Review Reports
- Ignacio Norambuena-Paredes 1,
- José Luis Gálvez-Nieto 1,* and
- Constanza Norambuena-Candia 4
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Omar Durrah Reviewer 2: Cheol-Woo Park
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Authors,
This manuscript evaluates the psychometric properties and measurement invariance of the Entrepreneurial Intentions Scale among university students in Colombia and Ecuador. The topic is relevant to entrepreneurship research and cross-cultural measurement, and the study provides useful evidence regarding the validity and comparability of the scale in two Latin American contexts. The sample size is adequate, and the use of confirmatory factor analysis (CFA), measurement invariance testing, and reliability analysis is appropriate. However, several issues should be addressed to improve the manuscript's contribution and methodological rigor.
1. Clarify the study’s unique contribution, as the manuscript primarily provides an additional validation of an existing scale and offers limited theoretical novelty.
2. Strengthen the theoretical framework, particularly the connection between the Entrepreneurial Intentions Scale and the Theory of Planned Behavior, and explain the importance of cross-country measurement equivalence.
3. Provide more details about the sampling procedure, including participant recruitment, sampling method, response rate, and sample representativeness.
4. Justify the acceptance of scalar invariance more thoroughly, especially given the increase in RMSEA observed in the invariance analysis.
5. Include additional validity evidence, such as convergent, discriminant, or criterion-related validity, to strengthen the psychometric evaluation.
6. Avoid overstating the findings, as the study demonstrates measurement equivalence rather than explaining entrepreneurial behavior or broader regional entrepreneurship patterns.
7. Reduce repetition and improve readability, particularly in the discussion of configural, metric, and scalar invariance.
8. Provide a clearer explanation of the normality assessment and the rationale for using robust estimation methods.
9. Carefully review and clean the reference list, as several references appear to be duplicated and some formatting inconsistencies are present.
10. Expand the practical implications, offering more specific recommendations for entrepreneurship educators, universities, and policymakers regarding the application of the scale.
Author Response
|
Comments 1: Clarify the study’s unique contribution, as the manuscript primarily provides an additional validation of an existing scale and offers limited theoretical novelty.
|
|
Response 1: Thank you for the reviewer's comment. In response, we strengthened the study's contribution in the final section of the Introduction by providing a clearer explanation of the research gap, the study's objective, and its methodological contribution. We emphasised that the principal contribution of the study is not merely an additional validation of the scale, but rather the provision of evidence regarding its measurement equivalence among university students in Colombia and Ecuador, thereby establishing a robust foundation for future comparative research across Latin America. This revision has been highlighted in yellow in the manuscript and can be found in lines 162–177.
|
|
Comments 2: Strengthen the theoretical framework, particularly the connection between the Entrepreneurial Intentions Scale and the Theory of Planned Behavior, and explain the importance of cross-country measurement equivalence. |
|
Response 2: Thank you for the reviewer's comment. In response, we strengthened the theoretical framework by providing a more explicit explanation of the relationship between the Entrepreneurial Intentions Scale and the Theory of Planned Behaviour, as well as the importance of measurement equivalence for conducting valid cross-country comparisons. These revisions have been incorporated into the manuscript, highlighted in yellow, and can be found in lines 143–150 and 170–177.
|
|
Comments 3: Provide more details about the sampling procedure, including participant recruitment, sampling method, response rate, and sample representativeness. |
|
Response 3: Thank you for your comment. We have expanded the Participants section to clarify the participant recruitment process, the use of convenience sampling, and the lack of statistical representativeness of the sample.
|
|
Comments 4: Justify the acceptance of scalar invariance more thoroughly, especially given the increase in RMSEA observed in the invariance analysis. |
|
Response 4: Thank you for your comment. We expanded the justification for accepting scalar invariance by clarifying that, although the RMSEA increased in the scalar model, its absolute value remained within the range of good model fit (RMSEA = 0.044). We also highlighted that the ΔCFI remained below the recommended threshold (Chen, 2007) and that the overall pattern of fit indices supported the acceptance of scalar invariance.
|
|
Comments 5: Include additional validity evidence, such as convergent, discriminant, or criterion-related validity, to strengthen the psychometric evaluation. |
|
Response 5: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We agree that additional validity evidence would further strengthen the psychometric evaluation of the instrument. As the present study focused on factorial validity, measurement invariance, and reliability, we have incorporated this recommendation as a direction for future research in the Discussion section.
