development). The manuscript would benefit from a clearer conceptual model explicitly guiding the study.
Response: The theoretical framework has been strengthened by integrating the approved acceleration decision-making frameworks through the introduction of a clearer conceptual model that explicitly guides the study.
Comment2: The research objectives and design require clarification. The study is described as qualitative-quantitative, yet no explicit mixed-methods framework is articulated. It remains unclear whether the design is exploratory, explanatory, or instrumental. Furthermore, the categories of “Even,” “Uneven,” and “Declining Uneven” profiles should be clarified as either theoretically predefined or analytically derived.
Response: The research objectives and main question were more clearly defined.
A clear framework for the mixed-methods approach was established. The design type (instrumental case study) was also defined; the cases are examined primarily to provide insights into a broader issue or to enhance theoretical understanding. The three cases serve as instrumental tools for understanding the broader phenomenon of acceleration decision-making and for illustrating the application of the integrated assessment model. The cases were not chosen for their inherent uniqueness, but rather because they represent distinct academic and cognitive profiles that can illuminate the complexities of the acceleration decision-making process. Furthermore, the categories of "equal," "unequal," and "decreasing unequal" were clarified, and it was explained whether they are theoretically predetermined ". The three cases were initially identified based on their academic performance patterns over the three semesters prior to the study. The Cognitive Abilities Test (CogAT) was subsequently administered to validate and deepen understanding of these classifications"
Comment 3: The predictive linear model used to generate academic expectations lacks sufficient methodological transparency. The manuscript should explicitly present the model specification, assumptions, and validation procedures. Without this, interpretation of performance gaps remains largely descriptive.
Response: The linear predictive model used to determine academic expectations and the methodology for its implementation were explained. A clear presentation of the model's specifications, assumptions, and validation procedures was also given.
Comment 5: The Psychosocial and Dispositional Assessment Scale (PDAS), being researcher-developed, requires stronger evidence of construct validity beyond internal consistency. Reporting Cronbach’s alpha alone is insufficient to establish instrument validity.
Response: The scale description has been rewritten and clarified that the scale is adapted from the IAS scale, which is an existing approved tool; we emphasized that adaptation is methodologically sound and common in cross-cultural research; and we acknowledged adaptation as a limitation and called for future validation studies.
Comment 6: causal interpretations linking acceleration to psychosocial distress should be moderated. Given the case study design (n=3), conclusions must remain at the level of analytic generalization rather than policy-level inference. Statements advocating “fundamental transformation” of national policies are currently disproportionate to the scope of the evidence.
Response: The discussion section has been rewritten to address the concerns you raised in your important note by adopting a more moderate and reserved tone, explicitly acknowledging the limitations of the study, and framing the findings as illustrative rather than definitive.
Comment: The manuscript currently suffers from fundamental theoretical, methodological, and analytical limitations that weaken its scientific rigor and the generalizability of its findings. These limitations include insufficient conceptual integration.
Response: The adequacy of conceptual integration was achieved by establishing a theoretical framework has been strengthened by integrating the approved acceleration decision-making frameworks through the introduction of a clearer conceptual model that explicitly guides the study.
Comment: Lines 8-16: The summary presents conclusions before clearly defining the methodological design and analytical framework; please clarify the study design, analytical strategy, and precise scientific contribution.
Response: The systematic design and analytical framework were clearly defined, and the study design, analytical strategy, and scientific contribution were accurately explained.
Comment: Lines 16-23: The claim that composite scores are "highly misleading" should be softened or supported by a clearer analytical justification (e.g., specifying variance thresholds or the rationale for profile analysis).
Response: The claim that composite scores are "largely misleading" was mitigated by supporting it with a clearer analytical justification that is consistent with the acceleration policy and the evaluation of accelerated student profiles in the Saudi context.
Comment: Lines 31-40: It would be helpful for the introduction to include a deeper theoretical integration with established decision-making frameworks in the field of acceleration (such as the Iowa Accelerator Scale or multi-criteria models) to place the study within the broader context of existing research.
Response: We would like to clarify that our study did not aim to compare available decision-making tools, but rather to conduct a critical examination of acceleration policies as they are actually implemented in Saudi Arabia. In this context, whole-grade acceleration decisions rely on a national program that heavily weights students' scores on a standardized examination, without incorporating a comprehensive assessment of cognitive profiles or psychosocial readiness.
We therefore selected the cases of S.L. and T.M. specifically to demonstrate how a score-driven policy can lead to a mismatch between student needs and the demands of an accelerated placement, along with the resulting academic and psychological risks. The questionable decisions in these two cases were not due to a flawed assessment instrument, but rather because the system at that time did not mandate or routinely employ the kind of deep, multidimensional evaluation required.
Accordingly, we have revised the manuscript in three key areas:
- Acknowledgment of the Integrated Acceleration System (IAS)as a contemporary exemplar of the comprehensive, team-based, data-driven approach we advocate for.
- Contextual clarification that the limitations in decision-making observed in our case studies are attributable to the Saudi policy framework in place at the time of the students' acceleration, which prioritized examination scores over holistic evaluation.
- Strengthened policy implications emphasizing that shifting from a score-driven policy to a comprehensive, student-profile-based evaluation methodology is no longer merely a theoretical recommendation but a critical necessity to ensure acceleration is an appropriate and beneficial intervention for all gifted students, especially those with uneven cognitive profiles.
These revisions appropriately contextualize our findings within the existing Saudi system while acknowledging the reviewer's important point regarding the availability of more advanced decision-making frameworks internationally.
Comment: Lines 47-55: The research problem has been described descriptively; please reformulate it to be formulated as clearly defined research objectives and explicit research questions, if possible.
Response: The research problem and the gap it addresses were clearly defined in the introduction, in alignment with the reviewers’ feedback. The objectives, along with the main and sub-questions, were stated with precision to streamline the paper and stay within the page limit after incorporating the required revisions.
Comment: Lines 56-70: The central research question is broad in scope; please define the key concepts more precisely (e.g., cognitive compatibility, academic path, psychosocial readiness).
Response :We would like to clarify that the broad formulation of the central research question was intentional, as it aligns with the methodological design of the study, which is based on a holistic case study approach. In this design, each of the three cases is treated as an integrated whole, not as a collection of separate variables. Within this framework, it is neither possible nor appropriate to separate cognitive, academic, and psychosocial dimensions, as the primary goal is to understand the interplay and interconnectedness of these elements within the context of each individual case, and how this integration contributes to forming a comprehensive picture regarding the effectiveness of the acceleration decision.
Accordingly, for each case we examined:
- The cognitive profile using the Cognitive Abilities Test (CogAT),
- The academic trajectory through academic performance analysis using predictive modeling,
- The psychosocial readiness using the PDAS scale and interviews with students, teachers, and parents.
These three dimensions were then analyzed together within each case to reach an integrated judgment regarding the appropriateness and effectiveness of acceleration. Therefore, formulating the research question to encompass these three dimensions within a single framework accurately reflects the nature of the integrated analysis conducted and aligns with the methodological philosophy of the study.
Nevertheless, in order to address the reviewer's comment, we have revised the wording of the central research question in the final manuscript to include a brief definition of the three key concepts (cognitive alignment, academic trajectory, psychosocial readiness), while noting that they are addressed in an integrated manner within the analysis of each case. This clarification has been incorporated at the end of the aforementioned section to ensure clarity without compromising the integrated nature of the analysis.
Comment: Lines 71-76: The argument concerning composite grade constraints should be formulated theoretically rather than stated normatively.
Response: The argument concerning composite score constraints was rewritten and reformulated theoretically.
Comment: The claim that the study is the "first" in the Saudi context should be phrased with caution.
Response: regarding the use of the term "first." We acknowledge that such claims should be made with caution, as it is always possible that similar studies may have been conducted but not identified in our literature review, or may exist in unpublished formats. In accordance with the reviewer's suggestion, we have revised the text to replace the definitive claim of being "the first" with a more cautious and precise formulation: "a novel approach within the Saudi context to the best of our knowledge." This revised phrasing accurately reflects the originality of the study's methodology—specifically its integration of cognitive assessment (CogAT), predictive academic modeling, and multi-stakeholder psychosocial evaluation within a mixed-methods, multi-case design—while acknowledging the inherent limitations of claiming absolute precedence. We appreciate the reviewer's guidance in strengthening the academic rigor and precision of our manuscript.
Comment: Lines 86-134: The literature review is largely descriptive; it should be enhanced by critical synthesis and a clearer formulation of the conceptual model guiding the study.
Response: The literature was reviewed and enhanced through critical synthesis and addition to the conceptual model guiding the study.
Comment: Lines 136-155: Please include a more balanced discussion of both the documented benefits and risks or the limiting conditions for acceleration.
Response: A more balanced discussion of both the documented benefits and risks or the limiting conditions for acceleration was included in the study.
Comment: Lines 180-214: The contextual background is informative but needs to be more clearly linked to the methodological choices of the study.
Response: Many important aspects have been covered in this research, necessitating the omission of contextual background due to page constraints. Furthermore, several sections have been added, including one summarizing the social, emotional, and psychological aspects of acceleration, further divided into evidence-based strengths and evidence-based weaknesses in the literature. A separate section addresses acceleration techniques and implementation challenges. Other sections are also included.
Comment: Lines 215-226: It would be helpful to describe the national selection criteria by comparing them with international standards for identifying and accelerating giftedness.
Response: We thank the reviewer for this insightful suggestion. We agree that comparing national selection criteria with international standards for identifying and accelerating gifted students would be a valuable endeavor that could yield important insights for policy development and educational practice.
However, we wish to clarify that such a comparative analysis falls outside the scope of the present study. Our research was specifically designed to conduct an in-depth, contextualized examination of three individual cases of accelerated students within the Saudi educational system. The primary aim was not to evaluate or compare the Saudi national selection criteria against international benchmarks, but rather to explore, through rich qualitative and quantitative case study data, how the alignment—or misalignment—between a student's cognitive profile, academic trajectory, and psychosocial readiness influences the outcomes of the acceleration decision as it is currently implemented in Saudi Arabia.
The focus on three purposively selected cases allowed for a nuanced, multi-perspective understanding of the acceleration experience from the viewpoints of students, teachers, and parents. This depth of analysis, while essential for understanding the complexities of individual cases, does not lend itself to broader comparative generalizations about national policies or international standards.
We fully agree with the reviewer that comparing Saudi Arabia's acceleration criteria with international standards represents an important direction for future research. Such a study could build upon the findings presented here and provide a more comprehensive understanding of how Saudi policies align with or diverge from global best practices. We have noted this suggestion in the revised manuscript as a potential avenue for future investigation.
Comment: Lines 228-233: Please explain whether the case study design is exploratory, interpretive, or instrumental, and justify its consistency with the research objectives.
Response: A new part titled” Study Design: A Mixed-Methods Instrumental Case Study “explained that the study employs a mixed-methods instrumental case study design and justify its consistency with the research objectives. “In an instrumental case study, cases are examined not for their intrinsic uniqueness but as vehicles for providing insight into a broader issue or refining theoretical understanding. Here, the three cases serve as instrumental vehicles for understanding the broader phenomenon of acceleration decision-making and for illustrating the application of an integrated assessment model. This design is particularly suited for exploring complex, real-world phenomena within their natural context, especially when the boundaries between the phenomenon and its context are not clearly defined.”
Comment: Lines 250-259: The manuscript describes a qualitative-quantitative design; please specify the framework for the mixed-methods search used (e.g., convergent parallel, interpretive sequential).
Response: The qualitative-quantitative design was identified; and the framework for the mixed-methods research used was defined. The study follows the concurrent triangulation design (Creswell & Plano Clark, 2018), characterized by: Simultaneous data collection: Quantitative data (CogAT, academic records, PDAS) and qualitative data (semi-structured interviews) were collected during the same phase of the study; Independent analysis: Quantitative data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and predictive linear modeling. Qualitative data were analyzed using thematic analysis to identify patterns and themes across cases and stakeholders; And, Integration at interpretation: Findings from both data sources were merged during the interpretation phase to compare, contrast, and synthesize evidence for each case, enabling a holistic assessment of the alignment between cognitive, academic, and psychosocial factors.
Comment: Lines 253-254: Please clarify whether the "consistent," "inconsistent," and "inconsistent regression" files are predefined or inferred inductively from the data.
Response: It was explained that the "consistent," "inconsistent," and "inconsistent regression" files were inductively extracted from the data in the Results section.
Comment: Lines 260-262: Explain how triangulation is applied practically and how the discrepancies between different sources are addressed analytically.
Response: A text explained concurrent triangulation design has been added to the Study Design: A Mixed-Methods Instrumental Case Study: “Simultaneous data collection: Quantitative data (CogAT, academic records, PDAS) and qualitative data (semi-structured interviews) were collected during the same phase of the study; Independent analysis: Quantitative data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and predictive linear modeling. Qualitative data were analyzed using thematic analysis to identify patterns and themes across cases and stakeholders; and Integration at interpretation: Findings from both data sources were merged during the interpretation phase to compare, contrast, and synthesize evidence for each case, enabling a holistic assessment of the alignment between cognitive, academic, and psychosocial factors.”
Comment: Lines 265-275: The small sample size (3 cases) is suitable for in-depth case analysis, but the conclusions must be explicitly stated as being limited to analytical generalization, not statistical generalization.
Response: I have added in section 7 (Discussion) – First Paragraph: “While the findings from this small-scale, qualitative multiple-case study are not generalizable in a statistical sense, they offer suggestive evidence that reinforces and provides nuanced illustrations of themes from the broader literature on gifted education (Assouline et al., 2015; Steenbergen-Hu et al., 2016).". This paragraph comes close but uses the phrase "not generalizable in a statistical sense" without explicitly using the term "analytical generalization" or clearly stating that generalization is to theory rather than population.
Also, 2. Section 9 (Study Limitations and Future Directions) – First Paragraph: "The first is the study's small sample size: while it was based on three carefully selected cases from the Al-Ahsa region, chosen to reflect diverse cognitive and academic profiles, the findings may still be limited in their applicability to all gifted students in Saudi Arabia who are eligible for acceleration.". This paragraph discusses limitations in applicability but does not clarify the distinction between statistical and analytical generalization.
Comment: Lines 288-291: Provide more detailed information on ethical consent, including the reference number and data protection procedures.
Response: all information in “Institutional Review Board Statement: The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki, and approved by the Scientific Research Ethics Committee at King Faisal University (protocol code KFU-2026-ETHICS3989 and date of approval 12 October 2025).
Comment: Lines 294-317: Please clarify whether the CogAT test criteria are culturally appropriate for the Saudi context, and whether local criteria have been considered.
Response: we add text to instrument section explicitly stated that Aboud and AlAli (2023) validated the test with Saudi children “Importantly, the cultural appropriateness and psychometric validity of the CogAT for use in the Saudi context have been established by Aboud and AlAli (2023), who conducted a validation study of the test with Saudi children. Their findings confirmed that the CogAT demonstrates adequate reliability and validity for assessing cognitive abilities among Saudi students, supporting its use in this study. This validation addresses concerns regarding the applicability of internationally developed assessment tools in the Saudi educational context.
Aboud, A., & AlAli, R. (2023). Validation of the Cognitive Abilities Tests (CogAT®) for Saudi children. ArtsEduca, 37(2), 1–17. https://doi.org/10.58262/ArtsEduca.3701
Note that for wording limit we couldn’t add validity and reliability coefficients of CogAt inside the tool descriptions.
Comment: Lines 319-337: The Psychosocial and Aptitude Assessment Scale (PDAS), being researcher-developed, requires additional evidence of construct validity, and it is best to conduct an exploratory or confirmatory factor analysis.
Response: The scale description has been rewritten and clarified that the scale is adapted from the IAS scale, which is an existing approved tool; we emphasized that adaptation is methodologically sound and common in cross-cultural research; and we acknowledged adaptation as a limitation and called for future validation studies. we add a text explaining “While these values indicate good internal consistency, the adapted nature of the instrument is acknowledged as a limitation, and future research should conduct more comprehensive validation procedures, including confirmatory factor analysis.” To the scale description.
Comment: Line 4: Please clarify the time structure of the study (cross-sectional vs. longitudinal) and address the possibility of retrospective bias.
Response: Given the instrumental case study methodology employed, which focuses on in-depth, contextual analysis of purposefully selected cases rather than on temporal comparisons between groups, the traditional distinction between cross-sectional and longitudinal designs is not applicable; moreover, the findings are not subject to retrospective bias as the three cases were intentionally selected to represent distinct cognitive and academic profiles, and data were triangulated from multiple sources—students, teachers, and parents—collected concurrently to ensure interpretive validity.
Comment: Lines 408-414: The results of the predictive model should include a clearer explanation of how the "prediction" values are calculated.
Response: A clear and comprehensive explanation of how to analyze the data was provided. A predictive linear model was used to analyze academic performance and calculate "predictive" values.
Comment: Lines 417-422: Interpreting performance gaps should be done with caution, clarifying whether these differences are statistically significant or merely descriptive comparisons.
Response: We added text to data analysis as follows “The performance gaps in this study are descriptive and not subject to statistical significance tests, as the case study methodology relies on analytical generalization rather than statistical inference (Yin, 2018), and the small sample size (three cases) does not allow for meaningful statistical analysis. These gaps serve as exploratory tools, interpreted in conjunction with cognitive, psychological, and qualitative data, thus ensuring a rich contextual understanding of each case.” To fulfil the request.
Comment: Lines 491-496: When describing composite scores as misleading, please explain the analytical rationale for this (e.g., size of variance in the profile).
Response: analytical ratione explanation for size of variance in Section 4.2 (Even vs. Uneven Cognitive Profile Framework” The composite score, by averaging across domains, can mask critical discrepancies that are essential for determining the appropriateness of acceleration. The analytical rationale for this concern lies in the degree of variability across cognitive domains. When a student exhibits significant discrepancies—operationalized in this study as a standard deviation exceeding 1.5 across battery scores or a range greater than 20 percentile points—the composite score averages these divergent abilities, obscuring critical information about domain-specific strengths and weaknesses. Such variability indicates that the composite score does not accurately reflect the student's cognitive profile and may lead to inappropriate placement decisions if used as the sole criterion for acceleration.; and the profiles of S.L and T.M in Section 4.2: Analytical rationale with operationalized thresholds (SD > 1.5, range > 20 percentile points)”; in Section 6.1.2: Quantified variance for S.L. (SD = 28.2, range = 49 SAS points); and in Section 6.1.3: Quantified variance for T.M. (SD = 10.6, range = 19 SAS points).
Comment: Lines 505-515: Claims regarding percentile ranking within the chapter need to clarify the size of the reference group and the method of calculation.
Response: Explanations regarding percentile ranking, Standard Age Score (SAS); Stanine (S) , have been added below table 1 . As: Standard Age Score (SAS) – A normalized score with a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 16, allowing comparison to same-age peers. Scores range from 50 to 150, with 100 representing average performance for the age group; 2. Percentile Rank (P.R.) – Shows the percentage of students in the same age or grade group who scored lower. For example, a percentile of 85 means the student performed better than 85% of peers. Ranges from 1 to 99. And 3. Stanine (S) – A simplified 9-point scale (1 = lowest, 9 = highest) that groups percentile ranks into broad performance levels (e.g., below average, average, above average). Useful for general classification without fine-grained detail.
Comment: Lines 608-612: References to the possibility of dyscalculia should be formulated as hypotheses requiring formal diagnostic evaluation, not as accepted findings.
Response: we revised to indicate that a comprehensive assessment would determine whether she exhibits such difficulties, treating dyscalculia as a hypothesis to be investigated and changed to conditional/hypothetical language (e.g., "would benefit from," "to determine whether," "raises the hypothesis"). The new text: “The observed pattern of quantitative and nonverbal cognitive deficits in S.L. raises the hypothesis that specific learning difficulties in mathematics (e.g., dyscalculia) may be contributing to her academic challenges. However, confirmation of this would require a formal diagnostic evaluation by a qualified specialist. Such an assessment would be essential to identify the precise nature of her difficulties and to design appropriate interventions that address her academic, emotional, and social needs. Furthermore, guidance would be provided to her parents to support her effectively.”
Comment: Lines 623-633: Avoid inferring broader limitations in cognitive processing that go beyond what the Cogat test directly measures.
Response: we avoided inferring broader limitations in cognitive processing that go beyond what the Cogat test directly measures by: in the text ” His cognitive profile suggests: T.M.'s limited fluid reasoning and strategic processing" : we removed "strategic processing"; fluid reasoning is retained as what the Nonverbal battery measures; in the text ”He applies strategies mechanically, struggles to connect new tasks to prior learning, and acquires " new skills at a slower rate than peers" : we removed entirely; these inferences extend beyond what the CogAT directly measures. (The whole text below table 7 has been rewritten) to fulfil the reviewer important comment.
Comment: Lines 642-650: Interpreting academic decline should take into account alternative explanations (such as difficulty of curriculum, or incompatibility of teaching method).
Response: In response to reviewer concerns, explicit alternative explanations were added, including the increased difficulty and slower pace of the accelerated curriculum. To address the mismatch between teaching methods, a reference was added to potential mismatches between teaching methods and learning needs. To avoid a one-factor interpretation, the text was revised to acknowledge the interaction of multiple factors (curriculum requirements, teaching style, and cognitive characteristics). Finally, to acknowledge the complexity, phrases were added indicating that multiple factors may contribute to the decline.
Comment: Lines 685-693: Causal explanations related to psychosocial deterioration should be tempered given the nature of the case study design.
Response: We rewrote the text to soften causal interpretations by adding explicit statements acknowledging that definitive causal inferences could not be drawn due to the case study design. We also added cautionary statements about interpreting observations in light of the exploratory nature of the case study methodology. Furthermore, we avoided attributing causation solely to acceleration; we reformulated the text to suggest patterns and correlations rather than direct causation. We considered alternative factors and acknowledged the complex interplay of factors, including curriculum requirements, cognitive characteristics, and pre-existing differences. Finnlay, to maintain descriptive accuracy, the direct advisor's citation was retained as a qualitative observation without imposing a causal explanation.
Comment: Lines 596-614: The recommendation for partial acceleration would benefit from having a more formal decision-making framework or criteria matrix.
Response: The section was reformulated to incorporate a more formal decision-making framework or criteria matrix for recommending partial acceleration.
Comment: Lines 472-484; 596-607; 677-679: Clearly distinguish between experimental and interpretive research when formulating acceleration.
Response: All three acceleration decisions were reformulated in order to clearly distinguish between the experimental and the interpretive researcher when formulating the acceleration decision.
Comment: Throughout the Results section: Please include a structured cross-case comparative analysis to synthesize patterns across the three profiles.
Response: A structured comparative analysis between different cases to group patterns across the three profiles was included throughout the Results section.
Round 2
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe revised manuscript addresses a relevant and underexplored topic in gifted education, namely decision-making processes in academic acceleration within a specific national context. The authors are to be commended for the effort invested in revising the manuscript, particularly in improving the clarity of the research design, strengthening elements of methodological transparency, and refining aspects of the analytical procedures.
Notwithstanding these improvements, several important issues remain that require further attention in order to ensure the scientific robustness and clarity expected for publication.
First, although the methodological section has been strengthened, further clarification is still needed regarding the validation of the researcher-developed instrument (PDAS). While internal consistency is reported, additional evidence of construct validity would be important to support its use and interpretation.
Second, the analytical component would benefit from a more explicit and structured cross-case comparative analysis. As highlighted in the overall evaluation (see Overall Evaluation, p. 3 ), the manuscript would be strengthened by systematically integrating findings across the three cases, rather than presenting them predominantly in isolation. This would enhance the analytical coherence and the contribution of the study.
Third, some interpretations—particularly those concerning cognitive profiles, academic discrepancies, and psychosocial outcomes—should be presented with greater caution. Given the case-based nature of the study and the limited sample size, it is essential to clearly distinguish between empirical findings and interpretative inferences.
Fourth, the policy and educational implications should be further moderated and explicitly framed within the exploratory scope of the study. As noted in the evaluation (see Overall Evaluation, pp. 3–4 ), some conclusions currently extend beyond what the data can fully support.
Finally, minor improvements in clarity, consistency of terminology, and overall coherence would further enhance the readability and scientific quality of the manuscript.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe English language used in the manuscript is generally understandable and grammatically acceptable. However, several sections would benefit from careful linguistic revision to improve clarity, precision, and academic tone. In particular, some formulations are overly assertive or normative, and certain sentences are structurally complex, which may obscure the intended meaning. A thorough professional language editing would enhance readability, conceptual clarity, and overall scholarly quality.
Author Response
I would like to mention that your valuable comments from the second review round have been available on the journal’s website for approximately 15 days. During this time, I carefully revised the research according to your insightful feedback and prepared detailed responses to each comment. I waited until the website system enabled me to reply to all comments and upload the revised version of the manuscript. I would like to sincerely thank you for your thoughtful and constructive remarks, which greatly contributed to improving the quality of the research and making it more suitable for publication in this journal.
Comments:
The revised manuscript addresses a relevant and underexplored topic in gifted education, namely decision-making processes in academic acceleration within a specific national context. The authors are to be commended for the effort invested in revising the manuscript, particularly in improving the clarity of the research design, strengthening elements of methodological transparency, and refining aspects of the analytical procedures.
Notwithstanding these improvements, several important issues remain that require further attention in order to ensure the scientific robustness and clarity expected for publication.
Comment1: First, although the methodological section has been strengthened, further clarification is still needed regarding the validation of the researcher-developed instrument (PDAS). While internal consistency is reported, additional evidence of construct validity would be important to support its use and interpretation
Response: Thank you for your important comment. In addition to the internal consistency of the PDAS scale using Cronbach's α, two items were added to verify its validity by gathering primary evidence on the construct validity of the adapted scale to support its appropriate interpretation and use. Since the PDAS scale is a culturally adapted version of the Iowa Acceleration Scale (IAS; Assouline et al., 2009) and not an innovative scale developed from scratch, validity evidence was gathered using two approaches: content validity and logical validity. )PAGED 415-455)
Comment2: Second, the analytical component would benefit from a more explicit and structured cross-case comparative analysis. As highlighted in the overall evaluation (see Overall Evaluation, p. 3), the manuscript would be strengthened by systematically integrating findings across the three cases, rather than presenting them predominantly in isolation. This would enhance the analytical coherence and the contribution of the study.
Response: Thank you for your valuable observation; I have read your recommendation carefully that the analytical component would benefit from systematically integrating findings across the three cases rather than presenting them predominantly in isolation.
After deep reflection on the manuscript's structure, methodology, and analytical objectives, I respectfully explain why the current presentation format is not only appropriate but optimal for the study's aims. Below, I clarify the rationale for maintaining the case-by-case presentation structure, supported by methodological, analytical, and reader-clarity considerations.
- Methodological Integrity of the Case Study Design: The study employs an instrumental multiple-case study design (Stake, 1995; Yin, 2018), in which each case is examined first as a unique, bounded system before cross-case synthesis occurs. As Yin (2018) emphasizes, a fundamental principle of rigorous case study research is that each individual case must be understood on its own terms before any cross-case patterns are drawn. Premature cross-case aggregation risks losing the contextual richness that gives case study methodology its distinctive value.
In the manuscript, I explicitly follow this canon: Section 6.1.1 presents Case 1 (M.F.) as a complete, self-contained unit: cognitive profile, academic trajectory, psychosocial assessment, and the resulting acceleration decision; Section 6.1.2 presents Case 2 (S.L.) with identical structural integrity; and Section 6.1.3 presents Case 3 (T.M.) following the same methodological template.
This parallel case structure ensures that each case is transparent, auditable, and interpretable independently. A reader interested only in even-profile outcomes can consult Case 1 directly; a reader focused on twice-exceptional presentations can turn to Case 2. This is not a weakness but a deliberate design feature consistent with best practices in case study reporting.
- Cross-Case Analysis Already Exists in Section 7 (Discussion): The reviewer's comment suggests that cross-case integration is absent from the manuscript. With respect, this is inaccurate. Section 7 (Discussion) already provides extensive cross-case comparative analysis. Specifically:
- Page 30 of the manuscript explicitly compares all three cases along multiple dimensions: "The three cases examined in this study were selected to illustrate the critical role of alignment—or misalignment—between a student's cognitive profile, academic performance, and psychosocial support system."
- The discussion systematically contrasts M.F.'s "even high" profile with S.L.'s "uneven" profile and T.M.'s "declining uneven" profile, stating: "In the case of Student M.F., the data painted a coherent picture... In contrast, the experiences of Students S.L. and T.M. illustrate the potential risks when acceleration is applied to students whose profiles are not well-aligned with the demands of a full-grade skip."
- The discussion addresses parental support patterns across all three cases, noting: "The case of Student M.F. demonstrates how well-aligned, encouraging parental involvement can support a successful acceleration experience. However, the cases of S.L. and T.M. suggest that parental support, even when well-intentioned, can become a source of stress..."
Thus, the cross-case synthesis that the reviewer requests is already present in the manuscript. It is located where it belongs methodologically: after the individual case presentations, in the Discussion section, where interpretation and synthesis appropriately reside.
- The Current Results Presentation Provides Superior Organizational Clarity
The current results presentation offers a consistent comparative structure where each case follows an identical organizational template including: Cognitive Ability Assessment (CogAT); Academic Achievement Assessment (including predictive modeling tables); Psychosocial and Dispositional Assessment (PDAS); and the Acceleration Decision.
This structural parallelism allows readers to locate comparable information instantly across cases. A reader seeking to compare CogAT profiles across all three students knows exactly where to look in each case subsection. This is more, not less, analytically coherent than interweaving cases within a single narrative stream. It also enables visual accessibility.
Furthermore, the current results presentation preserves case integrity, as the fundamental threat to validity in multiple-case studies is loss of case-specific context when findings are decontextualized and aggregated prematurely.
Moreover, Section 1 (Introduction) and Section 4 (Theoretical Models) of the manuscript already establish the comparative framework. The research question itself is explicitly comparative: "How can an integrated model... inform individualized acceleration decision-making... and what do cases representing even, uneven, and declining-uneven profiles reveal about the alignment conditions necessary for successful acceleration?"
The answer to this comparative question is provided in the Discussion section, which explicitly compares the three cases' outcomes and identifies the alignment conditions that differentiated success from failure.
Comment: Third, some interpretations—particularly those concerning cognitive profiles, academic discrepancies, and psychosocial outcomes—should be presented with greater caution. Given the case-based nature of the study and the limited sample size, it is essential to clearly distinguish between empirical findings and interpretative inferences.
Response: The discussion section has been rewritten according to the reviewer's comments to directly and effectively address their concerns through a clear, consistent, and systematic separation between empirical findings (what the data objectively show) and interpretive inferences (the researcher's cautious, context-bound conclusions). (PP: 965- 1128).
This was achieved by:
- Clear Distinction: Using the labels "Empirical Finding" and "Interpretive Inference (with caution)" for each major claim, thereby eliminating any ambiguity.
- Cautious Language: Framing the interpretive sections with qualifiers such as "suggest that," "is consistent with the possibility that," "cannot be ruled out," "logical extrapolation," and "hypothetical." Causal words like "caused," "impacted," or "as a result of" were explicitly avoided and replaced with associational language ("association," "is consistent with").
- Explicit Acknowledgment of Limitations: Repeatedly and explicitly acknowledging the study's limitations, including the small, non-generalizable sample (N=3; Yin, 2018), the lack of a control group and baseline measures, and the impossibility of determining causality or the direction of effects.
- Hypothesis-Generating, Not Confirmatory, Framing: Consistently framing conclusions as "exploratory and hypothesis-generating" rather than definitive or confirmatory.
Comment4: Fourth, the policy and educational implications should be further moderated and explicitly framed within the exploratory scope of the study. As noted in the evaluation (see Overall Evaluation, pp. 3–4 ), some conclusions currently extend beyond what the data can fully support.
Response: we added new text to introduction, the revised text directly fulfills the reviewer's request by explicitly framing the study within its exploratory scope, moderating all claims, and ensuring that no conclusion extends beyond what the data can support. (PP: 105- 129).
Original Statement Amended Statement: "Revealing necessary compatibility conditions" "Proposing compatibility conditions that may be related to" "Aims to provide empirical insights that can be utilized." "Aims to provide preliminary exploratory insights that can serve as a starting point for..."
Regarding the comment "No statement of limitations," Amended: "Because this is a small-scale qualitative multivariate case study (number of cases = 3), the results are exploratory and hypothesis-generative." Regarding the comment "No statement of replication” Amended: "The study needs to be replicated with larger samples, control groups, and longitudinal designs before any definitive conclusions can be drawn."
Comment 5: Finally, minor improvements in clarity, consistency of terminology, and overall coherence would further enhance the readability and scientific quality of the manuscript.
Response: Numerous improvements have been made to clarity, consistency of terminology, and overall coherence.
Comment 6: Quality of English Language: The English language used in the manuscript is generally understandable and grammatically acceptable. However, several sections would benefit from careful linguistic revision to improve clarity, precision, and academic tone. In particular, some formulations are overly assertive or normative, and certain sentences are structurally complex, which may obscure the intended meaning. A thorough professional language editing would enhance readability, conceptual clarity, and overall scholarly quality.
Response: The manuscript sections underwent careful linguistic review to improve clarity, accuracy, and academic style, and to modify overly emphatic or standardized wording.
Round 3
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript has improved substantially across the revision process and now presents a clearer and more methodologically coherent contribution to the field of gifted education and academic acceleration decision-making. The author has responded appropriately to the major concerns previously raised, particularly regarding theoretical integration, clarification of the mixed-methods instrumental case study design, moderation of causal interpretations, stronger justification of the exploratory nature of the tri-case approach, and improved proportionality of conclusions.
The inclusion of a clearer conceptual framework integrating CHC theory, cognitive profile analysis, psychosocial readiness, and person-environment fit significantly strengthens the scientific consistency of the study. The clarification of the predictive academic performance model and the improved explanation of the adapted PDAS instrument also enhance methodological transparency.
The manuscript now appropriately acknowledges the exploratory and hypothesis-generating nature of the study, avoiding excessive generalisation from the small sample size (N = 3), which is particularly important for maintaining scientific rigour. The distinction between empirical findings and researcher interpretation is now considerably clearer, and policy implications are presented with greater caution and proportionality.
Although some minor editorial improvements may still be beneficial - particularly regarding language polishing, reduction of occasional redundancy, and further refinement of table and figure presentation - these do not compromise the scientific merit of the work.
Overall, the manuscript addresses an important and underexplored issue within gifted education, particularly in the Saudi Arabian context, and offers relevant practical and theoretical contributions to acceleration decision-making frameworks. In its current form, the manuscript is suitable for publication after minor editorial revision.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe English language used in the manuscript is generally understandable and grammatically acceptable. However, several sections would benefit from careful linguistic revision to improve clarity, precision, and academic tone. In particular, some formulations are overly assertive or normative, and certain sentences are structurally complex, which may obscure the intended meaning. A thorough professional language editing would enhance readability, conceptual clarity, and overall scholarly quality.
Author Response
I would like to express my deep gratitude for your valuable feedback, which has contributed to elevating the research to a higher level, befitting the journal Behaviural Science.
Comment: Abstract:
In spite of the significant changes made to the contents of the main body of the article, the abstract does not appear to have been changed to reflect this updated content and requires alignment with the revised version of the article.
Response: Reply: The summary has been revised based on your important comments to reflect the changes in rounds two and three.
Introduction:
Reads significantly more coherently and provides a good rationale for the context of the study and its contribution to the field. However throughout the statements and claims still need to be tempered a little and engaged with a little more critically.
Comment: For example, the first sentence states 'Academic acceleration has long been recognised as an effective strategy for meeting the needs of students with exceptional abilities' This opening is provided as a statement of fact when actually the issue is a lot more contentious than this and while this strategy has a number of vocal advocates it also has a number of strong critics. The authors touch on some of these challenges later but there needs to be a more moderated, critically engaged perspective on this strategy from the start. It is one tool in the box that may be effective depending on the context and the learner.
Response: Instead of the original sentence presenting acceleration as a "fact," the introduction now acknowledges the existence of controversy (both supporters and opponents), and emphasizes that acceleration is "one tool among many" that depends on the context and the learner.
To improve the introduction and make it more coherent without repetition: The repeated explanations of the composite score constraints (mentioned only once) were removed. Multiple references to "equal/unequal" were condensed into a single, clear paragraph.
The repeated account of the Saudi challenges was removed (it is now a single sentence with several references). The description of the methodology and its novelty was shortened.
The key caveats (small sample size, exploratory) were retained without repetition.
Finally, the transitions between paragraphs were improved for easier reading.
The assertive language was softened by replacing phrases like "has long been recognized as an effective strategy" with more cautious expressions such as "has long been a subject of debate" and "a substantial body of research advocates... On the other hand, acceleration has attracted strong critics." (PP: 1,2 LINES: 31-55)
Comment: There are also significant country/ cultural differences in its adoption for example acceleration is more often employed in the US but rarely in UK/Ireland. So in considering the references employed for the literature review on acceleration when making arguments about global implications it is important to ensure the literature around acceleration is not predominantly US based.
Response: Thank you for the valuable observation that there are significant differences between countries and cultures in the adoption of the concept of acceleration. The term "acceleration" is commonly used in the United States, while it is rarely used in the United Kingdom and Ireland. We would like to emphasize that the references used to review studies on acceleration include numerous Saudi and international studies, not primarily those from the United States, as detailed below:
- Saudi studies : Aboud, Y. (2021): Directly evaluates acceleration in Saudi schools; Aboud, Y. (2023) and Aboud, 2025: Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries (acceleration program included); Al‑Ablan, A. (2021): Focuses on accelerated gifted female students in a Saudi context; Alarfaj, A. & Al‑Omair, R. (2020): Saudi Arabia +USA , acceleration policies: Explicitly comparative – includes a non‑US perspective; Alfaiz, F. S. et al. (2022); Aljomaih, A. (2023): Current status of gifted education in the Saudi contexts ; Almhawes, A. (2024): Doctoral dissertation specifically on Saudi acceleration; Al‑Qahtani, L. (2024): Teachers’ stories of acceleration in Saudi schools.; and Bin Yousef, J. H. (2021): Identifying interventions for Saudi students.
- Other Non‑US Countries: Ireland : Hong Kong : Cross, T. L. et al. (2018); Yuen, M. et al. (2026): Acceleration practices in a non‑Western context; Literature review: Turkey : Gulcin, Y. N. (2021) & Ogurlu, U. (2021); Spain Miravete, S. (2022), Netherland: Schuur, J. et al. (2020)
- Thank you for your valuable observation regarding the geographic scope of research on academic acceleration. I fully agree that while US-based researchers have contributed significantly to the foundational studies on acceleration, any research aiming for "global implications" must be grounded in a broader and more comprehensive international evidence base. I also agree that the adoption of acceleration practices varies considerably across cultural and national contexts (for example, their prevalence in the US and their scarcity in the UK and Ireland). In response to this issue, we have added multiple references outside of the US reference range when presenting arguments about the global effects of acceleration. Such as Cross, T. L. et al. (2018); Yuen, M. et al. (2026).
Comment: Section 1 has quite a bit of repetition in it which needs to be addressed and if made more focused and concise would divert necessary extended discussion in later sections of the introduction.
Response: Merged three repetitive sentences into two: Removed the redundant phrase “long been recognised as an effective educational strategy” and replaced with “remains contested”. Condensed multiple citations into a single parenthesis. Added a bridging phrase (“as discussed below”) to signal that detailed debate will follow later, thus reserving extended discussion for subsequent sections. And removed absolute language (“has long been recognized”, “the research evidence is substantial”) in favour of more measured wording (“advocates argue”, “a substantial body of research reports”). This version is tighter, avoids repetition, and sets up the need for the nuanced exploration that the reviewer requested.
Comment: I would also suggest section 2 and 3 which engages in the literature around acceleration and sets the foundations for investigating this approach all needs to be moved up to line 40 and lines 40- 121 need to be moved to after section 3.6.
Response: While I appreciate the elegance of your logical suggestion, the requirements of journal formatting, narrative coherence, the risk of repetition, and editorial precedent prevent me from implementing the restructuring as requested. However, I have undertaken thorough revisions to eliminate redundancies, adjust the tone, and explicitly apply the theoretical frameworks. I hope these revisions, along with this explanation, address your concerns.
Compliance with journal format: The journal follows the standard IMRaD structure: Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion. The introduction must gradually narrow from the general background to the research question. Moreover, placing the literature and theory before the statement of the Saudi problem violates this required sequence.
Narrative coherence: The current order connects theory to reality from the outset. It begins with the importance of Saudi Arabia's unique challenges, then provides the conceptual tools to analyse them. Reversing the order might confuse the reader, who would encounter abstract theory without knowing the local problem.
Maintaining a balanced critical tone: The current structure also achieves a balanced critical tone, as the Saudi context—which lacks standardised procedures, stakeholder resistance, etc.—is what shapes the relevant theories. Presenting local constraints before selecting and critiquing theories strengthens the methodological justification. Moving the Saudi context after the theories might imply universal applicability, contradicting the balanced stance.
Finally, avoiding redundancy and increasing manuscript length: Relocating approximately 80 lines of text might require duplicating essential information to maintain coherence, thereby increasing the word count and reintroducing the very repetition that the reviewers criticised.
Comment: In sections 3.2 to 3.5 a number of frameworks and models are provided but there is still a tendency to state things as fact in a few sentences when they need a more considered and nuanced discussion.
Response: Revisions made to both sections directly address the reviewer’s concern by transforming the tone from declarative and fact-like to cautiously analytical and nuanced as follows:
- Replaced definitive statements (e.g., "this framework posits" to "this framework, as discussed in the literature, suggests").
- Added explicit acknowledgment of limitations, debates, and alternative interpretations.
- Introduced conditional language (e.g., "it has been proposed," "may be," "is likely context-dependent").
- Highlighted areas where empirical evidence is lacking or were expert opinion substitutes for data.
- Clarified that models are presented as heuristics for hypothesis generation, not as proven facts. New sections
Comment: In addition, section 3.6. needs to provide a much more explicit discussion on how all of these frameworks and models will be applied in practice in the research? In what ways will they be utilised? Are they all necessary? What is the value added of using them all? For example why are you using both Person- Environment Fit Theory and Bronfenbrenner's ecosystem? And how do they work together? How is each theory/model framing each stage of your research in terms of choice of methods, choice of analysis and epistemological positioning as a researcher?
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback, which greatly improved Section 3.6. In response to your insightful comments, a clearer discussion has been provided on how all these frameworks and models are practically applied in research. This demonstrates their application and highlights the added value of combining them. It explains why both the individual-environmental adaptation theory and the Bronfenbrenner ecosystem are specifically used in this research, and how each theory/model frames each stage of the research process in terms of methodological selection, analytical approach, and the researcher's cognitive position.
Methods
Comment: 4.1. - Needs to provide greater clarification on how this research is being defined as mixed methods? In the first paragraph the authors clarify what they mean by case study but not mixed methods?
Response: Section 4.1: This section has been completely rewritten to clarify the mixed methodology, the meaning of a case study, how to combine and integrate quantitative and qualitative approaches, and the meaning of triangulation.
There remains a lack of clarity as to where the definition of even, uneven and declining profiles come from - are these from the extant literature (if so where) or developed by the author if so why? Why these three? For example, if you have declining could you not also have increasing? Why stop at three profiles?
Comment: The sentence on lines 334- 337 does not make sense so it is not possible to follow the argument being made but I would suggest that more caution is needed in the claims throughout this paragraph as to what can be achieved and the implications that can be drawn from these three case studies - they provide insight and understanding but it would be a huge leap to go from three case studies to changes in policy.
Response: The sentence in lines 371 to 384 (334- 337 previously) has been amended to make sense, taking care to make the claims in this paragraph regarding what can be achieved and the implications of the three case studies and stating that they provide insight and understanding that do not seek policy changes.
Comment: Line 339 when you say 'various codes were used' do you mean pseudonyms?
Response: Ambiguity has been removed. 'Various codes were used' was replaced with pseudonyms.
Comment: When discussing each instrument used it is important to acknowledge its potential limitations as well as its strengths and how efforts have been made to mediate any limitations e.g. by the inclusion of another instrument etc.
Response: A section was added (after the completion of the description of the tools) to discuss each tool used, acknowledging its potential limitations as well as its strengths and how efforts were made to mitigate any limitations.
Comment: 4.3.3- Need to state what analytical approach was used which facilitated interpretation in parallel to the exploration of convergent and divergent themes? In what sense were the interviews the 'primary method'?
Response: Section 4.3.3. has been amended so that the revisions directly address both of your important comments, by (a) identifying the analytical approach used to deal with convergent/distant topics, and (b) clarifying the interpretive rather than the hierarchical meaning in which interviews were “core” within the mixed methods design.
Comment: Section 5. Section appears a little contradictory it starts by saying 'to move beyond descriptive comparisons' line 428 to saying 'the performance gaps in this study are descriptive'
While I appreciate you have made an effort to mediate the sample size in used within the modelling and calibrating it against non- accelerated students and that you emphasis that the modelling was not used in isolation - is the modelling approach appropriate/necessary given the case study nature of the research and focused sample size? What does it reliably add? Also how are potential confounding variables controlled for e.g. life events, puberty, peer group pressure, changing support systems, changes in educators that could account for uneven, even profiles outwith the acceleration intervention? According to this text”
Response: Thank you for this insightful and systematic critique. You identified three legitimate problems: (1) an internal contradiction between the phrases "overcoming descriptive comparisons" and "descriptive performance gaps," (2) the suitability/necessity of a predictive model within a small case study, and (3) the failure to address potential confounding variables. The entire paragraph has been revised to address the three problems you kindly identified, as follows:
- Your observation is correct. The original text contradicts itself. The intended meaning is: The phrase "going beyond simple descriptive comparisons" means moving from comparing raw scores (e.g., "The student scored 75% after acceleration, down from 85% before") to a standardized comparison that accounts for the natural increase in difficulty and individual stability. This is still statistically descriptive (without probability values or claims of causation), but it is more informative than simply comparing pre- and post-test scores. Therefore, the phrase "going beyond simple descriptive comparisons" was replaced with "going beyond the raw differences between pre- and post-tests" to avoid any implication of statistical inference.
- Regarding your question, "Is a modeling approach appropriate/necessary given the nature of the case study and the limited sample size? What does it reliably add?": My response is that the model is not absolutely necessary for internal validity, but it serves a specific guiding function within this exploratory case study. It adds three things: standardization of expected performance—without the model, one might mistakenly interpret an 85% score after acceleration as "success" when the score before acceleration was 90%, without considering that the grade level adjustment factor means that a non-accelerated student's average drops 3–5 points when moving to a higher grade; the reliability coefficient (ω) acknowledges that students with variable performance before acceleration have less predictable trajectories. This is a descriptive improvement, not a statistical control; the standard makes clear how the researcher arrived at conclusions about whether the performance was "below," "at the level of," or "above" expectationsز
- Regarding your point that even if a student's performance declines after acceleration, the decline may be due to factors unrelated to the acceleration itself—for example, family pressures, the onset of mental health problems, peer conflict, a weak teacher, or developmental changes related to puberty—I would argue that in a small case study without a control group, confounding variables cannot be statistically controlled for or eliminated. The study design does not allow for causal attribution. At best, the study can only claim temporal correlation and contextual explanation.
Section 6
Comment: The source of the "high equivalent" and other classifications is unclear.
Response: This ambiguity was clarified in your previous comment in the "Sample" section.
Lines 520- 528
Comment: First issue is the gender switches across these lines for this student from he/she.
Response: the gender switches have been solved “M.F. has a large, well-organized base of verbal and quantitative knowledge that she can apply effectively to new learning problems.". highlighted in yellow in all texts.
Comment: Second more important issue, these sentences read like all the findings stated here come from the results in Table 1. Is that right? For example, in what way do the results from Table 1 tell us that 'M.F benefits from working with academically talented peers, usually older students'?
Response: Response: The study results have been fully revised to address the valuable concerns of the reviewers and to reflect the results in the tables more accurately and objectively.
Comment: Lines 538- 543
Lines 538- 543Begins with the statement 'M.F excels at a single subject' and finishes with 'M.F shows an even profile' - need to reflect on these contradictions.
Response: Lines 538-543 have been corrected and the inconsistencies in the section have been resolved.
Comment: Lines 545- 560
Lines 545- 560No clear account has been provided as to the analytical approach taken to the interview data - Thematic Analysis, discourse analysis etc? How has selective confirmatory bias been avoided?
The word confirm is repeatedly used in relation to the different data points and I would argue that more caution is needed than this as the research is very interesting both very exploratory and as such I would suggest that the findings at best suggest potential alignment rather than confirmation - qualitative approaches generally don't seek to 'confirm' in the ways that qualitative do - they seek to extend our understanding.
Response: We thank the reviewer for this valuable and important methodological critique. We fully agree that the manuscript lacked a clear definition of the analytical method for the interview data, and to address this, the overly forceful use of the term "confirmation" has been neutralized. As follows:
- All interviews were transcribed verbatim with participants anonymized.
- Pre-existing codes were extracted from theoretical models (Community Health Care Theory, Individual-Environmental Conformity Model, and Bronfenbrenner Model).
- Open coding was conducted to identify emerging themes not anticipated by the theory.
- A convergence/divergence matrix was created to correlate each theme with three types of respondents per case (student, teacher, and parent).
- Two independent coders analyzed all transcripts using NVivo software.
- Inter-code reliability was calculated (Cohen's kappa coefficient = 0.88), indicating high agreement. Differences were resolved through consensus discussion.
- Comparisons between cases identified patterns of convergence (agreement of all respondents), partial convergence (agreement of two), and divergence (disagreement).
Comment: Lines 570- 592
This is actually an interpretation of the interview data not the PDAS. There appears to only be two sentences directly related to the PDAS
Response: Adjusted to interpret the results of the Personal Performance Assessment Scale (PDAS).
Comment: Line 609- 610
How do you know that this is a consequence of the acceleration intervention and would not have occurred irrespective of the acceleration intervention given the student's strengths and supportive family environments?
Response: The text has been rewritten to clarify any ambiguity and to explain how the extraneous variables were controlled.
Comment: Lines 662- 670
Again are some leaps in presumption being taken here?
You have used different scales on the axis for the three figures which distorts the differences visually - e.g. figure 2 goes up in 1s, figures 3 & 4 go up in tens
Again the interpretation after table 6 relates more to interview data than to an interpretation of the PDAs
Similar issues as below with case study three.
The overall challenge with the results is that a case study methodology is being interpreted as providing causal findings, there are no apparent considerations of other confounding variables or cautions against confirmatory bias. The results section require a full review with a clear understanding of the purpose and limitations of the different methodologies employed and what we can actually conclude from case studies. Case studies are incredibly valuable and provide very valuable detailed insights but they can not be extrapolated in this way.
Response:
We thank the reviewer for this rigorous and critical assessment. We have addressed each point as follows:
- Leaps in presumption – All strong causal or confirmatory language has been replaced throughout the Results section. Words such as “confirms,” “validates,” “concludes,” and “shows” have been changed to “is consistent with,” “aligns with,” “suggests,” and “the researcher interprets that.” Explicit cautionary statements have been added to each case’s “Integration and Acceleration Decision” subsection (e.g., “This interpretation is offered with the understanding that the case study design does not permit causal claims”).
- Different Y‑axis scales on figures – This is an excellent point. Figure 2 (Even High profile) used a 1‑point scale because all scores were 95–100, while Figures 3 and 4 used 10‑point scales to display wider ranges. To avoid visual distortion, we have re‑plotted all three figures using the same scale (0–100 in increments of 10) and added a clear note in the figure legends that the scales are now uniform to enable direct comparison. Revised figures are included.
- Interpretation after Table 6 relates more to interview data than to PDAS – The reviewer is correct. We have restructured this section. The PDAS table is now followed by a brief, direct interpretation of the PDAS ratings only (e.g., “Table 6 shows that teachers rated S.L. as sometimes emotionally disturbed and often sensitive to criticism”). All rich narrative context (student quotes, teacher comments) has been moved to a separate “Qualitative Interview Data” sub‑subsection immediately after the PDAS interpretation, clearly labelled and not conflated with the PDAS scores.
- Similar issues in Case Study 3 – The same restructuring has been applied to Case Study 3. The PDAS table is interpreted succinctly on its own; interview and counselor quotes are presented in a separate, clearly labelled qualitative subsection.
- Overall: case study methodology cannot provide causal findings – We fully agree. The Results section now opens with a new prefatory paragraph (before 6.1) stating explicitly:
“Because this is a small‑scale exploratory case study (N=3), no causal claims are made. Findings are descriptive and hypothesis‑generating. Patterns observed are associations, not effects. Alternative explanations cannot be ruled out.
Additionally, each case’s “Integration and Acceleration Decision” ends with a standard cautionary sentence. The Discussion section has been revised to emphasise that convergence is associational, not causal, and that confounding variables (life events, peer changes, teaching quality, etc.) are acknowledged as uncontrolled.
- Extrapolation – The manuscript no longer extrapolates beyond the cases. All implications are framed as “suggestions for future research” or “hypotheses to be tested,” not as definitive policy recommendations. The abstract and conclusion have been adjusted accordingly.
Comment: Discussion
The work necessary on the results section will lead inevitably to changes within the discussion section where I would whole heartedly agree with reviewer three's comments on the revised article - the discussion needs to revised and the policy and educational implications need to be moderated and explicitly framed within the small exploratory scope of the study. I would also agree that some of the current conclusions extend considerably beyond what the data can fully support. They provide incredibly interesting and valuable points for discussion and further investigation but they do not in themselves lead to clear and definite implications for education and policy in the manner stated.
Response: The results section was revised, and significant changes were made to the discussion section, mitigating policy and educational implications and explicitly framing them within the small exploratory scope of the study. All conclusions that extended beyond what the data could fully support were modified and discussed more broadly, clarifying that they do not, in themselves, lead to clear and specific implications for education and policy.
Comment: As a general comment there are some issues with clarity of argument throughout due to difficulties in sentence structure and phrasing, so clarity of the article would also be enhanced by addressing these.
Response: The research was thoroughly reviewed, and a language editor was consulted to verify the clarity and wording of the sentences and that they convey the intended meaning.