Review Reports
- Mishal Trevor Morepje 1,2,*,
- Glen Themba Mendi 1,3 and
- Siphe Zantsi 1,3
Reviewer 1: Theodore Tarnanidis Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors- In the abstract, condense the background information.
- In the introduction, try to provide a strong foundation regarding nutrition transition and food security in South Africa.
- The connection between Maslow's theory and actual results needs to be clearly stated in the theoretical section.
- Include more details about the search strategy's implementation and criteria in the methodology section using PRISMA.
- In the results section, emphasize cross-study patterns and summarizes major themes that emerge from the literature.
- Make clear which figures are either conceptual trends or aggregated empirical evidence. Also, try to include more relevant sources
- In the discussion and conclusion sections give more in-depth information about the findings. Additionally, mention any differences between rural and urban contexts in South Africa, or other contexts,
Author Response
Dear esteemed reviewer, Thank you for your time and dedication to ensuring that this paper is of the highest scientific quality. Kindly consider the following responses and inputs when implementing your comments and suggestions:
Reviewer comment 1: In the abstract, condense the background information.
Revision made: The background information has been condensed. Please refer to Lines 12-15 of the revised manuscript.
Reviewer comment 2: In the introduction, try to provide a strong foundation regarding nutrition transition and food security in South Africa.
Revision: More nutritional information in relation to South Africa has been added in lines 42–69 of the revised manuscript.
Reviewer comment 3: The connection between Maslow's theory and actual results needs to be clearly stated in the theoretical section.
Revision made: The connection between Maslow's theory and actual results has been stated in Lines 591- 624 of the revised manuscript.
Reviewer comment 4: Include more details about the search strategy's implementation and criteria in the methodology section using PRISMA.
Revisions made: More details regarding the search strategy and criteria, as well as the implementation of the PRISMA checklist and framework, were added in lines 187–229 of the revised manuscript.
Reviewer comment 5: In the results section, emphasize cross-study patterns and summarizes major themes that emerge from the literature.
Revision made: The results section has been revised to be more analytical, with references to major patterns and themes. Refer to Lines 252–502 of the revised manuscript.
Reviewer comment 6: Make clear which figures are either conceptual trends or aggregated empirical evidence. Also, try to include more relevant sources.
Revisions made: The figures were removed from the study as other reviewers mentioned that the figures are quantitative which might be confusing for readers as the study is a review of secondary literature and not data (statistics).
Reviewer comment 7: In the discussion and conclusion sections give more in-depth information about the findings. Additionally, mention any differences between rural and urban contexts in South Africa, or other contexts.
Revision made: More in-depth information has been added in the discussion and conclusion section of the revised manuscript. Refer to the mentions of the differences between consumption and acceptance patterns between urban and rural consumers in Lines 343 -378
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsComments and Suggestions for Authors
The manuscript addresses a relevant and timely topic and has the potential to make a useful contribution to the literature on indigenous foods, consumer behaviour, and food-system transformation in South Africa. The paper is generally well structured and covers important themes, including dietary transition, cultural relevance, consumer attitudes, and market-related barriers. However, the manuscript would benefit from clearer conceptual consistency, a more explicitly defined research gap, greater methodological transparency, and a stronger distinction between results, discussion, and recommendations. In addition, the theoretical framework should be more clearly justified and better integrated into the synthesis and discussion of the findings. With these revisions, the manuscript could be substantially improved in terms of clarity, analytical depth, and overall scientific contribution.
Abstract
The abstract addresses a relevant and timely topic and provides a generally clear overview of the review focus, main findings, and broader policy relevance. It successfully highlights the decline in indigenous food consumption, the persistence of these foods in rural diets, and the constraints related to market development. However, several aspects should be improved. First, since the manuscript is presented as a systematic review, the abstract should more explicitly state the review design and briefly indicate key methodological elements, such as the use of a systematic review approach and, if possible, the number of included studies. Second, the final part of the abstract reads somewhat like a discussion or recommendations section and could be made more concise so that the abstract remains more focused on the study aim, review approach, principal findings, and main conclusion. It would also be helpful to mention more explicitly that the review covers both indigenous leafy vegetables and edible insects, as these appear to be the two main food categories discussed in the manuscript.
The keywords are generally relevant.
- Introduction
The Introduction addresses a relevant and important topic and provides a useful overview of the nutritional, cultural, and food-system significance of indigenous foods in South Africa. However, the Introduction would benefit from further sharpening of the research gap and the specific contribution of this review.
The Introduction provides relevant background on dietary transition and the declining role of indigenous foods in South Africa, but the specific research gap is not yet stated clearly enough. The authors should explain more explicitly what remains insufficiently understood in the literature and why a systematic review on household attitudes, consumption patterns, and market-related barriers is needed.
The terminology used in the Introduction should be made more consistent. In several places, the text moves between “indigenous foods” and the broader notion of “healthy foods and diets,” which may weaken the conceptual focus of the paper. The authors should clarify that the review is specifically centred on indigenous foods and their role within healthier and more sustainable diets.
The final part of the Introduction would benefit from a more precise statement of the review objective and its analytical scope. In particular, the authors should formulate clearer review questions or thematic dimensions and specify from the outset that the manuscript addresses both indigenous leafy vegetables and edible insects as key components of indigenous food consumption in South Africa.
- Theoretical Framework
The theoretical framework provides a clear and generally readable attempt to interpret indigenous food consumption through Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, and the section is well structured in moving from physiological needs to self-actualisation.
However, the main weakness of this section is that the justification for selecting Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs as the central interpretive lens remains underdeveloped. The authors state that the framework is adopted to interpret household attitudes and consumption patterns, but they do not explain sufficiently why this model is more appropriate than other consumer behaviour or food choice frameworks that may be more directly suited to analysing attitudes, perceptions, and purchasing behaviour. As a result, the choice of framework appears somewhat generic rather than analytically well grounded.
- Methodology
The methodology section shows a clear intention to follow a systematic review design and includes several important elements, such as reference to the PRISMA guidelines, use of multiple databases, independent screening by two reviewers, narrative thematic synthesis, and quality appraisal with the MMAT. These are all positive features and indicate that the authors aimed to apply a structured and transparent review process. However, two aspects should be improved.
The methodology should report the search procedure in greater detail to ensure transparency and reproducibility. In particular, the authors should present the full search strings, specify the exact search dates, and define the inclusion and exclusion criteria more operationally, especially regarding the treatment of theoretical literature, grey literature, and the distinction between “healthy diets” and “indigenous foods.”
The manuscript should describe more clearly how the extracted studies were coded, how the narrative themes were developed, and how Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs was actually used in the synthesis. In addition, the authors should provide more detail on how the MMAT quality assessment was performed and how the appraisal results influenced the interpretation of the reviewed evidence.
- Results
The Results section addresses several relevant themes, including overall dietary transition, health and nutrition implications, consumer attitudes towards edible insects, market and regulatory constraints, and trends in the consumption of indigenous leafy vegetables. The thematic organisation is generally logical, and the distinction between edible insects and indigenous leafy vegetables is useful for the reader. The section also captures important contrasts between rural and urban contexts and identifies several recurring barriers, such as stigma, weak value chains, and limited product innovation.
The Results section should more clearly show how the conclusions were derived from the included studies. At present, many statements are presented in a broad narrative form, but it is often unclear how many studies support each theme and what type of evidence underpins the claims. The section would be stronger if the authors more explicitly synthesised the reviewed literature across themes.
A major issue is the use of trend figures that appear to present precise quantitative trajectories, while the manuscript later states that no longitudinal quantitative data exist for indigenous leafy vegetable consumption at the national level. The authors should therefore either justify clearly how the percentages and trends in Figures 3 and 4 were generated or revise these figures so that they are presented only as conceptual illustrations rather than empirical trend data.
Several parts of the Results section move beyond reporting the literature and already introduce broader interpretation, implications, and recommendations, especially in the discussion of nutrition, public health, and market reintegration of indigenous foods. These interpretive and policy-oriented points would be more appropriate in the Discussion section, while the Results should remain focused on reporting the actual review findings.
- Discussion
The Discussion section addresses relevant interpretive themes and succeeds in linking the review findings to broader issues of dietary transition, food environments, cultural identity, and market integration in South Africa. A positive aspect is that the authors do not merely restate the descriptive results, but attempt to explain the coexistence of declining indigenous food consumption, continuing rural use, and emerging urban niche demand. The subsections on edible insects and indigenous leafy vegetables are also logically organised and help maintain the thematic coherence of the section.
The Discussion should move beyond summarising the review findings and provide a more analytical interpretation of how the South African case relates to wider international research on dietary transition, traditional foods, and consumer behaviour. In addition, the authors should connect the discussion more explicitly to Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, since this framework is introduced earlier as the main interpretive lens but is only weakly integrated into the actual discussion of the findings.
The later part of the manuscript becomes structurally confusing because the discussion, synthesis, and implications overlap considerably, and there is also a numbering inconsistency where a later section is again labeled as “5. Implications for food systems, policy and research.” The authors should streamline this part of the manuscript to avoid repetition, clarify the distinction between interpretation and recommendations, and present limitations more explicitly within the discussion itself.
- Conclusion and recommendations
The conclusion section provides a clear summary of the main findings of the review and successfully reiterates the central message of the manuscript: indigenous foods in South Africa retain important nutritional, cultural, and food-system value, yet remain marginal in mainstream consumption and formal markets. It is also positive that the authors link the conclusion to practical recommendations concerning data systems, value-chain development, public awareness, innovation, and policy support. These recommendations are generally relevant and logically derived from the issues discussed earlier in the manuscript.
However, the section would benefit from a stronger emphasis on the specific scientific contribution of the review. The conclusion should go beyond restating the main findings and explain more explicitly what this review contributes to the literature. In particular, the authors should highlight the specific added value of their synthesis in relation to indigenous foods, consumer behaviour, and market integration in South Africa.
The section should use terminology more consistently, especially by focusing on indigenous foods rather than reverting to the broader term healthy foods. In addition, the authors should more directly acknowledge the limitations of the available evidence base, particularly the lack of disaggregated national consumption data, before moving to policy and practice recommendations.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
The manuscript addresses a relevant and timely topic and has the potential to make a useful contribution to the literature on indigenous foods, consumer behaviour, and food-system transformation in South Africa. The paper is generally well structured and covers important themes, including dietary transition, cultural relevance, consumer attitudes, and market-related barriers. However, the manuscript would benefit from clearer conceptual consistency, a more explicitly defined research gap, greater methodological transparency, and a stronger distinction between results, discussion, and recommendations. In addition, the theoretical framework should be more clearly justified and better integrated into the synthesis and discussion of the findings. With these revisions, the manuscript could be substantially improved in terms of clarity, analytical depth, and overall scientific contribution.
- Reviewer’s comment on the abstract: The abstract addresses a relevant and timely topic and provides a generally clear overview of the review focus, main findings, and broader policy relevance. It successfully highlights the decline in indigenous food consumption, the persistence of these foods in rural diets, and the constraints related to market development. However, several aspects should be improved. First, since the manuscript is presented as a systematic review, the abstract should more explicitly state the review design and briefly indicate key methodological elements, such as the use of a systematic review approach and, if possible, the number of included studies. Second, the final part of the abstract reads somewhat like a discussion or recommendations section and could be made more concise so that the abstract remains more focused on the study aim, review approach, principal findings, and main conclusion. It would also be helpful to mention more explicitly that the review covers both indigenous leafy vegetables and edible insects, as these appear to be the two main food categories discussed in the manuscript.
The keywords are generally relevant.
Author response to reviewer comment on the abstract
- The authors amended the abstract in line with the recommendations above. Refer to Lines 12 – 31.
- Reviewer’s comment on the Introduction: The Introduction addresses a relevant and important topic and provides a useful overview of the nutritional, cultural, and food-system significance of indigenous foods in South Africa. However, the Introduction would benefit from further sharpening of the research gap and the specific contribution of this review.
The Introduction provides relevant background on dietary transition and the declining role of indigenous foods in South Africa, but the specific research gap is not yet stated clearly enough. The authors should explain more explicitly what remains insufficiently understood in the literature and why a systematic review on household attitudes, consumption patterns, and market-related barriers is needed.
The terminology used in the Introduction should be made more consistent. In several places, the text moves between “indigenous foods” and the broader notion of “healthy foods and diets,” which may weaken the conceptual focus of the paper. The authors should clarify that the review is specifically centred on indigenous foods and their role within healthier and more sustainable diets.
The final part of the Introduction would benefit from a more precise statement of the review objective and its analytical scope. In particular, the authors should formulate clearer review questions or thematic dimensions and specify from the outset that the manuscript addresses both indigenous leafy vegetables and edible insects as key components of indigenous food consumption in South Africa.
Author response to reviewer comment on the introduction
- The confusion surrounding the use of the terms “Indigenous foods” and “Healthy foods” has been addressed by using “indigenous foods” as the main focus of the study with the term “Healthy foods” used to describe the benefits linked with the consumption of indigenous food.
- The research gap well-articulated in Lines 77 – 94 of the revised manuscript.
- The study aim and objectives are well highlighted in Lines 86 – 94 of the revised manuscript.
- Reviewer’s comment on the Theoretical Framework
The theoretical framework provides a clear and generally readable attempt to interpret indigenous food consumption through Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, and the section is well structured in moving from physiological needs to self-actualisation.
However, the main weakness of this section is that the justification for selecting Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs as the central interpretive lens remains underdeveloped. The authors state that the framework is adopted to interpret household attitudes and consumption patterns, but they do not explain sufficiently why this model is more appropriate than other consumer behaviour or food choice frameworks that may be more directly suited to analysing attitudes, perceptions, and purchasing behaviour. As a result, the choice of framework appears somewhat generic rather than analytically well grounded.
Author response to reviewer comment on the Theoretical framework.
- The reviewer’s comments regarding the rationale supporting the use of the Marslow’s Hierarchy of Needs as the study’s theoretical framework has been added in Lines 107 – 120.
- Reviewer’s comment on the Methodology
The methodology section shows a clear intention to follow a systematic review design and includes several important elements, such as reference to the PRISMA guidelines, use of multiple databases, independent screening by two reviewers, narrative thematic synthesis, and quality appraisal with the MMAT. These are all positive features and indicate that the authors aimed to apply a structured and transparent review process. However, two aspects should be improved.
The methodology should report the search procedure in greater detail to ensure transparency and reproducibility. In particular, the authors should present the full search strings, specify the exact search dates, and define the inclusion and exclusion criteria more operationally, especially regarding the treatment of theoretical literature, grey literature, and the distinction between “healthy diets” and “indigenous foods.”
The manuscript should describe more clearly how the extracted studies were coded, how the narrative themes were developed, and how Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs was actually used in the synthesis. In addition, the authors should provide more detail on how the MMAT quality assessment was performed and how the appraisal results influenced the interpretation of the reviewed evidence.
Author response to reviewer comment on the methodology
- The entirety of the methodology section has been reworked to reflect all the comments and suggestions made. Kindly refer to Lines 190 -273 of the revised manuscript.
- Reviewer’s comment on the Results
The Results section addresses several relevant themes, including overall dietary transition, health and nutrition implications, consumer attitudes towards edible insects, market and regulatory constraints, and trends in the consumption of indigenous leafy vegetables. The thematic organisation is generally logical, and the distinction between edible insects and indigenous leafy vegetables is useful for the reader. The section also captures important contrasts between rural and urban contexts and identifies several recurring barriers, such as stigma, weak value chains, and limited product innovation.
The Results section should more clearly show how the conclusions were derived from the included studies. At present, many statements are presented in a broad narrative form, but it is often unclear how many studies support each theme and what type of evidence underpins the claims. The section would be stronger if the authors more explicitly synthesised the reviewed literature across themes.
A major issue is the use of trend figures that appear to present precise quantitative trajectories, while the manuscript later states that no longitudinal quantitative data exist for indigenous leafy vegetable consumption at the national level. The authors should therefore either justify clearly how the percentages and trends in Figures 3 and 4 were generated or revise these figures so that they are presented only as conceptual illustrations rather than empirical trend data.
Several parts of the Results section move beyond reporting the literature and already introduce broader interpretation, implications, and recommendations, especially in the discussion of nutrition, public health, and market reintegration of indigenous foods. These interpretive and policy-oriented points would be more appropriate in the Discussion section, while the Results should remain focused on reporting the actual review findings.
Author response to reviewer comment on the methodology
- The results in the revised manuscript were presented analytically with the figures removed after realising their misalignment with the study design and focus.
- The figures were drafted using secondary data which is an error; hence the removal of the figures in the results section.
- Reviewer’s comment on the Discussion
The Discussion section addresses relevant interpretive themes and succeeds in linking the review findings to broader issues of dietary transition, food environments, cultural identity, and market integration in South Africa. A positive aspect is that the authors do not merely restate the descriptive results, but attempt to explain the coexistence of declining indigenous food consumption, continuing rural use, and emerging urban niche demand. The subsections on edible insects and indigenous leafy vegetables are also logically organised and help maintain the thematic coherence of the section.
The Discussion should move beyond summarising the review findings and provide a more analytical interpretation of how the South African case relates to wider international research on dietary transition, traditional foods, and consumer behaviour. In addition, the authors should connect the discussion more explicitly to Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, since this framework is introduced earlier as the main interpretive lens but is only weakly integrated into the actual discussion of the findings.
The later part of the manuscript becomes structurally confusing because the discussion, synthesis, and implications overlap considerably, and there is also a numbering inconsistency where a later section is again labeled as “5. Implications for food systems, policy and research.” The authors should streamline this part of the manuscript to avoid repetition, clarify the distinction between interpretation and recommendations, and present limitations more explicitly within the discussion itself.
Author response to reviewer comment on the discussion
- The study’s discussion has been corrected to be more analytical and also the discussion of the implications of the study are now intertwined with the principles of the Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs. Refer to Lines 613 -646 of the revised manuscript.
- The “ Implications for food systems, policy and research.” Has been merged into the discussion section to make the paper more streamlined. Refer to Lines 647 – 675 of then revised manuscript.
- Reviewer’s comment on the Conclusion and recommendations
The conclusion section provides a clear summary of the main findings of the review and successfully reiterates the central message of the manuscript: indigenous foods in South Africa retain important nutritional, cultural, and food-system value, yet remain marginal in mainstream consumption and formal markets. It is also positive that the authors link the conclusion to practical recommendations concerning data systems, value-chain development, public awareness, innovation, and policy support. These recommendations are generally relevant and logically derived from the issues discussed earlier in the manuscript.
However, the section would benefit from a stronger emphasis on the specific scientific contribution of the review. The conclusion should go beyond restating the main findings and explain more explicitly what this review contributes to the literature. In particular, the authors should highlight the specific added value of their synthesis in relation to indigenous foods, consumer behaviour, and market integration in South Africa.
The section should use terminology more consistently, especially by focusing on indigenous foods rather than reverting to the broader term healthy foods. In addition, the authors should more directly acknowledge the limitations of the available evidence base, particularly the lack of disaggregated national consumption data, before moving to policy and practice recommendations.
Author response to reviewer comment on the Conclusion and recommendations
- All the comments and suggestions raised have been addressed. Refer to Lines 697 – 749 of the revised manuscript.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript addresses a timely and relevant topic, examining the role of indigenous foods within the broader context of dietary transition, consumer behaviour, and food systems in South Africa. The subject fits well within the scope of the journal and contributes to ongoing discussions on sustainable diets and culturally grounded food systems. The paper is generally well structured and supported by a substantial body of literature. The integration of nutritional, socio-cultural, and market perspectives, as well as the distinction between rural and urban contexts, represents a clear strength. While the manuscript has several strengths, it currently reads more as a narrative review than a rigorous systematic review. Although PRISMA and MMAT are mentioned, their application is not sufficiently transparent, and the analysis remains largely descriptive. In addition, some figures appear to present trends without a clearly established empirical basis, which may lead to misinterpretation. With substantial revision, the manuscript has the potential to make a meaningful contribution. However, significant improvements are required before the manuscript can be considered for publication.
ABSTRACT:
- Lines 11–12: It would be helpful to explicitly state that this is a systematic review, as this is not entirely clear from the current wording.
- Lines 19–24: Findings are presented in rather general terms (e.g., findings indicate), which limits their impact. Including more specific insights or key patterns would strengthen the abstract.
- Lines 27–31: The concluding part is somewhat generic and leans toward policy statements. A clearer link to the main findings would improve overall clarity.
INTRODUCTION:
- Lines 42–47: The reference to Mediterranean and DASH diets is informative, but the connection to the South African context is not entirely clear. This part could either be better integrated or slightly reduced.
- Lines 54–60: The notion of indigenous foods being perceived as “poverty foods” is important, but it is treated quite briefly. A more in-depth discussion of the socio-cultural background would add value here.
- Lines 82–86: The aim of the study is somewhat broad. It would benefit from clearer definition of the analytical focus and scope.
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK:
- Lines 89–93: Introducing Maslow’s hierarchy is interesting, though its relevance to food systems and consumer behaviour could be more explicitly justified.
- Lines 150–158: The discussion of self-actualisation is conceptually sound but comes across as somewhat speculative. Additional empirical support would strengthen this part.
- Lines 160–172: At present, the framework is not clearly carried forward into the later sections. Clarifying its role in the analysis-or alternatively shortening this section would improve coherence.
METHODOLOGY:
- Lines 173–176: Reference to PRISMA is appropriate. However, the description of its implementation could be more detailed.
- Lines 182–190: The search strategy is explained in general terms, but a fully reproducible search string is not provided.
- Lines 202–205: The screening process is described, although no information is given on inter-reviewer agreement.
- Lines 217–222: The use of MMAT is noted, but the results of the quality assessment are not presented, which weakens methodological transparency.
RESULTS:
- Lines 236–243: The presentation of trends gives the impression of quantitative evidence, despite the acknowledged lack of longitudinal data. This point should be clarified to avoid potential misinterpretation.
- Lines 248–254: The discussion on nutritional implications is relevant, though it remains largely descriptive. A more analytical approach would strengthen this section.
- Lines 293–312: The section on edible insects provides a useful overview of rural versus urban acceptance. However, it remains largely descriptive. A clearer synthesis of the key drivers of acceptance and resistance would strengthen this part.
- Lines 320–340: The discussion of regulatory constraints is relevant, though it would benefit from a more structured presentation (for example, grouping barriers into regulatory, economic, and supply chain dimensions).
- Lines 402–410: The absence of quantitative data on indigenous leafy vegetables is clearly acknowledged. This limitation has important implications for the interpretation of trends and should be more critically discussed.
- Lines 417–426: The reported decline and partial resurgence of indigenous leafy vegetables are interesting, but the argument would benefit from clearer differentiation between qualitative observations and empirically supported evidence.
DISCUSSION:
- Lines 431–438: The discussion tends to restate results rather than engage with them critically. Greater synthesis and comparison across studies would improve analytical depth.
- Lines 441–446: The idea of revalorisation of indigenous foods is interesting but could be developed further to enhance its contribution.
- Lines 481–500: The section on indigenous leafy vegetables highlights important trends, but it remains largely descriptive. A more critical engagement with the literature would strengthen this part.
- Lines 505–525: The synthesis of findings is relevant. It mainly summarises earlier sections rather than offering deeper integrative insights. Clearer identification of overarching patterns would improve the discussion.
- Lines 526–567: The section on implications for food systems and policy is well organised, but several points remain quite general. More specific, context-driven recommendations would increase its practical relevance.
CONCLUSION:
- Lines 586–590: Although the lack of quantitative data is acknowledged, its implications for the robustness of the conclusions are not fully explored.
- Lines 592–610: The recommendations are relevant but remain somewhat general. More concrete and actionable suggestions would strengthen the overall impact of the manuscript.
FIGURES:
- Figure 3: The figure suggests clear trends in indigenous versus processed food consumption over time, but it is not evident what these trends are based on. Since the manuscript itself notes the lack of longitudinal quantitative data, this presentation is somewhat confusing and could be interpreted as data-driven. It would be helpful to either clearly state that the figure is conceptual or provide supporting data sources.
- Figure 4: A similar issue appears in the figure on consumer acceptance of edible insects. The percentages imply a quantitative basis, yet no source or methodology is provided. Clarifying how these values were derived would make the figure more transparent.
Author Response
Dear Esteemed reviewer – Thank you for taking the time to review the manuscript. Below are responses to comments and suggestions.
The manuscript addresses a timely and relevant topic, examining the role of indigenous foods within the broader context of dietary transition, consumer behaviour, and food systems in South Africa. The subject fits well within the scope of the journal and contributes to ongoing discussions on sustainable diets and culturally grounded food systems. The paper is generally well structured and supported by a substantial body of literature. The integration of nutritional, socio-cultural, and market perspectives, as well as the distinction between rural and urban contexts, represents a clear strength. While the manuscript has several strengths, it currently reads more as a narrative review than a rigorous systematic review. Although PRISMA and MMAT are mentioned, their application is not sufficiently transparent, and the analysis remains largely descriptive. In addition, some figures appear to present trends without a clearly established empirical basis, which may lead to misinterpretation. With substantial revision, the manuscript has the potential to make a meaningful contribution. However, significant improvements are required before the manuscript can be considered for publication.
- Reviewer comments on the ABSTRACT:
- Lines 11–12: It would be helpful to explicitly state that this is a systematic review, as this is not entirely clear from the current wording.
- Lines 19–24: Findings are presented in rather general terms (e.g., findings indicate), which limits their impact. Including more specific insights or key patterns would strengthen the abstract.
- Lines 27–31: The concluding part is somewhat generic and leans toward policy statements. A clearer link to the main findings would improve overall clarity.
Response to reviewer comments on the abstract
- All the above comments and suggestions were implemented in the revised manuscript. Refer to Lines 12 – 28 of the revised manuscript.
- Reviewer comments on the INTRODUCTION:
- Lines 42–47: The reference to Mediterranean and DASH diets is informative, but the connection to the South African context is not entirely clear. This part could either be better integrated or slightly reduced.
- Lines 54–60: The notion of indigenous foods being perceived as “poverty foods” is important, but it is treated quite briefly. A more in-depth discussion of the socio-cultural background would add value here.
- Lines 82–86: The aim of the study is somewhat broad. It would benefit from clearer definition of the analytical focus and scope.
Response to reviewer comments on the introduction
- The above comments were addressed in the revised manuscript particularly in Lines 37 – 49.
- Reviewer comments on the THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK:
- Lines 89–93: Introducing Maslow’s hierarchy is interesting, though its relevance to food systems and consumer behaviour could be more explicitly justified.
- Lines 150–158: The discussion of self-actualisation is conceptually sound but comes across as somewhat speculative. Additional empirical support would strengthen this part.
- Lines 160–172: At present, the framework is not clearly carried forward into the later sections. Clarifying its role in the analysis-or alternatively shortening this section would improve coherence.
Response to reviewer comments on the theoretical framework
- The relevance of the Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs particularly to food systems and consumer behaviour is explained in Lines 96 - 120 of the revised manuscript.
- The self-actualisation is discussed more in an analytical manner with reference to empirical studies, refer to Lines 169 – 177 of the revised manuscript.
- The Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs has been implemented in the discussion. Refer to Lines 613 -646 of the revised manuscript.
- Reviewer comments on the METHODOLOGY:
- Lines 173–176: Reference to PRISMA is appropriate. However, the description of its implementation could be more detailed.
- Lines 182–190: The search strategy is explained in general terms, but a fully reproducible search string is not provided.
- Lines 202–205: The screening process is described, although no information is given on inter-reviewer agreement.
- Lines 217–222: The use of MMAT is noted, but the results of the quality assessment are not presented, which weakens methodological transparency.
Response to reviewer comments on the methodology
- The PRISMA framework and its implementation in the manuscript has been described in detail. Refer to Lines 191 – 208 of the revised manuscript.
- The search strategy has been described in detail in Lines 209 – 233 of the revised manuscript.
- The inter-reviewer agreement is well explained in Lines 243 -249 of the revised manuscript.
- Reviewer comments on the RESULTS:
- Lines 236–243: The presentation of trends gives the impression of quantitative evidence, despite the acknowledged lack of longitudinal data. This point should be clarified to avoid potential misinterpretation.
- Lines 248–254: The discussion on nutritional implications is relevant, though it remains largely descriptive. A more analytical approach would strengthen this section.
- Lines 293–312: The section on edible insects provides a useful overview of rural versus urban acceptance. However, it remains largely descriptive. A clearer synthesis of the key drivers of acceptance and resistance would strengthen this part.
- Lines 320–340: The discussion of regulatory constraints is relevant, though it would benefit from a more structured presentation (for example, grouping barriers into regulatory, economic, and supply chain dimensions).
- Lines 402–410: The absence of quantitative data on indigenous leafy vegetables is clearly acknowledged. This limitation has important implications for the interpretation of trends and should be more critically discussed.
- Lines 417–426: The reported decline and partial resurgence of indigenous leafy vegetables are interesting, but the argument would benefit from clearer differentiation between qualitative observations and empirically supported evidence.
Response to reviewer comments on the Results.
- The entire results section was reworked in the process of implementing the reviewer comments and the revised section can be found in Lines 274 – 524 of the revised manuscript.
- Reviewer comments on the DISCUSSION:
- Lines 431–438: The discussion tends to restate results rather than engage with them critically. Greater synthesis and comparison across studies would improve analytical depth.
- Lines 441–446: The idea of revalorisation of indigenous foods is interesting but could be developed further to enhance its contribution.
- Lines 481–500: The section on indigenous leafy vegetables highlights important trends, but it remains largely descriptive. A more critical engagement with the literature would strengthen this part.
- Lines 505–525: The synthesis of findings is relevant. It mainly summarises earlier sections rather than offering deeper integrative insights. Clearer identification of overarching patterns would improve the discussion.
- Lines 526–567: The section on implications for food systems and policy is well organised, but several points remain quite general. More specific, context-driven recommendations would increase its practical relevance.
Response to reviewer comments on the discussion
- Similarly to the results section, the discussion section was revised to be more analytical while ensuring that each of the above comments are implemented. Refer to Lines 525 - 696 of the revised manuscript.
- Reviewer comments on the CONCLUSION:
- Lines 586–590: Although the lack of quantitative data is acknowledged, its implications for the robustness of the conclusions are not fully explored.
- Lines 592–610: The recommendations are relevant but remain somewhat general. More concrete and actionable suggestions would strengthen the overall impact of the manuscript.
Response to reviewer comments on the conclusion
- The conclusion and recommendation section has been revised to be more reflective of its robustness with the recommendations now being more specific and actionable in the revised manuscript. See Lines 697 – 749 of the revised manuscript.
- Reviewer comments on the FIGURES:
- Figure 3: The figure suggests clear trends in indigenous versus processed food consumption over time, but it is not evident what these trends are based on. Since the manuscript itself notes the lack of longitudinal quantitative data, this presentation is somewhat confusing and could be interpreted as data-driven. It would be helpful to either clearly state that the figure is conceptual or provide supporting data sources.
- Figure 4: A similar issue appears in the figure on consumer acceptance of edible insects. The percentages imply a quantitative basis, yet no source or methodology is provided. Clarifying how these values were derived would make the figure more transparent.
Response to reviewer comments on the Figures
- The reviewer ‘s comments on the Figures has been noted and to our realization, secondary data has been used to develop Fig. 3 and Fig. 4 which is not inline with the principles and design of a systematic review. Hence, the figures were removed to minimize confusion.
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThank you for the revisions provided. The English has improved. However, the manuscript would benefit from further language polishing to ensure clarity and consistency. In addition, please carefully check the text for duplicated or overlapping sections (e.g., in the Abstract, Introduction, Theoretical Framework, and Methodology) and remove these repetitions to improve overall readability and structure.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe English language requires minor polishing to improve clarity and consistency.
Author Response
Dear Esteemed Reviewer, thank you for your comments and suggestions on where to better improve the quality of our manuscript. Below is a response to your comments and suggestions:
Comment: Thank you for the revisions provided. The English has improved. However, the manuscript would benefit from further language polishing to ensure clarity and consistency. In addition, please carefully check the text for duplicated or overlapping sections (e.g., in the Abstract, Introduction, Theoretical Framework, and Methodology) and remove these repetitions to improve overall readability and structure.
Response: The manuscript has been English-language edited for clarity and consistency throughout. The repeating content in the abstract, introduction, theoretical framework, and methodology has been removed. Kindly refer to the revised sections in Lines 12-216 in the revised manuscript.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Authors,
Thank you for the revised version of your manuscript. It is clear that you have carefully considered the previous comments, and the paper has improved, particularly in the methodological section, which is now much clearer and more transparent.
There are, however, a few points that would benefit from further attention before publication:
First, there are still some sections where text appears to be repeated or slightly overlapping (especially in the Introduction, Theoretical Framework, and parts of the Methodology). A careful read-through to remove these duplications would improve the overall clarity and flow of the manuscript.
Second, while the Results section is improved, parts of it still read somewhat descriptively. It would strengthen the paper to more clearly highlight common patterns across studies, as well as any differences or contradictions where relevant.
Similarly, the Discussion could benefit from a bit more synthesis, rather than restating the results. Bringing the key findings together more explicitly would make this section stronger.
Finally, a light language and structural polish would help improve readability and ensure consistency throughout the manuscript.
Overall, the manuscript has improved considerably and addresses an important topic. With these relatively minor adjustments, it should be suitable for publication.
Author Response
Dear Esteemed reviewer,
Kindly take note of the following revisions as per your comments and suggestions:
Comment 1: First, there are still some sections where text appears to be repeated or slightly overlapping (especially in the Introduction, Theoretical Framework, and parts of the Methodology). A careful read-through to remove these duplications would improve the overall clarity and flow of the manuscript.
Response: The duplications noted in the Introduction, Theoretical framework, and some parts of the methodology has been removed. The revision can be found on Lines 33-216.
Comment 2: Second, while the Results section is improved, parts of it still read somewhat descriptively. It would strengthen the paper to more clearly highlight common patterns across studies, as well as any differences or contradictions where relevant.
Response: A section has been inserted in the results section to better highlight the common patterns across the studies cited in the manuscript, including some of the differences and/or contradictions thereof. Refer to section 4.4. Lines 465-518 of the revised manuscript.
Comment 3: Similarly, the Discussion could benefit from a bit more synthesis, rather than restating the results. Bringing the key findings together more explicitly would make this section stronger.
Response: Similarly to what has been done in the results section, a systhesis of reviewed literature sub-section was added to bridge the key findings of the paper to avoid having the discussion seen as descriptive rather analytical. Refer to Lines 607-663 of the revised manuscript.
Comment 4: Finally, a light language and structural polish would help improve readability and ensure consistency throughout the manuscript.
Response: The entire manuscript has been English-language edited to ensure the content is readable and uses a constant writing style throughout.