|
|
Comments 6: Avoid overstating the findings, as the study demonstrates measurement equivalence rather than explaining entrepreneurial behavior or broader regional entrepreneurship patterns |
|
Response 6: Thank you for the reviewer's valuable comment. We agree that the primary aim of the present study is to demonstrate the measurement equivalence of the scale rather than to explain entrepreneurial behaviour or establish broader regional patterns. Accordingly, we revised the Discussion and Conclusions sections, moderating the interpretation of the findings to ensure that it remains within the scope of the psychometric evidence obtained. Statements that could be interpreted as overextending the findings have been reformulated, emphasising that the conclusions are limited to measurement equivalence and its implications for future comparative research. These revisions have been highlighted in yellow in the revised manuscript and can be found in lines 398–405, 443–449, and 562–566.
|
|
Comments 7: Reduce repetition and improve readability, particularly in the discussion of configural, metric, and scalar invariance |
|
Response 7: Thank you for the reviewer's comment. In response to this suggestion, we revised the Discussion section to reduce repetition and improve the clarity, coherence, and readability of the text. In particular, the discussion of configural, metric, and scalar invariance was streamlined by avoiding conceptual repetition and providing a more concise summary of the main methodological implications of the findings. All revisions have been highlighted in yellow in the revised manuscript and can be found in lines 412–418, 423–428, and 439–444.
|
|
Comments 8: Provide a clearer explanation of the normality assessment and the rationale for using robust estimation methods. |
|
Response 8: Gracias por su comentario. Hemos aclarado la evaluación de la normalidad univariada y multivariada, ampliado la justificación para el uso del estimador de máxima verosimilitud robusta (MLR) e incorporado los resultados de la prueba de Kolmogorov-Smirnov en la Tabla 1.
|
|
Comments 9: Carefully review and clean the reference list, as several references appear to be duplicated and some formatting inconsistencies are present. |
|
Response 9: Thank you for the reviewer's comment. In response to this suggestion, we carefully reviewed the reference list, identified and removed duplicate references, and verified the consistency of the bibliographic formatting as well as the correspondence between the in-text citations and the reference list. These revisions were made to ensure full compliance with the journal's editorial guidelines.
|
|
Comments 10: Expand the practical implications, offering more specific recommendations for entrepreneurship educators, universities, and policymakers regarding the application of the scale. |
|
Response 10: Thank you for the reviewer's valuable comment. In response to this suggestion, we expanded the discussion of the practical implications of the findings by incorporating more specific recommendations regarding the application of the Entrepreneurial Intentions Scale in higher education settings. We also strengthened the Conclusions section by highlighting the potential of the scale as a useful tool for entrepreneurship educators, higher education institutions, and policymakers, both for assessing and monitoring entrepreneurial intentions and for designing and evaluating entrepreneurship education programmes and initiatives. All revisions have been highlighted in yellow in the revised manuscript and can be found in lines 482–489 and 587–594. |
|
4. Response to Comments on the Quality of English Language |
|
Point 1: |
|
Response 1 The English is fine and does not require any improvement. |
|
5. Additional clarifications |
|
We sincerely appreciate your valuable observations. We have made the corresponding changes according to the reviewer’s suggestions. |
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis paper holds academic and practical significance in that it provides a common scale applicable in the field of entrepreneurship research and entrepreneurship education evaluation, based on a sample of university students from Colombia and Ecuador (a total of 803).
Furthermore, a key strength of this study is its clear purpose and theoretical foundation: it is persuasive that the concept of entrepreneurial intention is defined based on the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB), and that a distinct research gap—namely, the "lack of measurement invariance in the multicultural context of Latin America"—is identified.
Appropriateness of Sample Size and Design: Although the sample is a convenience sample comprising 319 university students from Colombia and 484 from Ecuador, it is sufficient for performing CFA, invariance testing, and reliability analysis. Additionally, the confirmation of basic homogeneity through a comparison of the age and gender distributions of the two groups is appropriate.
