Review Reports
- Austra Zuševica 1,*,
- Viktorija Vendina 1,2 and
- Santa Celma 1
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis study investigates the natural ecological recovery of forest land following regional sand mining activities and employs various conventional analytical methods to assess recovery across different years. Currently, the manuscript reads more like an investigative report than a research paper. It lacks descriptions of technical methodology and research innovation, exhibits limited scientific rigor in its design, and some conclusions are insufficiently supported.
The main issues are outlined below:
1. Natural ecological recovery is a highly complex process influenced by climate, precipitation, soil properties, and human activities. The study design, however, focuses solely on surveying surface vegetation. This approach is arguably inadequate to support robust conclusions about the overall recovery process. How were other potential influencing factors considered? Was any attempt made to control for or measure these variables?
2. The data collection and processing appear to rely on very conventional survey techniques. What, if any, methodological innovation does this study offer compared to previous work in this field? The manuscript should clearly articulate its novel contribution.
3. The current Introduction only provides background context. It should be significantly expanded to include a review of recent research progress on the natural regeneration of quarry/mining sites, covering similar studies, methodologies, and findings. This review should logically lead to a clear statement of the research gaps this study aims to address, along with a detailed explanation of the study's design rationale and its intended innovative or breakthrough aspects.
4. Materials and Methods:
① It is recommended to add a small-scale map showing the regional geographical location of the study area.
② The orthophoto title should specify the image source and acquisition date. It is also advised to show the complete extent of the sand mining site(s), and the locations of all sample plots should be clearly marked within the figure.
③ More detailed information should be provided regarding the study area's climatic and soil conditions, as well as a more thorough description of the sand mining activities themselves (e.g., intensity, duration).
④ The specific survey date for all field investigations must be indicated.
5. The content in the Discussion and Conclusion sections lacks direct support from the experimental data presented. Claims and interpretations should be explicitly and consistently linked to the results.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
We are submitting the responses for your comments.
We added the line number, which indicates line in edited file (sustainability-4166575_track changees).
Thank you very much for all the comments and suggestions, the detailed responses are below:
------------------------
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
This study investigates the natural ecological recovery of forest land following regional sand mining activities and employs various conventional analytical methods to assess recovery across different years. Currently, the manuscript reads more like an investigative report than a research paper. It lacks descriptions of technical methodology and research innovation, exhibits limited scientific rigor in its design, and some conclusions are insufficiently supported.
The main issues are outlined below:
- Natural ecological recovery is a highly complex process influenced by climate, precipitation, soil properties, and human activities. The study design, however, focuses solely on surveying surface vegetation. This approach is arguably inadequate to support robust conclusions about the overall recovery process. How were other potential influencing factors considered? Was any attempt made to control for or measure these variables?
Answer: In this case study, we analysed vegetation development, focusing on ground vegetation and lichen species diversity. We are aware that this represents a complex system, and although we did not include additional measures in this study, we have now incorporated more recent studies on ecological functions under different restoration pathways in quarries in the Introduction section (Lines 44-49, 96-115). We also added a paragraph in the Discussion section addressing possible implications under climate change and highlighting the importance of considering functional perspectives in ecological studies (Lines 590–598). In addition, we included a statement in the Conclusion section noting that future multi-scale studies are needed (Lines 620–629).
- The data collection and processing appear to rely on very conventional survey techniques. What, if any, methodological innovation does this study offer compared to previous work in this field? The manuscript should clearly articulate its novel contribution.
Answer: We agree that we did not include any innovative methodology in the article. However, we believe that the study contributes novelty to the scientific literature by presenting a case study from the boreal region. Another aspect of novelty in our paper is the focus on two distinct taxonomic groups with different optimal environmental conditions—understory vegetation and epiphytic lichens. This aspect was not clearly articulated in the text previously, but we have now emphasized the importance of the multidimensionality of biodiversity and the need to consider different components of diversity (Lines 111–115). We also addressed this in the Conclusion section, highlighting that the diversity patterns of ground vegetation and epiphytic lichens differ, with ground vegetation diversity being higher in the youngest stands and epiphytic lichen diversity higher in the oldest stands (Lines 607–609). Furthermore, we added that the multidimensionality of biodiversity should be further investigated in future studies (Lines 621–623). This aspect has also been included in the Abstract (Lines 27–28).
- The current Introduction only provides background context. It should be significantly expanded to include a review of recent research progress on the natural regeneration of quarry/mining sites, covering similar studies, methodologies, and findings. This review should logically lead to a clear statement of the research gaps this study aims to address, along with a detailed explanation of the study's design rationale and its intended innovative or breakthrough aspects.
Answer: We edited the Introduction section by adding more studies related to quarry restoration, including the positive and negative aspects of passive and active restoration, as well as a paragraph emphasizing the need for future research and highlighting existing knowledge gaps. We also added a final paragraph discussing the broader scientific importance of this type of research in a wider ecological context.
- Materials and Methods:
① It is recommended to add a small-scale map showing the regional geographical location of the study area.
Answer: We added a map in addition to the orthophoto (Line 168).
② The orthophoto title should specify the image source and acquisition date. It is also advised to show the complete extent of the sand mining site(s), and the locations of all sample plots should be clearly marked within the figure.
Answer: We added the image source and acquisition date. As suggested, we created a new orthophoto image showing the study stand boundaries as well as the rest of the quarry (Lines 169-171). We did not include the sampling plots, as the ground vegetation and lichen surveys used different plots, which sometimes overlapped.
③ More detailed information should be provided regarding the study area's climatic and soil conditions, as well as a more thorough description of the sand mining activities themselves (e.g., intensity, duration).
Answer: We added information about the climatic conditions at the site, including air temperature and precipitation levels from the closest meteorological station (Lines 142-148). We also included additional details on soil parameters and the intensity of reclamation (Lines 151–160).
④ The specific survey date for all field investigations must be indicated.
Answer: We included this in the method section (Lines 173-174).
- The content in the Discussion and Conclusion sections lacks direct support from the experimental data presented. Claims and interpretations should be explicitly and consistently linked to the results.
Answer: We thoroughly revised the Discussion section, editing and linking the topics to our results. We also revised the Conclusion regarding the role of animals in seed dispersal, clarifying that this was inferred only from plant species’ dispersal types and not from direct observations.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear authors,
The topic of the article is interesting, and the problem is well identified. The article is effectively argued. The authors provide an in-depth literature review to support the theoretical framework and discuss it appropriately. Numerous models and methods are applied, and the results are explained and discussed well. The paper is written in accordance with technical specifications and uses correct English. However, for the sake of clarity, several comments are presented below. Their implementation and further explanation would enhance the overall quality of the paper:
- Lines 69-71 - Can you provide at least one more study suggesting that after natural regeneration of sand mines, vegetation composition is dominated by dry and mesic open-habitat species, since you mentioned "previous studies"?
- Line 79 – This sentence is incomplete.
- Introduction – At the end of the last paragraph, it is necessary to include a section about the main outputs and the significance of the study.
- Line 90 – Place Figure 1 in parentheses. Do the same for Table 1. Apply this throughout the entire paper.
- The subheadings after section 2.2 (including the section 2.2) should be combined into a single, more important heading, such as Methodology or Methods.
- In the conclusion, it is also necessary to address the importance of conducting such a study both from a scientific perspective (use of methods, obtained results, etc) and for practical applications (specifically for this study area).
- It is also important to mention future work on this topic, specifically which research fields remain open.
- In the discussion, it is important to address another field relevant to the process of natural regeneration: the influence of climate change or variations in microclimatic conditions. Do global or local trends impact the process of natural regeneration of sand areas, and has any research been conducted on this topic? Although the treated area is not among the particularly endangered regions (such as the sub-Mediterranean region), this aspect should be considered.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
We are submitting the responses for your comments.
We added the line number, which indicates line in edited file (sustainability-4166575_track changees).
Thank you very much for all the comments and suggestions, the detailed responses are below:
------------------------
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
Dear authors,
The topic of the article is interesting, and the problem is well identified. The article is effectively argued. The authors provide an in-depth literature review to support the theoretical framework and discuss it appropriately. Numerous models and methods are applied, and the results are explained and discussed well. The paper is written in accordance with technical specifications and uses correct English. However, for the sake of clarity, several comments are presented below. Their implementation and further explanation would enhance the overall quality of the paper:
- Lines 69-71 - Can you provide at least one more study suggesting that after natural regeneration of sand mines, vegetation composition is dominated by dry and mesic open-habitat species, since you mentioned "previous studies"?
Answer: Thank you for the comment. We have now included the previously cited reference: Řehounková, K.; Prach, K. Spontaneous vegetation succession in disused gravel-sand pits: Role of local site and landscape factors. J. Veg. Sci. 2006, 17, 583–590. https://doi.org/10.1658/1100-9233(2006)17[583:SVSIDG]2.0.CO;2, which demonstrated this relationship under dry conditions (Line 93).
- Line 79 – This sentence is incomplete.
Answer: We revised the last sentence to improve clarity (Lines 116–117).
- Introduction – At the end of the last paragraph, it is necessary to include a section about the main outputs and the significance of the study.
Answer: We added an additional paragraph at the end of the Introduction section, highlighting the importance of the study in both the European and regional context (Lines 131-137).
Line 90 – Place Figure 1 in parentheses. Do the same for Table 1. Apply this throughout the entire paper.
Answer: These edits were applied consistently throughout the entire paper.
- The subheadings after section 2.2 (including the section 2.2) should be combined into a single, more important heading, such as Methodology or Methods.
Answer: We removed the subtitles in Methods section.
- In the conclusion, it is also necessary to address the importance of conducting such a study both from a scientific perspective (use of methods, obtained results, etc) and for practical applications (specifically for this study area).
Answer: We now discussed this at the end of the conclusion section (Lines 623-629).
- It is also important to mention future work on this topic, specifically which research fields remain open.
Answer: We added this at the beginning of the last paragraph of conclusion section (Lines 620-623).
- In the discussion, it is important to address another field relevant to the process of natural regeneration: the influence of climate change or variations in microclimatic conditions. Do global or local trends impact the process of natural regeneration of sand areas, and has any research been conducted on this topic? Although the treated area is not among the particularly endangered regions (such as the sub-Mediterranean region), this aspect should be considered.
Answer: Thank you for the comment. We have addressed this aspect in the Discussion subsection on functional groups, noting that climate change can influence species distributions, including the spread of invasive species (Lines 590–598).
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Editor of Sustainability
I hope you are doing well. Thank you for your invitation. This is a well-structured manuscript investigating natural regeneration in sand quarries and succession toward Western Taiga habitat. The study provides valuable insights for restoration ecology and conservation management. However, several sections require revisions to improve clarity, methodological rigor, and scientific impact. Overall, the manuscript is in need of major revision.
Abstract
- The methods description is too detailed for an abstract. Move detailed statistical approaches to Methods section.
- The authors well- described age-related patterns, but I recommend adding specific numbers: How much higher was diversity in younger stands?, What percentage increase in high-value lichens?
- The statement about no invasive species is important, but quantify "likely due to quarry isolation" - what was the actual distance?
Introduction
- The opening on sand extraction is good but could be strengthened with specific statistics on quarry extent in the Baltic region.
- The discussion of restoration approaches is well-structured but lacks citations for key claims about costs.
- The section on Western Taiga 9010 is informative but too detailed for introduction. Some of this could move to Discussion when interpreting results.
- The research questions and hypotheses may be improved as follows: Specifically, we tested: (1) whether natural regeneration over 9-28 years produces understory and epiphytic communities resembling Western Taiga 9010 reference conditions; (2) if proximity to mature forest (>1 km from major disturbance sources) limits invasive species establishment; and (3) how functional trait composition (dispersal modes, life forms) shifts during succession."
Materials and Methods
Study area
- Describe the climate and topology of the study area, if possible.
- Add Mean annual temperature and precipitation, mean annual temperature and precipitation, Mean annual temperature and precipitation
- Mean annual temperature and precipitation as follows: How were "year extraction ended" determined? (records, aerial photos, dendrochronology?), Were all stands from the same original extraction or different phases?
Understory vegetation survey
- The different plot sizes (50m² vs 100m²) based on stand area introduce sampling bias. Justify why this doesn't affect comparability, or acknowledge as limitation.
- The LEDA traitbase citation [17] is appropriate, but explain why these specific traits (life form, dispersal) were chosen for your research questions.
- The "vegetative" dispersal category is problematic. You're mixing two concepts: Vegetative propagation (clonal growth) vs. sexual reproduction. This should be a separate trait, not a dispersal category.
Epiphytic lichen survey
- Use only one consistent system (e.g., Central Europe [20] with 1-9 scale)
- Provide strong justification for combining systems and the weighting scheme
- Or present each indicator separately rather than creating a composite index
- Table 2 is difficult to interpret. Consider moving to Supplementary Materials and summarizing key patterns in text.
Data analyses
- Good use of Kruskal-Wallis for non-normal data, but report how normality was tested (Shapiro-Wilk? Visual inspection?).
- GLM specification: Poisson for richness is appropriate. Justify why not log-normal for Gamma for cover. In addition, include checks for overdispersion
- Lines 215-220: RDA is appropriate, but: report how many axes were retained. In addition, include variance explained and test for significance of constraints
Results
Understory vegetation
- "The only significant difference" - Report test statistics: Kruskal-Wallis χ² value, df, p-value, Post-hoc pairwise comparisons with adjusted p-values.
- Figure 2 referenced but not visible. Ensure final submission includes all figures with proper resolution.
- The seed dispersal results are described as "no significant differences" but trends are mentioned. Either: report that differences were not significant (p > 0.05) with actual p-values, Or if underpowered, acknowledge as limitation
Epiphytic lichen
- "Vulpicida pinastri, a species with higher pollution tolerance, was also common" - This contradicts the earlier statement that species with low-moderate tolerance dominated. Clarify relative abundance.
- GLM results need full reporting: Coefficient estimates with standard errors, Incidence rate ratios for Poisson model, and Deviance explained
Ecosystem trends
- What percentage of variance does age explain?
- Which traits are significantly correlated with age (envfit results)?
Discussion
Succession and understory vegetation
- Good observation of 57 species. Compare with: species richness in reference Western Taiga sites and other quarry succession studies.
- The mention of Vaccinio-Piceetea communities is appropriate, but: Provide quantitative comparison (similarity indices?) and reference published relevés from the region.
- Shannon diversity decline is expected, but needs to discuss the following: Is this decline toward target values? Compare with reference sites. In addition, discuss Evenness component vs. richness.
Species dispersal
- The link between zoochory absence and animal activity is plausible but: 1- You measured species traits, not animal activity directly, 2- Damage observations support but don't prove dispersal, and 3- consider alternative explanations (environmental filters, competition).
- The 83% damage statistic is striking (Table A1). Include this in Results, not just Discussion.
- The damage data in Table A1 is valuable. Consider moving to main text or at least referencing more prominently.
Epiphytic lichens as indicators
- Lines 353-357:The statement that high ecological value lichens were absent in young stands but present in old stands is expected - you defined "high value" based on traits associated with old forests. This is somewhat circular.
- Good discussion of landscape connectivity. Consider adding: 1- What is the minimum distance for effective dispersal? and 2- Are these species present in surrounding forests? (need data)
- The microclimate explanation at 0.5m vs 1.5m is plausible but speculative. Support with Microclimate measurements (if available) or cite studies showing understory effects on lichen communities
Ecosystem trends
- Potential successional trajectory" is appropriately cautious. However, with only 4 time points (9,16,19,28 years), you have a chronosequence, not true temporal replication. Acknowledge space-for-time substitution limitations.
- The geomorphological variation point is important. Explain how might microtopography affect diversity?
- The "habitat islands" concept is compelling. Develop this more by comparing with other disturbance-dependent habitats and discussing conservation value in managed landscapes
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
We are submitting the responses for your comments.
We added the line number, which indicates line in edited file (sustainability-4166575_track changees).
Thank you very much for all the comments and suggestions, the detailed responses are below:
------------------------
Dear Editor of Sustainability
I hope you are doing well. Thank you for your invitation. This is a well-structured manuscript investigating natural regeneration in sand quarries and succession toward Western Taiga habitat. The study provides valuable insights for restoration ecology and conservation management. However, several sections require revisions to improve clarity, methodological rigor, and scientific impact. Overall, the manuscript is in need of major revision.
Abstract
- The methods description is too detailed for an abstract. Move detailed statistical approaches to Methods section.
Answer: We removed too detailed part of methodology and combined in overall terminology.
- The authors well- described age-related patterns, but I recommend adding specific numbers: How much higher was diversity in younger stands? What percentage increase in high-value lichens?
Answer: Thank you so much for this comment, we agree, that this would make reader clearer about the results. We included this in the abstract (Line 22-24), as well in the result section (Lines 339-349).
- The statement about no invasive species is important, but quantify "likely due to quarry isolation" - what was the actual distance?
Answer: We indicated that in the abstract section (Lines 27-27)
Introduction
- The opening on sand extraction is good but could be strengthened with specific statistics on quarry extent in the Baltic region.
Answer: Thank you for the comment, we added at the very beginning of the introduction section latest data from Latvia about sand and gravel extraction (Lines 35-38)
- The discussion of restoration approaches is well-structured but lacks citations for key claims about costs.
Answer: Thank you for your comment. We did not find any articles dealing with the cost problem for active restoration practices. However, we agree, that this is an important thing to add, therefore we added segment to point directly what kind of actions could be included to active restoration practices in sand and gravel quarries (Lines 53-57)
- The section on Western Taiga 9010 is informative but too detailed for introduction. Some of this could move to Discussion when interpreting results.
Answer: We moved this part to discussion section (Lines 551-561)
- The research questions and hypotheses may be improved as follows: Specifically, we tested: (1) whether natural regeneration over 9-28 years produces understory and epiphytic communities resembling Western Taiga 9010 reference conditions; (2) if proximity to mature forest (>1 km from major disturbance sources) limits invasive species establishment; and (3) how functional trait composition (dispersal modes, life forms) shifts during succession."
Answer: Thank you for your suggestions on improving research questions, we edited them in the text (Lines 117-121).
Materials and Methods
Study area
- Describe the climate and topology of the study area, if possible.
Answer: We added more information about climate and topology in the first method paragraph (Lines 142-160).
- Add Mean annual temperature and precipitation, mean annual temperature and precipitation, Mean annual temperature and precipitation
Answer: We added climate data for last 20 years for air temperature, and for 10 years (because 20 was not available) for precipitation level form nearest meteorological station (Lines 142-148).
- Mean annual temperature and precipitation as follows: How were "year extraction ended" determined? (records, aerial photos, dendrochronology?), Were all stands from the same original extraction or different phases?
Answer: The year of extraction ended was determine by the inventory data through LVM GEO platform (https://www.lvmgeo.lv). The area is rented by one extraction company, but all stands were extracted at different times. The end of the extraction is no more than 1 year older than stand, as the legislation of mining in Latvia determines the reclamation to take place no longer than 1 year after the end of extraction:
“86.1 Reclamation shall be initiated within one year and completed within three years after the completion of mineral extraction. Reclamation may be carried out simultaneously with mineral extraction. If crystalline bedrock is being extracted, reclamation shall be carried out simultaneously with the extraction of the mineral resources.” (Wording according to Cabinet Regulation No. 768 of 19 December 2023). https://likumi.lv/ta/id/251021-derigo-izraktenu-ieguves-kartiba.
We added this in the method section (Lines 161-165).
Understory vegetation survey
- The different plot sizes (50m² vs 100m²) based on stand area introduce sampling bias. Justify why this doesn't affect comparability, or acknowledge as limitation.
Answer: This approach was necessary due to the variable sizes of the forest stands of different ages. To minimize overlap of sampling plot margins in the smallest stands, we applied different plot sizes. We have now clarified and justified this in the Methods section (Lines 178–183).
- The LEDA traitbase citation [17] is appropriate, but explain why these specific traits (life form, dispersal) were chosen for your research questions.
Answer: Explanation added (Lines 205-207)
- The "vegetative" dispersal category is problematic. You're mixing two concepts: Vegetative propagation (clonal growth) vs. sexual reproduction. This should be a separate trait, not a dispersal category.
Answer: We agree, that this may be problematic. We excluded horstaills and moss species, that do not have seeds, but put Phragmites australis and Aegopodium podagraria in the classes based on LEDA traitbase. We deleted this paragraph from method section, as well redone the analyses that included this trait (Lines 209-217). Therefore, we also uploaded the reanalysed RDA image (Lines 430).
Epiphytic lichen survey
- Provide strong justification for combining systems and the weighting scheme
Answer: We included justification and citation, why paleotolerance have the strongest weighed value (Lines 265-268).
- Use only one consistent system (e.g., Central Europe [20] with 1-9 scale)
- Or present each indicator separately rather than creating a composite index
Answer: We acknowledge the concern regarding the use of multiple indicator value systems. However, because our study region (Latvia) is not specifically covered by any of the existing classifications, we created a composite ecological value index to integrate information from multiple European studies. This approach allows for a more objective assessment of species ecological preferences without bias toward a particular region. Additionally, poleotolerance, which is a critical variable for assessing forest continuity and old-growth characteristics, is only available in the Nimis study [32]; excluding it would omit an ecologically important trait for our research. Methodological differences among studies in recording indicator values also justify combining them, as it ensures a more robust characterization of lichen ecological traits across our dataset. The weighting scheme was applied based on the relative importance of each trait for habitat assessment, with poleotolerance prioritized, followed by eutrophication, reaction, moisture, and light. We include wider justification in method section (Lines 240-245).
- Table 2 is difficult to interpret. Consider moving to Supplementary Materials and summarizing key patterns in text.
Answer: We moved table to appendix section (Lines 653).
Data analyses
- Good use of Kruskal-Wallis for non-normal data, but report how normality was tested (Shapiro-Wilk? Visual inspection?).
Answer: We included this in the text (Lines 280-281)
- GLM specification: Poisson for richness is appropriate. Justify why not log-normal for Gamma for cover. In addition, include checks for overdispersion
Answer: Overdispersion for the Poisson GLMM was assessed using Pearson residuals and simulation-based diagnostics from the DHARMa package. The results indicated no overdispersion (Pearson dispersion ratio = 0.43; DHARMa dispersion = 0.59), confirming that the Poisson model adequately represented the variance structure of the species richness data. For the Gamma GLM, model assumptions were evaluated using simulation-based residual diagnostics (DHARMa), which indicated an adequate fit of the Gamma distribution with log link for the cover data. We entered also this justification in the method section (Lines 297-300)
- Lines 215-220: RDA is appropriate, but: report how many axes were retained. In addition, include variance explained and test for significance of constraints
Answer: We have now included additional information on the number of retained axes, the variance explained, and permutation tests of the constraints. The RDA model explained 41.3% of the total variance in the dataset (adjusted R² = 0.36). The first three canonical axes accounted for 71.5%, 17.2%, and 11.3% of the constrained variance, respectively. The overall model was significant based on permutation tests (F = 7.49, p = 0.001), and all canonical axes were significant (RDA1: p = 0.001; RDA2: p = 0.001; RDA3: p = 0.003). We included this in the methodology (Lines 313-316), as well as in result section.
Results
Understory vegetation
- "The only significant difference" - Report test statistics: Kruskal-Wallis χ² value, df, p-value, Post-hoc pairwise comparisons with adjusted p-values.
Answer: We added significance differences (Lines 326-330), also revised figure, as it contains some errors (Line 338).
- Figure 2 referenced but not visible. Ensure final submission includes all figures with proper resolution.
Answer: Thank you for comment, we will ensure this in submission.
- The seed dispersal results are described as "no significant differences" but trends are mentioned. Either: report that differences were not significant (p > 0.05) with actual p-values, Or if underpowered, acknowledge as limitation
Answer: We have revised the Results section to report the full ANOVA statistics for seed dispersal strategies, after excluding ‘vegetative’ dispersal type from data. No significant differences among stand ages were detected for any dispersal mode (Anemochory: F= 0.83, p = 0.488; Autochory: F = 1.06, p = 0.381; Endozoochory: F = 1.13, p = 0.354; Epizoochory: F = 1.76, p = 0.178). We therefore clarified that observed patterns represent tendencies rather than statistically significant differences and noted that the limited number of sampling plots may have reduced statistical power (Lines 341-347).
Epiphytic lichen
- "Vulpicida pinastri, a species with higher pollution tolerance, was also common" - This contradicts the earlier statement that species with low-moderate tolerance dominated. Clarify relative abundance.
Answer: Thank you for your comment, we accidentally mixed ecological value with pollution tolerance, that’s why we made this mistake. We now corrected it in the text (Lines 354-357)
- GLM results need full reporting: Coefficient estimates with standard errors, Incidence rate ratios for Poisson model, and Deviance explained
Answer: We revised the Results section to provide full reporting of the GLM outputs. Coefficient estimates with standard errors are now included for all models. For the Poisson GLMM analysing species richness, incidence rate ratios (IRR) were additionally reported to facilitate interpretation. Model results were clarified to reflect statistically significant effects only, and p-values are now explicitly provided.
Ecosystem trends
- What percentage of variance does age explain?
- Which traits are significantly correlated with age (envfit results)?
Answer: Envfit analysis confirmed that stand age significantly structures community composition, explaining 74.1% of the variance in ecosystem traits (r² = 0.74, p = 0.001). The 9-year-old stands differed most from older stands, with low-ecological-value epiphytic lichens more abundant in young stands and higher lichen cover and biodiversity observed in 28-year-old stands. We included these results in the paragraph (Lines 415-420)
Discussion
Succession and understory vegetation
- Good observation of 57 species. Compare with: species richness in reference Western Taiga sites and other quarry succession studies.
Answer: We added source about herbaceous species richness in sand quarries (Lines 444-446).
- The mention of Vaccinio-Piceetea communities is appropriate, but: Provide quantitative comparison (similarity indices?) and reference published relevés from the region.
Answer: We included relevés in the text (Lines 453-459)
- Shannon diversity decline is expected, but needs to discuss the following: Is this decline toward target values? Compare with reference sites. In addition, discuss Evenness component vs. richness.
Answer: We included a source showing that species richness increase in early stages is connected to the availability of suitable habitat for more species (Lines 465–467).
Species dispersal
- The link between zoochory absence and animal activity is plausible but: 1- You measured species traits, not animal activity directly, 2- Damage observations support but don't prove dispersal, and 3- consider alternative explanations (environmental filters, competition).
Answer: We acknowledged this and, in the revised text, corrected places to highlight that we referred to plant species dominated by zoochory processes, not zoochory itself. We made corrections in the abstract and conclusion sections to make this more straightforward. We also added the alternative explanation, as you suggested, to the discussion section (Lines 505–510).
- The 83% damage statistic is striking (Table A1). Include this in Results, not just Discussion.
- The damage data in Table A1 is valuable. Consider moving to main text or at least referencing more prominently.
Answer: Thank you so much for the comment. We also agree that these results are important. However, this was only done outside the main campaign of data gathering for this study, and therefore, the data were observed only in the youngest stands. Based on visual observations, which we mention in the text, we noted that no new large animal damage occurred in older stands. Because we only have data from the youngest stands and no quantitative data from the oldest, we decided not to include these observations in the main text.
Epiphytic lichens as indicators
- Lines 353-357:The statement that high ecological value lichens were absent in young stands but present in old stands is expected - you defined "high value" based on traits associated with old forests. This is somewhat circular.
Answer: We acknowledge that defining ‘high ecological value’ based on traits associated with old forests means their absence in young stands is somewhat expected. However, we retain this statement because one of our aims is to assess whether succession under the applied management practice facilitates the development of structurally and functionally mature lichen communities, and these patterns provide evidence in that context.
- Good discussion of landscape connectivity. Consider adding: 1- What is the minimum distance for effective dispersal? and 2- Are these species present in surrounding forests? (need data)
Answer: Thank you for your comment, we added data for lichen dispersal from other studies (Lines 524-527).
- The microclimate explanation at 0.5m vs 1.5m is plausible but speculative. Support with Microclimate measurements (if available) or cite studies showing understory effects on lichen communities
Answer: We added a new source, this study examines that on a vertical scale in the forest, microclimate tends to decrease (Line 538).
Ecosystem trends
- Potential successional trajectory" is appropriately cautious. However, with only 4 time points (9,16,19,28 years), you have a chronosequence, not true temporal replication. Acknowledge space-for-time substitution limitations.
Answer: At the beginning of the section, we added a comment noting that these results should be interpreted with caution due to the limited number of points in the successional trajectory (four time points) (Lines 542–544).
- The geomorphological variation point is important. Explain how might microtopography affect diversity?
Answer: We decided to remove this sentence and the corresponding reference, as it is not directly connected to the data or scope of our study. While we agree that this aspect is important in such habitats, in the context of our study it appeared somewhat out of place.
- The "habitat islands" concept is compelling. Develop this more by comparing with other disturbance-dependent habitats and discussing conservation value in managed landscapes
Answer: Thank you for this comment. We also consider this to be one of the most important aspects of the study. Therefore, we expanded the paragraph and added additional information and references (Lines 583–589).
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors have made substantial revisions to the manuscript in response to the first-round comments. Currently, the conclusions and discussion appear to be largely derived from the experimental data. However, the research significance, methodological innovation, and reliability of the conclusions remain insufficiently demonstrated.
Additionally, the formatting of the manuscript requires adjustments, specifically lines 169–177 and lines 770–777, which should be revised to adhere to the journal's guidelines.
Author Response
Thank you for your input. We have corrected the formatting issues in the indicated sections.
We believe that the research significance is presented in the Introduction, where we outline the challenges of ecological restoration, including its importance as well as associated costs. The main aim of this study was to provide a case study demonstrating that successful natural restoration can occur in areas that are not exposed to a high invasive species pressure. To further emphasize the importance of this aspect, we have incorporated additional segment and references that quantify the costs of active restoration practices (Lines 56-63).
We consider the main methodological novelty of this study to be the inclusion of multiple components of biodiversity (Lines 100–109). We acknowledge that epigeal lichens and mosses, vascular plants, and epiphytic lichens represent only a subset of total ecosystem diversity; therefore, this limitation has been explicitly addressed in the Discussion section (Lines 547–550).
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Editor of Sustainability
I hope you are doing well. Thank you for your invitation again. I appreciate the efforts done by the authors in improving the manuscript. The authors respond to the majority of the comments. However, few issues still need to be resolved. Overall, the manuscript is in need of minor revision.
Materials and Methods
- Line 148-149: The heading "2. Materials and Methods" should be on its own line. The sub-heading "2.1. Study area" is missing. Please add it.
Understory vegetation survey
- The heading is currently "Deleted: 2.2. Understory vegetation survey." Please correct this.
- The description of the sampling plots is clear. Justify why different plot sizes were used (50 m² vs 100 m²) earlier in the text, not just in a comment.
Epiphytic lichen survey
- The heading is currently "Deleted: 2.3. Epiphytic lichen survey." Please correct this.
- The survey of only 3 trees per stand (9 per age class) is a very small sample size for lichen communities, which can be highly variable even on a small scale. This should be explicitly acknowledged as a limitation in the Discussion.
Data analyses
- The study design uses a space-for-time substitution with only four stands (one per age class). This means that "stand age" is confounded with other unique site characteristics (e.g., micro-topography, exact history). This is a major limitation that must be clearly stated in both the Methods and the Discussion. The text acknowledges this, but it should be introduced earlier as a fundamental constraint of the study design.
Results
Understory vegetation
- The final sentence, "The lack of species that primarily depend on animals..." is an interpretation and should be moved to the Discussion.
Conclusion
- Consider adding a very brief, specific recommendation for policy or management, e.g., "We recommend maintaining forested buffers around quarry sites to facilitate natural regeneration and support the development of Western Taiga habitats."
Author Response
Materials and Methods
- Line 148-149: The heading "2. Materials and Methods" should be on its own line. The sub-heading "2.1. Study area" is missing. Please add it.
Answer: We edited this part (Lines 129-130).
Understory vegetation survey
- The heading is currently "Deleted: 2.2. Understory vegetation survey." Please correct this.
Answer: We included second subdivision (Line 163). As suggested by reviewer 2 during 1st review phase, we combined subsections starting form 2.2.
- The description of the sampling plots is clear. Justify why different plot sizes were used (50 m² vs 100 m²) earlier in the text, not just in a comment.
Answer: We included justification in the method section as well (Lines 170-172, 174-176)
Epiphytic lichen survey
- The heading is currently "Deleted: 2.3. Epiphytic lichen survey." Please correct this.
Answer: As indiceted earlier, based on Reviewer 2nd suggestion, now this section in combined in one under a title “2.2. Field Sampling and Data Analysis”
- The survey of only 3 trees per stand (9 per age class) is a very small sample size for lichen communities, which can be highly variable even on a small scale. This should be explicitly acknowledged as a limitation in the Discussion.
Answer: We included this at the end of discussion subsection about epiphytic lichen (Line 509-511)
Data analyses
- The study design uses a space-for-time substitution with only four stands (one per age class). This means that "stand age" is confounded with other unique site characteristics (e.g., micro-topography, exact history). This is a major limitation that must be clearly stated in both the Methods and the Discussion. The text acknowledges this, but it should be introduced earlier as a fundamental constraint of the study design.
Answer: To better represent this limitation, we included in abstract section (Line 13) and method section (lines 164-165), that we only observed 4 stands with different ages and one per stand age.
Results
Understory vegetation
- The final sentence, "The lack of species that primarily depend on animals..." is an interpretation and should be moved to the Discussion.
Answer: We excluded this sentence from result section, we did not moved it to discussion section, because we already discussed this trend in species dispersal subsection (453-478).
Conclusion
- Consider adding a very brief, specific recommendation for policy or management, e.g., "We recommend maintaining forested buffers around quarry sites to facilitate natural regeneration and support the development of Western Taiga habitats."
Answer: We added this, including the statement of invasive species monitoring, at the end of second conclusion paragraph (lines 588-590).
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 3
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors' response and revisions to the manuscript have, to some extent, emphasized the significance of the research. However, further explanation regarding the methodological innovation and the reliability of the conclusions remains lacking. It is recommended that controlled experiments be included in future studies to strengthen these aspects.