Review Reports
- Wiktoria Staśkiewicz-Bartecka 1,*,
- Julia Lubojańska 1 and
- Marek Kardas 1
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThank you for the opportunity to evaluate this scientific work. In short, my suggestions for correcting the manuscript are the following:
Introduction
This section is too long and includes redundant passages (e.g. general description of physical activity and WHO recommendations), which dilutes the focus on the research problem.
Clarifications are missing regarding gaps in the previous literature: it is not explicit why pole dancing might influence body image differently from other activities.
Materials and Methods
Procedure
The sampling component is vaguely described, and the term “dedicated sampling approach” is not explained and may raise questions about selection bias.
Results
In its current form, the presentation of the results is difficult to navigate, as some tables are excessively loaded with information. A more synthetic structuring, possibly by simplifying the tables or moving secondary details to supplementary material, would considerably improve clarity and readability. Also, the analysis is largely limited to describing the data, without providing an in-depth statistical interpretation; discussions on the significance of the results and the size of the effects, which are essential for assessing the empirical relevance of the findings, are missing.
Discussion
The section is in its current form at a relatively general level and does not explore the psychological mechanisms by which pole dancing could influence body image, although the literature provides sufficient references for such an interpretation. In addition, the reporting on previous research is limited: comparisons are sporadic, and some statements are generic in nature and are not supported by clear references to specific studies.
Conclusions
There is a grammatical error (“may is associated”) and requires reformulation.
In addition, the practical implications are mentioned superficially; a clearer discussion of how the results can be used in interventions or educational programs would be useful.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you very much for your time, careful reading, and constructive comments on our manuscript. We sincerely appreciate your efforts to help improve the quality and clarity of our work.
Below, we provide a point-by-point response to all your suggestions and concerns. In the revised manuscript, all new or modified sections have been marked in red font to facilitate your evaluation.
Should you find that any aspect still requires further clarification or revision, we will be more than happy to address it promptly.
Comment 1: Thank you for the opportunity to evaluate this scientific work. In short, my suggestions for correcting the manuscript are the following:
Introduction
This section is too long and includes redundant passages (e.g. general description of physical activity and WHO recommendations), which dilutes the focus on the research problem.
Clarifications are missing regarding gaps in the previous literature: it is not explicit why pole dancing might influence body image differently from other activities.
Response 1: Thank you for this valuable comment. The Introduction has been revised in accordance with your suggestions to improve clarity.
Comment 2: Materials and Methods
Procedure
The sampling component is vaguely described, and the term “dedicated sampling approach” is not explained and may raise questions about selection bias.
Response 2:
We thank the Reviewer for this important comment. We agree that the description of the sampling procedure was not sufficiently precise and that the term “dedicated sampling approach” could be unclear and potentially misleading. To improve transparency and address concerns regarding potential selection bias, we have revised Section 2.1 (Procedure for the study).
Comment 3: Results
In its current form, the presentation of the results is difficult to navigate, as some tables are excessively loaded with information. A more synthetic structuring, possibly by simplifying the tables or moving secondary details to supplementary material, would considerably improve clarity and readability. Also, the analysis is largely limited to describing the data, without providing an in-depth statistical interpretation; discussions on the significance of the results and the size of the effects, which are essential for assessing the empirical relevance of the findings, are missing.
Response 3: Thank you for this helpful comment. The Results section has been revised in line with your suggestions to improve readability and provide clearer interpretation of the findings.
Comment 4: Discussion
The section is in its current form at a relatively general level and does not explore the psychological mechanisms by which pole dancing could influence body image, although the literature provides sufficient references for such an interpretation. In addition, the reporting on previous research is limited: comparisons are sporadic, and some statements are generic in nature and are not supported by clear references to specific studies.
Response 4: Thank you for this important suggestion. The Discussion section has been revised in accordance with your comments to provide more systematic comparisons with previous studies.
Comment 5: Conclusions
There is a grammatical error (“may is associated”) and requires reformulation.
In addition, the practical implications are mentioned superficially; a clearer discussion of how the results can be used in interventions or educational programs would be useful.
Response 5: Thank you for this observation. The Conclusions have been revised following your suggestions to improve clarity, correct the grammatical error, and strengthen practical implications.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authorspaper title - Body image evaluation and sociocultural attitudes toward one’s own body among women practicing pole dance
an interesting study -was thinking why pole dance
- i notice a growing interest in this previously, authors did note the relevance in the introduction with WHO data - seems great
here are some comments, suggestions, and questions
manuscript presents a cross-sectional study comparing body image perceptions and sociocultural attitudes toward appearance between women practicing pole dance - using control / experimental in Poland - why this study locale?
the use of
Sociocultural Attitudes Towards Appearance Questionnaire 3 (SATAQ-3) and the Body Esteem Scale (BES) - seems adequate - are these translated? , if so, should be noted (validation already provided - OK)
addresses a timely topic in sports psychology and public health, focusing on pole dance
sample size is adequate for group comparisons, and exploratory correlation analyses are appropriately cautious, which is also good
but, might want to elaborate more on
self-reported data might be inaccurate.. might want to note the lack of verification methods..
correlations are insightful - absence of adjustments for multiple comparisons risks Type I errors would suggest to try some causal inferences?
was thinking that their might also be some confounders - maybe duration or intensity of pol dance, SES? or media exposre as noted - but was not fully controlled during the analysis
can elaborate more on why the results shows higher athlete internalization - would also note the cultural issues?
overall a very interesting study
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you very much for your time, careful reading, and constructive comments on our manuscript. We sincerely appreciate your efforts to help improve the quality and clarity of our work.
Below, we provide a point-by-point response to all your suggestions and concerns. In the revised manuscript, all new or modified sections have been marked in red font to facilitate your evaluation.
Should you find that any aspect still requires further clarification or revision, we will be more than happy to address it promptly.
Comment 1: paper title - Body image evaluation and sociocultural attitudes toward one’s own body among women practicing pole dance
an interesting study -was thinking why pole dance
- i notice a growing interest in this previously, authors did note the relevance in the introduction with WHO data - seems great
here are some comments, suggestions, and questions
manuscript presents a cross-sectional study comparing body image perceptions and sociocultural attitudes toward appearance between women practicing pole dance - using control / experimental in Poland - why this study locale?
Response 1:
We thank the Reviewer for this thoughtful comment. The study was conducted in Poland for several methodological and contextual reasons, which we have now clarified in the revised manuscript.
First, pole dance has experienced dynamic growth in Poland in recent years, both as a recreational activity and as a competitive sport (including national federations affiliated with international structures). Despite this growing popularity, there is a clear lack of empirical research examining psychological aspects of pole dance participation in the Polish context.
Second, Poland represents a sociocultural environment undergoing rapid transformation in media exposure, beauty standards, and social media engagement, particularly among young women. These processes may influence body image and internalization of appearance ideals, making this population particularly relevant for studying sociocultural determinants of body perception.
Third, validated Polish adaptations of the SATAQ-3 and BES were available and normed for the Polish population, ensuring methodological accuracy and cultural appropriateness of the measurement tools.
For these reasons, Poland provided both a practical and theoretically justified context for conducting the study.
Comment 2: the use of
Sociocultural Attitudes Towards Appearance Questionnaire 3 (SATAQ-3) and the Body Esteem Scale (BES) - seems adequate - are these translated? , if so, should be noted (validation already provided - OK)
Response 2: Thank you for this observation. We have confirmed that the Polish versions of SATAQ-3 and BES, previously validated, were used. This is now clearly stated in the Methods section.
Comment 3: addresses a timely topic in sports psychology and public health, focusing on pole dance
sample size is adequate for group comparisons, and exploratory correlation analyses are appropriately cautious, which is also good
but, might want to elaborate more on
self-reported data might be inaccurate.. might want to note the lack of verification methods..
Response 3: Thank you for this important remark. We have highlighted this limitation in the revised manuscript.
Comment 4: correlations are insightful - absence of adjustments for multiple comparisons risks Type I errors would suggest to try some causal inferences?
Response 4:
We appreciate the Reviewer’s suggestion to consider causal inference. However, due to the cross-sectional design, causal relationships cannot be established. The temporal direction between internalization of sociocultural norms and body image perception cannot be determined in this study.
To address this point:
We explicitly strengthened the wording throughout the manuscript to avoid causal language.
We replaced phrases suggesting “impact” or “influence” with “association” or “relationship” where appropriate.
We added a clarifying statement in the Discussion.
Comment 5: was thinking that their might also be some confounders - maybe duration or intensity of pol dance, SES? or media exposre as noted - but was not fully controlled during the analysis
Response 5: Thank you for this observation. We have acknowledged these potential confounders in the limitations and suggested their consideration in future research.
Comment 6: can elaborate more on why the results shows higher athlete internalization - would also note the cultural issues?
overall a very interesting study
Response 6: Thank you for this valuable comment. The Discussion has been revised in accordance with your suggestion.
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsI believe that the authors understood and properly implemented the observations mentioned in the first round of review, significantly improving the quality of the manuscript.
Author Response
Thank You.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authorsafter going over the extensive revisions made by the authors, the paper is now ready for acceptance, great work
Author Response
Thank You