In the results and discussion, the part connecting the finding that the potential mean difference between the two countries is not significant to the interpretation that “entrepreneurial intention is shared among Latin American university students as a common educational and vocational aspiration” is logical and is judged to be well-aligned with prior research (youth unemployment, the informal labor market, the expansion of entrepreneurship education, etc.).
However, some improvements are needed to refine awkward expressions in the technical and translation aspects.
Additionally, the core points of the research question and conclusion need to be clarified.
While the introduction presents various points such as the theoretical importance of entrepreneurial intention, the context of the Latin American youth employment and entrepreneurship ecosystem, and an introduction to TPB, the focus on the core research question (“Are EIS equivalent in factor structure and measurement between the two countries?”) is explained only towards the end, making it appear unclear.
Improving the reporting format of the statistical results is also considered a very important area for correction. Some figures presented in the tables and text (e.g., RMSEA, ΔCFI, factor loading ranges) are presented redundantly and sporadically, somewhat disrupting the reading flow. Simply mentioning the effect size of the latent mean comparison (e.g., the estimate corresponding to Cohen’s d) can numerically support the conclusion that there is “no difference.”
It is necessary to organize the discussion and conclusion by distinguishing between the limitations of generalization and the policy implications.
While the limitations section effectively addresses important points such as the cross-sectional design, the university student sample, the geographical scope (two countries), and self-reporting bias, the discussion and conclusion still expresses sentences that extend the implications to “youth entrepreneurship across Latin America” somewhat strongly.
Clearly separating the “results targeting university students in Colombia and Ecuador” from the “implications for designing regional policies and entrepreneurship education in Latin America” at the paragraph level, thereby distinguishing between the level of empirical results and policy inference, would provide a more balanced impression.
Regarding the academic contribution, the systematic verification of the factor structure of EIS and cross-country measurement invariance within the Latin American context is sufficiently meaningful to the readership of Behavioral Sciences.
The analysis techniques used and the reported metrics meet current international journal standards, and the paper will become even more robust with a few additional technical improvements.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThis paper holds academic and practical significance in that it provides a common scale applicable in the field of entrepreneurship research and entrepreneurship education evaluation, based on a sample of university students from Colombia and Ecuador (a total of 803).
Furthermore, a key strength of this study is its clear purpose and theoretical foundation: it is persuasive that the concept of entrepreneurial intention is defined based on the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB), and that a distinct research gap—namely, the "lack of measurement invariance in the multicultural context of Latin America"—is identified.
Appropriateness of Sample Size and Design: Although the sample is a convenience sample comprising 319 university students from Colombia and 484 from Ecuador, it is sufficient for performing CFA, invariance testing, and reliability analysis. Additionally, the confirmation of basic homogeneity through a comparison of the age and gender distributions of the two groups is appropriate.
In the results and discussion, the part connecting the finding that the potential mean difference between the two countries is not significant to the interpretation that “entrepreneurial intention is shared among Latin American university students as a common educational and vocational aspiration” is logical and is judged to be well-aligned with prior research (youth unemployment, the informal labor market, the expansion of entrepreneurship education, etc.).
However, some improvements are needed to refine awkward expressions in the technical and translation aspects.
Additionally, the core points of the research question and conclusion need to be clarified.
While the introduction presents various points such as the theoretical importance of entrepreneurial intention, the context of the Latin American youth employment and entrepreneurship ecosystem, and an introduction to TPB, the focus on the core research question (“Are EIS equivalent in factor structure and measurement between the two countries?”) is explained only towards the end, making it appear unclear.
Improving the reporting format of the statistical results is also considered a very important area for correction. Some figures presented in the tables and text (e.g., RMSEA, ΔCFI, factor loading ranges) are presented redundantly and sporadically, somewhat disrupting the reading flow. Simply mentioning the effect size of the latent mean comparison (e.g., the estimate corresponding to Cohen’s d) can numerically support the conclusion that there is “no difference.”
It is necessary to organize the discussion and conclusion by distinguishing between the limitations of generalization and the policy implications.
While the limitations section effectively addresses important points such as the cross-sectional design, the university student sample, the geographical scope (two countries), and self-reporting bias, the discussion and conclusion still expresses sentences that extend the implications to “youth entrepreneurship across Latin America” somewhat strongly.
Clearly separating the “results targeting university students in Colombia and Ecuador” from the “implications for designing regional policies and entrepreneurship education in Latin America” at the paragraph level, thereby distinguishing between the level of empirical results and policy inference, would provide a more balanced impression.
Regarding the academic contribution, the systematic verification of the factor structure of EIS and cross-country measurement invariance within the Latin American context is sufficiently meaningful to the readership of Behavioral Sciences.
The analysis techniques used and the reported metrics meet current international journal standards, and the paper will become even more robust with a few additional technical improvements.
Author Response
|
Comments 1: This paper holds academic and practical significance in that it provides a common scale applicable in the field of entrepreneurship research and entrepreneurship education evaluation, based on a sample of university students from Colombia and Ecuador (a total of 803) |
|
Response 1: Thank you for your comments. In response, we revised the manuscript to strengthen the presentation of the study's academic and practical significance. In particular, we emphasised that the scale provides a common instrument for comparative research and for evaluating entrepreneurship education among university students in Colombia and Ecuador. We also expanded the discussion of its potential applications in higher education, research, and policy-making contexts.
|
|
Comments 2: Furthermore, a key strength of this study is its clear purpose and theoretical foundation: it is persuasive that the concept of entrepreneurial intention is defined based on the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB), and that a distinct research gap—namely, the "lack of measurement invariance in the multicultural context of Latin America"—is identified |
|
Response 2: Thank you for the reviewer's comment. We revised the manuscript to strengthen the clarity of the theoretical rationale and the research gap underpinning the study. In particular, we emphasised the role of the Theory of Planned Behaviour as the conceptual framework for entrepreneurial intention and highlighted the importance of assessing measurement invariance in multicultural contexts across Latin America. These revisions have been highlighted in yellow in the revised manuscript and can be found in lines 143–150.
|
|
Comments 3: Appropriateness of Sample Size and Design: Although the sample is a convenience sample comprising 319 university students from Colombia and 484 from Ecuador, it is sufficient for performing CFA, invariance testing, and reliability analysis. Additionally, the confirmation of basic homogeneity through a comparison of the age and gender distributions of the two groups is appropriate. |
|
Response 3: Thank you for your comment. The Participants section has been revised to include statistical comparisons of age and sex between the two samples. We now report the chi-square test and its associated effect size (Cramér's V), which indicate only small demographic differences between the groups. We also clarify the adequacy of the sample size for the planned psychometric analyses.
|
|
Comments 4: In the results and discussion, the part connecting the finding that the potential mean difference between the two countries is not significant to the interpretation that “entrepreneurial intention is shared among Latin American university students as a common educational and vocational aspiration” is logical and is judged to be well-aligned with prior research (youth unemployment, the informal labor market, the expansion of entrepreneurship education, etc.). |
|
Response 4: Thank you for the reviewer's comment. In response, we revised the Discussion section to strengthen the connection between the findings and the existing evidence, thereby improving the clarity of the interpretation while ensuring that it remains aligned with the scope of the study.
|
|
Comments 5: However, some improvements are needed to refine awkward expressions in the technical and translation aspects. |
|
Response 5: Thank you for your comment. In response, we conducted a thorough revision of the entire manuscript to improve the quality of the academic English, the precision of the technical terminology, and the overall fluency of the text. We corrected awkward expressions, translation inconsistencies, and grammatical issues to ensure greater clarity and compliance with the standards of scientific writing. All revisions made in response to this comment have been highlighted in yellow in the revised manuscript to facilitate their identification.
|
|
Comments 6: Additionally, the core points of the research question and conclusion need to be clarified. |
|
Response 6: Thank you for your comments. This point has been addressed and improved in the revised manuscript.
|
|
Comments 7: While the introduction presents various points such as the theoretical importance of entrepreneurial intention, the context of the Latin American youth employment and entrepreneurship ecosystem, and an introduction to TPB, the focus on the core research question (“Are EIS equivalent in factor structure and measurement between the two countries?”) is explained only towards the end, making it appear unclear. |
|
Response 7: Thank you very much for this valuable comment. In response, we strengthened the Introduction by incorporating a clearer and earlier methodological justification for the study. Specifically, we added a new paragraph (lines 93–99, highlighted in yellow) emphasising that, despite the widespread international use of the Entrepreneurial Intentions Scale, there is still limited evidence regarding its measurement equivalence across Latin American countries. We also highlight that the absence of measurement invariance evidence may lead to biased comparisons between groups, thereby justifying the need to establish the instrument's psychometric equivalence before conducting cross-cultural comparisons. We believe that this addition establishes the research problem and the significance of the study at an earlier stage of the Introduction, thereby strengthening the coherence and overall flow of the manuscript. All revisions have been highlighted in yellow to facilitate their identification.
|
|
Comments 8: Improving the reporting format of the statistical results is also considered a very important area for correction. Some figures presented in the tables and text (e.g., RMSEA, ΔCFI, factor loading ranges) are presented redundantly and sporadically, somewhat disrupting the reading flow. Simply mentioning the effect size of the latent mean comparison (e.g., the estimate corresponding to Cohen’s d) can numerically support the conclusion that there is “no difference.” |
|
Response 8: Thank you for the suggestion. We removed the redundant statistical information from the Results section and clarified that the estimated latent mean difference was negligible, supporting the conclusion that the scores were comparable across the two groups.
|
|
Comments 9: It is necessary to organize the discussion and conclusion by distinguishing between the limitations of generalization and the policy implications. |
|
Response 9: Thank you for this valuable comment. In response to your suggestion, we revised and reorganised the structure of the final sections of the manuscript to clearly distinguish the limitations related to the generalisability of the findings from the practical and policy implications derived from the results. Specifically, the limitations are now presented separately in the "Limitations and Future Research" section, emphasising the scope of the findings and outlining directions for future research. In addition, the "Conclusions" section has been reorganised to present the practical and policy implications more clearly, highlighting their applications for entrepreneurship education, higher education institutions, and policymakers. These revisions improve the conceptual clarity and overall organisation of the manuscript. All modifications have been highlighted in yellow to facilitate their identification.
|
|
Comments 10: While the limitations section effectively addresses important points such as the cross-sectional design, the university student sample, the geographical scope (two countries), and self-reporting bias, the discussion and conclusion still expresses sentences that extend the implications to “youth entrepreneurship across Latin America” somewhat strongly. |
|
Response 10: Thank you for this valuable comment. In response, we reorganised the manuscript to provide a clearer distinction between the limitations related to the generalisability of the findings and the practical and policy implications of the results. In particular, we strengthened the discussion of the limitations concerning the scope of the findings and relocated the practical and policy implications to the Conclusions section, thereby improving the organisation and clarity of the manuscript. All revisions have been highlighted in yellow to facilitate their identification.
|
|
Comments 11: Clearly separating the “results targeting university students in Colombia and Ecuador” from the “implications for designing regional policies and entrepreneurship education in Latin America” at the paragraph level, thereby distinguishing between the level of empirical results and policy inference, would provide a more balanced impression.
|
|
Response 11: Thank you for this valuable comment. In response, we reorganised the Discussion and Conclusions sections to provide a clearer distinction between the empirical findings obtained from university students in Colombia and Ecuador and the practical and policy implications for entrepreneurship education. The implications are now presented in a separate paragraph, avoiding direct extrapolations to the broader regional context. All revisions have been highlighted in yellow in the revised manuscript and can be found in lines 556–561.
|
|
Comments 12: Regarding the academic contribution, the systematic verification of the factor structure of EIS and cross-country measurement invariance within the Latin American context is sufficiently meaningful to the readership of Behavioral Sciences. |
|
Response 12: Thank you very much for this positive assessment of our work. We are pleased that the reviewer considers the confirmation of the factorial structure and measurement invariance of the Entrepreneurial Intentions Scale among university students in Colombia and Ecuador to be a valuable contribution to psychometric and cross-cultural research in Latin America, as well as of interest to the readership of Behavioral Sciences.
|
|
Comments 13: The analysis techniques used and the reported metrics meet current international journal standards, and the paper will become even more robust with a few additional technical improvements. |
|
Response 13: We sincerely appreciate this positive assessment of our work. |
|
4. Response to Comments on the Quality of English Language |
|
Point: The English could be improved to more clearly express the research. |
|
Response 1 The English could be improved to more clearly express the research. |
|
5. Additional clarifications |
|
We sincerely appreciate your valuable observations. We have made the corresponding changes according to the reviewer’s suggestions. |
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThanks