Review Reports
- Katarzyna Lomper 1,2,* and
- Julia Buczkowska 3
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Christos Fragoulis
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsMaterials and Methods:
It must be clarified the timing of the clinical assessments during the hospitalization. It is unclear if a standardized protocol was followed, or if measurements were taken at different time points for each patient. For example: was the data collected after diuretic ingestion?
Results:
The Results section must be rewritten. There are too many tables, and the results lack a clear connection between them; additionally, the presentation fails to follow standard formatting. Reordering the results is necessary to ensure a logical progression that guides the reader through the study’s findings.
-Provide the full term for the abbreviation PLN.
-To improve readability, any tables containing only one or two variables should be converted into descriptive text within the main body. (Tables: 4, 5, 6, 8, 9)
-Variables must be expressed as mean ± SD or median and 95% CI/IQR/range, depending on the distribution (parametric or non-parametric), but not by both metrics as currently shown in the tables. Also, the reporting of dispersion around the median must be standardized using range (min–max) or quartiles, or 95% confidence intervals.
-Mean and median are not abbreviated in the tables so is not necessary to include M for mean and Me for median in the legends.
- The content labeled as Figure 1 corresponds to the description for Figure 2, and vice versa.
-Translate to English: Ocena stanu odzywiania
-Table 7 presentation must be improved. Also, while the authors demonstrated a moderate correlation between MNA and BMI, they must provide a narrative bridge explaining the rationale for correlating these variables with the laboratory markers
Redo Table 10 using standard regression nomenclature. The terms 'trait' and 'parameter' should be replaced with Independent Variables and B (unstandardized coefficient), respectively since, according to the text, the coefficient is related to the variables' original units. Ensure this change is reflected in the Abstract as well. Furthermore, the Coefficient of Determination (R²) should be reported. Finally, the authors must provide the Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) to assess potential multicollinearity among the predictors.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 1
We would like to sincerely thank the Reviewer for the thorough evaluation of our manuscript and for the insightful and constructive comments. We greatly appreciate the time and effort invested in improving the quality and clarity of our paper. All suggestions have been carefully considered, and the manuscript has been revised accordingly. Below, we provide detailed responses to each comment. Are changes in manuscript are made in red.
It must be clarified the timing of the clinical assessments during the hospitalization. It is unclear if a standardized protocol was followed, or if measurements were taken at different time points for each patient. For example: was the data collected after diuretic ingestion?
Response:
Thank you for this important comment. We have clarified this issue in the Methods section. All assessments were conducted on the day of the patient’s discharge, after clinical stabilization. This ensured consistency in the timing of measurements across participants and minimized the potential influence of acute clinical fluctuations, including recent pharmacological interventions.
- The Results section must be rewritten. There are too many tables, and the results lack a clear connection between them; additionally, the presentation fails to follow standard formatting. Reordering the results is necessary to ensure a logical progression that guides the reader through the study’s findings.
Response:
We appreciate this valuable suggestion. The Results section has been substantially revised to improve clarity, coherence, and logical flow. The number of tables has been reduced, and the presentation of results has been reorganized to better guide the reader through the key findings.
Provide the full term for the abbreviation PLN.
Response:
The abbreviation has been clarified in the manuscript as “Polish złoty (PLN)”.
To improve readability, any tables containing only one or two variables should be converted into descriptive text within the main body. (Tables: 4, 5, 6, 8, 9)
Response:
In accordance with the Reviewer’s suggestion, we have removed Tables 4, 5, 6, 8, 9 and incorporated the corresponding results into the main text of the Results section to improve readability and conciseness.
Variables must be expressed as mean ± SD or median and 95% CI/IQR/range, depending on the distribution, but not both.
Response:
After careful consideration and consultation with a statistician, we decided to retain both mean ± SD and median values in the tables. This approach was adopted to facilitate comparability with previously published studies in this field, where mean values are still frequently reported, even for non-normally distributed data. At the same time, all inferential analyses were conducted using appropriate non-parametric methods, consistent with the data distribution.
- Mean and median are not abbreviated in the tables so is not necessary to include M for mean and Me for median in the legends.
Response:
The table legends have been revised, and unnecessary abbreviations have been removed to improve clarity.
- The content labeled as Figure 1 corresponds to Figure 2, and vice versa.
Response:
The figure captions have been corrected accordingly.
Translate to English: Ocena stanu odżywiania.
Response:
This has been corrected in the revised manuscript.
Table 7 presentation must be improved. Also, a narrative bridge explaining the rationale for correlating MNA and BMI with laboratory markers is required.
Response:
Table 7 has been revised to improve clarity and readability, including a simplified structure, grouping of variables, and clearer presentation of correlation coefficients and p-values.
Redo Table 10 using standard regression nomenclature. The terms 'trait' and 'parameter' should be replaced with Independent Variables and B (unstandardized coefficient), respectively since, according to the text, the coefficient is related to the variables' original units. Ensure this change is reflected in the Abstract as well. Furthermore, the Coefficient of Determination (R²) should be reported. Finally, the authors must provide the Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) to assess potential multicollinearity among the predictors.
Response:
Table 10 has been revised in accordance with standard regression reporting guidelines.
To address potential multicollinearity, we calculated the Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) for all predictors. The VIF values ranged from 1.096 to 1.177, indicating no evidence of multicollinearity among the independent variables.
|
Independent variable |
VIF |
|
9-EHFScBS |
1.163 |
|
NT-proBNP [1000 pg/ml] |
1.120 |
|
Hgb [g/dl] |
1.103 |
|
Number of chronic comorbidities |
1.138 |
|
NYHA |
1.177 |
|
BMI [kg/m²] |
1.096 |
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis manuscript addresses a relevant clinical topic, as malnutrition is clearly important in patients with chronic heart failure and may influence both prognosis and quality of life. The paper is generally readable, and the use of established tools such as the Mini Nutritional Assessment and the 9-item European Heart Failure Self-care Behaviour Scale is appropriate. However, after reading the manuscript, I am not convinced that it provides enough novelty or scientific value for publication in Nutrients.
Several aspects of the study design also need clarification. The study objective should be stated more clearly, and the inclusion criteria should be presented more explicitly in the Methods section.
The main concern is that the study mostly confirms findings that are already well known. The associations between poorer nutritional status and more advanced heart failure, higher NT-proBNP, lower BMI, and greater comorbidity burden have already been described in previous studies. For this reason, the manuscript reads more as a confirmation of existing knowledge than as a study that substantially adds to the field. The only potentially more interesting point is the association between nutritional status and self-care. However, even this finding is relatively weak and difficult to interpret. Because the study is cross-sectional, it is not possible to know whether poorer self-care contributes to malnutrition, whether malnourished and frailer patients are less able to perform self-care, or whether both are simply markers of more severe disease. In other words, the observed relationship is interesting, but it remains descriptive and does not provide a clear new insight.
A second important issue is the study design itself. This is a small, single-center cohort . Such a population is quite specific, and the findings cannot easily be generalized to the broader heart failure population, especially to stable outpatients. In addition, the manuscript does not provide a clear justification for sample size, which is particularly relevant given the use of multivariable regression.
I also have concerns regarding the statistical presentation. The use of a one-sample t-test to compare the self-care score with a reference value of 51.82 is not adequately explained. It is unclear where this value comes from, why it should be used as a benchmark, and what the clinical meaning of this comparison actually is. Without a clear rationale, this analysis does not seem very informative.
The Results section could also be improved. A considerable amount of detail is provided regarding sociodemographic variables, but many of these do not seem to contribute meaningfully to the main analyses or interpretation. This makes the section feel overly descriptive in parts, while the clinically relevant findings remain fairly limited.
Finally, I think the conclusions are somewhat stronger than the data support. For example, the reference to the “obesity paradox” seems overstated based on this study alone, particularly since BMI is an imperfect marker in heart failure and may be influenced by fluid retention. Similarly, the statement that this is “one of the few studies” examining these variables together does not seem strong enough to support a claim of novelty.
Overall, while the topic is important, the manuscript in its current form mainly confirms already known associations and does not, in my opinion, offer enough novelty or methodological strength for publication in Nutrients.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 2
We would like to thank the Reviewer for the thorough evaluation of our manuscript and for the insightful comments. We appreciate the critical perspective and have revised the manuscript accordingly.
1.Several aspects of the study design also need clarification. The study objective should be stated more clearly, and the inclusion criteria should be presented more explicitly in the Methods section.
Response:
We thank the Reviewer for this comment. The study objective has been clarified and more explicitly stated in the revised manuscript. In addition, the Methods section has been expanded to clearly define the inclusion criteria and improve the transparency of the study design.
2.The main concern is that the study mostly confirms findings that are already well known. The associations between poorer nutritional status and more advanced heart failure, higher NT-proBNP, lower BMI, and greater comorbidity burden have already been described in previous studies. For this reason, the manuscript reads more as a confirmation of existing knowledge than as a study that substantially adds to the field. The only potentially more interesting point is the association between nutritional status and self-care. However, even this finding is relatively weak and difficult to interpret. Because the study is cross-sectional, it is not possible to know whether poorer self-care contributes to malnutrition, whether malnourished and frailer patients are less able to perform self-care, or whether both are simply markers of more severe disease. In other words, the observed relationship is interesting, but it remains descriptive and does not provide a clear new insight.
Response:
We fully agree that several of the observed associations have been previously reported. However, the aim of our study was not to establish novel individual relationships, but rather to provide an integrated assessment of nutritional status in relation to clinical, biochemical, and behavioral factors within a single cohort of patients with chronic heart failure. At the same time, we believe that our findings remains clinically relevant, as it highlights a potential link between behavioural and nutritional domains that is relatively underexplored. The cross-sectional design reflects the exploratory nature of the study and cannot be modified; however, prospective studies are currently being planned to further investigate these relationships. The Conclusions section has been revised accordingly.
- A second important issue is the study design itself. This is a small, single-center cohort . Such a population is quite specific, and the findings cannot easily be generalized to the broader heart failure population, especially to stable outpatients. In addition, the manuscript does not provide a clear justification for sample size, which is particularly relevant given the use of multivariable regression.
Response:
The sample size was determined by the number of eligible patients meeting the inclusion criteria during the study period. Therefore, a convenience sampling approach was applied. We recognize that this method does not allow for a priori sample size calculation, however, it reflects real-world clinical practice and provides insight into a well-defined and clinically relevant patient group. Regarding the use of multivariable regression, we took care to limit the number of variables included in the model to those that were clinically justified and significant in univariate analyses, in order to reduce the risk of model overfitting. Multicollinearity was assessed using the Variance Inflation Factor - VIF. The VIF values ranged from 1.096 to 1.177, indicating no evidence of multicollinearity among the independent variables.
4.I also have concerns regarding the statistical presentation. The use of a one-sample t-test to compare the self-care score with a reference value of 51.82 is not adequately explained. It is unclear where this value comes from, why it should be used as a benchmark, and what the clinical meaning of this comparison actually is. Without a clear rationale, this analysis does not seem very informative.
Response:
In response to this comment, we have removed the one-sample t-test and the comparison with the reference value from the manuscript. The self-care results are now presented descriptively, which we believe provides a clearer and more appropriate representation of the data.
- The Results section could also be improved. A considerable amount of detail is provided regarding sociodemographic variables, but many of these do not seem to contribute meaningfully to the main analyses or interpretation. This makes the section feel overly descriptive in parts, while the clinically relevant findings remain fairly limited.
Response:
We agree that the Results section contained an extensive description of sociodemographic characteristics that did not directly contribute to the main analyses or interpretation. In response, we have revised the Results section to improve its clarity and focus. The description of sociodemographic variables has been substantially shortened and limited to key characteristics.
- Finally, I think the conclusions are somewhat stronger than the data support. For example, the reference to the “obesity paradox” seems overstated based on this study alone, particularly since BMI is an imperfect marker in heart failure and may be influenced by fluid retention. Similarly, the statement that this is “one of the few studies” examining these variables together does not seem strong enough to support a claim of novelty.
Response:
We agree that some statements in the Conclusions were overly strong. The section has been revised to provide a more balanced interpretation of the findings. References to the “obesity paradox” have been moderated, and unsupported claims regarding novelty have been removed.
We hope that these revisions have adequately addressed the Reviewer’s concerns and improved the quality of the manuscript.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis manuscript examines the associations between nutritional status, clinical characteristics, and self-care behaviours in patients with chronic heart failure. The topic is clinically relevant, as malnutrition remains an underrecognized issue in heart failure management. The manuscript is generally well structured and the use of validated tools such as the Mini Nutritional Assessment (MNA) and the 9-item European Heart Failure Self-care Behaviour Scale strengthens the study. However, several methodological and reporting issues should be addressed to improve clarity, scientific rigor, and interpretation of the findings:
1)The cross-sectional design should be more clearly emphasized throughout the manuscript. Some statements in the Discussion imply causal relationships between nutritional status, self-care behaviours, and clinical outcomes, which cannot be established with this design.
