Review Reports
- Yan Wang 1,
- Wei Xu 2,* and
- Emine Sarigöllü 3
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Ioana Mihaela Balan Reviewer 3: Maidul Islam Reviewer 4: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe topic is timely, theoretically interesting, and practically important. The research design is well done, the hypotheses are clearly articulated, and the findings are robust across methods. Overall, this is a strong manuscript that makes a meaningful contribution to food waste and marketing literature and is suitable for publication after minor revisions.
- Introduction & Research Gap
- The article addresses a topical issue concerning food waste and its connection with marketing practices.
- The connection of price promotion with the logic of the social dilemma is theoretically apt and original.
Suggestions for improvement
- Although it is stated that “there is a lack of marketing-based research”, the logical chain of the gap could be more explicit, about what we already know about food waste, what we know about price promotions and what exactly we do not know about the mechanism that connects them.
- A brief reference in the introduction with a title is suggested, bridging marketing – sustainability – psychology, and a reference after the research gap explicitly stating that the contribution is mechanistic (mechanism-based)
- Literature Review & Theoretical Framework
- The literature on price promotions is extensive and balanced (positive and negative effects).
- The concept of perceived resources is well documented and convincingly incorporated as a mediator.
- Τhe hypotheses (H1–H4) are clear, testable and logically consistent.
Suggestions for improvement
- The article does not explicitly “name” a broader theoretical model. The theoretical frameworks S-O-R and mental accounting are used indirectly. Therefore, a brief theoretical anchoring would enhance the theoretical visibility of the article.
- Across studies, the manuscript alternates between intentions (Studies 1, 3, 4) and actual behavior (Study 2). Add a short paragraph in the literature review paper clarifying when food waste is measured as intention, when it is measured behaviorally and why intentions are theoretically appropriate proxies in the these contexts.
Recommended Additional References (Optional)
To further strengthen theoretical grounding, the authors may consider selectively integrating the following well-established works:
- Core Theory (Mental Accounting, Abundance, S-O-R)
- Thaler, R. (1985). Mental accounting and consumer choice. Marketing Science, 4(3), 199–214.
- Shah, A. K., Mullainathan, S., & Shafir, E. (2012). Some consequences of having too little. Science, 338(6107), 682–685.
- Cannon, C., Goldsmith, K., & Roux, C. (2019). A self-regulatory model of resource scarcity. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 29(1), 104–127.
- Mehrabian, A., & Russell, J. A. (1974). An approach to environmental psychology. MIT Press.
- Food Waste Theory and Psychological Drivers
- Porpino, G. (2016). Household food waste behavior: Avenues for future research. Journal of the Association for Consumer Research, 1(1), 41–51.
- Hebrok, M., & Boks, C. (2017). Household food waste: Drivers and potential intervention points. Journal of Cleaner Production, 151, 380–392.
- Stancu, V., Haugaard, P., & Lähteenmäki, L. (2016). Determinants of consumer food waste behaviour. Appetite, 96, 7–17.
- Poulis, A., Theodoridis, P., & Chatzopoulou, E. (2024). Sustainable Brand Resilience: Mitigating Panic Buying through Brand Value and Food Waste Attitudes Amid Social Media Misinformation. Sustainability (2071-1050), 16(15).
- Principato, L., et al. (2021). The household wasteful behaviour framework. Industrial Marketing Management, 93, 641–649.
- Marketing Actions and Post-Purchase Consequences – SOR Theory
- Lee, L., & Tsai, C. I. (2014). How price promotions influence postpurchase consumption experience. Journal of Consumer Research, 40(5), 943–959.
- Chatzopoulou, E., Tsogas, M. M., & Kyriakou, M. (2022). Retail atmospherics in times of disruption: a PLS modeling approach of the role of emotions in a pharmacy environment. International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, 50(2), 158-182.
- Shaddy, F., & Lee, L. (2020). Price promotions cause impatience. Journal of Marketing Research, 57(1), 118–133.
- Sultan, P., Wong, H. Y., & Azam, M. S. (2021). How perceived communication source and food value stimulate purchase intention of organic food: An examination of the stimulus-organism-response (SOR) model. Journal of Cleaner Production, 312, 127807.
(These references are suggestions only and do not require substantial revision of the manuscript.)
- Methodology
- Very strong multimethodological design: 4 studies.
- Study 2 (canteen) substantially strengthens external validity.
- The manipulations are clean and realistic.
Suggestions for improvement
- Reliability indices (Cronbach’s α) for the scales, nor the items
- confirmatory validity checks should be added
- Food waste intention is based on hypothetical scenarios with a negative product taste, which may act as a confound.
- Analysis & Results
- The analyses are consistent with the hypotheses.
- The use of PROCESS for mediation is good.
- The results are clear, repeatable and theoretically consistent.
Suggestions for improvement
- There is no control for a possible dose effect (20% vs 50% is not always different).
- Conclusions & Contribution
Theoretical contribution
- Strong and clear shift from purchase behavior -> post-purchase consequences and the mechanistic explanation of waste as a result of perceived abundance.
Practical implications
- Very specific and applicable spending reminders, budget cues and the timing of interventions during promotional periods.
Suggestions for improvement
- They are adequately recognized, but the cultural specificity and the restriction to low-value foods could be added.
- Needs more connection to the literature
Author Response
Please see the attachment
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript addresses a relevant topic in the field of behavioral sciences, analyzing the relationship between eating behaviors, consumer perceptions, and their implications for sustainability and food systems. The topic is current and belongs to an expanding interdisciplinary field, located at the intersection of behavioral psychology, food consumption studies, and food systems sustainability.
The paper is well structured and uses a relatively extensive literature to contextualize the research problem. It attempts to integrate the behavioral perspective on food decisions with the social and cultural dimensions of consumption.
However, the manuscript requires some conceptual and methodological clarifications, as well as a strengthening of the interpretation of the results, in order to more clearly highlight its contribution to the specialized literature, for a higher scientific impact in the future.
Below are my comments and recommendations, poin by point, which I hope will help you improve the manuscript.
1. Introduction
The introduction presents the general context of the research and highlights the importance of analyzing eating behaviors in the context of food systems sustainability. It emphasizes the role of psychological and social factors in shaping food preferences and adopting more sustainable consumption patterns. The section is well documented and draws on numerous sources from recent literature, but it could be improved by:
Comment 1 - clearer formulation of the research problem;
Comment 2 - more precise delimitation of the study objectives
Comment 3 - explicit formulation of research questions or hypotheses.
In its current form, these elements appear implicitly, but are not clearly highlighted enough.
2. Literature review
The literature section provides an overview of the main studies on food behavior, psychological factors influencing food choices and their implications for the sustainability of food systems. A coherent synthesis of the existing literature is presented and several relevant theoretical perspectives are highlighted. However, this section could benefit from:
Comment 4 - a clearer structuring into subthemes;
Comment 5. more explicit highlighting of the gap in the specialized literature that the study tries to cover;
Comment 6-a better connection between the presented literature and the objectives of the study.
Currently, the section sometimes has a descriptive rather than analytical character.
3. Materials and methods
The methodological section describes the research design, the instruments used and the data collection procedure.The description of the method is generally clear, but some additional clarifications would be useful, as:
Comment7 - details regarding the participant selection procedure;
Comment 8- justification of the sample size;
Comment 9- more detailed explanations regarding the validation of the instrument used
Comment 10 - clearer presentation of the statistical methods used for data analysis.It would also be useful to specify whether the instrument used has been previously tested or whether an analysis of validity and internal consistency has been performed.
4. Results
The results section presents the results of the data analysis in a structured and easy-to-follow manner. Tables and figures facilitate the understanding of the main findings of the study. The results are presented in a clear manner, but it would be useful to:
Comment 11- a more detailed explanation of the significance of some statistical results;
Comment 12- a clearer connection between the results and the hypotheses formulated in the introductory section.
In its current form, some results are presented in a relatively descriptive manner, without sufficient discussion of their implications.
5. Discussion
The discussion section attempts to interpret the results in relation to the literature. It highlights how the results obtained confirm or complement the results of other studies.
However, it could be strengthened by:
Comment 13- a more in-depth analysis of the theoretical implications of the results;
Comment 15 - a clearer highlighting of the original contribution of the study;
Comment 16 - discuss the limitations of the research in more detail. In particular, it would be useful if the authors discussed more explicitly the limitations associated with the data collection method and the representativeness of the sample.
6. Conclusions
The conclusions summarize the main results of the study and highlight their relevance for understanding food behaviors and the transition to more sustainable food systems.
However, this section could be improved by:
Comment 17 - avoiding repetition of ideas already presented in the discussion section;
Comment 18 - more clearly formulating the practical and policy implications of the results;
Comment 19 - suggesting directions for future research.
Author Response
Please see the attachment
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsReviewer comments
- As there are quite some papers within the same section (of food waste from a marketing perspective, yet they cite Ilyuk (2018), Van Doorn (2016), and Mookerjee et al. (2021)), hence claiming that there has been very little exploration is bit overstatement of the research gap.
- I would suggest authors to be more precise and honest characterization of the existing marketing-food waste intersection is needed, distinguishing what specifically has and has not been studied.
- “Consumer food waste behavior” is not formally defined in the introduction, paper directly moved into the problem without clarifying whether it refers to unintentional spoilage, deliberate disposal, or plate waste.
- Gender Imbalance Not Addressed- All three online studies report approximately 66% female participants, yet gender is never used as a covariate in any analysis, and the paper does not discuss whether gender moderates the price promotion–food waste relationship.
- Authors should address gender issues in their limitation section thoroughly.
- If I am not wrong, no manipulation checks reported for studies 3 and 4 while it included in study 1.
- I also suggest authors should draw a conceptual business model to improve the readability of the paper with all the hypotheses marked on it.
- Missing Reference
- The paper cites "Qian et al., 2022" (line 64) in relation to cultural norms, but this reference does not appear in the reference list. This might be Qian et al 2021.
- There are several other issues with reference ie. Hebrok, is listed in the reference but missing from the body of the main text. I would suggest authors to review throughout the paper and see the errors in reference.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThank you for the opportunity to review the manuscript “Do promotions make consumers more wasteful? The effect of price promotion on consumer food waste behavior “. This manuscript investigates an important and underexplored question: whether price promotions increase consumer food waste behaviour and by what psychological mechanism. The topic is timely and the framing as a social dilemma is appropriate. The multi-study approach combining experimental and field evidence is a genuine strength. However, some revisions are recommended before publication.
Major comments
The manuscript does not report any manipulation checks for the experimental conditions in Studies 3 and 4. Study 1 includes a perceived resources measure that functions as an indirect check, but Studies 3 and 4 lack verification that participants in the different focus conditions (money-saving vs. money-spending; within-budget vs. over-budget) actually experienced the intended psychological states. Including brief manipulation checks is standard practice and would strengthen the causal inferences.
All online samples are drawn from Chinese participants, predominantly young and female. The authors should address this limitation more directly and discuss how cultural context may moderate the effects. Moreover, the consistency of gender imbalance across samples (all ≈66% female) raises questions about sampling procedures. Was this incidental, or does the platform skew female? This should be clarified, as gender may be a relevant covariate given documented gender differences in food waste.
Minor comments
- Abstract: The abstract could more clearly state the methodology (four experiments, one field study) for readers scanning for empirical design.
- Introduction (line 70–74): The claim that “price promotion essentially induces consumers to overpurchase” is presented as a fact without citation. Please add supporting references.
- Study 1 (lines 259–261): It would strengthen the manuscript if the authors briefly addressed the non-significant difference between the 20%-off and 50%-off conditions (p=0.16). For instance, the authors might consider whether the data point toward a threshold effect where any discount above a certain level produces similar waste intentions or whether the study was not powered to detect a difference between these two conditions.
- Study 2 measurement: To help readers fully evaluate the rigour of the field experiment, it would be useful if the authors briefly described the steps taken to ensure objectivity in recording food waste. For example, clarifying whether the research assistant who distributed the coupons was aware of which customers had received a discount coupon. This would allow readers to assess the potential for unintentional observer influence.
- Scenario design: All studies use a bitter/unpalatable food scenario to elicit waste. This choice limits generalizability to situations where waste arises from quality disappointment. Wasted food due to over-purchasing (which is arguably more directly linked to promotions) is not captured. The authors should acknowledge this as a scope limitation.
- Practical implications (Section 4.2): The suggestion that businesses remind consumers of their spending during promotions may conflict with commercial incentives. A more nuanced discussion of who would implement such nudges (government, retailers etc.) would improve the actionability of the recommendations.
- References: “Hebrok & Boks (2017)” appears in the reference list but is not cited in the text. Please check for consistency.
Overall, this manuscript presents important results. I recommend that the authors consider the above points to improve their manuscript.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors have significantly improved the paper and addressed the majority of the comments that were pointed out during the first round of review. Hence, the paper can be accepted in its current form.
Thank you.