Abstract
Despite the government’s significant interest in sustainable development of the population and maintaining public health, its health policies do not always achieve the desired results, either in containing the spread of infectious diseases during outbreaks (e.g., COVID-19) or in preventing noncommunicable diseases. This discrepancy can be explained by the fact that population health behavior is shaped not so much by targeted policy measures as by ingrained cultural traditions of specific social communities. The Sociocultural Health Code (SHC) framework methodology developed at the National Medical Research Center for Therapy and Preventive Medicine (Moscow, Russia) is designed to identify vulnerabilities in citizens’ health attitudes, their capacity for self-organization in maintaining health, their level of health literacy, and the degree of trust in information sources, interpersonal networks, and the public organizations, the activities of which influence health outcomes. This study offers a theoretical analysis of the value of the findings obtained using the SHC methodology for policymaking at both the central and regional levels of government. The study also provides a comparative assessment of the analytical potential offered by alternative methodological frameworks that consider the sociocultural dimension of health. The study assesses the potential of employing the SHC methodology to obtain and interpret data essential for developing technologies contributing to understanding the semantic context in which individuals make health-related decisions, as well as for addressing, where necessary, issues associated with personal attitudes of people toward their health. The SHC framework is designed to capture behavioral vulnerabilities and the population’s level of trust in government health initiatives; like several mixed-methods frameworks, it combines qualitative and quantitative techniques. At its current stage of development, however, the findings should be read as an assessment of analytical potential rather than as evidence of predictive accuracy or policy effectiveness. Given these limitations, the approach may help identify population groups based on an appropriate set of parameters and the implementation of targeted legal and informational measures in response to specific challenges and policy goals.
1. Introduction
Caring for the health of its citizens is a historically established responsibility and obligation of any socially oriented state. The degree of a state’s commitment to the health of its population is reflected in the development of public healthcare systems, which are based on advances in medical science and designed to provide medical care. At the same time, there is currently growing discussion in both the medical community and political circles about the importance of disease prevention, not just treatment. However, in Russia and other countries, social policy in the healthcare sector remains largely focused on improving the quality of medical services rather than on fostering a culture of sanitation and hygiene or promoting a healthy lifestyle among citizens [1], although significant efforts have already been made in this direction.
Against the backdrop of advances in modern medicine and healthcare systems, two opposing trends can be identified. On the one hand, there is a significant expansion of scientific knowledge about infectious and noncommunicable diseases, their treatment, and preventive measures, accompanied by a clear commitment to a healthy lifestyle promoted by healthcare institutions, government agencies, and civil society organizations. On the other hand, public attitudes toward personal health remain characterized by widespread disregard, persisting until the risk of losing that health becomes tangible. Given insufficient basic knowledge about disease management and prevention, unequal access to quality healthcare, and widespread mistrust of healthcare professionals, such a careless attitude can lead to actual deterioration in health or even premature death. Moreover, the growing dissemination of conflicting information about diseases, their prevention, and treatment further complicates the situation, as has been clearly demonstrated during the COVID-19 pandemic. The resulting situation is one in which comprehensive public health measures aimed at disease prevention encounter significant resistance from people, whose attitudes are largely determined by their sociocultural background [2].
The goal of this study is to assess, conceptually and comparatively, the analytical potential of the original methodology called Sociocultural Health Code (SHC) for identifying shortcomings in public health practices that legal and informational measures might subsequently address. This approach takes into account the different perceptions of the intrinsic value of health and the dissimilar behavioral strategies used by various social groups to maintain it. The study does not test the predictive accuracy of the framework or the effectiveness of any policy intervention.
2. Materials and Methods
This article is a conceptual comparative analysis. The theoretical and methodological framework chosen for this comparative analysis allows for an adequate consideration of the sociocultural determinants of health. This article does not report any original or unpublished human-participant data. It relies exclusively on previously published research and on publicly available documents. Accordingly, no ethical approval was required for the present analysis. The empirical study mentioned in Section 3.2 was conducted separately under its own ethics approval and is cited here as published/in-press work, not as data generated for this manuscript.
The empirical basis of the study is based on scientific publications, including research articles, critical reviews, and monographs indexed in the RSCI, Scopus, Web of Science, PubMed, and Google Scholar databases.
The review of academic literature was carried out between April and September 2026. Key search queries included: (1) “health and culture” and “health policy”; (2) “health promotion,” “health intervention,” “health behavior,” “cultural competence,” “health determinants,” “health communication,” and “public health”; and (3) these same concepts combined with the terms “policy” and “culture.”
Selection criteria for the publications to be used in this review were as follows:
- Inclusion criteria: 1. The study presents or empirically applies a model that defines the role of culture in explaining health behavior; 2. the article describes the process of developing a health-related policy intervention (including diagnosis, target groups, type of intervention, and evaluation).
- Exclusion criteria: 1. Publications that mention culture but do not operationalize it (i.e., lack specific analysis of cultural factors); 2. articles based on purely clinical studies that do not address the behavioral or population level.
- Publication types: Solely peer-reviewed articles and monographs.
- Chronological scope: No restrictions.
Rationale for selection: To facilitate comparison with the SHC methodology, we selected models that represent different strategies for incorporating culture into the explanation of attitudes toward health and behavioral orientations, ranging from reducing culture entirely to individual beliefs to interpreting it as a system of meanings. Thus, model selection meets the following criteria: 1. they represent a spectrum of strategies based on how culture is interpreted and how its influence on attitudes toward health is defined; 2. they are functionally comparable, as each model allows for the description of potential interventions and their specific characteristics; and 3. they are supported by a range of practical applications.
Our study did not aim to examine the full spectrum of applications for the models under review. Rather, it assessed their potential for developing various interventions by the state aimed at influencing the health-preservation practices of the population. For each model, the foundational publications were identified, along with studies reflecting the practical application of these models. Consequently, we did not conduct a systematic review of all publications for each approach.
To compare SHC with other methodological approaches, we employed an integrated set of methods, consistent with the interdisciplinary nature of the study. A theoretical systems analysis was used to explain the main constructs (culture, sociocultural context, health, and health behavior), how they are conceptualized within each approach, and to determine the boundaries of their applicability. The comparative analysis was conducted along the following criteria: the focal unit (individual behavior, interaction, community, or the system); the form of culture operationalization (as a variable, as a context, as a basis for interpretation, or as a resource); indicators and instruments used to measure cultural factors; practical applicability (assessed in terms of the availability of step-by-step protocols and ready-to-use tools for both researchers and practitioners); and ethical and epistemological foundations, with particular attention to attitudes to authorities, knowledge, and community participation.
We employed a directed content analysis (following the typology of H.-F. Hsieh and S. Shannon) with the coding scheme built on comparative categories established prior to the analysis. This aligns directly with the research goal since the focus is on comparing different approaches. Accordingly, rather than inductively generating theory, this approach focuses on testing and contrasting predefined constructs.
The unit of analysis was a meaningful segment (a paragraph or a coherent block of text) containing a complete statement regarding key aspects: e.g., how culture is understood in relation to health, who should act as the agent of intervention, what type of intervention is recommended, and what the role of the state should be. Each segment was considered sufficiently self-contained in terms of context, providing enough meaning for accurate interpretation. Furthermore, a single segment could be assigned to multiple categories, as the procedure allowed for such multiple coding.
A limitation of this approach is that the comparability of the models is constrained by differences in their nature, ranging from theories supported by extensive quantitative empirical data to those focused on strategies for assessing sociocultural impacts.
The SHC concept was formalized recently (2023–2024; see Section 3.2), making this study one of the first to provide its comparative validation.
3. Results
3.1. Challenges Created by the Sociocultural Environment in the Implementation of Social Policy Aimed at Maintaining Public Health
The sociocultural context plays a key role in the implementation of social policy aimed at maintaining public health. It functions not only as a passive backdrop, but as an active interpretive filter through which all decisions concerning health policy are processed. Sociocultural determinants shape fundamental attitudes and value systems, behavior patterns, ingrained traditions, prevailing priorities, and the perceived hierarchy of social problems. They also determine the degree of public trust in political and civil institutions, government programs, and medical interventions. Collectively, these factors define the specific characteristics and inherent challenges of communication between citizens and the institutional framework of governance and civil society.
For instance, disease prevention as a component of public health policy often encounters communication barriers and limitations arising from ethnocultural characteristics inherent in the healthcare sector, which manifest themselves in contemporary social groups, e.g., in a reluctance to assimilate information that authorities and medical institutions seek to convey regarding modern scientific understanding of methods of preventing and self-treating various diseases [3]. An important problem is the spread of communication conflicts in the information space, generated by a combination of attributes characteristic of the modern media environment. The expansion of the media landscape, accompanied by information overload and an excess of unreliable content, exacerbates problems associated with disease prevention, self-medication, the use of traditional remedies, etc. Self-proclaimed experts often mislead the public by offering information that contradicts the established medical consensus on a particular issue, ultimately harming public health.
The result is an internal informational conflict in the minds of citizens, generating deep-rooted ideological contradictions and leading to mutually exclusive practices and traditions related to health, both at the individual level and within broader social communities. One of the most noticeable manifestations of this conflict is a growing atmosphere of mistrust and an extremely negative public reaction to state healthcare policy [4].
The COVID-19 pandemic, during which the state sought to demonstrate concern for the health of its citizens and actively intervened in healthcare, has become an indicator of these phenomena. The debates that erupted in both the media and everyday life about the effectiveness of the measures introduced, as well as about the allegedly correct methods of prevention and treatment, largely reflected prevailing ideas about healthcare and the level of health literacy of the population. Contradictory actions by regional authorities, the spread of myths in the media, and the lack of a clear understanding of the situation in the medical community have effectively divided Russian society between those who accepted and supported the measures introduced by the government and those who opposed them, arguing that such policies not only violate civil rights but also, through the measures per se, cause further harm to public health. For example, no fewer than fifteen versions of the interim guidelines on the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of novel coronavirus infection [5] have been issued. As a result, there was a wide range of behavioral strategies adopted by people in response to the implemented policies, strategies and assessments shaped by the various interactions of individual responsibility for their own health, the level of essential knowledge in the field of healthcare, and the degree of trust in medical institutions. Significantly, against the backdrop of existing citizen mistrust of medical institutions, there was an increased general mistrust of the social policies of regional and federal government bodies [6,7].
The COVID-19 pandemic has revealed striking disparities in the responses of people within the same social and professional groups when faced with similar challenges, while the issue of maintaining health has become increasingly politicized. The roots of these internal contradictions in the health information and communication system lie in heterogeneous interpretations of what constitutes the value of health, varying degrees of personal responsibility assumed for it, and uneven levels of essential knowledge about disease prevention and treatment.
The state has sufficient resources to address the public health situation and existing shortcomings through the use of economic and legal instruments [8,9,10], as well as a range of mechanisms for controlling the information space. Public policy can simultaneously establish the necessary boundaries of acceptable and encouraged behavior and provide the essential information support for decision-making, along with information and educational efforts aimed at the population. At the same time, the effectiveness of measures implemented within the framework of social policy in the field of healthcare largely depends on the extent to which the sociocultural characteristics of various social groups are taken into account during their development and, consequently, on the receptivity of these groups to the methods of transmitting health-related information [11,12]. The validity of decisions made is largely determined by the ongoing monitoring of prevailing public attitude toward health and healthcare.
Accordingly, alongside developing the healthcare system and strengthening public trust, a critical task of contemporary social policy is analyzing the semantic context behind health-related decisions. This allows for the subsequent adjustment of citizens’ attitudes toward health, which constitute the sociocultural code of the healthcare sector. Among the essential measures, the axiological and regulatory dimensions are of primary importance: cultivating health as a genuine, rather than solely declarative, value among the population, combined with increased personal responsibility for one’s own well-being, while simultaneously ensuring high-quality health education and the effective dissemination of the compulsory information regarding its maintenance.
Consequently, state intervention in the healthcare sector is essential. However, its extent and modalities must be carefully balanced. There are areas in which state participation is indispensable, but it should not transform into excessive paternalism that displaces individual responsibility. To this end, it is crucial to conduct targeted empirical research aimed at examining the information and communication infrastructure of the healthcare system, as well as the relevant sociocultural attitudes of the entire population or specific social groups.
3.2. Sociocultural Health Code
To investigate this problem, the National Medical Research Center for Therapy and Preventive Medicine (Moscow, Russia) developed a framework methodology, Sociocultural Health Code (SHC) [12,13,14]. This methodology interprets health as an information and communication model in which each person bears a specific SHC—i.e., a set of information about the surrounding world that determines their behavioral attitude toward health. SHC changes throughout life depending on a person’s communications and the surrounding information space.
In this context, the code should be understood not as a set of traditions, but rather as a stable system of meanings and rules that people rely on to navigate the world. That is to say, it is information stored in memory, transmitted, and transformed through communication. In the context of health, the code manifests itself in value orientations (e.g., health can be viewed as a matter of personal responsibility, as the concern of the family or clan, as the prerogative of medical institutions, or even as the responsibility of the state), in interpretations of health (why people become sick—whether it is punishment, the evil eye, environmental factors, heredity, or stress—and what should be done about it), in practices and daily routines (eating habits, attitudes toward preventive care, doctor visits, and medication intake), in institutional expectations (trust in the healthcare system, willingness to follow medical recommendations, and acceptance of preventive medical examinations), and in linguistic and symbolic forms (the words and metaphors used to describe health and illness, and which images are considered appropriate in communication). These elements are transmitted through the family, the educational system, the media, religion, and professional communities, ultimately becoming unspoken rules that profoundly shape behavior, even when people do not explicitly reflect on them.
In practice, it is convenient to split the analysis of the SHC into three levels:
- Macro level (society and social institutions). Here, the focus is on the dominant values and norms embedded in culture and politics, such as medical paternalism, the prevailing emphasis on cure over prevention, or, conversely, the growing trend toward personal responsibility and biohacking. This level also includes the historical and religious context, which defines the boundaries of acceptable behavior in health matters.
- Meso level (communities, professions, and local groups). Attention shifts to regional and subcultural differences: urban vs. rural attitudes, ethnic peculiarities, and professional health cultures, such as those prevalent among teachers, workers, or doctors. It is at this level that differences in trust in the healthcare system and in health-seeking behavioral practices become particularly pronounced.
- Micro level (family, everyday life, personal experience) An emphasis on everyday life and habits: how the family reacts to a cold, how they view vaccinations, or how they perceive fatigue (as a norm or a symptom). At this level, the code manifests itself as a set of habitual actions and explanations that are rarely questioned.
A comprehensive analysis of the SHC requires a mixed methods approach, integrating both qualitative and quantitative research methods as follows:
- Survey questionnaires administered to various population groups. These provide quantitative data reflecting the attitudes of individual sociodemographic, professional, or ethnocultural groups toward health-related issues [14].
- In-depth interviews. These facilitate the collection of expert opinions from specialists in public administration, healthcare, and related sectors.
- Focus groups and community workshops. These enable joint interpretation of data and testing of hypotheses regarding the health code, while reducing the risk of reinforcing preconceived stereotypes.
- Ethnographic observation in combination with in-depth interviews. This provides an inside look at healthcare practices, allowing researchers to observe behavior in real-world settings and understand how people rationalize their choices.
- Discourse analysis of texts and media. This helps identify dominant meanings in public messages, media outlets, official documents, and social media.
- Practice mapping. This technique documents typical behavioral scripts, such as ‘what people do when they fall ill’, ‘whom they turn to first’, or ‘what sources of information they deem trustworthy’.
- Semantic and narrative analysis. These approaches bring to light recurrent metaphors and stock storylines (e.g., ‘illness signifies weakness’, ‘the physician holds all the answers’, or ‘medications are inherently harmful’).
A SHC analysis based on the mixed methods approach yields SHC maps that include typologies of attitudes, semantic profiles, behavioral scripts, and inventories of barriers and resources specific to a particular social group.
The application of the SHC approach in social and healthcare policy opens up a number of avenues. Within the context of strategic planning, analyzing the components of the SHC helps formulate long-term goals that resonate with societal values. e.g., if paternalistic attitudes are strong in a region, the strategy based on the premise that ‘everyone is responsible for their own health’ may be perceived as an accusation, while a more effective model would be ‘the state helps, the family supports, the doctor accompanies’.
When designing programs and campaigns aimed at engaging citizens in various health-promoting practices, knowledge of the SHC components allows for tailoring messages and delivery channels. The deliberate usage of culturally relevant linguistic devices and imagery allows for the use of clear metaphors, while avoiding terms that may evoke resistance (such as ‘control’, ‘surveillance’, or ‘commitment’) and selecting vocabulary that conveys caring and support rather than being prescriptive. When selecting influencers, it is crucial to rely on trusted figures in the community. When defining involvement scripts, it is advisable to offer formats that align with familiar practices: for example, instead of ‘come to a lecture’, offer ‘meeting at a club/kitchen/church’, or instead of ‘register online’, ‘register with a coordinator in your area’.
Analysis of data obtained through the use of the SHC framework can serve as a powerful tool for mitigating health inequalities and barriers to access to both health literacy and healthcare services per se. Studying the components of the code helps us understand not only cultural barriers but also how they intersect with social barriers, including poverty, migration, gender roles, and stigma. For example, in some communities, seeking mental health care may be taboo not because of ignorance, but because of fear of stigmatizing labels and their consequences for the family. Understanding this allows for the design of more nuanced, sensitive and safer formats for communication between authorities and civil society and for the provision of health care per se.
The SHC also could be used to track changes over time in citizens’ attitudes, behavioral practices, and trust in the system, as well as in public and political institutions related to healthcare system thus complement formal indicators such as the number of visits.
Hence, using the SHC opens the possibility of obtaining various data necessary for scientific research. It also serves as a useful tool for designing communications between authorities and citizens by helping formulate messages and formats that do not appear alien or imposed, but rather understandable and respectful.
While the social and cultural determinants of health behavior are well studied in isolation, a unified approach that fully accounts for both the role of culture and social factors in health-promoting behavior remains to be developed. Neither a purely cultural nor a purely sociological perspective is sufficient for a comprehensive analysis, since the sociocultural code is a synthesis, rather than a mere summation, of these approaches. This code integrates symbolic resources and their meanings, which a community uses as a common language to interpret the world and its own behavior. This enables social groups to accumulate, preserve, and transmit information about health care. In this case, there is no opposition between culture and social structure. By conceptualizing culture as a semiotic information system, we establish a foundation for the social determinants of health. A key feature of the sociocultural code is its synthetic nature: it simultaneously captures both cultural meanings and social practices. The result is not merely a sum of components, but a unified analytical matrix.
Existing approaches often treat concepts such as a healthy lifestyle, culture of health, and health literacy as independent phenomena, while the sociocultural code positions health within a broader hierarchical system, viewing it as a subsystem of the sociocultural code of a person or a social group. Such approach fundamentally shifts the theoretical understanding of attitudes toward health: health is no longer interpreted as a matter of individual choice or the simple acquisition of medical knowledge; rather, it is considered a product of a community’s holistic worldview, shaped by its historical trajectory, established practices, and dominant ways of perceiving the world.
A key feature of the sociocultural code is its multilevel structure. A unified analytical model integrates various levels of the sociocultural code: the national level (encompassing national culture and the healthcare system), the ethnic level, and corporate and socioprofessional levels. Altogether, these levels create a unique individual health code, along with a corresponding family-level code. This addresses the issues of average metrics, as existing models fail to explain why attitudes toward medical treatment may diverge across generations within a single family, or why a distinct professional code, governing attitudes toward the body, injury, and prevention, emerges within a corporate environment.
The SHC framework allows for the identification of the underlying causes of actions and the prediction of behavior in various circumstances through the analysis and interpretation of specific informational markers. Several stable semantic clusters can be identified within the structure of the SHC: concepts of a healthy individual, dietary norms, proper clothing and housing, perceptions of medical treatment and disease prevention, along with sacral, moral and ethical beliefs. Defining the code as a coordinate system or a health matrix is an analytical, rather than merely metaphorical, approach. By examining a set of markers, it is possible to reconstruct the behavioral logic of a given community and predict its responses to external stimuli, such as the introduction of new sanitary regulations, the implementation of medical technologies, or the launch of alcohol awareness and vaccination campaigns.
The sociocultural code does not exist in isolation: it evolves under the influence of factors such as the functioning of the healthcare system, living standards of the population, globalization processes, prevailing aesthetic standards, the values of a consumer society, etc. Consequently, the code can shift significantly, diluting the ethnic component as broader national meanings and norms take precedence. This carries a significant managerial implication: since the code is subject to change, it can also be intentionally adjusted. This represents a fundamental difference from static concepts such as mentality or national character, which treat attitudes toward health as constants.
This approach is not just academic or neutral: its stated objective is to propose cultural and political technology, along with mechanisms for adjusting attitudes and behaviors that increase health risks, thereby complementing, rather than displacing, medical sociology and anthropology. The SHC methodology facilitates effective interaction between the authorities and citizens, assisting in organizing how information is presented by government representatives, and in tailoring the emphasis to align with the diverse worldviews of a multicultural population. In a sense, this framework serves as a bridge, connecting medicine, sociology, and political science.
The evolution of this research trajectory was consistently unveiling various facets of the concept: a foundational 2023 publication articulated the initial framework [12]; a 2024 study proposed a typology and described the dynamics of the sociocultural code [13]; and the 2025 research design provided the development of measurement tools, enabling empirical verification [14]. Some publications, focusing on political discourse, have applied this approach within the field of political science. The ongoing development of the concept is now aimed at converting general principles into a concrete research program that is both measurable and testable. Here, the classification of worldview types serves as more than an analytical tool: it provides a framework for targeted policy interventions to alter health behaviors and practices.
The SHC concept is currently more of a methodological approach than a fully established theory with a standardized toolkit. The approach focuses on various social groups to identify enduring combinations of worldview orientations that influence attitudes toward health. The framework has been used in exploratory pilot studies conducted separately from the present review. For instance, a study conducted among young people aged 15 to 35 involved university and college students across various regions of Russia [14]. The results of this study are currently in press. The primary instrument used in that study was a sociological survey based on a specially designed questionnaire. However, this is intended to be supplemented by other sociological instruments combined with qualitative methods (such as interviews and focus groups) to gain an in-depth understanding of the context. The aforementioned study utilized an online survey consisting of 24 questions, the majority of which were closed-ended. This approach demonstrates how health behavior is affected by factors such as one’s social circle, the information environment, the level of trust in political and medical institutions, etc. Using these data, the approach applies factor and cluster analysis to classify stable combinations of worldview attitudes (defined here as ‘codes’) and assess their prevalence across various social groups.
At present, the ‘sociocultural health code’ construct has not been systematically or universally validated.
As for its predictive capacity, the concept postulates that analyzing informational markers (such as knowledge, stereotypes, and values) may not only describe current attitudes toward health but also help anticipate behavior in specific situations. However, the framework has not yet been validated as a predictive instrument, and the strength of any such predictions would depend directly on the quality and representativeness of the collected data and on other determinants (economic, medical, institutional).
The authors of this approach view the findings as a basis for developing targeted programs aimed at modifying risky behaviors, improving treatment adherence, and forming strategies for responsible self-care. The core idea of SHC is to tailor interventions to the specific cultural context of a given group, rather than using universal solutions.
A key advantage of this approach is its interdisciplinary nature and capacity to integrate cultural and social factors into the study of health, which is often overlooked in purely biomedical or sociological models. Its mixed-methods design, combining qualitative (underlying meanings and myths) and quantitative (the prevalence of specific types of attitudes) data, is not unique to SHC. What is specific to SHC is the attempt to treat the sociocultural code as a multilevel analytical construct and to derive group typologies from it, although the empirical basis for this claim is still being built.
To strengthen the empirical foundation of this approach, further research is needed to develop standardized methodology, rigorously validate instruments, and conduct cross-cultural comparisons.
4. Discussion
An analysis of the research and analytical potential of the SHC in social policy development would be incomplete without assessing the capabilities of other health approaches that take into account the social or cultural context (Table S1). This section examines only the potential and capabilities of other approaches—comparing them with the SHC—for developing relevant social policy directions or governance mechanisms, even if they have never been used for such purposes.
The PEN-3 cultural model developed by Collins O. Airhihenbuwa [15] is the closest one to the SHC. This model is a culturally oriented heuristic framework for the development and analysis of public health programs. The structural components of this model are cultural identity (this domain identifies who we are, focusing on the person, extended family, and neighborhood community), relationships and expectations (this domain specifies what is considered normal: perceptions, enablers, and nurturers), and cultural empowerment (the domain postulates how to act, classifying practices as positive, existential/neutral or negative with respect to health outcomes). PEN-3 emphasizes family and community as the main contexts for making health decisions. This approach is used as an analytical tool, e.g., to identify cultural factors, and as a design matrix for adapting messages, channels, and interaction formats to a specific community. PEN-3 was employed in various studies, such as HIV/AIDS, cancer screening, diabetes, nutrition, vaccination, violence prevention, and in different populations (migrants, ethnic minorities, rural communities) [16,17,18,19,20].
This model can be quite useful in the development of public policy to adapt programs to specific communities (ethnic, professional, etc.) [21,22]. For example, when developing programs for indigenous or migrant populations, the PEN-3 model helps identify key cultural factors (the role of family, local traditions, and health beliefs) and build community engagement by building on its strengths, not just barriers. Based on analyses conducted using the PEN-3 model, researchers typically offer practical recommendations for planning interventions and services aimed at preventing specific health problems. A comparison of the SHC and PEN-3 methodological approaches shows that PEN-3 analysis facilitates planning which cultural elements to use as resources, which barriers to identify, and how to overcome them when shaping health behaviors in the target audience. The study of the SHC is more focused on obtaining data from large samples to forecast and develop a common communication strategy for authorities and various social groups on health issues, although, like PEN-3, it can also be used to address more localized matters, such as determining the feasibility of a specific intervention to change behavior regarding specific health aspects for a narrow target audience.
Among approaches with a strong cultural focus, ecological models of health behavior (EMHB) deserve special attention. In 2008, Jay F. Sallis, along with colleagues N. Owen and E.B. Fisher, proposed an ecological model of health behavior [23]. This model echoes the ecological concept of Urie Bronfenbrenner, who in 1979 developed a multi-tiered system describing how children develop and interact with their environment.
J.F. Sallis et al. noted that behavior is formed at the intrapersonal (individual), interpersonal (family, friends), institutional/organizational, community, and public policy levels, the characteristics of which form the corresponding factors. The model emphasizes that each person is embedded in social systems, and individual health behavior is influenced by a multi-level environment that is cumulative and synergistic. Among the research topics based on this approach, there are publications on attitudes toward vaccination [24], suicidal ideation [25], and the use of electronic cigarettes among adolescents [26].
The principal advantage of this approach is its systematicity. It helps us go beyond the individual psychological profile and see the whole picture, which is critical for developing effective prevention programs and promoting the value of health. The ecological approach emphasizes that changes in policy and the physical environment can have a large-scale impact on entire population. This model can be used to design policies that change not only consciousness but also the environment itself, creating the conditions for the desired health behaviors of the population. Compared with the ecological approach, the SHC is more focused on adapting policies to the cultural context and their acceptance by the target audience. For example, even an ideal environment may fail if communication between the government and society is disrupted due to cultural filters.
Proposed by Albert Bandura to explain how people learn and shape behavior, social cognitive theory (SCT) has a strong cultural focus [27]. It grew out of social learning theory and emphasizes that behavior is shaped through the interaction of personal factors, behavior, and the environment. Its key element is the interplay between behavior, cognitive attitudes, and the environment, which illustrates the principle of reciprocal determinism [28]. SCT was employed in studies focused on various issues: evaluating quality-of-life improvements through interventions in cancer patients [29], increasing physical activity among adults with multiple sclerosis [30], and cooking and food skills training programs [31].
Since the theory emphasizes the interplay between the individual and the environment, at the government level this may mean not only education but also changes to the environment itself. SCT provides tools for designing specific interventions (e.g., making healthy food more accessible, limiting advertising of unhealthy foods, and implementing tax incentives. SCT can also assist in designing programs where people learn new skills (e.g., self-control) and see positive behavioral models [32]. Comparing SCT with SHC, it can be noted that the latter is more helpful in correctly defining the sociocultural context and making policies culturally sensitive, while SCT allows for the development of specific, psychologically grounded mechanisms that can help people move from awareness to action.
The theory of planned behavior (TPB) explains behavior through three principal constructs: attitudes toward action, subjective norms, and perceived behavioral control. The TPB can be used to quantitatively measure cultural barriers and elements of cultural dynamics. It is widely used in studying specific aspects of health behavior [33,34,35,36].
The model suggests that behavior is shaped by environmental norms rather than by personal beliefs alone. If this method is applied to the development of social policy in the field of health, it can emphasize the creation of an environment where healthy behavior becomes the norm, for instance, through infrastructure development or the implementation of workplace wellness programs. Unlike the SHC, the TPB is more focused on the individual level, identifying which components (attitudes, norms, or perceived behavioral control) most strongly inhibit desired behavior and designing interventions specifically targeting them. Contrariwise, the SHC operates at the group and community level, revealing a broader macro context in which individual activity is manifested.
The SHC can also be compared to approaches focused on values, meanings, and interpretation. The approach developed by the American anthropologist and psychiatrist Arthur Kleinman in the late 1970s and early 1980s, explanatory models, is a tool for understanding how people conceptualize illness, its etiology, course, and treatment. In research and practice, this approach helps identify differences in illness perceptions not only between different cultures but also within a single culture (e.g., due to differences in education or experience) [37,38]. The explanatory models approach emphasizes how individuals and communities explain illness causes, severity, expected outcomes, and preferred treatments. This model helps make sense of personal experiences: understanding why a problem arose, what it means, how to cope with it, and what outcomes to expect from treatment [39]. This approach is most often used in qualitative research and clinical communication [40,41].
The potential of this approach for social policy lies in its ability to understand how members of different social groups explain the causes of illness. This is critical for developing health policy in multicultural societies, as it is essential to avoid universal messages and seek common ground. Both explanatory models and SHC emphasize which beliefs need to be adjusted or negotiated for effective interventions. However, the difference lies in the fact that SHC can be used at the community level, identifying the macro context and setting the framework for health policy, while explanatory models can be used at the individual or small group level, analyzing specific cognitive and semantic constructs and identifying tools for fine-tuning policy implementation.
SHC shares similarities with the cultural competence/cultural humility frameworks, which represent not a single theory but a family of models (ranging from training to systemic change) aimed at making health services and assistance more culturally sensitive. Both approaches aim to reduce inequalities and improve communication, but they do so in different ways: cultural competence focuses on the acquisition of knowledge and skills, while cultural humility focuses on lifelong self-reflection and self-critique. Researchers note that patients’ cultural backgrounds can influence their values, beliefs, and practices regarding health [42].
The concept of cultural competence in healthcare emerged to address the issue of ethnic differences and ensure the appropriate quality of care for all patients [43]. The practical application of cultural competence is based on the development of training and checklists for staff, the standardization of communication protocols, and the assessment of competencies through questionnaires and case-based simulations [44]. The concept of cultural humility was proposed as a response to the limitations of cultural competence. Unlike competence, humility is a lifelong attitude, not a set of skills [45]. Practical tools include open-ended questions instead of assumptions, and shared decision-making, e.g., discussing treatment options taking into account cultural preferences, rather than imposing ‘the only right’ course of action. This approach reduces the risk of stereotyping, enhances trust and engagement with clients or patients, and better accounts for individual differences within cultures.
In contemporary practices, cultural competence and cultural humility are not opposed to each other, but rather complement each other. For instance, the former provides structure and essential knowledge, while the latter ensures flexibility and respect for individual differences. At the policy level, this contributes to specific institutional changes, such as requiring medical institutions to provide translation services, training medical workers in cultural competence, and implementing standards that reduce administrative and language barriers [46]. The principle of cultural humility is particularly important, as it can encourage politicians and officials to continually reflect on their biases and learn from communities, rather than imposing ready-made solutions. Comparing the SHC with these approaches, it can be noted that the SHC focuses on identifying the sociocultural context, cultural competence on defining tools, and cultural humility on critical reflection.
The SHC can be compared with community engagement and participatory design approaches in health domain, but in this case, the focus should be on their combination.
The intervention mapping (IM) approach is a step-by-step protocol for creating health programs that includes behavioral and environmental analysis, formulating goals and change matrices, selecting methods, and developing materials [47]. IM draws on theory and empirical data and clearly links program goals to specific methods and practical tools, thereby transforming an abstract goal into a concrete set of actions that can be implemented and measured.
During the analysis stage, this approach can be integrated with other cultural models (SHC, PEN-3) to structure who influences, what norms apply, and what practices are important. IM provides a step-by-step algorithm: from needs assessment and theory to planning specific interventions and evaluating results. At the public policy level, this facilitates the systemic design of large programs (e.g., chronic disease prevention), breaking down the task into stages and ensuring the logical coherence of all constituent elements.
The SHC can be used in conjunction with community-based participatory research (CBPR), an approach that focuses on engaging communities per se in the development of social policy components [48,49]. Governments can create platforms for dialogue where residents directly participate in problem framing, program design, and evaluation of their effectiveness. This approach increases trust and the chances of success, as solutions are developed at the grassroots level and based on real-world experience.
An approach similar in structure and logic to the classification of practices is the health belief model (HBM), a psychological framework used to explain and predict potentially detrimental behaviors and the adoption of preventive actions through perceived vulnerability, severity, benefits, barriers, and push incentives [50,51]. The potential for applying the HBM at the policy level means that risk perception should be addressed when developing campaigns (e.g., vaccination or screening) [52]. The government can analyze the fears and myths held by different groups and tailor messages to reduce barriers, for example, by explaining how the procedure saves lives rather than frightens. Unlike the SHC, the HBM is focused on the individual level, specifically addressing beliefs and barriers.
Consequently, SHC is designed to capture stable worldview configurations. These manifest as cultural codes characterized by distinct combinations of values, norms, and practices within a specific group. Such worldview configurations are not merely attitudes or norms, but rather stable semantic profiles that can persist even when environmental conditions change. While the TPB, HBM, and SCT measure individual determinants (such as attitudes, norms, or self-efficacy) and are effective at predicting intentions, they do not provide a typology of stable worldview configurations. The PEN-3 model captures cultural factors and their influence without modeling these semantic profiles as a distinct construct. Whether these configurations are as stable as the SHC framework postulates remains an open empirical question.
SHC proposes to explain behavior through an interpretive lens that shapes how individuals perceive health and illness. According to the framework, differences in how various groups respond to identical barriers or incentives are explained not only by predominant social norms or levels of self-efficacy, but primarily by how each group constructs the meaning of health; these unique conceptualizations ultimately dictate health decisions. Ecological models acknowledge context, yet they treat culture as a mere background setting rather than an active, central explanatory construct. SCT and TPB explain behavior through cognitive and social mechanisms, but not through stable, meaningful codes.
SHC views culture neither as a set of factors (as in the PEN-3 model) nor as an individual competency, but rather as a system of meanings and the ways in which these meanings are interconnected. This enables the categorization of communities based on their distinct profiles and the selection of interventions that not only address specific barriers but also align with how these communities themselves interpret a given situation.
Both SHC and Kleinman’s model focus on how people conceptualize health and illness within their own cultural context. SHC looks for stable, recurring patterns at the group level, whereas Kleinman’s model focuses on an individual’s culturally conditioned worldview.
The potential practical value of SHC lies in targeting interventions based on semantic profiles: messages and programs are tailored not merely to existing norms or barriers, but in terms of how a group conceptualizes health. This approach mitigates the risk of paternalism and enhances relevance. While CBPR method provides ethical partnership, it does not explain behavior. While cultural competence improves interaction, it does not provide an explanatory model. SHC does not replace models that predict intentions (TPB; HBM), nor does it replace ethical practices (CBPR; cultural competence model). Rather, it complements them.
This comparison demonstrates how SHC can be integrated with other approaches for developing a more objective picture of how a population perceives health. For instance, SHC helps to detect and describe the stable sociocultural patterns that shape attitudes toward health within a target group. To translate this insight into practice, the logic of the IM method can be employed—specifically, using the identified sociocultural code to formulate specific behavioral change objectives, selecting appropriate theoretical methods (such as TPB or SCT to address self-efficacy), and adapting communication channels to local norms.
A number of studies demonstrated how direct feedback from individuals (gathered via surveys, interviews, and focus groups) contributes to uncovering cultural nuances and avoiding pitfalls when developing healthcare policy.
A study by Taye et al. [53] presented the results of a survey involving 500 people from five different regions. The survey examined the effectiveness of public health infographics and concluded that individuals from different cultures respond differently to visual symbols, colors, and imagery. What works in one group may trigger rejection or misunderstanding in another. The study clearly demonstrated that, without accounting for cultural specifics, a message will fail to resonate and policies based on universal templates risk being ineffective (or even offensive) to certain segments of the population.
Research by de Peralta et al. [54] on mobile clinics for underserved minority population groups utilized the focus group approach to explore how patients themselves perceive the cultural competence and cultural humility of the staff. Participants emphasized the importance of personnel demonstrating self-awareness, acknowledging their prejudice, and making a genuine effort to understand the patient’s cultural context.
This finding highlights how community feedback can pinpoint specific barriers (such as a lack of empathy or unfamiliarity with local traditions) that might easily be overlooked at the level of abstract policy. Therefore, staff training can be tailored, and services can be made more culturally acceptable.
A large-scale survey conducted in Switzerland [55] regarding personalized research and biobanks revealed not only general attitudes but also some specific concerns: participants expressed worries about data confidentiality, the risk of discrimination, and the potential for their biological material to be used for commercial purposes. The authors noted that culture and context influence how people understand complex concepts (such as data sharing) and which barriers they perceive as critical. This is an argument for conducting localized research before launching large-scale initiatives, since what seems acceptable in one cultural environment may trigger resistance in another.
A study on the interviewer effects in public health surveys [56] highlighted a subtle yet significant nuance related to ethnocultural background. The alignment of race, ethnicity, or gender between an interviewer and a respondent can influence responses, particularly when addressing sensitive topics (such as sexual health or substance use). In certain cultural contexts (for instance, within conservative Islamic communities), the presence of an interviewer of a specific gender may entirely preclude the participation of women. This demonstrates that even data collection methodologies must be culturally sensitive, or else the statistics may become biased, thereby leading to policies based on flawed premises.
It is also worth noting that direct methods (interviews and focus groups) can reveal discrepancies between official discourse and local interpretations of the concepts being used. For example, the notion of responsibility for health is interpreted differently across various groups: as individual autonomy, as a matter of family care, or as a duty toward the community. If a policy does not account for this variability, it risks being perceived as alien or unfair, which undermines both its effectiveness and legitimacy. Also, surveys and interviews contribute to distinguishing cultural causes underlying certain behaviors from their structural causes. Patient refusal of preventive services and low treatment adherence are frequently driven by structural access barriers, suboptimal care quality, and negative clinical history, rather than individual attitudes. Ignoring such evidence risks falling into “cultural reductionism”—a perspective that attributes behavior to “cultural traits” rather than to actual, tangible obstacles. Ignoring these data risks cultural reductionism, whereby behavior may be explained by cultural idiosyncrasies rather than actual obstacles.
Hence, healthcare policy should not be based on a priori notions about the typical attitudes of specific groups. Instead, it should rely on systematic feedback collected using direct methods. Only in this way can bias be avoided, the diverse interpretations of key concepts accounted for, and the long-term sustainability and social acceptability of state-led interventions ensured. Direct interaction with the community serves as a practical tool for mitigating risks, enhancing decision-making, and, ultimately, improving health outcomes.
A critical analysis of the SHC approach reveals various complex issues, both structural and ethical. These structural factors and limitations include socioeconomic barriers, institutional reliability, and ethical implications.
Socioeconomic barriers. A key methodological challenge in working with the SHC framework is to distinguish between two types of factors: culturally conditioned attitudes (embedded in the code) and objective structural constraints (such as income, education, and availability of services). The effects of these factors often overlap. e.g., behavioral patterns (as part of the code per se) may either mask or amplify the impact of systemic barriers, making it difficult to correctly attribute the causes of observed practices.
Institutional reliability. Trust in medical and social institutions is part of the sociocultural code. However, if the institutions themselves function inconsistently due to issues like corruption, staff shortages, or bureaucratic hurdles, any attempt to tailor communication to fit a specific code may prove ineffective.
Ethical implications. Defining codes for particular groups (whether ethnic or corporate) carries the risk of reinforcing stereotypes. Even when the intentions are benign—such as aiming to make preventive healthcare more relevant—such categorization can oversimplify the complexity of individual life paths and lead to generalizations that fail to account for the internal diversity within a group. Even with good intentions, such as making disease prevention more relevant, categorization can simplify the complexity of individual life trajectories and lead to generalizations that do not take into account the internal heterogeneity of the group.
Collecting data on worldviews, values, and underlying beliefs touches upon the personal sphere. The methodology of the SHC approach is designed for use with large samples, and the surveys conducted are inherently structured to ensure anonymity of responses. Furthermore, this approach can be adapted for small sample sizes and individual-level questionnaires, provided that clear ethical protocols are in place, including informed consent, anonymization, and restricted access to the data.
Limitations of the review and the evidence base. The SHC is a methodological approach that, at its current stage, allows for variability regarding which specific variables are included in the analysis and which statistical or qualitative methods are employed. While we have developed a questionnaire for use with large samples, a unified toolkit is currently under development.
Authors’ involvement in development. The authors of this publication are the developers of the SHC methodological framework and are actively involved in creating the tools (such as questionnaires and analytical schemes) for studying the SHC.
Independent corroborating evidence. There is currently an insufficient number of systematic, independent replications by other teams to verify our findings. At the same time, no refutations or critical comments have been published to date.
Applicability beyond the Russian context. The methodology for collecting and interpreting empirical data is universal and can be applied to other countries and regions. However, extrapolating findings derived from the Russian context to other cultural, political, or institutional environments requires caution. Factors that hold significance in one sociocultural space may carry a different meaning (or even be entirely irrelevant) in another.
The goal of the SHC concept is not to replace structural analysis, but rather to provide an analytical framework for understanding how individuals perceive health and illness, how they interpret risks and trust, and how these meanings interact with objective barriers. It is precisely at the intersection of meanings and structures that major challenges often arise: for example, even when services are accessible, certain groups may still not use them due to entrenched customs, fears, or alternative explanations for illness. The SHC framework helps identify these meaning-based barriers, which are invisible in purely structural models.
It is important to point out that the SHC does not replace the analysis of structural determinants of health (income, education, access to services, or working conditions) but rather complements it. Effective policy interventions must simultaneously eliminate objective barriers while taking local meanings and norms into account. An SHC analysis can help tailor communication and service design to local meanings, but any policy measures must dismantle structural barriers (such as access, cost, and quality). Shifting public attitudes is possible only with a simultaneous improvement in objective conditions.
SHC is positioned as a fine-tuning tool that helps adapt communication, design services, and organize community engagement. The framework explicitly states that its application is appropriate only when combined with measures to eliminate objective barriers to healthcare services and improve their quality. This approach leverages the potential of SHC to design more precise and ethical interventions without substituting them for systemic changes.
We emphasize that interpreting a lack of trust in healthcare institutions as a cultural defect or a manifestation of insufficient health literacy is not only scientifically incorrect but also ethically risky. In many cases, a lack of distrust is a rational and well-founded response to actual structural and historical experiences with the healthcare system. For instance, typical adverse experiences (long lines, inattentive staff, the unavailability of specialists, or recurring service failures) can foster persistent negative attitudes. These are easily, yet erroneously, interpreted as a cultural norm, when in fact they are generated by systemic problems. That said, it is possible that if such situations persist over a long period, they may become institutionalized and effectively function as a cultural norm.
We also point out that SHC does not conflict with clinical approaches; rather, it complements them by providing a framework for contextual analysis. While clinical research identifies what happens to a patient, SHC explains why the same interventions yield different results across various communities. SHC can serve as a tool to explain the variability in the effects of interventions within different sociocultural contexts, and integrating it with clinical data remains a task for future research. In the future, we intend to conduct specific applied studies in which the SHC will be integrated with clinical data for assessing the impact of sociocultural profiles on treatment adherence and long-term outcomes.
It is necessary to highlight certain risks that require careful consideration when using the SHC. First, cultural reductionism presents the danger of explaining behavior primarily via a code while ignoring objective barriers. Second, paternalism leads to the risk of designing interventions based on the assumption that attitudes need to be corrected, rather than focusing on removing external obstacles. Finally, stigmatization creates the potential for reinforcing negative stereotypes about specific groups if their behavioral patterns are interpreted solely as features of their code.
5. Conclusions
Existing approaches are not ready-made recipes but rather analytical tools. Their importance lies in the fact that they help authorities avoid acting blindly, instead understanding people’s real motives, taking the context into account, and developing more targeted policies. Proper use of these tools helps make public health policy more effective, equitable, and sustainable because it is based on an understanding of people’s actual motives and barriers, rather than being predicated solely on clinical or economic indicators.
For social policy in public health to be effective, it must be aligned with the actual sociocultural context of target groups. This requires conducting relevant research to examine local perceptions, traditions, barriers, and resources; engaging community representatives in program development; and using approaches that resonate with local sociocultural codes and information and communication systems. Ignoring these nuances can lead to even well-designed initiatives failing to produce the expected results.
The application of the SHC framework and related methodologies are intended to provide a broad picture of how various social groups approach health, identifying consistent views, attitudes, and behavioral patterns. Based on this analysis, the authorities may be able to anticipate, subject to further empirical validation, how different groups will respond to certain measures and thereby develop long-term strategies that resonate with, rather than contradict, societal value orientations.
The SHC does not constitute a standalone solution; rather, it is designed for integration with complementary instruments and targeted deployment based on the specific policy challenge.
SHC should be presented as a promising analytical framework whose empirical and predictive value is a matter for future research.
Supplementary Materials
The following supporting information can be downloaded at https://www.mdpi.com/article/10.3390/soc16110414/s1. Table S1: Analytical summary of methodological frameworks investigating cultural and sociocultural health determinants.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, V.V.S. and A.R.K.; methodology, V.V.S. and A.R.K.; formal analysis, V.V.S.; investigation, V.V.S. and A.R.K.; resources, V.V.S.; data curation, V.V.S. and A.R.K.; manuscript preparation, V.V.S.; review and editing, A.R.K.; scientific supervision, A.R.K.; project administration, A.R.K. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
This research received no external funding.
Institutional Review Board Statement
Not applicable. This article is a conceptual comparative analysis based exclusively on previously published research and publicly available documents; it does not involve human participants or original unpublished data.
Informed Consent Statement
Not applicable.
Data Availability Statement
No new data were created or analyzed in this study. Data sharing is not applicable to this article.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
References
- Zhuravleva, I.V. The actual problems of social policy in health sphere. Sociol. Meditsini 2017, 16, 4–9. (In Russian) [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Suvorov, V.V. Physical health of citizens as a resource of state policy. Izv. Saratov Univ. Sociol. Politol. 2025, 25, 202–209. (In Russian) [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Suvorov, V.V.; Kiselev, A.R. The impact of sociocultural context on the rehabilitation of cognitive impairments. Sociology 2024, 4, 125–135. (In Russian) [Google Scholar]
- Suvorov, V.V. Political discourse of health and ideological attitudes of Russian citizens. Izv. Saratov Univ. Sociol. Politol. 2023, 23, 196–201. (In Russian) [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Guidelines, I. Prevention, Diagnosis, and Treatment of Novel Coronavirus Infection (COVID-19). Version 15. Available online: https://static-0.minzdrav.gov.ru/system/attachments/attaches/000/059/392/original/%D0%92%D0%9C%D0%A0_COVID-19_V15.pdf2022; (accessed on 22 May 2026).
- Zhade, Z.A.; Samygin, P.S. Trust in government as the basis for interaction between society and the state in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Mod. Sci. Innov. 2021, 4, 183–187. (In Russian) [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ilyinova, N.; Kireeva, I.; Kukva, E. Trust in government in the face of epidemiological threats: Indicators and strengthening measures (Using the COVID-19 pandemic case). Bull. Perm. Univ. Political Sci. 2024, 18, 80–91. (In Russian) [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ashuralieva, J.R. State regulation in the field of health protection. J. Appl. Res. 2022, 7, 543–546. (In Russian) [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Jo, P. The state policy of Russia in the field of healthy lifestyle formation. Eurasian Sci. J. 2024, 16, 24FAVN524. [Google Scholar]
- Sachs, R.E.; Hoffman, A.K. The Changing Role of the Government in American Health Law. J. Health Polit. Policy Law 2025, 50, 1017–1035. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Suvorov, V.V. Issue of developing spiritual and physical health of Russian citizens in political discourse. Bull. Volga Reg. Inst. Manag. 2023, 23, 30–35. (In Russian) [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Drapkina, O.M.; Suvorov, V.V.; Umetov, M.A.; Suslov, I.V.; Kiselev, A.R. Sociocultural health code as a methodological approach to social studies in the field of healthcare. Her. Russ. Acad. Sci. 2023, 93, 119–126. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Drapkina, O.M.; Suvorov, V.V.; Kiselev, A.R. Sociocultural code of the health sphere: Typology, variability, possibility of influence. Healthc. Russ. Fed. 2024, 68, 308–314. (In Russian) [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Suvorov, V.V.; Kiselev, A.R.; Drapkina, O.M. Design of the “Social Worldviews and Attitudes Regarding Health: Sociocultural Health Code” study. Russ. Open Med. J. 2025, 14, 311. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Airhihenbuwa, C.; Iwelunmor, J.; Munodawafa, D.; Ford, C.; Oni, T.; Agyemang, C.; Mota, C.; Ikuomola, O.; Simbayi, L.; Fallah, M.; et al. Culture Matters in Communicating the Global Response to COVID-19. Prev. Chronic Dis. 2020, 17, E60. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Iwelunmor, J.; Newsome, V.; Airhihenbuwa, C.O. Framing the impact of culture on health: A systematic review of the PEN-3 cultural model and its application in public health research and interventions. Ethn. Health 2014, 19, 20–46. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Blackstone, S.R.; Nwaozuru, U.; Iwelunmor, J. Antenatal HIV Testing in Sub-Saharan Africa During the Implementation of the Millennium Development Goals: A Systematic Review Using the PEN-3 Cultural Model. Int. Q. Community Health Educ. 2018, 38, 115–128. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Shahbazi, H.; Ghofranipour, F.; Amiri, P.; Rajab, A. Factors Affecting Self-Care Performance in Adolescents with Type I Diabetes According to the PEN-3 Cultural Model. Int. J. Endocrinol. Metab. 2018, 16, e62582. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Dadipoor, S.; Alavi, A.; Kader, Z.; Mohseni, S.; Eshaghi Sani Kakhaki, H.; Shahabi, N. Predictive power of PEN-3 cultural model in cervical cancer screening among women: A cross-sectional study in South of Iran. BMC Cancer 2023, 23, 730. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Shahabi, N.; Pourjalil, F.; Shafiei Sarvestani, F.; Mouseli, A.; Hosseini, Z.; Aghamolaei, T.; Nikparvar, M.; Dadipoor, S.; Ghanbarnejad, A. Effect of a PEN-3 model-based educational intervention on cigarette smoking in Iranian patients with myocardial infarction. Sci. Rep. 2025, 16, 2542. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Marie, L. PEN-3 Model Cultural Framework for Health Intervention and Prevention. Online J. Neurol. Brain Disord. 2018, 1, 000123. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Yick, A.G.; Oomen-Early, J. Using the PEN-3 model to plan culturally competent domestic violence intervention and prevention services in Chinese American and immigrant communities. Health Educ. 2009, 109, 125–139. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Sallis, J.F.; Owen, N.; Fisher, E.B. Ecological Models of Health Behavior. In Health Behavior and Health Education: Theory, Research, and Practice, 4th ed.; Glanz, K., Rimer, B.K., Viswanath, K., Eds.; Jossey-Bass: San Francisco, CA, USA, 2008; pp. 465–486. [Google Scholar]
- Braverman, A. Ecological model of health behavior as a methodology for reducing anti-vaccination trends. Wien. Klin. Wochenschr. 2021, 133, 721–723. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Xu, H.; Chen, Z.H.; Ji, J.J.; Qian, H.Y.; She, J.; Hou, C.T.; Zhang, Y.H. Behavioral and psychosocial factors associated with suicidal ideation in adolescents with depression: An ecological model of health behavior. J. Psychiatr. Res. 2025, 181, 411–416. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Deng, H.; Fang, L.; Zhang, L.; Li, J.; Wang, J.; Wang, F.; Zheng, P. Susceptibility to e-cigarette among high school students: A study based on the ecological model of health behavior. Front. Public Health 2024, 12, 1395717. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Bandura, A. Social cognitive theory: An agentic perspective. Annu. Rev. Psychol. 2001, 52, 1–26. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Islam, K.F.; Awal, A.; Mazumder, H.; Munni, U.R.; Majumder, K.; Afroz, K.; Tabassum, M.N.; Hossain, M.M. Social cognitive theory-based health promotion in primary care practice: A scoping review. Heliyon 2023, 9, e14889. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Graves, K.D. Social cognitive theory and cancer patients’ quality of life: A meta-analysis of psychosocial intervention components. Health Psychol. 2003, 22, 210–219. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Jeng, B.; Cederberg, K.L.; Huynh, T.L.; Silic, P.; Jones, C.D.; Feasel, C.D.; Sikes, E.M.; Baird, J.F.; Silveira, S.L.; Sasaki, J.E.; et al. Social Cognitive Theory variables as correlates of physical activity in fatigued persons with multiple sclerosis. Mult. Scler. Relat. Disord. 2022, 57, 103312. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Gordillo, P.; Prescott, M.P. Assessing the Use of Social Cognitive Theory Components in Cooking and Food Skills Interventions. Nutrients 2023, 15, 1287. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Zheng, D.; Lekdamrongkul, P.; Gao, X.; Sriyuktasuth, A. Exploring Theoretical Models and Frameworks Used to Explain Factors Influencing Breast Cancer Screening Participation: A Scoping Review. Int. J. Womens Health 2025, 17, 5639–5656. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Rajeh, M.T. Modeling the theory of planned behavior to predict adults’ intentions to improve oral health behaviors. BMC Public Health 2022, 22, 1391. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Hammer, J.H.; Vogel, D.L.; Grzanka, P.R.; Kim, N.; Keum, B.T.; Adams, C.; Wilson, S.A. The integrated behavioral model of mental health help seeking (IBM-HS): A health services utilization theory of planned behavior for accessing care. J. Couns. Psychol. 2024, 71, 315–327. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Douglas, M.E.; Blumenthal, H.; Guarnaccia, C.A. Theory of planned behavior and college student 24-hour dietary recalls. J. Am. Coll. Health 2024, 72, 47–54. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Fetene, B.M.; Wondiye, H.; Yigzaw, Z.A. Predictors of Intention to use Health Literacy Strategies in Patient Education among Health Care Professionals at Public Hospitals of Bahir Dar City: Application of Theory of Planned Behavior. Am. J. Health Promot. 2026, 40, 267–277. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Kleinman, A. Patients and Healers in the Context of Culture: An Exploration of the Borderland Between Anthropology, Medicine, and Psychiatry; University of California Press: Oakland, CA, USA, 1980. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Kleinman, A.; Benson, P. Anthropology in the Clinic: The Problem of Cultural Competency and How to Fix It. PLoS Med. 2006, 3, e294. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Harrison, L.C.; Rivas, S.; Fuentes, L.; Cáceres-Serrano, A.; Ferrara, G.; Antillon-Klussmann, F.; Rodriguez-Galindo, C.; Mack, J.W.; Graetz, D.E. Explanatory models in real-world clinical interactions at a pediatric cancer center in Guatemala. PLoS Glob. Public Health 2024, 4, e0003813. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Kendler, K.S. Explanatory models for psychiatric illness. Am. J. Psychiatry 2008, 165, 695–702. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Mikhel, D.V. Reading into the classic of medical anthropology: An analysis of the ideas of Arthur Kleinman. Med. Anthropol. Bioeth. 2015, 2, 6. (In Russian) [Google Scholar]
- Betancourt, J.R.; Green, A.R.; Carrillo, J.E.; Ananeh-Firempong, O., 2nd. Defining cultural competence: A practical framework for addressing racial/ethnic disparities in health and health care. Public Health Rep. 2003, 118, 293–302. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Royeen, M.; Crabtree, J. Culture in Rehabilitation: From Competency to Proficiency; Pearson Education: London, UK, 2006; 386p. [Google Scholar]
- Dickson, T.; Wilkinson, T.; Hegedus, E.J.; Gisselman, A.S. Transforming the Patient Experience: Moving Beyond Cultural Competence to Cultural Safety. Phys. Ther. 2022, 102, zac034. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Singh, H.; Sangrar, R.; Wijekoon, S.; Nekolaichuk, E.; Kokorelias, K.M.; A Nelson, M.L.; Mirzazada, S.; Nguyen, T.; Assaf, H.; Colquhoun, H. Applying ‘cultural humility’ to occupational therapy practice: A scoping review protocol. BMJ Open 2022, 12, e063655. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Kaplan, L. Promoting cultural competence through a health policy course. Nurse Educ. 2010, 35, 87–89. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Bakhuys Roozeboom, M.C.; Wiezer, N.M.; Boot, C.R.L.; Bongers, P.M.; Schelvis, R.M.C. Use of Intervention Mapping for Occupational Risk Prevention and Health Promotion: A Systematic Review of Literature. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2021, 18, 1775. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Reifsnider, E. About Research: Community-Based Participatory Research (CBPR). J. Hum. Lact. 2024, 40, 352–355. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Israel, B.A.; Schulz, A.J.; Becker, A.B.; Reyes, C.L.; Parker, E.A.; Reyes, A.G. Community-Based Participatory Research: Evolution and Significant Developments. Annu Rev. Public Health 2026, 47, 135–157. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Parwati, N.M.; Bakta, I.M.; Januraga, P.P.; Wirawan, I.M.A. A Health Belief Model-Based Motivational Interviewing for Medication Adherence and Treatment Success in Pulmonary Tuberculosis Patients. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2021, 18, 13238. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- De Leon, A.N.; Peterson, R.; Dvorak, R.D.; Leary, A.V.; Kramer, M.P.; Burr, E.K.; Toth, E.M.; Pinto, D. The Health Belief Model in the Context of Alcohol Protective Behavioral Strategies. Psychiatry 2023, 86, 1–16. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Hijazi, M.H.A.; Jeffree, M.S.; Woon, F.C.; Jelip, J.; Avoi, R.; Ahmed, K. Educational frameworks for zoonotic malaria prevention: A narrative review integrating behavioural theory, participatory design, and instructional models for Plasmodium knowlesi in Southeast Asia. Malar. J. 2026, 25, 192. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Taye, R.; Paswan, A.; Deori, K. Effectiveness of Cultural Sensitivity on Public Health Infographics in Diverse Population. SSRN 2024, 5015994. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- de Peralta, A.M.; Gillispie, M.; Mobley, C.; Gibson, L.M. It’’s All About Trust and Respect: Cultural Competence and Cultural Humility in Mobile Health Clinic Services for Underserved Minority Populations. J. Health Care Poor Underserved 2019, 30, 1103–1118. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Brall, C.; Berlin, C.; Zwahlen, M.; Ormond, K.E.; Egger, M.; Vayena, E. Public willingness to participate in personalized health research and biobanking: A large-scale Swiss survey. PLoS ONE 2021, 16, e0249141. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Davis, R.E.; Couper, M.P.; Janz, N.K.; Caldwell, C.H.; Resnicow, K. Interviewer effects in public health surveys. Health Educ. Res. 2010, 25, 14–26. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.