2)The study includes only 100 participants from a single centre. The manuscript would benefit from a brief justification of the sample size or a discussion regarding statistical power, particularly for multivariate regression analyses.
3)Several laboratory parameters appear to have been available only for a subset of participants (e.g., albumin, lipid profile). The manuscript should clarify the extent of missing data and how this may have influenced the analyses.
4)The selection of variables included in the multivariate regression model requires further clarification. It would be helpful to explain whether variables were selected based on clinical relevance, univariate significance, or another predefined strategy.
5)The interpretation of BMI as a surrogate of better nutritional status should be approached more cautiously. Given the possibility of fluid retention and altered body composition in heart failure patients, the Discussion should more clearly acknowledge these limitations.
6)The manuscript reports the use of a reversed and standardized scoring procedure for the 9-EHFScBS. The Methods section should describe this transformation more clearly to ensure reproducibility.
7)Several sentences could be streamlined for clarity and conciseness, particularly in the Introduction and Discussion sections.
8)Statistical results should be reported consistently (e.g., p-values, confidence intervals, and test statistics). Some tables mix different reporting formats.
9)Tables 6–8 contain extensive information that may reduce readability. The authors should simplify or summarize the most relevant results. Also, the captions of Figures 1 and 2 should more clearly describe what is being displayed and how the variables are distributed.
10)The authors should revise for mistypo.
11)Some sections of the Discussion reiterate results rather than interpret them. The authors may consider shortening these parts and focusing more on clinical implications.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 3
We would like to sincerely thank the Reviewer for the thorough evaluation of our manuscript and for the insightful and constructive comments. We greatly appreciate the time and effort invested in improving the quality and clarity of our paper. All suggestions have been carefully considered, and the manuscript has been revised accordingly. Below, we provide detailed responses to each comment. Are changes in manuscript are made in red.
1)The cross-sectional design should be more clearly emphasized throughout the manuscript. Some statements in the Discussion imply causal relationships between nutritional status, self-care behaviours, and clinical outcomes, which cannot be established with this design.
Response:
We want to thank for the helpful suggestion. The paper has been revised.
2)The study includes only 100 participants from a single centre. The manuscript would benefit from a brief justification of the sample size or a discussion regarding statistical power, particularly for multivariate regression analyses.
Response:
The sample size was determined by the number of eligible patients meeting the inclusion criteria during the study period. Therefore, a convenience sampling approach was applied. We recognize that this method does not allow for a priori sample size calculation, however, it reflects real-world clinical practice and provides insight into a well-defined and clinically relevant patient group. Regarding the use of multivariable regression, we took care to limit the number of variables included in the model to those that were clinically justified and significant in univariate analyses, in order to reduce the risk of model overfitting. Multicollinearity was assessed using the Variance Inflation Factor - VIF. The VIF values ranged from 1.096 to 1.177, indicating no evidence of multicollinearity among the independent variables.
3)Several laboratory parameters appear to have been available only for a subset of participants (e.g., albumin, lipid profile). The manuscript should clarify the extent of missing data and how this may have influenced the analyses.
Response:
Some laboratory parameters (e.g., albumin, lipid profile) were available only for a subset of participants, as these tests were performed based on clinical indications rather than as part of a standardized study protocol. In the statistical analyses, we applied an available-case, meaning that each analysis included all participants for whom the relevant variables were available. For example, correlations between BMI and platelet count were calculated using all cases with both BMI and platelet measurements, regardless of the availability of other laboratory parameters. We acknowledge that this approach may result in varying sample sizes across analyses, which has now been clarified in the revised manuscript. We have also noted this as a limitation, as missing data may have influenced the precision of some estimates.
4)The selection of variables included in the multivariate regression model requires further clarification. It would be helpful to explain whether variables were selected based on clinical relevance, univariate significance, or another predefined strategy.
Response:
In the present study, variables were selected based on a combination of clinical relevance and results of univariate analyses. Specifically, variables that were considered clinically meaningful and showed an association with the dependent variable in univariate analyses were included in the multivariable model. This approach was applied to ensure both clinical interpretability and to reduce the risk of overfitting, given the sample size. The description of this procedure has been clarified in the revised Methods section.
5)The interpretation of BMI as a surrogate of better nutritional status should be approached more cautiously. Given the possibility of fluid retention and altered body composition in heart failure patients, the Discussion should more clearly acknowledge these limitations.
Response:
We fully agree that the interpretation of BMI as a surrogate marker of nutritional status in patients with heart failure should be approached with caution. As noted, BMI does not distinguish between fat mass, lean body mass, and fluid retention, which are particularly relevant in this patient population. Therefore, it may not accurately reflect true nutritional status. In response to this comment, we have revised the Discussion section to more clearly acknowledge these limitations and to emphasize that BMI should be interpreted as a simplified and indirect measure, particularly in the context of heart failure.
6)The manuscript reports the use of a reversed and standardized scoring procedure for the 9-EHFScBS. The Methods section should describe this transformation more clearly to ensure reproducibility.
Response:
In response, we have revised the Methods section to provide a more detailed description of the transformation procedure. Specifically, the original score (ranging from 9 to 45, with lower scores indicating better self-care) was reversed and standardized to a 0–100 scale according to the method proposed by Vellone et al., with higher scores indicating better self-care. The manuscript has been updated accordingly.
7)Several sentences could be streamlined for clarity and conciseness, particularly in the Introduction and Discussion sections.
Response:
In response, we have revised the discussion section.
8)Statistical results should be reported consistently (e.g., p-values, confidence intervals, and test statistics). Some tables mix different reporting formats.
Response:
We have updated the results section. We hope that, in their current form, they are clearer and more accurate.
9)Tables 6–8 contain extensive information that may reduce readability. The authors should simplify or summarize the most relevant results. Also, the captions of Figures 1 and 2 should more clearly describe what is being displayed and how the variables are distributed.
Response:
We have removed Tables 4, 5, 6, 8, 9 and incorporated the corresponding results into the main text of the Results section to improve readability and conciseness.
10)The authors should revise for mistypo.
Response:
We want to thank for thorough review our paper —the entire manuscript has been checked for stylistic errors and typos.
11)Some sections of the Discussion reiterate results rather than interpret them. The authors may consider shortening these parts and focusing more on clinical implications.
Response:
We have revised and shortened these sections to reduce repetition of the results and to place greater emphasis on the clinical interpretation and implications of the findings.
We believe that these changes have improved the clarity and readability of the Discussion.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsAs already mentioned previously:
Abstract: ß= standardized coefficient is different from B= unstandardized coefficient.
So the abstract must be corrected: self-care score (ß = 0.083 per point), BMI (ß = 0.368 per kg/m²), comorbidity burden (ß = -0.401 per comorbidity), and NYHA class (NYHA III: ß = -2.425; NYHAIV: ß = -5.966, vs. NYHA II)
The authors are inconsistent with their decimal places for variables like age, weight and BMI. It looks like lack of proofreading.
Also they frequently report both the mean and median, which creates confusion. The choice of descriptive statistics should follow the results of the Shapiro-Wilk normality test (as mentioned in Methods). For example, in Table 3, the Mann-Whitney test, a non parametric measure, was used but the authors keep reporting both the mean and median in Table 3. The authors should only report the metric that matches the data's distribution.
The multivariate regression analysis did not report the Coefficient of Determination (R²) result, which is necessary to evaluate the model's goodness-of-fit. And the authors must provide the Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) to assess potential multicollinearity among the predictors.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 1
We would like to thank the Reviewer for the careful reading of our manuscript and for the valuable and constructive comments. We have addressed all concerns raised, and the manuscript has been revised accordingly. Below we provide a detailed, point-by-point response. All changes are made in red.
Abstract: ß=standardized coefficientis different from B= unstandardized coefficient.
So the abstract must be corrected: self-care score (ß = 0.083 per point), BMI (ß = 0.368 per kg/m²), comorbidity burden (ß = -0.401 per comorbidity), and NYHA class (NYHA III: ß= -2.425; NYHAIV: ß = -5.966, vs. NYHA II)
Response:
The Abstract has been revised to correctly report unstandardized coefficients (B) instead of β. The description has been clarified to ensure consistency with the regression model presented in the manuscript.
- The authors are inconsistent with their decimal places for variables like age, weight and BMI. It looks like lack of proofreading.
Response:
All numerical values throughout the manuscript have been carefully reviewed and standardized. Continuous variables (e.g., age, weight, BMI) are now consistently reported with one decimal place, ensuring uniformity and improving readability.
- Also they frequently report both the mean and median, which creates confusion. The choice of descriptive statistics should follow the results of the Shapiro-Wilk normality test (as mentioned in Methods). For example, inTable 3, the Mann-Whitney test, a non parametric measure, was used but the authors keep reporting both the mean and median in Table 3. The authors should only report the metric that matches the data's distribution.
