Review Reports
- Galia Meoded Karabanov * and
- Dorit Aram
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous Reviewer 4: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Author(s), thank you for conducting this study. I have outlined the strengths and weaknesses/areas for improvement of this research below.
Strengths and weaknesses/areas for improvement:
- The article title is structured to accurately reflect the content.
- The article addresses a highly significant topic. This is because the transition from traditional literacy to a digital literacy environment is rapidly spreading worldwide. The topic is relevant to current developments.
- The choice of a mixed-methods approach is consistent with the research methodology. The sample size is adequate.
- The abstract provides sufficient information about the entire study. It is also written in a fluent manner.
- The keywords are consistent with the content of the study. They are also sufficient in number. However, is it necessary to include “mixed-methods”? Could the term “early childhood” be used instead to reach a wider audience?
- The article includes an adequate number of in-text citations and references from recent years. This demonstrates that the researchers are keeping up with current studies.
- Theories suggesting that children are influenced by their environment have been included. This effectively strengthens the rationale and foundation of the research.
- The objectives of the study are appropriately listed.
- I recommend including the research paradigm that outlines the underlying philosophy of the study’s design.
- Approval from the ethics committee is mentioned.
- What criteria were considered when determining the size of the study group? You must explain this separately in both qualitative and quantitative contexts, based on the references.
- I recommend explaining the validity and reliability results of the measurement tools used.
- If generative AI tools were used to create the figures, this must be disclosed. It is important to include a disclosure regarding the use of generative AI tools at every stage of the research.
- The rationale for choosing the preferred statistical methods in data analysis can be explained.
- What methods were used to ensure inter-researcher reliability in the analysis of qualitative data? How were themes identified? Were Cohen’s Kappa or Miles & Huberman techniques employed?
- I recommend providing detailed information on the demographic characteristics of the study group. For example, there are significant developmental differences among children aged 47–82. Therefore, more detailed information could be included to help us better understand the participant group.
- The discussion section is of high quality in terms of content. It includes both differing and supporting viewpoints. However, potential causes, predictions, and recommendations could be explored in greater depth.
- Regarding the study’s limitations, various shortcomings or weaknesses, such as socioeconomic status, are clearly stated.
- The research recommendations are sufficient and practical. However, instead of broad or general recommendations, more specific ones could also be included.
- When and by what methods were the research data collected? This needs to be explained in detail.
Author Response
Reviewer 1
Dear Author(s), thank you for conducting this study. I have outlined the strengths and weaknesses/areas for improvement of this research below.
Strengths and weaknesses/areas for improvement:
- The article title is structured to accurately reflect the content.
- The article addresses a highly significant topic. This is because the transition from traditional literacy to a digital literacy environment is rapidly spreading worldwide. The topic is relevant to current developments.
- The choice of a mixed-methods approach is consistent with the research methodology. The sample size is adequate.
- The abstract provides sufficient information about the entire study. It is also written in a fluent manner.
- The keywords are consistent with the content of the study. They are also sufficient in number. However, is it necessary to include “mixed-methods”? Could the term “early childhood” be used instead to reach a wider audience?
Thank you for your comment. Regarding the list of keywords, we appreciate your suggestion and replaced "mixed methods" with "early childhood" to improve the article's discoverability and broaden its reach.
- The article includes an adequate number of in-text citations and references from recent years. This demonstrates that the researchers are keeping up with current studies.
- Theories suggesting that children are influenced by their environment have been included. This effectively strengthens the rationale and foundation of the research.
- The objectives of the study are appropriately listed.
- I recommend including the research paradigm that outlines the underlying philosophy of the study’s design.
Thank you for your comments. In line with your suggestion, we added that the study was guided by a pragmatic research paradigm and was consistent with an embedded mixed-methods design that integrates quantitative and qualitative data to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the research questions. This information has been added to the Study Design and Procedure section (see p. 5).
- Approval from the ethics committee is mentioned.
- What criteria were considered when determining the size of the study group? You must explain this separately in both qualitative and quantitative contexts, based on the references.
Thank you for this comment. We have now clarified the rationale for the sample size separately for the study's quantitative and qualitative components. Specifically, we added the methodological justification for the quantitative sample size, based on recommendations for multiple regression analyses, and explained the adequacy of the qualitative sample using the principle of information power. These clarifications have been added to the Study Design and Procedure section (p. 5).
- I recommend explaining the validity and reliability results of the measurement tools used.
All measurement instruments used in the present study were based on previously developed and validated questionnaires used in prior research (e.g., Aram & Bar-Am, 2016; Meoded Karabanov et al., 2021). To provide a more comprehensive description of the measures, additional sample items were included for each instrument, and references to studies in which these measures were previously used were added where applicable. As shown in Table 1, Cronbach's alpha coefficients for the multi-item scales in the current sample ranged from .67 to .88, indicating acceptable to good internal consistency (Nunnally & Bernstein, 1994).
Additional References
Aram, D., & Bar-Am, O. C. (2016). Mothers helping their preschool children to spell words: A comparison between interactions using the computer vs. pencil and paper. International Journal of Child-Computer Interactions, 7, 15– 21. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijcci.2016.03.001
Meoded Karabanov, G., Asaf, M., Ziv, M., & Aram, D. (2021). Parental Behaviors and Involvement in Children’s Digital Activities among Israeli Jewish and Arab Families during the COVID-19 Lockdown. Early Education and Development, 32(6), 881–902. https://doi.org/10.1080/10409289.2021.1882810
Nunnally, J. C., & Bernstein, I. H. (1994). Psychometric theory (3rd ed.). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
- If generative AI tools were used to create the figures, this must be disclosed. It is important to include a disclosure regarding the use of generative AI tools at every stage of the research.
Thank you for this important comment. We have added a transparent disclosure regarding the use of generative AI in accordance with the journal's guidelines. Specifically, we included (a) a statement in the Methods section describing that the images used as standardized visual stimuli during the children's interviews were generated using ChatGPT (OpenAI), (b) a corresponding note in the caption of Figure 1 (p. 7), and (c) an acknowledgment at the end of the manuscript, clarifying the scope of AI use and emphasizing that all aspects of the study design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, and conclusions were conducted by the authors.
- The rationale for choosing the preferred statistical methods in data analysis can be explained.
Thank you for this suggestion. We have revised the Data Analysis section (pp. 6–7) to provide a clearer rationale for the selected quantitative and qualitative analytic methods. Specifically, we explain why each statistical procedure (descriptive statistics, partial Pearson correlations, and hierarchical multiple regression) was chosen to address the study's research questions and hypotheses. We also revised the description of the qualitative analysis to clarify the rationale for using thematic analysis and to provide a more detailed account of the coding and theme development process.
- What methods were used to ensure inter-researcher reliability in the analysis of qualitative data? How were themes identified? Were Cohen’s Kappa or Miles & Huberman techniques employed?
We have further revised the Analysis of Qualitative Data section (p. 8) to provide a more detailed description of the qualitative analytic process. Specifically, we clarified how themes were identified through an inductive thematic analysis, including the processes of coding, constant comparison, and iterative refinement. We also expanded the description of the procedures used to enhance the trustworthiness of the analysis, explaining that both authors independently reviewed the codes and emerging themes, discussed coding decisions throughout the analytic process, and refined the thematic structure until consensus was reached (Braun & Clarke, 2006).
- I recommend providing detailed information on the demographic characteristics of the study group. For example, there are significant developmental differences among children aged 47–82. Therefore, more detailed information could be included to help us better understand the participant group.
We have expanded the Participants section (pp. 5-6) by providing a more detailed description of the children's age distribution, including the number and percentage of participants in each age group, to better characterize the study sample.
- The discussion section is of high quality in terms of content. It includes both differing and supporting viewpoints. However, potential causes, predictions, and recommendations could be explored in greater depth.
We thank the reviewer for this positive and constructive comment. In response, we further strengthened the Discussion by expanding the interpretation of the findings and providing additional consideration of potential explanations for the observed patterns. We also elaborated on the educational and theoretical implications of the findings and added a forward-looking perspective on the evolving role of digital literacy in children's home literacy environments, while maintaining appropriately cautious interpretations consistent with the study's cross-sectional design (pp. 15-19).
- Regarding the study’s limitations, various shortcomings or weaknesses, such as socioeconomic status, are clearly stated.
Thank you for your positive evaluation of the study's limitations section.
- The research recommendations are sufficient and practical. However, instead of broad or general recommendations, more specific ones could also be included.
In response to this suggestion, we revised the Implications section to include more specific educational recommendations. In particular, we emphasized the potential value of meaningful parent-child co-use, shared digital literacy activities, and scaffolded engagement with digital tools, rather than providing only broad recommendations regarding children's digital media use.
- When and by what methods were the research data collected? This needs to be explained in detail.
We have revised the Study Design and Procedure section to specify that data were collected between January and April 2025 and to provide additional details regarding the data collection procedures for both parents and children (p. 5).
Thank you for the thorough review process. We appreciate the comments and have made every effort to respond to each. We believe that this has both clarified and strengthened the manuscript.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis manuscript addresses an incresingly relevant topic, namely the role of digital home environments and parent-child digital literacy activities in shaping young children's interest in literacy practices. The mixed-methods design is a strength of the study, as it combines quantitative findings with the perspectives of both parents and children. I particularly appreciated the inclusion of children's voices, which remains relatively uncommon in this literature and adds value to the paper.
Overall, the manuscript is well organised, clearly written, and grounded in established theoretical frameworks,. The findings are generally consistent with the study aims and make a useful contibution to the growing literature on digital literacy in early childhood.
Major Comments
-
Literature Review
The introduction provides a solid overview of digital home environments and parent-child literacy practices. However, the discussion of technology-assisted learning could be broadened somewhat. The curent review focuses mainly on preschool literacy and parental mediation, but there is less consideration of the wider evidence showing how technology can support children's learning and academic engagement.
The authors may wish to consider citing:
Andreou, G., & Argatzopoulou, A. (2024). A systematic review on the use of technology to enhance the academic achievements of children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in language learning. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 145, 104666.
Although focused on children with ADHD and language learning outcomes, this review provides a useful synthesis regarding the educational potential of technology-supported learning environments and may strengthen the broader rationale regarding the role of digital tools in children's learning and engagement.
-
Interpretation of Parental Mediation Findings
The finding that parental involvement in selecting digital content was negatively associated with children's interest in digital literacy activities is interesting and deserves a little more discussion. While the authors suggest that restrictive medition may reduce children's autonomy, alternative explanations should also be acknowledged. For example, parents may become more controlling when children already demonstrate lower engagment or difficulties with self-regulation. Given the cross-sectional nature of the study, causal interpretations should be avoided.
-
Sample Characteristics and Generalisability
The authors acnowledge that the sample largely represents middle- to high-SES families. I think this limitation deserves slightly greater attention. Access to digital devices, parental confidence with techology, and literacy-related activities can vary substantially across socioeconomic contexts. A short discusion of how these factors may influence the findings would strengthen the manuscript.
Minor Comments
-
Some sections of the Discusion repeat finings before interpreting them. The flow could be improved by reducing repetition and moving more quickly toward interpretation and implications.
-
The qualitative findings are interesting, but additional information regarding coding reliability or procedures used to enhance trustworhiness would be helpful.
-
The manuscript occasionally alternates between discussing "digital media", "digital literacy activities", and "digital writing". At some points these concepts seem to overlap. Greater conceptual clarity may improve readability.
-
It may be useful to indicate whether any gender differences were explored, even if no significant findings emerged.
-
A careful proofread would be beneficial, as there are a few minor wording inconsistencies throughout the manuscript.
This is a timely and well-conducted study that contributes valuable insights into children's digital literacy experiences within the home environment. The mixed-methods aproach and inclusion of children's perspectives are notable strengths. However, several points need clarification/improvement before a further evaluation should be made.
Author Response
10 July, 2026
Manuscript ID: behavsci-4377018
Reviewer 2
This manuscript addresses an increasingly relevant topic, namely the role of digital home environments and parent-child digital literacy activities in shaping young children's interest in literacy practices. The mixed-methods design is a strength of the study, as it combines quantitative findings with the perspectives of both parents and children. I particularly appreciated the inclusion of children's voices, which remains relatively uncommon in this literature and adds value to the paper.
Overall, the manuscript is well organized, clearly written, and grounded in established theoretical frameworks. The findings are generally consistent with the study aims and make a useful contribution to the growing literature on digital literacy in early childhood.
We sincerely thank Reviewer 2 for the thoughtful and constructive evaluation of our manuscript. We greatly appreciate the positive comments regarding the relevance of the topic, the mixed-methods design, and the inclusion of children's perspectives. The reviewer's insightful suggestions have helped us improve the clarity and quality of the manuscript, and we have carefully addressed each comment in the revised version. Our responses are detailed below in italics.
Major Comments
- Literature Review
The introduction provides a solid overview of digital home environments and parent-child literacy practices. However, the discussion of technology-assisted learning could be broadened somewhat. The current review focuses mainly on preschool literacy and parental mediation, but there is less consideration of the wider evidence showing how technology can support children's learning and academic engagement. The authors may wish to consider citing:
Andreou, G., & Argatzopoulou, A. (2024). A systematic review on the use of technology to enhance the academic achievements of children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in language learning. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 145, 104666. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ridd.2023.104666.
Although focused on children with ADHD and language learning outcomes, this review provides a useful synthesis regarding the educational potential of technology-supported learning environments and may strengthen the broader rationale regarding the role of digital tools in children's learning and engagement.
Thank you for your suggestion. We have addressed this comment by adding a paragraph to the Introduction (p. 3) that broadens the discussion of technology-assisted learning and highlights evidence that well-designed digital technologies can support children's engagement and learning.
- Interpretation of Parental Mediation Findings
The finding that parental involvement in selecting digital content was negatively associated with children's interest in digital literacy activities is interesting and deserves a little more discussion. While the authors suggest that restrictive mediation may reduce children's autonomy, alternative explanations should also be acknowledged. For example, parents may become more controlling when children already demonstrate lower engagement or difficulties with self-regulation. Given the cross-sectional nature of the study, causal interpretations should be avoided.
Following your suggestion, we have expanded the Discussion (p. 15) to acknowledge an alternative explanation for this finding: that more restrictive parental mediation may reflect a response to children's lower engagement or self-regulation difficulties. In addition, we revised the wording to avoid causal interpretations. Thank you.
- Sample Characteristics and Generalizability
The authors acknowledge that the sample largely represents middle- to high-SES families. I think this limitation deserves slightly greater attention. Access to digital devices, parental confidence with technology, and literacy-related activities can vary substantially across socioeconomic contexts. A short discussion of how these factors may influence the findings would strengthen the manuscript.
Thank you for this valuable comment. We have revised the limitations section to acknowledge the sample's socioeconomic characteristics and their implications for the generalizability of the findings (p. 17).
Minor Comments
- Some sections of the Discussion repeat finings before interpreting them. The flow could be improved by reducing repetition and moving more quickly toward interpretation and implications.
Following your valuable comment, we revised the Discussion by reducing repetition of the findings and moving more directly to their interpretation and implications (pp. 13-15).
- The qualitative findings are interesting, but additional information regarding coding reliability or procedures used to enhance trustworthiness would be helpful.
Thank you. In line with this comment, and those of other reviewers, we have revised the Analysis of Qualitative Data section (p. 8) to provide a more detailed description of the qualitative analytic process. Specifically, we clarified how themes were identified through an inductive thematic analysis, including the processes of coding, constant comparison, and iterative refinement. We also expanded the description of the procedures used to enhance the trustworthiness of the analysis, explaining that both authors reviewed the initial codes and emerging themes, discussed coding decisions throughout the analytic process, and refined the thematic structure until consensus was reached.
- The manuscript occasionally alternates between discussing "digital media", "digital literacy activities", and "digital writing". At some points these concepts seem to overlap. Greater conceptual clarity may improve readability.
Thank you for this helpful suggestion. We added a clarification of the three related constructs in the Introduction (p. 2) and ensured consistent terminology throughout the manuscript.
- It may be useful to indicate whether any gender differences were explored, even if no significant findings emerged.
Thank you for this suggestion. Examining gender differences was beyond the scope of the present study. We agree that this is an important avenue for future research and have added this recommendation to the Limitations and Future Directions section (p. 16).
- A careful proofread would be beneficial, as there are a few minor wording inconsistencies throughout the manuscript.
We carefully proofread the entire manuscript and revised minor wording, grammar, and stylistic inconsistencies throughout the text to improve clarity and readability. Additionally, in light of this comment, we had a native English-language editor proofread and review the manuscript.
This is a timely and well-conducted study that contributes valuable insights into children's digital literacy experiences within the home environment. The mixed-methods approach and inclusion of children's perspectives are notable strengths. However, several points need clarification/improvement before a further evaluation should be made.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the positive evaluation of our manuscript and for the constructive and thoughtful comments. We carefully addressed all of the points raised and revised the manuscript accordingly. We believe these revisions have improved the clarity and overall quality of the paper.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsYour manuscript addresses an important and timely topic concerning preschool children's digital and traditional literacy experiences in the home environment. The mixed-methods approach is a notable strength, particularly the inclusion of children's own perspectives on digital writing, which remains relatively underexplored in the literature. Your manuscript is well organized, theoretically grounded, and engages with relevant scholarship on home literacy environments, digital literacy, and parental involvement. Your study makes a valuable contribution to the field; however, several aspects would benefit from clarification and further development before publication.
1. Provide additional information about measurement validity
While internal consistency coefficients are reported for the study measures, the manuscript would benefit from additional information regarding the development and validation of the instruments used. In particular, readers would benefit from a clearer description of the Digital Home Environment measures and the literacy interest scales, including sample items, evidence of prior use, and any available validity information. This would strengthen confidence in the interpretation of the findings.
2. Increase transparency of the qualitative analysis procedures
The qualitative component is an important contribution of the study. To enhance methodological rigor and transparency, please provide additional details regarding the coding process. Specifically:
- Were transcripts coded independently by more than one researcher?
- How were coding decisions developed and refined?
- Were any procedures used to enhance trustworthiness (e.g., intercoder discussion, audit trail, peer debriefing, reflexive memoing)?
- How were disagreements resolved?
Providing these details would allow readers to better evaluate the credibility of the qualitative findings.
3. Interpret correlational findings more cautiously
The discussion of the negative association between parental involvement in digital content selection and children's interest in digital literacy activities is interesting and potentially important. However, because the study is cross-sectional and correlational, the current interpretation should be more cautious. Alternative explanations deserve consideration. For example, parents may become more involved in selecting content when children show lower interest in literacy activities, or when parents have concerns about media quality or screen use. A broader discussion of possible bidirectional relationships would strengthen the interpretation.
4. Further address shared-method variance
Many key variables were measured through parent reports, including aspects of the home environment and children's literacy interests. Although this limitation is acknowledged, the manuscript would benefit from a more explicit discussion of how shared-method variance may have influenced the observed associations and how future research might address this issue through multiple informants or observational methods.
5. Expand discussion of generalizability
The sample appears to consist primarily of relatively highly educated Israeli families. Additional discussion is warranted regarding the extent to which the findings may generalize to families from different socioeconomic, linguistic, cultural, or national contexts. Clarifying these boundaries would help readers interpret the applicability of the findings.
6. Strengthen integration of quantitative and qualitative findings
The manuscript presents both quantitative and qualitative findings clearly. However, the mixed-methods contribution would be strengthened by more explicitly integrating the two strands in the discussion section. For example, the authors could highlight how children's qualitative descriptions help explain, elaborate on, or contextualize specific quantitative findings regarding literacy interests and home literacy practices.
To sum up, this is a well-conceived and potentially impactful study that contributes to the growing literature on early childhood digital literacy. The suggested revisions primarily concern clarification, methodological transparency, and more cautious interpretation of the findings. Addressing these points would further strengthen the manuscript and enhance its contribution to the field.
Author Response
10 July, 2026
Manuscript ID: behavsci-4377018
Reviewer 3
Your manuscript addresses an important and timely topic concerning preschool children's digital and traditional literacy experiences in the home environment. The mixed-methods approach is a notable strength, particularly the inclusion of children's own perspectives on digital writing, which remains relatively underexplored in the literature. Your manuscript is well organized, theoretically grounded, and engages with relevant scholarship on home literacy environments, digital literacy, and parental involvement. Your study makes a valuable contribution to the field; however, several aspects would benefit from clarification and further development before publication.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the positive evaluation of our manuscript and for the constructive and thoughtful comments. We have carefully addressed all of the suggestions in the revised manuscript. Our responses to the comments are detailed below in italics.
- Provide additional information about measurement validity
While internal consistency coefficients are reported for the study measures, the manuscript would benefit from additional information regarding the development and validation of the instruments used. In particular, readers would benefit from a clearer description of the Digital Home Environment measures and the literacy interest scales, including sample items, evidence of prior use, and any available validity information. This would strengthen confidence in the interpretation of the findings.
Thank you for your comment. Accordingly, we revised the Measures section by adding additional sample items for each questionnaire and including references to the original instruments from which the measures were adapted.
- Increase transparency of the qualitative analysis procedures
The qualitative component is an important contribution of the study. To enhance methodological rigor and transparency, please provide additional details regarding the coding process. Specifically:
- Were transcripts coded independently by more than one researcher?
- How were coding decisions developed and refined?
- Were any procedures used to enhance trustworthiness (e.g., intercoder discussion, audit trail, peer debriefing, reflexive memoing)?
- How were disagreements resolved?
Providing these details would allow readers to better evaluate the credibility of the qualitative findings.
Thank you for this important comment. In light of this, and comments by other reviewers, we have revised the Analysis of Qualitative Data section (p. 8) to provide a more detailed description of the qualitative analytic process. Specifically, we clarified how themes were identified through an inductive thematic analysis, including the processes of coding, constant comparison, and iterative refinement. We also expanded the description of the procedures used to enhance the trustworthiness of the analysis, explaining that both authors reviewed the initial codes and emerging themes, discussed coding decisions throughout the analytic process, and refined the thematic structure until consensus was reached.
- Interpret correlational findings more cautiously
The discussion of the negative association between parental involvement in digital content selection and children's interest in digital literacy activities is interesting and potentially important. However, because the study is cross-sectional and correlational, the current interpretation should be more cautious. Alternative explanations deserve consideration. For example, parents may become more involved in selecting content when children show lower interest in literacy activities, or when parents have concerns about media quality or screen use. A broader discussion of possible bidirectional relationships would strengthen the interpretation.
Thank you for this valuable comment. We revised the Discussion to present a more cautious interpretation of the observed association, emphasizing the study's cross-sectional and correlational design. We also added alternative explanations, including the possibility that greater parental involvement in selecting digital content may reflect children's lower interest in digital literacy activities or parents' concerns about media quality and screen use, and acknowledged the potential for bidirectional relationships (p.15).
- Further address shared-method variance
Many key variables were measured through parent reports, including aspects of the home environment and children's literacy interests. Although this limitation is acknowledged, the manuscript would benefit from a more explicit discussion of how shared-method variance may have influenced the observed associations and how future research might address this issue through multiple informants or observational methods.
Thank you for this important comment. We addressed this point in the Limitations section (p. 16) by discussing the potential influence of shared-method variance, acknowledging its possible effect on the observed associations, and suggesting that future research incorporate multiple informants and observational methods. We also noted that the qualitative data from both parents and children provided complementary perspectives.
- Expand discussion of generalizability
The sample appears to consist primarily of relatively highly educated Israeli families. Additional discussion is warranted regarding the extent to which the findings may generalize to families from different socioeconomic, linguistic, cultural, or national contexts. Clarifying these boundaries would help readers interpret the applicability of the findings.
Thank you for this recommendation. We have addressed this point in the Limitations section (p. 16) by expanding the discussion of the study's generalizability. Specifically, we acknowledged that the sample primarily comprised middle- to high-SES Israeli families with relatively high educational attainment, which may limit the generalizability of the findings to families from different socioeconomic and cultural backgrounds. We also highlighted the need for future research to examine more diverse populations.
- Strengthen integration of quantitative and qualitative findings
The manuscript presents both quantitative and qualitative findings clearly. However, the mixed-methods contribution would be strengthened by more explicitly integrating the two strands in the discussion section. For example, the authors could highlight how children's qualitative descriptions help explain, elaborate on, or contextualize specific quantitative findings regarding literacy interests and home literacy practices.
Thank you for this helpful comment. We revised the Discussion to more explicitly integrate the quantitative and qualitative findings. Specifically, we highlighted how the qualitative findings from both parents and children help explain, elaborate on, and contextualize the quantitative results regarding children's literacy interests, parental mediation, and home literacy practices.
To sum up, this is a well-conceived and potentially impactful study that contributes to the growing literature on early childhood digital literacy. The suggested revisions primarily concern clarification, methodological transparency, and more cautious interpretation of the findings. Addressing these points would further strengthen the manuscript and enhance its contribution to the field.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the positive evaluation of our manuscript and for the constructive and thoughtful comments. We carefully addressed all of the points raised and revised the manuscript accordingly. We believe these revisions have improved the clarity and overall quality of the paper.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis mixed-methods study addresses a timely question about preschool children’s digital and traditional literacy experiences at home. The inclusion of both parental and child perspectives is valuable, and the attempt to move beyond screen-time metrics toward socially mediated technology use is commendable.
Overall, the study has merit and addresses an important topic, but stronger measurement, more rigorous integration of mixed methods, and substantially more cautious causal and developmental conclusions are required. Thus, in this reviewer's view, the manuscript requires substantial revision before its conclusions can be considered adequately supported.
Major concerns
- The Digital Home Environment questionnaire contains only five items, divided into two-item and single-item indicators. In particular, “parental involvement in selecting digital content” is measured by a single item and should not be treated as a robust latent construct. The authors should report the complete items, response distributions, psychometric rationale, previous validation evidence, and reliability estimates for every multi-item measure. The relatively low reliability of parents’ perceptions of digital tools should also be acknowledged when interpreting the null association with children’s interest.
- Both the main predictors and the principal outcomes, including children’s interest in digital and traditional literacy, were reported by the same parent. The observed associations may therefore reflect parental beliefs, response styles, or global evaluations of the child rather than children’s actual engagement. The child interviews do not directly validate the parental interest ratings. This limitation should be made central to the interpretation.
- The manuscript suggests that parental content selection may reduce children’s autonomy and interest. This conclusion is not warranted by a cross-sectional association derived from a single-item measure. Parents may select content more actively because their children show little interest, use inappropriate content, or require greater supervision. The result should be described as an association with multiple plausible causal directions.
- The authors should report unstandardized coefficients, standard errors, confidence intervals, collinearity diagnostics, residual checks, and procedures for handling missing data. The association between joint digital and traditional literacy activities raises concerns about multicollinearity. Also, parental education, socioeconomic circumstances, child gender, device availability, language background, and actual frequency of device use are potential confounders that should be considered. If this is not feasible, the authors should note these aspects as limitations of the study.
- The qualitative component is described as cross-validating the quantitative findings, but the two components assess partly different constructs and use different respondent subsets. The authors should explain precisely how integration occurred, ideally through a joint display connecting quantitative variables, qualitative themes, convergence, divergence, and added explanatory value.
- The manuscript should report the number and role of coders, whether coding was independent, how disagreements were resolved, whether a codebook was developed, and how reflexivity and interpretive credibility were addressed.
- The two gender-matched images are not perceptually equivalent. They differ in keyboard appearance, surrounding objects, body posture, visual complexity, and potentially the apparent realism or attractiveness of the activity. These differences may influence children’s interpretations and preferences. This is a critical limitation of the study that should be acknowledged. Also, the study's narrative itself should be toned down, including the inclusion of an exploratory aim in the title.
- The findings support an association between reported joint activity and reported interest, but they do not demonstrate literacy learning, developmental benefit, or improved digital competence. The manuscript should distinguish interest from learning outcomes. A more appropriate interpretation is that active, meaningful, socially interactive digital experiences may create conditions conducive to learning, rather than proving that shared digital activities improve literacy development (Hirsh-Pasek et al., 2015).
- Interaction with technology involves partially distinguishable semantic, visuospatial, sensorimotor, executive, and socially mediated processes. The authors should provide a more precise account of what distinguishes digital literacy from traditional literacy at the neurocognitive level. An integrated technological-cognition framework may be useful here, particularly because it emphasises that technology use emerges from interactions among domain-general processors, technology-related knowledge, action systems, and social learning (Federico et al., 2025a). Also, recent evidence that digital and mechanical technologies can recruit partly distinct neurocognitive pathways further cautions against treating “digital” simply as a change in delivery medium (Federico et al., 2025b).
Minor concerns
- The manuscript requires careful language editing and correction of inconsistent publication years, duplicated headings, numbering errors, and several ambiguous descriptions. The hypotheses should be mapped explicitly onto the reported analyses.
- The authors should distinguish exploratory from confirmatory analyses and consider sharing the materials, anonymised data, coding framework, and analysis scripts.
References
- Federico, G., Osiurak, F., Brandimonte, M. A., Marangolo, P., & Ilardi, C. R. (2025a). An integrated account for technological cognition. Cognitive Neuroscience. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/17588928.2025.2542195
- Federico, G., Lesourd, M., Fournel, A., Bluet, A., Bryche, C., Metaireau, M., Baldi, D., Brandimonte, M. A., Soricelli, A., Rossetti, Y., & Osiurak, F. (2025b). Two distinct neural pathways for mechanical versus digital technology. NeuroImage, 305, Article 120971. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2024.120971
- Hirsh-Pasek, K., Zosh, J. M., Golinkoff, R. M., Gray, J. H., Robb, M. B., & Kaufman, J. (2015). Putting education in “educational” apps: Lessons from the science of learning. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 16(1), 3–34. https://doi.org/10.1177/1529100615569721
Author Response
10 July, 2026
Manuscript ID: behavsci-4377018
Reviewer 4
This mixed-methods study addresses a timely question about preschool children’s digital and traditional literacy experiences at home. The inclusion of both parental and child perspectives is valuable, and the attempt to move beyond screen-time metrics toward socially mediated technology use is commendable.
Overall, the study has merit and addresses an important topic, but stronger measurement, more rigorous integration of mixed methods, and substantially more cautious causal and developmental conclusions are required. Thus, in this reviewer's view, the manuscript requires substantial revision before its conclusions can be considered adequately supported.
We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful and constructive comments and for the positive evaluation of our study. We carefully revised the manuscript in response to all comments, including strengthening the description of the measures, improving the integration of quantitative and qualitative findings, and adopting more cautious interpretations throughout. Our detailed responses appear below in italics.
Major concerns
- The Digital Home Environment questionnaire contains only five items, divided into two-item and single-item indicators. In particular, “parental involvement in selecting digital content” is measured by a single item and should not be treated as a robust latent construct. The authors should report the complete items, response distributions, psychometric rationale, previous validation evidence, and reliability estimates for every multi-item measure. The relatively low reliability of parents’ perceptions of digital tools should also be acknowledged when interpreting the null association with children’s interest.
We revised the Measures section to provide a more detailed description of the Digital Home Environment questionnaire, including sample items for each subscale, the response format, and information regarding the development and adaptation of the measures (pp. 6-7). In addition, we have added a statement in the Discussion acknowledging that the relatively low reliability of the parents' perceptions of the digital tools measure may have reduced the ability to detect a significant unique contribution (pp. 10–11).
- Both the main predictors and the principal outcomes, including children’s interest in digital and traditional literacy, were reported by the same parent. The observed associations may therefore reflect parental beliefs, response styles, or global evaluations of the child rather than children’s actual engagement. The child interviews do not directly validate the parental interest ratings. This limitation should be made central to the interpretation.
Thank you for this important comment. We addressed this point in the Limitations section (p. 16) by discussing the potential influence of shared-method variance, acknowledging its possible effect on the observed associations, and suggesting that future research incorporate multiple informants and observational methods. We also noted that the qualitative data from both parents and children provided complementary perspectives.
- The manuscript suggests that parental content selection may reduce children’s autonomy and interest. This conclusion is not warranted by a cross-sectional association derived from a single-item measure. Parents may select content more actively because their children show little interest, use inappropriate content, or require greater supervision. The result should be described as an association with multiple plausible causal directions.
Thank you for this valuable comment. We added alternative explanations, including the possibility that greater parental involvement in selecting digital content may reflect children's lower interest in digital literacy activities or parents' concerns about media quality and screen use, and acknowledged the potential for bidirectional relationships (p.15).
- The authors should report unstandardized coefficients, standard errors, confidence intervals, collinearity diagnostics, residual checks, and procedures for handling missing data. The association between joint digital and traditional literacy activities raises concerns about multicollinearity. Also, parental education, socioeconomic circumstances, child gender, device availability, language background, and actual frequency of device use are potential confounders that should be considered. If this is not feasible, the authors should note these aspects as limitations of the study.
Following the reviewer's recommendation, we expanded the reporting of the hierarchical regression analyses. Specifically, we added information regarding missing data procedures, multicollinearity diagnostics, and residual checks in the Results (p. 10-11). We also revised the hierarchical regression analyses by including children's age, gender, parental education, and parent-reported independent digital device use as control variables. The revised results are presented in Table 3. Language background was not assessed because all participating families were Hebrew-speaking Israeli families, and device availability was not included because all participating families had access to digital devices, resulting in no variability on this measure. Research Question c) was updated to include the additional demographic variables (p. 5).
- The qualitative component is described as cross-validating the quantitative findings, but the two components assess partly different constructs and use different respondent subsets. The authors should explain precisely how integration occurred, ideally through a joint display connecting quantitative variables, qualitative themes, convergence, divergence, and added explanatory value.
We thank the reviewer for this valuable suggestion. We added a new subsection (Section 3.3 Integration of Quantitative and Qualitative Findings) and a joint display to explicitly present the integration of the quantitative and qualitative findings, including areas of convergence, complementarity, expansion, and their added explanatory value (pp. 15–16).
- The manuscript should report the number and role of coders, whether coding was independent, how disagreements were resolved, whether a codebook was developed, and how reflexivity and interpretive credibility were addressed.
We thank the reviewer for this valuable comment. We substantially revised the Analysis of Qualitative Data section (p. 9) to provide a clearer and more transparent description of the qualitative analytic process. The revised section clarifies the researchers' roles in the coding process, the development of the coding framework, the resolution of coding decisions through discussion, and the use of reflexive discussions to enhance the interpretive credibility of the findings.
- The two gender-matched images are not perceptually equivalent. They differ in keyboard appearance, surrounding objects, body posture, visual complexity, and potentially the apparent realism or attractiveness of the activity. These differences may influence children’s interpretations and preferences. This is a critical limitation of the study that should be acknowledged.
We acknowledged this limitation in the Limitations and Future Directions section by noting that the visual stimuli used in the child interviews were not fully equivalent and may have influenced children's initial responses to the visual prompt. We also clarified that this potential influence primarily relates to the first interview question, whereas the subsequent questions focused on children's own writing preferences and experiences rather than on the images themselves (p. 20).
- Also, the study's narrative itself should be toned down, including the inclusion of an exploratory aim in the title.
We thank the reviewer for this comment. We revised the Discussion to adopt a more cautious and exploratory interpretation of the findings throughout (pp. 16-19). Specifically, we softened the wording where appropriate (e.g., replacing "the findings indicate" with "the findings suggest") and revised the titles of the qualitative Discussion subsections to emphasize their exploratory nature (e.g., "Exploring Parents' Perspectives" and "Exploring Children's Perspectives").
- The findings support an association between reported joint activity and reported interest, but they do not demonstrate literacy learning, developmental benefit, or improved digital competence. The manuscript should distinguish interest from learning outcomes. A more appropriate interpretation is that active, meaningful, socially interactive digital experiences may create conditions conducive to learning, rather than proving that shared digital activities improve literacy development (Hirsh-Pasek et al., 2015).
Thank you for raising this important point. Accordingly, we revised the Discussion throughout to distinguish more clearly between children's reported interest and learning outcomes. Specifically, we softened the interpretation of the findings by avoiding causal and developmental claims and emphasizing that shared parent–child digital literacy activities may create conditions that are more conducive to children's engagement in literacy activities than screen exposure alone (Hirsh-Pasek et al., 2015) e.g., p. 19.
- Interaction with technology involves partially distinguishable semantic, visuospatial, sensorimotor, executive, and socially mediated processes. The authors should provide a more precise account of what distinguishes digital literacy from traditional literacy at the neurocognitive level. An integrated technological-cognition framework may be useful here, particularly because it emphasizes that technology use emerges from interactions among domain-general processors, technology-related knowledge, action systems, and social learning (Federico et al., 2025a). Also, recent evidence that digital and mechanical technologies can recruit partly distinct neurocognitive pathways further cautions against treating “digital” simply as a change in delivery medium (Federico et al., 2025b).
Thank you for this comment. We revised the Introduction to clarify the conceptual distinction between digital and traditional literacy, emphasizing that digital literacy involves more than a change in the delivery medium. We also incorporated the suggested theoretical perspective and references (Federico et al., 2025a, 2025b) to acknowledge that interacting with digital technologies may involve partly distinct cognitive and socially mediated processes (pp. 2-3).
Minor concerns
- The manuscript requires careful language editing and correction of inconsistent publication years, duplicated headings, numbering errors, and several ambiguous descriptions. The hypotheses should be mapped explicitly onto the reported analyses.
- The authors should distinguish exploratory from confirmatory analyses and consider sharing the materials, anonymised data, coding framework, and analysis scripts.
References
- Federico, G., Osiurak, F., Brandimonte, M. A., Marangolo, P., & Ilardi, C. R. (2025a). An integrated account for technological cognition. Cognitive Neuroscience. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/17588928.2025.2542195
- Federico, G., Lesourd, M., Fournel, A., Bluet, A., Bryche, C., Metaireau, M., Baldi, D., Brandimonte, M. A., Soricelli, A., Rossetti, Y., & Osiurak, F. (2025b). Two distinct neural pathways for mechanical versus digital technology. NeuroImage, 305, Article 120971. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2024.120971
- Hirsh-Pasek, K., Zosh, J. M., Golinkoff, R. M., Gray, J. H., Robb, M. B., & Kaufman, J. (2015). Putting education in “educational” apps: Lessons from the science of learning. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 16(1), 3–34. https://doi.org/10.1177/1529100615569721
We carefully revised the manuscript for language, consistency, and formatting, corrected publication years, duplicated headings, numbering, and ambiguous wording, and clarified the correspondence between the study hypotheses and the reported analyses throughout the manuscript.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Author(s), thank you for carefully reading the feedback and for the careful revisions you made. I believe your work has improved as a result.
Author Response
Thank you again for your time and valuable feedback, which helped us improve the manuscript.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsI am happy with the revisions made that fully address all my concerns
Author Response
Thank you again for your time and valuable feedback, which helped us improve the manuscript.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe revised version is very good. Thank for your hard
work and efforts.
Author Response
Thank you again for your time and valuable feedback, which helped us improve the manuscript.
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors addressed all my points, and the manuscript can be accepted in my view.
Just a minor point, the correct reference for Federico et al., (Cognitive Neuroscience) is:
Federico, G., Osiurak, F., Brandimonte, M. A., Marangolo, P., & Ilardi, C. R. (2026). An integrated account for technological cognition. Cognitive neuroscience, 17(3), 115–127. https://doi.org/10.1080/17588928.2025.2542195Author Response
We have corrected the reference to Federico et al. (2026) in the manuscript (p. 3) and updated the reference list (p. 22), as suggested by Reviewer 4. We are grateful to the reviewer for the careful reading of our manuscript and for bringing this reference correction to our attention. Thank you again for your time and valuable feedback, which helped us improve the manuscript.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf