Review Reports
- Shiying Yang 1,
- Tao Dong 1 and
- Bo Song 3,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Venkata Vijaya Kumar Dalai Reviewer 3: Atanu Kumar Pati
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear author(s),
This manuscript examines the relationships among short‑form video addiction, social anxiety, self‑control, and sleep quality among college students, with a particular focus on the serial mediating roles of social anxiety and self‑control. The topic is relevant and potentially valuable for the fields of behavioral science and mental health, and the effort to integrate the I‑PACE model with a serial mediation framework is commendable. The manuscript also has practical significance in that it attempts to clarify the psychological pathways through which short‑form video addiction may be associated with sleep quality. At the same time, the current version has several theoretical, methodological, interpretive, and practical weaknesses that need to be addressed before the manuscript can be considered for publication. My comments below are intended to help strengthen the paper.
First, the paper ignores the potential bidirectional causal relationship and endogeneity issues between short-form video addiction and poor sleep quality. Though the reciprocal association is partially mentioned, the research only assumes a unidirectional causal path, lacking rigorous verification of reverse causality, which undermines the validity of causal inference.
Second, the introduction does not sufficiently summarise the gaps in existing research, so the innovative points of this study are not very clear. The introduction reviews relevant studies and clearly shows the relationships between short‑form video addiction, social anxiety, self‑control, and sleep quality. However, it does not clearly point out the gaps or limitations of previous research. As a result, readers may find it difficult to quickly see how this study differs from past work and what its unique value is. We suggest briefly summarising the limitations of existing research, and then naturally leading to the need and main contribution of this study. This would make the innovative points clearer and more convincing.
Third, the explanation of the serial mediation effect is not deep enough, and the theoretical meaning behind the relatively small effect size is not fully explored. The paper notes that the serial mediation effect accounts for only 6.25% of the total effect, which is much smaller than the independent mediating effects. However, it simply attributes this to "other factors that may play a role", without using the I‑PACE model or other relevant theories to deeply analyse the meaning of this result. It also does not discuss the practical value of this serial path within the overall research model. We suggest adding a deeper analysis of why the serial mediation effect is small, using the I‑PACE model or related psychological theories, and clearly stating the actual role and theoretical value of this serial path in the research model. This would make the explanation more insightful and professional.
Fourth, the selection and handling of control variables lack sufficient theoretical support, and the reasons for including these variables are not very clear. The model includes gender, whether the participant is an only child, and type of residence as covariates. However, the paper does not explain why these control variables were chosen or how they are theoretically related to the core variables (such as short‑form video addiction and sleep quality). Therefore, the logic of including these variables could be made clearer. We suggest adding a justification for the choice of covariates in the Methods section, clearly explaining how gender, only‑child status, and residence type may potentially relate to the core variables. This would improve the reasonableness and scientific quality of the control variable selection.
Fifth, the study does not present a clear hypothesised model diagram, which makes it less easy for readers to grasp the overall research framework at a glance. The paper only describes the research hypotheses and the paths between variables in words, without designing and inserting a simple hypothesised model diagram. Readers have to read through the text carefully to understand the relationships among the variables, which reduces the efficiency of comprehension. It is also harder to quickly see the core logic of the study. We suggest adding a clear and simple hypothesised model diagram in the section on research hypotheses, visually showing the path relationships among the variables. This would help readers quickly and accurately understand the overall research framework.
Sixth, the specific sampling procedures within the university are not described in detail, so the transparency of the sampling process could be improved. The paper only briefly mentions that convenience sampling was used, but it does not explain the specific sampling process within the university. As a result, readers cannot understand the details of sample selection, which makes it harder to judge the representativeness of the sample. We suggest adding more details about how the sampling was carried out within the university. This would make the sampling process more concrete and clear, and improve the transparency and trustworthiness of the research procedures.
Seventh, the demographic variables included in the study are relatively limited, so the sample characteristics are not fully presented. The paper only reports three demographic variables: gender, whether the participant is an only child, and type of residence. It does not include other key variables that are closely related to the research topic, such as grade level or daily time spent watching short videos. As a result, readers cannot fully understand the basic characteristics of the participating university students, which is not helpful for interpreting the results or generalising the findings. We suggest adding key demographic variables such as age, grade level, and daily short‑form video viewing time. This would provide a more complete picture of the sample characteristics and help readers better understand the participant group.
Eighth, the description of the exclusion criterion related to open‑ended questions is not clear, so the rigour of this criterion could be strengthened. Section 3.1 states that "failing to answer a required open‑ended question" was used as a criterion for excluding questionnaires. However, later the paper only introduces the four scales used in the study, all of which are closed‑ended Likert scales. This may confuse readers. We suggest clearly stating what the open‑ended questions were and why failing to answer them was used as an exclusion criterion. This would ensure that the description is accurate and easy to understand.
Ninth, the practical intervention suggestions offered by the study are rather broad, and their specificity and actionability could be improved. Therefore, the applied value of the research is not fully shown. The paper only makes general suggestions such as "regulating the recommendation algorithms of short‑video platforms" and "introducing relevant policies". It does not design specific and feasible intervention plans that take into account the psychological characteristics and behavioural habits of university students. As a result, it is difficult to directly guide practical interventions by universities, students, or platforms. We suggest adding a stratified intervention strategy targeting three parties: universities, university students, and short‑video platforms. This would make the intervention suggestions more concrete and easier to implement, and would better realise the practical value of the research.
Overall, I believe the manuscript addresses a meaningful research question and has the potential to make a useful contribution. However, the current version requires substantial revision in order to clarify the conceptual framework and causal assumptions, improve methodological transparency and sampling details, provide a deeper interpretation of the serial mediation findings, and strengthen the practical implications with more actionable intervention strategies.
Best regards.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 1
First, we would like to express our sincere gratitude for your thorough and professional review.
Comment 1: “First, the paper ignores the potential bidirectional causal relationship and endogeneity issues between short-form video addiction and poor sleep quality.”
Author's answer: Thank you for pointing out this critical issue. The bidirectional relationship between variables is a core argument of the I-PACE model. However, due to the cross-sectional design of this study, we are unable to infer causality or examine bidirectional relationships. Therefore, we have explicitly highlighted this limitation in the limitations and future directions paragraph of the Discussion section and noted that future research should employ longitudinal designs to explore bidirectional relationships.
Comment 2: “Second, the introduction does not sufficiently summarise the gaps in existing research...”
Author's answer: This is an excellent suggestion. We have supplemented the gaps and limitations of previous research in the Introduction (last paragraph), explicitly noting that “previous studies have mainly focused on single mediators and have not explored the synergistic effects of affective, cognitive, and executive components within a unified theoretical framework.” We have also strengthened the statements on the innovative and theoretical contributions of this study in the Introduction and Conclusion.
Comment 3: “Third, the explanation of the serial mediation effect is not deep enough...”
Author's answer: Thank you for your insightful comment. The proportion of the total effect accounted for by a serial mediation effect is typically smaller than that of independent mediation effects due to statistical reasons (it is the product of multiple regression coefficients). After revision, we have deepened the theoretical explanation of this pathway in the Discussion, clarifying that although its effect size is small, it is statistically robust and theoretically meaningful, representing a sequential transmission mechanism from affective-cognitive to executive components (see paragraph 7 of the Discussion for details).
Comment 4: “Fourth, the selection and handling of control variables lack sufficient theoretical support...”
Author's answer: In response, we have added a rationale for the selection of control variables in Section 3.3, supported by relevant literature and the observed correlations among variables in this study. We also added “age” as a control variable to make the model more reasonable.
Comment 5: “Fifth, the study does not present a clear hypothesised model diagram...”
Author's answer: This suggestion has been adopted. We have added a clear and concise hypothesized model diagram (Figure 1) at the end of Section 2.4 to help readers quickly grasp the overall research framework.