Response:
We have revised the presentation of descriptive statistics in accordance with the distribution of the data. Since most variables did not follow a normal distribution, non-parametric tests were applied. Accordingly, in Table 3 and related sections, we now report median and interquartile ranges only, and the mean values have been removed to ensure methodological consistency.
- The multivariate regression analysis did not report theCoefficient of Determination (R²)result, which is necessary to evaluate the model's goodness-of-fit. And the authors must provide theVariance Inflation Factor (VIF) to assess potential multicollinearity among the predictors.
Response:
The Coefficient of Determination (R²) has now been added to the Results section. In addition, multicollinearity was assessed using the Variance Inflation Factor, as now described in the Methods section. The Results section has been updated to report that all VIF values were low, indicating no evidence of multicollinearity among the predictors.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Authors,
Thank you for the revised version of your manuscript. The paper has clearly improved, particularly in the presentation of the results and the reporting of the regression analysis. The results are now easier to follow, and the limitations are appropriately acknowledged.
There are, however, a few points that still need clarification. The statistical approach would benefit from a more consistent justification, especially regarding the use of parametric tests despite non-normal distributions. The use of the one-sample t-test also remains unclear, and the reference value used should be explicitly stated and justified.
In addition, although missing laboratory data are mentioned, the potential impact on bias is not discussed in detail. It would also be helpful to clarify how variables were selected for the multivariate model, beyond statistical significance alone. Finally, a brief comment on the clinical relevance of the observed associations (not only their statistical significance) would strengthen the interpretation of the findings.
As a conclusion, the manuscript has improved, but these issues should be addressed to further strengthen the study.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 2
We would like to thank the Reviewer for the careful reading of our manuscript and for the valuable and constructive comments. We have addressed all concerns raised, and the manuscript has been revised accordingly. Below we provide a detailed, point-by-point response. All changes are made in red.
There are, however, a few points that still need clarification. The statistical approach would benefit from a more consistent justification, especially regarding the use of parametric tests despite non-normal distributions.
Response:
In response to the Reviewer’s suggestion, we reanalyzed the results. As the assumption of normality was not met for the analyzed variables, we replaced Pearson’s correlation coefficient with Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient, which is more appropriate for non-normally distributed data (table 4).
- The use of the one-sample t-test also remains unclear, and the reference value used should be explicitly stated and justified.
Response:
We carefully reviewed our results, and the indicated fragment concerning the use of the one-sample t-test has been removed in accordance with the suggestion of another Reviewer. We appreciate the thorough evaluation of our work. These valuable comments will be taken into account in our future research.
- In addition, although missing laboratory data are mentioned, the potential impact on bias is not discussed in detail.
Response:
Due to the clinical nature of data collection, some laboratory parameters were available only for a subset of participants, and analyses were therefore conducted using an available-case approach. This may have reduced the statistical power of certain analyses, particularly in univariate comparisons (Table 3), where smaller sample sizes for selected variables (e.g., albumin) limited the ability to detect statistically significant differences between groups. Consequently, non-significant findings for these parameters should be interpreted with caution, as they may reflect insufficient sample size rather than a true lack of association. In other words, the absence of statistically significant differences does not necessarily indicate equivalence between groups. Relevant clarification has been added to the limitations section of the manuscript. We appreciate this insightful comment, which has helped to improve the transparency and interpretation of our results.
- It would also be helpful to clarify how variables were selected for the multivariate model, beyond statistical significance alone.
Response:
We acknowledge that the selection of variables for the multivariate model was based primarily on statistical significance in univariate analyses. This approach was adopted due to the relatively small sample size and the exploratory nature of the study, with the aim of limiting the number of variables included in the model and reducing the risk of overfitting. However, we agree that relying solely on statistical criteria may overlook clinically relevant variables. This limitation has now been clarified in the revised manuscript. We appreciate this valuable suggestion, which will be taken into account in future studies, where variable selection will also incorporate clinical relevance and evidence from the literature.
- Finally, a brief comment on the clinical relevance of the observed associations (not only their statistical significance) would strengthen the interpretation of the findings.
Response:
We have revised the Discussion section to better emphasize the clinical relevance of the observed associations, beyond their statistical significance. Specifically, we have added a paragraph highlighting the potential clinical implications of the relationships between nutritional status, disease severity, and self-care behaviours.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf