Review Reports
- Mateusz Gawelczyk,
- Magdalena Kaszuba and
- Adam Maszczyk
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
Effects of Low-Carbohydrate and Ketogenic Diets on Aerobic Performance in Trained Athletes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
By Maszcyk et al., Aimed for publication in nutrients
This review is a well written and substantial paper the gives a good overview of the effects of how low-carbohydrate and ketogenic diets affect aerobic performance. However, I do lack information of the distribution of males/females included in the tables, as well as in 2.2.1 Population. This should be added to the text and under 6.6 Generalizability and population Representation.
The definition of Low-carb and ketogenic diet is well established. However, it would have been of great value to compare, or at least discuss, the amounts of protein and fat in the respective definition. Maybe the low-carbo diet is already to close to a ketogenic diet to give differences in performance.
Minor comments.
The authors should decide how to write VO2max and VO2 peak and follow it throughout the paper. Suggestion is to use VO2max and VO2peak.
The readability of tables would increase if first column is adjusted to the left (i.e table 1), and for Table 6 it could be turned 90 degrees or reduce font size. As it is now text between columns is not well separated.
Table 2 is not necessary, since it is explained in text, or part of paragraph 3.1.2 could be added to Table 2.
A minor spell-check is needed, and also space is lacking between words several times.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer 1,
Please find attached the revised version of the manuscript (nutrients- 4105618) entitled: "Effects of Low-Carbohydrate and Ketogenic Diets on Aerobic Performance in Trained Athletes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis" by Adam Maszczyk, Mateusz Gawełczyk, Magdalena Kaszuba, Adam Zając *. We thank the reviewer for his comments and the time spent on helping us to improve the MS. In this improved version of the MS, we have implemented all of the suggestions point by point. All changes made in the MS are listed in our response to the reviewers and are also highlighted in green in the revised version of the MS.
We hope that you will find the new version of the MS suitable for publication in Nutrients.
Comment 1: I do lack information of the distribution of males/females included in the tables, as well as in 2.2.1 Population. This should be added to the text and under 6.6 Generalizability and population Representation.
Response 1: We agree, and we have revised these sections. All the necessary information has been included.
Comment 2: The definition of Low-carb and ketogenic diet is well established. However, it would have been of great value to compare, or at least discuss, the amounts of protein and fat in the respective definition. Maybe the low-carbo diet is already to close to a ketogenic diet to give differences in performance.
Response 2: We agree that protein and fat intake are important considerations when interpreting differences between low-carbohydrate and ketogenic diets. In the included studies, dietary classification was primarily based on carbohydrate intake thresholds; however, protein and fat intake often overlapped substantially between low-carbohydrate and ketogenic interventions. This overlap may have reduced metabolic and performance differences between diets, particularly in short-term studies and in the absence of sustained nutritional ketosis. We have added a paragraph to the Discussion addressing the continuum between low-carbohydrate and ketogenic diets, the limited control and reporting of protein intake, and the implications of these factors for interpreting performance outcomes.
Comment 3: The authors should decide how to write VO2max and VO2 peak and follow it throughout the paper. Suggestion is to use VO2max and VO2peak.
Response 3: We agree. The entire manuscript has been standardized.
Comment 4: The readability of tables would increase if first column is adjusted to the left (i.e table 1), and for Table 6 it could be turned 90 degrees or reduce font size. As it is now text between columns is not well separated.
Response 4: We agree. The first column in all tables is now shifted to the left. We also tried to make the table 6 easier to read.
Comment 5: Table 2 is not necessary, since it is explained in text, or part of paragraph 3.1.2 could be added to Table 2.
Response 5: This table has been removed.
Comment 6: A minor spell-check is needed, and also space is lacking between words several times.
Response 6: We checked the document one more time to correct all the spelling mistakes.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
Maszczyk et al. present interesting and intriguing insights regarding sports nutrition for sports athletes, especially those undergoing endurance-based training. Per the reviewers’ current understanding, The manuscript aims to compare the effects of low-carbohydrate and ketogenic diets on aerobic performance indices, among other outcomes. Overall, the manuscript is generally well written and presents a clear rationale for examining how differing dietary strategies influence endurance performance and substrate utilization. Therefore, the reviewer recommends acceptance pending minor revisions, as outlined below.
Methods
The Methods state that preprint repositories were searched, but it is unclear whether any preprints were included in the final analysis. Please clarify.
Discussion
The authors suggest that neuromuscular adaptations and limited substrate availability may contribute to the observed temporal dynamics in substrate utilization. Do the authors also consider whether alterations in fiber type composition could play a role in these effects? Given that fiber type distribution is closely linked to metabolic capacity and substrate preference, training-induced remodeling—particularly driven by training specificity—may meaningfully influence the observed patterns. It would be helpful for the authors to discuss whether shifts in oxidative versus glycolytic fiber proportions, or changes in hybrid fiber prevalence, could partially explain the temporal differences reported. If data on fiber type composition are available, incorporating these measures or acknowledging this as a limitation and future direction would strengthen the mechanistic interpretation of the findings.
Specific Comments:
Page 1, Line 30: This is very minor, but “Conclusions” should be bolded akin to how both “Background/Objectives” and “Methods” are bolded.
Page 2, Lines 61-64: This is an extremely dense sentence. It would be more digestible if this sentence was broken into two, but only if the meaning stays consistent if done so.
Page 4, Lines 170-177: Same as above. This sentence goes on for 7 lines and it is very easy to get lost while reading and can lose the reader. Thus, it would be more pragmatic to break this up.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer 2,
Please find attached the revised version of the manuscript (nutrients- 4105618) entitled: "Effects of Low-Carbohydrate and Ketogenic Diets on Aerobic Performance in Trained Athletes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis" by Adam Maszczyk, Mateusz Gawełczyk, Magdalena Kaszuba, Adam Zając *. We thank the reviewer for his comments and the time spent on helping us to improve the MS. In this improved version of the MS, we have implemented all of the suggestions point by point. All changes made in the MS are listed in our response to the reviewers and are also highlighted in green in the revised version of the MS.
We hope that you will find the new version of the MS suitable for publication in Nutrients.
Comment 1: The Methods state that preprint repositories were searched, but it is unclear whether any preprints were included in the final analysis. Please clarify.
Response 1: Thank you for this important clarification request. We confirm that no preprints were included in the final analysis. Although preprint repositories (bioRxiv and medRxiv) were searched as part of our comprehensive search strategy, all 33 studies included in the final analysis were peer-reviewed publications.
Our eligibility criteria (Section 2.2.5) explicitly required "peer-review publication status" as a minimum methodological requirement for inclusion. Studies were systematically excluded if they consisted of "animal studies, case reports, or conference abstracts without subsequent peer-reviewed publication."
The search of preprint repositories was conducted to ensure comprehensive coverage and to identify potentially relevant studies that might have been subsequently published in peer-reviewed journals. However, the screening process identified no preprints meeting our inclusion criteria that were not already captured through the peer-reviewed literature search.
To enhance clarity and transparency, we have made the following revisions to the manuscript:
- Section 2.1 (Study Design and Search Strategy): We added explicit clarification that no preprints were included: "However, no preprints meeting our inclusion criteria were identified, and all 33 studies included in the final analysis were peer-reviewed publications."
- Section 2.2.5 (Study Design - Eligibility Criteria): We added a new sentence clarifying the exclusion of preprints: "While preprint repositories were searched to ensure comprehensive literature coverage, no preprints were ultimately included in the analysis; all 33 included studies were published in peer-reviewed journals."
- Section 2.3 (Study Selection Process): We added explicit statement: "All 33 included studies were peer-reviewed journal publications. Although preprint repositories (bioRxiv, medRxiv) were systematically searched, no preprints meeting our eligibility criteria, specifically the requirement for peer-review publication status, were identified for inclusion."
- Section 3.1 (Characteristics of Included Studies): We revised the opening sentence to emphasize that all included studies were peer-reviewed publications and clarified that no preprints met the inclusion criteria.
These revisions ensure complete transparency regarding our search strategy and the publication status of all included studies. All changes are highlighted in the revised manuscript for your convenience.
Comment 2: The authors suggest that neuromuscular adaptations and limited substrate availability may contribute to the observed temporal dynamics in substrate utilization. Do the authors also consider whether alterations in fiber type composition could play a role in these effects? Given that fiber type distribution is closely linked to metabolic capacity and substrate preference, training-induced remodeling—particularly driven by training specificity—may meaningfully influence the observed patterns. It would be helpful for the authors to discuss whether shifts in oxidative versus glycolytic fiber proportions, or changes in hybrid fiber prevalence, could partially explain the temporal differences reported. If data on fiber type composition are available, incorporating these measures or acknowledging this as a limitation and future direction would strengthen the mechanistic interpretation of the findings.
Response 2: Thank you for this insightful comment. We agree that fiber type composition and training-induced remodeling may meaningfully influence substrate utilization and performance responses to low-carbohydrate and ketogenic diets. While direct measures of fiber type distribution were not available in the majority of included studies, existing mechanistic evidence suggests that carbohydrate restriction may differentially affect oxidative (Type I), glycolytic (Type II), and hybrid fibers over time. We have expanded the Discussion to acknowledge the potential role of fiber type–specific adaptations, including shifts in hybrid fiber prevalence and functional remodeling driven by training specificity, as a plausible contributor to the observed temporal dynamics. We also identify the lack of direct fiber type data as a limitation and an important direction for future research.
Comment 3: Page 1, Line 30: This is very minor, but “Conclusions” should be bolded akin to how both “Background/Objectives” and “Methods” are bolded.
Response 3: We agree, and we have corrected the mistake.
Comment 4: Page 2, Lines 61-64: This is an extremely dense sentence. It would be more digestible if this sentence was broken into two, but only if the meaning stays consistent if done so.
Response 4: We agree and have broken this sentence down into three parts.
Comment 5: Page 4, Lines 170-177: Same as above. This sentence goes on for 7 lines and it is very easy to get lost while reading and can lose the reader. Thus, it would be more pragmatic to break this up.
Response 5: We thank the reviewer for this suggestion and have revised the sentence by dividing it into shorter, clearer statements to improve readability.