Review Reports
- Jingjing Zhou 1,
- Yushu Zhang 2 and
- Xiaoli Ye 2,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Jess Moriarty
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThank you for your research project examining how graduate students construct meaning and identity in discussing their relationship with their supervisors. I found your paper well-developed and learned a lot from your research perspectives. I have some questions for you to further refine and enhance your paper for publication:
- Your introduction is very long. To increase engagement with your work, I highly suggest some re-organization for a concise and easily readable introduction. First, I'd suggest bringing section 2.4 to the end of the introduction so your research questions come before your literature review. Then I suggest making this whole introduction into four or five (not too long) paragraphs. The introduction should help your readers quickly know what is the bigger conversation this research is joining (graduate-supervisor relationships and identity), where it is situated (what gaps it is filling or what new understandings it is seeking to offer to this conversation, and what are your specific research questions and objectives. If there are important information in introduction that needs to be in the paper, add it to your literature review, which will provide the supporting background literature for your work (and some of the stuff you currently have in introduction can go to literature review easily).
- Your findings section uses present tense language, which makes it difficult to understand whether you are reporting on what we know from scholarship or reporting findings from the research. On principle, your findings from research should be past tense (as per APA guidelines) and when you are speaking as discussions from findings, you can use present tense.
- Your discussions and implications section are generally great, but they are generalized to populations beyond China. I am not saying you can't do that, but I suggest saying here is the implications for Chinese context and here are larger contributions to literature on graduate students that are likely applicable beyond the Chinese context.
- I understand that providing direct quotes form participants can be tricky given that you don't want to expose information that may reveal their identities or usernames on the platform. But when possible, I'd encourage you to include more direct quotes. After all, a good qualitative research provides "thick" descriptions and your findings are very lean on student quotes. Speaking of which, I encourage you adding a section in your methods section to speak of what you have done to ensure rigor in your qualitative research (I understand rigor not to be about validity or quantitative frames, but what qualitative researchers have established to mean quality work).
Author Response
We sincerely thank you for your interest in and recognition of this study. Your affirmation of our exploration of meaning construction and identity formation in postgraduate supervisory relationships has greatly encouraged us. Your constructive suggestions regarding the readability and structural reorganization of the introduction, the tense conventions in the findings section, the scope of the discussion and implications, the enrichment of direct quotations, and the addition of a rigor statement for the qualitative inquiry have provided clear guidance for further improving this paper. We have carefully considered each of your points and made systematic revisions throughout the manuscript. Below, we will respond to each of your suggestions point by point.
Comment 1: Your introduction is very long. To increase engagement with your work, I highly suggest some re-organization for a concise and easily readable introduction. First, I'd suggest bringing section 2.4 to the end of the introduction so your research questions come before your literature review. Then I suggest making this whole introduction into four or five (not too long) paragraphs. The introduction should help your readers quickly know what is the bigger conversation this research is joining (graduate-supervisor relationships and identity), where it is situated (what gaps it is filling or what new understandings it is seeking to offer to this conversation, and what are your specific research questions and objectives. If there are important information in introduction that needs to be in the paper, add it to your literature review, which will provide the supporting background literature for your work (and some of the stuff you currently have in introduction can go to literature review easily).
Response 1:
Thank you for your highly constructive feedback. In response to your suggestions, we have made the following revisions in the revised manuscript:
First, regarding the relocation of Section 2.4 to the end of the introduction, we have strictly followed your suggestion by moving this part from the literature review to serve as the concluding section of the introduction. As a result, the introduction now ends with a clear statement of the research gaps and the two specific research questions (RQ1 and RQ2), enabling readers to grasp the research direction of this study at a glance.
Second, concerning the compression of the introduction into four to five concise paragraphs, we have condensed it into five logically coherent paragraphs. The revised introduction follows a progressive structure: "conceptualisation and significance of the supervisor–postgraduate relationship → global imbalances in supervisory relationships → contextual challenges in China → the rise of online narratives in the digital age → existing research and the positioning of this study." This structure ensures that readers can quickly grasp the core academic contribution of this paper.
Third, regarding the transfer of deleted content from the introduction to the literature review, we have carefully reviewed the omitted material and systematically integrated the historical evolution of the apprenticeship model, specific empirical details concerning power, emotion, and identity, as well as micro-level research evidence on influencing factors into Sections 2.1, 2.2, and 2.3 of the literature review.
Thank you again for your valuable comments.
Comment 2: Your findings section uses present tense language, which makes it difficult to understand whether you are reporting on what we know from scholarship or reporting findings from the research. On principle, your findings from research should be past tense (as per APA guidelines) and when you are speaking as discussions from findings, you can use present tense.
Response 2:
Thank you very much for your valuable suggestion.
We fully agree that the findings of the study should be reported in the past tense to distinguish them from general academic discussions and theoretical inferences. Accordingly, we have systematically revised the entire Findings section, changing all core verbs that describe the observed phenomena, participant behaviors, thematic patterns, and processual mechanisms from the present tense to the past tense. Direct quotations from participants retain their original tense, while the introductory and explanatory sentences surrounding them have been adjusted to the past tense accordingly. Meanwhile, the Discussion section continues to use the present tense for theoretical interpretation, meaning-making, and dialogue with the existing literature. Through these revisions, we have clearly differentiated empirical findings from theoretical inferences throughout the manuscript, in compliance with APA tense guidelines. We hope these changes meet your expectations.
We greatly value your critical engagement with this study.
Comment 3: Your discussions and implications section are generally great, but they are generalized to populations beyond China. I am not saying you can't do that, but I suggest saying here is the implications for Chinese context and here are larger contributions to literature on graduate students that are likely applicable beyond the Chinese context.
Response 3:
Thank you for this highly constructive suggestion, which has helped us more rigorously delineate the scope of applicability of our findings and implications.
We have addressed this through a tiered revision. First, at the beginning of the Practical Implications section, we have added a clear logical statement, noting that while the empirical evidence of this study originates from the Chinese context, the issues reflected in supervisor–postgraduate relationships, such as expectation misalignment, insufficient emotional support, and power asymmetry, are widely documented in the international literature and share cross-contextual commonalities. Therefore, although the practical recommendations are grounded in Chinese data, their problem orientation has general reference value, while we also acknowledge that their direct applicability in different institutional settings requires further cross-national comparative research.
Second, at the end of Section 6.4, we have distilled three theoretical contributions that can transcend the Chinese context as tools for broader academic dialogue. These include the four-dimensional framework of meaning construction through online narratives, the iterative "individual–group–individual" logic of meaning-making, and the analytical concept of digital communities as "institutional compensation."
Finally, we have added a limitations section at the end of the paper, explicitly stating that the data for this study originate from a single national platform, and that the generalizability of the specific findings to cross-national contexts should be approached with caution. Through these revisions, we have established a clear hierarchical relationship among practical implications, theoretical contributions, and data limitations, thereby addressing your concerns about the scope of our conclusions while preserving the theoretical value for engagement with the international academic community.
Once again, thank you for your invaluable feedback.
Comment 4: I understand that providing direct quotes form participants can be tricky given that you don't want to expose information that may reveal their identities or usernames on the platform. But when possible, I'd encourage you to include more direct quotes. After all, a good qualitative research provides "thick" descriptions and your findings are very lean on student quotes. Speaking of which, I encourage you adding a section in your methods section to speak of what you have done to ensure rigor in your qualitative research (I understand rigor not to be about validity or quantitative frames, but what qualitative researchers have established to mean quality work).
Response 4:
Thank you for your valuable comments on the manuscript. We have made the following revisions:
First, we have systematically incorporated additional direct quotations throughout the findings. We really appreciate your understanding of our ethical commitment to protecting participant privacy. To strengthen the persuasiveness of our findings and provide more substantial raw data support for each analytical claim, we have supplemented the original draft with carefully selected direct quotations from the dataset. These newly added quotations cover all sub-themes across the four core thematic dimensions and are closely aligned with each analytical assertion, thereby effectively substantiating our theoretical interpretations of identity construction, emotional interaction, experience sharing, and social connection. Throughout this process, we have strictly adhered to the ethical guidelines of netnography by removing all identifying information, including usernames, profile pictures, and URLs, and by omitting any details that could potentially reveal participants' institutions, academic disciplines, or supervisor characteristics. Furthermore, all quoted posts and comments were publicly available within the group, and no content marked as "do not quote" or private communications was used. These measures maintain an appropriate balance between the richness of quoted evidence and the full protection of participant privacy.
Second, we have provided additional clarification regarding the rigor of our qualitative inquiry. In response to your suggestion to include a rigor statement in the methods section, we have added a new subsection entitled "4.6 Rigor and Trustworthiness of the Study," which strictly follows the quality criteria for netnography proposed by Kurikko and Tuominen (2012). With respect to immersive depth, we conducted a nine-month period of participatory observation, during which we collected multiple sources of data, including narrative posts, comment threads, and reflexive field notes, and cross-validated these sources to develop a deep understanding of the community culture. With respect to prolonged engagement, the extended fieldwork period enabled us to trace the evolution of topics and the dynamics of interaction patterns, ensuring that the research remained grounded in authentic practice. With respect to researcher identification, we undertook a preliminary period of lurking observation to become familiar with the community context before formally entering the field. Subsequently, we disclosed our researcher identities in our profile biographies and commenced formal fieldwork. Throughout the entire process, we continuously reflected on our dual roles as both "observers" and "active participants," while rigorously implementing anonymization and transparent ethical disclosure. With respect to persistent dialogue, this was manifested not only in our active participation in community discussions but also extended into the data analysis phase, where two coders independently conducted thematic analysis on the selected texts. All coding disagreements were resolved through repeated discussion and negotiation until consensus was achieved, thereby ensuring the robustness of the analytical conclusions.
We sincerely appreciate your suggestions, which have significantly contributed to improving the overall quality of this study.
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsHello,
I have summarized my suggestions below. Your manuscript is quite strong and provides timely evidence of graduate student - supervisor dynamics and how graduate students respond to challenges. One thing that you should note is that you often utilize graduate students and postgraduates interchangeably. These are two different populations and as such, you should provide more clarification and consistency.
Introduction
- Can you clarify the participant pool for the 2022 Graduates Survey (line 55) and 2025 Nature Graduates Survey (line 61) - who took the surveys, what their disciplines were, geographical location, etc. Perhaps adding if any of the survey participants were students in China would be helpful as well.
- Of the 3.882 mil. graduate students in China (line 108), are all of them of China-origin or does this statistic include international students enrolled in Chinese universities? Similarly, of the 3.882 mil., how many of them are enrolled only in virtual learning as opposed to in-person/hybrid/hy-flex? If you have access to identifying these items, it would strengthen the section.
- Starting with "their antecedents" (line 156) and ending with "meaning-making perspective," (line 158) you have me lost. When I see "logic," I think of mathematical equations. I suggest you re-write this sentence to make it more understandable.
Literature Review: strongly written but do note my comment above re: graduate vs. postgraduate
Methods
- You note the Douban discussion group (line 452) which also appears in the abstract. You explain what it is in like 475 but perhaps you should move it closer to line 452.
- Can you clarify: Was the discussion group formed before you began your research? Was it formed by a member of your research team? Who designed the question, "Has your supervisor cared about you today?" Were the posts that you selected only from graduate students enrolled in a Chinese university?
- 4.4.2
- You note that the discussion group has strict criteria to join. How/did the research team verify the participants' authentic experiences?
- I advise you to move 4.5 Ethics upwards, perhaps before 4.3 Data Collection as the Ethics section addresses questions I have earlier (as a reader) regarding consent.
I look forward to your final manuscript.
Author Response
Thank you very much for your thorough review and valuable suggestions. Your comments are highly pertinent, especially regarding terminology usage, survey sample information, and the organization of the Methods section, all of which have helped clarify several parts of the discussion. Each point has been carefully considered, and corresponding revisions have been made throughout the paper to improve accuracy and logical clarity. Point‑by‑point responses are attached below for your review. Again, thank you for your time and professional guidance.
Introduction
Comment 1: Can you clarify the participant pool for the 2022 Graduates Survey (line 55) and 2025 Nature Graduates Survey (line 61) - who took the surveys, what their disciplines were, geographical location, etc. Perhaps adding if any of the survey participants were students in China would be helpful as well.
Response 1:
Thank you for your detailed questions. After reviewing the publicly available reports on the two Nature surveys, here is a brief summary of the participant pools:
The 2022 survey was administered to STEM graduate students globally, collecting 3,253 valid responses. It was the first survey since 2011 to include master's students. Respondents came from multiple countries across Asia, Europe, North America, South America, Africa, and Oceania. The survey was offered in five language versions, including Chinese, and included participants from China. Exact country‑specific sample sizes were not disclosed in Nature's official reports.
The 2025 survey targeted STEM doctoral students, with 3,785 valid responses from 107 countries, including 312 Chinese participants. It was jointly designed by Nature and the London‑based research consultancy Thinks Insight & Strategy.
This information has been added to the corresponding sections of the manuscript. Again, thank you for your careful scrutiny.
Comment 2: Of the 3.882 mil. graduate students in China (line 108), are all of them of China-origin or does this statistic include international students enrolled in Chinese universities? Similarly, of the 3.882 mil., how many of them are enrolled only in virtual learning as opposed to in-person/hybrid/hy-flex? If you have access to identifying these items, it would strengthen the section.
Response 2:
Thank you for your important questions regarding the postgraduate statistics.
Regarding the specific figures: the 3.8829 million postgraduates originally cited in the manuscript came from the 2023 Statistical Bulletin on the Development of China's Education, released by the Ministry of Education in 2024. Upon verification, the latest data show continued growth in postgraduate enrollment. According to the 2025 Statistical Bulletin on the Development of China's Education, issued in July 2026, the total number of enrolled postgraduates in 2025 reached 4.2995 million (including 594,700 doctoral students and 3.7048 million master's students). The manuscript has been revised accordingly, with the data updated to 4.2995 million for 2025, and the statistical year (2025) noted.
Regarding the national composition of postgraduates: according to statistics from the Department of International Cooperation and Exchange of the Ministry of Education, in the 2024–2025 academic year, over 380,000 international students from 191 countries and regions were studying in China, of which postgraduates accounted for approximately 35%, i.e., about 133,000 international postgraduates.
With respect to exclusively online learners, upon review, no official statistics specifically distinguish between "exclusively online learning" and "in‑person/hybrid/hy‑flex" modes among postgraduates. The official statistical system only differentiates between "full‑time" and "part‑time" enrollment, without further breakdown by delivery mode. This is because the core components of China's postgraduate education, coursework, supervisor mentoring, research training, thesis defense, etc., are all based on face‑to‑face interaction, with online learning primarily serving as a supplementary tool rather than a standalone mode.
Corresponding revisions have been made to the relevant sections of the manuscript. Again, thank you for your valuable input.
Comment 3: Starting with "their antecedents" (line 156) and ending with "meaning-making perspective," (line 158) you have me lost. When I see "logic," I think of mathematical equations. I suggest you re-write this sentence to make it more understandable.
Response 3:
Thank you very much for pointing out this phrasing issue.
The use of "internal logic" in our original manuscript was indeed imprecise and failed to clearly convey our intended meaning, causing confusion for the reader. What we actually intended to express was that existing studies have rarely focused on how postgraduates, as active subjects of meaning-making, understand and interpret their own supervisor-postgraduate relationship experiences through online narratives, that is, the generative mechanisms and operational processes behind these narratives. To avoid the ambiguity caused by the term "logic," the original sentence has been revised to "...have rarely examined the internal mechanisms of online narratives from a subject-centered meaning-making perspective," which more accurately reflects the core concern of this study.
We are sincerely grateful once more for your careful corrections.
Literature Review
Comment 1: strongly written but do note my comment above re: graduate vs. postgraduate
Response 1:
Thank you for your reminder.
Based on your suggestion regarding the distinction between "graduate" and "postgraduate," the entire manuscript, including the literature review, has been systematically reviewed and revised accordingly. Given that this study focuses on "postgraduates" in the Chinese higher education context (covering both master's and doctoral students), and that the title already uses the fixed phrase "supervisor‑postgraduate relationship," the term "postgraduate students" is now used consistently throughout the paper as the core term, with "postgraduates" retained as its abbreviated form to avoid repetition and maintain fluency, ensuring both consistency and accuracy of terminology.
Once again, we thank you for your thorough and thoughtful corrections.
Methods
Comment 1: You note the Douban discussion group (line 452) which also appears in the abstract. You explain what it is in like 475 but perhaps you should move it closer to line 452.
Response 1:
Thank you very much for this suggestion.
We fully agree that when a proper noun appears for the first time, a basic explanation should be provided immediately; this is a fundamental norm of academic writing. Placing the relevant information further down in the original text would indeed cause confusion for readers. Following your suggestion, the basic information about the Douban discussion group (including its founding date, member size, group description, and section settings) has been moved to immediately after its first mention, ensuring that readers obtain the necessary background context upon first encounter.
Again, thank you for your careful review.
Comment 2: Can you clarify: Was the discussion group formed before you began your research? Was it formed by a member of your research team? Who designed the question, "Has your supervisor cared about you today?" Were the posts that you selected only from graduate students enrolled in a Chinese university?
Response 2:
Thank you for your detailed questions.
Douban (douban.com) is a well-known Chinese cultural and lifestyle community platform centered around books, films, and music, attracting a large number of young users. As of 2024, Douban had registered over 300 million users, approximately 86% of whom were born in the 1980s and 1990s. Douban Groups are one of the platform's core features, allowing users to create and participate in discussion communities around specific topics. Currently, there are over 600,000 groups on the platform, covering a wide range of subjects from daily life to professional interests.
The group selected for this study, "Has Your Supervisor Cared About You Today?" was established on December 10, 2019. It is an online community spontaneously created by Douban users and was not established by any member of our research team. This group focuses specifically on supervisor-postgraduate relationship issues. Its group description explicitly states, "The teacher-student relationship in universities has frequently been pushed to the forefront of public debate; come here and share your daily interactions with your supervisor." Members share their real experiences and emotional encounters with their supervisors. The group has several thematic sections, including "Shout-Outs" (sharing supervisors' caring behaviors and effective guidance), "Rants" (expressing dissatisfaction and confusion encountered in the supervisory relationship), "Q&A" (seeking practical advice on specific issues), and "Veterans' Voices" (where senior postgraduates share their experiences and reflections). Together, these sections form a complete narrative framework around supervisor-postgraduate relationships. For this reason, we selected this community as our research field given the study's focus.
Regarding the identity of the posters, this study has consistently focused on the Chinese postgraduate population. Based on the group's Chinese-language context, the repeated references in discussions to concepts specific to Chinese postgraduate education (such as "dual selection," "pre‑first‑year," "supervisor authorship," "professional vs. academic master's," and "graduation requirements"), as well as the group description's orientation toward teacher-student relationships in Chinese universities, it can be confirmed that participants are all current postgraduates enrolled in Chinese institutions. While Douban groups do not require members to disclose their university or nationality, the institutional knowledge reflected in the discussion content sufficiently attests to their group affiliation.
Your meticulous scrutiny has been of great help, and we thank you again.
Comment 3: 4.4.2 You note that the discussion group has strict criteria to join. How/did the research team verify the participants' authentic experiences?
Response 3:
Thank you for your question.
Regarding the determination of participants' identity and the authenticity of their experiences, our study did not rely on the Douban group's membership approval mechanism. The group's approval process requires applicants to read the group rules, find the entry code, and complete an application statement before being admitted after moderator review. The group also has detailed posting rules, including "Keep your posts rational and respectful," "Do not post content unrelated to the group's theme," and "No separate posts for interview recruitment or survey questionnaires." Members who violate the rules may be removed from the group. At the community management level, this mechanism ensures focused discussions and a clean environment; however, its primary function is to screen for genuine users who are truly interested in the topic and filter out irrelevant content, rather than to substantively verify each member's postgraduate status. We therefore base our judgment of participant identity on more substantial textual evidence.
First, the group is categorized under "Campus" communities on Douban, with its description explicitly centered on teacher-student relationships in Chinese universities, and all discussions are conducted in Chinese. Second, the post content repeatedly features concepts and institutional arrangements specific to the Chinese postgraduate education system, such as "dual selection," "pre-first-year," "supervisor authorship," "professional vs. academic master's," and "graduation requirements." The discussion context clearly points to a specific national and educational level orientation. Third, after several years of operation, the group has developed a stable discussion culture and focal concerns. Participants have long been immersed in this environment, and the institutional knowledge naturally embedded in their narratives itself serves as strong evidence of their group affiliation.
More importantly, through long-term immersive observation, we found that the narratives within the group are not scattered fragments but complete storylines that extend from initial posts, peer responses, and subsequent updates. Posters continuously share the evolution of their difficulties, the process of seeking help, and the eventual outcomes. We believe this narrative coherence and internal consistency itself constitute a powerful testament to the authenticity of their experiences.
We also acknowledge that online ethnography takes as its research object the public narrative texts spontaneously produced by participants in their natural state, focusing on the meaning-making processes presented in the texts rather than on retroactively tracing posters' offline identities. We recognize that no study based on public online communities can verify each participant's identity individually; we see this as a methodological premise of online data research rather than a unique limitation of our study. We have addressed this in the Limitations section and noted that future research could further compensate through methods such as in-depth interviews.
We are most grateful for your rigorous review.
Comment 4: I advise you to move 4.5 Ethics upwards, perhaps before 4.3 Data Collection as the Ethics section addresses questions I have earlier (as a reader) regarding consent.
Response 4:
Thank you for this suggestion.
We fully agree that the ethics statement should be placed earlier in the Methods section, so that readers are informed about our approach to informed consent and privacy protection before reading about the data collection process. Accordingly, the entire Ethics section (Section 4.5) has been moved between Section 4.2 (Research Setting and Participants) and Section 4.3 (Data Collection) to make the logical order of the Methods section more coherent.
Again, thank you for your careful review.
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThank you for sharing your paper, which I think any academic who supervises PGR students will be interested in – or at least they should be. It will also have huge relevance for PhD students conducting doctoral work who worry that they are not getting the most out of their supervisory experience. And this is hugely important. There is extensive data on the number of PhD students who drop out, which you don’t refer to, and so strengthening supervision and providing ideas for enhancing the student/supervisor relationship is crucial – for students, supervisors and institutions who rely on their high-quality scholarship, their fees and their positive feedback. I am sure that this article will be of significance and of interest to readers of this journal and beyond.
I am attaching an annotated file that contains suggestions for enhancing the article by giving further evidence and references. Where I have written ‘ref’ I suggest you add in a further reference to clarify your statements. You use very few quotes, and some of the references are relatively old when you are making claims about current debates, and both of these issues need rectifying. Often, the sections are in very lengthy, overly dense chunks, and you need to consider using more frequent paragraph breaks.
Your analysis in section 5 makes claims without stating where in the material you are evidencing this, and this needs significant consideration and development. If these are your findings, what exactly are they based on in the data and/or lit review, and what are your recommendations for enhancing the supervisory relationship? These need to be more clearly stated so that work in this article can be taken forward by interested readers – for their own research and/or for their own practice as supervisors, or as students.
You make some recommendations for what you think the supervisory relationship needs to enhance the students’ experience in the conclusion, but this is not clear and could be presented in bullet points for clarity.
You mention that the project has been reviewed, but you don’t mention specific ethical dilemmas. My understanding is that you entered an online community and pretended to be part of the community. This seems somewhat unethical or, if this isn’t the case, your positionality in these groups and how it was articulated to the members needs defending.
This is potentially an important article and so I hope some reworking and clarification can be made so it is ready for publication. I look forward to reading it again and sharing it with my PhD students so we can co-create better working relationships that enhance their experiences.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
We sincerely thank you for your careful review and valuable comments on this manuscript. Your affirmation of the potential value of this study, your concern for its practical relevance to doctoral students, and your constructive suggestions regarding the strengthening of literature support, the addition of direct quotations, the splitting of lengthy paragraphs, the clarification of data sources for the findings, the clearer presentation of recommendations, and the clarification of our ethical stance have all been immensely instructive in improving the quality of this paper. We have carefully considered each of your comments and made systematic revisions throughout the manuscript. In the following, we will respond to and clarify each of your suggestions point by point.
Comment 1: I am attaching an annotated file that contains suggestions for enhancing the article by giving further evidence and references. Where I have written 'ref' I suggest you add in a further reference to clarify your statements. You use very few quotes, and some of the references are relatively old when you are making claims about current debates, and both of these issues need rectifying. Often, the sections are in very lengthy, overly dense chunks, and you need to consider using more frequent paragraph breaks.
Response 1:
We sincerely thank you for the annotated file and the meticulous and constructive suggestions.
We have systematically addressed each "ref" mark you noted in the text by supplementing the relevant literature to ensure that every argument is adequately supported by scholarly sources. In response to your observation that direct quotations were relatively sparse, we have appropriately increased the direct presentation of participants' original words in the Findings section to enhance the texture and persuasiveness of the empirical material. At the same time, we have replaced and supplemented the references with more recent and cutting-edge research to improve the timeliness of the literature. Regarding the issues of overly long and dense paragraphs, we have restructured and split the paragraphs according to the logical progression of the arguments, making the text more accessible and allowing readers to grasp the core points more easily.
Once again, we sincerely appreciate your valuable feedback.
Comment 2: Your analysis in section 5 makes claims without stating where in the material you are evidencing this, and this needs significant consideration and development. If these are your findings, what exactly are they based on in the data and/or lit review, and what are your recommendations for enhancing the supervisory relationship? These need to be more clearly stated so that work in this article can be taken forward by interested readers – for their own research and/or for their own practice as supervisors, or as students.
Response 2:
Thank you for identifying this critical issue.
We have revised Section 5 paragraph by paragraph to ensure that each core analytical claim is traceable to its source. All participant narratives are presented through direct quotations. For the inductive claims made by the researchers based on multiple posts, the supporting evidence has been presented through post analysis and direct quotations, allowing readers to naturally trace each analytical claim back to its source during reading. Inferential statements that extend beyond the scope of the data have been moved to Section 6 (Discussion), where they are situated in dialogue with the existing literature. Meanwhile, recommendations for improving supervisory relationships have been presented in point form in Section 6.4 (Research Implications). Regarding the opening paragraph of Section 5.1, its function is to provide an overall introduction and transition for the subsequent subsections 5.1.1 and 5.1.2, rather than to present specific evidence within the paragraph itself. To make this structural intention clearer, we have added a natural transitional sentence at the end of the paragraph to guide readers into the subsequent post analysis and quotation presentation, thereby preventing any misunderstanding that might arise from readers not yet having encountered the evidence that follows.
We sincerely thank you for your valuable feedback again.
Comment 3: You make some recommendations for what you think the supervisory relationship needs to enhance the students' experience in the conclusion, but this is not clear and could be presented in bullet points for clarity.
Response 3:
Thank you very much for this suggestion.
After careful consideration, we fully agree that presenting the recommendations for improving supervisory relationships in point form can significantly enhance the clarity of information delivery and the reading experience. Accordingly, we have restructured the conclusion section, distilling the recommendations from narrative paragraphs into four clear points, focusing on four dimensions of action for universities: research, training, mechanism building, and support networks. This presentation makes each recommendation more targeted and allows readers to quickly grasp the practical directions and future research pathways proposed by this study.
We sincerely appreciate your valuable feedback.
Comment 4: You mention that the project has been reviewed, but you don't mention specific ethical dilemmas. My understanding is that you entered an online community and pretended to be part of the community. This seems somewhat unethical or, if this isn't the case, your positionality in these groups and how it was articulated to the members needs defending.
Response 4:
Thank you for raising this question.
Our ethical considerations are not merely a procedural formality; they stem from a core dilemma. Our data were collected from a Douban group that requires membership approval, where members share authentic experiences of supervisor–postgraduate relationships, involving highly sensitive content such as power dynamics, academic bullying, and mental health crises. This means the space possesses a dual nature of being both "semi-public" and "tree‑hole private." Members assume their audience consists of peers in similar situations rather than academic researchers. At the same time, the posts contain rich contextual details, and simply removing usernames still poses a risk of re-identification. We must therefore strike a balance between protecting individual privacy and realizing the research value.
Regarding the researcher's positioning within the group, we adhered to the basic netnographic principle of "participation without intervention." The researcher never initiated threads related to supervisor–postgraduate relationships, never posed leading questions, and never steered the direction of discussions. Brief comments made in the comment sections were intended solely to facilitate a natural state of community interaction, without introducing external topics or interfering with the existing discussion logic. All 260 posts and 1,326 comments included in the analysis were independently posted by members in their natural state; the researcher's only intervention was the post-hoc selection and analysis of texts.
In terms of informed consent and privacy protection, we implemented multi-layered measures: obtaining informed consent from the group administrators before the study commenced; contacting and securing secondary authorization from each poster whose content was ultimately cited; securing approval from the institutional ethics committee to strengthen overall compliance; and applying strict de-identification and contextual anonymization to all quoted texts, striving to tell these stories without harming the narrators.
We hope this response clarifies our approach. We thank you again for your rigorous scrutiny.
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThank you for addressing my comments.