Comment 6: “Sixth, the specific sampling procedures within the university are not described in detail...”
Author's answer: We have added a detailed description of the sampling procedure in Section 3.1, including how questionnaires were distributed and collected (e.g., using public class time and an online platform) to enhance the transparency and credibility of the research procedure.
Comment 7: “Seventh, the demographic variables included in the study are relatively limited...”
Author's answer: We have added demographic variables such as age and grade to Table 1. Regarding the variable “daily short-form video viewing time,” because we did not obtain objective data from participants’ mobile devices, accurate data are lacking. We have acknowledged this as a limitation in the final paragraph of the Discussion.
Comment 8: “Eighth, the description of the exclusion criterion related to open‑ended questions is not clear...”
Author's answer: Thank you for pointing out this error. Our study used only closed-ended Likert scales, not open-ended questions. The original intended meaning was “questionnaires with clearly incorrect responses (e.g., incorrect age or class).” We have corrected the description of the exclusion criteria in Section 3.1.
Comment 9: “Ninth, the practical intervention suggestions offered by the study are rather broad...”
Author's answer: We have rewritten this section, and, based on the findings of this study (the differing mediating effects of social anxiety and self-control at different stages), proposed more targeted and actionable tiered intervention strategies, including specific recommendations at the levels of public health agencies and government.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis manuscript addresses an important and increasingly relevant topic by examining the relationship between short-form video addiction and sleep quality among college students and exploring the mediating roles of social anxiety and self-control. The study is grounded in the I-PACE theoretical framework and contributes to the growing literature on problematic digital media use and its mental health consequences.
Strengths of the manuscript include the use of validated measurement instruments, an adequate sample size, and appropriate statistical analyses, including mediation modeling with bootstrapping procedures. The manuscript is generally well organized, and the theoretical rationale for the proposed relationships is clearly presented.
Several areas could be strengthened to improve the manuscript:
- The cross-sectional nature of the study should be emphasized more clearly throughout the discussion. Some interpretations imply directional or causal relationships that cannot be established from the current design. More cautious language is recommended.
- The practical significance of the findings should be discussed in greater depth. Although the reported associations and mediation effects are statistically significant, readers would benefit from additional discussion regarding their real-world implications and effect sizes.
- Because all measures were self-reported, the potential influence of common method variance and reporting bias should be addressed more comprehensively in the limitations section.
- The sample was recruited from a single university, which may limit the generalizability of the findings. Further discussion of cultural, geographic, and demographic considerations would strengthen the manuscript.
- The discussion section would benefit from a more balanced consideration of alternative explanations for the observed relationships, particularly the potential bidirectional relationship between sleep problems and problematic media use.
- Future research directions could be expanded to include longitudinal and experimental designs that would help clarify temporal and causal relationships among short-form video addiction, social anxiety, self-control, and sleep quality.
Overall, this is a well-conducted study that addresses a contemporary and clinically relevant issue. With revisions addressing the points above, the manuscript would make a useful contribution to the literature.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe manuscript would also benefit from professional English-language editing to improve clarity, grammar, and readability. Several sentences are awkwardly phrased, terminology is occasionally inconsistent, and some sections of the discussion are repetitive.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 2
Thank you for recognizing the significance of our study and for providing a series of constructive feedback.
Comment 1: “The cross-sectional nature of the study should be emphasized more clearly throughout the discussion. Some interpretations imply directional or causal relationships...”
Author's answer: We fully agree with your point. We have carefully reviewed the manuscript and revised any language that might imply causality, uniformly using more cautious terms such as “associated with” or “predicted” (in a statistical sense). We also reiterated this core limitation in the limitations and future directions section of the Discussion.
Comment 2: “The practical significance of the findings should be discussed in greater depth... readers would benefit from additional discussion regarding their real-world implications and effect sizes.”
Author's answer: Thank you for this suggestion. In the Discussion (paragraphs 3–7), we have deepened the discussion of the mediation effect sizes, including the total indirect effect, the independent indirect effects and their comparison, and the serial mediation effect. Drawing on the I-PACE model, we elaborated on the practical warning meaning of these effect sizes and their implications for interventions, thereby highlighting the practical value of our findings.
Comment 3: “Because all measures were self-reported, the potential influence of common method variance and reporting bias should be addressed more comprehensively...”
Author's answer: We have more comprehensively discussed the potential influence of common method bias in the limitations section of the Discussion. Although Harman’s single-factor test indicated that the bias was within an acceptable range, we acknowledge the limited sensitivity of this method and recommend that future research incorporate objective data.
Comment 4: “The sample was recruited from a single university, which may limit the generalizability of the findings.”
Author's answer: In the limitations section, we have detailed the restrictions on sample representativeness and generalizability due to convenience sampling and the single-university setting, citing relevant reviews, and we suggest future cross-cultural and cross-regional validation.
Comment 5: “The discussion section would benefit from a more balanced consideration of alternative explanations... particularly the potential bidirectional relationship...”
Author's answer: The bidirectional relationship is central to the I-PACE model, but our study only examined one direction. We have extensively discussed this as an important alternative explanation and future research direction in the limitations and future directions, and recommended cross-lagged panel designs for further investigation.
Comment 6: “Future research directions could be expanded to include longitudinal and experimental designs...”
Author's answer: We have added future research directions in the last paragraph of the Discussion, explicitly recommending longitudinal tracking and experimental designs to test temporal order and causality, thereby further elucidating the dynamic relationships among the variables observed in this study.
Comment 7: “The Quality of English Language... terminology is occasionally inconsistent, and some sections of the discussion are repetitive.”
Author's answer: We have carefully reviewed and revised the manuscript, unified terminology (e.g., consistently using “SVA” for short-form video addiction), optimized phrasing, and restructured the Discussion section to eliminate repetition.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsReference: behavsci-4336996
Title: The impact of short-term video addiction on sleep quality: The mediating roles of emotional, cognitive, and executive components.
Authors: Yang et al.
It has been well established that short-term video addiction has a substantial impact on sleep quality in humans in general and adolescents in particular (Zhao et al. 2023 and Xie et al., 2023 in Frontiers in Psychology; Xiao et al., 2026, in Brain and Bahavior and Yan et al. (2024) in Frontiers in Human Neuroscience). Further, Mona et al. (2026, in the International Journal of Adolescence and Youth) have extensively reviewed the studies conducted in this domain. Therefore, I found a little novelty in this study. However, the authors of this study had investigated the mediating role of social anxiety and self-control in the relationship between short-form video addiction and sleep quality.
This study has been well designed on a sample of adequate size. The authors have tested four different hypotheses to bring home their findings. However, there are many problems in the article that I outlined below:
- The literature review is inadequate, and the authors did not cite some of the very important original and review articles dealing with similar lines of investigation.
- There is a complete lack of information regarding the time period when the questionnaires were distributed and the responses were collected. How did the participants come to know about the online platform that was used to get the responses?
- The demographic variables mentioned in Table 1 are incomplete. The first column heading, ‘Projects,’ is difficult to comprehend. For example, how could the factor ' Gender ' be a project? There is no information about the anthropological variables of the participants and their food habits and chronotypes.
- The factor ‘Chronotype’ might have played a significant role in the extent of short-form addictive behavior and also in sleep quality. The authors may please provide information about the chronotypes of the participants. Normally, night-active/evening-active adolescents are likely to be the most addicted to SFV.
- The authors may please re-examine the data and find out how social anxiety, self-control, and sleep quality varied as a function of chronotype in the studied population.
- This reviewer did not find any data on individual components of the PSQI (Buysse et al. 1989). There is no mention of the global PSQI score. There is no idea how many participants crossed the standard cutoff PSQI score of 5.0 and how these scores were distributed across different characteristics of the sample, such as chronotype, gender, only child, and residence, etc.
- How many participants had a PSQI cutoff score of 8.0 or above? This information is very important for a study trying to find out the impact of SFV on sleep quality in adolescents.
- The data presented in Tables 2-4 and Figure 1 are essential, but they do not provide a clear perspective of the study to the readers.
- The authors have to elaborate on the I-PACE model for the benefit of the readers.
- The authors have established a negative relationship between SVA and sleep quality. The results surely corroborate a large body of research that has already discovered a negative relationship between SVA and sleep quality. However, this study is based on a sample that is large enough to say something about this relationship.
- The authors may please take note of the above-mentioned points. The negative reinforcement mechanisms may be explained in more detail for the benefit of the readers.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 3
Thank you for your thorough review and professional suggestions.
Comment 1: “The literature review is inadequate, and the authors did not cite some of the very important original and review articles...”
Author's answer: Thank you for your recommendations. We have added some of the important references you suggested, especially in the Introduction and literature review. After critical evaluation, we found that two of the recommended articles were not strongly relevant to the core pathways of this study; therefore, after careful consideration, we did not include them to avoid citation redundancy and ensure citation precision.
Comment 2: “There is a complete lack of information regarding the time period when the questionnaires were distributed and the responses were collected.”
Author's answer: We have added the specific time period for questionnaire distribution and collection (June 2025) in Section 3.1, along with a description of how participants were informed and completed the questionnaires online during public classes.
Comment 3: “The demographic variables mentioned in Table 1 are incomplete. The first column heading, ‘Projects,’ is difficult to comprehend.”
Author's answer: As suggested, we have added demographic variables such as age and grade to Table 1 to provide more complete sample information. We have also corrected the heading of the first column from “Projects” to “Variables.” Thank you for pointing out this inappropriate wording.
Comment 4: “The factor ‘Chronotype’ might have played a significant role...”
Author's answer: This is a very valuable perspective. Our study did not measure chronotype, which is a limitation. We have added this as an important limitation in the Discussion and suggested that future research include this variable.
Comment 5: “This reviewer did not find any data on individual components of the PSQI... There is no idea how many participants crossed the standard cutoff PSQI score of 5.0...”
Author's answer: We have added the numbers and percentages of participants with PSQI scores >5 and >7 to Table 1, and added an explanation of these two commonly used cut-off scores (5 and 7) in Section 3.2, along with a comparison with previous data from Chinese university students, to provide a clearer perspective.
Comment 6: “The authors have to elaborate on the I-PACE model for the benefit of the readers.”
Author's answer: We have expanded the explanation of the I-PACE model at the beginning of Chapter 2, particularly elaborating on its core mechanism—the vicious cycle formed by addictive behavior and risk factors—to help readers understand the theoretical foundation of this study.
Comment 7: “The negative reinforcement mechanisms may be explained in more detail for the benefit of the readers.”
Author's answer: Thank you for your insightful comment. We have added a detailed explanation of this mechanism in the literature review. It should be clarified that the previous reference to “negative reinforcement” was a translation error. In the current revision, we have used “reverse pathway reinforcement” and “vicious-cycle” to accurately describe the process. Specifically, “vicious-cycle” refers to the complete self-reinforcing cycle in the I-PACE model in which addictive behavior exacerbates its own risk factors through various components, comprising both the influence of PACE on behavior and the reverse effect of behavior on PACE; “reverse pathway reinforcement” specifically refers to the reverse effect of addictive behavior on PACE factors.
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Editor,
Thank you for the opportunity to review the revised manuscript. The authors have satisfactorily addressed all the concerns raised in the previous round of review. The revisions have significantly improved the manuscript, particularly in further refining the theoretical framework. I have no further comments or suggestions for revision. The paper is now suitable for publication in its current form.
Thank you again for the opportunity to contribute to the review process.
Best regards.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsFuture studies should account for chronotype as a potential confounding or moderating factor in the interpretation of findings.