Review Reports
- Pamela Yanina Giles 1,*,
- Gabriel Menegazzi 2 and
- Pablo Chilibroste 2
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Renato Fontaneli Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsFollow some suggestions:
a) Eliminate the scientific name (Lolium multiflorum), since the old name (Festuca arundinacea) is mentioned in the second paragraph of the introduction;
b) Eliminate the oven drying time until constant weight (sometimes 48 hours and other times 72 hours). Generally, they remain in the oven longer, or often even 72 hours may not be sufficient to determine the dry matter content;
c) Although the SAS statistical package is very well-known and widely used, it should be listed in the references;
d) I suggest also commenting on the months with excessive rainfall relative to historical averages, not just the months when it was significantly below average;
e) They should also include the season (spring) in the last sentence of item 3.3...chemical characteristics (in the results).
f) Finally, include it on page 13, line 430 (table 4) to make it easier to retrieve the information.
Author Response
Comment (a) Eliminate the scientific name (Lolium multiflorum), since the old name (Festuca arundinacea) is mentioned in the second paragraph of the introduction
Response: We have removed the scientific name Lolium multiflorum as suggested. We have ensured that Festuca arundinacea remains the reference in title and the Introduction to maintain consistency.
Comment (b): Eliminate the oven drying time until constant weight (sometimes 48 hours and other times 72 hours). Generally, they remain in the oven longer, or often even 72 hours may not be sufficient to determine the dry matter content.
Response: We have removed the specific drying times (48 and 72 hours) from the Materials and Methods section. The text now states that samples were dried until a constant weight was reached to ensure accurate dry matter determination.
Comment (c): Although the SAS statistical package is very well-known and widely used, it should be listed in the references.
Response: We have included the reference for the SAS software in the Reference list. The citation in the "Statistical Analysis" section has been updated to: SAS OnDemand for Academics, Version 9.4 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA) [27].
Comment (d): I suggest also commenting on the months with excessive rainfall relative to historical averages, not just the months when it was significantly below average.
Response: We have expanded the description of the weather conditions. In addition to mentioning the dry periods of June and July, we now highlight the excessive rainfall recorded between August and October (specifically 326.4 mm in August), which significantly exceeded historical averages and influenced the regrowth intervals.
Comment (e): They should also include the season (spring) in the last sentence of item 3.3...chemical characteristics (in the results).
Response: As suggested, we have clarified the seasonal context in the final sentence. We have specified that the lack of difference between seasons applies to both autumn-winter and spring, while maintaining the focus on the significant difference found between treatments.
Comment (f): Finally, include it on page 13, line 430 (table 4) to make it easier to retrieve the information.
Response: We have relocated or cross-referenced Table 4 at the indicated location (page 14, line 455) to facilitate the retrieval of information and improve the flow of the Results/Discussion section.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe paper presents how grazing management can affect forage production and pasture structural heterogeneity. The authors conclude that age distribution varied vertically and according to treatments, clearly influencing the chemical composition and structure of forages. The paper is well-structured and the conclusions are supported by the presented data. The overall quality of the paper is relatively good and I believe it can be accepted for publication after minor revisions.
Specific comments are as follows:
- In the abstract, after presenting the working hypothesis and the study design, the authors should highlight much more clearly the importance and usefulness of this study.
- In the Introduction the authors mainly list the literature without in-depth commentary. It is recommended that the authors conduct a more thorough analysis of how grazing management can affect forage production and pasture structural heterogeneity.
- To better explain how precipitation influenced grass regeneration after each grazing use, I believe that the data in Table 1 should be presented in detail, by decade and not just by month.
- For better clarity and understanding of the data in table 1, it is necessary to specify the meanings for the abbreviations of the months (Example Apr - April etc.).
- Checking the use of symbols, according to the paper's technical editing guide (example m-1 instead of m2, etc.).
- The authors have cited two of their own works in the course of this manuscript. It should be reviewed whether this is absolutely necessary to avoid the unjustified use of self-citations.
- In the conclusions section, the authors must present in much more detail the limits of this study, and from this perspective justify the need to continue these studies in the future.
Author Response
Please find the point-by-point response to the reviewers' comments in the attached file
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf